Added: 5 years ago
From: Robem69
Views: 135,758
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (1,375)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Ok this sort of list is almost like "How long is a piece of string" having said that as somebody who was reared in the 60's  I have found some of the "The Beatles" albums have not aged [exception "Revolver" still sounds great].

    Unlike Dylan's which I still find invigerating .

    Music is in the ear of the listner Pink Flyod Beach Boys or The Stones did nothing for me.

    Where are the Kinks, Richard Thompson and giving U2 honerable mention while The Beach Boys at 19th ?

    Thanks

    2 each thier own

  • Blonde on Blonde is the greatest album of all time for me

  • I think the best album of Frank Zappa is the Freak Out! and the Rolling Stones is the Exile on Main Street, also definitely missed the Forever Changes by Love, would rise on the list to The Velvet Underground and Nico for being a cult and avant-garde album and I think that might have entered the list Grace by Jeff Buckley

  • what about led zeppelin II,Nevermind,Moondance,Paranio­d,Legend,and Nirvana Unplugged,

  • You're opinion sucks. Get Behind Me Satan? Terrible taste in White Stripes Albums. Honorable Mention for Physical Graffiti? I don't care if its your opinion, it's God awful.

  • @HeavyD2544 Such opinions do not suck. Because they're personal, - they're not saying these are overall the world's best. And you MUST care, otherwise the video maker won't care for yours.

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 Not true. I can choose what I care about. So whose gonna stop me? You? Dream on Chump! That was an Aerosmith reference. I do not claim that song title as my own work, nor do I own the rights to it. Disclaimer and troll complete! Enjoy knowing that you fell for my trap. PEACE!

  • Dark Side Of The Moon - Pink Floyd = G.O.A.T. = Greatest Of All Time!

  • @AZ09astrophysicist B.O.A.T. - Best of all time

    C.O.A.T. - coolest of all time

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 G. O. A. T. As in you're dumber than one. See, I can do it too.

  • @HeavyD2544 One word - J.E.R.K. Try figuring out this one. It does stand for something about you.

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 Oh no. I'm really hurt. Haven't heard that one since the 3rd grade. Haha, nice try junior.

  • @HeavyD2544 No, the word wasn't jerk. It was J.E.R.K. and it stands for something. Maybe even a nice thing. Homework not done, 3rd-grader.

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 Oh my. That's so nice of you. I generally write what I mean. The English language is written in actual words not bullshit abbreviations. One can only read it as JERK. Don't try playing it off now chump. You fail again.

  • @HeavyD2544 Oh, sorry to "disappoint" you, then. I'm such a "failure".

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 Now that you agree with me you can move onto the 4th grade.

  • @HeavyD2544 I'm going to be a gentleman and let you go first.

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 Very good. 3 gold stars for you.

  • @HeavyD2544 You have just admitted I'm not a complete failure :P

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 See! All you need to feel good about yourself is my approval.

  • @HeavyD2544 Great. Now I owe you a thank-you or something. Great job, myself.

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 No, thank you for helping out so much. I'll sleep better at night now.

  • @HeavyD2544 Nighty night. Since I'm a working man, would you like my gran to put you to bed from now on? She tells stories for sooooooooooooooooo long it will put ANYONE to sleep.

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 That would be nice.

  • @HeavyD2544 No. Tits are nice. My gran telling stories - that is hilarious ;)

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 I'm always looking for a good laugh.

  • @HeavyD2544 Me too. I need one now.

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 You're kind of a joke though. Shouldn't be hard.

  • @HeavyD2544 I ain't a joke, but if this entertains you... can I really help it? If you can't beat them - show-off :)

  • @MoonchildMindaugas2 Ok. You do that.

  • @HeavyD2544 Sure thing. That was just the training level ;)

  • @HeavyD2544 I'll take two of that, please.

  • Where's Queen?

  • Graceland only made "honorable mentions"?

    boo..

  • I think it's hilarious how this person CLEARLY says in 'their own opinion' yet every yokel on Youtube shows up to tell them they're wrong somehow. Even saying "I know you said it's your opinion but...."

    Jesus H.

  • where are U2 ?

  • Revolver deserves it. Beatles4lyfe <3

  • Blonde on Blonde?

