Added: 3 years ago
From: irishdancermaeve
Views: 134,896
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (296)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Plus, Leona kinda looks like a conceded bitch.. not to say she is one, but idk. i just get that feeling watching her perform in this video is all...

  • Leona has an amazing voice and everything..but Alexandra makes her sound like a little girl.. dont get me wrong! Leona is like an idol of mine, but Alexandra's voice is a better match for this song.

  • My top 2 favorite x-factor FEMALE winners.

  • @309063048 haha i found out about x factor through leona and then alexandra.

  • both of them r gud but i think leona got this one !

  • Leona is just soooo much better than Alexandra. Leona is just pure talent. Long live Leona!!!!!

  • Love both of them, but neither did good

  • Leona was nervous it was her first show.But they both did good

  • its not fair 2 base it on this since their clearly singing in different octaves but i personally prefer alexandra rendition... X!

  • alexandra com certeze sensacional

  • Leona is an angel, she's just so special, she's got this voice...my god I can't explain it. She's too perfect to be explained.

  • THUMBS IF THEY VOICES ARE DIFFERENT 2 EACH OTHER BUT STILL THEY ARE BOTH AMAZING !

  • Alexandras sounds better there but Leona has improved immeasureably since then.

  • I like so much Leona but... in this SONG, Alexandra's version is better, has more power

  • Comment removed

  • prefer Alexandra i find Leona very boring

  • prefer Alexandra

  • Alex all day! Leona can sing but compared to Alex u mite well be saying Leona who??

  • Leona by a mile PERIOD.

  • Leona's voice control and range is obviously superior to Alexandra's. Alexandra is fantastic as well of course, but Leona is among the top, top vocalists in the world. Alexandra is not.

  • @xytheon Says who? If I recall, all the judges on X Factor said that Alexandra had a world class voice, and it is her song, Hallelujah that made the fastest dowload in European history. Plus, If you go on videos where Leona's compared to Whitney, Mariah, Celine, Christina, and Beyonce, the vast majority says that she's overrated and her belts are very whiny and pitchy.

    BTW, if Leona's voice control is so obviously superior to Alexandra's, then why did she sound so off-key compared to Alex?

  • alexandra better.

  • i like big voice i choose alexandra in general :)

  • their voice similar, but alexandra is better, more power

  • Comment removed

  • 2 strong women and great singers you don't need to judge either just enjoy the blessings of hearing them.

  • Alexandra is clearly the best.

  • alexandra is the best

  • Comment removed

  • Leona Lewis, it's not even a question. Leona's voice is elegant and her range so much greater. Alexandra Burke is just louder.

  • Alexandra definitely .

  • def alexandra!!!!

  • Leona is far better you muppet!! Alex is ok but let's face it none of the winners of xfactor have lived up to leona and that's a fact jack!

  • A both are great, but leona is leona :)

  • They both pwn all the other winners.

  • Alex, Alex, Alex!!!!!

  • Alex got 10 times strongest and better voice, Leona is a marketing product and has succes thanks to her beauty and sweetness, nomore...

  • Leona is a lady, so sweet

  • Also Alexandra has more power whereas Leona has a bigger range!

  • Alexandra has got that big voive and Leona has that sooting sweet voice! They are both completely different and amazing!

  • Alexandra much much better

  • check out Leona on Micheal Jackson Tribute concert ! i will be there, AWESOME

  • I am more a fan of Leona's voice, but Alex did better here.

  • Leona shanks <3

  • Alex is way better. You are the best!

  • They're both really good. Alex has a more powerful voice, but Leona can do more with hers. I prefer Leona she has a really unique voice.

    X Factor will never have a vocalist as good as Leona ever again.

  • Leona has the type of voice that you can just easily listen to, Alex is great and unique.

  • for me alex is the one... she is genios lol

    i love you ALEXANDRA...:))

  • C'mon guys its so obvious.. Leona is way better than Alexandra but Alex she has a strong voice, its pretty good I'm not ganna lie

  • Alex is only singing powerfully, but Leona is only singing beautifully. Both of them are GREAT!!!

  • Leona's way better. 

