Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (106)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Hello Doctor Carlisle Cullen

  • Oh MY Gosh I love Carlisle SO much! He's my favorite Cullen! :D He's so good-hearted, humble and the sweetest man ever! :D

    Carlisle's has such a beautiful soul that it gets even angels cry ~ for his sakes :)

    TEAM CARLISLE FOREVER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • OMG this is the SWEETEST song I EVER heard!! Amazing voice!!! PLEEEAASE tell me I can by the sheet music!! xox

  • This is so beautiful :) I love Carlisle and this song is amazing! The craziest thing is that the girl singing has the exact same name as me!

  • :D Carlisle is now my favourite Cullen! TEAM CARLISLE! Thumbs up if you agree and are Team Carlisle. CARLISLE CULLEN CARLISLE CULLEN!

  • cool XD i love it!

  • does anyone know how to download this song for free?

  • I LOVE CARLISLE CULLEN! he is gentle and understanding :)

  • mieko2034 adorei o vídeo achei a música muito linda ,assim como também achei que a música combina com o personagen do Dr. Carlisle Cullen

  • mieko2034 Dia 23 de Abril DE 2010 Horário; 7:50:15 amo esse video por causa do Dr .Carliele ele e o personagem mais maravilhoso de Crepúsculo.

  • Cool.

  • Stuff Edward and Jacob

    Team Carlisle! (L) XDDDD

    (not really, edward all the way) ^_^

    Beautiful song :)

  • We're not obsesive (well kinda) we only want someone like him and even if its a fictional character, so what? You people don't care when people write songs for other people! That's who he is for most of us, a person!

  • i lvoe this so much, beautifull (:

  • I really luv Carlisle, and don't get y people keep saying that all the Cullen's aren't real... Yes We Know!! We just luv him because we wish we had someone as beautiful/understanding/caring etc as him!

  • Thank you for your wise words! I agree and I love Carlisle and his gift of compassion! It's true that the Cullens especially Carlisle make us long for that... But I also think that we can find Carlisle inside of ourselves if we look deeply and we will find the understanding soft eyes of Carlsile somewhere in there. Hugs from Nenne in Stockholm

  • Carlisle can inspire us a lot in our daily lives!!

  • @VANDUYVENVOORDEx

    Hate to burst your buble there but believe it or not there are A LOT of songs out there that have been written about made-up or fictional characters o_O And also again this is merely my show of love for Natalie's song. Yes some people are a little over the top but its the same with everything eles so...anyway

  • @VANDUYVENVOORDEx We all know he sn't real, it's jut a tribute to the creative mind or stephanie meyer :)

    But yeah... some people terrify me with their obsession... I know someone who fainted when she met rob pattinsen...

  • @VANDUYVENVOORDEx i know this was a while ago but, obsessive people will stalk them, don't you think? plenty of tributes to edward, whos complaining about them? an yeah, the song is wonderful :)

  • @VANDUYVENVOORDEx How dare you!! D'you know how much effort somebody has put into this!?! Not to mention it's a bout the fittest guy in the galaxy, get some manners.

  • ♥ Beatiful Voice :-)

  • Beautiul Voice :)

  • this is beautiful :)

  • he is like offft haha hes bloody gorgeous

  • i love carlisle more than the other cullens

  • A beautiful soul such as Carlisle deserves a beautiful song like this!!! ... Thank you

  • That is ... just ... amazingly beautiful!!! ... Brings tears to my eyes.... The most beautiful song I've heard in a long time! I love the twilight saga! I love Carlisle. This song is moving like he is... He is more humane than human beings normally are... Because humans don't often fight so hard to live in peace... The vampires have many impressive gifts. But his gift is compassion: Most important thing to posess!

  • thats a very beautiful song. it made me cry.

