@sunlovejam Jacky's fans don't go out of their way to attack any newcomers but Jam's fans keep posting exaggerated remarks about his 'wonderful vocal' when he's covering a Jacky's song! It's natural for Jacky's fans to respond to those posts. Both Jacky and Jam have fantastic vocals. The difference is, Jacky has already achieved super star status in terms of his longevity, record sales and numerous sell-out concerts while Jam is still finding his way. He may or may not get there, who knows?
@MrRightAllTime real player SP does it. just download the video, when u play it on ur comp. there is a convert button on the screen. just choose the right options and u can get a mp3 version:) hope it helps:)
沒什麼好比較的~~都很會唱~唱的各有各的感情~也有自己的方式~重點是聽他們就只有享受兩個字可以形容~要怎麼比較內~><(太為難聽歌的人了)
ALINGSHIA 6 days ago
巫启賢唱得更有感情......
TheCheukchung 1 week ago
蕭敬騰放在張學友的年代,或許會是歌神,但在這個年代,絕對不會。並不是因為說技巧音色什麽之類的,等等因素大家揣測,看看某些電視上見了一面,聲音驚豔的歌手卻是驚鴻一瞥、消失不見,就知道世界黑暗了。
hjxcvbnm 1 week ago
歌神也是會老 所以需要接班人
acky2282000 3 weeks ago
覺得張學友過強...
01478963258A 1 month ago
i really love his songs !
yummytummy7 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
学友中学时期曾经喜欢过,但现在觉得他的声音偏薄兼带硬,胜在演唱会现场够稳定,唱法较多变化,也敢向高难度挑战!萧死死板板,声音轻浮,没弹性,较少挑战高难度歌曲,唱得非常保守,如果站在“实力派“歌手里,我会觉得他像个个垃圾。。。。
yiaphwee 1 month ago
@yiaphwee 輕浮?哪輕浮= = 甚麼叫做彈性...
他高低音轉的順阿
請問你說的試音色還是技巧...不懂唱歌不要亂屁
nasamsss 1 month ago
萧敬腾唱法就一种,学友哥各种唱法都会。这就是高手和神的区别
lkfczzw 2 months ago 8
张学友唱这首歌几岁 快30了吧 萧敬腾21的时候唱的这首歌 这样子比根本就不怎么公平 而且张学友在20多的时候唱腔根本不是这样 听他1983年歌唱比赛就知道了 所以很多东西还需要时间的沉淀 每个人随着时间对生活的体悟都不一样 对歌的诠释也会不一样 我很喜欢张学友 他的地位没有人可以取代 但是我更喜欢萧敬腾 因为他再22岁的时候已经被很多喜欢了 这就是他的厉害
MICHELLEXI20 2 months ago 2
@MICHELLEXI20 张学友刚出道时确实唱歌技巧很一般,听上去很傻的感觉,后来经过失败后反思自己的唱腔,找到了鼻腔共鸣发音,随后红遍大江南北
miaoopeter 4 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
说敬腾是接班人 很赞同 唱歌好听的 太多太多 但是敬腾有种态度 包括他的访问啊 什么的 看的出他很用心 不做作 敬腾 加油
halin0128 2 months ago
说敬腾是接班人 很赞同 唱歌好听的 太多太多 但是敬腾有种态度 包括他的访问啊 什么的 看的出他很用心 不做作 敬腾 加油
halin0128 2 months ago 2
蕭敬騰的聲音很平凡,好多歌手都是差唔多聲(包括港台新進男歌手A,B,C,D,E....),是平凡的中高音震音聲+強迫舒情(不是由心而發的,是刻意變聲的),但張學友聲音的是獨特,一聽便知是張學友
apple185604 2 months ago
現在還沒有任何人可以替代張學友
ONI8482 2 months ago
歌神自己都沒有以老賣老,搞不懂爲什麽歌神的歌迷比他還自信,到處攻擊新人,難道歌神沒當過新人啊,這個時代想像以前那樣靠媒體轟炸就捧紅一個人是根本沒可能的,就是歌神到這個年代一樣只有歎氣的份。不過是占了一個時代的先機罷了,卻天天自誇的天上有地下無的,有沒有必要啊。你現在讓歌神再出張專輯看看能不能全華人區流行!!
sunlovejam 2 months ago
@sunlovejam Jacky's fans don't go out of their way to attack any newcomers but Jam's fans keep posting exaggerated remarks about his 'wonderful vocal' when he's covering a Jacky's song! It's natural for Jacky's fans to respond to those posts. Both Jacky and Jam have fantastic vocals. The difference is, Jacky has already achieved super star status in terms of his longevity, record sales and numerous sell-out concerts while Jam is still finding his way. He may or may not get there, who knows?
ozalice96 2 months ago
蕭敬騰第一張照片好像梁赫群
david123341 2 months ago
只有用廣東話才能完全表達此曲神髓
apple185604 3 months ago 2
口哨吹起的那一幕,有一种莫名其妙的快感
61field61 3 months ago
歌神,只有一个字=劲!
