wah, nice. ive never heard this style of mucic before. i read a research paper that said the unusual proportion of high frequencies found in gamelan music enhanced brain activity. :) interesting.
im not balinesse,or live in indonesia,but the Bali traditional music and culture make me want to know more,hope one day i can watch and listen Balinesse people playing the music live,Bali!one day i will visit you.
I'm Balinese, and playing gamelan. I think it will be better if competition is only for the young and kids. For senior player it's better to do some kind of exhibition like in the jazz world, no competition no ego boosting. Cheers and jeers for the young and silent appreciation for the mature artists. Imagine! enjoying those ethereally beautiful sound in silent...
I think there is a misunderstanding here...I really didn't want to judge anyone...I had only noticed that the audience was noisy and I just thought that this beatiful music could have needed a silent audience...I'm not american, I hope I didn't bother any balinese with my comment!
SiKedek is right but wrong. Yes, Gamelan musicians like to have feedback and yes they would hate a silent audience. HOWEVER, when they perform in competitions and to their own people, the response is appropriate and relates to what they are hearing. This audience would whoop and holler is someone came out and made farting sounds. There is no understanding or discernment in their response. The Audience noise is just for their own amusement and to impress their friends, not to show understanding.
Understandably, there may be some gamelan musicians who might be bothered to a certain extent. However, according to Wayne Vitale in his CD featuring Pak Windha's works, the players must "maintain a high _mental_ (attitude) in the face of screaming and sometimes malicious spectators". In other words, if a musician is so freaked out by this charged atmosphere, it's better for him/her to quit. So it's not the most ideal environment - but it's there anyway. They just have to deal with it.
You know, that is the fact how the Balinese audiences are. We, Balinese, wasn't bothered with all of that. Both of you are right!! Balinese audience just loves to express their impression directly when there are something good or bad that are going on in the stage. Especially in the Gong Kebyar Competition.
However, sometimes there are lots of audience who doesn't know about music at all, comes there to watch and gives inappropriate responses to what are going on. Those are audiences who doesn't have understanding to the arts.
I lived in Bali for 5 years. Do you know what the musicians think of the morons watching this performance? Can you imagine? The Balinese are tolerant, fun loving and friendly, but even they can't understand why people would pay money and devote their time to go to a concert then make monkey noises and squeals. There is a Balinese expression that equates to 'take the money and run'. When I am in Bali I am ashamed by westerners who behave like this. Oh and before anyone comments, I HAVE A LIFE!
Did you even bother to look at my response to "hexachordal"?
"No, you misunderstand - any traditional gamelan performance worth its salt will have audience outbursts like this, especially in a gamelan competition situation. That way, you know the audience is paying attention. A silent audience is definitely NOT DESIRED in Bali! And a Balinese audience will not reserve any judgment"
In other words, Balinese gamelans like this noise from the audience.
let's help out this fellow over here... the Hindu Swastika (with a K) denotes prosperity and goodwill. and if you are keen in enough in observing, you should have noticed Hitler's swastika is facing the opposite direction!
The swastika is an extremely old auspicious symbol, long before its reappropriation by the Nazis.
In East Asia, one can see it in a particular lattice-like pattern in China, Japan, Korea, and anywhere within strong Sinitic (i.e. Chinese) influence - this was brought along with Buddhism. I've also seen this in on some headdresses from a few Native American groups.
I don't care. I'll report this video to the Anti-Defamation League and Jewish Defense Group so that they can take the appropriate actions to put this antisemitism DOWN.
So, are you going to oversee the public censure of Bali and Balinese culture? Cultural suppression because of perceived cross-cultural misunderstanding? Yeah, that will go over really well...
inricheetos: So, you're going to report this video to those groups, despite the fact that people have already told you that the hindu swastika (which came first by the way) is completely different to the nazi one, and is in no way anti semitic. By the way, you do realise that everyone else already knew this, right? Good luck with that.
This some great music! To paraphrase the Beatles in "Let It Be": "Phillip Glass ain't got nothing on this figure..." You got it all here. Time changes, dissonance, dynamics, a non-twelve step octave and repetition--and it's all traditional folk music played and directed by real people. To us Amero-European composers using synthesizers, this is what we call progressive or experimental. In a real since, we're just stealing from our past.
inthefade: are you a QOTSA/Gamelan fan too? Thought I was the only one!!
Posters: Thank you SO much for this! I always get all emotional listening to Gamelan, I'm not sure why, my guess is that it is beautiful and familiar to my soul on a subconscious level.
