Added: 5 years ago
From: easteralex
Views: 90,334
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (182)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Why are people so sure that's really Mary he's talking to? I think that the Mary in bed is simply another projection of James' subconscious, and the scene symbolizes how he has finally forgiven himself and is thus free to leave(or commit suicide) Silent Hill. Mary's words seem to be exactly what James himself wants to hear, and the game is entirely from James perspective. Since when did Silent Hill ever bring back a spirit from the dead? Its kinda like the scene with Cobb's wife in Inception.

  • to me is the best ending because at the end, James repents for his sins and Mary forgive him and tells him to go on on his life, in fact, if we see the scene where the letter is read by mary we can see Laura and James so that means that he fulfilled Mary's wish to adopt laura and to continue his life

  • what is the song?

  • Only ending i can truly assume as good. All the others seem rather twisted compared to it. Maria coughs and hits at her getting sick at her end. The dog one. The rebirth one is sick. And james dying eh.

  • i ve got maria ending but i like this too .....

    and as i played on all the difficulties i thought that the easy one is just for you to find out the strory which is the best i ve seen so far .............

  • does anyone else think the "then why do you look so sad?" line is completely heartbreaking?

  • This is the ending I had. I was expecting something else oO

    Where did you find the part at the end, with james and the dog ??

  • i got this ending...

    and i like it more...

  • In this ending James such an asshole!

  • @20kiv10

    Interesting. I found it the most appropriate ending for James and felt sorry for the guy.

  • @refuckulate420 felt sorry for him? He throw Mary out of his life and leave Silent hill with no regrets. Best ending for me is "In water".

    P.S. Best game ever!

  • @20kiv10

    Mary was already going to die, and she didn't treat James well. Silent Hill is all about James punishing himself for his actions. He felt deep regret and remorse for what he did, even though Mary wanted an escape from the pain. Use your head man, you make no sense.

    The in water ending is the worst outcome, he could've just killed himself from the beginning! It means he went through the experience at Silent Hill for nothing!

  • @refuckulate420 Mary didnt want to be killed by her husband. Look how Maria reacts on James in this two endings. Reactions are absolutle different. "In water ending" Mary said "You suffered enough" so it means that James finally repented.

    *The in water ending is the worst outcome, he could've just killed himself from the beginning! It means he went through the experience at Silent Hill for nothing!*

    *facepalm* Did you play SH2 without sound?

  • @20kiv10

    Mary wanted an end to the pain. I'm sure she'd rather her husband do it then die a slow, agonizing death. Of course no one WANTS to die, but we all must face that at one point. James does feel deep remorse and regret for what he did.

    There's also the end of the letter, in which Mary tells him to live his life, go on without her and be happy.

    Remember. What loved one would want you to die with them? They still loved each other despite Mary treating him badly while she was sick

  • @refuckulate420 If she wanted her husbend to do it why she was fighing for her life until the end then?

    And only reason of my "child acting" is your phrase "use your head" which sound very rude.

  • @20kiv10

    But you haven't been using your head, so no it's not very rude. You are trying to simplify a complex game.

    The letter at the end says it all about how she feels, she wants James to go on and live a happy live.

  • @20kiv10

    "*facepalm* Did you play SH2 without sound?"

    Stop acting like a little child because I don't agree with your interpetation of someone committing suicide being a good ending. If I was James, the best way to remember Mary would be to lead an honest and good life in her name. I'm sure Mary would want the same. Suicide is never a good outcome. That means James went through all that happened in Silent Hill for NOTHING.

    He could've just killed himself from the very start.

  • @refuckulate420 He couldnt kill himself from start because he didnt rememeber what he done until the hotel scene. James went through all events for total recalling, recognising what role Mary played in his life and finding reasons for the. "In water" is good ending among other SH2 endings but not happy and good at all.

  • @20kiv10

    No, James knew what he did and went through SH because of the guilt he was feeling for what he did. I mean we can assume, Mary was in his trunk. In water is NOT a good ending, it never will be. Suicide is never a good ending, I doubt Mary would've wanted him to kill himself. Sorry but you are completely wrong.

  • @refuckulate420 wtf? Are you trolling me? When James came in to Sillent hill he didnt remember what he did and was sure that Mary died few years earlier. Sorry but you played SH2 without sound and subtitles.

  • @20kiv10

    No, you are just too stupid to understand a complex story. I'm not trolling you, you just don't have the intelligence to understand a game too deep for you.

    You still haven't answered me. When is suicide ever a good ending? Considering Mary wanted him to go on with his life. I post regularly on a Silent Hill fan forum, the consesus is that the in water ending is the WORST ending..and a poll revealed over 90%(195 people) felt sorry for James while 15 people didn't like him.

