Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (173)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i dont like pineda... good try 'dough... good one.. steve..please come back...at least one last time.....

  • my favourite song of all time love you steve mind yourself always you will be back we miss you too much hellsbels lreland and all over the world you are loved xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx­xxxxxxxxx

  • sounds good but arnel needs to work on his english slang a little more

  • I was there At that concert, First concert in my young life and i'm glad it was Journey, there is no other band for me Keep On Runnin' Journey!

  • You guys pls grow up!! There's nothing to argue about.I've been a journey fan ever since and boy I'm so glad someone is there to continue their music which we all love thru the years it doesn't matter if it's arnel or steve singng they both are excellent singers in their own way!Rock on!!

  • It's good there's AP to make the song heard on air at this time, when Perry won't. Just that Arnel makes it great in many ways while respecting the song's original rendition; in some ways ,but better in a lot of a whole new way, with all due respect to Perry fans.

  • Cont... that same emotional connection with the song as Perry does. To Arnel, this is just another song to learn and sing in his style. To Perry, it was what his heart felt.

  • i agree with you man.i am filipino but steve perry is only one.he is the orignal.i love both singer no disrespect to arnel i like him too.but steve perry is the one and hek a lot of good songs.and originality of his voice.

  • @ajtmex True SP's version sounds better because it's a studio version. He never did it live...doubt he could at this point anyway. But Arnel does a smashing job of it live...got to give him credit....

  • lovelovelove ...this rendition by Arnel...amazing,captivating, emotion filled, epic,goosebumpy, titillating, more lung power, and soulfully croons and rocks...the best!!!

  • i would pay big bucks to watch steve sail away on the fail boat.

  • Check out Arnel with his band The Zoo singing their original So Wrong.

    v=hgJo2engeP8

  • this is a live version....amazing compare to the live version of sp.....

  • I think perry wasn't able to sing this live. Arnel made it far better than the original.

  • sp's original is more soulful, ap's tone is more rock ballad.

    both sp and ap are great lead singers, they have their pros and cons, which make up their different styles. comparing these two is meaningless. love them both because sp did a great job for the last generation, which ap is doing to this generation.

  • thanks echo, you did justice to the concert, thanks arnel, your're great,,,,,,

  • OMG. What a voice! The last note just make me weak in the knees. Great control there Arnel. Bravo.

  • I am a great fan of Journey, and when I heard

    SP was being replaced I am almost cried! Right now for he first time I listened to his replacement Arnel Pineda. I am thrilled the he too has a rich and powerful voice. All I can say is go Journey go and don't stop the music.....love them both

    AFROSIYAB

  • i feel you, if they only waited for his knee surgery.

  • I admire your magnanimity koenurgenc5. You're a true fan of Journey. I like Ap and SP both too.

  • Amazing!!!

    Grandma Mary

  • awesome lyrics.i always like journey music

  • How can you compare Steve Perry and Arnel Pineda on this song?

    Steve Perry never performed this song live and Arnel Pineda only performed this song live and no studio recording.

  • But it is STILL a "Steve Perry" Song. :o)

  • Maybe so HRHPrincessDiana, but on this performance, Arnel made this song "HIS"...Steve who?

  • I totally agree. No comparison here. Thanks for the upload echoNpapa

  • OK. let me humour you a bit. Assuming they didn't replace SP and waited for him 'til his "knee surgery" has fully healed. What's he gonna do then? Can he perform at the level Arnel is performing now? How about those jumps by the drum riser? Running around the stage? 60+++ live concerts with an average of 14 songs in a set list? Arnel is at his prime. SP's 20 years ago. Enough said.

  • he had back surgery

  • nope eileenluvsdod, SP didn't have back surgery. He had a hip surgery. Well, I was wrong too. Cheers! Let's just root for Journey... shall we? Give PEACE a chance.

  • I wouldn't pay to watch SP to sing these day. He had a concert in 1994 singing Journey song and he butchered the song.  AP is the next best thing and the best live now.

  • alriiiight. lol. amen.

  • ok. lets wait and see. last year they say that hell be on tour 2009. Comes 2009, it will be 2010. Just wait in your dreams. hehehe

  • I agree there jack. FYI he needed hip surgery not knee as per " Journey and Steve Perry" video

  • Thanks for your reply otherperla. I corrected my error earlier. Yes. It was a hip surgery. I wish SP all the best just as I wish AP a successful career with Journey.

