Red Rag Top

[gatorthang]

that was amazing :) i wish i knew how to do stuff like that

[BillyBob1776]

Great interpretation.

The song is about that first love lost back in your youth more than anything else.

Setting it to game characters had not crossed my mind, but it works pretty well.

Congratulations!

[MrStefansone]

You did a Fantastic Job, and I can watch this video any time!

[bethiegirl824]

You did a great job - I'm impressed!

[Eeecca0729]

nice job :)

[sonictherevenge]

Freaking awsome well done

[sonictherevenge]

Is that a game if so what one??

[i3igpete]

great adaptation of the song. very well done.

[cutieshelbz]

WELL DONE XX

[stage1hand]

Oh my god, that is so very cool, I love that song it reminds me of a girl from long ago. Everything but the age. It is fantastic.

[perry200789]

I have to say hun that it id wonderful you want to make films I think this is very good editing no jump cuts or flash frames...I love the song and the video is cute it fit in most of the songs...great job! take care!

[nw1018]

wow, nice

[FinalDestroy]

i have to be honest with...not the best video for tim mcgraw but i did like how you rearranged the story with ffx and ffx-2 lol very amusing and the scenes went well with your story...big props nice job

[MeLinasPassion]

Seems like still most people don't read descriptions oO The creator of this video wrote an own story and it's up to everybody's own, how to interpret lyrics. Of course, it depends also on the personal taste (to be honestly, I think it was a little bit boring, but still you did a great job on editing!) and this video is kinda headstrong ^__^ But the only thing that I had to criticize would be about the contest, but I am not a juror, so I wish you good luck and Keep up the good work!

[ChaiyaProvo]

I appreciate the constructive criticism. Everyone has their own opinion, I realize that. I will try to make my future works less boring. May I ask what you mean by headstrong? Thank you for your comment.

[MeLinasPassion]

You're welcome^^

By headstrong I meant that it's kinda contrary but in a positive way I think^^ The song choice is very risky and I think this video is not like most vids on youtube... Even if it not one of the best videos out there, I'll not forget this one =D

[acidragdoll]

... What made you think this was a good idea for a story about the characters of Final Fantasy X? There's "AU" and then there's this unrecognizeable, irrelevent, futile, redundant and superfluous nonsense. It has nothing to do with any of the characters except for the fact that Yuna and Tidus were romantically involved in the game.

I don't understand how people can even call these AMVs when they insist on such ridiculous departures from anything that resembles canon...

[ChaiyaProvo]

I'm sorry you feel that way, but perhaps you could see my perspective. I make videos like this for the entertainment of myself an for others, such as my friends, most of which seem to enjoy my efforts. Do I say I am a good video maker? No. Do I say I wish to be? Yes. As the creator I have control of how I want to interpret a song and footage. Moreover, perhaps you did not realize that this video is seven months old and that I may have not had the experience or brainpower to make something good.

[acidragdoll]

That is an extraordinarily weak excuse from somebody who claims they want to improve. I am telling you that as a creator, you picked a song that doesn't fit and imposed a story that doesn't fit. Clearly, you thought it was good enough to be entered into a contest despite being seven months old, so perhaps you should learn to accept criticism thoughtfully rather than making excuses.

Next time, you should pick a song that might actually fit the series or the characters.

[MeLinasPassion]

I think she is able to accept criticism very well! You can stop bashing her, she already knows about your opinion ;)

And what you're doing right now, is not onstructive criticism babout the video! You are getting very personal and that doesn't belong here.

[MeLinasPassion]

* constructive criticism about

sorry for the mistakes xD'

[acidragdoll]

I've said nothing personal. Not everything negative is bashing.

[ChaiyaProvo]

acidragdoll: I seem to have disappointed you in my error of judgment. Sorry.

MeLinasPassion: Thank you for support.

I appreciate that both of you have suggestions and criticisms and compliments, but I feel that the conversation has played itself out to an ending, and I would politely request that you cease and desist. If you desperately wish to continue, I would request that you continue on your own. I apologize and thank you.

[MrCaleb1515]

Who are you to criticize his work??? He was just making a video that went along with the words as he heard them from his perspective! I think this work is really good did i great job editing! its really cool to see stuff like this. It means nothing that it has nothing todo with the game lets see you make something like this jackass. You need to pull your head out of your ass and get a life move out of your moms basement.

[MrCaleb1515]

Who are you to criticize his work??? He was just making a video that went along with the words as he heard them from his perspective! I think this work is really good did a great job editing! its really cool to see stuff like this. It means nothing that it has nothing todo with the game lets see you make something like this jackass. You need to pull your head out of your ass and get a life move out of your moms basement.

[acidragdoll]

@MrCaleb1515 Lol, check my channel out, I make videos like this all the time. That should answer your first questions about my qualifications as well. If you like it, cool, but I don't. 

[YEAHBRAH69]

never seen an amv/vgmv to country, but this song is better than half the linkin park and emo crap they are usually set to, good pairing

[prepsoccerplayer]

wow meh and my real dad use 2 listen 2 this all the time when i wuz lyk 7!!! :)))

[Brotherhood1517]

This is a really good video, you did a really great job! :)

[baseboy124]

why criticize??? until i can find the actual video this animated will be the official video to me. even though the video is animated it still gives you the feeling of what the song writer was experiencing.

this video and song is great

[baseboy124]

why criticize??? can you do better??? well until i find the actual video this video will do. even though its animated i still gives you the feeling of what the song writer was experiencing.

love this song and video

[Brotherhood1517]

What does he know any way?  The interpretation of the song is up to the listener, thats why so many people can like it. You did a great job, and don't let people give you crap about how you see things.

[captainsmith1]

what the fuck is up with these simulated reality vids? They look stupid, and this one doesn't go alone with the song at all. LIfe is not a fucking cartoon people. This is a deeply human song about deeply human problems and heartaches. This just demoralizes the songwriters and the singer. It's a disgrace. I don't normally say this about amateur videos for fear of hurting someone's feelings, but the Simon Cowell in me is coming out. This is just wretched.

[ChaiyaProvo]

Congratulations. In making your opinion known about my video, you have left me my first negative comment. A true milestone in my videomaking development. I am sorry you feel that way about this video. I put a lot of time and effort into making it look as believable as possible. Clearly I have not succeeded. I might remind you, however, that this video is my attempt at representing the song to its fullest with the materials I have, in this case simulated video clips. Thank you for your comment.

[DrJones06]

wonderful combination, Tim s Music and this great Movie...THX

[Semperfi1098]

very interesting how u somehow tied ffx to tim mcgraw

[vampirephantom27]

i have an odd question... in the background at the beginning of the video, what that destiny island?

[ChaiyaProvo]

Nope. It's all from FFX and X-2.

[vampirephantom27]

k, thanks.

[yourdadjtky]

awesome job on this vid.hope to see more.

[hippygirlruns]

haha this is really good!

[Rorap15]

plot sure as hell sounds like a country song. lol i love it

[nwowy]

wow you are extremely good :O

[jwarebabii08]

i love this song.

it makes me cry everytime!

XD

[balaylor]

such a beautiful song

and good video

[MLTBARockStar]

this is confuziling

[MLTBARockStar]

that was alaena babe, not me