"Lily was here" version piano & sax

[Viccordion]

it deerves a better score of "like/dislike"

[rcortez911]

Sounds too mechanical, needs more soul

[MsKot83]

кто ответил жду?

[Danio5551995]

Oh please, put more emotion in that piece .

It really deserves it! ; )

[MsKot83]

СТЕК-!0 мордва! это же мелодия моего детства...

[pianosax14]

@MsKot83

can you speak english, please!!

thank you

[vicko620]

very nice :)) Can you tell me in what scale you improvise in 1:25, it's very cool ;d

[silastecladista]

muito bom parabens....

[duranzita]

The notes please..! (: (saxo)

[bustybasti09]

i love this vid. i´m playing piano and keyboards, a little guitar also, but i always thougt about trying a saxophone. a few days later i was in a musicstore and tried out a sax !!! although i wasn´t able to get a right tone out of this thing, i loved it. i would be very happy if i could play the sax as talented and with souch a feeling like you !!!

RESPEKT !!! VERY NICE !!!

[981644]

i always respect musicians, pro and beginners. just do your thing friend.

[metallicamacedonia]

I don't see emotions on the sax?!

[tasigogue]

Sweet, love the alto

[GeniOfficial]

nope nope it suck i dont like it

[HardcoreChildHolland]

Bad timing and I don't think this is played with al lot of feeling..

[Davyd191292]

a love this music, its just Love

[mkguitarhero]

off tempo sax is good the piano is faster then the original :)

[ursuxxl]

a bit off tune

[ManOrAlien]

THIS SUCKS!

not a good kombination and the sax guy really sucks!!!!!

[unterhose666]

i wanna see more feeling :O

[88natallia]

bez serca to zagrali. Wręcz wystukane, zwłaszcza pianino. słabo.

[uhg0]

it sounds very "artificial", no feeling

[speedfreakske]

sax part is just not good at all

[xxLielxx]

wow!! awesome!! bien!! superb!!

is it alto sax or tenor

[pianosax14]

Alto!

[yuothineyesasian]

The speed up was cool for a second but killed the emotion of the song, do it again but slower!

[Isfio]

If people playing this are amateurs, then Ok, good job.

[pianosax14]

I'm the only player: piano & sax.

[TheHugo0001]

10 a 0

[Aneurysm22]

AMAZING

[pianosax14]

OK OK OK : more timing, more timing!!! I'm not a metronome, I don't play techno music, I play cool music, ok, I'm going to sleeping!!!!!

[maagaa100]

Piano is coooooooooooooooooool!!!!!!!!!­!

[TheSuperMaasinator]

more timing guys

[genxdarkangel]

Nice attempt, need to work on timing, and tone

[smiguet]

Wow your timing is really good! And its a very interresting arrangement! :) Good job!

[yourforte]

I enjoyed this arrangement.

[woodfit]

Bad bad timing issues with the sax, is he playing a differnt song

[carlybear25]

love it guys, i play alto sax and play this with guitar- i enjoyed your arrangment alot!! nice tone on that sax,keep it up!!!

[Vivallity]

The sax starts out loud but it plays the licks to the end pretty soft. Try to play every note loud, because now I can barely hear the notes at the end. This is a song where the sax has to squeeze.

You did pretty good though :) I'd give it 4 out of 5.

[motilla123]

Saxo is ok but piono suck :/

[alxe1987]

not bad

[earlyblue]

aha ok. i`m from Sweden,,,,,

[parfumeria33ro]

Quite interesting.

Come on, guys, don't be mean! The original not only that was performed by two great artists, but it was recorded by professionals through professional instruments.

I'm not saying it doesn't suck! Because it does.

BUT

I know I do too when singing in the bathroom. Yet, I keep singing for the joy of it. My soul sings itself out, you know.

I bet that's what made these two try performing "Lily Was Here"... so don't go hard on them.

[earlyblue]

hehe ok. were do you live? USA?

[pianosax14]

no, i'm living in France

[earlyblue]

hi i`m sorry. i was in a bad mood that day. the version is ok, but still the sax should have moore timing even though he plays the right notes.....

[pianosax14]

ok man, but, I play this version in 1 time, so I think I can play better for a next time but I'm too lazy for playing many times!!!

[earlyblue]

its a great song but this version really sucks!!!! theres no timing AT ALL when the sax plays!!!!!!!

[pianosax14]

why so much aggressivity!!

many likes my version, but if you can, play better than me, and record a video.

[0362tam94]

wonderfull song

[Platinumbiz]

Sax has got to let loose get rid of bloody piano

Donk Donk Donk this is not what Lilly was about !!!

[Platinumbiz]

Sorry Horrible no energy spin chilling moments like Dave and Candy

[profeso07]

5 stars

[jdallassword]

This is a wonder rendition. I am thinking seriously about using a piano in my own version. You both played very well.

[Platinumbiz]

Only a Piano Player could say That !!!

[deborah9790]

ah can I have notes of piano and sax(A)?

[Focus0o]

If it is possible, the same for me.

btw:: NICE!

[pianosax14]

go to the candy dulfer's site, you find it

[ejens05]

do you have saxophone notes of these ? ; )

[Whaming]

If you polish you saxophone it will sound better and try to borrow a real piano or mayby a grand piano... then I think your on to something. Cause it really isnt bad, just sounds a little flat :)

[xcheryl123]

Polishing a saxophone...Makes it sound better????..... Hmmm.... I thought practice did that. ...... I guess if you cant play, you can always look good being bad.

[Carlsunchik]

without bassline and drums 3.5/5

[vivaelfulham23]

Sounds great but i definately prefer the original

[pianosax14]

I also think that the original is better. So I wanted to play something different. Thank you.

[myjanuary151987]

Nice, but original one is better, I think

[u2bclient]

Right. This is the genius of Dave Stewart: try any other combination of instruments and it will fail the same. It is the way the sound gets out of the sax / quitar that makes this tune fantastic!

[sympho4]

how amazing to hear your sax and piano!!

i like this song.

"lilly was here."by Candy Dulfer

your version is exelent.

thank you for your posting!

from japan sympho4

[cameltrophy3]

I dig it! Great sax. I never heard Lily on a piano.

[mirbez]

Sounds like an RPG synth... like a battle theme :/

[soebbieh]

dunno somehow the left hand of the piano doesnt fit in my opinion should be less powerful in my opinion and less staccato...

dunno just my opinion 4/5 though..

[andrewtswong]

agreed the left hand should be less powerful=)

[Qatmir]

really good!!

where can I get the music notes for both, the sax & piano?? really love this song.

[asianpom]

yeah really good, only smaall critism is that the sax is a little laggy, but yeah 9.5/10 guys! well done

[djdudra]

baaaaaaad !!!

[juliantay88]

can you do better?? if not...shut up...

[russianG0d]

very niz!

[asianpom]

yeah nice sounds the sax is lagging a bit but yeah overall really good guys!

[f2szilard]

honest congratulations! I always loved playing this song on bass :)

[Tankista1922]

good job!!

[LilianS66]

Super !!!

[nicolaesax]

BRAVO awsome sound great i love it how long you been playin the sax for?

[pianosax14]

hello,

thanks, I play since many years (1970!!), but if you want a good sound: works, works, & works....

[skytxada]

Bravo