When I learned the artist responsible for the recording when this musical went to a DVD, I felt
absorbed in a voice the world is as thrilled about from this first song to the new ones on his latest tour, which sadly ended, and I was lucky in my lifetime to see, ...
btw, to answer the question of who the camera keeps cutting to, this might help us all remember why he is in the same category as Warren Beatty and Elton John and Julia Child, to whom all wom the Life time Kennedy Award that year.
@soccerstaralways Whether I could or couldn't is not the point , however if one if going to pass themselves of a professional singer they should know when they won't do a song the justice it deserves. Also since when did my singing ability get into this video he is singing not I.
@sunnyboycj You know, I agree. I love Josh Groban, but I love Phantom too, and this performance just felt really forced and kind of rushed through. :/
I never thought Id say this about Josh Groban, but an utterly heartless and emotionless performance! Thank god he has such an orgasmic voice on its own, or this performance would have been a complete fail!
Omg lmao @ his facial expression @ 1:05. I got to agree with the others, this was not his best.
However, he did much better than what I could even dream of performing. He may have been nervous, and yea I would be nervous too if I was singing in front of ALW!
guys... seriously, this is fucking awful. he couldnt even be an understudy at a respectable production. his high note sounds like a goat bleeting. watch the professionals do it
He isn't getting into the song. He needs to be more passionate when he sings this song. He needs to slow down a bit too. But other than that it was beautiful. I love how Webber is mouthing the words along as Josh Groban was singing them lol :DD
@missanakin ARE YOU KIDDING ME. i love gerard butler and his version. but the vocals aren't even close to being comparable. they aren't even in the same category of talent. jesus christ people. open up your ears.
the songs get changed by sir webber, to go with the person singing, the words michael crawford sing are the original since he was the first one to sing it,memory was changed so was phantom of the opera that went from duet to solo,
I like Josh Groban a lot and have a couple of his CDs but after having seen Michael Crawford perform this on stage as well as in concert Michael just sings this so much better. I also respect Michael Ball "phantomlabyrinth" and I would say give Michael Crawford a chance as well because MC has produced some very good CDs that have received Grammy and Dove nominations. Plus like Groban MC puts his heart and soul into his music. Peace and Love.
andrew lloyd webber has a scary face. anybody notice when josh sang that long, note, his eyes were all big like they were gonna come out? looked kinda funny. he looks better when he sings normally.
I'm with you that this isn't Groban's best, but I still thought he did a pretty good job. And I've heard people butcher it much worse, so at least I'll give him that. I actually have some of Ball's stuff and am seriously considering Vittorio...Thanks for the input!
@aarontenor the Ab is high for him since he's a lower baritone-upper bass. The part is meant for a mid baritone-low tenor. For his range, he did a pretty good job. I also take this to be one of his earlier performances so he's nervous.
Josh Groban is a great singer. Vocally, he has about one octave that sounds wonderful. And that's ok! You don't have to be Pavarotti or Celine Dion to touch people.
To your diagnosis: If he is a baritone or low baritone as you claim, then the low notes would have been big and full. He didn't get those either unfortunately. Josh is a high baritone or "lazy tenor." He should just stick to what we love in him; songs like "To where you are," and "You raise me up," etc etc.
josh groban is AMAZING!!! Not only can he sing but he can play drums, piano and GUITAR!!! he's an angel of music :-) (and u can't compare clay w/ Josh groban...i'm sorry)
I love Josh, and I think he has an amazing voice, but it seems like he's struggling with these falsetto notes. Other than that, it was an amazing performance.
great, josh groban!! now to cap it off they should also do a clay aiken rendition of it...that would too good for words! those two are amazing singers.
When I learned the artist responsible for the recording when this musical went to a DVD, I felt
absorbed in a voice the world is as thrilled about from this first song to the new ones on his latest tour, which sadly ended, and I was lucky in my lifetime to see, ...
btw, to answer the question of who the camera keeps cutting to, this might help us all remember why he is in the same category as Warren Beatty and Elton John and Julia Child, to whom all wom the Life time Kennedy Award that year.
bookshop101 1 week ago
this is great... I still like the real phantoms version better. Ya his eyes are kind a creepy at some points haha
ohtobehismary 3 months ago
I think Josh would make a great Raoul.
YumiRulz 3 months ago
JOsh has a wonderful voice but doesn't really do this song justice.
dnmurphy48 4 months ago
If he slowed this down and did the whole song, i'm sure he could make the performance perfect. He's voice is absolutely beautiful
KellyAlexandra19 4 months ago
What the hell is steven spielberg doing next to clay eyed llyod webber? is a knight as well?
eyedea81 4 months ago
@eyedea81 No. These are the Kennedy Center Awards.
