She is like the scottish elvis for the 2000,s. love everything about her, her attitude her voice her ability to write these songs she is sooooooooooooooo underated yet very original.
Her voice in the live performances is very annoying to me; it's pressured, coming from her throat; real shame; the studio versions are way better imho
Una muy buena cancion, y una muy buena artista! pese a que su voz en directo no es igual que la de estudio (pasa con muchisimos artistas). Su voz es particular, aún así a mi me gusta!
amy Macdonald is one of my lovely singer,she had very unique voice and also the music is difference..I love her so,so much she is so preety and charming
it isn't live...why? look the bassist ;) sometomes he isn't playing and when he plays listen to de melodir this "dumm dumm" it's fatser then he moves the fingers... an his hand for playing is like playing guitar...an NOT bass....maybe the voice is live..but i guess it's playback too...
i think she is pulling her voice down too much. i think it a little disagree with other version ive listened to and there was her voice ok and i liked that video much more. but still nice song. i like it :-)
i love her album but her voice live is much better that is her voice and to me its brilliant,i love to hear summit different and she has a truly unique voice good stuff amy !!
I can't understand. Why does she change her voice in this so bad way???? It's really a pity. I like the album, but I'm certainly not ready to go to see her in concert!
Well... I've been listening to several live performances of her and... I'm disapointed! She can't perform live! I hope she can learn it soon but for now she is very bad... and by the way, stop making stupid comparisons, she is nothing like Shakira. Shakira sings the same (studio or live) and she do it always very very well.
She really sound different live, it really make you wonder how if she is the same Amy that recorded that album version. It's a shame that she can't perform live, but you got to give her credit for trying.
Why is it so different from that recorded?I LOVE THIS SONG but i hate that in record performance her voice is amazing while in live performance her voice annoying!Inside the hall records her recorders use filters to the voice or is she?
Mi sembra una vasciaiola di Afragola quando canta live D: Ma è bravissima **
ilvecchiopoeta 5 months ago
Студийная запись намного лучше :((
poohini 7 months ago
BRILLIANT!
I found out about amy a week ago and she is now one of my fave singers!!
You go Amy!
vampolover3698 9 months ago
She is like the scottish elvis for the 2000,s. love everything about her, her attitude her voice her ability to write these songs she is sooooooooooooooo underated yet very original.
britturk123 9 months ago
Does anyone think she looks like Amy Fowler from Big Bang Theory? :P
Fcutrechtfans 10 months ago
@Fcutrechtfans Amy Fowler looks like HER!! *TABLE FLIP*
koolp3nguin 3 months ago
beutiful
galhardao11 1 year ago
that's ok
TheGiampy65 1 year ago
questa canzone piu' la sento piu' mi piace
TheGiampy65 1 year ago
amu mac donald a the boyfriend? o this is single?
BambolottoPervertito 1 year ago
I dont like her live. She sounds, like a guy, only live.
pinkuggboots1 1 year ago
o0h my god this is so good....
Thermonuklear666 1 year ago
Like this version better than CD version. I think it's the Scottish accent that is more prominent.
sebakerckhof 1 year ago
the voices yess they aree livee buttt the guitars andd the drumms anddd coross not
blinkeros182 1 year ago
this is not live... :( comercials.. .S
blinkeros182 1 year ago
@blinkeros182 IT IS LIVE, lol can't ya hear?
PollyRedHead 1 year ago
pésimo directo!!!!!
I hate this live!
miquelpradas 1 year ago
menuda mierda de directo!!!!
alex29ist 1 year ago
Her voice in the live performances is very annoying to me; it's pressured, coming from her throat; real shame; the studio versions are way better imho
kesseldorz 1 year ago 2
Maybe 'cos she's a scottish lassie and in live they can't fix her sound
Anyway, I like more her live souind than the studio fixed.
ivangorcsev88 1 year ago
@ivangorcsev88
I like her scottish accent, it's more of a singing technique issue
kesseldorz 1 year ago
super j adore
MrJacky60 1 year ago
She is great live.
People say she can't sing i don't understand i went too her concert she is way better live too me because her voice has such soul live.
