whenever the nations are caught in turmoil such as 1943-45 the jews attempt some massive hoax. William Dudley Pelley published "The 45 Questions Most Frequently Asked About the Jews" in 1939 which footnoted the 8 million european jews who were moved to America from 1932 thru 1939. Another 1.2 million jews were moved to Palestine from 1934 thru 1939. When the USSR archives were finally unsealed in 1991 it was revealed that the Soviets only knew of 76,000 jewish deaths which resulted during WW2.
There should be another Anschluss now, imagine how much more powerful and prosperous Greater Germany could be economically etc. Same people so why not?
So um mal was loszuwerden. Ich bin 3/4 Deutscher und 1/4 Österreicher. Und man sagt immer die Österreicher sind freiwillig an Deutsche Reich angeschlossen worden. Mein Uropa(Österreicher) der Pfarrer war und gegen die Nazis predigte und später beinahe ins KZ kam hat auch für den Anschluss gestimmt. Wieso? Erstens: Man hatte keine andere Wahl(SA). Und Armut war groß. Wieso haben auch 99% dafür gestimmt wenn min. 3% Juden waren. Macht euch darüber mal Gedanken.(Austria had no chance -> SA)
Germany now is a liberal democratic federation so Austria will become a member state of the Federation during the next decade, and without any problem. In fact, German liberals supported the Reunification of Austria into a German Federation. Currenty Germany and Austria have the same currency, the same language and the same borders so Reunification is just a political decission which will take place during the next decade.
"Germany now is a liberal democratic federation so Austria will become a member state of the Federation during the next decade,"
NO WAY!!!!!!!!!! We are neighbours, and speak the same language but are two independant countries,and we WANT !!!!! to remain like this, just because Austria joint Germany during the war does not mean that we want to be united with them. NOT AT ALL!!!!
They are our neighbours, but no more, it is like suggesting to unit the US and Canada!!!
well we do have more in common other than the language (o: (even I admit this (o: ), but I just feel like you that it is good to be good neighbours and learn to get on really well with each other, but to unify as they so obviously think we should do goes toooooo far, it was tried out once, we al know the consequences, and it will not happen again.
Peaceful greetings to my dear neighbouring country (o:
Well austria and germany have mor in common then just the same language. some hundred years ago AUSTRIA was the LEADER of GERMANY. Austrians are just germans like Saxonys bavarians and any other german state. The only reason why austria isnt leading germany today is Prussia won a war agains austria and kicked them out of germany.
did you read my message, I said that we have more in common than just the language and like you I was refering to the holy german empire,but even so we had our own empire at the same time, and this was one of many nationalities, we are for sure a germanic counry but for sure with a much bigger part of a slavic influence (which I love to have!)I am very happy for Prussia having "kicked us out" because I trully love to be independant from Germany, they are neighbours but not my people
@SiggyStern that does not make sense... the modern austria is 1:1 "Deutschösterreich" plus Burgenland. The percentage of slavic blood is much higher in "Prussia" then in austria.
When you talk about the territory than yes I agree with you,but I was talking about those centuries before WW1 ended the monarchical times, where we also had slavic nowadays nations in our monarchy time and events change boarders and I just want to state that I see myself as Austrian (full stop) Germany is my neighbouring country which I respect like all my other neighbouring countries,but I do not feel a close bond to them,nor will I ever see myself as German ,for I am not
oh ok. Then we talk about different things. I was talking about the austrians as such, not about the double monarchy and the lands they ruled. I didn't know you are a monarchist of the KK. But the K.K was a multi-cultural Kingdom, in which the Austrians were fully calling themself Germans. (Every austrian with german name is decendant of a german settler. I hope you don't deny our history as such) and there was a big racism against non-germans in the KK. thats why it was also called
@000000AEA000000 "Völkergefängniss" (prison of races). Because it did not work, and gladly the people got freed from Austrian tyranny of foreign-regency after the (Austrian started) world war 1.
I agree with you,there was no equality between the different parts of the monarchy...and when efforts were made it was far too late, nationalism and the wish to be independant was already too strong.....about Austria starting the war (we were for sure the trigger that started WW1) but I would very much also say that the situation of Europe before that =say from the 2nd part of the 19th century, with huge conflicts about colonis,wars such as that of France and "Germany",
= I talked about the war between France and Germany (1870-71)...and the many conflicts that the colonial countries had with each other for gaining even more territory and influence......all this very much also made that the international climate was very much loaded with tensions, and than of course there is the many treaties that bonded so many countries together,so when one delclaring war,all the others had to follow, the ultimatum was made in a way that war happened..
