Two days back I had an opportunity to watch Karnatriix performing live at Kerala Fine Arts Hall,Cochin. I am really spellbound by their performance. Still now that great music is lingering in my ears. Hats Off to all in the band especially the Lady German Drummer..Looking forward for more from Kanatriix.
you guys are livin my dream..i mean every ROCK fan from the south india's dream..how many times didnt we think about an AMAZING sound when the CARNATIC music is played on western hard rock instruments..kudos..thanks for makin MY dream come true..
Not discounting the guitarist's skill, I must say that it mocks the original intent / bhAva in the composition. While rAga based confusion / fusion / improvisation is all fine, picking on a bhakti-heavy composition like this and riddling it with incompatible nuances makes it a vain display of skill and nothing else.
Its the soul that is important. Not bickering over minute aspects of pronunciation and bhava etc etc.
The fact that many classical musicians with your mentality have no real connection with divinity and are just musical politicians, is proof in the pudding.
@sonofthedestroyer :: hi i am not nitpicky it depends who is translating it Tamil language speaking people say it as entharo but kriti writen in telugu .. it is endaro ..
Hey Guys. No comparison.....this rendition spells out the gift in the guitarist and the group. I agree with most, this rendition can be repeatedly be played again and again and still want more...and is sooooo soothing!!! Most Support you for what you are....Karnatriix.Keep up the good work and lets see more from you....CHEERS
If I had seen this when I was in Class 8 a lot of people would have been happy including *amma*. I would not have become some fanatic of some marijuana smoking cat killing, some satan worshiping lunatic.
Before I Brush my teeth and Before I go to sleep I'm hearing this blend not only that when I feel free I could'nt stop hearing to this "Master Piece" and of course it is a Master Peace for me. Thanks Johnny garu
Oh yes, this is a great find!!! many thanks to you, I was playing some of my faves Brand X, Bruford and Mahavishnu Orchestra, then stumbled upon this - Wow, real fun stuff, love it! What else would you recommend???
extremely high display of skill.....india gives its own kind of music....this note makes my mind relaxed.....what a combination......good composed sir
@manas919 sorry, i cannot agree with you, this is not indian music. they raped indian music here. real indian music is hindustani and karnataka sangeetham (south indian) . you should hear this ragam and keerthanam in its proper karnatic version to understnad how horrible this version is. pls listen to rendition of balamuralikrishna of the same song.
i request you not to send hatemail or use indecent language in reply to my comment
Music is constantly changing. How do you think Hindustani music came about? when the muslims 'raped' carnatic style sangeetam and formed an Islamicized style. This is the reality. I personally appreciate this song. Many people hated Kunnakudi Vaidyanathan for similar reasons
@manas919 Well, it does make your mind relaxed. Of course its in "Shree" raga. One of the most beautiful ragas. If you think it is his composition, you are wrong. This composition is called "endaro mahano bhavulu". It was composed by the great saint "Thyagaraja", 244 years ago. This composition is one among the "pancharatna kruthi" (meaning, 5 gems among compositions). The song means "There are so many great people around me. I bow to every one of them in humility".
I first heard your music when you guys performed at Guitar Gurus in Bangalore. I complimented your performance after the show and I wasn't drunk when I said it! I genuinely loved it :-) Wondering if I should buy your CD or download it from CDbaby.
This piece is great,, especially the last two minutes. I wonder if it is the raag that lends itself to a different form easily? Maybe some improvisations would liven up the second minute and the end.
You hit the nail on the head! That's the wonder of Indian melody system - you have only a few notes in the Raga whose domain is fixed. The range however is infinite! And St. Tyagaraja shows that range in this composition of his, which is one of his Pancha Ratna (5 gems). And when Karnatriix plays it, it sounds out of this world!!
Yes of course! what I meant was that perhaps Raag Shree lends itself to adaptation in a new form. All other raags may not do so. Good playing and very nice on the ear.
these guys are talented but such profound compositions are at their best when they remain in their original classical style. This just sounds like a simplified version of the original piece.
Hello, it is anything but simplified. Why is it because they are a fusion band? I believe St. Tyagaraja would be the happiest to see his composition celebrated through such experiments. Listen again the parts around 3:45 - the harmonies and tonics, maintaining the raga grammar - it is anything but simple.
Sublime!! Is the only word that comes to my mind..such a moving and feeling provoking rendition..I immediately logged into cdbaby and bought the album..Kudos to John, Siva and Faizal for such an interpretation..looking forward to a bluesy 'Jagadanandakaraka'..you dudes rock..and we salute you..