BladeAndSoul 1 year ago 3
she is very preetyful but her voice sounds like a man but i am not saying it in a bad way she is my idol love amy
XcandyxmcfanX125 2 years ago 2
her voice doesnt sound to good here ,
it was well better when i went watching her in manchester
16xXamyXx16 2 years ago 3
Funny, but when i see the vid, i think of the 70es..But she has a beatyfull voice and and a karisma...
hvodenmark 2 years ago 3
the guitar player on the left is not doing anything.....even the acoustic lead is on a track.....why isn't that guy playing that part.
amy mcdonald is my favorite singer/songwriter of our time
fillmore12321 2 years ago
alles atrappe=D
venaly3 2 years ago
Amazing song, singer, and music.
jclc13 2 years ago 3
She is absolutely perfect.
Everything in Amy is fantastic
She is beatiful, her voice sounds really good and i love her smile *.*
joaodrt 2 years ago 15
@joaodrt
You love her smile? She never smiles, dude.
idelac 4 months ago
her voice is not so good here :\
it's much better in the video
בכל זאת שיר יפה :)
reema157 2 years ago 3
Comment removed
exhesham 2 years ago
מה יש לך עמי? סה"כ הבעתי דעה! אז באק אופ!
reema157 2 years ago
נכון, את צודקת! יש לה קול מכוער כאן! כמו הכלי הסקוטי הזה
exhesham 2 years ago
חח סבבה.. אז מה הבעיה?
reema157 2 years ago
her voice is so diffent in her CD Version
daniel6h 2 years ago 7
uh first time i heard her life i thought "is she doing this tone in her throat on purpose??" but now i feel like she always has this strange voice oO
70x1c 2 years ago
so do i!
rautibo 2 years ago
you obviously haven't listened to "Run" or "Dancing in the dark". Or to her interviews ^^
revilo178 2 years ago
I think it is beautiful...just 100% pure...and no fake. What about you?
thiesjaarsma 2 years ago 5
Dios santo... cuan retocada tiene que estar su voz para sonar tan diferente en directo.
Aunque con esa voz puede hacer un country genial, todo sea dicho... xDDD
MaRKeSDeGoDDeMoN 2 years ago 2
her voice is very very ugly live....
it's so different in her album version!
picturethislove 2 years ago 2
True...Why?
I think she use a lot the sinth...argh...
Queen Rocks!
XD
shinylifeforty 2 years ago
This Good Tabe :o)
MatthiasBeta1 2 years ago
se escuxa muy distinto en vivo, pero está recién comenzando!
arriba Amy MacDonald!
panxolodvg 2 years ago
recien? Has visto de cuando es el video?
jevorro 2 years ago
Me refiero a que estaba comenzando con su carrera ^^
panxolodvg 2 years ago
ejejejeje ok te todas formas ya se echaba de menos una voz diferente que ya deberiais estar hartos de escuchar musica prefabrica con voces clonicas
jevorro 2 years ago
jajaja si tienes mucha razon... hoy en dia es dificil encontrar talentos y no voces de computadora
panxolodvg 2 years ago
Naaa, no manches, buena la canción pero horrible su voz
nzentenoa 2 years ago
Una muy buena cancion, y una muy buena artista! pese a que su voz en directo no es igual que la de estudio (pasa con muchisimos artistas). Su voz es particular, aún así a mi me gusta!
arandazgz 2 years ago
cuando dice : where you gonna go, whre you gonna sleep to night si se parece al disco xDDD
Arkhantoss16 2 years ago 2
su voz es rara , pero no desafina , la voz de estudio si kcambia las cosas .. cancion bellisima!!!!
Paoluchii13 2 years ago
She is a beatiful girl but her voice is strange I don t like very much
sanduzzu 2 years ago 3
In this live her voice is different than studio version. She got a great voice, her voice is particular. But it misses something....
Rain1284 2 years ago 6
Love Here Acent!!
humpie18 2 years ago
She sings now BETTER live than this.I think so.
venaly3 2 years ago 3
e prelucrata vocea pe cd... live e praf...
grigceltandru 2 years ago
asa e . live e naspa
guitarist99john 2 years ago
Her cd must be just a result of technology,don't you think?
dnmkR 2 years ago 4
Hahah, so very true!
