I am starting to agree with Monitchka. The older dancers like Sylvie Guillem and Darcey Bussell are gone from the stage and I believe Natalia is their rightful successor.
Natalia Osipova is special. That is sure. Look at Kitri.
Yes, passion is good and necessary.. but Giselle has a style, a clear style in the port de bras, and in the whole dynamic, the actual way of performing the steps of the choreography...
I don't see much of that in the performance of this very lovely, very strong lady.
When one plays Beethoven, well, it should sound like Beethoven, therefor, Gisselle should look in the style of Giselle.
Definitivamente Natalia es pasión hirviendo! De acuerdo con otros comentarios, hay muchas bailarinas con técnica perfecta; Natalia es una de ellas... y además su presencia es la de un gigante! Inigualable! Su energía e intención llegan a tocarte las entrañas!! La amo!!
Natalia Osipova is absolutely wonderful. I am grateful that there is a growing collection from Natalia Osipova. She is so utterly talented and magnificent. S! MJ
Did not think she would make a good Giselle but more I see of her Giselle videos, the more I'm proven wrong. She's absolutely brilliant in this role, right up there with all time great Giselles IMO
some people don't understand passion. Natalia has so much passion for her dancing and it shows..that is what is so magnetic about her and gives her that extra spark. but it's too much for some people to handle because very few people have it. they would rather watch plain dancing, with little emotion. she is extremely special and one of the greatest ballerinas of all time. many can have great technique but very few have the stage presence that she has.
Bravo!!!!!! Her soul in this role is shown so clearly. Not only are her steps exquisitely perfect, but her emotions brought to the audience make her so much better than many who perform this piece. Absolutely excellent.
too much kitri in giselle. giselle ia, at least to my opinion, a young innocent and fragile girl who gives her whole heart away. this interpretation seems too 'look at me!'
@kimmois1 you cantcompaire - ballerinas today have much more physical skills. The speed of Osipova isnt caused by pld reproduction technique :)
Nevertheless i like Kirklands variation, but the best i ever saw is natalia Bessmertnovas. It is middle of the 70th i think, but no other ballerina did this variation as smooth as Bessmertnova.
@Leirix61 If you look at Kirkland she actually tombees into a deep penchee from the arabesque while she's on fucking point. Osipova just goes to arabesque and falls off the pointe. Kirkland's treatment is far greater technically than Osipova's in this variation. And Bessmertnova was fucking shit, she just fucked the AD of the Kirov.
alina and osipova are both gifted with the things that all aspiring ballerinas want but they both have this lack of control and they lose their artistic quality by always trying ot be over the top. I prefer osipova a hundred times over alina but even then i feel she's too harsh in her movements sometimes. where's the character and grace that made ballet so popular in the past???
@KittyUSF i like what you said about osipova hundred times over cojocaru! because that's so true. however, i am not insisting you like what i like, but i like nunez as giselle. even though i know i'm not suppose to say it here. hehe.
@LRBSballerinaz watch Alina Cojocaru, she's the best Giselle EVER, i love Osipova, but Cojocaru has... so much elegance, and her acting is also PERFECT, cojocaru's the ultimate prima ballerina!!!!!
@88888Di88888 I know, this was good, but Alina Cojocaru is my favorite ballerina for this role. She plays it very well. I like Natalia as Kitri and Esmerelda, but Alina is better at Giselle.
@88888Di88888 no way! cojocaru's not the ultimate prima ballerina. she can't even dance swan lake and sylvia. duh. i am not really a fan of osipova, but i really like her and i think she's fantastic here.
She is not Giselle at all...sorry! I love her in any other thing that requires high technique.....Giselle is the supreme role for a complete ballerina.....she is not ready yet.
Excellent hops en pointw, but considering that the two arabesques in this variation are the only two arabesquesin all of Act I in standard performing versions, they seem almost unfinished if you have seen as many great Giselles over the generations as I have.
eh...those costumes...>:\
marakisweety 2 days ago
i love natalia osipova and here she is great but she is better in spanish dances like kitri. sorri fore bed inglesh ;D
2xklopwieisdaar 1 week ago
[art of her headpeice fell off at the end....oh well! that was awesome i luv her costume sooo much
jekaroxssss 3 weeks ago
that was beautiful!
YmustTh3w0rldG0r0und 1 month ago
Very great upload. Osipova Light as a Feather! She is a phenomenon.Grande.Thanks for sharing.
prince2000ful 1 month ago
I am starting to agree with Monitchka. The older dancers like Sylvie Guillem and Darcey Bussell are gone from the stage and I believe Natalia is their rightful successor.