2) the military was faster than the diplomates....tomorrow is the day where WW1 ended.........it happened a long time ago,but the things that were put in motion through that had such a long lasting effect....it always stunns me......
and the arms built up of several countries did their bit too......but I do agree that the spark was lit from my country.....that is one side (historical part) the other part that I seperate is that I just say that I am Austrian and do not feel German, I say so because several people here say they feel like that......this is not something that one has to discuss about ,for we all have our opinions and will stick to them,but about history we can talk,
@SiggyStern then you are a product of anti-germanism, and you have to ask yourself, if you might maybe be only a product of your times, and if your ancestors maybe thought different. Modern Austria is a very new state, since 1945 you are an independant country now, the past is; that is to say: German history. The new-generation of austrians got a feeling of being something 'unique' by the political changes after the world war, and it is an absolute new phenomenon.
=I am not anti-German ,but pro Austrian if you want to call it this way, I was born in Austria and when I am on a mountain of my country and look down I say I am at home, this is where I belong, when I go to Germany than I feel I am in a neighbouring country that I like but I do not FEEL a bond more than that........can you just accept that it is like that, I am sure we will not come closer than that.....the German and the Austrian history have always been entwined,
2)and we still are (as we are neighbours),but please just accept that I feel within as I do, you are entitled to your opinon,but so am I.......Austria is my heart and my home......
@SiggyStern you talked about colonization only, not french-german wars.
And of course I accept your point of view. Its just YOURS. And it does not have to be historical truth. I told you I accept it, and I said: "you are free to feel as whatever you want"
PS: Pro-austrian does not expell pro-german, and you can find mountains in bavaria aswell. Its a bit simple-minded to bind a nations history arround mountains.
@000000AEA000000 Austria is my heart and my identity aswell. But like it is now, it is a lie. Lets be honest; the difference between Austria and Germany is, that one was forced to look at its own history, and the other one sneaked away to do not have to pay. And of course many Austrians are not seeing themself as germans anymore, because that would mean to be seen in hatred of everybody. (even though much might be propaganda) Truth got sacrificed for comfort.
"you talked about colonization only, not french-german wars"
=read what I have written, than you will see that I talked about several facts that made WW1 that more likely to happen, both wars between countries such as France and Germany but also the many in the colonies, I do not try to interprete what you are saying how it suites me and I would like you to do the same!..Yes it is my opinion,and that of many others...it took a long time for Austria to accept it´s new form
but in the now we have....you are living in the past,and I live in the present...if you are Austrian and still feel German, do you feel at home in Austria,or do you feel you need to live in Germany to feel THAT much more German than the Germans themselves?? I know where I am at home,and what is being sung in "I am from Austria is what I feel within, do not try to make it seem as if I am standing alone with feeling Austrian if I am a born Austrian, the only ones that are still
dreaming of joining to me are those who are living in the past......Ostarichii (realm to the east) =boarder to the east......it is rubbish to say that we say that we are Austrians,because we do not want to be hated as Germans???? You have a strange way of looking at things! I for one say that I am Austrian because I am!! nothing more or less!
@SiggyStern if it is only about history: austrians are, and have always been german.
If it is what you feel... you are free to feel what you want to be.
I find it awesome that there are still many, that feel somehow "german", as I have seen some of the history lessons that are tought in austria on behalf of the "german" topic, the allied indoctrination was also strong. And then all the hollywood movies, and winner propaganda. Those people seem to have a strong soul that looks behind things.
Austrians have always been German speakers and linked to the Germans via the many things that they have shared through history,this is not something that I would say is untrue,for I know it is......but it has nothing to do with indoctrination that the highest percentage of Austrians in the nowadays really do feel Austrians, but with a getting used to having been reduced from a big monarchy to a very small unimportant country in central Europe
I do not know why you say this,I give you my opinon,and all you can say is that Ì did not think much ?? How so (by the way as you have asked me,my family background is entirely Austrian for as long as I can trace my family history).......so I am now waiting for you to tell me what made you state what you just have....
@SiggyStern I just suddenly gained the strong impression that you didn't think much, because you did just partly repeat already clearified, partially sound very simple-minded, aswell as very impulsive out of reason. If you want to argue, then please bring arguments. Don't repeat your own opinion over and over again. You should not post in a history video, if you are not interested in history of your country. I think the past of Austria is very clear, but maybe your sources are better?
