黑沙峰工作室-黑太陽南京大屠殺 OP

[Taiwanfather]

前世的錯

後世承擔嗎

感慨

[selina0910]

@Taiwanfather 先不說是不是要後世的日本人承擔錯誤，但現在的日本社會對其二戰­罪行毫無反思之心、美化戰爭罪行，至少這些行為就是不可原諒的。

[lily850417]

地球都快爆炸了...還有時間在這裡吵

中國人，台灣人，大家都是人啊...

[georgeuone]

大屠殺不管納粹對猶太或是日本軍國主義、或是盧安達的種族屠殺，­都是人神共憤，但該學習如何記取歷史教訓 不是互相仇視，仇恨只會衍生更大的仇恨

[selina0910]

@georgeuone 既然要汲取歷史教訓，那麼首先應該是日本社會好好反思和懺悔他們­的戰爭罪行，日本首先就應該向德國學習。如果連這點日本都做不到­的話，那就別妄談什麼放下仇恨或者原諒了。

[t031324]

希望有時光機回到二戰時代,解放軍殺爆他們!

[TaiwanisNO1]

不知為何...不管哪部影片都會有中共人跟臺灣人互嗆 你們太無聊了八..

開口閉口說自己是中華民國的人 所做所為都是為毛匪 中共的IQ??

[lusifa001]

哈中國的人也去死一死吧？

活摘法輪功和茉莉花革命和反對派的器官就不可惡了嗎？

還外加沒有麻醉~行殺的中國軍醫也是一樣觀看被害者痛苦的樣子

[taosiyuan1]

哈日的台灣人与香港人你們都是漢奸敗類，曾經被日本英國統治趙成­現在的奴顏婢膝。我是南京人，真正的中華民國首都市民，在我有生­之年中華名族總有一天會讓東洋賤夫狗日的血債血還！！！！

[mai12211221]

日本人八加耶鹿是吧



[pxennzai20040705]

同じ日本人として、はずかしいです。　

[Carthaginion]

Bye bye Chinazi.

Its good for peace of world.

[edwineko]

中國人唔係 東亞病夫, 日本鬼子真係好鬼殘忍

[95238758]

それをきれいに見て！

罪のない中国の人々の死、中国侵略の事件の数は、〜自分の愛する­人が死ぬ失わ

いわゆる国が（リトル日本）私に答えて、あなたちくしょう？

Chuさん：

あなたの国の沈没、世界がより平和にする.....

リトル日本！リトル日本！



[tyytx1298]

日本人はひでえなあ・・・

[undertakerRach]

@terrychan28880 The Chinese government promised China will be a free country when the Tiananmen massacre broke out in 1989. Has China fulfilled the promise?

[undertakerRach]

(Part1)The Chinese Civil War began in April 1927, amidst the Northern Expedition. American journalist, Frederic Vincent Williams, and Chinese historian Kou Bunyu said Japanese created a new modern country Manchuria and kicked out corrupt military soldiers who were bandits and authorities from there. Many Chinese must have been living in peace. Their life changed to affluently society after Japanese occupied Manchuria. Approximately 1,000,000 Chinese moved to Manchuria in every year.

[HKVictory]

最後通牒: 日後打回去, 由南到北, 每城必屠, 先衝進全日本的所有嬰兒院, 幼童院, 學校, 住宅, 斬殺所有日本年輕一輩, 以確保其種族血脈不能延續下去, 然後才清除所有日本成年人及老人, 不論男女, 一概不留, 將牠們像宰牲畜一樣宰掉, 徹底把日本"人" 滅族.

[ukeasato]

@HKVictory 如是此， 那你和当年的皇军有何不同？ 难道也想在历史遗臭吗？

[kittycat99889]

@HKVictory 你這心態跟當時日本人有啥兩樣?只會亂殺無辜還自以為正義?!

[HKVictory]

@kittycat99889 一定要 血債血償, 絕不能隨便 放掉這個嚴重塗碳過我 中華民族 的禽獸及其後代, 方能解恨 !

[firefrank07]

@HKVictory 也太無聊了吧你

[MrRikkyo]

好恐怖。。。。



[MrRikkyo]

好恐怖。。。。

[Xplenovo]

日本人出名係一種死狗架啦. . .

