JOSHUA! You are even more beautiful than the beauty itself! You are dream's dream. You are not beautiful, beautiful is you. GOD, I want to say so bad how much i love you but i cant because i cant express it with words the way i feel it... in 100 years we'll all be gone, and those people will only be able to watch you on TVs or computers, so even if i cant see you in real life i still consider myself as lucky cause we both existed in the same century.
Yes this was one of the first times he sang it. By the way he IS singing in Italian and not in German. He does the romance languages and English, prefers sad songs. Just listen to "Vincent". Rare tribute to Van Gogh, and very moving.
I love Josh Groban. And this may not be his best performance, but it was a long time ago. He's gotten so much better over the years. Besides, he said so himself, he didn't enjoy his success for a couple of years. He was probably nervous. Don't be so harsh on him.
Unfortunately I just don't buy it and I'm not so sure he even understands what he's saying here -- I just don't see the feeling - the acting needed for great opera -- he is singing the words but there is no deep blinding soulful passion of looking out across the Sea of Sorrento after holding his crying woman in his arms and trying to say how much he loves her sorry I don't dislike it but it's not a thumbs up for me
Try and hear this song in the voice of Lucio Dalla and then you will realise who puts Groban, Bocelli and even Pavarotti in his pocket! Gli meti tutti in tasca!
Groban is not as good as many act when it comes to actual skill. He has a very pleasant voice, but when it comes to the power you need behind songs like this he falls terribly flat!
he can sing...but i thought he was boring......i know singers that sing this at their local night club and would blow his version out of the water,it didnt move me at all.....i think if you sing a song u have to be open to criticism...and will be compared to the singers that send chills down your spine singing the same song. good job ,but didnt do it for me
@MrKeysjimmy i don't think the problem is his singing. i can't say for sure, but it really seems as if he doesn't understand the lyics. ex. "ma tanto tanto, bene assai" that's a powerful statement, yet he kinda glosses over it. also his mastery of italian gets in his way.
all together, i have no problem with it, i think it's quite laudable that he steps out of his comfort zone.
wow. seems the pressure he put on himself here is fairly obvious. a super talented guy for sure, who as of this writing appears to have really grown into himself, and is throughly enjoying what he does. he wasn't quite so much in this video. and still very enjoyable.
I agree with " lordshin73 , it is missing a lot in his performance a very dull performande by this a very mediocre singer with a powerful promotional lobby.
If I didn't see Pavarotti, Lara Fabian, or the composer of this piece, Lucio Dalla sing this, I'd actually think this rendition was good...however, I am watching this after previewing the three vocalist I've mentioned...something is missing in his performance here....feels empty. As a talent, however, he's the real deal...but this performance lacks something.
Cancel orPost or Create a video response LEASE DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE.TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN THIS DONT STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY, PUT THIS ON ATleast 5 videos
@drcise Was just thinking that I would love to hear Josh sing this song with Lara. I love them both and think they do an equally great great job of this song which is one of my favorites. Josh did sing For Always with Lara.
There is feeling there if you are listening properly. People need to listen not just hear. There is a difference. Pavarottis version is a differnt key, so cannot cmpare but i have listened and his version is forced. This isn't, it sounds free.
Josh has an incredible voice, but I agree that he doesn't have the passion for this song. I have heard him sing others where he totally grasps the power and meaning. I think that is part of the cultural divide. Americans don't feel like Europeans, nor can Europeans ever feel like Americans. The psyche just does not mesh, sad as it is!
very nice voice. I have heart Pavarotti's version and Il divo's version, and in my opinion pavarotti will be always "The Man", but this guy doesnt do it bad!
@PrEttYbAbYmx well said. People would do well to listen to this advice. Its usually the ones that dont no anything at all that comeout with the most ridiculous comments. Keep things positive but keep your feet on the ground. Dont go for pie in the sky comments! Listen to this girl, she has more sense than the older people!
ich hab das damals bei wetten dass...? gesehen ohne zu wissen, wer denn dieser süße typ ist, der da auf italienisch singt. xD jetzt bin ich schlauer^^ gott sei dank! and I just hope that this incredible singer comes back to germany next year!!! PLEASE!! To watch him perform live would be a real gift to me...and many others as well^^ Seine neue Single lässt schon darauf hinweisen, dass das neue album großartig sein wird und mal wieder voll von wunderbarem schmalz xDD
Lara Fabian's got a great voice but I went to watch her video after some people were criticizing this and other interpretations and said hers was the best...I don't understand why people equate good singing with sighing and moaning...
