Rorschach's Death - Watchmen Motion Comic Version

[99UFOman]

bad



[ArtieNakamura3]

Roscharch's hat is alive

[gale1243]

Wow, the movie was 100% better when it came to showing this scene.

Honestly, this just sucks.

[BernardDeHond]

@gale1243 The voice acting and animation really don't do it justice. The scene is better in the comic.

[gale1243]

@BernardDeHond

Well, I agree that the voice-acting and animation really doesn't work for this scene. I have to say however, Dan (Nite Owl II) being there for his partner Rorschach's death, instead of staying inside and acting like nothing happened make the movie better for this particular scene instead of the comic. It was one of the changes I liked the best.

[CompyRex]

"What's that, Dan? What's that the smell of?"

"...Nostalgia."

[sealdude36]

The comic is so much more depressing than the movie

[dude13zo]

Damn motiopn comics sucks...I mean look at that....

[gokito2000]

can someone tell me why rorschach had to die? werent all of them good guy?

[Surathan]

@gokito2000 Are you fucking serious?

Did you not pay attention to anything in the comic or movie?!

[gokito2000]

@Surathan wow wow calm down dude.. i saw half of the movie and didnt understand it much

[Surathan]

@gokito2000 Dear gods... please, commit suicide.

[gokito2000]

@Surathan -_- fuck you... god ur such a fan boy, nerd, i dont even know what to call u

[Surathan]

@gokito2000 You're such a fucktard nigger.

Please die.

[gokito2000]

@Surathan its funny how ur getting so offended u fucking nerd, seriously

[CarnageRulez469]

@gokito2000 Too keep it short...Ozymandias had a plan to keep the world united,but it costs the lives of millions of ppl. Ozy enacted his plan and succeeded in uniting the world with his plan. Rorschach died because he was going to reveal Ozy's plan to the world,and if he were to tell the world,the U.S. and Soviet Union would be back at each others throats.

[HerrJamie]

@gokito2000 Watch the movie, pay attention to it rather than doing what ever the fuck you were clearly doing. Read the comic properly also.

Option 2: get off the internet and if you have real world interactions; stop them at once. Save the world from your stupidity.

[IrishKnight89]

I feel like there are certain stories that work better as comics than as movies.

[Obsidian182]

When he took off the mask I immediately began to laugh my ass off.

[godschamp1]

rorshack had to die,he was my fav character.i was so mad when i saw the movie.he was the only character that did not talk the viewers ears off and let his fist do the talking.

[Llama212ify]

Movie ending was better.

[dalektaliban]

everyone sounds like boba fett

[PredatorExpert]

rorschach sounds like shephard from mw2

[matuhatin]

when i saw it, i thought it was fanmade.

when i knew it was an official product for sale... man...

[BrianMagnumFilms]

DAT ASS

[RoflMcCopterson]

D8<

[4everplaid]

do it.

[dartagnanv]

This kind of animation is crap and the voice acting is worse.

Please, don't do that. Let the beauty stay in the comics.

[TimmyTheRapper]

@dartagnanv The animation is good, the voice acting isn't.

[567supergirl]

in the movie, his death scene had more emotion..and rorschach wuz more sexy.

[RettMikhal]

@567supergirl I agree, plus it has my favorite line in the entire series. "Suddenly you discovered humanity? Convenient." To me, this always represented the way people seem to change in such a way as to deny you something, or allow themselves to grow apart. You run into someone you always loved and they're married, how convenient. In this case, Manhattan developed humanity just in time to justify killing Rorshach but after Veidt's plan killed millions. How convenient.

[godschamp1]

@567supergirl ,WOW a girl that likes action movies,i think thats sexy.hope you like black guys

[ScreamingStarr]

@godschamp1 I love it when people hit on other people over the internet. I find it cute in a pathetic way.

[godschamp1]

@ScreamingStarr,lol thanks i think,i was just kidding though lol.

[TheDominionOfElites]

Voice acting destroys it. They got the casting spot on for the movie.

[enemybird]

...Rorschach... 0:56

[Redrobin1301]

Rorschach needs to die EPICLY! Not like this!

[jwhoff619]

Put a little umph in in your voice, man! You just died!

[steelie2010]

the voice messes this up the movie one is the real thing

[shadowmax889]

i think the problem is not the motion comic as a concept per se, but the voice acting in this scene ruins it

[xxlamaxx1]

This is fucking retarded, why not just read the goddamn book?