  • DOES ANYONE KNOW WERE I CAN DOWNLOAD THIS SONG OTHER THAN AMAZON AND iTUNES?????? PLEASE PLEASE TELL ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ♥

  • Nope, the artist (Natalie Nicole Gilbert) isn't very well known so its only available via amazon and iTUNES. If you really love the song then show your support and just download it that way ^-^

  • thankyou xoxo just wondering ^_^

  • Your welcome ^-^

  • @tashaizdabest123 google " youtube to mp3 converter" that always works for me

  • in the books i really liked his charecter i loved him!! (ive read bookswith 800 yr old wizards i hav thing for the young and beutiful 800 yr olds)) evreytime i hear carlisles voice i smile!!!!

  • He is not a WIZARD hes a vampire!

  • Carlisle is wonderful, makes me smile everytime I see his face! I'm love drunk on Carlisle Cullen.

  • so hot!

  • omg i freakin love carlisle e my fav boy/ man in it... i tink e way betr lukin dan edward

  • wow that a great tribute and Carlisle really deserves a tribute

  • This is awesome !!

  • Thanks ^^

  • thanks for uploading this

  • No Probs ^^

  • I reli like Carlisle, I think he deserves this! =]

  • same

  • wow this is a nice song

    its not wat you'd think twilight'd go for

    its nice ndcalming you know

    like you can relax nd stuff

    <3 luv Carlisle he rox

  • This is beautiful. I love carlisle: behind Edward, he's my fave xx

  • if i think about what carlisle have see and have todo in his life...omg T_T...so much pain...i love carlisle and esme...they're so sweet

  • Its really nice, I could listen to this song over and over again. AND TO NOT JUGE TWILIGHT FOR ITS MOVIE!!!!!!!!!! Sry but read the book its better and the movie and the character arent all that good for twilight.

  • Its up to the artist on what they make thier songs about lol and I think she mainly did Carlisle as theres always so much spotlight on the main chracters including Jacob...you make think that but theres also a lot of people out there who would disagree~

  • i agree and carlisle is mint

  • i love twilight and i lovee this song soo muchh :D

  • Again please don't post spoilers even if you think people should know or not ¬¬ As it is im still reading breaking dawn so...yeah thanks ¬¬ In future please don't post spoliers~ again as nothing to do with the video lol

  • What? Why is the guy in the twilight movie in this video ?

  • Because this song was written about him.

  • About carlisle cullen or about the acual actor in the movie ?

  • About Carlisle. It's in the description..

  • duuuuuuhhh. carlisle cullen is his name!

  • God  ! Calm down !! some ppl dont know he is geeezz !!

  • And by the way the actors name is not carlisle its Peter Facinelli

  • some people shud know he is.

  • no offense but i dont really like this song

  • This song is so good at telling us about him it should be on the sound track

  • who writes a song about a fictional character?

    Not that im saying it isnt a beautiful song, because it is, but.....

  • Actually ALOT of people rofl. But all of the songs that were written about the charcters in Twilight are amazing. The Mitch Hansen Band is a Twilight inspired group - all their songs are based on the books. Twilight Girls are another band. There is alot of people who do.

    This song is beautiful though :)

  • I <3 Carlisle

  • Jees! Never new I'd get 2thumbs down from asking a simple question >:-( FGS! I like Carlisle, I was ONLY ASKING A QUESTION!

    Hope my point is proven.

  • oh wow.

    nice song... but the topic is a little weird.

    the song does suit him though.

    i loooved the books before they got big,

    and the movie was way too serious and rosalie was just ugly.

    fingers crossed that new moon will be better (L)

  • Why all the tributes to Carlisle?

  • cuz he is the most outstanding individual in the series. he has accomplished so much and deserves a tribute!

  • Because he's just as Bella describes him, and more: -he's super sexi -he's like a vampire god -he's nice -he's the one who brought the whole Cullen together/back alive -his face is flawless -everyone loves him -he's a doctor -he knew just exactly how to get Bella, Edward, and Renesmee out of trouble when the Voultri came for them -he knows all vampire loopholes -he's smart -he's a vampire matchmaker -he's fine with whatever anybody does, because he understands it's their life.... AND MUCH MORE
  • trying to make me faint?

