Although, the piano sound is quite different from a harpsichord, that's besides the point. I believe technically you have the skill to execute the piece, however, the interpretation is a bit off for a baroque piece. Definitely does not sound from the period, even ignoring the fact that it is played on a piano. Listen to this one:
Search for the video: Rameau suite en G 1728 Les sauvages Christie
Again, great job, but the interpretation sounds wrong.
@adamworth1979 Hello, thank you for your comments, comments like your are very important for me. And I liked very much this video you told me, wonderful interpretation!
Muito obrigado, cara Renata. Passei anos com essa melodia na cabeca e sem saber de que era, pois a escutei uma vez na rua. Linda execucão a tua e que Deus te proteja sempre para nos brindar com música tão linda. Abracos e beijos fraternais desde Borås, Suécia.
@Guangxi56 Desculpe-me a demora! E obrigada pelos comentários, fico contente que tenha gostado do vídeo e que o mesmo tenha ajudado a descobrir o nome da música! Abraços do Brasil!
Yes, only harpsichord can sound like the bird cage being struck by an iron bar or the cats copulating onthe tin roof. I like harpsichord but It is better to play it on a piano than on a bad harpsicord. And if you have not got a harpsichord, it is better to play it on whatever than not play at all.
Although, the piano sound is quite different from a harpsichord, that's besides the point. I believe technically you have the skill to execute the piece, however, the interpretation is a bit off for a baroque piece. Definitely does not sound from the period, even ignoring the fact that it is played on a piano. Listen to this one:
Search for the video: Rameau suite en G 1728 Les sauvages Christie
Again, great job, but the interpretation sounds wrong.
adamworth1979 5 months ago
@adamworth1979 Hello, thank you for your comments, comments like your are very important for me. And I liked very much this video you told me, wonderful interpretation!
rcsica 5 months ago
great interpretation for the piano!
ladypojkfroken 6 months ago
@ladypojkfroken Thank you very much!
rcsica 5 months ago
Muito obrigado, cara Renata. Passei anos com essa melodia na cabeca e sem saber de que era, pois a escutei uma vez na rua. Linda execucão a tua e que Deus te proteja sempre para nos brindar com música tão linda. Abracos e beijos fraternais desde Borås, Suécia.
Guangxi56 6 months ago
@Guangxi56 Desculpe-me a demora! E obrigada pelos comentários, fico contente que tenha gostado do vídeo e que o mesmo tenha ajudado a descobrir o nome da música! Abraços do Brasil!
rcsica 5 months ago
Well played!! That said, i must agree with the majority here, and opine that this music sounds much better on a harpsichord.
HolyMotherofGrid 1 year ago
Great !!!!
polcup200 2 years ago
OH!!!111 i must find this notes!11
Krinkelss1 2 years ago
Yes, only harpsichord can sound like the bird cage being struck by an iron bar or the cats copulating onthe tin roof. I like harpsichord but It is better to play it on a piano than on a bad harpsicord. And if you have not got a harpsichord, it is better to play it on whatever than not play at all.
zrshwe 2 years ago
I agree with you too! :-)
rcsica 2 years ago
As do I! :D
TheClassicalKid 2 years ago
Renata Parabéns Pelo Rameau
Me senti como Luís XV em pleno palácio de Versalhes, muito bom.
gustavoractz3 3 years ago
Hahaha, você é muito gentil! Obrigada por ter assistido, Gustavo! :-)
rcsica 3 years ago
nice to see your Baroque side, Renata!
bien fait!
BernardProfitendieu 3 years ago
Thank you Bernard! I like "Les Indes galantes" very much :-)
rcsica 3 years ago
Very good playing ,Renata.Great wishes from Norway.Hans
hansm02 3 years ago
Thank you very much! It's very nice to see you here, Hans :-) Great wishes from Brazil!
rcsica 3 years ago
Beautiful playing. I loved it. Wonderful composition. Thanks:)
Mayka99 3 years ago
Thank you for your comments! :-)
rcsica 3 years ago