[Jackeduphobo33]

I don't know why, but I just love the heartlessness of this scene. It's so creepy!

[causeandeffect06]

so bad...

[Trepidox]

I love the lack of epicness.

[Sadisticjellyfish73]

God this motion comic is so hit-and-miss. Like you have scenes like Rorschach's monologue over the Comedian's grave, which are better then the movie, and then there's shit like this...

[DanBlabbers]

LOL, no no no...so bad XD

[tommyt1971]

Ok... that sucked. Think I'll go back to Bunny Shooter...

[ijwi]

It's a shame because this version got the cross-cutting between images right, which the movie didn't (well, maybe they did in the Director's cut) but the voice acting is a little flat... I really like the Manhattan origins scene, though. The voice actor is perfect for that. Should have had Alan Moore voice Rorschach.

[seminoleboy96]

I think this is a nightmare rorschach had after saving the day.... I think that in real life Rorschach punched Dr Manhattan straight in his stupid blue face and walked into the room and killed Veight. Thats my story and im sticking to it.

[nana78748]

Aww shit he was just like "Do It" and Doc reduced him to a pile of blood.

[gamecommanderCOD4]

I love Watchmen but this was terrible

[atomichead777]

i preferred the movie's ending

I liked how Dan was there to atleast witness the death of his friend, rather than screwing laurie for the 3rd or 4th time

[Shazam53G]

@atomichead777 I Agree

[StrangeFilm]

@atomichead777 I so agree this seem so damn heartless :(...

[TheSnowdog21121]

@atomichead777 The movie's ending was the weakest part of the movie. The people who made this movies are not better filmakers than Alan Moore is as a writer.

[SuperQuasar]

Lol this made me fucking LOL. This made watchman seem reallllyy gay.

[Louistogies]

This - dialog - is - emotionless....

[TheTrohl]

I don't get it... is there a difference between a motion comic and a badly animated movie?

[SpadaComics]

@TheTrohl the movie could be better. the motion comic is good as the animators can do it, they aren't gods at all dude :/

[TheTrohl]

@SpadaComics I know, but I don't really see the point of making a motion comic when you could make a real movie with some decent animation instead. Not that I think it would work for Watchmen, but it just makes me wonder.

[SpadaComics]

@TheTrohl oh, of course!, but the money makes dance the monkey xD motion comics, movies, action figures, just comercial garbage to make money out of the fans...

[SqullLeonHeart3]

Isn't has epic has it was in the movie..lol

[Ivaria]

Rooooorschaaaach............

[EnchantEmerson]

This is better than the movie hahah

[TetraperantosNikos]

so .. he died .. just like that .. poofff...

[ffirth1]

humm not as good as the movie 1 lol!

[im26y4yall]

this was so anti climatic

[mattwilhelm60]

@im26y4yall watch the movie version... JEH desurves an oscar

[caseyman100]

wow doctor manhattan is a faggot

[illahstrait1]

dawm

[SonicStantz]

This Motion comic SUCKED!!!!!!!!

[linkfreak117]

0:38 I'm afraid i cant let you do that Star Fox

[shadowario96]

I cried when this happened in the movie

[NefariousNarcissist7]

Not bad.

[Owneador1337]

NO GIANT BLUE PENIS???

No deal.

[punkyhiphopdood]

Not quite the same amount of passion as the movie haha.

[RB35MrIzuna]

Did Vin Diesel voice everybody?!

[ReeveRuddock]

Rorschachs fucking ginger!!!!!!!!

[moonsilverish]

...fail

[TheOjibway84]

corny voices. corny animation. it was more emotional in the movie!

[ficsci]

Yeah, the motion comic version is just hella awkward. Can you believe that even Laurie's voice was filled with that same narrator guy's voice? :S

[Clonehunter1]

Yah, this isn't as epic as it was portrayed in the comic or the movie.

[alahad]

I love how this thing is not related to the movie... I don't feel the essence of the moviee... if you could do all of them it would be awesome!

[erblecde]

@alahad I hope you're aware that both are based off of comics. And if you weren't, then now you are and you look really stupid.

[alahad]

@erblecde no, you didn't understand my comment, what i actually meant is that I love how this short is based directly on the comic and not in the movie... the scenario is from the comic, the dialogues and everything is from the graphic novel, I know both come from the same thing but the scenario and some stuff are different... thats what makes you stupid for not being able to understand a simple idea...