  • @johncourage1 what the fuck you talking about..If you haven't listening to blonde on blonde you haven't lived..

  • @benjamincli He's asking why Blonde on Blonde wasn't on the list, considering there were multiple Bob Dylan albums. Shit don't get your panties in a bunch.

  • dark side of the moon ,well i agree with you ,

  • Dark Side of the Moon should be #1 without a second thought.

  • njoyed this great album in downloadmusic .im

  • A pretty good list. I disagree on some of the placements but not a bad one in there.

  • A pretty good list. I disagree on some of the placements but not a bad one in there.

  • I love these lists....This one is great....I would only disagree with Brian Wilson presents Smile....There's been so much legend and mystery surrounding this lost album......It was, to me , a major disapointment........Brian Wilson should have let the legend be. There is enough bootleg material to compile a 'what if ' album anyway.......

  • How the hell is Abbey Road not #1 that is without a doubt the greatest album ever by the best band ever . . . at least revolver was up there

  • Right just because people discover an album that 95% of people don’t know about doesn’t make you interesting, clever, crazy ,unique or musically educated it just means you happen to discover something that you love and enjoy and are happy you found it. at the end of the day there is always goanna be albums and artist that you are never ever goanna hear of or listen to……so people please stop ranting on about discovering and not reading magazines its really stupid

  • Great list I like all of them apart from maybe a few, personal I think Dylan’s blonde on blonde or blood on the tracks shld of replaced love and theft. I love Syd Barrett nice to see him in there. But there is loads of great ones id of put in there and changed….but its your opinion so its all cool….

  • Very nice list and I applaud you for having the guts to just put it out there. Of course, people will disagree with some choices, but a healthy (and respectful.....) debate is half the fun of it. Love the Stones in the background and like another person here, I would push Abbey Road up the list. Good work!

  • Dylan=Overrated!!!

    The Beatels=Sucks big.........(OVERRATED!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!)

    the rolling stones= dont get me started!

    The Beach boys= nothing special!

    im glad that you have zappa/beefheart & king crimson on that list:)

  • Fantastic list dude. I have nearly all of these albums on your list. I will say even though it's your opinion, I wouldn't have Trout Mask Replica at 50 nevermind #10. I have tried to get into that album, but I just can't it irritates the hell out of me.

  • Kansas Leftoverture ? Grand Funk Grand Funk ? Areosmith Dream On ?  You got too much Zappa and dylan .

  • Abbey Road at #40?!!? Are you fucking kidding me!

  • Nice list.. But East West by Butterfield and Projections by the Blues Project are in my Top 5. And where is Aftermath and Rubber Soul? Meet the Beatles??? blaaaaaah. Definitely list loses cred. How about Nat and Cannonball, Roy Orbison, Carl Perkins, and Derek and the Dominoes and Joe Cocker. gsavage 115

  • Pet Sounds IS the greatest album of all-time and it has nothing to do with rock n roll. It is just miles above that.

  • nice taste, obviously the overwhelming number one will always be The King Of Popular Music- Thriller. But I love the albums on your list.

  • I guess people forget what opinon means.

  • Very impressive!! im suprised to see Syd Barretts the madcap laughs on there octopus is a good song  My only cpmplaint is that you didnt put in "Rumors" By Fleetwood Mac but again this video is about oppinion

  • Here are some of my favorites: The Zombies - Odessey and Oracle, Harry Nilsson - Nilsson Sings Newman, Neutral Milk Hotel - In The Aeroplane Over The Sea, Beach Boys - Pet Sounds, Anything By The Beatles, Carole King - Tapestry, George Harrison - All things must pass, John Lennon - John Lennon/Plastic Ono Band, Mothers Of Invention - We're Only In It For The Money, The Violent Femmes (album), Nico - Chelsea Girl, The Velvet Underground and Nico, Bjork - Post
  • Comment removed

  • nice choices!

  • Abbey Road dam near last. No U2, police, doors, stevie wonder, micheal jackson, fleetwood mac, queen, war, or e,w& f? the host has awful taste in music.

  • @craigblast No he doesn't, this is a really good list! Sure, no U2 or FM, but who cares? Look at all the other brilliant albums!

