Added: 4 years ago
From: katem3
Views: 89,253
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (358)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • You have a beautiful voice Kate.And this is one of my fav. songs.I know you can cover this better.Sing it a little bit slower.This one's too fast

  • I love this cover :) I'm learning from it! check out my channel :)

  • keep on playing guitar but stop singing please

  • I like it :)

  • your voice is beautiful ...

  • Im not gonna say some cheesy shit, im gonna say what i think. this is the best cover of this song ive heard possibly ever. you sang it simple, the way this song should be. and you were REAL, it wasnt all hollywooded up. Anyway, there's my two cents.

  • this is simply great.

  • @jakass317 yeah, cheers for this useful insight.

  • i like pie

  • you did a beautiful job at this song!!! :) <3

  • what a beautiful voice! like your note at 0:39 and 1:27.

  • Not bad at all. I wish I could play guitar.  Thanks for sharing your gift

  • Not easy to sing, & crazy lyrics. I liked it.

  • Great cover. You have an amazing voice.

  • Those 73 dislikes were probably miss clicks. there is no way anyone could dislike this.

  • its not you but the song sounds very hallow using a classical. loses the passion. however this vid is 2 years old so i doubt you care :)

  • Great cover!!!!!....right up there with the original!!!!!.......Beautiful voice and awesome guitar playing.....dont ever stop!!!

  • ignore the haters, you play and sing this song great! anyone who has tried to learn this song knows it it's not easy to sing and play and remember all the lyrics. cheers keep it up!

  • <3 this

  • katem3....your dumb i like how this girl sings ever your the same person....j/k if that was one of ur first songs the you have natural talent and thats a turn on....keep it goin

  • Great job.

  • Horry shit you got a beautiful voice

  • I like it...substance in in the content which showed your true potential to be perfect in your own right!

    PnL

  • my daughter has the same guitar

  • Not that wonderfull, I`m sorry...but has to be a good taste in music ;-)

    probably its amazing how much likes a beautiful girl with middle talent has got, and how less a normal looking with taltent...sad, but don`t worry, your beauty could open you a lot of doors ;-)

  • how are you not as famous as justine bieber you have way more talent then her

  • Not gonna lie, i think it sounds a bit better when you sing it, good job :{D

  • This girl has insane potential! All that's needed is some good production behind her but seriously, that voice is so good.

  • this is amazing!

  • you are so beautiful, and your voice too...

    :*

  • wow, you are soo amazing at singing and guitar <3 and you're also suuuuper pretty :]

    love this song, btw

  • i started with a classical too :D

  • you beautiful beautiful music

  • Yeah... you need to remake this at some point

  • I absolutely LOVE this cover. This is one of my favorite songs of all time so (Y)!!! Your voice and accent are both amazing :D<333

  • i would marry you

  • I could tell you had some sort of British accent... And I was right, as I see your website has .uk at the end. Pretty good cover also.

  • chords?

    

  • This is awful... wow I regret watching my oldest videos

  • @katem3 Get off of your own case. It's not that bad. There is some nervousness in it that makes it work, not to mention that you played correctly.

  • @katem3 Its not that bad, hahaha, a cute girl can never have a "bad" video!

  • @katem3 As I stressed earlier, Gotta have you was pretty good.

  • @katem3 It's not awful, it's quite good actually. But then I'm canadian so who gives a fuck.

  • @katem3 i'm taking singing lessons for 2 years now and i really like that vid :D

  • @katem3 it's not bad, you did quite well! don't be so cynical.

  • @katem3 yeah yeah awful ... but you're voice is just wonderful and makes me smile. 1000 times better than all the other covers!

  • @katem3 I love it!

  • @katem3 I just watched this video and then watched your cover of 'I will follow you into the dark' - You have gotten infinitely better in that time.

  • i love you.

    

  • Everyone says "Like a girl takes to the wind"

    But it's "Like a gull takes to the wind"

    Pretty good cover.