[CoRkSkr3w]

Forgive me for this comparison but manhattan sounds like Brian on family guy when meg's about to kill herself.

"no...come on...stop it...c'mon..."

[ramjet94]

@CoRkSkr3w that was the point hes supposed to be emotionless and non caring.

[fredo18ify]

@CoRkSkr3w No, a fair comparison, Doc Manhattan is the height of dispassionate. I love the live action movie, but they did try to make him too human. In the graphic novel, the God parallel was much more tangible, and included the obvious indifference Alan Moore felt a god would have for an individual human.

[DannyCBrennan]

I know they can't have moving lips but come on that just looked silly when he took his mask off

[N00bSa1b0tMK]

Lol at his D:< face the whole time

[jimbobhk2009]

@N00bSa1b0tMK i'm guessing you don't read comics lol

[N00bSa1b0tMK]

@jimbobhk2009 Its still a silly face :D

[MrFood239]

@N00bSa1b0tMK That made me srsly laugh xD

[Liam1993R]

hehehe lame. Movie did it better [/captain obvious]

[3rixtat3]

why the fuck did he have ginger frizzy hair

[pilule1995]

@3rixtat3 The fuck thats so gay

[1215ra]

I know it's just me but when Rorschach says "Back to Owlship" it almost sounds like "Back to Auschwitz"

[pricture]

Oh wow the code to put in another comment was "mashout" :P

[guitar19904]

@pricture lol strange indeed

[MASTERREVAN118]

sorry but fail, this guys voice is so monotone i just gotta say the motion comics arent my thing

[pricture]

@MASTERREVAN118 I know, I mean Rorschach's journal's with his voice is ok but ugh theres no feeling at all in this scene!

Just listen to how Mahatten says "Rorschach" right before he kills him and walks off like nothing happened. XD

[Suthek]

@pricture It sounds like he's going friendly and jokingly. like 'Oh Rohrschach, you don't mean that.'

[11Deez]

@MASTERREVAN118 when u watch the comic the physiotherapist says he has no expression in voice or face

[MASTERREVAN118]

@11Deez well its just that one guy does EVERY SINGLE voice in this thing it gets pretty redundant to me hearing the same guy (not even really change his tone or pitch) do every voice in this

[fwgross3]

I hated this scene when I flipped through the movie whilst flying at 35000 feet. I thought this blue guy has set himslef up as a god (note little g). This blue guy thinks he knows what is best but in actuallity he is just the same as R - a damn evil murderer. I sure would not want to live in a place where this sort of thing goes on.

[Psycho3418]

You've could made the do it! a bit more DO It!! Anyway I don't really want to complain.

[nooonem]

no, just no. Both in the comic and this motion comic his death is so quick and anti-climatic. It feels so insignificant . And I love the comic, but I have to say that this is the most badly done part of it.

[ElvishMaster]

@nooonem

Its funny, because you just validated the scenes. the point is they ARE insignificant. It means nothing in the big picture. Ozymandias and jon were right. 10,000 deaths is the same as 9,999 deaths.

[nooonem]

I've thought of that and I know what was meant, but that doesn't mean it's a good death scene. It's still lackluster, it still doesn't cause impact, unlike all the other deaths in the comic. The Comedian's death was insignificant, so was the first Nite Owl's, but they're deaths were not handled as "lol ur ded nao" and cut to a fat man having sex with a girl. I still think that in the comics all of the characters ended up being huge douches, but after watching the movie I feel better about them.

[ElvishMaster]

@nooonem

i getcha i getcha. i personally think that the movie was better than the graphic novel. The graphic novel was good, but the movie did a better job of fully illustrating the motifs that were supposed to be present. but they were both real good :)

[Drgamedood]

@ElvishMaster Is the creator of this series a nihilist?

[cha5]

@Drgamedood No he's a Glyconian and a practicing magician among other things, a nihilist has no belief in anything and Alan Moore most definately is passionate about what he believes in.

For me the motion comic just never captured the emotion of the original comic, IMHO it's a basic matter of choppy animation and having one narrator voicing every character in in the story as opposed to reading it yourself and letting the character's voices come alive in your own head.

[cha5]

@Drgamedood Not to mention cutting out whole chunks of the graphic novel, but I guess text on the page is impossible to work into a motion comic, I can't wait to see how DC does cramming everything into their Watchmen E-Book. (actually maybe I can) ;-)