  • You know what? Halatang nang-a-asar ka lang eh. May tawag dyan, KSP - Kulang Sa Pansin. There... napansin ka na besides getting -2's.

  • Absolutely beautiful, I listen to it over & over, I love Arnel's voice. I think Journey sounds better than ever.

  • Can't compare this song with SP. He never sang it live..oh well..AP well do..and did great live.

  • first time i heard this song...great one!!! do check out his performance in Manila, Philippines just yesterday.....AWESOME!!! stage, performance, audio....world class act!!!!!

  • The JOURNEY continue with Arnel. End of the Story.. HA HA HA HA. Go Arnel keep it up....

  • minsan lang nangyari ito sa lahing pilipino at ngayon kahit papaano tataas ang pagtingin sa ating mga pilipino....salamat Arnel!

  • pretty

  • I WAS THERE!!!

  • If you compare SP's and AP's Voices I still think that SP's version is still better. But AP is not far behind. He's rendition of this song is far better than any of that successors of SP. Nevertheless I am proud of AP for making it.

  • Even though it ain't Steve..I must say, it's good to finally hear this song live.

    Arnel is definitely a great singer.

  • hearing this song while making love to my woman is...PRICELESS

  • NAKAKAHIYA KA JOURNEYLITIS...HINDI KA PILIPINO .ISA KANG MABAHONG ISDA SA PUTIKAN  PATI SIGURO NANAY MO KINAIN MO SA UGALI MONG YAN..mawalang galang po sa kapwa ko

  • Hayop ka rin pati ina dinamy mo. Mahiya ka naman kahit papaano. Huwag ng idamay ang mga magulang.

  • Comment removed

  • You journeylitis is an embarrassment to the race. I do not care for you nor your friend kuhliglig, whatever his name was. I only have problem with people who does not have regards to parents. That is a damn shame.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • QUINTUSMAXIMUS- why is it I see your name on all the controversial subjects, Religion, The Middle East, Racial Issues and Journey without Steve Perry...are you just a miserable person or do you just gravitate toward negatives. Ever hear if you having nothing positive to say then say nothing?

    You delibertly go on Journey videos to trash them with Arnel.

    LIVE and LET LIVE!

  • let me tell you something dumbass..steve perry SUCKS BIG TIME and there's nothing you can do!!why dont you Go to hell and fuck the devil? that's more suits you FUCKED FACE!!!

  • Perry was named the 76th greatest singer of all-time by Rolling Stone Magazine on its list of "The 100 Greatest Singers of All-Time."He was given the Peacock of Wisdom award for his efforts over seas and involving Hurricane Katrina.

    Queen guitarist Brian May said in a 2007 interview "Perry is a truly luminous singer, in my opinion — a voice in a million". [4] [5].

  • I can appreciate that you passionately love Arnel Pineda and you are proud of him, and I wish him and you the best of luck.

  • One more thing journeylitis, you are one major fucked up in the head. You are garbage.

  • Thank you...you are so kind. I pray God will take you soon to heaven.

  • Best live performance of this song ever.

  • hunkdude27 I AGREE WITH U.

  • I agree with OTE24! just enjoy and appreciate journey music instead of fighting over who's better or who's not.

  • Oh! i wish that next time Journey can make there Concert here in Berlin, Germany...Dec. 3.2008

  • Journey Rocks! You know guys instead of having war of words of whose better, who"s not.

    Just enjoy Journey"s music thats it!

    Peace!.

    God bless you all!.

  • Journey with AP, so addictive.....Most of the time I only play their cds or watch them @ youtube....wish they'll record more songs!!!

  • nothing i can say it's great !!!!!

  • Its true, AP is not SP but this kid have a great voice and charisma, time gonna give him the prefection like SP, he was a great master,shame that he´s not yeat with JRNY, we love him n miss him 4ever.

    pas to my channel n let your comment, thanks.

  • OMG,,I've never heard somebody sing this song with so much passion and soul. Well done.

  • brianwhitely101, you're listening to Arnel almost at the end of a 69 concert tour, when the poor guy has already had a few bouts with illness. Not only that he's pretty tired at this point. You'd be exhausted too, and not at your par. Wait till he returns from hiatus to kick butt again..you'll be pleasantly surprised. Check him out on the Revelation album, the decide whether SP is still better, or even at the beginning of the tour...Listen with an open mind...nuff said.