  • Nice cover, enjoyed hearing it. Wish i had skills like that.

  • If you think you sound like a 80 yrs old, then I must sound like a 1000 yrs old monster.

  • You have done a great job with this song you are the only one that I have found so far that plays this close to the original version thanks :-)

  • beautiful girl and beautiful music are great combination's

  • very good cover, especially with the others out there

  • "You haven't got much power in your voice" would an "expert" say. But I think your voice is sweet and you got the mood of the song. I really like this cover.

  • Holy fuck, you're perfect. We have identical taste in music.

  • love it :)

  • Well done! I've got a Chilean Red and your integrity tonight :D

  • Takes guts to post a vid in the 1st place. I enjoyed it, I love British accents, they're sexy as hell

  • I think its beautiful :)

  • I just made a cover of this song, Love it, you should check mine out and let me know what you think... Great Job!!

  • @Passion4Rock88 : It's not bad, but the reason why I like this version (Kate McGill) is because she sings it like she means it- very passionate and loud.

  • not bad, i like it. and you probably already know this, but youre pretty

  • :DD awesome!

  • Even Britney Spears could cover this song and it´ll be good. This ones ok...

  • Comment removed

  • @iwaslikeMUFFINS that wavering voice is called vibrato. lol

  • you did absolutely fantastic. really. c;

  • @iwaslikeMUFFINS thats called vibrato just so ya know.

  • i love your accent!

  • This is beautiful :)

  • terrible !

  • You got it.Keep it up.Your an angel

  • I Love You.

  • This is really good! I love this song and this is a wonderful cover!

  • you gave me goosebumbs and you made a tear come out.... you truly have an amazing and unique voice. i fucking love you.

  • it's funny, it ain't perfect, but i just spent the last half hour looking for good covers of this song and this is the best

  • @Shermanicus

    agreed!

  • @Shermanicus u really didnt look that hard mate

  • you remind me a lot of things!!!!!!!!!!!

  • i think that everybody loves this girl, i mean she's awesome (:

    @jocluiz261191

  • Comment removed

  • GIL Says: i LOVE THAT GIRL (L)

    Youtube user /katem3

    

  • great cover!! I love it! I'm so glad I'm not an asshole who posts mean things about really good musicians.

  • you sing really well and these cute bye!!! :D

  • Best cover I've seen :) beautiful job :)

  • i liked it and added to my favourites, bravo =)

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Like :)

  • Dislike

  • Awesome... I can't even tell what the hell they're saying 75% of the time... Great music though. Good cover :)

  • omg your new cover on myspace is sooo much better wow!

  • Bloody hell shes a brit

  • i would.

  • sounds great like it much :)

  • I love that you love the shins <3

  • You gotta learn how to breathe, it'll help with keeping your pitch at the lower end of your range.

  • Hey nice cover!

    what're the chords to this song?

  • Mediocre...

  • this is really good :)

  • Nice cover, your voice is good but that guitar is just so wrong for this song.. and most Shins songs for that matter. It sounds so dull and lifeless, look forward to hearing you playing a guitar that compliments your voice :)

  • you are fucking stellar.

    that is a fakt

  • Whompus.

  • beautiful :)

  • this is my favourite song, and you did such an amazing job :)

  • Awesome. I love this song, and you're cute/talented, making this an excellent video.

  • Love Love Loooove this song, more shins please :)

  • more shins!

  • Genial :)

  • that was really good! nice work :)

  • im starting to like her version better

  • Comment removed

  • love it x

  • Pretty decent. The song is awesome so you can't go wrong

  • cool

  • you're really good! and you have really good taste in music!

  • beautifull song and beautifull girl. hug, (Y)

  • your voice is very pretty (: very calming. take it somewhere. take it far.

  • I very much like it. ^^

  • Nice, but I think the guitar would sound better if a steel string.

  • I love your accent. It sounds awesome.

  • this song is amazing!

  • I really love this, I find this a hard song to cover.

