The Doctor & Rose -- Doctor Who -- Long Distance

[Spiritofeowyn]

You used the line of the 11th's Doctor where he says that you gave them your life, you're surprised they walked off with it-" brilliantly. It's now in my head that that was what he was thinking then. Of Course Clone Doctor would run off with Rose given the chance. And the music fits the mood and lyrics and theme and everything. Love this! You took scenes we have all seen before and remade them, new and lovely and heartbreaking.

[SilverVintage82]

@Spiritofeowyn Naturally, that's where my mind went with that line so I had to connect it. Or at least offer an alternative interpretation. :) Well anyway, thank you! I'm glad you enjoyed the video. My sister and I loved making it! I really wanted to get inside Eleven's head a little bit. But yeah, I agree, of course the Clone Doctor would run off with Rose! Thanks again!

[SaraMiriamAmaro]

Rose and human Doctor back, pleeeeeease!!!!!!

[SilverVintage82]

@SaraMiriamAmaro I hope they bring them back for the 50th anniversary.

[maskeyfilmz117]

The very beginning w/ the 11th doctor where that guy asks what the doctor would do if he could have 1 more day w/ his beloved, what episode is that?

[SilverVintage82]

@maskeyfilmz117 It's from the first episode of season 6, "A Christmas Carol."

[MsLissy09]

That was beautiful. Made my Rose/Doctor heart go crazy. I completely lost it with her scenes in Let's Kill Hitler.

I would love for Moffat to bring back Rose and the meta-crisis Doctor for an episode to show that they are married and happy. :) But Moffat hates Rose so he probably wont. Little f***er

[SilverVintage82]

@MsLissy09 Thanks so much! It was nice to see a little bit of reaction from Eleven about Rose.

Yeah, that would be cool! I personally don't think Moffat hates Rose that much though. He's been pretty heavy on the Rose subtext through out his run with the series so I hope the rumor he hates her isn't true. I never got that impression from him. But then maybe I'm wrong. Who knows.

[MiloTheUberLegend]

I'm actually kind of happy with Moffat. Atleast he hasn't wiped Rose out of The Doctor's mind. And, in the Christmas special, I'm certain everyone, including himself, thought of Rose in those two pauses. Amazing video.

You make it seem she could actually come back (which I hope happens ;A;) <3

[SilverVintage82]

@MiloTheUberLegend You know, I actually think there has been a ton of Rose/Doctor subtext through out season 5 and 6 (particularly 6) and Moffat has recently said that he has a continuous story for Rose in his head, so hopefully we'll be able to eventually see it play out! And yeah, there's no way "A Christmas Carol" wasn't all about Rose. :) Well anyway, thank you!

[MiloTheUberLegend]

@SilverVintage82  I thought that too. He does seem to make a few references to lost companions.

Wow, really? Apparently, Moffat hates Rose and said when he first started writing he had no intention of bringing her back. Yet, she pops up in Let's Kill Hitler! I really do hope he's planning something big. :D

[SilverVintage82]

Yeah, Steven Moffat lies! You just never know. It also probably depends on the availability of the actors as well!

I do think he's a pretty sarcastic person and has a tendency to mess with people's heads. But after reading "The Writer's Tale," among other things I think his hate for Rose has been blown out of proportion particularly in relation to that sarcastic comment he made about her at Comic-Con a while back. I do think he's trying to do something different from RTD though.

[MiloTheUberLegend]

@SilverVintage82 Yes.

They did say they haven't forgotten about the contract with Billie Piper.

I'm pretty sure he's messed with alot of people's heads with series 6 Cx I know, I saw some comic-con parts. xD

[SilverVintage82]

@MiloTheUberLegend He probably thinks it's fun! Well anyway, I do hope they eventually bring Rose back. Actually, I really hope they bring back the Human Doctor as well as Donna. I honestly loved all of RTD's characters and would be thrilled to see any and all of them!

[bookdork1]

Good to know I wasn't the only one who screamed at the TV when Rose appeared!