  • @refuckulate420 go play SH2 before posting bull shit, you idiot.

  • @20kiv10

    Played it several times, you just don't understand anything. SH2 is too complex for your simple mind.

  • @refuckulate420 you tell him buddy :D

  • @refuckulate420 *reasons for murder*

  • i got this ending too!

  • Mary:YOU DESEVERE TO DIE TOO JAMES!!

    *Turns to a monster*

    James:Ah shut your fricking mouth and die already!

    *Shoots her with his shotgun*

    Mary:DAM IT!!

    *Falls on the ground*

    Mary:Please no!James!

    James:Time to end this.

    *Finishes her off*

  • so was the fact that james left with loura a sign of his redemption or am i just stupid XD

  • so wahts the good ending?

    i guss its this but i though the warter ending sutted the game alot moer.

  • this is the good ending. Leaving with Laura.

  • este final yo lo acabe de pasar XD .........esta muy bueno el Videojuego

  • wait so this is the best ending? or maria ending is?

  • i got in water ending my first time

  • Why?

  • yeah, this is my ending too:) PS:James is an asshole!

  • i got this ending.  i think it fit the best too.

  • I got this ending too xD

  • I 've got this ending in my first time...

  • in mine too, however it was also my last, I spent about 2 weeks afterwards in slowly releasing depression :))). this game has a really deep impressive story, even now when I see a bits of it, I drop a tear :))))

    happy to not to get ufo or dog ending.

  • it's soooooo good game !! <3

  • omg so many endings i cant tell whats good,bad or ufo anymore ugg its too much

  • this nigga B TRIPPIN

  • Maria = way to easy to be a boss.

  • I Think the Water ending is very sad : (

  • pedazo de sonido...

  • this is the most happiest ending but for me the true ending is "In Water" ending

  • these endings are all so depressing! after mary reads that note right before the credits and everything. and the music. even this ending is depressing

  • its a story about hunan nature, and an uraveling mind, its actually very touching if you take the time to understand the people in the game. one of the best games ever made. easely

  • maybe on beginner or easy mode?

  • best ending.

  • Mary: You killed me but that's cool cause I was a whiny bitch. now go on and ignore my death. I totally deserved it.

    James: Finally I can let go of the memory that I repressed for so long and forgot about anyway. See ya never!

    Talk about an abusive relationship!

  • Lawl! Amazing!

  • LMFAO XD!

  • i just think that he speed up the video

  • I wished they made an edning where they revived Mary (i know its stupid but I would love to see that happen to James)

  • i think thats the Rebirth Ending

  • nah the creators made the game to whatever first ending you got to be the true ending becuz of the choices u made and how it affects u.

    so basically everyone has a different true ending in this game

  • is this a good ending, the kind of ending you would want if you want a "happy" ending?

    i know that nothing that happens in silent hill is actually "happy" but still? =) PLEASE TELL ME (A)

  • It is, yes. In this one, James moves on with his life, in the others he, well, doesn't.

  • this was my ending!

  • I don't get it.

    Does James had to choose between maria and mary or is maria is mar herself?

  • oh yay, then I did get the good ending!!!

  • Leave: good+

    Rebirth: good

    In water: bad

    Maria: bad+

    thats is how much guilt and or forgivness that james got

  • you know what song goes great with this ending?over you by chris daughtry.

  • I beat the Xbox version played on my Xbox 360 and the ending is messed up. The music played through the entire ending from when you are fighting the last boss. Really diappointed me! Stupid glitch.

  • I beat the Xbox version played on my Xbox 360 and the ending is messed up. The music played through the entire ending from when you are fighting the last boss. Really diappointed me! Stupid glitch.

  • when i play silent hill i always had this end -.-

  • Thats a good+ ending cause he learned from being theyre and mary forgave him and he has a daughter to look after...maria and in water are the worst and rebirth is more good but not good plus.

  • U Kill That Bitch in just 3 Shots?

  • in the end, the dog ending clip and the silent hill song clip. ☻ minna de, minna de...

  • my favourite ending...

    what a sad story T_T

  • I don`t understand. How could he talk to Mary if she was already dead?

    Was that a repressed memorie or it was made by the town?

    I dont understand.....

