No other singer performed this role like Caballe did. Her ethereal pianissimi and prodigious breath control helped to set her apart. I never tire of listening to her.
magnificent in every detail. I'm SO FRUSTRATED that the only DVD Caballe Carreras performance available (although THEY are wonderful) is the Japanese production.I have it, but it pales next to this production. Caballe is so much better in this aria and their final love duet - better costumes, more delicacy of pianissimos, better sound, better stage direction - like Carreras kneeling as he proposes in the last scene. If anyone has THIS on DVD-answer.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Caballe's voice is on and off with me. Sometimes I absolutely melt, while other times I cringe at obvious technical flaws. Callas was that way too. But Caballe has amazing subito pianos and floats.
if caballe and callas have these 'obvious technical flaws'--oh God.. the two great gifts of God for us in the 20th century...who would be at a greater level..that you believe is up to snuff?..i'd really like to know,,REALLY!!!! Please reply to me
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
exactly! Compared to the technical atrocities all the rest of the singers did Callas and Caballe were flawless before them! It's just my friend that no-one ever bothered to described the count-less technical mistakes of other great singers, thus in the common mind they appear as "flawless".
Come on Montserrat! You can do it! Just one little word ... Good diction is not that hard ... LOVE YOU THOUGH!!! :-)
cevicentevideos 3 months ago
I love this production! Watching it right now. Except for the support cast being a bit finer in Tokyo, this is wonderful!
dsenRuskin 1 year ago
No other singer performed this role like Caballe did. Her ethereal pianissimi and prodigious breath control helped to set her apart. I never tire of listening to her.
JessyeNormanFan 1 year ago
Exquisite. This whole 1978 Nice production is
magnificent in every detail. I'm SO FRUSTRATED that the only DVD Caballe Carreras performance available (although THEY are wonderful) is the Japanese production.I have it, but it pales next to this production. Caballe is so much better in this aria and their final love duet - better costumes, more delicacy of pianissimos, better sound, better stage direction - like Carreras kneeling as he proposes in the last scene. If anyone has THIS on DVD-answer.
tuadolcefanciulla 1 year ago
It seems to me that when she sings this aria, it rings with truth. It reflects what she believes about herself. Wonderful!
dsenRuskin 2 years ago
In my humble opinion, Caballe's voice is flawless.
mebert10 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Both Freni's recital version and the Met gala are better than this interpretation. Freni wipes the floor with Caballe...end of story.
dennisdeem 3 years ago
............your short story
cualalumpur2 3 years ago 6
Another great video from our friend Oneguin - aren't we lucky to have him share such bounty?
Gracias por todo!!!!!
cantorandopera 4 years ago 13
I totally agree!!! Absolutamente de acuerdo.....Gracias Oneguin!!!
colibridelapampa 4 years ago 9
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Caballe's voice is on and off with me. Sometimes I absolutely melt, while other times I cringe at obvious technical flaws. Callas was that way too. But Caballe has amazing subito pianos and floats.
dennisdeem 4 years ago
if caballe and callas have these 'obvious technical flaws'--oh God.. the two great gifts of God for us in the 20th century...who would be at a greater level..that you believe is up to snuff?..i'd really like to know,,REALLY!!!! Please reply to me
pirocagrande 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
exactly! Compared to the technical atrocities all the rest of the singers did Callas and Caballe were flawless before them! It's just my friend that no-one ever bothered to described the count-less technical mistakes of other great singers, thus in the common mind they appear as "flawless".
Lohengrin 4 years ago