Well obviously you did not get what I wrote to you in our own mother tongue,I am a historian and well aware and much interested in the history of my country,so please do not make yourself a fool to say what you have just said,if you say that I repeat myself over and over again,than you need to ask yourself why this is so because blantly I am only replying to all those posts that you have written here.....(get the hint?)....it is very funny that you tell me that I am
(possibly) the one who is interested in an arguement,for all those that I usually talk to (and those are many) would tell you that I am usually very much the contrary, but if somebody tells me that I have to feel this or that way and should I say I do not ,you tell me this is about politics??..than I do get a bit pissed off.....I know when it is time to talk and when it is time to leave there is not going to be anything to gain with talking to you.
@SiggyStern I dont get you... a post was a direct answer to your old ones, the other ones werent for you... glasses? And on the rest. Ok Siggy darling. I am the King of China btw... you get it... its a tiiiiny bit silly ol' boy.
@SiggyStern nette Zitate host in deinem Kanal... So ein Austro-Patriot sogt er ist ein "Weltbürger", "All World is my Country", alle Menschen gleichermaßen seine Brüder, aber sogt er is nur in Österreich dahoam? Fuikoffa nennans sowas, wo I herkim
;-). Ist ja a echt a schens Land wo I herkumm, aber G'schicht solltatst auch lesen tun, ned nur 'Bergsteign und Wurst'.
Wea von uns is da Voikoffa? Du oda i?? I bin a Wüdbuaga,oba I was a wo mei Heimat is!!!.....Die Wüd is mei Land,aber mei Heimat is mei Wurzel!.....
Und über Gschichte wissn oda ned´, es is vielleicht on da Zeit dia zu sogn,das I Gschichte studiert hob und mia deshoib "onmaß" zwissen wovon i red....
A echta Patriot. Dei Heimat, deine Wurzeln, aber oan auf Gutmensch mochn im Öffentlichen... Du warst scho kreht gwen für de oide Zeit, Und sowos ois G'schichtsstudent. Samma uns ehrlich: des beisst si a wengal.
Mal ganz sachlich... "Alter"... glaub ma uns beide nich so recht, oda?
@SiggyStern Oida oida oida... hallo? verstehst koan spaß? A echter Patriot aber so unhumorig? Mochs da scheh und geh wieda schloffn. Un Gutsch numoi, wei's so oibern is. Küss die Hand.
Das war so eine freche Antwort (oibern und K d H),dass es mich doch einen Lacher gekostet hat es zu lesen......
Wir haben uns echt nicht "verstanden" (vielleicht einfach aneinander vorbeigesprochen)......aber Du hast mich Nerven gekostet (echt!).....naja wieder was dazugelernt........
@SiggyStern Okay die Antwort überrascht mich jetzt. Ich hab dich auch ziemlich provoziert... nichts für Ungut... Ich finde diese "Schnitzelpatrioten" Schiene nur albern. Österreich hatten die höchste NSDAP Wählerquote im ganzen Reich, und jetzt macht man einen auf undeutsch, das ist undankbar, und wäre nicht passiert, wenn der Krieg anders verlaufen wäre. Ich wünsch dir auch ernsthaft alles gute, von ganzem Herzen; sorry für die Harten Worte.
Ohhhhh scheiße!!! Wir überschneiden uns und jetzt habe ich erst gesehen,dass Du doch freundlich geschrieben hast (tut mir leid für meine letzte Mail )o:) ich weiß,dass wir Österreich den Anschluß mehrheitlich wollten (aus der damaligen Situation heraus sehr verständlich)......Danke,dass Du das letzte mail freundlich geschrieben hast, Du hast es vermutlich nicht mitbekommen,ich bin kein "Oida" sondern eine "Oide"....und ich bin so harte Worte nicht gewohnt....
@SiggyStern Keine Überschneidung, hab gewartet, bis deine Antwort kam. (bin halt Galant) Ich glaub' wir meinen so ziemlich das gleiche, als Mann ist man denk' ich nur Territorialer, und vielleicht etwas anders unterwegs.
Ganz, ganz liebe und aufrichtige Grüße. Und nichts für ungut;-)
lass mas bei am Patt, damit koana sog'n kunn es war a Gschlechterk(r)ampf.
Ich danke Dir auch noch einmal dafür,dass unser Gespräch so ausgegangen ist.....es hat mir wirklich weh getan,wie Du mit mir gesprochen hast,aber jetzt hast Du ein Pflaster auf die Wunde getan.........wo ich zuerst total traurig war, lache ich wieder.......ein Patt ist fair (o:
Ebenfalls ganz liebe Grüsse und ich habe wieder was dazu gelernt (im Positiven!)
@SiggyStern Na Sicha Voikoffa, Du host sogoar " ' " Flügerl am 'un Gutsch'. A Österreicher bist jednvois ned, so unlustig wia du bist. Du host gschriebn Slawen... do bist so stoiz drauf, dann wiss mas scho herr Kubbich.
