Added: 3 years ago
From: babiebar
Views: 185,372
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (192)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • u can tell in the later songs/videos how she has much better control of her vocal range and breathing while singing. this was really good don't get me wrong. love carrie :)

  • I wish I had the chance to see Brooks & Dunn in concert before they hung it up:( I hope to see Carrie in concert:)

  • I love her sooooooooooooo much~~she,s definitely awesome~

  • she's so beautiful and talented!

  • This is called..."getting even"

  • Is it me? But why do I feel that when some singers perform a song, they may start out strong at the start, but when they get out of breath later, it gets weaker and weaker. Carrie Underwood is like the only one I feel always starts out strong and then gets even better throughout the song. Gosh her songs are DAMN hard to sing.

  • @92Dionne That's because she's the most amazing singer in music, bar none. Carrie can sing GNR as well as country, a Tony Bennett song or an Eagles song... any genre, any time. Carrie puts so much more feeling into a song than most because she has so much god-given talent that she is fearless on stage using her voice to captivate the world in the process. Her "Thou Art" performance at ACM Girls Night Out proved she has no peers, just her on top of the mountain. Taylor? Miranda? please...

  • Hmmm, I thought Before He cheats was out before Jesus take the wheel.

  • @trailed Nope Jesus Take the Wheel was one of her first songs.

  • Carry sings about what every woman in America wants to do when the bastard cheats (I include myself )but lets face it girls...If we would we would get locked up hahaha we are to damn smart for that psssh I would most certainly not spend a day in some nasty germ infested place eww for some ass hole that doesn't deserve it. So I say hire someone to do it ;D hahaha Who's with me thumbs up girls!

  • @miresly2010 HAHAHA MA YOU A TRIP I GOT IT RATED IT LIKE YOU SAID NOW CALL ME!!!!!!!!!!! 301-345-2057

  • @MrCalifasfinest liar your number is 213-345-2057 ;D why you change the area code>>? lmfao you are crazy ass hell O-O

  • She is the best Amercian Idol ever!!!

  • That guy next to the guy in the cow boy hat looks like Billy Ray Cyrus a little lol!!!!!!!!!

  • This song is 4 James Edward Postell and his piece of *ss Dana Michelle (multiple last names) Wells... Cause he a cheater and she a ho..

  • Comment removed

  • she deserves a standing ovation!!

  • She looks nervus

  • Love taylor, but taylor CANNOT touch Carrie. I don't even no who brought this convo between "whos better, carrie or taylor" they were deff cocked off there ass.

  • Carrie is the reason i start listening to country music i wouldve never thought that i would be watching the CMA's every year lol she is one of the few talented ppl that were picked on AI...and btw did you know you dont have to be country to sing country music? this is country a country song! lol please just stop hating!!! and there is no Carrie vs. Taylor because Taylor cant sing her lyrics would be better off sold to someone else that can sing.btw this is a fact not an opinion.love this song!

  • Damn every single time I watch her live it sounds exactly like the music video! Her voice is AMAZING :) <3 u Carrie ♥

  • @unofficialmiley i think there were some points that it was playback.. her lips were moving wrong at parts of the song. i dont know if that was youtube or just her.. i love her voice and her carisma anyhow but im not sure!!

    No matter what she is the best thing that ever happened to american idol!! everyone else kinda faded away!

  • Best legs in the business.

  • alsome!!!!!!!!!!!!! i love you!!!!!!

  • alsome!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • She is sooooo goos :)

  • love carrie 

  • Get over the fact that Carrie will always be better than Taylor.

  • Taylor swift sucks..she can't sing live... Off tune..pitchy....

    How could she won CMA and Grammy Awards?/ i'm wondering

  • i LOVE Carrie, she is the most AMAZING singer EVER!!!! XD

  • She looked amazing!

  • Amazing performance(:

  • I am from Croatia,and i believe how good is this singer.

    Both in studio version,and live. And she can get even better.

    She has stage movements,charisma and the voice!WHOLE PACKAGE.

    Why the hell she isnt bigger star?

  • @Istarskazastava1 shes absolutely HUGE in America, and im from England so shes not big over here either!!! XD

  • she sounds amazing live and studio most of the singers suck live go carrie taylor is good too

  • Eight people missed the wrong button.

  • Taylor Swift ISN'T country. I hate when people say she's a country singer. SHES NOT!

  • @KatieKay164 well the people at CMA disagree haha.

  • @KatieKay164 then what is she?

  • @chick26ify Bubblegum POP.

  • @KatieKay164

    Agree Taylor isn't country she's pop and can't carry a tune. Like she would ever be able to sing Before He Cheats she doesn't have the vocal power for this song. That's why Carrie is singing it!!!