  • same to you. Check out Escape to Frontiers.

  • stop all this nonsense Listen to both SP or AP they're both doing great.

  • I like both of their rendition both passionately delivered.

  • Both SP and AP have the voice,,,but putting a heart to a song, that where AP has the advantage, it takes real life experiences for a singer to put emotions to a song.

  • You're sooo right hunkdude27!

  • SP is a Rock God and will always have a special place in many hearts and deserves the respect of all rock music loving savants.

    But this AP is an incredibly soulful, goosebump raising, soaring rock n roll voice with so such depth and emotional range that to compare him to another Journey singer isn't fair to the other guy!

    After hearing SPs terrific version of this song on UTube and then hearing this, I realized he isn't a great SP, he's a great, one and only AP, in a vocal class by himself!

  • Wow, what an emotional rendition. I felt it! Gave me goosebumps and made me teary... and I'm a dude! lol!

  • i dont care whos singing but please they all good

  • you know what laurajames723 you talk too much; can you sing better than him, if not just shut up

  • pnoybuddy, laurajames723 was actually complementing Arnel by saying that he is NOT a Perry copycat and that he surpasses Perry by far.. which is why she thought the REVELATION album went PLATINUM!! Why are you dissing her?

  • Thanks 8Jubilee8...I think something got lost in translation of my words to pnoybuddy...I wouldn't worry about it. Heck we live in a global community now, things will get lost in translation every so often....But thanks for explaining to him anyway...Peace, and God Bless!

  • she didn't understand what laurajames were saying surpassing SP she think it differently.

  • Epal ka kasi. pinupuri na nga, tinitira mo pa..bobo ka ba sa english at di ka makaunawa ng pinakasimpleng sentences. Turuan kita. The dog is you..you are a dog...simple lang diba?

  • Arnel, you're the man!!! Great performance...whatta voice!

  • one word: SPECTACULAR!!!!

  • Perfect for arnel's voice, so beautiful way better than the original...

  • Love, love, love this song, AP delivered big time, beautiful & soulful rendition of this wonderful song, can't get enough of it...

  • everything sounds great except that hysterical woman on the background lol

  • Gosh, I can't wait to hear him record this one in the studio!!!

  • echoNpapa,

    very tremendous, clear, beautiful sound. i love this song. i can't get enough of this.

    this is my favorite. thank you!

  • his true voice came out this time, not a copy cat of steve perry. great song!!!

  • As it does on the Revelation CD of the new songs...even on the one of the classics, I don't think he really sounds like Perry copycat...infact, he surpasses Perry by far...which is why the album went Platinum...

  • I think so too Laura. I just hope that Perry fans don't get offended by your comment.

  • arnel owned perry and augeri on this one

  • Right on axel0780...it is sooooo true what you said...

  • Live version and studio version are very big difference. Kudos to Arnel for performing it flawlessly live!. Studio version can be corrected ,enchange, fix to make it sound better.

  • nice vid

  • i'd try to listen both steve perry and arnel pineda in this song, they are both good, nothing to compare!!!!!!!

  • the only difference, AP is in live concert while SP is in the studio!!!!!!

  • True they are both good except the end of the song when Perry's voice loses texture while Pineda's voice kept soaring!! Just imagine if Pineda does a studio version! ;) which I don't think they would because the re-record of the classics with Pineda shows how much better Pineda's voice is compare to Perry...

    IMO, they should not do that because it will only incense the Perryloonies!! lol

  • What a voice....I guess theres a MIRACLE....I believe in JESUS AMEN! :)

  • Nice Song Arnel!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Great Journey Band

  • Good job...Nel...proud 2 be Filipino!

  • Awesome video. Thanks for posting the lyrics! I love this song now after hearing AP's version. He has so much soul. Check out Chica77843, another awesome clip of this song.

  • love it!

  • He sang this on original key. I run this and the original SP verion on a voice analyzer, AP sound like he's not into the top yet, the way it sounds AP can still go higher, maybe a couple of keys higher than SP, no wonder AP can sing songs from Survivor, Cheap Trick, Heart, Kenny Loggins, Aero, Air Supply, LedZep

    & John Farnham. I was wondering though if he did any Chaka Khan song. Any of you guys happen to captured one on video during their gigs on Manila before journey's discovery of him?