This version is marvelous! I did not expect that Josh Groban made so many appearances on German TV. Too bad I've never seen one. ... at least Thomas Gottschalk is not mispronouncing Josh's name ;D
As much as I love, love, love Josh, those who love this song should listen to Lara Fabian's version - it made the hair on the back of my neck stand up, as well as brought me to tears.
How to ruin a beautiful song. Give it to an average singer who can't phrase italian and you get this rubbish. Stick to singing tat Josh you will never be an opera singer and you simply don't have the heart or emotion for this song. This is a song for someone who has lived a full life and can do it justice.
@straponjane Sorry but I can't agree. I don't know if you know Josh Groban or his songs or not but I think you don't. If you would know him you wouldn't say that he has no heart or emotion for this song. Josh is a very soulful singer. He sings with his heart and whit passion. Always. Maybe it is not his best performance but don't say he is an average singer! It is not true. And nobody said he is an opera singer or he will be one. I like e.g. Lara's version but that is too theatrical for me.
@straponjane This song is not an "opera-song"... Pavarotti and Bocelli give their interpretation, but the original version is different. Lucio Dalla is the writer and he doesn't have a strong voice, but he his so soulful!
His Italian pronunciation, accent and voice are faultless. Few Italian performers sound as Italian as he, yet he’s not. For those who’s idea of Italian, is to gesticulate and sound Calabrese, please go back to school. Manzoni rolls in his grave, when you open your mouths ….
I've heard so many versions of this song, but honestly, 'for me' (not quotation marks of a subjective statement) I didn't really feel anything. It is technically good and sound, but no poignant emotions to be felt. I loved Lara's version better. And of course Pavarotti. Now those, I felt the ache.
Once you hear Pavarotti's version, it's hard to appreciate any other performance. But of course, the difference is that Pavarotti was a real operatic tenor and Groban is just a wannabe tenor, so it's really quite unfair to compare the two.
@averagehomosapien Josh Groban is young. just regard that aspect before comparing a legend with a "will be" one. They're both good, if you want to hear a performance that personally i consider it extremely great, search for Caruso sung by Lara Fabian. Just a recommandation.
This is the second German television show I've seen with Josh where they had all this fire around. That seems odd to have a singer perform around all that smoke -- not very good for the voice, i would think. Beautiful song, though.
great voice!! beautiful and powerful baritone. as a lyrico tenor myself I can say what he really is.. but it doesnt matter. He is a fantastic singer, thats what he is. This world needs more singers!!
Un día, un día cualquiera, nuestra alma subirá quien sabe donde, de entre los colores de las voces del mundo oiremos al oido esta música, no importa quien la cante, Josh, Andrea, el magister Luciano o Plácido, no habrá mas nada en tu mirada que los recuerdos en tu mente...y es que no hay nada mas amigos...Bravo bambino!!!!
Personally I think that the accent and the pronounciation is just a detail to this point. I am italian and when I heard this my first thought wasn't "Oh, he can't speak properly!"....it was "This is great love and hurting in singing"
Josh he is great, please, never put together singers, just look at their talent, they all are great, we can not live our life with one singer, so take it easy, lets enjoy what this great guys do...... one at the time.... he is good.... I have hundreds of names in my book, and I love all of them...
@khodemooni well, i am a 19 yo italian boy... I was lookin for a song to dedicate to my girlfriend, and i finally found it... this guy sings in a perfect italian ( some italians talk italian in a worst way xD) GO JOSH! YOU ROCK!
@khodemooni There are not hundreds of great singers... please refrain from misusing the word "great", thanks.
Great = Pavarotti, Bocelli, Domingo, and maybe there is 100 great singers... i challenge you to back your words up and name me at least 200 GREAT singers... then i will believe you when i see the list.
no doubts about this... I should have been in a good mood when I wrote that, he's actually good as pop singer (=crap) but this song is clearly not a pitch for him
not convincing......too much emphasis on the word pronounciation ,negleting the feeling, pitch changing twice.....josh is capable of much much more if u listen to "to where you are" for example...