And these children are awesome cool -- catch the kids in one row spinning their little hammer things between parts. Reminds me of the horn section in "The Blues Brothers."
I Love Love Gamelan. I Love the fact it's tuned in quarter tones and not the usual western chromatic system(meaning we've got C-C# for example, & they've got an extra note in between) Whats the differemce between Balinese Gamelan and Javanese Gamelan?
Cheers mate! I played Gamelan once, but my timing was terrible.hehe^^I'd love to own a whole Orchestra oneday!! Thanks for uploading your vids, much appreciated.
It really annoys me how you can hear all these people in the background going 'WOOO YEAH! CLAP CLAP CLAPPITY CLAP!' at EVERY OPPORTUNITY. Why don't they just shut up and respect the gamelan tradition in the way it's meant to be appreciated... in silence?
No, you misunderstand - any traditional gamelan performance worth its salt will have audience outbursts like this, especially in a gamelan competition situation. That way, you know the audience is paying attention. A silent audience is definitely NOT DESIRED in Bali! And a Balinese audience will not reserve any judgment - if you're considered low quality, they'll be glad to criticize, laugh, holler, or jeer. It's just the name of the game in Bali...
If you initially found the noisy audience annoying, a typical Balinese temple ceremony will shock you. In the same space, there may be as many as five or six ensembles playing at the same time - different pieces, different timbres, not to mention different tunings. A cacophonous situation for sure, but highly desired because the Balinese love a festive situation that is rame, or "lively, busy". Its antonym, sepi "silent, quiet", is an almost depressing situation.
By the way, if you are interested in hearing more of Alit's compositions, check out the recorded work of the Balinese gamelan "Cudamani". Alit and his brothers founded that group and built it into one of the most innovative gamelans in Bali today. The have done international tours, so keep an eye out for Cudamani. Alit has also worked with gamelan's in Vancouver, B.C., and Boston, MA.
The composer of this piece is I Dewa Ketut Alit, one of the great young composers in Bali. He originally composed this piece for Angklung, but they would not allow it in such an arrangement for the competition in the Bali Arts Festival. So he re-arranged it for Gong Kebyar. This is the performance during the Bali Arts festival, summer 2005 and the group is the childrens group from the region (state/province) of Gianyar, Bali.
salam dari orang yogyakarta yang tinggal di los angeles. bagus gamelannya. regenrasi yang baik sekali. di yogya sendiri sudah jarang anak kecil main gamelan. bravo.
tiang mangkin ring boston nike chandanatha...tolong sampaikan sareng cok wah..wenten salam sakeng cok wira..tiang semetone cok wah nike..seneng banget udah bisa liat penampilan gambelan cenik wayah..malih bendan balik ke bali chandanatha??salam sareng cok wah n sukses n terus berkarya gambelan cenik wayah..sukses cw,,,sukseme
sukses selalu n terus berkarya cenik wayah...thank uploadnya chandanatha..salam dari tiang di rantauan n seneng banget udagh bisa liat penampilan cenik wayah..matur sukseme jung wah di puri saraswati sebagai pembina dan membetuk gamelan cenik wayah ..salam untuk tukang ugalnya..sukses cenik wayah..cw...sukseme...cokwira..di rantauan
this video reminds me 7 years ago, I was a flute player who sat in the front position!
agunghere 5 months ago
This music is incredible. I have not heard anything like this before. Fantastic!!
crookedmelody1 7 months ago in playlist Bali - Gamelan
Saya suka sekali kain ini musika.
donluigi42 11 months ago
I wonder if I would've heard a similar audience at the Balinese dance performance if I hadn't been surrounded by tourists ;).
keppiezbt 1 year ago
wah, nice. ive never heard this style of mucic before. i read a research paper that said the unusual proportion of high frequencies found in gamelan music enhanced brain activity. :) interesting.
MustNotRead 1 year ago
wow! Hammer Time!
WimGrundy 1 year ago 2
for some strange reason the beginning reminded me of the old classic pc game LOOM
SethP666 1 year ago
this is great peforment
widyanaajus 1 year ago
im not balinesse,or live in indonesia,but the Bali traditional music and culture make me want to know more,hope one day i can watch and listen Balinesse people playing the music live,Bali!one day i will visit you.