    @Robem69 I've no problem with the Beatles being at number 1, but I'd swap Revolver for the White Album or Sgt. Peppers. I'd also throw the Pixies in there somewhere...fantastic list all the same ;)

  • This list was made by someone who totally believed every rolling stone article ever. THINK FOR YOURSELF DUDE!! LISTEN TO SOME MUSIC THAT YOU DIDN'T READ ABOUT IN ROLLINGSTONE, OR SAW IT ON VH1, DUDE!!

  • Impressively eclectic - to have Zappa and Beatles on the same list. Only slightly disagree, Would put "Hot Rats" as highest for Zappa and "Sgt Pepper" as No 1. I know thats a cliche now - but , man, listen to the remastered CD on head-phones. Its so perfect it gives me chills. But Its all Great Apples and Great Oranges. Zappa is like listening to a mathematical puzzle and The Beatles just make you happy to be alive. VERY different experiences.

  • no radiohead?

  • blonde on blonde?

  • great list! your list has a lot of the same albums as mine. check it out if you want, although the audio was disabled on part 1

  • Very nice selection and hopefully you have still have a few on crackly vinyl.

  • No album is the best ever, in my opinion ;)

  • I know its your opinion, so it doesn't really matter, but c'mon, the highest Zeppelin is 38????? You sir, have a retarded musical palate. Any "Greatest Album" list needs at least 1 Zep album n the Top 10 just for some kind of credibility.

  • why is london calling so low???

  • Ok-ish selection. But there isn't really much variety.

    Soul? Jazz? Blues? Heavy Metal?

    Nice work on disregarding great genres.

  • Revolver is a really great album. Nice list.

  • nice 2see beefheart included......

  • IRON MAIDEN: BRAVE NEW WORLD...greatest album of all time

  • @Xnothinbetter2dewX No, def. not.

  • @thespecter2

    thats my opinion and nothins changing it...give the whole album a listen its a masterpiece..like all recent Iron Maiden albums 2000 up

  • @Xnothinbetter2dewX Really? Wasn't Iron Maiden out in the 80s? The only reason I am asking is because usually bands get worse later in their careers. What do you think is better about later Maiden stuff?

  • @thespecter2

    Iron Maiden was out in the 80's, but they are a rare band that just gets better with age... technicality and song writing is amazing.. i seen them back in august..great..if you would like i could give you some names of songs to check out off recent albums..if you are a music fan and not afraid of 7-8 minute songs you'll enjoy them

  • @Xnothinbetter2dewX Sure, go ahead and give them a send.

  • Dude you don't The Doors, Music From Big Pink, and Led Zeppelin IV on there?? Great list but those albums are ESSENTIAL.

  • wow you have great taste I agree with your top 100  cheers to you !!!!

  • bet he is 56 years old and votes on bush

  • @tjsson I bet not. In fact, all those artists he had up there wouldn't vote for Bush. Do you know anything about Bob Dylan? Or the Clash? Or John Lennon? You sir, are an idiot.

  • Nice list... I personally would have ranked Derrick and the Dominoes the best album of all time, followed by Dylan's Blood on the Tracks... Live Dead was a really good album, but I have a hard time characterizing anything other than being, literally, live at a Dead Show (which I've been to a number of) that high... Also, you left off any mention of Genesis... Why?They may have gotten pop/cheesy towards the end, but they produced some KICK @SS albums, from Trespass (1972) until Genesis (1983)

  • you may be the only man who agrees with me that revolver is indeed the greatest album of all time.

  • @borrist420 No, not the only one . . .

  • Excellent list!! I digg your taste. But I disagree with number one. hahah. I think Highway 61 is the greatest, or maybe Led Zeppelin IV.

  • thank you for not putting thriller on there

  • you're basically a beatles,bob dylan pink floyd fan. Bob dylan - the worst singer of all time. This list is shit.

  • @TheWolvie450 Fuck you, Dylan is not famous for his voice hes famous for his outstanding lyrics. Maybe if u took some of your precious time to listen to a song like desolation row, or It's Alright, Ma (I'm Only Bleeding, u would realise why hes held in such high regard. I hate people like u who know fuck all about him yet slate him idiot!!