Really, his pronounciation is actually quite good for an English speaker. His e's are a bit too rounded and he can't seem to master the diphthongs - his 'voglio' sounds rather strange to me. But his singing is superb, even if I like his French renditions much better.
It's funny though, speaking of languages, this video confuses me. I suppose I'm just not used to hearing German, Italian and English all in the span of a few minutes.
Never to be compared to Lucio Dalla! Go sing jingles kid
torpido999 5 days ago
Hermosooo!♥
cintiamaida 1 week ago
Hermoso!!
hypotanuz 2 weeks ago
My god, that's obsession!!
mcarralero 3 weeks ago
ps: pavarotti or anyone else cant even be compared to 1 tiny dust molecule on your shoelace.
jonightforest 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
JOSHUA! You are even more beautiful than the beauty itself! You are dream's dream. You are not beautiful, beautiful is you. GOD, I want to say so bad how much i love you but i cant because i cant express it with words the way i feel it... in 100 years we'll all be gone, and those people will only be able to watch you on TVs or computers, so even if i cant see you in real life i still consider myself as lucky cause we both existed in the same century.
You are my everything.
jonightforest 1 month ago
Comment removed
jonightforest 1 month ago
Please sing this to me <3
RhianJosieRose 2 months ago
Yes this was one of the first times he sang it. By the way he IS singing in Italian and not in German. He does the romance languages and English, prefers sad songs. Just listen to "Vincent". Rare tribute to Van Gogh, and very moving.
Momo2Ts 2 months ago
I thought his performance was great. I don't see anything wrong with it. German sounds very difficult to sing in. But he does a good job of it.
rebarox85 2 months ago
Comment removed
rebarox85 2 months ago
"Ichtnk akkkek kkkkzzkkkk chtttik Josh Groban."
sethadamlee 3 months ago
I love Josh Groban. And this may not be his best performance, but it was a long time ago. He's gotten so much better over the years. Besides, he said so himself, he didn't enjoy his success for a couple of years. He was probably nervous. Don't be so harsh on him.
ARUIZ1789 3 months ago
but i recommend lara fabian or bochelli or jolio iglasius
ppayneish 3 months ago
I like this
jannlee555 3 months ago
The show was live from Austria, in Klagenfurt
Thanks for posting!
hiko718 4 months ago
OMG !!!! wie er wunderschoen singt......
esterka17 4 months ago in playlist Więcej filmów od użytkownika billy1983yes
If you want to hear an amezing live intpretation of this song try Lucio Dalla live in Verona
wilsondeibasilici 4 months ago
Unfortunately I just don't buy it and I'm not so sure he even understands what he's saying here -- I just don't see the feeling - the acting needed for great opera -- he is singing the words but there is no deep blinding soulful passion of looking out across the Sea of Sorrento after holding his crying woman in his arms and trying to say how much he loves her sorry I don't dislike it but it's not a thumbs up for me
dixiedragon54 4 months ago
You do an outstanding job on this Josh. You do so much better than Pavarotti. You don't cry your way through this song like Pavarotti does.
Maggie12ification 4 months ago
Try and hear this song in the voice of Lucio Dalla and then you will realise who puts Groban, Bocelli and even Pavarotti in his pocket! Gli meti tutti in tasca!
fascin80 4 months ago
@fascin80 hahahaha,good joke
jakedezziderius 4 months ago
@jakedezziderius You know that Lucio Dalla actually WROTE this song? Here, try this: youtube.com/watch?v=-2VRd8EtYzM
fascin80 4 months ago
@fascin80 i know,i just commented somethin else :)
jakedezziderius 4 months ago
Meh his good...but Andrea bocelli gives me goosebumps when his sings Caruso. In my opinion. His voice isn't as strong as Andrea's.
MsBreeze2009 5 months ago
I love how he voice dips down very deep for a brief moment. Absolutely amazing. His range blows me away.
VolleyballQueen2016 5 months ago
I am sorry but I don't think that Josh Groban does a good job with this song.
peludomolina 5 months ago
I don't know a whole lot about music, but I know what I like. Pavarotti owns this song. Groban sounds weak to me....again, I'm no expert.
jtoosph22 5 months ago
@jtoosph22
Groban is not as good as many act when it comes to actual skill. He has a very pleasant voice, but when it comes to the power you need behind songs like this he falls terribly flat!