MrJsgoh 4 months ago 2
想當年在大學生的節目上
蕭:在寫歌的時候...不知道為什麼...我就會亂唱
被歌神附身了拉
wintersleep007 6 months ago
jacky cheung's live singing is even better than his cd recording.
shadowj3di 7 months ago 9
原唱是张学友。广东的。比这个好听,
heaven860714 10 months ago
I like Jam and he has talent. But Jacky is better. He is always steady.
TheVOWVOW 10 months ago
I like Jam and he has talent. But Jacky is better. He is always steady.
TheVOWVOW 10 months ago
此版沒有巫啟賢原唱,不過張學友、蕭敬騰、巫啟賢唱歌都了得,三個都唱的很有味道
a7887082001 1 year ago
兩個小宇宙~
aoteng812 1 year ago
萧敬腾只能用耳朵听 张学友令我用灵魂听
MrLikevolvo 1 year ago 16
Jam's voice is smooooth. His vibrato is really sexy.
jacky is legend
garetyy 1 year ago 2
張學友...國..粵..英..旣歌都唱得好!蕭除國..得外...幾時唱得掂粵..英呀?咁點比呀?
一個廣東話係母語...一個國語....最公平大家唱齊3首比啦!
mpvhk2002 1 year ago 6
@mpvhk2002
嗯同意。
我欣赏学友的国语歌。
rividizd 1 year ago
@mpvhk2002
Jacky's age is twice of Jam's.. what's that to compare?
kuanhon79 9 months ago
這種比賽對學友很不公平!
表面上睇是各善勝長, 但其實是這歌難度不算過大, 所以很多人也能唱得不錯, 就是你到ktv聽也間中發現唱這歌的青年唱得不錯!
但想一想, 如這首歌是蕭先唱, 他能把這首歌唱的多紅呢?
當年學友把這歌唱到不是中國人的亞洲地方也流行的, 知道嗎? 就只有歌神有這種感染力!
diljapangals 1 year ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
他們倆唱歌都能感動人心,蕭敬騰再加把勁,一定是未來的歌神。
leon1429 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
他們倆唱歌都能感動人心,蕭敬騰再加把勁,一定是未來的歌神。
leon1429 1 year ago
他們倆唱歌都能感動人心,蕭敬騰再加把勁,一定是未來的歌神。
leon1429 1 year ago 2
他們倆唱歌都能感動人心,蕭敬騰再加把勁,一定是未來的歌神。
leon1429 1 year ago
真是勞了我吧........................
aerinya 1 year ago
就是有人無聊愛把兩個人的版本剪在一起
完全沒得比
音色如何可能是主觀的
但詮釋上
蕭敬騰再唱個十年再來比吧
stranger4135 1 year ago 2
jackie win~~
jaysonTsen 1 year ago 6
廣東話聽不懂......坦白說,蕭敬騰的音色條件較好......
shrgrls 1 year ago
學友哥 巨肺 勁! 廣東歌較好聽!
h3366991512 1 year ago 8
luv jackie but i don't know who Jam is... how does he compare/relate to jackie?
saowamu 1 year ago
(歌神)这个位子无人可担任的!!!只有(张学友)可以担任而已。
boy6427 1 year ago 12
luv jam forever~~
luvjam2012 1 year ago
等你等到我心痛 等你等到沒有夢
所有感覺已成空 就讓一切都隨風
等你等到我心痛 我的心情誰會懂
所有真情的感動 已消失無影蹤
愛你愛你始終 恨你恨你不懂
我付出的心有多深重 反反覆覆的愛不能相擁
愛你愛你始終 恨你恨你不懂
我真的等你等到心痛 平平淡淡的愛怎能相容
好聽^^
wingchiu617 1 year ago
謝謝你的分享!!
相片都找得超棒超配的~~!
敬騰是難得一見的奇蹟...
我相信在他身上會有無限的可能!!