  • @KatieKay164 and this is country? carrie is barely country herself.. amazing, but not "real" country.

  • Carrie did great. I like her new backup singer way better, though. This one sounds like she's trying to out-do Carrie. :/ Not possible!

  • Carrie Rocks! Her leggs go to heaven too! :)

  • Carrie us beatiful!! And has an fabulous voice!

  • Brazil

  • Wow she can really sing

  • but still, this is not her best performance... she can do better

  • @veetothebee not HER best but still the best =)

  • omg..carrie is amazing go girl!!!!!

  • Carrie has been nominated for a 2010 Teen Choice Award – Choice Music: Female Country Artist Now is the time to VOTE Carrie! Be sure to vote everyday....

  • omg..The Carrie Underwood of today is so much skinnier than this carrie Underwood. I can't say go eat a hamburger because she is a vegitarian, so how about go eat some carbs!!!!

  • Get a real singer on - K D Lang would sing her into the ground

  • a little off tune, but still any other performance by her is flawless. i love her so much!

    i think she was nervous.

  • @jllove1992 ya it was but I remember she was really sick during the awards & probly really nervous. I think this is the only performance of hers that was out tune in like 5 years she is so amazing!!

  • @roxygirly12 this isnt out of tune its slightly off key , there's a difference , and it's due to a blocked nose

  • @Matty3Mite3 Still amazing though!!! LUV her!!

  • @Matty3Mite3 out of tune and off key is the same thing.

  • @lornanorman no they're not dear , that's why they have different names

  • @Matty3Mite3 yes they are. England also has the name Britain, but does that make them different? No it doesn't. Other examples, mom and mother, dad and father, picture and photo, need any more examples? Just because their are two different ways of saying something, doesn't mean they are different. Out of tune and off key are the same thing.

  • @lornanorman Okay a) how stupid are you? Britain is the name of a collection of countries , England is a country. Out of tune is not singing the melodic line , Off Key i being sharp or flat of the melody , they are two differet things.

  • @Matty3Mite3 no i think you are confusing the united kingdom with britain. Out-of-tune and off key are synonyms, look it up in a thesaurus!!!! and the definitions of the two are the same, just said differently.

  • @lornanorman omg i didn't really think people this dim existed , the United Kingdom and Great Britain are the same thing , look it up , I live here , whilst you look that up and realise you're wrong , look up out of tune and off key , and again , realise you're wrong.

  • @Matty3Mite3 well, good for you. but when most people hear britain they think of england. How about you look up out of tune and off key and you will se that they are synonyms. I am right now aren't I? hmm...

  • @lornanorman No , no they don't , i love how you just totally ignored the fact you're wrong , and no I will say it again Off Key refers to one note , when you are sharp or flat , out of tune is a series of notes. Do i really need to post links to sites to prove this and embarrass you furthur?

  • @Matty3Mite3 No, there is no difference. They both mean you are completely out of sync with the notes. Sometimes a person is slightly flat or sharp by close to a half step, and sometimes they are completely away from the original key.

  • @lornanorman No they aren't! you could play a melody on a piano in C and sing all the same notes in G sharp , you'd be out of key , but not out of tune because you were still hitting the correct notes , Out of tune is singing the wrong notes all together , you see the difference?

  • @Matty3Mite3 no because that was a round about answer. you said the same thing, in two different ways.

  • @lornanorman No I didn't , they were two very clearly different things , WOW you're dim.

  • @Matty3Mite3 please tell me how playing c and singing g is singing the correct notes? if your suppose to sing in c, and sing in c thats in tune and on key. not singing c is off key and out of tune.

  • @lornanorman because you can sing a c note in the key of c and in the key of g , you're still singing the note c , therefore not out of tune .

  • @lornanorman That still doesn't make any sense. Now I have a life to go to, and I really don't think that I have to sit here, conversing about this. This isn't quitting, this is being smart and moving on. Obviously we have different opinions and views, and no one is gonna budge, so lets end it ok? I would appreciate not having another response.

  • @lornanorman Yes it does make sense , just because something doesn't make sense to you doesn't make it wrong. And as for being smart , you're the person that just publically said the UK and England were the same thing so lets not boast about our intelligence shall we?

  • @Matty3Mite3 um...I never did say that the UK and England were the same...so maybe go check the messages. OK. good. and I thought we were done with this.

  • @lornanorman" lornanorman

    1 week ago @Matty3Mite3 yes they are. England also has the name Britain, but does that make them different? No it doesn't" I rest my case.

  • @Matty3Mite3 you said, " you're the person that just publically said the UK and England were the same " i didn't say uk,...now im gonna block you because this is bs that you are pulling now. And you seem to be the type of person who doesn't seem to be wrong, so guess what, you are right. Now will that help your confidence. I'm done with this sh*t and I don't want to do this anymore. So don't contact me.