SebastienCade 4 months ago
WELL....MAYBE HE CAN BEET ME ON A TENNIS GAME BUT HE NEEDS A LONG WAY TO BEAT ME SINGING! YOUTUBE SEARCH ...ROGERLEECYPRUS!THANKS!
rogerleecyprus 6 months ago
he can sing...but i thought he was boring......i know singers that sing this at their local night club and would blow his version out of the water,it didnt move me at all.....i think if you sing a song u have to be open to criticism...and will be compared to the singers that send chills down your spine singing the same song. good job ,but didnt do it for me
MrKeysjimmy 6 months ago
@MrKeysjimmy i don't think the problem is his singing. i can't say for sure, but it really seems as if he doesn't understand the lyics. ex. "ma tanto tanto, bene assai" that's a powerful statement, yet he kinda glosses over it. also his mastery of italian gets in his way.
all together, i have no problem with it, i think it's quite laudable that he steps out of his comfort zone.
thoyo 5 months ago
wow. seems the pressure he put on himself here is fairly obvious. a super talented guy for sure, who as of this writing appears to have really grown into himself, and is throughly enjoying what he does. he wasn't quite so much in this video. and still very enjoyable.
jeanneadele 6 months ago
Caruso isn't opera lol.
goldengal1989 7 months ago
The song is transposed i think,
Ok, he is not an opera singer. So why on earth he try and do.
Is he a tenor? Is he a baritone? I m not sure, but i guess he is a lyric baritone who sings songs composed for tenor, but transposed.
Rodolfomorello1965 7 months ago
I agree with " lordshin73 , it is missing a lot in his performance a very dull performande by this a very mediocre singer with a powerful promotional lobby.
ed131039 7 months ago
If I didn't see Pavarotti, Lara Fabian, or the composer of this piece, Lucio Dalla sing this, I'd actually think this rendition was good...however, I am watching this after previewing the three vocalist I've mentioned...something is missing in his performance here....feels empty. As a talent, however, he's the real deal...but this performance lacks something.
lordshin73 7 months ago
@lordshin73 Ah yes, you are quite right. Fireworks at the end is what it needed. :)
Tirza777 7 months ago
He has the voice for it, but not the depth of emotion.
GaelinW 7 months ago
@GaelinW maybe he was nervous.... don't be so harsh. :( This video is at the beginning of his career- he's still shy at this point.
Tirza777 7 months ago
not even close to the older versions..it simply does not move you...why they dont stick to their own songs
hoomanasad 7 months ago
Josh Groban, marry me!!!!
andreca90 7 months ago 7
@andreca90 Please, Josh dont marry me, I'm a guy. But let me hear some more. :)
chansonfinlandaise 1 month ago
ma fatela finita si sente che non e´italiano!!!!!!!!!! oppure siciliano!!!!!!!!
davidecesco 8 months ago
Josh is already great and he will only get better.
sk8412c 8 months ago 2
@sk8412c Like a fine wine, he gets better with age. ;)
Tirza777 7 months ago
Complimenti! Veramente. Perfetta interpretazione valutando che lui é di Los Angeles.
In Italia ci sono cantanti che bisbigliano e si mangiano le parole... Bravo, bravo, bravo!!!
corradohit 8 months ago
Respond to this video... characters remaining
Cancel orPost or Create a video response LEASE DONT READ THIS CAUSE IT ACTUALLY WORKS. YOU WILL GET KISSED ON THE NEAREST POSSIBLE FRIDAY BY THE LOVE OF YOUR LIFE.TOMORROW WILL BE THE BEST DAY OF YOUR LIFE. HOWEVER IF YOU DONT POST THIS COMMENT TO AT LEAST 3 VIDEOS YOU WILL DIE WITHIN 2 DAYS. NOW UV STARTED READIN THIS DONT STOP. THIS IS SO SCARY, PUT THIS ON ATleast 5 videos
Darkangeldeea1987 9 months ago
Saw him live.. He is very very very GOOD!
cutator 9 months ago 4
I would agree that Josh has a good voice, but more presense is needed.
sopranoms 9 months ago
awesome!!!!
francita2007 9 months ago
e minunat!
deniss393 10 months ago
If you want to see passion. Check out Lara Fabian's live version. Amazing.
Not saying Josh Groban doesn't have a beautiful voice though.
drcise 10 months ago 2
@drcise Was just thinking that I would love to hear Josh sing this song with Lara. I love them both and think they do an equally great great job of this song which is one of my favorites. Josh did sing For Always with Lara.