他要超越的不在是歌王歌神,
而是他自己!!!
ucat099 2 years ago 17
張學友 is 張學友 he is number 1
xxxsuperxxx 2 years ago 19
感動到眼眶紅了!
lzz1232 2 years ago
thankz for link to mp3 :)
so thoughtful of u!
p1min1s 2 years ago
@p1min1s
any video on youtube or internet can be convert to mp3 too
MrRightAllTime 1 year ago
@MrRightAllTime real player SP does it. just download the video, when u play it on ur comp. there is a convert button on the screen. just choose the right options and u can get a mp3 version:) hope it helps:)
babygee84 1 year ago
兩個都很好聽喔
這首歌用廣東話唱會比較傳神
ericcheung712 2 years ago 13
把一个才22岁的出道两年的歌手跟唱了多少年的歌神相比,已经对萧敬腾是种肯定,张学友唱只所以感动人其中还要多少年岁月的沉淀,萧敬腾才22岁呀。
MICHELLEXI20 2 years ago 12
真的真的希望萧敬藤不要再受伤了!好好保重自己!开心,平安
jessbeebee 2 years ago 7
張學友是現在的歌神,蕭敬騰是未來的歌神
sksjackie 2 years ago 31
agreed ^^
limloke 2 years ago
學友唱的歌
不管經過多久的時間就是一個高標準在那
敬螣唱的也不錯 有自己的特色!
但要跟學友比 還要努力!!
jp200248 2 years ago 10
最神奇的是
無論多少年之後
學友的歌都像是當代的流行歌
毫不會有落伍之感
tam1234hk 2 years ago 18
喜歡學友
但是太愛蕭敬騰了
chq0207 2 years ago 13
2個都唱得好好聽, 但我只會買敬騰的正版專輯~
siuchu610 2 years ago 8
個人認為....
張學友好好多...
mrMokck 2 years ago 11
張學友是歌神, 蕭敬騰是新人,沒得比較.但是蕭敬騰很有潛質.
xjojw321 2 years ago 87
敬腾把这首歌唱错的厉害。要超越歌神不防参考作曲者的演译。
assermanyt 2 years ago
Not even close. Jacky is wayyyyyyyyyyy better.
jackyyu113 2 years ago
現在的華語樂壇歌神-張學友
將來的華語樂壇歌神-蕭敬騰
cathychung622 2 years ago 15
there is noooo comparison to jacky<3
thatch1nesegirl 2 years ago 2
学友名为歌神真不是闹的,强
unchargedboy 2 years ago 6
Both of them are great!!
daimawong 2 years ago 6
沒錯...要說國語樂譠歌神
張學友..再來就是蕭敬騰~
crag3036 2 years ago 4
Right. But Jam is only 22 right now~
yyqin 2 years ago
後生可畏..青出於藍~~
crag3036 2 years ago 14
did you hear jacky sing when he was 22 ?
cabarkapa 2 years ago 5
Yeah he was darn good in 1984 when he won the 18th division singing competition.
phoboi 2 years ago 7
i love you anniejc , thank for upload 等你等到我心痛- 蕭敬騰 / 張學友..hope you keep on^^
kevkevintsw 2 years ago 4
敬騰加油
做自己就好
超越自己最重要
支持你
wenyen813 2 years ago 12
20年來只買過張學友的專輯
去年蕭敬騰讓我破例了
希望他以學友為榜樣繼續加油
這2人我都很喜歡
ascncblue 2 years ago 20
This comment has received too many negative votes show
jam is a good singer, but sometimes i feel that his singing is so fake and too much 'rockish'. jacky is better. more natural.
myacnt8999 2 years ago
JAm is so handsome!
diaicy 2 years ago 4
敬騰好帥~哈~
喜歡他的聲音
kazunarykimo 2 years ago 9
未來的歌神接班人, 敬騰加油!
rttt1874 2 years ago 53
This has been flagged as spam show
有吗?
fallenjp 2 years ago
不明白閣下的意思,願聞其祥!
rttt1874 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
张学友很难超越吧,不觉得蕭敬騰有接近或超越张学友的机会呀``
fallenjp 2 years ago
別開玩笑了。。那张学友又是超越了誰,接了誰的班?
根本是不同風格唱腔路綫的人。
是在比較蘋果和山竹那個比較好吃嗎?
怎麽不管看流行樂或古典樂的帖子都有這種人啊。蕭邦和貝多芬哪個才是真正的音樂家嗎?怎麽就是不明白每個類型的樂手都有其存在價值。
蕭敬騰就是蕭敬騰
不需要超越誰或接誰的班
他要超越的只有他自己
他也一直在這樣做。。
QQboxfish 2 years ago 29
唏! 我那有說過蕭敬騰超越張學友? 我只是希望蕭敬騰將來也像張學友般受到尊崇。蕭敬騰出道多久?閣下那麼快便肯定他不行?想必閣下是神算子,能看透未來 ! 佩服! 佩服!
rttt1874 2 years ago 5