=weil ich einen Fehler gemacht habe, bin ich kein Österreich (sehr witzig) Ich spreche 5 Sprachen und Polnisch ist die,die ich gerade dazu lerne,vermutlich ist es mir da hineingerutscht, (ooooh wie schrecklich).....ich dachte mit Dir kann man vielleicht doch noch vernünftig reden,aber das scheint nicht der Fall zu sein,naja in 2 Jahren YT mußte ich ja irgendwann einmal auch solchen Wapplern über den Weg laufen......
Ich würde mich freuen,dass wir uns nach diesen (für mich sehr ungewöhnlich harten "Kampf") in Frieden und in Ehren trennen können. Ich bin dazu bereit.....
Alles Gute (und ich hoffe es gibt jetzt keine blöde "Überschneidung"mehr!!
I am not a monarchist by the way, I am just very much interested in history......
Greetings
Siggy
PS: I would say The Austrian and later Austrian - Hungarian monarchy was for sure not the only one where people of different nationalities felt not equally treated....look at how others treated the people of their colonies, or foreign parts of their own territory (for example the Polish in the German part of the Partition....) or the Russians.(just an example)
@Lolerdan that is correct. now it is an independent country but actually they are nothing others like bavarians, saxony´s etc.
...and as you can see the mass of people appreciate the "Wiederanschluss".
but actually it doesn´t matter today as we have a united europe. so just beleive in your history and don´t deny it, even it is easier like most countries do.
@Lolerdan not only one time... The most frequent holy roman empirers' of german Nations Kaisers' over the time, were Austrians. Much more often as from any other germanic country, and the 'Capital' was Vienna.
Des hob i oafach loswern missn ;-)
BTW: the name Austria comes from the old german Austar, which means "in the east(of something)", that cant mean europe, because my home is exactly in the heart of it :-D. It goes back to the first south-german Kaisers.
@zacub thats true, but austria would also have had to pay huge reparations, thats why they turned their back on the ones that jumped in to help their brothers(Germany joined Austria-Hungary in World war 1, because the Germans stuck to their agreements, just like germans fought on all fronts of their allies in ww2, even finland) and after WW2, they got left.
I am Austrian btw, my Family originates from "Wiener Neustadt" and near Salzburg, but iam not a denier and want to hold the truth up.
A friend of mine who is a historian made here phd about the military correspondance between the German and Austrian military organisations, she was rather astonished to what great extent the Germans were encouraging the Austrians to go ahead for they would stand on our side.....I do not see that Germany was only becoming an ally because they were in alliance with us,but also because while for us it was about Serbia (and the conflict with Russia about the Balkan) they
fuk german & austria u little shitz
dzwonik 1 year ago
@dzwonik woo. fuck you too. And fuck the history of your land. And give back Ireland, you boat-germanic pig.
Servus.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
"Hitler filled me with the enthusiasms of life." -- Albert Speer, 'Inside The Third Reich'
TookUpTheCause 1 year ago
whenever the nations are caught in turmoil such as 1943-45 the jews attempt some massive hoax. William Dudley Pelley published "The 45 Questions Most Frequently Asked About the Jews" in 1939 which footnoted the 8 million european jews who were moved to America from 1932 thru 1939. Another 1.2 million jews were moved to Palestine from 1934 thru 1939. When the USSR archives were finally unsealed in 1991 it was revealed that the Soviets only knew of 76,000 jewish deaths which resulted during WW2.
MaxSpaTemp103 1 year ago 2
There should be another Anschluss now, imagine how much more powerful and prosperous Greater Germany could be economically etc. Same people so why not?
ancestoralmemory 1 year ago 2
Hardly a mention of the Heimwehr, Engelbert Dollfuss or his murder by Austrian Nazis. Lame.
kenaz888 1 year ago
Come on now fine people of Austrian,don't deny your proud German heritage,come to us. Wir gehoeren zusammen. Fur immer.
gunninlinguist 1 year ago
So um mal was loszuwerden. Ich bin 3/4 Deutscher und 1/4 Österreicher. Und man sagt immer die Österreicher sind freiwillig an Deutsche Reich angeschlossen worden. Mein Uropa(Österreicher) der Pfarrer war und gegen die Nazis predigte und später beinahe ins KZ kam hat auch für den Anschluss gestimmt. Wieso? Erstens: Man hatte keine andere Wahl(SA). Und Armut war groß. Wieso haben auch 99% dafür gestimmt wenn min. 3% Juden waren. Macht euch darüber mal Gedanken.(Austria had no chance -> SA)
ThePornowatcher 2 years ago
Oesterreich ist Deutschland und wir gehoerren zusammen!!!!