Francesca42 8 months ago
There is feeling there if you are listening properly. People need to listen not just hear. There is a difference. Pavarottis version is a differnt key, so cannot cmpare but i have listened and his version is forced. This isn't, it sounds free.
singerman2008 10 months ago
Josh has an incredible voice, but I agree that he doesn't have the passion for this song. I have heard him sing others where he totally grasps the power and meaning. I think that is part of the cultural divide. Americans don't feel like Europeans, nor can Europeans ever feel like Americans. The psyche just does not mesh, sad as it is!
Nevermore1953 10 months ago
A esta gente no deberian permitirle interpretar una pieza como esta. Es un insulto
reconditaArmoniia 10 months ago
no passion...........no caruso
MrSorrento80 11 months ago 2
I know this has little to do with the video, but I absolutely love the set he's singing on.
MrCatnip88 11 months ago
very nice voice. I have heart Pavarotti's version and Il divo's version, and in my opinion pavarotti will be always "The Man", but this guy doesnt do it bad!
;)
thestoryofatoy 11 months ago
Good voice, lacks feeling..
MikeXwolf 11 months ago
He is doing his own version and believe he interprets it just fine - he is not Pavarotti - he is Josh Groban!
rionilo67 11 months ago
Verdammt ... und ausgerechnet diese "Wetten, dass..."-Folge habe ich nicht gesehen!!
Dabei liebe ich Josh Groban und seine Stimme so unsagbar! :(
WankiTank 11 months ago
pięknie
cynamone80 1 year ago
IF U DONT HAVE SOMETHING GOOD TO SAY ABOUT SOMEBODY,, DONT SAY NOTHING DAMN IT!!!... each singer si different thats WHY they sell cds ...
I think this is the best interpretation of this song. i hear it thousends of times with hundred of singers ... and i like JOSH GROBAN . im his fan!!
by the way ... listen that with LARA FABIANA...
PrEttYbAbYmx 1 year ago 2
@PrEttYbAbYmx have you ever listen by andea bocelli....josh is good,but not enough....!!!
bar3nconiku 10 months ago
Andrea is italian ... :) its because of it
ThePidzej 10 months ago
@PrEttYbAbYmx well said. People would do well to listen to this advice. Its usually the ones that dont no anything at all that comeout with the most ridiculous comments. Keep things positive but keep your feet on the ground. Dont go for pie in the sky comments! Listen to this girl, she has more sense than the older people!
singerman2008 10 months ago
Vitas is better
daturainoxia1 1 year ago
Vitas is more, more good.
daturainoxia1 1 year ago
ha ucciso caruso per la seconda volta
kastori123 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Keep singing that shit that you have done so far and leave this music to people that really know how to do it.
Liu666able 1 year ago
limp, listen to the writer of the song lucio dallia live in verona.
soulfullmusic100 1 year ago
this presentator sucks so much, he's always so disrespectful
dromycatcher 1 year ago
Pavarotti has Passion when he sings this!!!
JAtria 1 year ago 2
Another great performance by Josh!
goldengal1989 1 year ago 3
You can get the audio-mp3 of this video at grabyourmp3s doht cohm.
ZoraFreid601556 1 year ago
The voice of an ANGEL........... God knows what he's doing when he gives us these people!!
sixstring49 1 year ago
Lucio dalla sings the song perfect!!!
italboy13 1 year ago
I believe this young fella is a fantastic Star with a tremendous voice
TheScottypom 1 year ago 2
Whoa, that announcer is tall. *_*
unknowndeoxys00 1 year ago
da paura!!!
sierracoswort 1 year ago
Very good Italian pronunciation!
goldenthroat86 1 year ago
ich hab das damals bei wetten dass...? gesehen ohne zu wissen, wer denn dieser süße typ ist, der da auf italienisch singt. xD jetzt bin ich schlauer^^ gott sei dank! and I just hope that this incredible singer comes back to germany next year!!! PLEASE!! To watch him perform live would be a real gift to me...and many others as well^^ Seine neue Single lässt schon darauf hinweisen, dass das neue album großartig sein wird und mal wieder voll von wunderbarem schmalz xDD
EasyAsLife93 1 year ago
just SUPERB!!!!!!!!!!!!
