i love this rendition (of course! it's yo yo ma!) but i have to say i think this piece is more suited for the viola, range wise and tone wise. it's still beautiful though!
@loorloop Well, if we're going with your judgement...I'll be a ass about it and say this: do you really think viola can stand against the power of the cello? No, it cant. Ok. Thanks. Bye.
@Tokushimaz Yes, The viola is like the arpeggione without the E string so the viola is better . I am sorry but the viola is more powerful than the cello =) Like Violin is more powerful than the Viola =)
@loorloop Dude, search arpeggione to see pictures and information.
"The arpeggione is a six-stringed musical instrument, fretted and tuned like a guitar, but bowed like a cello, and thus similar to the bass viola da gamba.photo The body shape of the instrument, is however more similar to a medieval fiddle than either the guitar or the bass viol."
How's the arpeggione like the viola? They're from different families, and its more related to the cello and the bass. Learn your facts.
This is good , but listen to Andras Schiff and Miklos Perenyi, a wonderful interpretation where you can see the interpreters playing (with their eyes closed) in perfect harmony.
i get a little pissed when people have to gloat about other videos performed by someone else (in this case this 12 year kid Oliver). I for one dont feel the full effect of what someone is playing if they are only 12 years old. I myself am a cellist entering college, and i know the things you hear out of a cellist mature with time, and cannot fully be understood at such a young age. He is no doubt a great cellist, but I still listen to this version because Yo Yo Ma connects with the music so much
@Bigbug123456 Couldnt have said it better myself. I wish people would just appreciate the music, and keep their criticism to themselves. This is one of my favorite interpretations, and Yo-yo Ma is an incredible cellist.
Divino!!! misterioso!!! Magico!!! Invaluable!!!! una de las cosas que me devuelven la fe en la humanidad.. Schubert.. Extraña criatura... Si han notado que su música son solo melodias? pequeñas obras maestras por pedacitos por todas partes Amazing!!!!
Bashmet's recording of this is probably my least favorite recording that he's done. The video of him playing it on youtube is almost embarrassing to the violists of the world.
Goes to show that even the world's best violists can have horrible days.
Oui, je pense aussi que les interpretation de celles ne sont pas nombreuses(sur YouTube). Mais quand on trouve "la meilleure interpretation," elle est belle et tres speciale parce qu'on ne le trouve pas souvent.
Je suis desolee parce que je n'ai pas la vocabulaire pour dire quoi je veux dire avec la passion je me sens. Alors, comprendez-vous?
Someone wrote a comment in French and I thought it would only be decent to reply in French. If you would like to know what I said, I could repeat it in English. :)
haha noo thanks, i understand it, i was just wondering... but now i see the comment you were responding to so it makes more sense now that you wrote in French
Great! Thx for uploading!
chough65 3 weeks ago
Endless tranquility...
TheFunkyKingston 2 months ago
Ohh man, I really love this part, and the interpretation is so beautiful...
Zafioso 2 months ago
As i repeat this piece again and again,
I get more and more deep into it.
I love this. Thanks!
jiwonnia 3 months ago 2
Thumbs up if The Ask Octavia Tumblr lead you here!
Linkzor24 4 months ago 2
@Linkzor24
Well, you've got one thump up from me. So you felt compelled to look up this song too? I didn't expect to find any pony related comments here.
olivesama 4 months ago
Awesome!
shushu551 4 months ago
can't everyone just agree that although it's better on cello, it's EASIER on viola! and perhaps more naturally suited to the viola's range
playsapocby4cellos 5 months ago
i love this rendition (of course! it's yo yo ma!) but i have to say i think this piece is more suited for the viola, range wise and tone wise. it's still beautiful though!
careinn10 6 months ago
Oh my goodness, this is the most perfect piece of music which I have ever heard in my entire life!
