this clay and ruben season is similar to the adam and kris season, adam and clay are both so much better than kris and ruben, but they didn't win, what a pity, there's something very wrong about the voting system!!!
....why clay aiken beat in the finale?????????????? he is a great singer and he is deserved to win............but for me he is the American Idol and i love the way he sang especially in the finale moment
Even after 9 seasons, this is still the single best performance on American Idol. Clay Aiken completely redefined this classic song and made it his own. The climax can still give me goosebumps; what a fantastic singer and a fantastic performance.
I'm speechless... I mean "Bridge over troubled water" is a classic by the great "Simon & Garfunkel" and it's not exactly an easy song. He pulled it off so beautifully and clean. <3
You do realize that it is IMPOSSIBLE to have it fixed. FOX would not chance having to pay huge fines, get sued, and everything else by changing the numbers? It's like saying the Oscars are fixed. They have an independent house that counts the numbers. People always forget this is NOT a singing contest. Like Adam, people did not connect to Clay as much as Ruben. Not to mention neither Adam nor Clay needed to come in first - the other two did.
after Clay i rooted for Adam..what a let down and yes what a waiste...Adam blew it! Should have come out with a 2009/1980 rock ballard combo..i miss clay!!!!!!!!!
i remember my mom would only watch because of him/his distinguishable voice. after that season she never watched again. did you notice that judges only compare contestants to him when it's barely comparable? they never say 'you sound like ruben or clarkson'. just aiken. don't see those on idol anymore--it's not just about raw talent but the doomed 'package'. i don't see those who have range like he does. idol's changed! clay got cheated--he had the top votes for every round until the end. :(
@qwertyrolls they have compared people to kelly- but not many, because she was the best freakin' contestant the show had or will ever have. as for ruben, he had a good voice but went nowhere.
Because black people are inevitably better singers. I have always been amazed at how all the professional black singers blow the white ones out of the water. But oh well, i'll sit in my corner being a lame white guy.... Even though Clay Aiken one that final hands down..... My head hurts.
Nice voice, I gotta say. I like the rest of his work... But this is just one of those songs you don't remake. Paul Simon is pretty much the only person that can sing it to its full potential.
I still get goose bumps when I hear this song. Clay is an amazing artist with a phenomenal voice and in my opinion he should have won AI. No problem though he's very successful and has a great career.
apart from in a bed with his bf (=)), he's off doing outstanding albums, and great musicals (he was in spamalot, not my favorite, but good). he's a great musician.
uhh... that's what famous is. Ruben has fallen into obscurity, as David Cook probably will. it's the pop singers who use good (and ultimately classical habits) who endure. Elton John, Billy Joel, Tina Turner.
I'd like to see David Cook and David A sing these songs Clay did...... they don't come close to Clays beautiful singing voice...........big hugs to u Clay
Class
miurathejap1066 6 months ago
this clay and ruben season is similar to the adam and kris season, adam and clay are both so much better than kris and ruben, but they didn't win, what a pity, there's something very wrong about the voting system!!!
dbly88888888 9 months ago
this has to be his best performance ever!!!
90upt 9 months ago
Why that man didn't win I'll never know
bluelakemafia 11 months ago
Best Performance ever on IDOL... <3 Much love
gunnasveins 11 months ago 2
i like ruben but honestly clay should of won!
DoubleDBlogXX 11 months ago 2
He should sing some song which only have low notes... that fvcking vibrato man, eargasmic
Guitarscreech06 1 year ago
that end note still gives me chills after all these years!!! damn!!!
WhoseLineBabygirl 1 year ago
....why clay aiken beat in the finale?????????????? he is a great singer and he is deserved to win............but for me he is the American Idol and i love the way he sang especially in the finale moment
monsonize 1 year ago 3
Canta muito...quem nasce com o talento, não precisa nem se esforçar....sai naturalmente.
edwilce 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
One of the WORST performances I've ever heard! He, or SHE, behaves just like a SUPERDIVA a DRAMA "QUEER" or something!! He's really weird and UGLY!
ironman84ish 1 year ago
@ironman84ish Do better.