thepowerofnow 1 year ago 2
Lara Fabian's got a great voice but I went to watch her video after some people were criticizing this and other interpretations and said hers was the best...I don't understand why people equate good singing with sighing and moaning...
alesolsal 1 year ago
Pippin from Lord of The Rings.
drakonimetal 1 year ago
This version is marvelous! I did not expect that Josh Groban made so many appearances on German TV. Too bad I've never seen one. ... at least Thomas Gottschalk is not mispronouncing Josh's name ;D
Quallenforscherin 1 year ago
was??wann war das??ahhhhhh ich ich habes verpasst.ich will josh
2010santini 1 year ago
I'm italian and I can say that his pronunciation is very, very, very... good! :-)
I love also his voice!
HellyHappy 1 year ago 3
-his voice is like an Angel!!!!!!!! love him!!
puertorico199112 1 year ago
Pavarotti and Bocelli do it better.
MovidaNapoletana 1 year ago 2
@MovidaNapoletana
Correctly: "I guess......" ;)
Vagabundusz 1 year ago
i love he
claudiashina 1 year ago
Chills all through my body and I almost cried.
heyyyyy1111 1 year ago
like pavarotti...ahahahahahahahahahaah si o zess
zitarraseven 1 year ago
As much as I love, love, love Josh, those who love this song should listen to Lara Fabian's version - it made the hair on the back of my neck stand up, as well as brought me to tears.
ledger66 1 year ago 3
How to ruin a beautiful song. Give it to an average singer who can't phrase italian and you get this rubbish. Stick to singing tat Josh you will never be an opera singer and you simply don't have the heart or emotion for this song. This is a song for someone who has lived a full life and can do it justice.
straponjane 1 year ago
@straponjane Sorry but I can't agree. I don't know if you know Josh Groban or his songs or not but I think you don't. If you would know him you wouldn't say that he has no heart or emotion for this song. Josh is a very soulful singer. He sings with his heart and whit passion. Always. Maybe it is not his best performance but don't say he is an average singer! It is not true. And nobody said he is an opera singer or he will be one. I like e.g. Lara's version but that is too theatrical for me.
Maybenextyear1 1 year ago 17
@Maybenextyear1 if your not an opera singer, then don't sing it. it just ends up bad. he's good at what he does but not this.
dittohead791 4 months ago
Comment removed
HellyHappy 1 year ago
@straponjane This song is not an "opera-song"... Pavarotti and Bocelli give their interpretation, but the original version is different. Lucio Dalla is the writer and he doesn't have a strong voice, but he his so soulful!
I love also this version!
HellyHappy 1 year ago
me gusto vocalmente no hay peros ,aunque siento que le falto fuerza a la interpretacion
Raikkoniana 1 year ago
LA MUSICA PARLA ITALIANO, NINTE DA DIRE.
mercuryandzeppelin1 1 year ago 3
His Italian pronunciation, accent and voice are faultless. Few Italian performers sound as Italian as he, yet he’s not. For those who’s idea of Italian, is to gesticulate and sound Calabrese, please go back to school. Manzoni rolls in his grave, when you open your mouths ….
Bravo Groban!
2cosmo3 1 year ago
BEST VERSION MINA MAZZINI SORRY IF IVE OFFENED ANYONE ....
TTTRRRAAA3 1 year ago
BLOODY AWEFULL ...
TTTRRRAAA3 1 year ago
I've heard so many versions of this song, but honestly, 'for me' (not quotation marks of a subjective statement) I didn't really feel anything. It is technically good and sound, but no poignant emotions to be felt. I loved Lara's version better. And of course Pavarotti. Now those, I felt the ache.
heelrunner 1 year ago
@heelrunner No one can come close to Lara's version ! The emotion, the passion dripping, renders me breathless every time.
hereonearthme 1 year ago
good Italian,exellent singer. it's difficult for an american guy.I've heard wrost italian pronounces...
The Host is a little weird..
despstud1984 1 year ago
He is f*cking incredible..
the best male voice..honestly
italianstallion92 1 year ago
Respect your opinion but for me, Lara fabian is the best singer for this song..
wellonm 1 year ago
@wellonm she sings it nicely...but dont forget the original one by Lucio dalla...his duet with pavarotti live is just stunning
AleksMichel 1 year ago
his Italian is poor... i mean the accent..i agree with alecutesmile..
