Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (76)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Why couldn't they put the final verse in the 2004 movie?

    I mean, why did they have to make Raoul sing the "In this Labyrinth"?

  • Good job!

  • This actually made it watchable, Thanks! Nice job! What could have been.....

  • the word triumph was low on the first syllable, THEN high. e-e believe me, ive seen ALL the versions to know.

  • you guys are morons. michael crawford and sarah brightman only sang in theater, they never created a movie. this movie was created in 2004. the phantom in the movie is played by gerard butler and christine is played by emma rossum.

  • @crazysocksgirl13 Thanks for enlightening everyone

  • omg reading these comments is unnerving - this is how Phantom is SUPPOSED to sound. ;). 

  • yes the Phantom movie was rather disappointing...not only the casting but trimming the title song? wth? Great work here! Now I can enjoy it again!!

  • Why have you cut this guys voice into the movie? I was all excited to have found the movie but... this... is disappointing

  • haha thats whats diffrent i was thinking thats not how i remeber gerard butler sounding like when i first watched it

  • This is awesome I remember I would play the soundtrack over the movie when I would watch it cause the actors in the movie...their voices are just bleh. :3

  • my fave Opera :D

  • Sarah Brightman has a much better voice than Emmy Rossum

  • i personally thought the movie cast was best, and this was after i fell in love with the orig, but this is soo cool.

  • Hey! Now I can actually stand to watch this movie! Yay!

  • you have my greatest thanks for making this wondrous work for dubbing with the original cast recording.. the original movie singers just killed the show

  • Im sorry They both have great voices now doubt but i prefer the original voices of the stars in this movie its more melodic :D

  • Holy crap!! Michael Crawford's voice coming out of Gerard Butler's body?! MY PRAYERS HAVE BEEN ANSWERED!!!!

  • I love you. Seriously, I love you. Now I can show this movie to my boyfriend and not have to listen to Butler's hideous voice. Crawford's is perfection incarnate.

  • WTF IS THIS?!!!? MICHAEL CRAWFORD CANT SING!!!!!

  • I really, really, really wish there was a way to here Emmy and Michael sing this.

  • My understanding is that originally around 1990 or so, ALW had been planning that there WOULD be a POTO musical movie in the works WITH Michael Crawford and Sarah Brightman. But "complications" arose (I think the marriage between Webber and Brightman hit a rocky point) and it was never done. Michael Crawford always said, even around the time this movie was made, that he'd have been glad to voice the Phantom - as he SHOULD HAVE! At least we now have MC's great voice if not his physical role.

  • This is very well done, and I agree with everyone on here. This was Micheal Crawford's and Sarah Brightman's. They will always and forever be The Phantom and Christine.

  • the movie was fairly well done in my opinion (with the exception of butler), but god damnit those moving arm candle holder things are just RIDICULOUS.

  • wait...where did the horse come from? did i miss something?

  • omg its micheals ghost using butler as his puppet

  • 'I am there, inside!'

    Believe me, I wish you were!

  • @Lotto15719 HA! xD

  • I have to say the singing voiced are really good, but I do believe the voices of butler and rossum have a sort of connection. Like Butlers has a rough edge to it and makes it seem that the phantom is obsessed but also a genuis. Rossum has that professional sound to it for she is singing broadway (her character is).

  • @BlueAnimator101 I totally agree, regarding their connection, perhaps Butler is not an opera singer, but he deserves credit, for he was a very passionate Phantom. Your expression makes so much sense we can perceive his sorrow and and passion for her. All in all I liked Butler. Sorry

  • i like this song better with antonio banderas singing it

  • I wish they had either dubbed Michael Crawford's voice in the movie, or got someone who was a better singer. Gerard Butler's voice was sooo weak in the role.

  • this is my favorite song and scene

  • why didn't you put the actual movie cast songs in. I liked that too

  • BRILLIANT!!

    

  • Love this version of Phantom of the Opera song. It has a cooler beat than the movie version, although I like that version too. I kinda perfer the movie Christine in this song but I'm falling in love with the Michael Crawford Phantom!