88Loki14 2 years ago 10
Österreich ist Österreich und bleibt frei, bis in Alle Ewigkeit!
Bombur86 2 years ago
@88Loki14: naja ich weiß ja nicht... ist schon gut dass das zwei Länder sind... weil so Leute wie Hitler könnt ihr ruhig in Österreich behalten (-:
Supenmanu 1 year ago
Comment removed
StellandBlood 2 years ago
Comment removed
SiggyStern 2 years ago
HAHAHAHAHA we#ve got like 100 of ur nukes... gg no re sam
Volrath6161 2 years ago
Germany now is a liberal democratic federation so Austria will become a member state of the Federation during the next decade, and without any problem. In fact, German liberals supported the Reunification of Austria into a German Federation. Currenty Germany and Austria have the same currency, the same language and the same borders so Reunification is just a political decission which will take place during the next decade.
trokoro 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Democratic... you are jokeing
Aimbob92 2 years ago
trokoro,
"Germany now is a liberal democratic federation so Austria will become a member state of the Federation during the next decade,"
NO WAY!!!!!!!!!! We are neighbours, and speak the same language but are two independant countries,and we WANT !!!!! to remain like this, just because Austria joint Germany during the war does not mean that we want to be united with them. NOT AT ALL!!!!
They are our neighbours, but no more, it is like suggesting to unit the US and Canada!!!
Austrian Siggy
SiggyStern 2 years ago
Dear Siggy! You are absolutely right! Germany and Austria do not have much in common besides the same language! Only Nazis want a union!
Beuterich 2 years ago
Beuterich,
well we do have more in common other than the language (o: (even I admit this (o: ), but I just feel like you that it is good to be good neighbours and learn to get on really well with each other, but to unify as they so obviously think we should do goes toooooo far, it was tried out once, we al know the consequences, and it will not happen again.
Peaceful greetings to my dear neighbouring country (o:
Siggy
SiggyStern 2 years ago
Well austria and germany have mor in common then just the same language. some hundred years ago AUSTRIA was the LEADER of GERMANY. Austrians are just germans like Saxonys bavarians and any other german state. The only reason why austria isnt leading germany today is Prussia won a war agains austria and kicked them out of germany.
Lolerdan 2 years ago 15
Lolerdan,
did you read my message, I said that we have more in common than just the language and like you I was refering to the holy german empire,but even so we had our own empire at the same time, and this was one of many nationalities, we are for sure a germanic counry but for sure with a much bigger part of a slavic influence (which I love to have!)I am very happy for Prussia having "kicked us out" because I trully love to be independant from Germany, they are neighbours but not my people
SiggyStern 2 years ago
@SiggyStern that does not make sense... the modern austria is 1:1 "Deutschösterreich" plus Burgenland. The percentage of slavic blood is much higher in "Prussia" then in austria.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
When you talk about the territory than yes I agree with you,but I was talking about those centuries before WW1 ended the monarchical times, where we also had slavic nowadays nations in our monarchy time and events change boarders and I just want to state that I see myself as Austrian (full stop) Germany is my neighbouring country which I respect like all my other neighbouring countries,but I do not feel a close bond to them,nor will I ever see myself as German ,for I am not
SiggyStern 1 year ago
oh ok. Then we talk about different things. I was talking about the austrians as such, not about the double monarchy and the lands they ruled. I didn't know you are a monarchist of the KK. But the K.K was a multi-cultural Kingdom, in which the Austrians were fully calling themself Germans. (Every austrian with german name is decendant of a german settler. I hope you don't deny our history as such) and there was a big racism against non-germans in the KK. thats why it was also called
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000 "Völkergefängniss" (prison of races). Because it did not work, and gladly the people got freed from Austrian tyranny of foreign-regency after the (Austrian started) world war 1.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
I agree with you,there was no equality between the different parts of the monarchy...and when efforts were made it was far too late, nationalism and the wish to be independant was already too strong.....about Austria starting the war (we were for sure the trigger that started WW1) but I would very much also say that the situation of Europe before that =say from the 2nd part of the 19th century, with huge conflicts about colonis,wars such as that of France and "Germany",
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern pardon, I dont get the second part of your post?
What about colonisation of france and germany?
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
= I talked about the war between France and Germany (1870-71)...and the many conflicts that the colonial countries had with each other for gaining even more territory and influence......all this very much also made that the international climate was very much loaded with tensions, and than of course there is the many treaties that bonded so many countries together,so when one delclaring war,all the others had to follow, the ultimatum was made in a way that war happened..