  • it's cause he's already dead he finds his own resting place

  • The power of the god Samael over Silent Hill makes the town a place when everything that is in your head get materialized. Mary was a memory of James, Maria, was a desire for James, the perfect, though shameless beautifull woman

  • The endindg depends o fteh actions you took in the game, that means, the dessitions that James took in his heart. If felt too guilty you obtain in the water's ending. If he loved mary enough you obtain leave ending. If heloved more the woman that he invented on his mind you get Maria anding. Every person sees silent hill depending from the wishes in their heart. That's why Angela sees the towna as a burning hell

  • And that's why the little girl wasn't afraid of the town. Her heart was pure. But James saw the monsters because he felt too guilty for murdering his wife. In effect, piramyd head monster is really a personification of the executioner from the jail. He saw it because he think he needed a punishiment for what he did. If I could speak english better I could explain you more but,that's close to what you asked for

  • Thanks a lot.

  • never fails. everytime i beat this game to the leave ending, i always come close to tears. just thinking about it makes me close to tears. just yesterday i beat the game once again and my eyes were so teary.

  • THE DOG!!!!!!!!

  • I think the dog was Samael... a hairy demon

  • demon of silent hill?? maybe...

  • this ending almost made me cry when i finished the game =.(

  • But I also happen to that topic when Mary James happens to the letter leaves me a feeling that never feel

  • This ending makes the most sence to me.

  • laura is james"s doughter..... nad that video is a little bit wrong . at the end james and laura got eddies grave and they go to ngelas but shes standing there a live .... and thts what i saw when i finshed silent hill 2

  • To me, this is the proper ending, as it's the only positive ending. He was brought to Silent Hill by his guilt, and in this ending, he left in one piece, with Laura who is a real girl. The demon Samual (or whatever his name is) did not get the better of him.

  • Samael isn't a demon, she/he is a god

  • I think basically a "Pagan god" is nothing more than a demon, I dunno about you, but I dont think a real god could be killed by a few bullets!

  • as things go, it seems that Samael is the christian god, Samael must be one of his names, he got so many XP

    plus he got aborted, he almost died so he lost part of his powers, and he also fused himself with a human, something not very smart for a god to do

  • You fool, Samael is no the christian god he is a demon from the ancient testament in the "torá" he is the one who gave the apple of sin to Eva in the paradise and the one who causes death and pain, and of course he's a demon don't you see how ugly is this guy

  • Man I was so wrong, Samael isnt a demon or a god, he's a freakin illusion, I read that all the "gods" you fight in silent hill are nothing more than monsters created from the image of god that the cultists had, its kinda like the ending of ghost busters when a giant marshmellow monster appears just because they imagined it

  • Well you're righ regarding to silent hill, but really at least samael's name is based on the name of a jewish demon you can search in wikipedia if you want

  • correct. samael is the demon that represents darkness. michael is the angel that represents light. the town of silent hill constantly changes from dark to light.

  • thanks man, i had not analyzed the game changes in that way, you're right.

  • Sorry guys samael is not a god, he is one of the fallen angel who mingled with the daughter's of man that is why he was cast away from heaven and fallen to earth to wonder for all eternity until judgement day..

  • ╔╗╔═╦╗

    ║╚╣║║╚╗

    ╚═╩═╩═╝

  • aaaah

  • Please explain...how can the bitch hurt him inside that cage? I never got the chance to really think, and give thought to that. I don't get it...what the hell can she do in that cage to him? Wow...by the way...in America/Mexico/Germany/Norway/­and Britain...that's what you would call a bitch.

    -Rene

  • this is a true ending trust me on this

  • let's hope so

  • hehe in Silent Hill 4 we find out: Henry and Mary never returned from Silent Hill but we don't know why....

  • the in the water ending is the official one.

  • this is the ending i got on my first try

  • Ya'll makes this game too easy

  • Then who is that on the bed?

  • Someone that is not real, created my Samual, or whoever that demon is that controlling Silent Hill. Maria was created by him too. mary already died. Laura is real though.

  • i have finished the game around 7 times now, and ive got Leave Endingd 5 of the times..

  • i think this is the true ending.that is i take it that way.

    what do you think?

  • the in the water ending is the official (sob)...

  • no it isnt, the creators said that james fate is up to the player and what he thinks, so there is no ''official ending''

  • then what about that stuff in the 4th game?

  • ok, now your just babling

  • yep, and speaking of silent hill 4, do you have any chocolate milk on ya ???

  • you got shovel?

  • yeah man, theressss something written on it , now hand over the chocolate milk

  • *tosses milk* this better be worth it, I have only have a wine bottle left to drink. Look out, monster!! *smashes bottle on monster*

    crap

  • oh man, that was.....AWESOME !!! that nosy guy came and talllllkkkkkked of bout thhhhaaaat third revelatation

  • was not!! *sob*

    now just don't go and catch on fire while i read this note, then i'll deal with you

  • Well just because it said James disappeared doesn't prove anything. The cops would probably be looking for James so he probably went into hiding.