  • @TheWolvie450 Bob Dylan is awesome as hell he has a amazing voice

  • @TheWolvie450 Bob Dylan is awesome as hell he has a amazing voice

  • @TheWolvie450

    Thanks for telling him what he is a fan of. He didnt know.

    And thanks for thinking your opinion is the last word. Where were you all these years. Please tell me what to listen to next..

    fag

  • Uncle Meat was the best Frank Zappa album.'The Hangmans Beautiful Daughter',anything by Laura Nyro and 'Blue' should've been in there too.Otherwise,not bad.

  • there are great ones on here but how did Led Zeppelin 4, Hotel California, and Back in Black not make the list?

  • @bleebleblabble50

    I'll tell you how. Read the heading, and concentrate on the words in brackets

  • When Court of the Crimson King is number 49, you know you're into a pretty damn good list.

  • yah i love the beatles the r fuckin awesome

  • lol, how original

  • Most of it's kick-arse! Great choices. Great honorable mentions too. Wolfmother is a very different story however.

  • 1. Definitely Maybe

  • I know the beatles were the biggest band of all time but my favorite has to be The Cure.

  • No Creedence Clearwater Revival????

  • No one makes an album like Pink Floyd does (well, cept solo roger waters)... I find it borderline impossible to not listen to them from start to finish every time, all the songs flow together so nicely. There are never any filler songs.

  • Trout Mask Replica should be #1,but a great list all the same!

  • I love Trout Mask Replica especially if ur tripping out on LSD

  • The Wall should be higher than 14, maybe like....1. Greatest album of all time.

  • i like the list. bowie is always on the top of my lists.

  • great list

  • Great List! I would add Moby Grape's debut album on there, but glad to see trout mask replica and Velvet underground debut on you list!

  • I think Dylan shaped the beetles up and without Dylan they would of continued to drone out I want to hold your hand and I love you yeah yeah yeah.

  • Remember he said (IN MY OPINION)!!!!So if you dont FEEL HIS TOP50 is SUITABLE to your taste post your OWN!!!! I think I'll give him 4 stars for all his effort!!!!Plus I enjoyed Stones song!!!!!!

  • i think blonde on blonde deserves to be on here, at least in the honorable mentions

  • mantis - umphrey's mcgee

  • Beatles are overrated.

  • To some extent, yes (they weren't the greatest, or the only, rock innovators of their time). But you really have to give it to them - they seem to have the stars lined up for them, from the start.

  • Of course, they did change music, and im not saying that's a bad thing, but i think there are bands much better out there but still people obsess over the Beatles.

  • even if you dont think they "sound" the greatest, music would not have evolved as it did without the beatles. they changed EVERYTHING.

  • so... your saying that they helped create todays excuse for music? In that case The Beatles are a lot worse than i thought...

  • yes, they inadvertently created the shitty pop music of today. but at the same time, they created the music we loved through the 70s and 80s man. you cant hate them for that.

  • Couldn't agree more.

  • Abbey Road at No40? This a joke,right?

  • great parade!! if i were you i would have put 1: are you experienced-jimi hendrix 2:sgt pepper's lonely hearts club band-the beatles 3: outlandos d'amourà- the police 4:magical mystery tour- the beatles 5:houses of the holy- Led Zeppelin 6 house of ska- a tribute to madness- Madenss 7:the raise and fall of ziggy staredust and spiders from mars- david bowie 8: discovery: daft punk 9 pet sound: the beach boys 10: my generation the who
  • Es increible como somos. Si tenemos que destacar los 50 mejores discos (como en este caso) siempre nos vamos atrás en el tiempo como si en los últimos 20 años no hubiese nada mejor que muchos de estos 50. Es como si quisiésemos demostrar que somos unos enormes entendidos. Seguramente si se hiciese la misma elección en 1980, muchos de estos buenos duiscos se habrían sustuido por otros más antiguos. ¿Ley natural no reconocer lo bueno en vida?.

  • Trout mask replica best ever

  • u left out led zepplen IV man that was the only one you missed

  • Better then any "VH1" top 50, I have ever seen. Good job!

  • great choice for #1. long live the beatles!

  • Great choice, but for Frank Zappa albums you forgot You Are What You Is, all the ones you picked are great though.