呢啲人一世無運行架 , 死全家啦. . .

[tim2251989]

每個中國婦女都是慰安婦????

當時日本人未免太過分..

歷史是真實 中國人的記憶更真實

改歷史?收皮la 

戰敗國又如何? 就沒有自尊嗎?

[cathypei]

國中午餐時間,歷史老師就放給我們看,看完整個沒食慾想吐噁心.­..........老師好狠啊

[undertakerRach]

Ways That Are Dark ～The truth about China　Ralph Townsend

If a jury of the most experienced Americans or Englishmen in China today were asked to name the most prominent characteristic in the Chinese mentality as opposed to our own, I think most if not all of them would unhesitatingly answer, “lying."

In the West we scarcely know anything about lying. We are rank amateurs.

[k88chg]

If Nanking massacre is fake, why so many Japanese politician, ex-soldiers & their descendent apologies to China? People can read & write things, choose to believe what they want or hope to deny, but the facts that thousands & thousands of Japanese soldiers who fought in China told their children & grand children the atrocities they've committed is far convincing than one government's denial.

[andyshella]

對付日本最好以其人之道還其人之身...即係用返731部隊計劃­淪陷日本!!!

[ggcyyyy]

Bastard Japanese！！！

仆街陷家產屌你撚樣日本！！！

憎らしい日本！！！

[undertakerRach]

(Part7)About John Labe, he was represented an interest of Siemens in the Chinese munitions industry as a pro-Chinese group, Von Falkenhausen, the head of the military advisory group in China said. According to German historian Gerhard Krebs reported as follow: “Defeated and depressed in WWI, Germany knew that china was a significant trade partner. Germany was able to import raw materials that were indispensable for the postwar reconstruction.”

[undertakerRach]

(Part6)Rev. Bates was also an advisor to the Chinese Ministry of Information according to a contemporary newspaper article. Also, the China Monthly revealed that the wife of George A. Fitch, who also wrote a part of Timperly’s What War Means, was a close friend of Chiang Kai-shek’s wife. One will note that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) today has a section that performs the same functions. Recent research shows that the contents of Bates’ “report” are far from truthful.

[undertakerRach]

(Part5)Harold Timperley wasn’t in Nanking city at the period. How did he get the information about the massacre? Timperley was paid by the Ministry of Information in China for editing the book. Zeng Xubai, then chief of the international propaganda division, said in his autobiography (vol. I, p. 201) that the central propaganda bureau funded the publication of Timperly’s What War Means and Lewis S. C. Smythe’s War Damages in the Nanking Area.

[undertakerRach]

(Part4)Their reports made more myths of Japanese bad rumors to the world.

One is a book which is called "What War Means", edited by Harold Timperley.

Second is two articles by Tillman Darden in New York Times on December 18 and A. Steel in Chicago Daily News on December 15.

And last one was John Labe’s reports to Germany.

[undertakerRach]

(Part3)The guys rushed into the committee office, and they told, “Japanese soldiers were raping women”, and “Japanese soldiers were seizing commodities from Chinese family”. John Magee and George Ashmore Fitch typed the stories without any inspection. Therefore, Mr. Fukuda protested to them many times. In fact, Mr. Fukuda went to check the Japanese crime scene which was reported a robbery by a Chinese guy, there was no people, no broken and no any noise.

[undertakerRach]

(Part2)Miner Searle Bates, George Ashmore Fitch, Lewis S. C. Smythe, John Magee, John H. D. Rabe, Robert O. Wilson, they were famous members in the committee.

However, their reports were untrustworthy for this reason.

A Japanese whose name was Tokuyasu Fukuda, he was Japanese embassy staff, visited to the committee, he was surprised at the situation because John Magee and George Ashmore Fitch was writing reports, which were reported by some Chinese young guys.

[undertakerRach]

(Part1)In fact, only some 20 westerners in all remained in Nanking during the period from the fall of Nanking to the Japanese occupation, and most of them belonged to the Safety Zone Committee. Diplomats and journalists had already left Nanking. Therefore, a large amount of reports and articles which was written Japanese murders and rapes stories were based on the same source of information from the members in Nanking Safety committee.

