Katharine McPhee, Mary Jane, Seattle

[Mattgraham9135]

no!!!!!

[DancingFan28]

I would do anything to hear her sing this live

[helaina00]

she did good :)..but, nobody can even compare to Alanis..of course.

[goskateclayfan247]

Stunning!! I have always loved katharine...and this proves why she is beautiful inside and out

[jdmans]

She was the best ever on AI

[Spotlighter15]

I watch this and am in awe.

[kurtluvstori]

realy pretty!

[RePoEdPsYcHo]

The song isn't complete without the amazing note alanis usually holds at "keep warm my dear, keep DRYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY­YYYYYYYYYYYYYYY" 18 seconds on average.

[nothlithawk777]

I love Katharine's ending. I like Alanis' note, too, but that wouldn't fit Kat's version.

[youprobablysmell]

She should've won. Girl can sing, and she has to be one of the most talented singers to every hit the idol stage, ever.

[mellowboy]

McPhee shines in this video. Everything was perfect the runs, pitch, melisma, everything. This is her element and she should stick to this type of music. Her voice was haunting in this song but in a very good way. I wouldn't change a thing about this performance. She should have sang it on AI.

[twinkles112]

Absolutely spectacular!!!!

[Ctwirler12]

Maaan, I had NO clue that Katharine sang this song! This is one of my all time favorite songs and hearing her sing it it a dream come true!!

[2KatAce2]

Omg...Im speechless...I always something to say...but this time I just dont, no words can describe how beautiful and amazing this performance is, I'm in tears, you rock Kat =)

[georgie1]

The pure beauty of Kat's voice with just a piano...bliss!She uses her voice like an instrument...amazing talent and totally gorgeous!!!!!!

[venycal]

she should hav sang that during AI!!!

FANTASTIC!!!

[frankareno]

"Beautiful" is the only word I can come up with!

[DunnoTrump]

Wow...incredible.

[rbhrockon]

Katharine is just amazing. She nails this song every time.

[jmoney37]

i was there.

[psycheeros3704]

That was amazing. Her voice nearly moved me to tears. She couldn't have done a better job- it was perfect.

[Pheenomenal]

Nearly? I've heard her sing this dozens of times over several performances and it makes me tear up every time still.

[ricardo11252]

I think that this is her way of adressing her bulimia issues.

listen to the lyrics:"you are losing weight again, Mary Jane/Do you ever wonder who you are losing it for?

[hani901]

she is great.she was way better than fergie both voice and looks.

[steigejh]

Good God! When McPhee is on, she is beyond amazing. And she is ON with this number. There is nobody quite like her. It is a matter of talent, a matter of beauty, and above all, a matter of heart. She has so much heart, born of some kind of inner pain we can only guess about, and it comes through in her singing.

[niati]

chilling. beautiful.

[bbb7689]

wow so lovely.

[idolgrl84]

HOLY CRAP. That was effing amazing.

[idoladdicts1]

Wow!! I am one PROUD FAN!! WAY TO GO KATHARINE!!

[J0NES]

She's amazing! So beautiful and such an amazing voice.

[Jandecbs]

Can she be any better? WOW That is incredible. She has the MOST beautiful voice.

[Katcrazy2006]

I love Kat's cover of Mary Jane! WOW!! I had chills several times. Her voice moves me! Gosh, I would love to actually be able to see her expressions clearly during this performance. Thanks for sharing!! The audio is awesome!!!

[anherji]

A M A Z I N G

[Vadia4Kat]

Incredible.  The whole performance had me spellbound.

[DunnoTrump]

WOW!!!!!!

She totally nailed it.

[areaal]

beautifully performed...

[greenmonkey7]

thats pretty funny that fergie had to go after this!

[katfan4ever]

Holy freakin jebus!

that was absolutely amazing!!!!!!!

I'm just... wow.

no words, just, wow.

[bbb7689]

O.M.G. that was PHANTABULOUS!!!! HOLY CRAP!! soooooo good!!

[TinaG06]

I just peed myself because that was so amazing!

[YesTheyAre]

Jaw meets floor.

[georgie1]

Brilliant performance...this song is perfect for Kat's voice!Thanks you so much for this..loved it!!!!!

[nothlithawk777]

Breathtaking.

[greenmonkey7]

amazing. taylor hicks who?

[ntzalc]

I was there and she sounded much more beautiful LIVE! I guess the acoustics of the center helps too. I was also closer to the speakers. She ought to record and release this song. She nailed it! First, it was KT Tunstall with "Black Horse and the Cherry Tree", then, Alanis Morissett with "Mary Jane". She is an artist's artist.

[cbotten106]

I appreciate this very much. Thank you for taking the time to post this video of Katharine.

[min8nie]

AMAZING!

[Nmore54]

McPhabulous!!!!!!!!

[Pheenomenal]

Great video, great sound, nice close ups, great song, great and beautiful performer. Thanks a ton for this! One for the history books.

[iloveemus112]

wow amazing job getting this! the audio is fantastic. she's sounds so damn good. <3

[tkd901]

Great video! very nice quality.

[doremi30]

I got goosebumps.

[radname]

Beautiful.