  • Excellent selection of albums here!! I would have put a number of them in different order . . . but it would be very difficult for me to pick any to remove from the list! I would have probably put Highway 61 at number 1 . . . Revolver at 2 . . . I would have had Springsteen's Nebraska album in the top 20 somewhere (somehow missed your list). All in all . . . very good selections!

  • What the fuck is wrong with that?

  • Missing out on decades of extremely good music, for one.

  • Listening to this decade of utter crap (well, mostly).

  • This has been one of the best decades ever for music. Probably the best since the 70s if not the 60s. And I just can't continue to respect anyone who claims that the Beatles are overrated. I'm sorry.

  • This is one of the worst decades ever for rock, if we hold the multiplicity of great artists as an absolute value.

  • this has been one of the best decades for music? as in the 2000's? Get the fuck out of here man you have no place here

  • @Toro953 Come now. No reason for that shit. If you take the time to actually listen to modern music you might find some insanely rewarding albums. You can't live in the past.

  • hey man, im all for some new bands like radiohead and muse. what im saying is that the majority of them sound the same and they are so repetitive in their music that i cant even tell them apart aside from their singer.

  • @edtpjp get the hell outta here man

  • Still, in essence, you're missing out on some very good albums from this decade. See John Zorn or Sleepytime Gorilla Museum or, heck, even Devin Townsend, for details.

  • Great taste in music!!! Highway 61 is a great album and one of my favourites too! but Blonde on Blonde is better! (and that's my poinion!)

  • Queen 4ever!

    Blame the list!

  • ..and you wanna add The Dreaming Kate Bush. Agree about the Zappa stuff though

  • where the fuck is SHEER HEART ATTACK?  and the white stripes before any REM album lol are you serious?

  • Most of those albums I own. You have a very good taste in music...

  • jesus what a load of douchebag comments...

    this man obviously has good taste in music.

  • Except for your penchant for the Beatles...ya got great taste.

  • I liked the list, but how is Led Zeppelin IV just an honorable mention?!

  • i dont agree with you

  • not bad of a list but you forgot The Doors and you placed Wolfmother way too high on the list.

  • far too skewed to rock, what about jazz and classical too...and...and....and, definitely no thriller shite there thank god and Bruce ??, forget that..

  • totally agree. the boss? hes the boss of fuck all. liked a few of ur selections but found some 2 be a bit pretentious, any tom, DICK or harry could pull the majority of these off any "greatest album" list, total gash, get some originality about u.

  • I like many of the same artists, but I'd have different albums and in differing orders. You have good taste. This is a daunting task.

  • Wheres Micheal Jacksons Thriller?

  • This is his list, and given the artists and time period he prefers, Michael Jackson wouldn't belong on this list. Now, Thriller is a great album but you have to allow for people's taste on these things. He is presenting his favorite albums, and he's heavily influenced by 60s's-70's rock and roll.

    Was Axis Bold as Love on the list?

  • 1) Murmur- R.E.M

    2) Let it Bleed- Rolling Stones

    3) Doolittle- the Pixies

    4) Paul's Boutique- Beastie Boys

    5) Odessey and Oracle- The Zombies

    6) The Bends- Radiohead

    7) Exile on Main Street- Rolling Stones

    8) Funeral- Arcade Fire

    9) Automatic for the People- R.E.M

    10) Magical mystery Tour- The Beatles

  • Fail. all wrong.

  • fuck you, dickweasel, they're all great albums and either way it's down to personal taste. why don't you tell me your top ten so i can pass judgement on whatever it is you like?

  • lol. No one has ever heard of thoes albums you lised except for the beatles one.

  • you, sir, clearly have no knowledge of music; who hasn't heard of let it bleed and exile on mainstreet by the rolling stones (both of which are in the top twenty of this list), odessey and oracle was ranked as the 80th best album of all time on rolling stone's top 500 albums list, the bends was 110 and doolittle was on there somewhere, so people have heard of them, just because too much of a fucking idiot to have isn't my fault. automatic for the people is also very famous

  • also paul's boutique is by the beastie boys, one they're totally mainstream and everyone knows who they are, two it's actually listed on the description for the video under honourable mention.

    so fuck off, you know nothing wankshaft

  • I'v heard of every single album on this list

    idiot

  • the best one ever is trout mask replica