  • Aex is better. her voice is stronger :x

  • i can't help myself, i hate leonas voice!! alexandra is waaaaaaaay better!

  • Alexandra is better than Leona :)

  • ALEXXXX U KILLED TO LEONA, BOTH HAVE A GOOD VOICE BUT ALEXANDRA,VOICE IS AMAZING, WOW!

  • Alex has Leona beat by a mile. Leona sounds whinny. Alex voice is much stronger.

  • They're both great .

  • leona was more nerves then her on the show. leona got better and better

  • Alex.

  • sorry i like alex voice more but leona sings i see you from thze movie avatar so nice

  • There's no question to who's better Leona is just another league even though i love Alex too,come on guys be serious

  • Leona is the best!!!!

  • even though i really like leona, alexandra's versions sounds much better ;)

  • Leona has a better and more pleasent voice

  • Even if I say tie because I love both, Alexandra's high part at 1:30 is A LOT better than Leonas one. Alex hits E5 and Leona hits F5, but her F5 is kinda thin. Alexandra sounds better.

  • It's kinda hard to say who's better.

    I think Alex has the best voice: she has an amazing soulful tone, more power, volume and resonance than Leona.

    Leona's voice is wonderful, too. She has more technique and control than Alex, being more experienced, and belts higher with more security.

    I say tie.

  • leona voice is to week, but alexanders voice is like ISNDUISQBDNUHBCYWHCBGH

  • Im more of a Leona fan but for this song it suits Alex more as its more clearer and smooth where Leona got a bit too high for her vocals on this song. Compare Leona and Alex on Without You, Leona wins that hands down. Certain tracks suits certain singers..Leona is more catered for I Will Always Love You, All By Myself, I Have Nothing where Alex is catered for Unbreak My Heart, Listen...but they are both excellent in what they do

  • no need to compare guys..

    both are good..

  • I don't like what i see in the Highest Rated Commens -_-

  • Leona please! :)

    and yet Alexandra is good.

    but i choose Leona :)

  • ALEXANDRA IS BEST OF LEONA! ALEX IS THE BEST SINGER FOREVER!! YES, I LOVE ALEX! ALEXANDRA = MY LIFE

  • next year, Alex will to put everyone down.

  • @BraveVesperia101 yes it's just you

  • i like Alexandra but i love Leona,this song was one of the best performances of Alex while this was one of the less beautiful performances of Leona.I think it is unfair to compare them here,but still i stand for Leona.She is the best singer in the world for me.

  • @Endriking aww, how cute... :p

  • leona is better she has a sweet voice. go leona!!!!!!!

  • For me, Leona is clearly the better one. However, I will admit Alexandra has a stronger lower register which carrys her through this song. All this, Alexandra has jack shit on Leona! Overall shes inferior to Leonas strength and beauty when singing.

  • Alexandra Burke better than Leona..

  • think alex's wins this 1... but for reals, theres enought room 4 both!

  • Alex is so much better than Leona, she will rock the world soon. Alex looks better too.

  • leona ! she is %1000 better i think alex sounds like a man ! hahahah she is rubbish a rubbish old man singer

  • i'll be there , by michael jackson ..

    i miss you mike .. i really do

  • i dont care, who has better vocal range..i think leona have more charisma ,beautiful high notes,what alexandra never does and her own personal style,thats why i love Leona!!!

  • I dont knw why, but i am more towards leona on this. Alex is nevertheless amazing.

  • Alexandra's is better sound quality for a start and that was Leona's first week compared to Alexandra's 4th or 5th week.. Leona has the better voice.

  • It was Alex's second week and if you listen to her first week that was brilliant to.

  • @chutchins05

    This was actually Alex's 2nd week, and even in her first, her stage presence and vocal quality were amazing! :)

  • Alexandra has a certain stage presence that leona hasnt and her voice sounds a lot fuller!!

  • alexandras deffo

  • alexandra for sure she just makes it her song it's not a rip off

  • Burke on this one.

  • There both better at different songs id say there on a par with each other

  • the video speaks for it's self ALEXANDRA BY about 100years

  • Comment removed

  • Surprisingly, Alex wins for this performance! :D Love them both though! :)

  • Alexandra's voice is so rich and BIG compared to Leona's. Dont understand why Leona is so adored theyre both gorgeous, and talented.