  • Lol. That was kinda my goal. XD

    I would have put more, but YouTube would let me put any more text in it. I think I'm gonna make a video with ALL the reasons of why Carlisle is so frikken awesome. :)

  • I made this video simply because I know the artist and she asked if I wouldn't mind making her a video after seeing someone had already made one using her song~ The tribute is mainly her song

  • Simply because he deserves it! =)

  • This song suits Carlisle

  • i love this song, its so beautiful

  • i'm crying... i don't know why just the music sounds sad.. :(( such a good song! xxx

  • *sighs* Calrisle...sorry had to do it

  • i really dont like this song.

    the music is terrible with just the same few bars of piano repeated over and over and over and over again. the singing is quite good but such a boring song.

  • i agree :)

  • i love carlisle! :D i had this wicked dream he was in once :D

  • Yeah sorry!^

    Well done!!!

    (But the Book is better...)^^

  • Can people please stop leaving comments about what was or wasnt good about the movie compared to the book. This video is just a tribute to the character of Carlisle hence the title of the video lol and not about the movie ^_^

  • i think he's really pretty^^

  • omg this is soooo sweet. Cuz i love love love Carlisle

  • they do call him Dr.Feelgood hahah jk but hes a cutie (and yes im a grl)!!!!!!! hes like the hero uv my dreams. really i had like 4 dreams in the past week about him and him saving my life (like i was Bella) really it was soo weird and fun and last but not least AWSOME

  • one word....beautiful

  • I love this song!

    It suits carlisle perfectly. <3

  • Agreed xDD

  • This song is so amazing and breath-taking.

    It defo goes with Carlisle.

    The lyrics are so powerful and have a moral to them unlike some songs.

    Thanks for the video <3

  • Agreeing with you completely ^_^

    & your very welcome! xD

    Please go check out Natalies facebook!

  • I don´t like the film much and I do´t like Rob Pattison and Kristen Steward but I love the books.

  • Yeah they were totally wrong for the parts, I thought Edward and Bella were totally in love but still had a few jokey funny moments but the film just totally wiped those out and made it too, intense...

  • I know i didn't like how serious it all was at times, but they have a new director for new moon now so hopefully it will be better (:

    i love this song, i didnt like it at first, i thought it was a bit cheesey, but i really like it now.

  • this is a good song but it is sooooo slow that u can bearly understand wat she is saying

  • what is the point in this song? has something happened to carlisle?

  • erm its called a TRIBUTE like the title says :S

  • yh i figuered, but wat is the tribute for?

  • it's a tribute to HIM.

    google the definition of tribute, n00b ¬_¬

  • LOL XD

  • I agree, I like the song, and love Carlisle, but mostly Tributes are for people once they've died? Thats my opinion anyway, so I would have asked something similar.

    No need to have ago at her, idiots. It's just a question.

  • well, in a way, carlisle is kinda already dead. so...yeah.

  • this song is soo cute!

    but i think it may b abit

    slow 4 my liking...but

    i still lyk it!...xD

  • i thought the first twilight was a bit boaring hopefully the 2nd one would be better

  • have you even read the book!!?? the book was way better!

  • i have read the book its definitly bettr than the film

  • Breathing Hope is now available on iTunes. :)

  • Awesome XD

  • Beautiful song lovee it.

    blats not as much as Twilight its self XD

  • Wow. This song makes me cry.

  • definately perfect for carlisle,,

    possibly on ths soundtrack for new moon ??x

    i love it XD

  • Would be awesome for it to be on new moon! I told natalie that the moment i heard it XD So maybe?

    Shall pass on the message ^^

  • I love this song, so beautiful.

  • SameSame XD

  • amazing song isnt it..

    its calm and so relaxing

    beautiful lyrics.

    way better than some random song like single ladies - beyonce...

    these lyrics have a point..and tell a story

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more