You Should Have Lied

[TheCUTEanimefangirl]

ok, i feel a little sad now TT_TT

[KuruDarkness]

if i pm u can u email me the song file?

[AnimeAlyssal1]

This makes me wonder if I should have even told her about cutting? She is my dearest sister the 1 I though needed to know everything. I learned the hard way, she looks at me with pity. she loses her smile sometimes when she looks at me. I wish I lied, I should have said it was a cat scarch. She would have trusted me I know this is about some cheating guy but this is what it reminds me of.

[AngelS773]

okkkkaaaaayyy. Sudden idea/question for peeps. Have u thought what would have happened if clair had married tamaki and then Haruhi ended up with Hikaru? and in the future she became SUPER beautiful and then on a romantic date hikaru and haruhi happen to bump into tamaki and clair. then seeing haruhi tamaki's mouth drops in a perfect "O". What are ur thoughts on this?

[RenskeAnimeFan]

love this song!! You made the vid match at the right times with the song!!!! Really Weldone!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Glad you were able to upload it!!!

[aublus01]

this is wonderful. good job. i was in tears.

[kimychi02]

Wa.. Awesome.. *tears up*

[chellaybearxo]

i cried



[chellaybearxo]

this is fuckin amazing

[ToniXTemptress]

omg i teared up T.T



[crisk38]

See that babe next girlfriend you have just say that it won't work when you dump her. Don't tell her things to make her insecure like you did me. I mean really " My friends laugh at me for dating you," Go jump of a cliff jerk.

[viovamp16]

love this vid and the song :)

Your very good

[Mangaissuper]

i love it

it's good that you didn't give up when your computer was going mad

it became a beautifull video

[DarkMoon118]

Great video!!!!

One question....

Can you make it so I can watch on my iPod?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

PLEASE!!!! I would love that

Cause this vid is awesome and I can only watch it on my computer :(

[lotrfan8811]

I really need to stop watching this video over and over... XD I just cannot express how much I love it. It makes me feel so sad for them even though I know it didn't really happen.

I love the part when it says "where was your conscience when you were with her" You timing is amazing!!

[lotrfan8811]

Oh my gosh, this is such a sad video! It made me fall in love with the song though!

It makes Tamaki look like such a bad guy, lol. Really nice job though. :)

[prowlsgirl101]

I was about 2 cry as this was playing. My boyfriend and me broke up last year. We went out for 3 years but a few days ago he told me he only went out with me because of a bet. His friends bet him to go out with me and he did. I fell in love with him in those 3 years and then he just dumped me. he first told me that he was moving and now i know, thanks to him and his friends, that it was a bet. he broke my heart and now everyday i cry. I think of him everyday.

[Mewluver101]

Wow... I teared up a little. This is amazing <3

[Aivilo32611]

Woooooooow...........that was a really, really great video! ^_^ The timing was sooo perfect and the song was really nice too! >_< And Haruhi looked so sad....TT_TT

[HopefulOTaKu]

T-T *crying*

[KwitnacejWisni]

nice.

[luffylvr676]

ooohhh!! dont worry tamaki, i know ur to much in love with/too epic to cheat on haruhi!

[klarasjoo1]

The series with the long haired girl Which is i dont recognize it from OHSHC? And if it from an episode which?

[scarycatsscaringcats]

i'm glad you did not surrender lovelessalex... now you're not gonna be loveless hahaha^_^

by the way this vid is awesome... i know haruhi is as DENSE as hell but she sure realized that she has feelings for tono...

[kyouyarules101]

TT^TT  *crys* why?WHY?

[GaruGaru24]

grr i hate you this video had me in tears and usually i'm not too emotional you are evil and put some sort of crying magic on this video, but you did a great job

[canadiansock]

This song gives really bad advice.

[lovelierlex]

Wow, this is really good. I was surprised by how well the scenes (and even the subs!) went with the lyrics. Makes you think the show was really about Tamaki cheating on Haruhi with that other girl. And I liked the end, with Haruhi removing her wig. She's really strong ^^. I'd like to watch a remake of this without subs if you ever get the footage.

[xNightxwolfx2]

Honestly i like Haruhi's wonderland, more than Alice's. Each part has an underlying cause, whereas Alice's seemed random (in both movies the classic and remake)

[xNightxwolfx2]

I think I might prefer my bf to tell me if he cheated, but of course I really really hope he doesn't do it.

[Chill5624]

I hate to cry and this video brought back alll those painfull memories of...him...

and I couldn`t stop cryng for half an houer. I thought it was over, that I was over him...

guess I`m still hurting, but...at least thid song made me realise that. So thanks for making the video.

