The reason why I feel so hurt every time I see this is not because it's their goodbye, bu because she will never remember all the things they did together, all the adventures and -most importantly to me- the person she became thanks to the Doctor. It kills me.
@FHomeBrew He doesn't wipe their memories so that they know how wonderful Donna is (her mother is not always nice to her) and so that they can keep an eye out for her not remembering.
Donna is the best. Brilliant. wizard... best tem in chiswick.... SHE SAVED THE FLIPPING UNIVERSE!!!!! and she has to forget all of it.... BBC it isnt fair. Why do this tho the most love and enjoyed character in doctor who!? did u thinnk it would have been a good ending!? IT sucked because donna left.... i tryed not to bawl... but it didnt work.... Long live donna. FANS OF DONNA DONT FORGET HER EPIC MAGNIFICINCE!!!!
@xxDaniCaliforniaxx For some reason the whole concept of this brutalised me. She was the most important person, and she'll never know. So sad. Not fair.
@KAmilkshakeP This show does that to you, lol. One of my favorite scenes ever. If you watch it you will cry forever. (You totally should watch it though.)
Just curious, how/why did you come upon this if you'd never seen it?
@durkinator27 I'm not sure... I know I love David Tennant... and I love Chameleon Circuit.. OH It's because I wanted to see Catherine Tate!! She'd been on the Office last season and I wanted to see her I looked her up and this is what came up first haha
@durkinator27 I'm not sure... I know I love David Tennant... and I love Chameleon Circuit.. OH It's because I wanted to see Catherine Tate!! She'd been on the Office last season and I wanted to see her I looked her up and this is what came up first haha
Catherine Tate as Donna was amazing! I miss her and David Tennant. Best Doctor and companion ever! I don't even watch the new episodes because like reaper911ify said, they just don't compare.
The only option that he had was to let her keep his consciousness and allow it to consume her as he watched, all for the sake of having a companion...or to take that consciousness along with her memory and allow her to live and be with her family on earth. That's a hard, hard choice. Sure, it's cruel to Donna, but how about how cruel it was for the Doctor to lose his best friend? Either way he's the "bad" guy. Hey, if Wilf ain't mad neither am I.
The show should have ended here, yes i now it comes back again and again
bu the thing is that everything comes full cirlce here, everything is wraped up, our david gives us one last final damn impressive scene, and with him walking away it shows that he will always be there even though it kills him on the inside
the specials just ruined it, i mean i dont even like the new version not because of mat smith, but because of the episodes they dont compare
well i needent tell you when this was first aired on tv i was litteraly inconsolable. God i was heartbroken for poor donna and then i was going out later that night with a big red face from crying so much. funny looking back on it
I love how at 3:14, he's says 'And for one moment, one shining moment, she was the most important woman in the whole wide universe.' and her mother says 'She still is. She's my daughter!' and the Doctor snaps at her 'Then maybe you should tell her that once in a while!'
It's like - Dumbledore getting angry with the Dursleys for treating Harry so badly all those years.
good god, this is the worst ending for a companion ever... cant stop crying... everyone else got to rememeber this brilliant man even if it broke their hearts but she can never remember any of it... and then he crys which gets me going again... aww
out of all the companions who got lost, died, or left, i cried the hardest here. i think what happened was horrible. i mean, rose got trapped in an alternate universe but she got to keep her memories, martha chose to leave, but donna. she never felt special. "just donna" and finally, she becomes the savior of humanity, finally realizing she's special, and just goes right back to thinking she isn't. i thought it was cruel, for her to never know, not really. so so sad
wat is the song at :09 i love that song and its so sad this part makes me cry all the time poor danna has no say in it but she has the doctor lookin after her life that is a true friend
...I'm not crying... It's raining I tell you..!! Raining indoors, yes! T_T
onlyone1990 6 days ago
@xxDaniCaliforniaxx not rose
FireFistAse 1 week ago
Why is it that my favorite partner ever can never return? I mean, some others I would have been ok with this happening, but DONNA!?
PotterGal394 2 months ago
I think I short circuited my laptop with my teara
treyegirl 2 months ago
It's so unfair. She was the best of them.....
Co0kiex 2 months ago
donna is changed, she was such a good person with the doctor. now she`s her old self, it`s sad...
kollinn 2 months ago
Poor him.. he knows he can't be alone :(
zusjeszondernaam 2 months ago
Chameleon Circuit should write a song about this scene.
carlyndegreat 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos 2
Why do I watch such heart breaking videos! This is the 3rd goodbye I've watched at cried at each one! <3
TeenageDreeaam 3 months ago
"How long are you gonna be with me?"