Bdawg9891 3 months ago
Five people are absolutely uncultured barbarians
Willysaur725 6 months ago
Webber looks very displeased with this performance I cannot blame him
dethe8ter 6 months ago
@dethe8ter No... I think that's just how his face is.
anddlizzle 5 months ago
@anddlizzle Perhaps but if I were him I would be upset Groban does this song no justice what so ever.
dethe8ter 5 months ago
@dethe8ter Yeah, well... Gerard didn't do such a great job either. Oh well. At least we still have Michael Crawford.
anddlizzle 5 months ago
@anddlizzle Butler did worse than Groban and yes Michael Crawford was born for this role there is no doubting that to most Phantom lovers.
dethe8ter 5 months ago
@dethe8ter you think you could do any better? Yeah. didn't think so
soccerstaralways 5 months ago
@soccerstaralways Whether I could or couldn't is not the point , however if one if going to pass themselves of a professional singer they should know when they won't do a song the justice it deserves. Also since when did my singing ability get into this video he is singing not I.
dethe8ter 5 months ago
There is a man that was in white for this tribute. I want to know what he sang I cant find it. Help anyone please.
jam90jaay 6 months ago
those eyes....LOL....Josh is awesome :)
ngh41369 7 months ago
@sunnyboycj You know, I agree. I love Josh Groban, but I love Phantom too, and this performance just felt really forced and kind of rushed through. :/
chris0513 7 months ago
hahaha! love josh's eyes!!!!!!!! <3
Youcantstopthebeat22 9 months ago
1:19 - who is that?
sturnbull09 9 months ago
@sturnbull09 That's Andrew Lloyd Webber. He's the one who 'wrote' music of the Night, along with all the other Phantom songs.
PPxPhantomPhoenix 9 months ago
@PPxPhantomPhoenix nice!!!
sturnbull09 9 months ago
@sturnbull09 Andrew Lloyd Webber. He's the Composer for The Phantom Of The Opera.
RosesNightengales 8 months ago
@sturnbull09 Andrew Lloyd Webber. :) My music teacher is related to him! I found out at the last day of school :) So cool.
CGftwxD 8 months ago
I never thought Id say this about Josh Groban, but an utterly heartless and emotionless performance! Thank god he has such an orgasmic voice on its own, or this performance would have been a complete fail!
sunnyboycj 10 months ago 2
1:06 ooooh a cookie!!! hahaha <3
annababyz 10 months ago
Who is the man in the audience that the camera keeps panning to?
mrme1010101 11 months ago
@mrme1010101 Thats Sir Andrew Lloyd Webber! The one who wrote the music!
AnimeIdiot19 11 months ago
@mrme1010101 Andrew Lloyd Webber
phantomlabyrinth 10 months ago 10
This has been flagged as spam show
@mrme1010101 way to pay attention!!!
bigjoetube 3 months ago
OMGOSH HE CAN BE MY PHANTOM ANY DAY!
CryingGypsy 11 months ago 3
Omg lmao @ his facial expression @ 1:05. I got to agree with the others, this was not his best.
However, he did much better than what I could even dream of performing. He may have been nervous, and yea I would be nervous too if I was singing in front of ALW!
kasha20 1 year ago
love josh groban and this is a beautiful song. 8D
SteampunkEpsilon 1 year ago
guys... seriously, this is fucking awful. he couldnt even be an understudy at a respectable production. his high note sounds like a goat bleeting. watch the professionals do it
justliveit05 1 year ago
@justliveit05 youtube.com/watch?v=GnwpUeI4nqk
justliveit05 1 year ago
@justliveit05 Actually, I think he did a good job. The high note thing....it sounded like he maxed out the mic. just saying.
TuggersTeazer 11 months ago
I love this.
sirhumsalot616 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
we should start a petition, musicalmeg19!!! he sings like an angel!
MusicallHeartt 1 year ago
He needs to record this so desperately!!!!!!!!! Let's all start a petition!!!
musicalmeg19 1 year ago 2
This song makes my soul happy!!!
ElvenDagger14 1 year ago
He isn't getting into the song. He needs to be more passionate when he sings this song. He needs to slow down a bit too. But other than that it was beautiful. I love how Webber is mouthing the words along as Josh Groban was singing them lol :DD
pyroundead 1 year ago
Love Love Love A.L.Webber. GENIOUS!
alphacentoree 1 year ago
Love Love Love A.L.Weber! genious!!!!!
alphacentoree 1 year ago
I saw Dolly Parton :D
germanman3826 1 year ago
I am surprised with some of these comments...it was live, in front of Webber..come on...it was perfect...
Josedehesa 1 year ago
he has to be phantom!!!! or at least raoul :)
moviegurl16 1 year ago
cannot believe he performed for andrew lloyd webber... how special.
that would be so amazing. i would cry
therealmonicarene 1 year ago 3
i was surprisingly dissapointed. I love josh, but this wasn't his best....
CelticTears101 1 year ago
Fail Josh Groban Fail that Ab was embarassing
TheMusicalman1234 1 year ago
<3 his voice gives me chills. Its so angelic.
OsnapArden 1 year ago
wtf? the "beeeeee" part is much better in the movie, come on he could have done better.