I have never been moved to tears by a song like that. That was one of the best ever renderings of the song I've heard. And for a person like me who is a fan of rock and jazz and carnatic classical, it was a treat.
Never forget your roots never forget your traditions never forget from where your knolewdge comes this will make your music special ..earth is a so nice place beacuse each place on it is so special and so different from each other
Great playing Karnatriix! Very evocative! This is very special indeed! Good luck with everything and hope to keep hearing more great music in the years to come.
:) this is the song i have listened to a 1000 times both in my car and at home :) awesome.. first song in morning everyday :)
dudes794 2 months ago
Wonderful.
uthamanarayanan 3 months ago
You guys are an inspiration really ! Living Legends all o you !
Cheers
Fellow Dreamer :)
chinmaymenon 4 months ago
Aaaaha...!
HarishBhardwajable 4 months ago
superb
famesethu 7 months ago
this is a unique mix of skill and pure music...waah..! too good!
MegaNavitha 7 months ago
excellent talent
paayoub 10 months ago
Just Amazing.
ebhendra 10 months ago
genius from 2:50 to 3:30 ...even he acknowledges it!
arunbgg 1 year ago
@arunbgg : I agree....
sumodmadhavan 1 year ago
Hey I want to learn the chords. What are they?
soccalegend1 1 year ago
2 words. Just amazing.
soccalegend1 1 year ago
Two days back I had an opportunity to watch Karnatriix performing live at Kerala Fine Arts Hall,Cochin. I am really spellbound by their performance. Still now that great music is lingering in my ears. Hats Off to all in the band especially the Lady German Drummer..Looking forward for more from Kanatriix.
moviebuff1981 1 year ago
you guys are livin my dream..i mean every ROCK fan from the south india's dream..how many times didnt we think about an AMAZING sound when the CARNATIC music is played on western hard rock instruments..kudos..thanks for makin MY dream come true..
kingpinmanoz 1 year ago
Music is from the heart mon. Enjoy, relax, and last but not least mon.. Get a LIFE. Enjoy..PopaTab
tarponkidd 1 year ago
Not discounting the guitarist's skill, I must say that it mocks the original intent / bhAva in the composition. While rAga based confusion / fusion / improvisation is all fine, picking on a bhakti-heavy composition like this and riddling it with incompatible nuances makes it a vain display of skill and nothing else.
pavan1988 1 year ago
@pavan1988,
Its the soul that is important. Not bickering over minute aspects of pronunciation and bhava etc etc.
The fact that many classical musicians with your mentality have no real connection with divinity and are just musical politicians, is proof in the pudding.
sonofthedestroyer 1 year ago
its not Entharo ... its Endaro
podadi 1 year ago
@podadi,
Its not easy using the English to translate such words. If you want to be nitpicky i can correct you further and say its not Endaro BUT Endharo
sonofthedestroyer 1 year ago
@sonofthedestroyer :: hi i am not nitpicky it depends who is translating it Tamil language speaking people say it as entharo but kriti writen in telugu .. it is endaro ..
podadi 1 year ago
Music is music stop giving it boundaries! this is beautiful!
brajanandan 1 year ago
Hey Guys. No comparison.....this rendition spells out the gift in the guitarist and the group. I agree with most, this rendition can be repeatedly be played again and again and still want more...and is sooooo soothing!!! Most Support you for what you are....Karnatriix.Keep up the good work and lets see more from you....CHEERS
naughtyforty143 1 year ago
i have been listening to this song everyday at least twice for the past 20 days, that is from the day i came across this song
soorajprasad 1 year ago
What is the name of the band? Is it Karnatixx?
zxcvbnm052010 1 year ago
excellent
almithra83 1 year ago
the time is 4:20. who bets this was on purpose? *raises hand*
breathemachine 1 year ago
Love the guitarist! wish i could take few lessons from him!
kishoregsatwal 1 year ago
There is no mutilation of either the song or ragam here. What are bgsindhura and bhadriprasad talking about?
katakam52 1 year ago
If I had seen this when I was in Class 8 a lot of people would have been happy including *amma*. I would not have become some fanatic of some marijuana smoking cat killing, some satan worshiping lunatic.
\m/
This roccks!!!
moukound 1 year ago
Beautiful melody! Excellent rendition!!
Pian0Arpeggi0s 1 year ago
Its incredible!!!!