  • Sorry, I know what you mean about not deciding who's better, but I think Leona is 1 in a trillion.

  • 1 in a trillion she's a warbling whaling screcching wannabe mess!!!

    Truthfully

  • Echo fell 36 places on the American charts in a week. Happy fell 39 places on the American charts in a week, and it never even made it to the number one spot in the UK.

  • hmm truu

  • alex is got a bigger and better voice

  • @mymusiclova have you heard her? she sounds like a MAN!!! A MAN THAT CANT SING!!

  • @mymusiclova stronger and fuller tone maybe, but necessarily better...leona has an amazing angelic, ethereal timbre, great range, flexibility, head voice...if i could think of how angels in heaven would sound, it would definitely be like leona:)

  • i prefer alexandra

    but no need for all the who is better arguements, this is a great video

  • @JJBJJBJJBJJBJJBJJB there is a need for an argument because LEONA KILLS ALEX ! where is alex's number 1 in the usa?? ITS NON EXISTANT!!! and dont say its because she hasnt been out that long leonas first single from her first album was number 1 worldwide!!

  • @merrynutlump you started this remember that, also for the record i do like leona, Alex hasn't even released a song in the US yet so there are no comparisons that can be made yet, also echo didn't exactly set the charts on fire in the US did it? you should be judging success by the most recent releases

  • Alex was note perfect, Leona sounded pitchy in places, listen again and you will hear it.

  • omd they are both so so so amazing!

    but i am leona's number one fan :)

  • I think alex is better.

  • Echo's first week sales: 180,000 copies.

    Overcome's first week sales: 185,000 copies.

    I think the evidence speaks for itself....

  • Spirit's first week sales: 375,872

    Selling 130,000 in one dat

    I think the evidence speaks for itself

  • Yeah, her popularity has declined more than half....

  • Granted but who's to say the same won't happen to Alexandra? We can only see when she releases her second album.

  • Sorry, I made a mistake.

    Echo's first week sales: 161,000 copies (according to billboard).

  • leona has the better voice, but alexandra's gorgeous. :)

  • No Leona sings in a higher key, therefore, has a higher range, but that doesn't make it better. Some of the greatest females singers in the past such as Arethea, Mahelia, Dionne, Gladys Knight, and Roberta Flack just to mention a few didn't require high notes to show just how good they were, they just had good strong quality voices and singing ability and that is what Alexandra has plus a charismatic personality.

  • Firstly "succeed06" your girl Leona looklike a man, her single "happy" in the USA isn't doing so well. Leona is a bore she is a ugly Beyonce. Alex is beautiful sexy and the girl can dance sing. Alex is going to be big in the USA, big as Beyonce and Madonna watch this space I am American, I just love Alex over that woman. Alex is FUN, Leona IS NOT.

  • Alexandra isn't as sucsessfully and famous in the USA or in Germany as Leona is now. But that's because Leona got so much promotion (Gig's on American Idol, Britain got talent,...) But I think when The X Factor starts in the USA Alexandra will be promoted there and she will be bigger than Leona cause Alexandra has got a bigger Voice and Personality althought she never was a profisional musicien before she was on The X Factor. Leona started doing profassionell singing at the age of 7!!!!

  • Leona Voice hurt my ears and she is A BIG BORE.  Alex got a personality and her voice is extremely powerful. Leona audience is totally different I will never buy her album or singles so either have to worry. I vote only once and it was for Alex.

  • Alex is the better singer and looker. Leona looklike that girl in sex in the city.

  • Alexandra has a beautiful voice, it is strong, clear and filled with passion

  • leona has a sexy voice alexandra is like a mans

  • Leona sold 940,000 copies of Bleeding Love in the UK in a year. Alex sold 423,300 copies in less than a month.

  • Leona sold 489.000 copies in the 3 first week.

    U r trying to tell ???

  • I know I shouldnt compare an icon with contestants but ... mariah carey is better haha

  • alexadra is better in this performance but i like both of them...they are very talented!!!