[mhia29176]

Sad and cute >w<

[rosered181]

That is so true, lying is better when you know how much it would hurt someone else, but i guess its better they tell you and not find out for themselves later, because then it would hurt more than it does now

[rosered181]

I guess it was a good thing you didnt give up, you did a great job, i love it :D

[mcrgerardway923]

tamaki would never do that, he's too sweet and innocent! i mean everyone in the host club is rude to him alot (in a teasing way, except haruhi at times.) yet he forgets about it! cuz he's to innocent to actually THINK about standing up for himself, let alone cheat on haruhi! i love the video though, but for some reason, even if tama-chan DID cheat on her, i don't think i would feel sorry for her...i would...feel sorry for him...(just my opinion though!) i love tama-chan with all my heart!! <3

[Kokorochan90]

Nice vid! Who's the singer? o.ô

[SinnerFlame]

stephanie mcintosh (:

[Kokorochan90]

@SinnerFlame Thanks! ^^

[Gekomyeggo]

10 seconds after my ex dumped me he told me he had cheated on me I was preatty angry, he wouldve gotten away with it if he hadnt said anything (havnt had a good relationship after that cuz of trust issues) LOVE THIS ONG

[SinnerFlame]

Same here, I'm always being cheated on. But just don't give up! Mr. Right is out there somewhere! :D

[FantasyKunoichiFairy]

This is beautiful...I actually cried when I watched it. T.T More from the song itself than from the video though.

5/5

Continue to make amvs, you're great at it.

[werewolves95]

dat was beautiful. da vid went perfectly wit da music.

[sharonneke92]

It's a really beautifull song=D<3

[KyosButterfly]

i <3 this song! and it so fits my mood right now. stupid insensitive exboyfriend! NO BODY CARES THAT U SLEPT WITH MY BFF!!!! except for me... TT-TT i care... <3

[aiyen2sanz]

love the choice of song! ^_^

[i1am1baka]

ok can any1 answer this question; Did Tamaki sleep with Eclair?

Cuz just now I realized that when she throw him on the sofa and came dangerously close to him looked kinda fishy. And then she was taking shower. So I'm just like O.o Why the fuck would she be takin shower 4 no reason???

[mcrgerardway923]

i take showers for no reason, and yeah i was like "did they just...?" but no, i dont think tamaki would be forced to do something as that. And Eclair explained why she wanted to meet Tamaki, cuz of his mother talking about him. Eclair didnt want THAT, but to listen to his playing, hear it for herself.

[NojaChan]

@i1am1baka I don't think he slept with her, not in the anime anyway. Just maybe in this vid =P

[EmmaAnime96]

@i1am1baka I dont think he did (i dont THINK) I could be wrong o.o...but thinking of how Tamaki is...I don't think he'd do that XD

[sparklesandhugs]

@i1am1baka I don't think soo...this may be personal opinion, but from the look on his face, and his reactions otherwise, I don't think he did...I have watched the series twice, and the clips are out of sequence...she is trying to seduce him, but he wants none of it ....

[inukingranfan]

@i1am1baka hopefully you watched this anime by now to know your wrong i hate that bitch LOL and yeah she took a shower for no reason

[xShinigamiOfBlood]

@i1am1baka they didnt do anything tamaki was just going along with his father being with her until he realised haruhi was more important to him and jumped off the horse and carriage to save haru who had drop down into the river

He was merely providing some enterainment in the other rom while she showered as in both clips tamaki is fully dressed Lol

[MewMewWhiteTiger]

@i1am1baka your sooo right and in the anime she was telling him to stop playing pretend with the host club cause she could give him a really family

just wait until the rest of the host club finds out XD

[animepolarbear]

@i1am1baka hehe nope tama chan (Tamaki) was just hanging out with eclair because he is enganged to her nothing happens between them ^^ though i think maybe Eclair wanted to haha hopefully this helps =}

[lydster30]

@i1am1baka :O good point haha! i think so

[akam0416]

@i1am1baka good question! now you made me think :/

[NightfuryManaphy9987]

@i1am1baka Tamaki WOULD NOT do that. Plus everyone else is Saying NO. even Funimation i think.. *PHEW* Thank God he didn't tho..

[cupcakefluff16]

@i1am1baka I don't think so because Tamaki isn't that kind of person.

[kanitalynnjohnto]

@i1am1baka No, he didn't sleep with her. She was in the shower before that scene, she pretty much tried to seduce him, but he is too good of a person to do that. I mean, think about it. Could you imagine OUR TAMAKI SEMPAI hasing teh sex?