MrSureshkumarkumar 1 year ago
awesome ....\m/
adixya 1 year ago
noobs are busy with hip hop and commercial music. This is real art. Beautiful music. Goes back to our roots. Love it.
djaditya86 1 year ago
as an aside, this is one of the rare few enlightened discussions...what does it take to keep the n00bs away :-)?
ramblingwrek 1 year ago
Before I Brush my teeth and Before I go to sleep I'm hearing this blend not only that when I feel free I could'nt stop hearing to this "Master Piece" and of course it is a Master Peace for me. Thanks Johnny garu
darlapudisatry1975 2 years ago
Enjoyed a lot, Good Keepit up
darlapudisatry1975 2 years ago
Classic!!!!...The soul of the song was not lost...
Beutifull!!!!...Thnx
vishalmahawadhi 2 years ago
It is brilliant i have to admit. Perfect blend.
sonofthedestroyer 2 years ago 2
hahahahhahaha
This is a new way to hear this raagam
sonofthedestroyer 2 years ago
what an opening! this is awesome!
harinivaid 2 years ago 2
oh may god! this is so damn goooood.... from now on I'm your fan XD
iyadart 2 years ago 2
This song is so beautifully composed that even after this mutilation it still sounds good :)
bgsindura 2 years ago
its forbidden to change this raagam...but ya nice piece :)
bhadhriprasad 2 years ago
Oh yes, this is a great find!!! many thanks to you, I was playing some of my faves Brand X, Bruford and Mahavishnu Orchestra, then stumbled upon this - Wow, real fun stuff, love it! What else would you recommend???
madkatterier 2 years ago
Absolutely fabulous! A display of talent, control and feel...Johnny, you have done great! Warmest regards, Madhu
menonjay 2 years ago
I grew up hearing my father sing this and now how resplendent and delightful to hear your beautiful version!
bhamsy 2 years ago
excellent
vrrvenkat 2 years ago 11
extremely high display of skill.....india gives its own kind of music....this note makes my mind relaxed.....what a combination......good composed sir
manas919 2 years ago 8
@manas919 sorry, i cannot agree with you, this is not indian music. they raped indian music here. real indian music is hindustani and karnataka sangeetham (south indian) . you should hear this ragam and keerthanam in its proper karnatic version to understnad how horrible this version is. pls listen to rendition of balamuralikrishna of the same song.
i request you not to send hatemail or use indecent language in reply to my comment
knpradeep77 1 year ago
@knpradeep77,
Music is constantly changing. How do you think Hindustani music came about? when the muslims 'raped' carnatic style sangeetam and formed an Islamicized style. This is the reality. I personally appreciate this song. Many people hated Kunnakudi Vaidyanathan for similar reasons
sonofthedestroyer 1 year ago
@manas919 Well, it does make your mind relaxed. Of course its in "Shree" raga. One of the most beautiful ragas. If you think it is his composition, you are wrong. This composition is called "endaro mahano bhavulu". It was composed by the great saint "Thyagaraja", 244 years ago. This composition is one among the "pancharatna kruthi" (meaning, 5 gems among compositions). The song means "There are so many great people around me. I bow to every one of them in humility".
sunilanandatheertha 10 months ago 3
I first heard your music when you guys performed at Guitar Gurus in Bangalore. I complimented your performance after the show and I wasn't drunk when I said it! I genuinely loved it :-) Wondering if I should buy your CD or download it from CDbaby.
darkchild82 2 years ago
this is blast...i wanna hear these gods in real...man this is blast..total blast...it takes me to heaven...this is coke..
unitink 2 years ago 2
wow fantastic great music... no word seriously.... superb.
adam2124 2 years ago
Amazing Amazing Amazing :) Loved the rendition. Would love to hear a faster piece from these guys.
viswavsn 2 years ago
Simply brilliant!
SwirlingNebula 2 years ago
Hi Johnny,
Old Hijacker friend ...who staged your rock show in Chennai.Sunnu
Wonderful da!!!
I'm circulating to our family in the US, India and other countries.
Keep up the tradition which you enjoy. Gr8 music with sincerity. Bless U!
naughtyforty143 2 years ago
This piece is great,, especially the last two minutes. I wonder if it is the raag that lends itself to a different form easily? Maybe some improvisations would liven up the second minute and the end.
Ranjitha2009 2 years ago 2
You hit the nail on the head! That's the wonder of Indian melody system - you have only a few notes in the Raga whose domain is fixed. The range however is infinite! And St. Tyagaraja shows that range in this composition of his, which is one of his Pancha Ratna (5 gems). And when Karnatriix plays it, it sounds out of this world!!
tanapp 2 years ago
Yes of course! what I meant was that perhaps Raag Shree lends itself to adaptation in a new form. All other raags may not do so. Good playing and very nice on the ear.