MrMartinHead 1 year ago
@ironman84ish uh-oh someones jelous
xXHairDoXx 1 year ago 2
Even after 9 seasons, this is still the single best performance on American Idol. Clay Aiken completely redefined this classic song and made it his own. The climax can still give me goosebumps; what a fantastic singer and a fantastic performance.
PhantomCloneInX 1 year ago 7
season 2 = best season...period. Ruben + Clay = Too much for American Idol's own good. Oh jeeez!
BeefCake206 1 year ago 4
I'm speechless... I mean "Bridge over troubled water" is a classic by the great "Simon & Garfunkel" and it's not exactly an easy song. He pulled it off so beautifully and clean. <3
KittyKatty92 1 year ago 9
One of the bestest IDOL Performances !!!
HE arranged the song...JUST RIGHT !!!!
Brilliant !
marilynroythomas 1 year ago 6
prang di nya voice yan! His voice is unbelievable!!!
sazygurl02 1 year ago
You do realize that it is IMPOSSIBLE to have it fixed. FOX would not chance having to pay huge fines, get sued, and everything else by changing the numbers? It's like saying the Oscars are fixed. They have an independent house that counts the numbers. People always forget this is NOT a singing contest. Like Adam, people did not connect to Clay as much as Ruben. Not to mention neither Adam nor Clay needed to come in first - the other two did.
johndejordy 1 year ago
Awesome performance.!
thnn2427 1 year ago 3
I don't watch American Idol any more....Adam was was the last straw! Fixed Fixed Fixed!!!!!! all i have too say!
ness321ify 2 years ago
after Clay i rooted for Adam..what a let down and yes what a waiste...Adam blew it! Should have come out with a 2009/1980 rock ballard combo..i miss clay!!!!!!!!!
ness321ify 2 years ago
Music sucks now.......he knows that he always did!!!
ness321ify 2 years ago
i remember my mom would only watch because of him/his distinguishable voice. after that season she never watched again. did you notice that judges only compare contestants to him when it's barely comparable? they never say 'you sound like ruben or clarkson'. just aiken. don't see those on idol anymore--it's not just about raw talent but the doomed 'package'. i don't see those who have range like he does. idol's changed! clay got cheated--he had the top votes for every round until the end. :(
qwertyrolls 2 years ago 3
@qwertyrolls they have compared people to kelly- but not many, because she was the best freakin' contestant the show had or will ever have. as for ruben, he had a good voice but went nowhere.
xxkmlsmpxx 1 year ago
you can say whatever you want to about clay aiken, but you have to admit that he can sing.
that high note at the end gives you chills!
venusgospel 2 years ago 27
che bella voce! (what a beautiful voice!)
anya7979 2 years ago 2
he's gay?
why does it seem that many good singers are gay? wtf
Shokeybutsi 2 years ago
His actions wasn't so gay back then...wait, he's gay. But you never know, maybe he transformed or something.
I still like his performance, that has nothing to do with his sexuality.
vampypiano 2 years ago
brother at the beginning messing up the snapping haha
rommelaquino 2 years ago
Simply. Amazing.
babygurlonfire333 2 years ago 6
Still one of the best performances on Idol I think.
And why does everything undoubtedly sound better with a black gospel choir behind it??
junkmailboy1000 2 years ago 53
Because black people are inevitably better singers. I have always been amazed at how all the professional black singers blow the white ones out of the water. But oh well, i'll sit in my corner being a lame white guy.... Even though Clay Aiken one that final hands down..... My head hurts.
ged424 2 years ago 2
It's not because they are better singers. Most of the time they have a more powerfull voice.