YESHUAISMERCIFUL 1 year ago
I'm going to marry him. Officially
Broadwaybratt525600 1 year ago
Hes nervous give the poor guy a break!
JuggalettePrincess92 1 year ago
at 1:05 his eyes scare me otherwise a purely flawless performance
silence1453 2 years ago 38
I was laughing! lol His eyes were hay-UGE! But we still love Josh. =D
AriaInTheSky 2 years ago
@silence1453 Hahaha, I agree!!! :)
sweetops 5 months ago
yeah, its way too fast
but Josh Groban is amazing!!!!
MangledxImagination 2 years ago
i love you josh, but gerard butler sings it better. :)
missanakin 3 years ago
@missanakin ARE YOU KIDDING ME. i love gerard butler and his version. but the vocals aren't even close to being comparable. they aren't even in the same category of talent. jesus christ people. open up your ears.
OsnapArden 1 year ago
too fast- but good-
wallboi7 3 years ago 20
@wallboi7 yeah, if he had kept it slower, it would have sounded better.
CelticTears101 1 year ago
@wallboi7 i think they needed to speed it up for time
misssmilesunshine 1 year ago
the songs get changed by sir webber, to go with the person singing, the words michael crawford sing are the original since he was the first one to sing it,memory was changed so was phantom of the opera that went from duet to solo,
Vampirelayer008 3 years ago
i love you to much. he's beatiful!
JoycepinkyS2 3 years ago
I like Josh Groban a lot and have a couple of his CDs but after having seen Michael Crawford perform this on stage as well as in concert Michael just sings this so much better. I also respect Michael Ball "phantomlabyrinth" and I would say give Michael Crawford a chance as well because MC has produced some very good CDs that have received Grammy and Dove nominations. Plus like Groban MC puts his heart and soul into his music. Peace and Love.
mcbarnumphan 4 years ago
these words are not correct?
wehttam100 4 years ago
I believe they might be the original lyrics. So. they may sound a little bit different. ^^
MichaelCrawfordsFan 3 years ago 2
I love this one!!his "believe"was so cute!!And it wasn't rushed!!!!
avbunyan 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Yeah, PUKE!
I say Hallelujah to you.
srasm 5 years ago
i did not like this...its rushed
wehttam100 5 years ago
I agree he could have done such a better job I am sad :(
LilyPeters1540 4 years ago
yeah it sounds like he's trying to sing too fast and the microfone is a bit useless, which is a shame cos he has a fabulous voice
HugMonster341 3 years ago
andrew lloyd webber has a scary face. anybody notice when josh sang that long, note, his eyes were all big like they were gonna come out? looked kinda funny. he looks better when he sings normally.
greenjadedragon 5 years ago
Comment removed
aarontenor 5 years ago
I'm with you that this isn't Groban's best, but I still thought he did a pretty good job. And I've heard people butcher it much worse, so at least I'll give him that. I actually have some of Ball's stuff and am seriously considering Vittorio...Thanks for the input!
phantomlabyrinth 5 years ago
@phantomlabyrinth how did he even slightly butcher it? his voice is immaculate. you must be deaf. i'm sorry, but how was this bad in the least bit?
OsnapArden 1 year ago
@aarontenor the Ab is high for him since he's a lower baritone-upper bass. The part is meant for a mid baritone-low tenor. For his range, he did a pretty good job. I also take this to be one of his earlier performances so he's nervous.
JenovaCelestia 1 year ago
@JenovaCelestia
Josh Groban is a great singer. Vocally, he has about one octave that sounds wonderful. And that's ok! You don't have to be Pavarotti or Celine Dion to touch people.
To your diagnosis: If he is a baritone or low baritone as you claim, then the low notes would have been big and full. He didn't get those either unfortunately. Josh is a high baritone or "lazy tenor." He should just stick to what we love in him; songs like "To where you are," and "You raise me up," etc etc.
aarontenor 1 year ago
He has an amazing voice!
catholicteen 5 years ago
Oh that was my wish Josh sings this beautiful song!
This dream came true! Great!!! :-)
LittleSandy 5 years ago
josh groban is AMAZING!!! Not only can he sing but he can play drums, piano and GUITAR!!! he's an angel of music :-) (and u can't compare clay w/ Josh groban...i'm sorry)
ericabye 5 years ago
i love this song! and him! lol
xMusicalxDreamsx 5 years ago
I love Josh, and I think he has an amazing voice, but it seems like he's struggling with these falsetto notes. Other than that, it was an amazing performance.
mademoiselledaae 5 years ago
THIS VIDEO is the fullest prooof that he should sing in Phantom. Raoul or the Phantom, I don't care, he has an amazing voice for both.
MusicalLover6 5 years ago
great, josh groban!! now to cap it off they should also do a clay aiken rendition of it...that would too good for words! those two are amazing singers.
pagielme4ever 5 years ago
OMFG, I love you for submitting this! ~glomp/hug~ doesn't he sound so heavenly singing that? ~sighs dreamily~
thephantomsmuse 5 years ago