"Forever" -Rose and the Doctor
"I was gonna be with you forever...." -Donna
Evanescence2603 3 months ago 4
I love her. When she said "nice to meet you".... well that killed me.
snilyshipper 4 months ago
The reason why I feel so hurt every time I see this is not because it's their goodbye, bu because she will never remember all the things they did together, all the adventures and -most importantly to me- the person she became thanks to the Doctor. It kills me.
zusjeszondernaam 4 months ago
Donna's grandad's voice when he says "Donna?" when the Doctor is holding her is heartbreaking.
masteraj57 4 months ago 2
Does anyone know the music that plays exactly after Donna barges in at 3:33 and ends when Wilfred starts talking to the Doctor outside?
I can't find it anywhere, and it's beautifully sad.
Elysianrabbit 4 months ago 2
Oh my god I was in tears at this point. I did not want my two favorite Doctor Who characters saying goodbye after all this time.
David Tennant and Catherine Tate really pulled off everything perfectly, from start to finish, I miss them both so much ;-;
Omnimegas 5 months ago
Why doesn't he wipe her parents memory too? :p
FHomeBrew 5 months ago
@FHomeBrew He doesn't wipe their memories so that they know how wonderful Donna is (her mother is not always nice to her) and so that they can keep an eye out for her not remembering.
zusjeszondernaam 2 months ago
We will never forget her while she can never remember
TheInspectorwho 5 months ago
Donna is the best. Brilliant. wizard... best tem in chiswick.... SHE SAVED THE FLIPPING UNIVERSE!!!!! and she has to forget all of it.... BBC it isnt fair. Why do this tho the most love and enjoyed character in doctor who!? did u thinnk it would have been a good ending!? IT sucked because donna left.... i tryed not to bawl... but it didnt work.... Long live donna. FANS OF DONNA DONT FORGET HER EPIC MAGNIFICINCE!!!!
PKIvysaur 5 months ago
@xxDaniCaliforniaxx For some reason the whole concept of this brutalised me. She was the most important person, and she'll never know. So sad. Not fair.
Khronnus 5 months ago
the best of times =(
voyager16 5 months ago
Gah, ugh, WHY AM I CRYING?! I'VE NEVER EVEN WATCHED THIS SHOW!
KAmilkshakeP 5 months ago
@KAmilkshakeP This show does that to you, lol. One of my favorite scenes ever. If you watch it you will cry forever. (You totally should watch it though.)
Just curious, how/why did you come upon this if you'd never seen it?
durkinator27 5 months ago
@durkinator27 I'm not sure... I know I love David Tennant... and I love Chameleon Circuit.. OH It's because I wanted to see Catherine Tate!! She'd been on the Office last season and I wanted to see her I looked her up and this is what came up first haha
KAmilkshakeP 5 months ago
@durkinator27 I'm not sure... I know I love David Tennant... and I love Chameleon Circuit.. OH It's because I wanted to see Catherine Tate!! She'd been on the Office last season and I wanted to see her I looked her up and this is what came up first haha
KAmilkshakeP 5 months ago
Shit. 'Ive never watched any Doctor Who and watching this made me cry.
KAmilkshakeP 5 months ago
she really was his best friend, which is just so much more than the romantic-type relationship he had with Rose.
alkali11 6 months ago
I think the rain was hiding his tears
yoda5740 6 months ago
ill never forget donna she was kick ass
aman19991 7 months ago 2
This was the saddest companion goodbye, my god. It's just tragic, I hated that this happened to Donna, I loved her and the Doctor.
MrsHoek 9 months ago
I feel so sorry for the guy...always losing the ppl he's closest too....
stsars13 9 months ago
Miss the days of David Tennant and Russell T Davis!
best series of all time!
UltimateTARDIS 9 months ago
1:09 Apparently Time Lords know the Vulcan mind meld... That's handy.
RenardeBlanche 9 months ago
Catherine Tate as Donna was amazing! I miss her and David Tennant. Best Doctor and companion ever! I don't even watch the new episodes because like reaper911ify said, they just don't compare.
KokoroNohii 10 months ago
@xxDaniCaliforniaxx and the doctor.
JOAfan2 10 months ago
Awww! I liked Donna!!!
SGbubblez 1 year ago
The only option that he had was to let her keep his consciousness and allow it to consume her as he watched, all for the sake of having a companion...or to take that consciousness along with her memory and allow her to live and be with her family on earth. That's a hard, hard choice. Sure, it's cruel to Donna, but how about how cruel it was for the Doctor to lose his best friend? Either way he's the "bad" guy. Hey, if Wilf ain't mad neither am I.
antwinettec 1 year ago
This had to be the hardest companion loss in the series. Every time I think of Donna, I think it'd be better if she died.