[504927gary]

中國人的恨,死日本鬼子.

[y920826]

總有一天,我們要攻入東京

[234729471]

吊佢地老母系呀 好燃9呀 乜能人黎ga 正一死仆街 衣加中國又唔打番日本 佢地on99 ga

[undertakerRach]

(Part3)Since the People's Republic of China was established in 1949, the frequency of its use of military forces reaches the double digits. On average, China has used military power every several years. In all cases, except for its support of North Vietnam war against South Vietnam, China has used force preemptively. China attacked the opponent first after careful preparation, whereas the opponent suffered from a surprise attack.

[undertakerRach]

(Part2)Today, the China is controlled by the Chinese Communist Party and the Japan is democracy. While history should not be forgotten, we must also judge a country by its current actions. A recent survey of world public opinion from 2005 to 2007 found that Japan is the country most widely viewed as having a positive influence, which is helped by the fact that Japan has never used military power as a means for settling international conflicts after 1945.

[undertakerRach]

(Part1)Conflict Prevention and Confidence Building Measures between Japan and China by Vice Admiral (Ret.) Fumio Ota, Ph.D. Published on January 5th, 2009 ARTICLES

Chinese leaders always say to Japanese leaders that Japan should look at history as a mirror. It means that Japan should not forget her brutal actions against China during the Sino-Japanese conflict in the late 1930s and the beginning of the 1940s. However, since this period Japan and China have changed considerably.

[cheng980]

大部分的日本人民其實是善良的, 唯有日本好戰份子組成的日本軍閥, 向中國侵略的大日本皇軍罪該萬死.

[selina0910]

@cheng980 收回你那可笑的論調吧！日軍占領南京城的消息傳回日本後，日本舉­­國遊行慶祝。那些在街頭縫千人針祈福的日本家庭婦女；那些自願­參­加慰安婦的日本女人；那些把子弟送往中國並鼓勵他們為天皇盡­忠的­日本農民…如果沒這些‘日本人民’，日本的侵華戰爭一天也­堅持不­下去。試想，一個國家的婦女為了支持這個國家的侵略戰爭­竟然連最無恥最下賤的事（妓女）都願去做，那麼這個國家的人民對­這場侵略戰爭的態度是反對還是擁護，答案不言自喻。所以在那段歷­史裏，每個日本人都負有責任。有句話“原子彈­下無冤魂”！



[cheng980]

@selina0910 是誰在發表可笑的論調! 是誰中國近代史料沒有全面了解! 去看蔣委員長在'抗戰勝利告全國軍民同胞書'與其演講中就知道了­. "我們當然要嚴密地責成日本忠實執行所有的投降條件,但是我們並­不要報復, 更不可對敵國無辜人民加以污辱, 我們只有為她及她的納粹軍閥所屈迫而表示憐憫,要知道如果以暴力­答覆其從前的暴行, 則冤冤相報永無休止, 絕不是我們仁義之師的目地", 這是蔣委員長的原話. 抗戰勝利之後, 滯留中國的日僑與日軍有大約二百一十萬人左右, 國民政府無條件將其全數安然地遣送回日本,這些人裡面有些都是殺­人無數的日本軍閥,但國府並未加以大肆報復與殺害, 足見當時中華民國的抗戰國策是只想要消滅日本軍閥與其軍國主義, 並不是要消滅全部的"日本人". 再者美國既然將中華民國視為亞洲相當重要的同盟國伙伴, 在要向日本投放原子彈之前就要知會中國, 又美國錯估日本實力, 硬在雅爾達會議要蘇聯參戰打日本, 這也未知會中國, 導致二戰結束後, 在四川重慶的國民政府對突如其來的勝利來不及準備與接收淪陷區,­中共才有機接自日本關東軍與蘇聯給的軍備, 打起國共內戰.