0x5m2s 7 months ago
Comment removed
VooBag 8 months ago
Bashmet is the best sorry ! ^^
loorloop 9 months ago
@loorloop Well, if we're going with your judgement...I'll be a ass about it and say this: do you really think viola can stand against the power of the cello? No, it cant. Ok. Thanks. Bye.
Tokushimaz 7 months ago
@Tokushimaz Yes, The viola is like the arpeggione without the E string so the viola is better . I am sorry but the viola is more powerful than the cello =) Like Violin is more powerful than the Viola =)
loorloop 7 months ago
@loorloop dude, don't say that in viola it's better. It's not.
Tokushimaz 7 months ago
@Tokushimaz I just said that viola is better for this sonate because it is like the arpeggione
loorloop 7 months ago
@loorloop Dude, search arpeggione to see pictures and information.
"The arpeggione is a six-stringed musical instrument, fretted and tuned like a guitar, but bowed like a cello, and thus similar to the bass viola da gamba.photo The body shape of the instrument, is however more similar to a medieval fiddle than either the guitar or the bass viol."
How's the arpeggione like the viola? They're from different families, and its more related to the cello and the bass. Learn your facts.
Tokushimaz 7 months ago
Esto es poesia.....
Gracias.
Schubert es tan magnifico, tan grande, te trasnporta.. es tan dulce y tierno...
No se mucho de musika clasica pero esto si es romanticismo...
Jairgifr 1 year ago
Movie's cut...
0pus 1 year ago
a super raffinato phrasing.
maxtanz 1 year ago
Bravissimo!!!! Greate, and sound like viola! Or true Arpeggione.
BlissFullAcedia 1 year ago
Comment removed
abeleveh 1 year ago
it's a magnifique interpretation !!!! thanks !!!!!! it's very musical !!!! continue !!!!
Fania760 1 year ago
if anyone knows where i can get guitar tabs for this piece i would be very happy!
metalnevadies 1 year ago
@metalnevadies not meaning to be rude, but learn to read sheet music.
FaustAustin 1 year ago
@metalnevadies A guitar would ruin this piece. Trust me on this one.
platinumdynamite 11 months ago
@platinumdynamite
nah i imagined it in my mind it sounds real pretty
metalnevadies 11 months ago
@platinumdynamite @metalnevadies
What qualifies you to be trusted on this? This piece sounds great on guitar.
LenSaxMassiv 8 months ago
@LenSaxMassiv Sorry, when I read that he wanted tablature I assumed that he meant for electric guitar. On a classical it would sound nice.
platinumdynamite 7 months ago
This is good , but listen to Andras Schiff and Miklos Perenyi, a wonderful interpretation where you can see the interpreters playing (with their eyes closed) in perfect harmony.
musicfanBRA 1 year ago
i get a little pissed when people have to gloat about other videos performed by someone else (in this case this 12 year kid Oliver). I for one dont feel the full effect of what someone is playing if they are only 12 years old. I myself am a cellist entering college, and i know the things you hear out of a cellist mature with time, and cannot fully be understood at such a young age. He is no doubt a great cellist, but I still listen to this version because Yo Yo Ma connects with the music so much
Bigbug123456 1 year ago
@Bigbug123456 Couldnt have said it better myself. I wish people would just appreciate the music, and keep their criticism to themselves. This is one of my favorite interpretations, and Yo-yo Ma is an incredible cellist.
makuletboy 1 year ago
There's a very nice performance by brazilian's musicians: Antonio Menezes (Cello) and Gilberto Tinetti... Enjoy it, if you could!
MrJackal1954 1 year ago
Ouais un peu timide sur les premières notes au violoncelle, sinon très bonne interprétation.
crocrodile28 1 year ago
Divino!!! misterioso!!! Magico!!! Invaluable!!!! una de las cosas que me devuelven la fe en la humanidad.. Schubert.. Extraña criatura... Si han notado que su música son solo melodias? pequeñas obras maestras por pedacitos por todas partes Amazing!!!!