Natalia Osipova is special. That is sure. Look at Kitri.
zzp1 1 month ago 4
Yes, passion is good and necessary.. but Giselle has a style, a clear style in the port de bras, and in the whole dynamic, the actual way of performing the steps of the choreography...
I don't see much of that in the performance of this very lovely, very strong lady.
When one plays Beethoven, well, it should sound like Beethoven, therefor, Gisselle should look in the style of Giselle.
colonia3059 1 month ago 4
@colonia3059 Agreed. Energy is good, but I don't want to see an energetic puppy in every role.
5FnX17 1 month ago 3
Definitivamente Natalia es pasión hirviendo! De acuerdo con otros comentarios, hay muchas bailarinas con técnica perfecta; Natalia es una de ellas... y además su presencia es la de un gigante! Inigualable! Su energía e intención llegan a tocarte las entrañas!! La amo!!
TheMulapa 1 month ago
She is a very good giselle!
freakyretriever 1 month ago
what a passionate dancer she is
omgsls 2 months ago
She is just amazing. Come over to Australia with Natalia and Giselle, please
BRYLANT5700 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Natalia Osipova is absolutely wonderful. I am grateful that there is a growing collection from Natalia Osipova. She is so utterly talented and magnificent. S! MJ
mjmorrow76 3 months ago
Yes, Natalia Osipova is just great!
zeuszeus00 4 months ago
Comment removed
mjmorrow76 4 months ago
im a ballet dancer and i can only WISH i was this good
valentinazornik 5 months ago
Did not think she would make a good Giselle but more I see of her Giselle videos, the more I'm proven wrong. She's absolutely brilliant in this role, right up there with all time great Giselles IMO
sangfroidjen 5 months ago 5
YES! YES! YES!
icarrus4u 5 months ago
Ela é tão linda *-* Minha bailarina preferida depois de Svetlana Zakharova.
JessicaM2112 5 months ago
Every time I watch this it gets better and better!
EtrangerStranger 6 months ago
some people don't understand passion. Natalia has so much passion for her dancing and it shows..that is what is so magnetic about her and gives her that extra spark. but it's too much for some people to handle because very few people have it. they would rather watch plain dancing, with little emotion. she is extremely special and one of the greatest ballerinas of all time. many can have great technique but very few have the stage presence that she has.
monitchka 6 months ago 55
@monitchka Thank you, Monitchka!
TheBunduBallerina 6 months ago
That was absolutely stunning!
EtrangerStranger 6 months ago 4
aww wasn't that beautiful?
julie101rox 7 months ago
Bravo!!!!!! Her soul in this role is shown so clearly. Not only are her steps exquisitely perfect, but her emotions brought to the audience make her so much better than many who perform this piece. Absolutely excellent.
bolshoiballet1 7 months ago 22
@bolshoiballet1 Thanks so much for a lovely comment!
TheBunduBallerina 7 months ago 2
too much kitri in giselle. giselle ia, at least to my opinion, a young innocent and fragile girl who gives her whole heart away. this interpretation seems too 'look at me!'
imalwaysonmytoes 8 months ago
@imalwaysonmytoes I totally agree...while she dances it well there are others who really play the part
dancer4841 8 months ago
@imalwaysonmytoes , Right on!
zushixilaiyi 7 months ago
don't really care for her interpretation...
loulie1997 8 months ago
I absolutely love her as Giselle!!! As Kitri...not so much :-( But she is just amazing!
ninachiquitina 8 months ago
Say what you want about other variations being better; I love Natalia in this variation.
AndDanielaSays 8 months ago
1:40 natalia`s turns are classic!!
BiscuitOfMaple 9 months ago
she is very good but unfortunately she does not have the quality of alessandra ferri
nikizompa 9 months ago
@nikizompa Ferri's my favourite :D
xiheartzacefron94x 8 months ago
I like so much osipova as giselle.. indeed giselle wasn't a princess, but a fresh and vital peasant
prossimamente 9 months ago
ilovethis
XAnooouuk 9 months ago
i d love to see mad scene to too moving to TheBunduBallerina
TheNinakaization 10 months ago
The greatest clip of this variation on Youtube belongs to the incomparable Gelsey Kirkland, check it out.
kimmois1 10 months ago
@kimmois1 you cantcompaire - ballerinas today have much more physical skills. The speed of Osipova isnt caused by pld reproduction technique :)
Nevertheless i like Kirklands variation, but the best i ever saw is natalia Bessmertnovas. It is middle of the 70th i think, but no other ballerina did this variation as smooth as Bessmertnova.