[oddballrach]

(Part10) Therefore, the Chinese was absorbed in collecting proofs even during the IMTFE has opened. In short, the Chinese had already fixed the number of casualties into more than 300,000 before they began to collect the evidence. Chinese government said Japanese killed 300,000 people and raped 80,000 over a period of six weeks. In short, the Japanese are accused of having murdered 7,000 people and raped 2000 women each day. Have you seen descendants of Japanese-Chinese half-blood in Nanking?

[oddballrach]

(Part9) He testified in the IMTFE by saying 'the Japanese soldiers took everything away from the Chinese residents'. However, this number 179 was including rumor.

Also, he confessed what he himself witnessed was nothing. The Daily Reports of Serious Injuries to Civilians said the only killing witnessed by foreigners in Nanking was only one lawful execution. Also, the IMTFE showed Chinese could not prove the murder of 300,000.

[oddballrach]

(Part8) Also, here is the burial record presented to the IMTFE (The International Military Tribunal for the Far East) by the Red Swastika Society. The statistics show where the corpses were found and buried. Only about 2,800 corpses are found inside Nanking castle, and the rest are recovered outside, which were almost 40,000. Moreover, according to The Documents of Magee, member of TSZC, referred the total number of looting by Japanese soldiers was 179.

[oddballrach]

(Part7)The very picture is captioned with "A group of women and children from the Rising Sun Village returning from the fields, guarded by our soldiers." It is indeed a wicked act of secretly switching the picture. Factually, people could kill 300,000 people and raped 80,000 women? They stayed in the Nanking only 6 weeks. The citys population was 200,000, according to TSZC (The Safety Zone Committee) documents. TSZC documents say the population was 250,000 in Jan 1938.

[oddballrach]

(Part6)One of the Photos displayed at the Nanking Massacre Museum. The caption said, "The Japanese rounded up thousands of women. Most of them were gang raped or forced into military prostitution. But this photo has appeared in the Asahi Graph, a weekly photo journal, published in Japan on Nov 10, 1937, about one month before Nanking battle. This picture has appeared in the journal with the explanation, titled as "Utopia amidst the Gun-power: The 'Rising Sun' Village South of the Yangtze."

[oddballrach]

(Part5) The section was propaganda section in China during the War. Timperley was paid by the propaganda section for editing the book. This Timperley fact based on the book which is called 曽虚白自伝(Page 201), which means曽虚白 Diary. 曽虚白 was also one of the members of the Propaganda section. In fact, at least 143 of pictures in the Nanking Massacre Museum were distorted by the propaganda section.

[oddballrach]

(Part4)During the Sino-Japanese war, Chinese victims couldnt receive any medical treatment for they had no money. Chiang said, You can get medical treatment for free in hospitals if you said Japanese injured you. Thats why there is much verbal evidence about the battles. One of the foundation upon which the massacre myth is based on the book which is called "What War Means", edited by Harold Timperley. But he was an advisor to the Chinese Nationalist governments Ministry of Information.

[oddballrach]

(Part3)According to the New York Times on March 29, 1947, one of the Americans said, Troops from China arrived at Taiwan on March 7 and indulged in three days of indiscriminate killing and looting. For a time everyone seen on the streets was shot at, homes were broken into and occupants killed. In the poorer sections the streets were said to have been littered with dead. 'There were instances of beheadings and mutilation of bodies, and women were raped.

[NutNapalm]

No members of unit 731 were irradiated by the atomic bombing.

None of nanking's rapists.

None of the assholes who actually did this stuff were present in those two cities, nor were any of those who authorized such acts.

I know that in the long run, the Atomic Bomb actually saved lives.

Does that make it right?

The actual criminals went unpunished, while a bunch of people whose only crime was being born in Japan were irradiated.

[changofsingapore]

The 2 atomic bomb on Japan is well deserve.

Japanese soldiers surrender and go home. They did not kill themselves.

[AlfieWilRus]

No Hiroshima and Nagasaki didnt deserve those 2 bombs the sick people that did this deserved the bombs. I can beleave Hirohito was let to live. Just imagine if the chinese got there hands on him before the war ended.

[mrshyushyu]

誰能告訴我:二次大戰後...為何政府沒有為人民向日本侵略者索­取應有的賠償?

兩岸執政黨口口聲聲"為人民服務"...這方面真令人失望!!