  • NICE AUDIO

  • ....best rendition ever lol!....even if arnel pineda of journey band will sing lullaby's it will still sounds good will sound great lol!....we love you arnel hang on tight here in america coz americans are very stressful people to be with when some of their friends doesnt favor arnel or if their friends play that white supremacists behaviourss to please their other friends so good luck arnel youre doing just fine lol!....

  • I love this song and thanks for posting the lyrics too. That's awesome!

  • To sing along with Journey and Arnel, click on "more info" for lyrics!

  • WOW! I haven't even listened to the full video & I am so amazed at Arnel! I have always loved this beautiful song, ever since it came out in 1996, w/Steve Perry singing it!

    Arnel does a FANTASTIC job! Amazing!!!

  • Clear, starry nite, cool breeze brushing against your face, glass of margarita in one hand and your loved one's hand around you, listening to AP sing....THAT IS A LITTLE PIECE OF HEAVEN !!!

  • Fantastic ring quality on the upper registers! very very very rare!

    Love to hear "Still They Ride"

  • AP is a God given gift to all of us to enjoy!

  • Great & superb rendition...luv it!

  • This is actually my fav. Journey song and its my background music on my Friendsters, even before Arnel came on board.

  • I'd been waiting for this song idol..thank you , you didnt disappoint me and the rest of the world.JOURNEY you gave us the best summer ever,we'll never forget the year 2008.we should thank NDGOMEZ...he was the missing link.

  • PHENOMENAL vocal performance!

  • Oyu you are stereotyping. Even other races have also what you are saying. There are lots of use who educated and raised by our parents in the right way. Just as I was raised by my parents and how also the same way I am raising my children. Please, think 100x before you post these kinds of comments. By posting these kinds of you are also what you are saying. Thank you...

  • my apologies if u think I am stereotyping but I did mention"others". All I am stating is a fact. I signed in to read what others think of the songs and singers, not somebody's ugly comments about another subscriber.

  • I was there

  • nice Audio from the rest uploads

  • This is a really good rendition god this is live!! AP voice is really fit on this song.

  • tangna mo macky tagal na nating di nagkita pero english mo mabantot parin di na nagbago katangahan mo ...lmao saka yang wannabe AP voice mo keep mo na LANG SA SARILI MO OK?AHAHAHHAHAHAHAHA

  • I am just new in You tube...one thing I noticed quite common with Filipinos and others is their liking for throwing insults and character-assassination...can'­t you just be nice to each other? what one dishes out is a mirror of one's personality!!

  • ap rendtion wylaw sang w/emotion moved mountains  fact it was live version seen and heard live version in yt other singer, but this one is the best.perfect 100% makalaglag panty in tagalog.

  • all the journey catalogs in their concerts are sung in original registers - not lower bro

  • what else can you say he is amazing now he is forever journey

  • STUNNING!

  • i am out of words, what else is left unsaid about Arnel's vocal performance..

    GOOSEBUMPS...BROUGHT ME TO TEARS, HAAAAAAAY

  • this is one of my favorite songs of Journey and one of the last songs recorded by Steve Perry for Journey. I hope Arnel sings "I'll Be Alright Without You" too in their future concerts.

  • Yes, I was just thinking yesterday, I wish he would sing, I'll Be Alright Without You.

  • Tangapin natin mga kababayan ang katotohanan na walang AP ngayon kung hindi tuluyang umalis si SP sa Journey. Respetuhin natin si SP sa napakalaking kontribusyon niya sa Journey. At higit sa lahat respetuhin natin ang ating mga sarili na hindi tayo padala sa emosyon natin dahil lang sa mga tao na namimintas kay AP. Pasalamat tayo may pumapansin kay AP, even if good or bad because it is showbiz! He needs all the attention he could get to last.

  • Mga kababayan, wag n'yo na patulan iyong mga namimintas o may ayaw kay Arnel. Kasi sa totoo lang, kahit ipinagtatangol n'yo lang siya, ang pangit tingnan dahil sa mga salita na ginagamit n'yo. Kahit gaano pa siya kagaling, turn-off iyong ibang lahi dahil sa sobrang tindi ng mga salita na nakasulat. Lalo na, kapag ang paraan ng pag-tatanggol n'yo ay pagpintas naman kay SP. Kung maari lang ay ipakita natin na mas may edukasyon tayo, kung wag na lang sagutin iyong mga mapanirang salita.