BlyssfulStorm 1 year ago 4
The show should have ended here, yes i now it comes back again and again
bu the thing is that everything comes full cirlce here, everything is wraped up, our david gives us one last final damn impressive scene, and with him walking away it shows that he will always be there even though it kills him on the inside
the specials just ruined it, i mean i dont even like the new version not because of mat smith, but because of the episodes they dont compare
reaper911ify 1 year ago
god damn mom, she fucking pissis me off,
wilf oh wilf why are you bothering with her you are so much better
this whole scene is truly depressing, but it was all the doctor can do
reaper911ify 1 year ago
well i needent tell you when this was first aired on tv i was litteraly inconsolable. God i was heartbroken for poor donna and then i was going out later that night with a big red face from crying so much. funny looking back on it
trishadonoghue 1 year ago
this made me cry so hard..
letsbehapi 1 year ago
I love how at 3:14, he's says 'And for one moment, one shining moment, she was the most important woman in the whole wide universe.' and her mother says 'She still is. She's my daughter!' and the Doctor snaps at her 'Then maybe you should tell her that once in a while!'
It's like - Dumbledore getting angry with the Dursleys for treating Harry so badly all those years.
WendyBird5131 2 years ago 2
"I'll look up at the stars and think of you"
That still wells me up everytime I watch it. I look up at the stars sometimes and think of my grandmother. Saddest scene in Doctor Who.
AdamTariq002 2 years ago 2
donna was my fav of all the companions the doctor ever had, i will miss you donna noble. i will mourn you forever or until you come back to the show
ElviraTepes 2 years ago
this is worse than the doctor and Rose parting :(
deadstarlinz 2 years ago 4
It wasnt that bad. Even though I will miss her.
Oh, SHE'S COMING BACK!!
imeemgirl 2 years ago
good god, this is the worst ending for a companion ever... cant stop crying... everyone else got to rememeber this brilliant man even if it broke their hearts but she can never remember any of it... and then he crys which gets me going again... aww
ecream0308 2 years ago
The Doctor is a bastard! This was ultimate cruelty. Man, I love this show. I've watched every episode at least 5 times over!
Iwantvoids 3 years ago
out of all the companions who got lost, died, or left, i cried the hardest here. i think what happened was horrible. i mean, rose got trapped in an alternate universe but she got to keep her memories, martha chose to leave, but donna. she never felt special. "just donna" and finally, she becomes the savior of humanity, finally realizing she's special, and just goes right back to thinking she isn't. i thought it was cruel, for her to never know, not really. so so sad
wtjs123 3 years ago 3
Donna noble .And the dr
gillhill92 3 years ago
This was so sad! The first time I saw this I was crying ;(
If this happened to Rose I would be crying much much more! Can't even bare to think about it...
cheekymonkey3np 3 years ago
wat is the song at :09 i love that song and its so sad this part makes me cry all the time poor danna has no say in it but she has the doctor lookin after her life that is a true friend
sdik2000 3 years ago 15
@sdik2000 Is it The Rueful Fate of Donna Noble? That's a sad song that's in this video.
thefartydoctor 5 months ago
@sdik2000 its called The Rueful Fate Of Donna Noble
bennie128 2 months ago
Someone PLEASE tell me that the music from this scene is available somewhere? Because no matter what, THIS will always be "Donna's Theme" to me.
samuraiko 3 years ago 2
i cried when i watched this i like the music at the beggining of this vid.
aww the doctors alone again after everyone with him in the tardis and bang alone again crowded then alone that was a sad ending
bunkatv 3 years ago
Rose tyler was great but donna noble has got to be the no 1 my god what a heart breaker for the dr alone again .
gillhill92 3 years ago
how amazing are all the goodbyes in doctor who! i will miss seein these 2 together rele cried my eyes out :'(
tomthebaggie 3 years ago
Such a brilliant ending. I always cry every time. Very well written and acted
Aidenfan2 3 years ago 2
i was sat next to the wife of 20 years hiding the odd tear it was a great ending but lets get dr donna back
gillhill92 3 years ago
omg i cried soooo much when I watched this :'(
katiebaxter 3 years ago
The better bring her bck tht's if they make anymore dr whos
niknaknonoo 3 years ago
Gosh This Is Soooo Sad =[
I Belive She Will Be Back Though....
They Always Do xxx
RoxToxvideos 3 years ago
i cry every time oh god im realy sad aint ii
niknaknonoo 3 years ago