  • Leona has NO stage presence at all

    Alexandra is sooo proffesional and beuaitful

    look at leona flopping about at 1:34 to 1:41 compared to alexandra from the sassy snapping of fingers at 1:50 - 2:00

  • @LazeeLad2k8 ye very floppy leona like she wants to something but cant

  • Alexandra was obviously better in this performance but they are both amazing singers.

    PERSONALLY I prefer Alex; she's an all-rounder. She can't quite sing a ballad like Leona (with her beautiful range) but Leona CANNOT sing an up-tempo number like Alex whilst dancing etc. Besides Leona needs to work on her 'soul' voice more which Alex has in abundance hence this performance.

  • i love leona more but alexandras is better

  • This is a SOUL SONG. Most of you don't even know what SOUL really means but definitely Leona ha NO soul. The best singing this song is unquestionably Alexandra! Leona= only Pop vs Alex= Pop, Rock, Soul, R&B and everything.

  • I prefer Alexandra's one.

  • i prefer alexandra's one

  • They're supposed to sing Michael Jacksons version, but they sing Mariah Carey's version....

  • ther'ye women they can't sing micheal jackson's version so they sing mariah's

  • Maybe you're right.. But if they're pro's they should do their own thing... Their own version....

  • At this level, it is all a matter of taste. Personally, referring to this song, I prefer Alexandra's performance. This, of course, does not make her better or worse than Leona (whom I also love). Great singers, lovely voices and artistic drive.

  • Alexandra is better i'm sure. but leona is perfect xD i don't know xDD

  • they are both so amazing

  • makes me realize that I like alexandra's voice a LOT more!

  • both fantastic but leona a lot better!

  • Comment removed

  • i agree, ive been saying this to people who dont understand that alexandra burke is the same as leona

  • leona voice is more flexible...i think she'll be better recieved. i think alex's voice has star potential (which is why she won)...but lacks superstar merit (which is why she probably wont take the world by storm like leona)

  • They both won.... they didn't compete together

  • and if the did compete together...Leona woulda one..for sure.

  • I think Alexandra sounds much better than Leona. Her voice is so much stronger.

  • I find it difficult to decide between them. there both really great but when it comes to this id have to say leona!

  • Leona's is Better; Alexandra Sounds Like A Man :-/

  • ToxiiC33 you are really stupid. DO you know what a man sounds like? If you are one, then you sure do lack the male hormone. You are really sick!!!

  • Shut your retarded ass up toxiic ya ho!

    The key words were "If you are one" you dumb fuck....bitch upgraded you reading and comprehension skills before get into my zone ya heard me!!!

  • iWill Not Listen To You; You Bludy Fucktard Bastard Twat! Your Tha Retard Oh Fucking Hell You Didn't Know. "if You Are One" Just Suggests Your An idiot Fool As You Don't Know Tit For Tat Ya Lil Shit. iDon't Need To Upgrade Anyfing; Your Tha One Needing To Upgrade Ya Vocab Seing As You Copied A Phrase Or Two And Besides Your Zone? Am To Good For Tha Gutter Enemy, And Stop Tryna Act Like Your From Tha Ghetto You insignificant Little Fuck. Take Your Begging Ass Elsewhere Coz iAin't Gonna Listen Hoe

  • What the fuck are you really trying to drive across? I mean, all what you typed is pure stupidity. Do you attend school? Your spelling, reading, and comprehension skill = zero. I get really irritated reading from you because you are so stupid and annoying. Sit your dumb ass down. Why would you use a capital letter in the middle of a sentence? Weren't you thought that it distracts the reader? I'm done with your retarded ass. You have proved yourself to be very STUPID, you fool! DIE BITCH!

  • iShared An Opinion And You Took it Upon Yourself To Argue You Dumb Bastard Prick. Why Tha Fuck Do You Wanna Know if iAttend School? None Of Your Business Ya Dimwit. Sit My Dumb Ass Down? How Bout Back Tha Fuck Up & Shut Tha Fuck Up? iWill Type How iFucking Please You Bastard. Your Tha Retarded One You Fucking Hoe. Distracts Tha Reader? Maybe if They're Dumb it Will And Besides if My Reading Was Zero iWouldn't Know What Ya Saying FOOL. Me Proving iAm Stupid?You Must Be Just As Dumb To Reply Back.