UlimorUdamenta 1 year ago
The best performer of this song is Lara Fabian. Josh has a beautiful voice, but he should improve his pronunciation in Italian.
alecutesmile 1 year ago
this guy sing f-ing awesome!
snowboard2382 1 year ago
Once you hear Pavarotti's version, it's hard to appreciate any other performance. But of course, the difference is that Pavarotti was a real operatic tenor and Groban is just a wannabe tenor, so it's really quite unfair to compare the two.
averagehomosapien 1 year ago
@averagehomosapien Josh Groban is young. just regard that aspect before comparing a legend with a "will be" one. They're both good, if you want to hear a performance that personally i consider it extremely great, search for Caruso sung by Lara Fabian. Just a recommandation.
630r6i 1 year ago
This is the second German television show I've seen with Josh where they had all this fire around. That seems odd to have a singer perform around all that smoke -- not very good for the voice, i would think. Beautiful song, though.
straightarrow372 1 year ago
I won't compare this to Andrea's version, but it's beautiful!
idrawandsing 1 year ago
the best ever
heroesforever2010 1 year ago
incredibile questo ragazzo...e la pronuncia è perfetta!!!!
LORY1191 1 year ago
great song, great singer but his pronunciation i dont lke sorry, hear this song with lara fabian
dvictorio 1 year ago
great voice!! beautiful and powerful baritone. as a lyrico tenor myself I can say what he really is.. but it doesnt matter. He is a fantastic singer, thats what he is. This world needs more singers!!
floydroseforever 1 year ago
voll schön, love him)))))))))))))
TheSayki 1 year ago
abaixou em pelo menos três tons para conseguir cantar até o final.
Nos karaokes muitos fazem o mesmo.
MrVergennes 1 year ago
Un día, un día cualquiera, nuestra alma subirá quien sabe donde, de entre los colores de las voces del mundo oiremos al oido esta música, no importa quien la cante, Josh, Andrea, el magister Luciano o Plácido, no habrá mas nada en tu mirada que los recuerdos en tu mente...y es que no hay nada mas amigos...Bravo bambino!!!!
oski48v 1 year ago
Wonderfull voice, magic song, extraordinary language...
YaniQC 1 year ago 2
Personally I think that the accent and the pronounciation is just a detail to this point. I am italian and when I heard this my first thought wasn't "Oh, he can't speak properly!"....it was "This is great love and hurting in singing"
blueshrania 1 year ago
pfff ,,lol,,,
rexidk 1 year ago
Josh Groban is a brilliant powerful and multitalented BARITONE. He has incredible range. FYI the "tenor in training" was a joke
TheSnowfire55 1 year ago
Le parole + belle che si possono cantare, grazie Lucio Dalla!!!
castoro83 1 year ago
me encanta Josh pero el intèrprete favorito para mi con esta canción es sin duda Andrea Bocelli..
elizabethorion 1 year ago
Comment removed
etreus87 1 year ago
Comment removed
etreus87 1 year ago
Brilliant - and his Italian is perfect. I'd love to hear Rhydian sing this one!
pianotabbycat 1 year ago
I love this song;) Josh Groban is amazing;)
neftyda87 1 year ago
is this in madison square garden?
francotitsassfart 1 year ago
@francotitsassfart THIS IS IN GERMANY in Frankfurt TV
liderumcom 1 year ago
noooo, It says Germany in the title. And the guy's speaking german.
k425m 1 year ago
his pronunciation is almost perfect! Great Josh!
reddevil82 1 year ago 6
@reddevil82 He is Italian Jew
liderumcom 1 year ago
He is not Italian, idiot
reddevil82 1 year ago 2
@liderumcom
1) he's Russian/Norwegian, not Italian
2) He's not Jewish. His father was a Russian Jew, but then converted. He was raised as an Episcopalian.
fa2064 1 year ago
@liderumcom
1. he's not Italian, he's Russian/Norwegian
2. He's not Jewish. His father was a Russian Jew, but converted when he married. He was raised as an Episcopalian.
fa2064 1 year ago
@fa2064 Wow...I would 've never guessed...Anyways HE IS THE B E S T voice in the world/ counting time from beginning to the end..../Josh rules!!!!!
35empress35 1 year ago
The guy is actually good.