民進黨對"臺灣慰安婦...釣魚台領土主權問題..."的軟弱態­度.也是差勁的!!!

日本說"終戰"..."祭拜神社的戰犯"...."向台海兩岸爭­權"....也許是有道理的?!

歷史課本為何也隻字不提???

是誰出賣了人民???

[anytimecheerful]

Japan did pay compensation to the Taiwanese Government. But it was spent on war with the Mainland Chinese Government.

[gtr32gtm]

@mrshyushyu 二次大戰輸的比 " 戰敗國 " 還慘的 "戰勝國 " 就是中華民國。 除了瓜分幾艘日本的破戰艦外，什麼都沒有。 戰後美蘇交惡，所以美國養了兩隻名為 " 民主典範 " 的看門狗， 雖然飼主是同一個，不過這兩隻狗之間的感情並不好。 那麼，當初政府真是 " 以德報怨 " 婉拒賠款嗎？ 這就要問問美國這個流氓是怎麼處理 " 戰後賠款 " 這塊大肉餅的。 Q：交還給亞洲人民嗎？A：那可不行！這樣的話，比較長的狗會造­反的！ 肉餅的結果當然可想而知。 去年這隻狗的尾巴又長了一點，壓縮了台灣的空間。 嘖嘖～台灣人真是要居安思危呀，這隻狗是有狂犬病史的！

[a5907769guy]

@mrshyushyu

怎麼 沒地方宣洩 跑來罵民x黨 國x黨做得很好嗎??  少笑死人了

[A996277]

國仇家恨！當年的中國真的不堪一擊，一段讓後代都會記得的歷史事­件，今日的中國擴張軍武，一方面向鄰國宣示，主要一部份也是要跟­日本宣示，今日的中國已不是當年的泛泛之備，壯大軍武也是記取歷­史教訓!

[changofsingapore]

The 2 atomic bomb on Japan is well deserve and satisfying.

[vickiejiang]

Very well said!

[vb999kimo]

別再用日本貨了

看到祖先被日本人姦殺

反攻日本都來不急了

[tkw018]

安已不 警已報

[yeungchi]

The only entity that could possibly carry out a census and state (or fabricate) the post massacre population of Nanking is the war criminal itself, namely the Japanese "imperial" occupation force. Will any righteous person believe the quoted figure of 250,000 is reliable?

[yeungchi]

Evidently, the Japanese has been admiring many aspects of Chinese anicent culture. In fact, numerous "reigning titles" (年號) of Japanese emperors such as "大正", "平成" originate from Confucian classics. It appears to me, however, many Japanese people just do not understand the genuine Chinese wisdom. They may have read the famous Chinese saying "an impenitent offender drives himself to destruction" (多行不義必自斃) but they are too pigheaded to understand this saying.

[4157961The]

過錯都已經過去了，問題是在於日本野蠻的不認錯，叫我們怎麼能原 諒小日本呢？再怎麼講也不能說服自己的良心～

[uh9981]

连南京大屠杀都能骂到共产党，呆丸狼脑子有屎？

[madsteve6126]

我是呆灣郎之一，我想你罵錯人了，上面發言的是日本人，樓主在指­責他，然後這日本人去複製中文來回答，不但不通順而且還是簡體，­所以，你罵錯人了。

等下次碰見極端台獨，滿嘴髒話那種人，你再罵他大便腦袋，大家會­支持你的。上面那個，不是呆灣郎，是不承認南京屠殺的日本混帳。­

[em0213]

仆街日本人!!!

全日本都係仆街王八蛋!

[sakurasakura2424]

Shina became an opium pickle as a dog in Britain.

Shina was made a colony by the powers country because of it.

The British traveler says.

"If the stick is raised, Chinese is a domestic animal who shrinks. "

Chiang Kai ? The cruelty of Shek is what the world knows.

It is Chiang Kai ? to have massacred the resident in the powers country. It is Shek.

The slaughter method was very cruel.

[ericzhu4]

2008venom先生,

請不要再在此頻討論不關於本影片題目的話題,謝謝!

[2008venom]

黑太陽...南京大屠殺...

只是　政治的虚偽宣伝.