[NikkiNak111]

love this vid and song and when TAmaki and Haruhi are in the bedroom the subtitles fit with the song very nicely done

[Ladynightstalker101]

oh! what episodes are the ones where they're on the beach and try to figure out what Haruhi's afraid of?

[Angelchild11]

The episode was 8, I'm sure.

[MissPeaceChan]

Episode 8,

Enjoy!

[TheFogIsRising]

Aww

[SydneyCiara]

thanks so much!

[SydneyCiara]

could someone one send me a message telling me who sings this i would appreciate it. Thanx ^^

[PrincessMelissa1993]

Stephanie Mcintosh ;)

[kakashiXAino]

Stephanie McIntosh

[cloudpaw]

Stephanie Mcintosh

[animeluv9]

Stephanie Mcintosh

[happybunny985]

great job!!

[kimonocat001]

lovely, nice song and good choice of clips too! 5/5

[jucailla]

I cried watching this,b ut it was because I found it after hearing the news that someone lost a battle with abuse and is no longer with us..

It's a beautiful AMV though.

[NikkiNak111]

oh i'm so sorry

[cicyi]

Any and All. :D I am a very flexible person on that part. though I do favor really everyone over Tamaki, he would be a good Foil for Haruhi. What team are you on?

[eava123]

I hate that they ended the show like that. The manga is still going on.

[cicyi]

Hopefully, that means, that just maybe they will make a second season from the rest of the manga! Ok so hopeful thinking but... :D

[eava123]

I hope so. In the manga, Tamaki just realized he loves Haruhi, but so does Hikaur, and Hikaur askes Haruhi out, even though he knows Tamaki loves her. idk what happens after.

[cicyi]

I know! And can you even wait to see Hikaru change his hair, for Koaru! sigh... they could make even a OVA and I would be happy.

[eava123]

Totally. So whose Team on you on?

[ArialKyoSohma]

Tamaki's for me... Heh...

Though I want Hikaru and Kaoru to find people too!!! Dx

[eava123]

Ha, no come on, they belong together.

[ArialKyoSohma]

xD

If I was ever a Yaoi fangirl, I do have to agree it'd be for HikaruXKaoru, and if Haruhi wasn't in the picture for Tamaki...

I'd kidnap him and he'd be my very own sexeh prince dude... xD

[cicyi]

(haha and I reply 6 months later) I am on Koaru's side all the way though I know Hika is the one who likes her more.

[eava123]

Lol, totally.

[Melly0Kissy]

it's great I love it <3

[DarkSoulKagome17]

Does anyone know where i can watch

This anime....everytime i look for it here

I always get english dub....and i just want

English sub...anyone?

Great amv btw^_^

[eava123]

Really? everytime i google it, i get english subbed, not dubbed. i want the dubbed, where can i watch the dubbed?

[lilmimi24]

thx 4 the vid!!!!!!!!!

[TeziGnome]

I Love This!!!! <3

[tenten313]

perfectly fit ^_^ 10/5 keep making more videos

[kibasmyboi]

my computer did the same thing with the AMV im working on now. dont surrender, theyll never let you forget it

[SeldomlySane]

This is such a sad song, but I really love how you fit it to the video and show. Great job!

[xxaoi]

For a computer going down, you did very good ^^

I really liked it.

I saved it on Favorite's <3

[woofumms]

this made me cry...first time i've ever done that but i though it was perfect. . this song gets to me so much!!

[LovelessAlex]

you..cried...? umm I feel guilty now. I'll make a happy video to make it up for you♥

[Tommyswriter]

T.T omg so sad but so good! Great video really enjoyed watching it!

[LovelessAlex]

Good! I'm glad you liked it!

[sasukexsakura4eva1]

This is such a sad song. Who's it by?

Great vid, btw

[LovelessAlex]

It's by Stephanie McIntosh

[sasukexsakura4eva1]

Thank you ^^

[ConfirmDeletion]

Its beautiful! Great job ;-;

[LovelessAlex]

thank you, very much!!

[pandaeggy1]

Well it is amazing.. xD

Keep up the good work ..

[lilibaby]

Nice Vid. ;3

Love the song too. Its a bit sad, but its real pretty.

[LovelessAlex]

Thanks...

I know the song is pretty sad..*sobs*

[pandaeggy1]

I Love it, sorta sad though xD

[LovelessAlex]

I know...but the song was perfect I had to...

[PinkWingedMeroko]

this is AMAZING!!! :]

i loved itt

[LovelessAlex]

Thank you very much ^^