Greatmk 1 year ago 3
زنفل بيسلم عليكم
ihabhariri 1 year ago
офигенски
bubaloon100 2 years ago
It took balls for him to redo this song and I think its missing a little something that I cant put my finger on, but it was good.
razorbladekisses101 2 years ago
Passion, passion, he needs the passion!
ceebeeful 1 year ago 14
Yes!! Thats it..He tends to lack that on occasion.
razorbladekisses101 1 year ago
@ceebeeful Yes! The passion!
manliter 1 year ago
@ceebeeful I've always thought that. Whenever I hear "Caruso" by Josh, though I do adore that man, I think he rushes this song a bit.
Viennatea 1 year ago
@ceebeeful .He's pretty great for a young guy, actually....
TheMimzee 1 year ago 13
you are great espacialy in this song becoause I am neapolitan
Kenpachi00000 2 years ago
#First heard this in One more Kiss starring Gerard Butler fantastic. Beautiful song Beautiful Movie. Thank you Josh and Gerry.
LUVYA
Joan (HUG) xxx
nk44ab 2 years ago
Ahhh... me fascina. Voz y rostro apacibles.
SlNTULATIDO 2 years ago
He did a great interpretation of this song...
he has a wonderful voice
angelicalemus91 2 years ago 4
Josh he is great, please, never put together singers, just look at their talent, they all are great, we can not live our life with one singer, so take it easy, lets enjoy what this great guys do...... one at the time.... he is good.... I have hundreds of names in my book, and I love all of them...
khodemooni 2 years ago 36
@khodemooni well, i am a 19 yo italian boy... I was lookin for a song to dedicate to my girlfriend, and i finally found it... this guy sings in a perfect italian ( some italians talk italian in a worst way xD) GO JOSH! YOU ROCK!
xsuperferrox 1 year ago
@khodemooni There are not hundreds of great singers... please refrain from misusing the word "great", thanks.
Great = Pavarotti, Bocelli, Domingo, and maybe there is 100 great singers... i challenge you to back your words up and name me at least 200 GREAT singers... then i will believe you when i see the list.
LoveMusicRum 1 year ago
Very good performance! and good italian too ;) Please, it's unfair to compare him to Pavarotti: he's not a tenor! I think he interpreted very well
silbaar 2 years ago
Well he actually is but he has crappy popish technique.
thehix 2 years ago
no doubts about this... I should have been in a good mood when I wrote that, he's actually good as pop singer (=crap) but this song is clearly not a pitch for him
silbaar 2 years ago
He isn't a Tenor at all. He has said he is a 'tenor in training'.
akaisling 1 year ago 2
tomatela no tenes ni un poquito de cara para querer cantar = que pabaroti
cesarlarioja 2 years ago
not convincing......too much emphasis on the word pronounciation ,negleting the feeling, pitch changing twice.....josh is capable of much much more if u listen to "to where you are" for example...
Rafloch 2 years ago
i agree with you
hayleydisca 2 years ago
not bad... but i've seen better!
jolotmara 2 years ago 2
lara fabian is much better. probably because i love her haha
foxylove91 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this guy totally sucks. lara fabien is by far better
THERAMPAGER 2 years ago
fuck you
ATTYO100 2 years ago
bah ... nice voice wel made but...
i don't like , lara fabian is better ,
i dislike this german pronunciation as well english pronunciation.
expecially "zai" instead of "sai" in this version...
lara fabian is the only i can accept for this kind of music.
nowardev 2 years ago
This is not bad at all. He did a good job with this song.... Nice......
MarcusLeepapi 2 years ago 4
Sorrento my city Naples capital in world the song of my city sorrento
NapoliSalvatore 2 years ago
Ich hab ihn letztens bei Ally McBeal gesehen. Er hat dort in zwei Folgen mitgespielt. Wahnsinnsstimme!
MieseFarla 2 years ago
Love him!!
fifthdaughter 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Puedes escucha mi version en directo en mi canal.
Gracias
You can take a listen to my live version, visit my profile.
Thanks
caramelo55 2 years ago
Really, his pronounciation is actually quite good for an English speaker. His e's are a bit too rounded and he can't seem to master the diphthongs - his 'voglio' sounds rather strange to me. But his singing is superb, even if I like his French renditions much better.
It's funny though, speaking of languages, this video confuses me. I suppose I'm just not used to hearing German, Italian and English all in the span of a few minutes.
parvanaturalia 2 years ago 4