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
2) the military was faster than the diplomates....tomorrow is the day where WW1 ended.........it happened a long time ago,but the things that were put in motion through that had such a long lasting effect....it always stunns me......
Friendly greetings
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
2)
and the arms built up of several countries did their bit too......but I do agree that the spark was lit from my country.....that is one side (historical part) the other part that I seperate is that I just say that I am Austrian and do not feel German, I say so because several people here say they feel like that......this is not something that one has to discuss about ,for we all have our opinions and will stick to them,but about history we can talk,
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern then you are a product of anti-germanism, and you have to ask yourself, if you might maybe be only a product of your times, and if your ancestors maybe thought different. Modern Austria is a very new state, since 1945 you are an independant country now, the past is; that is to say: German history. The new-generation of austrians got a feeling of being something 'unique' by the political changes after the world war, and it is an absolute new phenomenon.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
=I am not anti-German ,but pro Austrian if you want to call it this way, I was born in Austria and when I am on a mountain of my country and look down I say I am at home, this is where I belong, when I go to Germany than I feel I am in a neighbouring country that I like but I do not FEEL a bond more than that........can you just accept that it is like that, I am sure we will not come closer than that.....the German and the Austrian history have always been entwined,
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern
2)and we still are (as we are neighbours),but please just accept that I feel within as I do, you are entitled to your opinon,but so am I.......Austria is my heart and my home......
Friendly greetings again
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern you talked about colonization only, not french-german wars.
And of course I accept your point of view. Its just YOURS. And it does not have to be historical truth. I told you I accept it, and I said: "you are free to feel as whatever you want"
PS: Pro-austrian does not expell pro-german, and you can find mountains in bavaria aswell. Its a bit simple-minded to bind a nations history arround mountains.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000 Austria is my heart and my identity aswell. But like it is now, it is a lie. Lets be honest; the difference between Austria and Germany is, that one was forced to look at its own history, and the other one sneaked away to do not have to pay. And of course many Austrians are not seeing themself as germans anymore, because that would mean to be seen in hatred of everybody. (even though much might be propaganda) Truth got sacrificed for comfort.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
"you talked about colonization only, not french-german wars"
=read what I have written, than you will see that I talked about several facts that made WW1 that more likely to happen, both wars between countries such as France and Germany but also the many in the colonies, I do not try to interprete what you are saying how it suites me and I would like you to do the same!..Yes it is my opinion,and that of many others...it took a long time for Austria to accept it´s new form
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern
2)
but in the now we have....you are living in the past,and I live in the present...if you are Austrian and still feel German, do you feel at home in Austria,or do you feel you need to live in Germany to feel THAT much more German than the Germans themselves?? I know where I am at home,and what is being sung in "I am from Austria is what I feel within, do not try to make it seem as if I am standing alone with feeling Austrian if I am a born Austrian, the only ones that are still
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern
3)
dreaming of joining to me are those who are living in the past......Ostarichii (realm to the east) =boarder to the east......it is rubbish to say that we say that we are Austrians,because we do not want to be hated as Germans???? You have a strange way of looking at things! I for one say that I am Austrian because I am!! nothing more or less!
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern if it is only about history: austrians are, and have always been german.
If it is what you feel... you are free to feel what you want to be.
I find it awesome that there are still many, that feel somehow "german", as I have seen some of the history lessons that are tought in austria on behalf of the "german" topic, the allied indoctrination was also strong. And then all the hollywood movies, and winner propaganda. Those people seem to have a strong soul that looks behind things.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Austrians have always been German speakers and linked to the Germans via the many things that they have shared through history,this is not something that I would say is untrue,for I know it is......but it has nothing to do with indoctrination that the highest percentage of Austrians in the nowadays really do feel Austrians, but with a getting used to having been reduced from a big monarchy to a very small unimportant country in central Europe
I am from Austria!!!!
SiggyStern 1 year ago
Comment removed
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@SiggyStern now that I read it again... you didn't think much about this, did you?
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
I do not know why you say this,I give you my opinon,and all you can say is that Ì did not think much ?? How so (by the way as you have asked me,my family background is entirely Austrian for as long as I can trace my family history).......so I am now waiting for you to tell me what made you state what you just have....
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern I just suddenly gained the strong impression that you didn't think much, because you did just partly repeat already clearified, partially sound very simple-minded, aswell as very impulsive out of reason. If you want to argue, then please bring arguments. Don't repeat your own opinion over and over again. You should not post in a history video, if you are not interested in history of your country. I think the past of Austria is very clear, but maybe your sources are better?