MckrooMagic 2 years ago 2
I really love this song, but She sounds really wierd live :P
sjokognome 2 years ago 5
She have a voice a la Shakira... But she sing nice...
wwwremarcabilro 2 years ago 3
its quite weird... her voice is much different from the CD...
godfather755 2 years ago
Yeah, I agree...
petraizzg 2 years ago
but I still love her! :D
godfather755 2 years ago 3
Hehehe :-D
petraizzg 2 years ago
shes good! :D
lauljatar15 2 years ago
are o voce de barbat:))
xzxz339 2 years ago
SUPER BON MORCEAU CONTINUE COMME CA C est comme ca que j aime la counrty
dolmaer 2 years ago
nici mie nu-mi place cum canta live...pacat
r23yan 2 years ago
it would be a nice sound as a "duo" this song
danibacila1 2 years ago
I love her accent.
csaja 2 years ago 6
she sings beatifully, I'm not surprised, everything from Scotland is beatifull!!! Respect for Amy Scotland MaCDonald from Serbia!!!!
mcteshman 2 years ago 6
i like this scottish accent xD
very good vid xD
timaeh1 3 years ago 9
hm, I thing she is scared and therefore her voice is so weird...
flertly 3 years ago
this is scotish accent
tujeslovenija 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
but she sounds like a man...
Storm1337 2 years ago
amy Macdonald is one of my lovely singer,she had very unique voice and also the music is difference..I love her so,so much she is so preety and charming
mikeztoni 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
tragedia xF
marekkubista 3 years ago
i think the music is playback but she sings live. am i right? it sounds like the studio version but the vocals are different.
antinameplus123 3 years ago 19
jumbo sorry lol
redspecialguy 3 years ago 2
i want that jimbo accoustic shes got
redspecialguy 3 years ago
Cute sexy head, deep voice; Amy turns it into a beautiful contradiction!
KingdomUploader 3 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she is singing really bad live like a man
but still I like this song
cris7nando9 3 years ago
it isn't live...why? look the bassist ;) sometomes he isn't playing and when he plays listen to de melodir this "dumm dumm" it's fatser then he moves the fingers... an his hand for playing is like playing guitar...an NOT bass....maybe the voice is live..but i guess it's playback too...
dogilux 3 years ago
ahh no?
the bassist is rigth and the guitar is left.
This song is good and LIVE!
Zwieback95 3 years ago
in this version she has deeper voice than in the original :) i think it's better :)
Messiplayer 3 years ago 7
you are lucky
earthgk2222 3 years ago
She is merried with a British footballer! That's the reason why she have write her song:"The Footballers Wife" Brainy!!
milanmezelf 3 years ago
no, that's not the reason. and they are only engaged, as far as I know.
revilo178 3 years ago 4
is she single?
Skopex 3 years ago
Nope, she's engaged
Huggles
Vhari x
Vhazza 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Amy's Stimme ist einfach der Knaller !
Sie hört sich Live noch tausend mal besser an als auf CD.
Ihre raue , dunkle Stimme mit dem schottischen Akzent ist einfach göttlich !
Ich könnte Ihr stundenlang zuhören.
Amy , ich liebe Dich !
Explorer1964 3 years ago 3
she is one of the most beautiful singers.a son is really great
nejc555 3 years ago
mai bine nu canta live...
sss3xs92 3 years ago
she sings soo differently when she sings live its amazing how different it is to her 'cover accent'
TheOneAndOnlyMe92 3 years ago
She sings a bit to "fat" here :p Too much accent xD
DVSKE007 3 years ago
She's always singing fat ;) :D
hamersakm 3 years ago 4
Yeah xD
That what's make here a real WOMAN :D
But she's a bit "fatter" here ...
In tone I mean :p
Just compare, you will see ...
But still good .. <3
Like TheOneAndOnlyMe92 says, just like :p
DVSKE007 3 years ago
Disguasting accent, the original audio record sounds much better
cony2007yahoocom 3 years ago
i think she is pulling her voice down too much. i think it a little disagree with other version ive listened to and there was her voice ok and i liked that video much more. but still nice song. i like it :-)
stuchly1 3 years ago
this is the life...a song which makes you really happy when you listen to it, amy you are the best...and the most beautiful!!
george20gtc 3 years ago 3
Ah crap, I'm in love.