XIngwingX 2 years ago
i htink 2
DFnumber8 2 years ago
@junkmailboy1000
THE BEST COMMENT IVE EVER READ ON A YOUTUBE VIDEO! MAJOR PROPS!
rememberthename5 2 years ago
@junkmailboy1000 It's not an all black choir though it has white people in it, don't just assume because it's gospel it is black
DemocracyCountsx 1 year ago
@junkmailboy1000 theres one white girl in it lol 0:17
ccguidry 7 months ago
He done his mama proud that night.
kakip64 2 years ago 4
He won the contest with this performance. I don't care what the numbers say. Ruben did great. But, compared to this.....C'MON!!!
kakip64 2 years ago 5
Nice voice, I gotta say. I like the rest of his work... But this is just one of those songs you don't remake. Paul Simon is pretty much the only person that can sing it to its full potential.
TheWhiteMarker 2 years ago
Wonderful!
hund65 2 years ago 2
i love him great voice and powerfull!!!
star20 2 years ago
I still get goose bumps when I hear this song. Clay is an amazing artist with a phenomenal voice and in my opinion he should have won AI. No problem though he's very successful and has a great career.
budapest49 2 years ago
I agree i dont understand why he didnt win. his voice is so rare.
tbmst2 2 years ago
hes amazing...where he is now?
fldannylobi 3 years ago
apart from in a bed with his bf (=)), he's off doing outstanding albums, and great musicals (he was in spamalot, not my favorite, but good). he's a great musician.
ged424 3 years ago
he is AMAZING!!!!!!!!!! what a voice!! I love his smile
kanynana 3 years ago
wow, that was pretty incredible. I think his phrasing is spot on. It doesn't stray too far from the original, but still sounds new. Awesome voice.
wherr5 3 years ago
he should have one, he became more famous then the winner. good on him (:
iLuuChrisBrezzyBaby 3 years ago
really wouldnt consider him famous...we just know his name
weezyania327 3 years ago
uhh... that's what famous is. Ruben has fallen into obscurity, as David Cook probably will. it's the pop singers who use good (and ultimately classical habits) who endure. Elton John, Billy Joel, Tina Turner.
ged424 3 years ago
david cook will probably be big cuz he'll probably sing with huge bands and make his on records
Cboyz24 2 years ago
He is a good singer, did he win?
sonturk00 3 years ago
this is so amazing and proof he should of won i amercia didnt like ruben after all , clay should of won
covergirl678 3 years ago
i could almost say that's better than the original
wow
4tabs5 3 years ago 3
still kinda bitter that he didnt win..but he obviously proved he didnt need to!!!!!
AIFanPA 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
just listen to his voice and you know he is not gay
glassyuri 3 years ago
Just to let you know, a voice has nothing to do with a person's sexuality...oh and btw, he came out of the closet in People this week.
zynnylove 3 years ago 3
preach it preach it!
Dallas3212 3 years ago
The greatest performance in Idol history.
trapsmv9 3 years ago 5
i agree, it has yet to be competed with. Archuleta's Imagine was a very close second, but not as powerful as this one.
paint1487 3 years ago
I'd like to see David Cook and David A sing these songs Clay did...... they don't come close to Clays beautiful singing voice...........big hugs to u Clay
lalamandelala121 3 years ago 2
lemongirl90, your videos are so nice & clear.
Captures every expression&gesture.Clay is so gorgeous!!!
Thanx for posting!!!
ImsweetonClay 3 years ago
I love Clay and Archie! They both should've won but the title isn't evrythang... Woohoo!
klouwey123 3 years ago
wow....he sang almost all his best songs like this, this is the night, don't let the sun go down on me............and he still lost?
tigergrrs2 3 years ago
One of the best Idol guys performance of all of Idol's history!! Clay, Bo, Chris D, and Elliot do not hold a candle to the Davids and Castro!!
batfan903 3 years ago
u forgot to add RUBEN!!!
dancedancestar14 3 years ago
Clay always gives me chills when he sings. This song is so beautiful and his voice just
takes it to a whole new level of power and beauty. Bravo Clay.
KATZGROOVE 3 years ago 2
Gorgeous!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and the voice too.
AikenFerClay 3 years ago
wow how diff he looks fr the clay auditioning
ouueee 4 years ago
Awesome Perfect Fantastic.
claykitty01 4 years ago 3
ooooh. he's so damn good.
Heeelene 4 years ago 2