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Well obviously you did not get what I wrote to you in our own mother tongue,I am a historian and well aware and much interested in the history of my country,so please do not make yourself a fool to say what you have just said,if you say that I repeat myself over and over again,than you need to ask yourself why this is so because blantly I am only replying to all those posts that you have written here.....(get the hint?)....it is very funny that you tell me that I am
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern
(possibly) the one who is interested in an arguement,for all those that I usually talk to (and those are many) would tell you that I am usually very much the contrary, but if somebody tells me that I have to feel this or that way and should I say I do not ,you tell me this is about politics??..than I do get a bit pissed off.....I know when it is time to talk and when it is time to leave there is not going to be anything to gain with talking to you.
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern I dont get you... a post was a direct answer to your old ones, the other ones werent for you... glasses? And on the rest. Ok Siggy darling. I am the King of China btw... you get it... its a tiiiiny bit silly ol' boy.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@SiggyStern
3)
I do not like vicious circles, it is a wast of time, ......I wish you a good life,but that´s about all I have to say to you before I leave.......
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern nette Zitate host in deinem Kanal... So ein Austro-Patriot sogt er ist ein "Weltbürger", "All World is my Country", alle Menschen gleichermaßen seine Brüder, aber sogt er is nur in Österreich dahoam? Fuikoffa nennans sowas, wo I herkim
;-). Ist ja a echt a schens Land wo I herkumm, aber G'schicht solltatst auch lesen tun, ned nur 'Bergsteign und Wurst'.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Wea von uns is da Voikoffa? Du oda i?? I bin a Wüdbuaga,oba I was a wo mei Heimat is!!!.....Die Wüd is mei Land,aber mei Heimat is mei Wurzel!.....
Und über Gschichte wissn oda ned´, es is vielleicht on da Zeit dia zu sogn,das I Gschichte studiert hob und mia deshoib "onmaß" zwissen wovon i red....
hab die Ehre....
Siggy
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern hahaaa na serwas hea auf.
A echta Patriot. Dei Heimat, deine Wurzeln, aber oan auf Gutmensch mochn im Öffentlichen... Du warst scho kreht gwen für de oide Zeit, Und sowos ois G'schichtsstudent. Samma uns ehrlich: des beisst si a wengal.
Mal ganz sachlich... "Alter"... glaub ma uns beide nich so recht, oda?
I bleib dabei...... du host net nachdacht.
'un gutsch'
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
Comment removed
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern Oida oida oida... hallo? verstehst koan spaß? A echter Patriot aber so unhumorig? Mochs da scheh und geh wieda schloffn. Un Gutsch numoi, wei's so oibern is. Küss die Hand.
HG Zauner.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Das war so eine freche Antwort (oibern und K d H),dass es mich doch einen Lacher gekostet hat es zu lesen......
Wir haben uns echt nicht "verstanden" (vielleicht einfach aneinander vorbeigesprochen)......aber Du hast mich Nerven gekostet (echt!).....naja wieder was dazugelernt........
Wünschl Dir trotzallem,alles Gute.......
Siggy
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern Okay die Antwort überrascht mich jetzt. Ich hab dich auch ziemlich provoziert... nichts für Ungut... Ich finde diese "Schnitzelpatrioten" Schiene nur albern. Österreich hatten die höchste NSDAP Wählerquote im ganzen Reich, und jetzt macht man einen auf undeutsch, das ist undankbar, und wäre nicht passiert, wenn der Krieg anders verlaufen wäre. Ich wünsch dir auch ernsthaft alles gute, von ganzem Herzen; sorry für die Harten Worte.
Trotz allem respektvolle Grüße.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Ohhhhh scheiße!!! Wir überschneiden uns und jetzt habe ich erst gesehen,dass Du doch freundlich geschrieben hast (tut mir leid für meine letzte Mail )o:) ich weiß,dass wir Österreich den Anschluß mehrheitlich wollten (aus der damaligen Situation heraus sehr verständlich)......Danke,dass Du das letzte mail freundlich geschrieben hast, Du hast es vermutlich nicht mitbekommen,ich bin kein "Oida" sondern eine "Oide"....und ich bin so harte Worte nicht gewohnt....
Friede!
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern na dann erst recht Küss die Hand;-) duad ma load.
FRIEDE!
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Dafür Danke ich Dir!!!
Friede!!
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern Keine Überschneidung, hab gewartet, bis deine Antwort kam. (bin halt Galant) Ich glaub' wir meinen so ziemlich das gleiche, als Mann ist man denk' ich nur Territorialer, und vielleicht etwas anders unterwegs.