  • i didn't think it was that terrible. good job!

  • i thought you did a lovely job, keep up the good work :-)

  • @SalElizabethh If she takes off her top, I'll reconsider my original opinion.

  • sweet ^^

  • I don't think you should pay any attention to pukakalains comment. Your voice was great. I really like your The Shins covers. You have a mellowness that fits really good with The Shins songs, I think

  • If you can still get a chill from a cover, thats gotta say something : )

  • I like it :) but is the microphone really necessary?

  • well i happen to think you did a good job, and seem to handle criticism well

  • your voice is fine. this pukapussy fag thinks hes simon cawell

  • @onehumorlesshaha She. She thinks she's Simon Cowell.

  • don listen to pukakalain, you sang it your way and thats fine

  • why does every person i find doing a cover of something sounds irish?

  • yay! the shins cover FTW

  • @pukakalain I agree. But this was 2 years ago...I like to think I have progressed. x

  • @katem3 i think your voice is really good, ignore him/her :) x

  • @katem3 why did you agree to such shittyrubbish? cmon jealousy there. you've progressed lots but ''your voice is terrible and off key''? hell no.

  • @katem3  puk is obviously jealous. You did great and you sounded nice. =)

  • @katem3 that person is a dick, you arent really that off key, i mean lets see them upload a video of them playing guitar and singing - not going to happen because they like to hide behind a youtube username and talk trash on people with more talent.

  • @katem3 it's still probably better than the fucker's voice who wrote that comment. I think you're a great singer and this is a great cover!

  • @katem3 dont lisson to that idiot you have a beautiful voice and sang this song like an angel!

  • @katem3 you should do this song again because your better :)

  • @katem3 It sounds great to me!

  • @pukakalain lmao

  • Comment removed

  • @wojtal1984

    Oh God, that hurt so bad.

  • @pukakalain you obviously know nothing about music if you think she is off key.... fucking tard

  • @pukakalain sounds fine to me. i hope you can do better, and even if you can it still makes you a dick for talking shit.

  • @pukakalain I'd like to hear how you sound. You bitch! Also, she is amazing.

  • Great rendition. Also, you're quite cute. :)

  • FWIW, I like your blonde hair better than your hair in this video.

  • seriously did not need that microphone and amp. were you playing at a large venue, or in your bedroom all alone?

  • first off this cover sucks, your voice sucks,

  • u rock!

  • good. not your best

  • my all time favortie song. i love you for this. thanks.

  • this was the first video i saw of you.

  • I agree no one will ever do this as well as the shins but i liked it

  • I want to kill you!!! You ruined it!!! LEAVE IT TO THE MEN!!! .....bitch

  • good job.. i really like your version of an already amazing song!

    you're really cute too.. this video makes me smile. keep doing what you're doing!

    Lucas

  • @elmntree "your cute too..." fucking fag cunt pedo pervert talking nice to her like he gonna get some then drops lucas on the end fuck me mate if i was you i would jump off a bridge and end my shit nothing life

  • @tzr2005 loollolololll you need angermanagement foo! i sense guy creepin too, but you totally called on it X a billion! way overboard man!

  • @DHLHC just because i think she is great at guitar and cute.. makes me a creep? there are alot of worse things being said on this video. if were opposite sex, and about the same age there is nothing pedo, perv, or faggy about it. sorry for the disturbance my comment caused.

  • @elmntree you hitting on her via interweb is pedo. btw katem3 id totally bang you, so whatdya say?

  • muy bien guapa!

    respect!

  • I like it, beautyful! really! a good interpretation!

  • awsome cover, nice accent

  • good effort...saw them when they came to Aus in 2006..highlight!!

  • i would agree that no one can ever beat the shins when trying to cover but from all of the ones i've heard i'd say yours are the best! you truly have a talent! keep up the good work :)

  • impressive.

  • Im very impressed this is a very hard song to cover just b/c the shins set the bar so high