Leirix61 10 months ago
@Leirix61 If you look at Kirkland she actually tombees into a deep penchee from the arabesque while she's on fucking point. Osipova just goes to arabesque and falls off the pointe. Kirkland's treatment is far greater technically than Osipova's in this variation. And Bessmertnova was fucking shit, she just fucked the AD of the Kirov.
kimmois1 10 months ago
someting fell out of her hair??
PokemonTCG88 10 months ago
not just like...love
dancer4841 10 months ago
who saw the little flower ( i think) pop off her headpiece at 1:47? lol
bozemandude 10 months ago 9
be still my beating heart. Beautiful x
TheGlossyglitz 11 months ago
Her work is SO BEAUTIFUL AND DELICATE!
101jecca 11 months ago
alina and osipova are both gifted with the things that all aspiring ballerinas want but they both have this lack of control and they lose their artistic quality by always trying ot be over the top. I prefer osipova a hundred times over alina but even then i feel she's too harsh in her movements sometimes. where's the character and grace that made ballet so popular in the past???
KittyUSF 11 months ago
@KittyUSF i like what you said about osipova hundred times over cojocaru! because that's so true. however, i am not insisting you like what i like, but i like nunez as giselle. even though i know i'm not suppose to say it here. hehe.
kkiimmiissiipp 3 months ago
I liked this, but... there's som lack of control, she's too fast for Giselle, it doesn't go with th style, a Romantic ballet should be softer
88888Di88888 1 year ago
Comment removed
roopeehoox 1 year ago
whaou!!! comme elle doit avoir mal aux jambes après ça!!!! en tout cas c'est super!
elylotus0 1 year ago
п-р-е-к-р-а-с-н-а-я.
rivombreuse 1 year ago
i looooved it.
s96ml14 1 year ago
not my ideal Giselle
garnetpasion 1 year ago
Perhaps this role might not show off her Best abilities but nevertheless I have not seen any other danced dovit better !!!
LRBSballerinaz 1 year ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
@LRBSballerinaz you could check out alina cojocaru's version :)
roopeehoox 1 year ago
@LRBSballerinaz watch Alina Cojocaru, she's the best Giselle EVER, i love Osipova, but Cojocaru has... so much elegance, and her acting is also PERFECT, cojocaru's the ultimate prima ballerina!!!!!
88888Di88888 1 year ago
@88888Di88888 I know, this was good, but Alina Cojocaru is my favorite ballerina for this role. She plays it very well. I like Natalia as Kitri and Esmerelda, but Alina is better at Giselle.
danceizmyworld 10 months ago
@88888Di88888 no way! cojocaru's not the ultimate prima ballerina. she can't even dance swan lake and sylvia. duh. i am not really a fan of osipova, but i really like her and i think she's fantastic here.
kkiimmiissiipp 3 months ago
She is not Giselle at all...sorry! I love her in any other thing that requires high technique.....Giselle is the supreme role for a complete ballerina.....she is not ready yet.
lospapos67 1 year ago
I dıdnt lıke her giselle ..I mean she ıs great dancer but not for all the roles very fix her ..
likeafirstday 1 year ago
isn't Giselle suppose to be a peasant girl and have a weak ( heart / murmur) or somtin ?
Isn't this why she (Giselle ) is perceived as FRAIL !!!
It seems this superb dancer always dances like she has to prove something
I think its because when I was younger there was only one big competition a yr
These dancers now days compete every two weeks
and dance every role has if they are competing
to me its FLAWED
havenization 1 year ago
Excellent hops en pointw, but considering that the two arabesques in this variation are the only two arabesquesin all of Act I in standard performing versions, they seem almost unfinished if you have seen as many great Giselles over the generations as I have.
Arrow
bestmaster3 1 year ago
not Giselle at all. sorry. it takes much more than sharp technique to be a great Giselle.
mpelle294 1 year ago 2
I love how she is shining in her white dress, like an angel or something.
4096quagmire 1 year ago
Great!!!!
ligamiao 1 year ago 2
does anyone have her mad scene? im dying to see how she interprets it
tutus4life 1 year ago 4
@tutus4life Yes, I have uploaded her mad scene. You can find it by visiting my channel.
TheBunduBallerina 1 year ago
@tutus4life Nice pun. Haahah
AndBecomeADuck 1 year ago
@AndBecomeADuck omg i didn't even realize that! hahaha!
tutus4life 1 year ago
incredable natalia is sooo perfect!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1 i wish she was
tommyf663 1 year ago
Natalia is the best!
elesol96 1 year ago
Thank you very much.~~~~~~
LuoCatherine 1 year ago