Ganz, ganz liebe und aufrichtige Grüße. Und nichts für ungut;-)
lass mas bei am Patt, damit koana sog'n kunn es war a Gschlechterk(r)ampf.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Ich danke Dir auch noch einmal dafür,dass unser Gespräch so ausgegangen ist.....es hat mir wirklich weh getan,wie Du mit mir gesprochen hast,aber jetzt hast Du ein Pflaster auf die Wunde getan.........wo ich zuerst total traurig war, lache ich wieder.......ein Patt ist fair (o:
Ebenfalls ganz liebe Grüsse und ich habe wieder was dazu gelernt (im Positiven!)
Sigrid
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern geht mir ähnlich! Alles liebe für dich!
Alex.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Wenn ich Dir weh getan habe,dann tut es mir auch leid! Wollte ich nicht!...
Winke Winke (o:
Siggy
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern Na Sicha Voikoffa, Du host sogoar " ' " Flügerl am 'un Gutsch'. A Österreicher bist jednvois ned, so unlustig wia du bist. Du host gschriebn Slawen... do bist so stoiz drauf, dann wiss mas scho herr Kubbich.
Heil di a seiba, Oida Wabbla.
SERVAS!
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
=weil ich einen Fehler gemacht habe, bin ich kein Österreich (sehr witzig) Ich spreche 5 Sprachen und Polnisch ist die,die ich gerade dazu lerne,vermutlich ist es mir da hineingerutscht, (ooooh wie schrecklich).....ich dachte mit Dir kann man vielleicht doch noch vernünftig reden,aber das scheint nicht der Fall zu sein,naja in 2 Jahren YT mußte ich ja irgendwann einmal auch solchen Wapplern über den Weg laufen......
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@SiggyStern und doch a schlechter Verlierer... des is jetz wieder typisch Deutsch^^.
Naja. Hoid a slawischer Österreicher, gibts ja gnuag.
Serwas: da Wabbla (aber bitte mit butterweichem 'b', dass ma dahischmuizt)
;-)
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
Wer sagt denn das ich verloren habe (o:....
Ich würde mich freuen,dass wir uns nach diesen (für mich sehr ungewöhnlich harten "Kampf") in Frieden und in Ehren trennen können. Ich bin dazu bereit.....
Alles Gute (und ich hoffe es gibt jetzt keine blöde "Überschneidung"mehr!!
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
3)
I am not a monarchist by the way, I am just very much interested in history......
Greetings
Siggy
PS: I would say The Austrian and later Austrian - Hungarian monarchy was for sure not the only one where people of different nationalities felt not equally treated....look at how others treated the people of their colonies, or foreign parts of their own territory (for example the Polish in the German part of the Partition....) or the Russians.(just an example)
SiggyStern 1 year ago
@Lolerdan that is correct. now it is an independent country but actually they are nothing others like bavarians, saxony´s etc.
...and as you can see the mass of people appreciate the "Wiederanschluss".
but actually it doesn´t matter today as we have a united europe. so just beleive in your history and don´t deny it, even it is easier like most countries do.
bwindi00 1 year ago
@Lolerdan not only one time... The most frequent holy roman empirers' of german Nations Kaisers' over the time, were Austrians. Much more often as from any other germanic country, and the 'Capital' was Vienna.
Des hob i oafach loswern missn ;-)
BTW: the name Austria comes from the old german Austar, which means "in the east(of something)", that cant mean europe, because my home is exactly in the heart of it :-D. It goes back to the first south-german Kaisers.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@Lolerdan there was an austrian leading em for a short while after that war wasnt there i think 1933 to 1945??
Laneperk1 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@Laneperk1 Austrians are Germans.
VinceNF1488 8 months ago
Austria should be apart of Germany. Austrians are Ethnic Germans
zacub 2 years ago
@zacub thats true, but austria would also have had to pay huge reparations, thats why they turned their back on the ones that jumped in to help their brothers(Germany joined Austria-Hungary in World war 1, because the Germans stuck to their agreements, just like germans fought on all fronts of their allies in ww2, even finland) and after WW2, they got left.
I am Austrian btw, my Family originates from "Wiener Neustadt" and near Salzburg, but iam not a denier and want to hold the truth up.
000000AEA000000 1 year ago
@000000AEA000000
A friend of mine who is a historian made here phd about the military correspondance between the German and Austrian military organisations, she was rather astonished to what great extent the Germans were encouraging the Austrians to go ahead for they would stand on our side.....I do not see that Germany was only becoming an ally because they were in alliance with us,but also because while for us it was about Serbia (and the conflict with Russia about the Balkan) they
SiggyStern 1 year ago