Ivangoven 1 year ago
I'm Balinese, and playing gamelan. I think it will be better if competition is only for the young and kids. For senior player it's better to do some kind of exhibition like in the jazz world, no competition no ego boosting. Cheers and jeers for the young and silent appreciation for the mature artists. Imagine! enjoying those ethereally beautiful sound in silent...
traveler313 2 years ago
This shit is wicked
tempohyeah 2 years ago
Wow !! Fantastic !!! Love it !! thank you so much for the video !! :)
TheMrOye 2 years ago
Great Song!
tera1320 cyberpunk extrodinaire!!!
tera1320 2 years ago
ndak ada gamelan baleganjur tolong diisi ya
tagolholiz 2 years ago
I loved the time I spent there...AWSOME!
classicallady 2 years ago 2
Saya mencintai gamelan, khususnya di Bali. Pos dan anak baik mempunyai bunyi luar biasa. Menyimpan mengirimkan lebih banyak. Indonesia bagus.
archimech1138 2 years ago
at 1.32 hat the left top is a hakenkreuz ^^
DmariusX 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Music is wordless.. beautiful and evoking..but seriously the audience is HORRIBLE...they really don't deserve this great music.
magamargot 3 years ago
Oh dear, not another one...
Just read my and chandanatha's previous comments, please.
SiKedek 3 years ago
....music is emotion, so you CANNOT judge... and remember: each culture expresses emotion in his way. DO NOT JUDGE. (are you american? i think yes)
cazztovv 3 years ago 3
I think there is a misunderstanding here...I really didn't want to judge anyone...I had only noticed that the audience was noisy and I just thought that this beatiful music could have needed a silent audience...I'm not american, I hope I didn't bother any balinese with my comment!
magamargot 2 years ago
lol you just judged Americans by assuming he was American. Nice hypocrisy.
n8tehgr8 2 years ago
hey, the chinese culture also encourages cheering on the part of the audience when a particularly difficult part is performed =]
cutefidgety 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
it strongly evoked a kaleidoscope and an antique shop, for some reason.
don't worry, i like kaleidoscopes and i respect antique shops.
but really, i gotta get some gamelan. it would be killer stoner music.
but don't worry, i don't smoke weed.
but seriously, i don't. and i do want some of this antique kaleidoscope music.
OH! IT'S LIKE NEEDLES!
but don't worry, i like needles.
helenclarkisalesbian 3 years ago
Weirdest.Post.Ever
PeterVilla21 3 years ago 2
u re stone
do weed with a singing bowl for meditation
lostamastasean 3 years ago
I'm just now gettin' into Gamelan. And I find peace in it. Good shat!
Shagalagasheed 3 years ago
Comelnya budak-budak ni main gamelan. Penuh perasaan dengan lenggok kepala nya....Suka saya tengok.
lecehlah 3 years ago
amazing performences... i like it... it very well... congratulation...
awiewong 3 years ago
SiKedek is right but wrong. Yes, Gamelan musicians like to have feedback and yes they would hate a silent audience. HOWEVER, when they perform in competitions and to their own people, the response is appropriate and relates to what they are hearing. This audience would whoop and holler is someone came out and made farting sounds. There is no understanding or discernment in their response. The Audience noise is just for their own amusement and to impress their friends, not to show understanding.
sasmanwayne 3 years ago
Understandably, there may be some gamelan musicians who might be bothered to a certain extent. However, according to Wayne Vitale in his CD featuring Pak Windha's works, the players must "maintain a high _mental_ (attitude) in the face of screaming and sometimes malicious spectators". In other words, if a musician is so freaked out by this charged atmosphere, it's better for him/her to quit. So it's not the most ideal environment - but it's there anyway. They just have to deal with it.
SiKedek 3 years ago
You know, that is the fact how the Balinese audiences are. We, Balinese, wasn't bothered with all of that. Both of you are right!! Balinese audience just loves to express their impression directly when there are something good or bad that are going on in the stage. Especially in the Gong Kebyar Competition.
chandanatha 3 years ago
However, sometimes there are lots of audience who doesn't know about music at all, comes there to watch and gives inappropriate responses to what are going on. Those are audiences who doesn't have understanding to the arts.
Regards,
I Wayan Sudirana
chandanatha 3 years ago
I lived in Bali for 5 years. Do you know what the musicians think of the morons watching this performance? Can you imagine? The Balinese are tolerant, fun loving and friendly, but even they can't understand why people would pay money and devote their time to go to a concert then make monkey noises and squeals. There is a Balinese expression that equates to 'take the money and run'. When I am in Bali I am ashamed by westerners who behave like this. Oh and before anyone comments, I HAVE A LIFE!
sasmanwayne 3 years ago
Hahaha! Excellent! And know we know where our modern day classical composers stole their ideas! It's like a rock concert from another world! Luv it!
VladtheEmailer 3 years ago 5
Great music, bad audience. Why people to shut the fck up and listen???