Ranjitha2009 2 years ago
Nice integrating composition, without loosing the originality of the divine music.
samlevas 2 years ago
5 stars uncle johnny!
- gopi's son, sasank ;-)
braunarsch 2 years ago
these guys are talented but such profound compositions are at their best when they remain in their original classical style. This just sounds like a simplified version of the original piece.
guitarguy1381 2 years ago
Hello, it is anything but simplified. Why is it because they are a fusion band? I believe St. Tyagaraja would be the happiest to see his composition celebrated through such experiments. Listen again the parts around 3:45 - the harmonies and tonics, maintaining the raga grammar - it is anything but simple.
tanapp 2 years ago
simply awesome!u guys rock!handled the delicate line of being full blown rock and classical very well.
drsam32 3 years ago
Awsome!!! Simply Divine!!
rseshadri 3 years ago
i will pay to watch this
kilby2 3 years ago 2
Breathtaking .... simpliy out of this world!!!!
pavan1811 3 years ago
dayum so much talent!!!
pravumj82 3 years ago
John sent me a mail announcing the release of their CD. Congratulations John, Faiyaaz and Shiva! Keep it up.
In this video, I wonder who is playing the bass? I hear a distinct bass line throughout the piece...hmm...
tanapp 3 years ago
Excellent ! I love Entharo !
Plesae, check my page on Youtube "froggygoestobollywoo" - another great musician from Tamil Nadu : Rajhesh Vaidhya
And a very explosive fusion !
froggygoestobollywoo 3 years ago
awesome guyz best piece of carnatic fusion ewa heard.....
hulkhoganan 3 years ago
What's with the bastardized spelling?
horneyvirus 3 years ago
fabulous work guys!! well done
pragv1 3 years ago
amazing song
prashrock19 3 years ago
amazing :) frankly speaking... i am not a big fan of the other songs, this one is simply awesome... :)
prashrock19 3 years ago
a very different way indeed .. keep it up !!
keshavsudheer 3 years ago
Awesome !! do you guys have a website with a schedule ?? any concerts in mumbai this year?
mahesh6699 3 years ago
beautiful
meews 3 years ago
Sublime!! Is the only word that comes to my mind..such a moving and feeling provoking rendition..I immediately logged into cdbaby and bought the album..Kudos to John, Siva and Faizal for such an interpretation..looking forward to a bluesy 'Jagadanandakaraka'..you dudes rock..and we salute you..
paachi17 3 years ago 2
Awesome. It was really a treat!. Good Job guys. I wish you good luck!
Hari1561 3 years ago
Great! Karnatriix rocks! Good luck John, Faiyaz and Siva for your upcoming performance in Shanghai Int'l Music Festival in April.
tanapp 3 years ago
The length of this song is 4:20. Oh shit, I think they're trying to tell us something.
breathemachine 3 years ago
I have never been moved to tears by a song like that. That was one of the best ever renderings of the song I've heard. And for a person like me who is a fan of rock and jazz and carnatic classical, it was a treat.
viveksubbu 3 years ago 2
Excellent .. This proves Good devine music can percolate anywhere ! Too Good.
akrishnancf 4 years ago 3
How many great men there have been! Jonny is one from the present for sure. Tyagaraja would be so happy to see his music flourish ike this.
salisiva 4 years ago 2
Heard a lot about this from Buster. keep the faith, Johny!! Thums up
maverickdivya 4 years ago 2
may TYAGARAJA SWAMY bless your HARDWORK.JOHNY THIS IS SOMETHING OUT OF THE WORLD.PANCHARATNAM with JOHNY S feel......!
dasrinivas66 4 years ago 2
Never forget your roots never forget your traditions never forget from where your knolewdge comes this will make your music special ..earth is a so nice place beacuse each place on it is so special and so different from each other
barbarabarbieri 4 years ago 3
Simple Music can make you sing.
Simple Hug makes you feel better.
Simple things can make you Happy.
Hope My simple Melody will make you smile.
RamaSethu2001 4 years ago 3
Great playing Karnatriix! Very evocative! This is very special indeed! Good luck with everything and hope to keep hearing more great music in the years to come.
mathewjosepht 4 years ago 3
Gud to hear Entharo in guitar.. Xlent work.
v4viki 4 years ago 3
Very refreshing, imaginative and mature music.I like the feel that you have developed. Good combination.
Keep it up, Johny.
josephpj1950 4 years ago 2