BartWux 3 years ago 4
this suks....on the record it's much beter!
en btw: where are you gonna sleep tonight??? XD
FckinHungry 3 years ago
she is beautiful
mikulasod 3 years ago 4
beautiful
dechko18 3 years ago
sounds weird...tanight xD
boarding4ever 3 years ago 2
Scottish must be the best English accent there is :D
RhINO4711 3 years ago
i prefer irish hehehe
LanDuul 3 years ago
this isnt live,,, the only live thing in this vid are the vocals,,
benhemoth184 3 years ago 5
So much better live. :]
SamAG99 3 years ago
i don't like this song live. it sounds better on record.
prchyyy 3 years ago
perfect:)
krowmanik 3 years ago
she doesnt sounds like on the record. It sounds weard i think. "/
SimonMathewOla 3 years ago 4
Отличная песня... скачал...спасибо !
kot39region 3 years ago
I really like her live version.Just love that accent.Her voice is huskier and deeper live but thats the real gal.Love her.
habdon 3 years ago
idiots you have no idea of music...she is fantastic
alexkazabou 3 years ago
hard vise
1keyblade1 3 years ago
je to hezka pisnicka ale amy je hezci
xXxJaraaxXx 3 years ago 2
jo jo to mas teda pravdu :D
Delwindar 3 years ago
ze maakt haar stem heel zwaar:s
marleosjuh 3 years ago
vind ik nou ook ;p
ChielOttinkFanx 3 years ago
i love her album but her voice live is much better that is her voice and to me its brilliant,i love to hear summit different and she has a truly unique voice good stuff amy !!
cleckioli 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
live she can´t sing..it sounds really terrible...the voice is really like a man...a pity....-.-
131cinemabizarre131 3 years ago
I can't understand. Why does she change her voice in this so bad way???? It's really a pity. I like the album, but I'm certainly not ready to go to see her in concert!
feuille73 3 years ago
Well... I've been listening to several live performances of her and... I'm disapointed! She can't perform live! I hope she can learn it soon but for now she is very bad... and by the way, stop making stupid comparisons, she is nothing like Shakira. Shakira sings the same (studio or live) and she do it always very very well.
shaisameri 3 years ago
She really sound different live, it really make you wonder how if she is the same Amy that recorded that album version. It's a shame that she can't perform live, but you got to give her credit for trying.
amenhotep77 3 years ago
she's so much better live :)
Mandieh 3 years ago 2
Why is it so different from that recorded?I LOVE THIS SONG but i hate that in record performance her voice is amazing while in live performance her voice annoying!Inside the hall records her recorders use filters to the voice or is she?
Lilly904ever 3 years ago
Because when she sings live, she uses her real voice rather than removing her accent. Personally, I like her better live.
SamAG99 3 years ago 3
Ok!!She is however great!
Lilly904ever 3 years ago
i think live she sounds a little bit like shakira
xxhajoxx 3 years ago 2
Her live voice is like another person singing, but I like both her studio and live songs. :)
relicen1 3 years ago
To be honest watching her live on TV has nothing on seeing and hearing her live :)
Huggles
Vhari x
Vhazza 3 years ago
see scares me.
xshx19 3 years ago
Love her eyes and her smile so beautiful! :D
Lightgiverss 3 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I hate her live songs normal track is much better!
pindafreak 3 years ago
I find her live songs soooo much better. I love hearing her real singing voice.
SamAG99 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
the version from the cd is better..she had such a dark and down voice...XD
19Todesengel91 3 years ago
Love this song,
we made our own version,
hope you like it!
cheers
No ANgry Young Man
NoAngryYoungMan 3 years ago
I like this song so much
see her smile on 2:27 great!
DutchFootball 3 years ago 11
amazing chick.. i usually listen to rock/punk music (and jack johnson), but this is freaking amazing.. well done my girl
samueloji 3 years ago 8
I wish she'd sing like this for her CDs.
SamAG99 3 years ago 5
This is the onli song from Amy that I like bt im not sure wen she sings it live, she sounds a bit wierd !!
Brettacul 3 years ago 2
Incredible how much stronger her accent is live than on the disk. Very Dolores O Reardon though.
davidzof 4 years ago 7
amy rock! her music is brill!
xxangelpeoplexx 4 years ago 9
Love her!! :)
mackic42 4 years ago 6