PaoloLegnetti 3 years ago
Did you even bother to look at my response to "hexachordal"?
"No, you misunderstand - any traditional gamelan performance worth its salt will have audience outbursts like this, especially in a gamelan competition situation. That way, you know the audience is paying attention. A silent audience is definitely NOT DESIRED in Bali! And a Balinese audience will not reserve any judgment"
In other words, Balinese gamelans like this noise from the audience.
SiKedek 3 years ago
It's a concert...not a studio recording! As a musician or any kind of performer, you feed off that energy...
greengtrs 3 years ago 3
COol. it really reflects the culture(:
Gladys973 3 years ago
gamelan music nice one i just learn this gamelan music quite nice to listen fun!:D
vanillabest 3 years ago
What is up with that swastica, this anti-semitism WILL NOT BE TOLERATED
inricheetos 3 years ago
Did you know what's the different between Hindu's Swastika and the one that Hitler had been use????
You should learn about it first before you give your comment about it! (in fact that your spelling is wrong too)
However, this performance is not related to that!!!
chandanatha 3 years ago
let's help out this fellow over here... the Hindu Swastika (with a K) denotes prosperity and goodwill. and if you are keen in enough in observing, you should have noticed Hitler's swastika is facing the opposite direction!
pjcbellora 3 years ago
Thanks pjcbellora...!
chandanatha 3 years ago
The swastika is an extremely old auspicious symbol, long before its reappropriation by the Nazis.
In East Asia, one can see it in a particular lattice-like pattern in China, Japan, Korea, and anywhere within strong Sinitic (i.e. Chinese) influence - this was brought along with Buddhism. I've also seen this in on some headdresses from a few Native American groups.
SiKedek 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't care. I'll report this video to the Anti-Defamation League and Jewish Defense Group so that they can take the appropriate actions to put this antisemitism DOWN.
inricheetos 3 years ago
So, are you going to oversee the public censure of Bali and Balinese culture? Cultural suppression because of perceived cross-cultural misunderstanding? Yeah, that will go over really well...
SiKedek 3 years ago
inricheetos: So, you're going to report this video to those groups, despite the fact that people have already told you that the hindu swastika (which came first by the way) is completely different to the nazi one, and is in no way anti semitic. By the way, you do realise that everyone else already knew this, right? Good luck with that.
TomBandfield 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@inricheetos Do not mix an Arts with Politic that you do not know as well as you write here..
Benzlamet 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
A M A Z I N G...
Benzlamet 1 month ago
mantep puniki vidione. salah kenal chandanata, tiang anak bali ring singapore, namun lacur ten bise megamelan..
kadeck 3 years ago
This some great music! To paraphrase the Beatles in "Let It Be": "Phillip Glass ain't got nothing on this figure..." You got it all here. Time changes, dissonance, dynamics, a non-twelve step octave and repetition--and it's all traditional folk music played and directed by real people. To us Amero-European composers using synthesizers, this is what we call progressive or experimental. In a real since, we're just stealing from our past.
gregor133 4 years ago
wow,ur analysis seems little bit though for me. But, i enjoy the music.
DDR1024 3 years ago
I can't get enough of this video.
inthefade 4 years ago
inthefade: are you a QOTSA/Gamelan fan too? Thought I was the only one!!
Posters: Thank you SO much for this! I always get all emotional listening to Gamelan, I'm not sure why, my guess is that it is beautiful and familiar to my soul on a subconscious level.
And these children are awesome cool -- catch the kids in one row spinning their little hammer things between parts. Reminds me of the horn section in "The Blues Brothers."
quorumangelorum 3 years ago
WOW!!!
BRILLIANT!!!
Nataraja13 4 years ago
gaya neh.........
cenik wayak....bon tut neh....hehehehehe
pu263092 4 years ago
I Love Love Gamelan. I Love the fact it's tuned in quarter tones and not the usual western chromatic system(meaning we've got C-C# for example, & they've got an extra note in between) Whats the differemce between Balinese Gamelan and Javanese Gamelan?
moshimoshi333 4 years ago
Well, simply speaking: Balinese Gamelan is fast and Javanese gamelan is slow. But, is a lot more than that, if we want to distinguish them.
chandanatha 4 years ago
Cheers mate! I played Gamelan once, but my timing was terrible.hehe^^I'd love to own a whole Orchestra oneday!! Thanks for uploading your vids, much appreciated.
moshimoshi333 4 years ago
Bali style of playing is my favourite!
moshimoshi333 4 years ago
It really annoys me how you can hear all these people in the background going 'WOOO YEAH! CLAP CLAP CLAPPITY CLAP!' at EVERY OPPORTUNITY. Why don't they just shut up and respect the gamelan tradition in the way it's meant to be appreciated... in silence?
hexachordal 4 years ago
No, you misunderstand - any traditional gamelan performance worth its salt will have audience outbursts like this, especially in a gamelan competition situation. That way, you know the audience is paying attention. A silent audience is definitely NOT DESIRED in Bali! And a Balinese audience will not reserve any judgment - if you're considered low quality, they'll be glad to criticize, laugh, holler, or jeer. It's just the name of the game in Bali...