Jairgifr 1 year ago
Buenísima, pero la de B. Britten y M. Rostropovich es mejor..!!
polloman29 1 year ago
Comment removed
MrJackal1954 1 year ago
MILKOS PERENYI FTW
squeakybeaky 1 year ago
I'm speechless...amazing!
adsmd29 1 year ago
I got to see Yo Yo Ma play this recently! Absolutely fantastic
werq34ac 1 year ago
Good, but I like Feuermann's much better
mrman6742 1 year ago
Now that's the way the Shubert Arpeggione Sonata should be played!
mjp13rockon 2 years ago
My heart is going to explode! Splendid
kimunag 2 years ago 23
Comment removed
kimunag 2 years ago
THAT'S GREAT!!!
gnappoto 2 years ago 7
lovely.....tears....love...pleasure...all this comes from this music.
livelife409 2 years ago 2
This sonata is one of my favorites and i was really lucky to hear it played by Yo Yo here in Lima-Peru last year. It was simply marvellous
reynasa62 2 years ago
two words.
emanuel feuermann
mrman6742 2 years ago
Total agreement here :-)
M145A5V9836E 2 years ago
A splendid performance. Thanx for sharing Yo-Yo with us.
stlivermore 2 years ago
great performace and well played by one of the best musicians, thanx for posting this:-)
Queenesy 2 years ago
Well i definitely like this interpretation better than that of Yuri Bashmet, This one is actually more in character.
joshviolinviola 2 years ago
Bashmet's recording of this is probably my least favorite recording that he's done. The video of him playing it on youtube is almost embarrassing to the violists of the world.
Goes to show that even the world's best violists can have horrible days.
BratscheBeast 2 years ago
Are referring to the perf. with Argerich? Does anyone know what happened to it I cannot see it anywhere anymore?
madaboutvoice 2 years ago
thank you for your posting.
i searched web for this.
10k33da 2 years ago
I love his performance.
But this is too fast for me.
mamayocello 3 years ago
A mon goût, la meilleure interprétation de celles que j'ai entendues ici sur YouTube,
faut dire qu'elles ne sont pas nombreuses lol.
Voir tout de même ce jeune garçon, Olivier Altdorf je crois, étonnant, non ?
Kerlerot 3 years ago 2
(Please forgive me to write in English.)
Yes! I've seen him (Olivier Altdorf) on YouTube. I'm very looking forward to see him in "proper orchestration" !!
yoyoloveT 3 years ago
je ne comprends tres bien francais. xDD
je suis desole!
younhafan124 3 years ago
Oui, je pense aussi que les interpretation de celles ne sont pas nombreuses(sur YouTube). Mais quand on trouve "la meilleure interpretation," elle est belle et tres speciale parce qu'on ne le trouve pas souvent.
Je suis desolee parce que je n'ai pas la vocabulaire pour dire quoi je veux dire avec la passion je me sens. Alors, comprendez-vous?
liziegrrl04 2 years ago 2
why are you commenting in French?
carrives 1 year ago
@carrives
Someone wrote a comment in French and I thought it would only be decent to reply in French. If you would like to know what I said, I could repeat it in English. :)
liziegrrl04 1 year ago
haha noo thanks, i understand it, i was just wondering... but now i see the comment you were responding to so it makes more sense now that you wrote in French
carrives 1 year ago
Comment removed
MrJackal1954 1 year ago
@Kerlerot DON'T YOU MEAN MDR, FAGGOT?
patugi 10 months ago
wow
Filfla1983 3 years ago
yoyo is AMAZING. HUGE fan!
stephenlau1984 3 years ago
I saw Yo-Yo do this at a concert. He is the most amazing cellist.
cellodude1 3 years ago
I am sooooo jealous!!
PlanBW 3 years ago
Thanks for posting. This is marvellous, real medicine for the soul.
musicdivinemusic 3 years ago