[SilverVintage82]

@bookdork1 It was definitely my favorite part of the latest episode, I'm not gonna lie! But it really made me want Rose, Martha and Donna to return for more episodes with meatier parts next round.

[bookdork1]

@SilverVintage82

I would love to see all the old companions interact with Eleven! Or if they brought back Human Doctor...That would be pretty awesome!

[SilverVintage82]

@bookdork1 That would be really cool! It would be particularly easy to bring in Martha and Mickey again. I'm hoping they'll bring back the Human Doctor and Rose too. Well as long as they don't ruin it or something and kill the human Doctor leaving Rose alone. I don't think they'd be that mean though!

[bookdork1]

@SilverVintage82

It would be too cruel to get rid of Human Doctor! That'd be terrible, I hope they wouldn't do that. I think Jack really needs to come back for a couple episodes. He and River would be epic together.

[RnDFoever25]

Sorry for commenting again, but this video is so brilliant I feel the need to keep commenting. Lol In fact, I thought your choices for your Eleven/Rose voice overs/parallels were brilliant. I mean right from the get-go with the infamous Christmas Carol scene. Your choices were just perfect. And I love that you used the Let's Kill Hitler clip. "Show me someone I like," indeed. Ugh! You guys rule. Seriously...just...awesome.

P.S. All the Nine/Ten/Rose scenes you picked killed me. Lol T^T

[SilverVintage82]

@RnDFoever25 Hey, don't apologize! We really appreciate your thoughts. So thank you for your comments. I'm glad you liked the video. It was definitely a challenge to make, but we're happy with the final result. Well anyway, thank you so much!

[RnDFoever25]

Okay, I love you guys. Seriously? This song...T^T It's been a fave of my since that Confidential too and the fact that you guys used it just makes me the happiest fangirl alive. It's so perfect for these two, this song...it's so somber and heartfelt, and just sad. Lol Ugh! This video was amazing! Especially the bits you used from The Rebel Flesh. I like that you highlighted the parallels of that episode to the Human Doctor and the Doctor...I thought that was quite an elegant touch.

[SilverVintage82]

Thank you. It's nice to know when someone really likes one of our videos! As soon as we heard that song, it was a total no-brainer to edit to it. It's gorgeous and haunting and just fits the Doctor and Rose perfectly! I'm glad the parts with "The Rebel Flesh" made sense. I really wanted to show that parallel and get inside the head of the Eleventh Doctor. He keeps things to himself, but I can see moments of subtext in the series that definitely seems to connect to his feelings for Rose.

[ThePinkBookworm]

Wow, that last line was perfect! You really did leave us with a bit of hope for those two. Great work!

Li Li

[SilverVintage82]

@ThePinkBookworm Thanks! I'm glad you could see the hope in the video and enjoyed it.

[FairyKingdom86]

Loved this so much! I love how you included the new scene as well. I went crazy over that scene, haha! Amazing job on this and gorgeous editing.

[SilverVintage82]

@FairyKingdom86 Thank you! I loved that scene. It's too bad they couldn't get Billie Piper to do a real scene! Now that would get me excited! Well anyway, thanks and I'm glad you liked it.

[RainOpProductions]

I wish time could be rewritten. Then the Doctor could go back and secure Rose and she would never fall through and they would still be together. I cried so hard when that happened.

[SilverVintage82]

@RainOpProductions I know! It was such a tragic separation. I would love it if the show could find a way for the Doctor and Rose to be together again. Though, I admit I've kind of gotten used to the human Doctor and thought it was a pretty fitting ending. I just feel like their story isn't completely told yet! So I guess we'll see.

[macamorajg]

EXCELLENT! I really enjoyed your video!!!



[SilverVintage82]

@macamorajg Thank you!

[startledsunshine]

I love the way you edit and how you juxtapose clips. Beautiful.

[SilverVintage82]

@startledsunshine Thanks so much! We appreciate it.

[Winterskel]

This is amazing

[SilverVintage82]

@Winterskel Thank you! :)