SiKedek 4 years ago 3
Just think of this like your average sporting event - with music groups as the competing teams.
SiKedek 4 years ago 2
oh goodness. I got completely the wrong end of the stick :P Thanks for taking the time to correct me!
hexachordal 4 years ago 4
If you initially found the noisy audience annoying, a typical Balinese temple ceremony will shock you. In the same space, there may be as many as five or six ensembles playing at the same time - different pieces, different timbres, not to mention different tunings. A cacophonous situation for sure, but highly desired because the Balinese love a festive situation that is rame, or "lively, busy". Its antonym, sepi "silent, quiet", is an almost depressing situation.
SiKedek 4 years ago 5
I like the music on Bali and played it often there but I don't like this "show".
3tristan 4 years ago
By the way, if you are interested in hearing more of Alit's compositions, check out the recorded work of the Balinese gamelan "Cudamani". Alit and his brothers founded that group and built it into one of the most innovative gamelans in Bali today. The have done international tours, so keep an eye out for Cudamani. Alit has also worked with gamelan's in Vancouver, B.C., and Boston, MA.
yesloow 4 years ago
The composer of this piece is I Dewa Ketut Alit, one of the great young composers in Bali. He originally composed this piece for Angklung, but they would not allow it in such an arrangement for the competition in the Bali Arts Festival. So he re-arranged it for Gong Kebyar. This is the performance during the Bali Arts festival, summer 2005 and the group is the childrens group from the region (state/province) of Gianyar, Bali.
yesloow 4 years ago
babat bodoh
950704 4 years ago
sakam semeton bali ring dije ye megenah tiang ketut uli karangasem dese jasri mangkin ring belanda
KetutErawati 4 years ago
brilliant vid.. cant wait to visit the beutiful place again...
kokulaa 4 years ago 2
Great tunes!!!!! Thanks for aploading it.
Semara1 4 years ago
Ethereal! Like a well-wound clock mechanism. Magnificent coordination and artistry. Great Production.
fidokalman 4 years ago 4
Muzik yang terindah di dunia. I'm proud to be Asian.
AzamBoi 4 years ago
Interesting.....My goosebumps up when listen to it....Get inspired....Tat was good....
peiYeez 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Great Song!
Wow this is a work of art!
Very random!
Check out my videos, I'll think you'll like it!
robotpeople 4 years ago
hillarious
psrolip 4 years ago
salam dari orang yogyakarta yang tinggal di los angeles. bagus gamelannya. regenrasi yang baik sekali. di yogya sendiri sudah jarang anak kecil main gamelan. bravo.
gudeg55781 4 years ago
Perhaps the favorite of my youtube favorits! Thanks a lot Chandanatha!
uno15234 4 years ago
tiang mangkin ring boston nike chandanatha...tolong sampaikan sareng cok wah..wenten salam sakeng cok wira..tiang semetone cok wah nike..seneng banget udah bisa liat penampilan gambelan cenik wayah..malih bendan balik ke bali chandanatha??salam sareng cok wah n sukses n terus berkarya gambelan cenik wayah..sukses cw,,,sukseme
cokwira 4 years ago
sukses selalu n terus berkarya cenik wayah...thank uploadnya chandanatha..salam dari tiang di rantauan n seneng banget udagh bisa liat penampilan cenik wayah..matur sukseme jung wah di puri saraswati sebagai pembina dan membetuk gamelan cenik wayah ..salam untuk tukang ugalnya..sukses cenik wayah..cw...sukseme...cokwira..di rantauan
cokwira 4 years ago
Cok Wira, ring dije niki mangkin?
tiang mangkin ring Vancouver, Canada.
salam kenal dari tiang (tiang assistantnya Cok Wah)
chandanatha 4 years ago
ma kasih... ada tetangga saya penabuhnya..., thanks a lot..
yanikjw 4 years ago
what a show. these is kids are amazing....
ballywood2006 4 years ago