  • It's great that someone uploaded the complete ending, but, arg, the audio quality is awful.

  • in my opinion this was the best ending, only that bitch died and James got what he wanted and at least in this movie you didnt see that kaufman die he was like the G man he was mint

  • you idiot ! it was a quick boss fight cux he had a walkthought. that says where to shoot the boss ! LOL

  • Yeah, totally, hit the boss in the stomach for massive damage! Actually, whoever made the video simply made a fast-cut edit between the fighting and the death scene.

  • What's the name of that song? Starting at 1:56

  • "Making Peace," from the unreleased soundtracks. You can listen to them at Silence Is Broken / SoundOfSilence.

  • This is the same shitty ending I got.

  • you have the volume up too loud.

  • I never understood that ending-does that mean he adopts Laura?

  • wtf is wrong with the audio

  • wow that was a quick boss fight!

  • wtf in the ending!

  • HEY!!! QUIT MAKING VIDEOS WITH AN UGLY AUDIO!!! (no offense)

  • That boss was like Abstract Daddy From Silent Hill XD

    Well, loved that game :)

    Didnt get the ending tho, thanks.

  • Well each of the endings besides the ufo and the dog one are how you played the game. This ending is that james realized maria was an illusion made real by his need for mary. After he kills the demon maria he makes peace with mary and decides to adopt laura like mary would have wanted and he just leaves silent hill with laura.

  • that makes me wonder, since Maria was created by the power around Silent Hill, could she exist outside Silent Hill?

  • propably not, 'cause maria is ''powered'' by SH so if she leaves there, he well die, does that make sense?!?

  • but in SH3 there were monsters outside the town O_o

  • well, maybe she was little bit 'wacko' you know..

  • yeah...I wonder if SH characters are all addicted to White Claudia lol

  • propably not

  • how do you get the different endings? what do your do differently?

  • It's a long story. Some of it depends on how you treat Maria, your health status, how often you view certain items, (the knife, the letter, the photo) etc. Check Gamefaqs for the complete rundown.

  • Whoever lost to that boss should be shot worst than Hana did in her death scene in Fear Effect 2.

  • shit hana dies nooooooooooooooooooo! spoliers dam you

  • god the audio on that was horrible

  • no kidding

  • theres supposed to be another vid on here like this where the audio is a lot better but i dont know what happened to it

  • he's in hell you idiots...

    he's drawn to silent hill by his guilt and has to go through all that to be punished for his sin of killing mary.

  • Dude, she can be there if she wants, there's nurses that wanna kill you and a man with a pyramid on his head. A Dead woman giving some guy an acid trip seems NORMAL in Silent Hill

  • it thought mary IS dead..how is she there? and the monster thing you have to kill is it maria? Damn i'm confused since i dont have the game...

  • Yeh this is the ending i had

  • for all of you that didnt understand the end, but understand the background of silent hill itself, him and his wife were linked to silent hill hence the whole story and hsi whole marrige he tried telling himself he didnt love his wife but in the end it showed how far he'd go just to see his dead wife again and proves that he really did love her and he needed her 'ok' or last message to go on with hsi life because he was obsessing over her death.

  • She dies with three shots....

  • i've got a couple things to say, YOU SUCK IF YOU LOST AT THIS FINAL BOSS ENDING, and two..i still don't get the whole story of this..odd

  • the acting was appauling lol

  • As if he just leave her! Shows how much he loves his wife...

  • I like "in the water ending", the most

  • yes this is the "Best" ending... there are two good endings (this and "rebirth") two bad endings (water and maria) and two... very silly endings. (DOG and UFO)

  • I wouldn't exactly call the "rebirth" ending to be a good one, though. He's using the darkness of Silent Hill to resurrect his wife, and this can only lead to very, very ill circumstances for both James and his wife.

  • rebirth ending sux

  • ? I thought it was brilliant voice acting

  • How I miss silent hill

  • that has got to be the...........* takes a deep breath THE WORST VOICE ACTING I'VE EVER HEARD NICE VID BAD ACTING!!!!!

  • Not THE worst, really bad, yes, but not worst. This was back in the days when people who worked on the games had to do the acting.

  • Not by a long shot. Most of the voice actors in the game do a great job most of the time- only Angela's voice is awful. You've got to play Martian Gothic, Symphony of the Night, or Resident Evil to hear truly awful voice acting.

  • Angela's VA wasn't bad, she was just capturing the character in a better way. Confused, abused, and lonely.