  • Why compare AP with SP, when AP is a replacement of JSS, not with SP? Does this mean, SA and JSS are not worth-mentioning as part of Journey history? IMO, that's not a fair comparison.

    Anyway, whatever... Irrefutable fact remains...

    AP with Journey is blasting stadiums after stadiums after stadiums!!!The tour's about to end, and yet people (pro-AP and not) are still fussing about it!!!If that's not a phenomenon, then I do not know what it is anymore. Rock on, Journey!!! Long live Rock Music!!!

  • Wow this is great very clean audio now i can record it to my zune and be my playlist while driving.nice one echoNpapa thanx,this is great to dub with my fav SP version

  • For LYRICS, please click on "More info"

  • i love this song

  • Thanks.... you have the best audio capture amoung 3 takes.... yes I listened to all of them.... over and over and over.... again. Heavenly.........

  • Thnx echoNpapa great audio.

  • Wow ....more of these kind of songs

  • ...continuation...

    I was at the Sleeptrain Concord..but too bad..He did not played this song...However..I heard that's where They played more song line ups ever..22 songs if im not mis calculating it :o)

    To you all Journey out there...WE'LL KEEP ROCKIN' THE WORLD TOWARDS OUR JOURNEY! GODSPEED! PEACE!

  • What a great effort echoNpapa! Fantastic Audio...great job! You made YOU TUBE alive again by posting this much awaited rendition...Why is it that when I watch SP's version of this song..I feel like im floating in the air/ but....when I heard AP's rendition? I feel like im floating in the clouds together with those cute cherubs playing the orchestra for AP...Ha!Ha!

  • With AP's soaring voice, he makes all cover songs, remakes, sounds good or better. The new songs bears his signature and may be hard to imitate.

    My fav Zoo covers: Amazing (Aerosmith), Oh Darling-NDGomez777 wife's fav too (The Beatles), Alone (Heart), The Flame (Cheap Trick), Rock 'N' Roll, Black Dog (Led Zeppelin), Amazing (Aerosmith), Ever Since the world Began & The Search is Over, to name a few, and of course all the Journey covers. Go through these and be prepared to appreciate AP more!

  • OMG! This is just what many of us have been waiting and watching to see and hear. Wish they had been singing this, and Feeling That Way when I saw them, but, at least I have the videos now. There is one other of this song, posted from the same night. The audio on yours is great.What more can be said about Arnel's voice? There are no new adjectives to describe it. Thank you for the post.

  • Very good sound. Arnel is fantastic. How come he could easily memorize the lyrics of old songs of Journey!!!!!!!!!. He's really a phonomenon guy. Very talented.

  • i love this song... glad he did this song that night.. he rock the amphitheater!!! =)

  • oh yeah! I like the Audio,Sound so good.

  • Hey what took you so long to do this song Arnel?

  • vangie811

    i totally agree, next album hope its gonna be, 1 cd love songs, 1 cd rock/upbeat songs and 1 video cd, i love jonathan cain for his ballads, neal schon for being a guitar god, deen an inspiration to my child addicted to playing drums, ross for sticking to the band after being fired (you know) and arnel for singing the songs of the greatest band of the century! I LOVE JOURNEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • OMG, what a soulful rendition of this song. It moved me to tears,

    Arnel you own this song, AMAZING, GOOSEBUMPS

  • Wow, goosebumps, goosebumps all over. yes Arenel its enough to make me cry with this song. Amazing! Awesome! Unbelievable!

  • the best audio...thanks a lot for posting this...can somebody make an mp3 file of this please????

  • Best audio. Amazing Arnel!

  • its better than the original, I think... thanks for the video echoNpapa its very nice/good ..........

  • thanks for this beaut. vid clip to echo npapa. very nice. beaut. sound.

  • beautiful piano and intro Jon. Thanks for taking this song out in the concert.Pls sing this in Greek theater in LA. Next title of the new album will be Love Songs Forever by the Journey .Arnel is great in ballads. If you watch him when he was singing with the zoo, "Forever",:"I wont hold you back" "Flame" theyre better than the origs. thats not even in the rec. studio.

  • this is not even in recording studio. next album Neil. if you include this more albums to sell again.

  • if he did this in a recording studio it wil be much much beter. next album ok!!!!