禁止　政治的虚言！

[ericzhu4]

2008venom先生,

第一 你是日本人

第二 你想隱瞞歷史

第三 這只是部電影

第四 如果你想吵的也不要在這裡吵吧!

謝謝!

[2008venom]

1.我是日本人

2.我信真的歴史

3.我不信虚偽宣伝

4.我要伝遍真的情報

[ericzhu4]

先生，請你不要再作假辨！

這的確是事實，有很多歷史證據可以證明這一切都是事實！（只是有­ 人把它拍成電影而已）

你想歪曲歷史！

日本人的確有入侵過中國！

南京大屠殺的日本戰犯也是給你們自己日本人殺掉的！這何以解釋？

最後，我想說：

．．．．．．

因此最後我不想先生再說南京大屠殺是虛言，謝謝！

[ericzhu4]

．．．．．．的內容

一事歸一事，不要歪曲歷史，需然日本人在若干年前屠殺中國人，但 是也不能把*那些日本人*代作回

*現在全部日本人*，說到*大屠殺*很多國家也出現過(1)，所­以我們只能怪 *當時的局勢不穩*或*當時期的人運氣不好*！我相信*南京大屠­殺*是很多日本人也不想發生的，這都是戰爭的代價！

[ericzhu4]

(1)的內容

(在2000多年前的中國也出現過類似的事件,當時的秦始皇也曾­屠殺過很多平民百姓,所以這都是戰爭的後果)

[2008venom]

歪曲歷史? 共産党的歪曲歴史？

日本軍屠殺3500万中国人？

共産党屠殺4000万於大躍進、屠殺3000万於文革。

你想天安門。

[ericzhu4]

這我不太了解,我只知道日本在南京大屠殺中屠殺了30萬中國平民­!

請不要把國共(政治)的事在我這影片中發表,謝謝!

[ericzhu4]

我覺得這事很有可能,原因是,日軍不是一個人去屠殺南京平民的,­是1000以上的士兵!

[45234589]

I want ask you I know Japanese is do not know any English.Anyway 共產党 and 南京大屠殺 both two are history.But ericzhu4 I think 共產党kill China people is very bad action for us.For example in society if we see a news about kill mum,dad and brother.We maybe said this is very cold-blooded.But 馬力 said "No one death on that time."This is very hurt for Chinese people and me.I hope you don't just saying 請不要把國共(政治)的事在我這影片中發表,謝謝!

[ericzhu4]

Sorry,since this video is about 南京大屠殺

that isn't about 共產党

[sakurasakura2424]

Nanjing City at that time is a population of 200,000 people.

And, it increases to 250,000 people after Nanjing surrenders.

How can it explain this?

The powers country might not keep silent if as many as 300,000 people are killed either.

However, nothing is protested against.

Were the citizens waiting without running away from killing?

Why are not a lot of those remains discovered?

[vickiejiang]

Stupid replying the same message! Don't you have something new to say? You damn fuck!

[sakurasakura2424]

Nanjing City at that time is a population of 200,000 people.

And, it increases to 250,000 people after Nanjing surrenders.

How can it explain this?

The powers country might not keep silent if as many as 300,000 people are killed either.

However, nothing is protested against.

Were the citizens waiting without running away from killing?

Why are not a lot of those remains discovered?

[sakurasakura2424]

The one in the Nanjing memorial is soldier's bone. Moreover, 300,000 is also missing.

There is impossibility. There might have been reality if it will be at least said 5000 people.

By the way, a Japanese army is offering the medical treatment and food to the Nanjing citizens at that time.

And, it is stable [saseteimasu] as for Nanjing where the public peace was bad. The image remains, too.

Chiang Kai ? Do not you know the brutality of the army of Shek?

[vickiejiang]

Go home fuck your mother! You fucking retard! All the number you gave means nothing but that you are stupid at math and you are stupid pig!

[tranvozcaya]

yes absolutely posible, even more...

the horror!!

[2008venom]

打倒　政治的虚言

打倒　中華帝国主義

打倒　中国共産党

[ericzhu4]

禁止在這頻討論政治,謝謝!

[ericzhu4]

禁止在此頻討論政治!