  • @lornanorman Yes and the UK and Britain are the same thing , I know I'm right I didn't need you to tell me , what I don't understand is rather than listen and learn about music theory you seem to be adimant to go against fact just so you don't appear wrong? and all you do is end up looking a fool

  • @Matty3Mite3 If it boosts your confidence, You're right.  I'm done arguing. its a waste of time. get over it, and leave.

  • @lornanorman You keep saying you're done and it's a waste of time but yet still reply , so how much time do you have to waste exactly?

  • @Matty3Mite3 @lornanorman Err the UK (United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland) isn't the same as Britain. Britain is the island (mainland England, Wales, Scotland) but UK includes northern ireland and also some overseas territories.

  • Can we all shut up about Taylor Swift - I love both, but thisvideo is about Carrie Underwood - any real fans would dedicate a vid about her to HER. I love Carrie Underwood, and she's awesome live.

  • @luvTaylorS4eva I know, I love both as well, but it seems to be that someone can't mention one without having to put down the other.

  • GOOSE BUMP ALL OVER ME! WOW

  • i'm so glad american idol gave carrie a great chance! she's has a true voice!

    some people like taylor hicks... i don't know why he won...

  • leave the kid alone

  • Carrie is amazing. =)

  • Voting is now open for the 2010 Entertainer Of The Year category at ACM Awards. Please head on over NOW and vote for Carrie!!! Every.single.vote counts, so we need to make sure we really step it up and vote hard!

  • Yeah shes the best vocalist after Beyonce and Leona Lewis

    Shes my Favourite Vocalist and my favourite Artist is Taylor ;)

  • this is the only mistake american idol didnt make.

    i will always love carrie underwood.

    favorite country singer.

  • i totally agree with u. i like taylor swift a whole lot but carrie underwood is on my top list when it comes to best country artist. although taylor swift is a really great singer too. :)

  • @vougechick i totally agree, other than kelly clarkson. shes amazing too

  • @vougechick let's not forget kelly clarkson!

  • @vougechick your wrong american idol has picked great singers jordan sparks chris dauthry kelly pickler

  • Carrie sounds awesome live and in her music videos unlike Miley Cyrus, Lady Gaga, and Demi Lovato.

  • Lady GaGa still sounds amazing. I give her much more slack considering she's performing everywhere almost every day, I bet.

    But Carrie is one of the best to have ever come from Idol. Her, J. Hud, Kelly, and Clay. There's no denying them. :D

  • thats because she actually can sing she won american idolll (:

  • carrie has sang at every CMA's since 2005!

  • I love Carrie Underwood.

  • Shes awsome live admit it shes awsome.I bet no one could ding like her.

  • Comment removed

  • someone cheated on carries?

    well shes a great singer

    taylor is 2 but carrie soundz way better

    i thk kellie 2nd and taylor last..srry tay but

    those 2 soundz alot better

  • Carrie,Taylor,and Kelly r the reasons 4 me LOVING country. But the first country song i heard was this one because it was my mom's ringtone.(;

  • Can we please get over the Carrie vs Taylor thing? It's getting old and annoying already. Can't we just agree to disagree people?

    BTW, Carrie's awesome lol.

  • mjdubo5, as for your comment about Taylor being the better performer. Have you ever seen a George Strait concert or a Reba? George Strait stands there and does nothing but sing from his 100's of # 1 hits because when you have an incredible vocal instrument people come to your concerts to hear that voice. There's no need for anything else. Same with reba McIntyre.

  • The first time Taylor tried to promote her music she was turned away. Then after Carrie entered the country music genre, the young people started looking at country music in a whole new way. Then Taylor remarketed herself. So no she didn't have IDOL she had CARRIE to pave her way.

  • *signed

  • you got to remember carrie's like 26 so i'm pretty sure it's okay for her to drink. And taylor's underaged (19) so her not drinking is to be expected. At least it's underaged where I live.

  • @mjdub05 so maybe carrie didnt want to get swarmed by her fans... would you want fans up in your face 24/7!

  • Carrie wrote So Small from her first album and it went #1, plus she wrote 7 of the songs on her new album. 3 of the songs on the new one in less than a month are heading to # 1. Taylor's not really country she's pop. The country lyrics she writes she turns to pop when she sings them.

  • Taylor swift isn't even in the same league as Carrie and never will be. She always sings off key iive and her voice can't compare.

  • But Carrie's songs can't compare to Taylor's...and Taylor is a great role model for kids. She has a mediocre voice, but to say that she can't compare is BS.