  • Sarah is good, (I won't deny it) but I think Emmy Rossum sounds better.

  • Gerard Butler did FANTASTIC for someone with no musical history. I think it was a amazing and 10 thousand times better than crawford ever could.

  • 6:11 HAHA rape cage :)

  • Hey its "echoes"

  • great dubbing makes it so much better great work

  • Oh look, now this film might actually be watchable. They overdubbed for Carlotta but couldn't be bothered for Gerald Butler's sake? And yay! I don't have to hear Emmy's thin voice. I actually found her singing painful and weak in some scenes.

  • SOOO MUCH BETTERRRR

  • i like this version for the sole reason it's fans aren't jerard butler fan-girls. also Michael can actually sing.

  • This movie really does suck. Wow. I'm only working through it because Michael is dubbed in. I'm still freaked out by the arm-delabras going down to the lair. I have been harangued into watching this

    Thank you immensely for all your hard work dubbing this.

  • I can understand why they didn't want Brightman and Crawford in the movie when it was shot. It was because they were too old for the roles. Brightman was in her early 40's and Crawford was in his 60's, but they could of at least dubbed the voices. They did it for Carlotta, they can do it for Erik and Christine. Yeah, then we wouldn't have to deal with the quality of Emmy and Gerry's voices.

  • @glamgirlsg Actually in the book Erik would have been about the same age as MC was at the time of taping. Also MC did NOT look his age at that time at all. He was, is and always will be the Phantom... He doesn't need costume and makeup to slip into the character and BE Erik.

  • Very good work! Couldn't tell it was a dub!

  • I know people are going to hate me for saying this, but I like Em's voice compared to Sarah's...I definately like Michael's better than Gerard's though.

  • i felt kinda stupid when i first watched this (not insulting the maker). the voice for the phantom doesn't fit the...... facial structure i want to say. It's like when you see a really big guy and he has a really squeaky voice. then i saw that it was dubbed and i was like, "Oooohhhh! Okay! i get it."

  • This is gorgeous. Thanks so much for doing this. :)

  • omg it was so weird to hear sarah's voice coming from emmy o.O

  • The only thing that is great about this is the original lyrics (which technically this is not the original lyrics either) though Michael Crawfords voice dosent fit the role as phantom that much, i admit he did a great job. But the phantom is suppose to have a beautiful voice, his voice dosent really fit.

  • @MirandaRiann um...... i <3 gerry as phantom but i mean.... michael was the better singer

  • This just sounds soooo right with the original stage version soundtrack dubbed in,bravo phantomofopera91,please get this up as 1 solid file a.s.a.p.,

  • no the songs

  • Great work dubbing this! do you have this uploaded anywhere as one complete divx file?

  • @TFreakburg No i'm afraid i don't. Maybe someday i will

  • @phantomofopera91

    This is wonderful, thanks! I love Phantom and it sounds even better in dubbed form! Emmie Rosem is amazing!!

  • To me, this is the song Gerry messed up the most! So thanks for fixing it!

  • WOW! The phantom is so good he makes pepole sing better with his meer presance.

  • hey were did you get this at

  • @GodzillaMr I made it

  • @phantomofopera91 imean the song

  • @GodzillaMr well its the original cast recording. i could have got it from any number of places but i probably got the songs from a friend

  • @phantomofopera91 K THANKS CUZ I CANT FIND THEM ANY WERE

  • @phantomofopera91 Good work with all the re dubbing I am impressed with how you did all of them good job way to dub Gerard and Emmy!

  • I agree if they were not going to use Michael they needed someone who sounded more like him. Gerard Butler just could not pull it off. I will say think Michael was the best! The lady playing Christine has a great voice!

  • @vienna319 the Original lead was Sarah Brightman and she is singing in this or are you referring Emmy Rossom who played Christine in the movie?

  • AMAZING but I wish It was Michael there not Butler Michael was soooooooo much more commanding in the role his voice his actions were all so fluid and beautiful.

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more