  • Also, Do You Know What Contradiction is? Coz You Tell Me Bout Starting Sentences Wiv Capital Letters And Yet You Type Words in Full Capitals in Mid Sentence. Me irritating? Don't Kid Yaself. if Telling Yourself i'm Tha Annoying One Helps You Sleep At Night Be My Guest You Sad Piece Of Turd. Quit Trying To Argue Coz iAin't Gonna Back Down. Can't Handle Sumin? Don't Fucking Start it if Ya Too Much Of A Pussy Twat Ta End it. You Dumbass Fucktard Lowlife Fool. Didn't You Get Attention As A Kid?

  • SHUT THE FUCK UP!!!!!

    Talking about "can't handle something?" Fuck outta here with your mediocre, pathetic, dumb-as fuck ass arguments. School yourself before you confront me ho! When you've learned how to spell, read and understand, come back to me okay? We could have an intellectual debate or conversation dumb fuck. Fuck outta here dumb fool.

  • Whatcha Gonna Do if iDon't Shut Up? Ooh i'm Quivering HAHA You Dumb Fuck. iWill Not Listen Ta You; Ya Stupid Raped Fish. Dumbass Arguments? Well Your No Better Doing Tha Exact Same. Me; Schooling? How Bout Getcha Fake Ass To Tha Street Man And Know Tha Real World, Coz You Ain't Gonna Be Discussing Someones Speliing When Ya Bout To Get Popped Now Are Ya? Get Street Smarts Then Come Back. Intellectual Debate? Yeah Coz Your Gonna Be Debating When Your Under Siege How Dumb Are You?So Back Tha Fuckup

  • I'm sure swearing once or twice every sentence shows how intellegent you are. Some pubescent kid still in school no doubt.

  • I am quite intelligent, i can tell you that.

    I sweared because that kid was just nerving the heck out of me.

  • Swore* come on, you're not that intelligent.

  • Lmaooo wow, that's quite embarrassing. I guess i got carried away. Damn, i definitely feel like an idiot with that error. smh. Thanks for the correction.

  • OK, I luv Leona + Alex equally..both talented singers in diffrent ways. There r songs that r suited 4 Alex + songs suited 4 Leona. Both sung this song realy well but 4 this song Alex was more richer + soulful. Leona is beter when she sings songs like I Will Always Love U, Without You, All By Myself..where Alex is beter with songs like this one, Unbreak My Heart, Candyman, Toxic...In general, Alex is a beter uptempo singer + Leona is a beter ballad singer but they can do both uptempo + ballads.

  • It is so obvious that the black girl sang better... the other one seems like the worst karaoke version ever

  • They are both blakc you fool!!!

    You mean the darker girl....omg ig'nant

  • the point is! maybe not at this but leona is much better than alex all round!!

  • the both of them have amazing voices =]

  • wow alexandra have an anamazing voice !!!

  • Okay leona doesnt sing this better. But Leona does has the better voice technique like Mariah. Leona is better vocally alla round then Alex.. that is the truth. But Alex does this song better. But really truth is, none of these two versions is really that great.

  • nice but try to view this ill be there very good version by rhap salazar....

  • This is no competition with this song. Alex's version is a better quality hands down. I love Leona, but she can't touch Alex vocally when comparing this song. They are both two talented women. When Leona was singing this song she was all over the place vocally and was not original at all opposed to Alex who has a much richer voice and her quality is much better. Again I am not saying that Alex is a better singer than Leona because I love them both and they are both VERY talented.

  • I do like Leona but Alex sung this song sooooo miles much better xoxox

  • Love them both..=]

    <3

  • Leona warbles the song too much, Alex has much more depth and soul in her voice and holds lower notes far better than Leona, but Leona's falsetto is unbeatable.

  • Can you imagine if the both off them were in X Factor at the same time singing against each other!

    Now that would have been A X Factor.

  • leona would have won by far... alex is simple leona has more grace and elegance in her voice ... theres many people who can sing like alex but theres only been mariah and leona who are the main people who sing with that "style" if u get me