  • In comparison. Carrie is just as wonderful of a role model, extremely humble, and always classy. She writes music every bit as well as Taylor and in my opinion more rounded, she is a wonderful humanitarian, every one of her singles has gone to #1 in the last 5 yrs and her new album Play On knocked Taylor out of the #1 spot. Her voice blows Taylor out of the water. Where was it that Taylor fits in that same league?

  • @mjdub05 so you're saying that her songs are better than carrie's? Carrie's songs are more mature and meaningful. All of taylor's songs are just fuck you boyfriend 1, fuck you boyfriend 2.

  • @mjdub05 plus, carrie's songs are more melodic in nature. I don't know who writes her songs, but whoever wrote them is certainly a talented person who doesn't get due recognition

  • dam...thing i like about her is that she sounds the same as she dose in the music videos, unlike some outher singers that just rock in music videos but live? there shit

  • most country artist sound really good live..i love her!

  • carrie is definitely better....

  • Comment removed

  • if taylor's is better then id like to see her sing carrie's song.doubt it if she can hit the high notes..:] carrie go!

  • I doubt Carrie could write all of her songs and have them all be #1 hits either.

  • @mjdub05 Carrie did.. and all the ones she released as a single did go to #1. Taylor however couldn't say the same..

  • @rytanya26 - Taylor Swift rocks. Who cares about the haters. =)

  • @mjdub05 Apprently you do.. Who cares about Taylortards. :D

  • @mjdub05 So why are you here watching carrie instead of taylor ??

  • @mjdub05 who cares about haters like you too.

  • @care4country - God thing I'm not a hater then. ;-)

    Glad to know you care. =)

  • Taylor Swift and Carrie Underwood both sound awesome

  • taylor sucks live. carrie has a true voice.

  • Taylor Swift made it on her own...WITHOUT American Idol. Carrie has the better voice, but Taylor has written some amazing country songs. Plus, I've seen them both in concert. Carrie is about as boring as it gets, but Taylor blows audiences away. Vocal range isn't everything when it comes to being a great performer. Sorry.

  • @mjdub05 amazing boy bashing songs?

  • yeah i love taylor's songs but her singing live pretty much sucks lol :[ carrie underwood can belt it anyday and still sound amazing! go carrie!

  • she is a great singer

  • everyone that keeps saying shes off key. so what. i see it as at least shes actually singing and not lip synching like some other people do. she still sounds great. enjoy it and stop complaining.

  • I love Carrie,she's better than Taylor Swift (like her, too!) But she sounds off key at points, so that was disappointing, but still amazing performance

  • you got to figure that this is an earlier performance so thats why its a little off, but the audio is not the best, so I think that plays a lot too!! She gives an awsome performance though!!!

  • yeah, she was sick in this performance.

  • She's my idol :) Best freakin voice in the world

  • Got to love that dress though, good lord..

  • wow she is so good her and kelly have awesome voices

  • Man, she looks AMAZING.. I do agree, doesn't happen often, she does sound a bit off key at parts.. Still very good though..

  • I LIVE CARRIE UNDERWOOD and her music, but she sounds a bit off key at times?

  • nah she just adds her own zaz into it sometimes

  • anybody what event it was that carrie sang before he cheats with drummers at the beginning of the song? been looking for it forever :(

  • that was at the grammys

  • i bet you that if Kelly Clarkson and Carrie sat down together, they could write an amazing boy bashing song. haha. Since U Been Gone meets Before He Cheats.

  • carrie write her own songs?

  • Kelly Clarkson writes her own songs,carrie has co written some songs but she didnt write on before he cheats it was written by Chris Tompkins & Josh Kear

  • if you look Kelly co writes and has a lot of her songs written for her as well.

  • yeah... but Carrie is a Amazing singer and good looking sooo yeah :D lol tottally off topic xD

  • I completley agree!

    I'd like to see that

  • this is like the only country singer tht i will listen to well sum of the songs at least and i do not hook up by clarkson

  • amazing live!!!! i would get annoyed that wind in my face though lol

  • wht wind but i agree its amazing

  • they must have like a fan blowing her hair

  • "Anger management issues"...! hahahahahaha! LOOOOOVE it!

  • I super duper love this song!

  • i like this song do u!!!!

  • lover carrie underwoods and this song rocks

  • Even "sick" she still has a great voice, still better then 95 percent of this pop crap out there. I hate country music as a whole, but do love this song.

  • actually, having a cold CAN affect your tuning. (whether she had one or not)

  • luv her so much!!

  • shes awesome the best country singer

    PS:even though i dont like country i like her music and this is my favorite song from her xD

  • only 4000 lol

  • she looks hot here.

    hope she doesn't keep skinnier.

    i miss the little chubby underwood. :(

    love you carrie!

  • The best legs in the music business!