@c6rocks It's not meant to be a complete sailing solution. Just demonstrates the principle which can be applied to other boats which have the ability to sail on different tacks.
I doubt the validity of this project. I'm pretty sure you need a guy with a fishing line at the other end of the water you are crossing to pull the boat across as the wind hitting the blades pushes back on the craft harder than the propeller can ever push you forward. It that weren't the case, then we could do the same with cars and we'd all do 70 mph down the highway without using any thing but our own airspeed.
@dlstb You need to check out the other videos on my channel before coming to that conclusion. I've lost count of the number of people who have said exactly the same thing. They and you fail to understand that the power comes from the difference between the velocities of the wind and the water. In the case you mention about the car, the velocities would be the same so that's why it doesn't work.
@dlstb Instead of having 'doubt's and considering yourself smart because of it, why not go get a basic education? The wind isn't blowing the blades back, it's blowing them around. With the spinning and flow of the wind the blades need to be on a diagonal, but the force imparted by the wind is almost all pushing it around faster, not back. Use that to spin a prop, which has far higher traction in the denser water, and it will easily pull the boat forward against the small drag of the wind.
if you had a variable pitch, and wider blades, you could sail downwind, having the wind push the static blades when they were in the no pitch position (that is, showing as much blade width to the wind). Of course, you could also reverse the pitch as well and get propulsion downwind, too. You could use a micro switch on a weather vane to determine the optimal pitch angle depending on the wind direction and the desired direction using a feedback control system........hmm
@hbunnie1120 It's not really for downwind work. Normal sails can do that quite well already. It's just directly upwind is impossible for them. Some sort of hybrid might be a good idea. This for direct upwind with maybe wingsail for other points of sailing. Please check out my channel for other videos on this subject.
@Splitsquid Thanks for your kind words. Yes, indeed there is a RC version. Please check my channel where you can find my other videos on the same subject.
@ZKMX7 "Think" might be too strong a word here. This person simply can't appreciate what's being demonstrated here and your video lacks the sex and violence needed to keep the attention of the average Youtuber. Your boat is cool, nice work.
I watched! I look like a very experimental project boat! I'm only an electric guitar player who sing from my heart. At the moment I look for a bassist, a drummer and other members and a life sharer for the my band. Also all support and help are welcome! I vote up because it look like a very experimental project boat and also piano there sounds in my mind great!
...and turbosails are born... welcome !!!!
srm13560 3 days ago
What if you want to go a different direction? Wait for a favorable wind?
c6rocks 6 days ago
@c6rocks It's not meant to be a complete sailing solution. Just demonstrates the principle which can be applied to other boats which have the ability to sail on different tacks.
ZKMX7 6 days ago
I doubt the validity of this project. I'm pretty sure you need a guy with a fishing line at the other end of the water you are crossing to pull the boat across as the wind hitting the blades pushes back on the craft harder than the propeller can ever push you forward. It that weren't the case, then we could do the same with cars and we'd all do 70 mph down the highway without using any thing but our own airspeed.
dlstb 1 week ago
@dlstb You need to check out the other videos on my channel before coming to that conclusion. I've lost count of the number of people who have said exactly the same thing. They and you fail to understand that the power comes from the difference between the velocities of the wind and the water. In the case you mention about the car, the velocities would be the same so that's why it doesn't work.
ZKMX7 1 week ago
@ZKMX7 you mean the difference in viscosity between air and water?
JebacPresretac101 6 days ago
@JebacPresretac101 No, the velocity, not viscosity.
ZKMX7 6 days ago
@dlstb Instead of having 'doubt's and considering yourself smart because of it, why not go get a basic education? The wind isn't blowing the blades back, it's blowing them around. With the spinning and flow of the wind the blades need to be on a diagonal, but the force imparted by the wind is almost all pushing it around faster, not back. Use that to spin a prop, which has far higher traction in the denser water, and it will easily pull the boat forward against the small drag of the wind.
ModelLights 5 days ago
GREAT IDEA TAKING NOTE!
808Hea 1 month ago
woooow :) that is wery nice, youst whis that it was mine :P
skjevemartin 1 month ago
exelente trabajo ( cool work)
telchar186 2 months ago
Why did they bother teaching us conservation of momentum at school?!
olivercoles87 2 months ago
if you had a variable pitch, and wider blades, you could sail downwind, having the wind push the static blades when they were in the no pitch position (that is, showing as much blade width to the wind). Of course, you could also reverse the pitch as well and get propulsion downwind, too. You could use a micro switch on a weather vane to determine the optimal pitch angle depending on the wind direction and the desired direction using a feedback control system........hmm
bradmacaboy 3 months ago
Just wondering how well does it sail down wind..?.. Just wondering. It is a very cool demonstration..
hbunnie1120 3 months ago
@hbunnie1120 It's not really for downwind work. Normal sails can do that quite well already. It's just directly upwind is impossible for them. Some sort of hybrid might be a good idea. This for direct upwind with maybe wingsail for other points of sailing. Please check out my channel for other videos on this subject.
ZKMX7 3 months ago
great job! whats the name of the song?
Stoettax 4 months ago
@Stoettax Thanks. "All of Me" - Jon Schmidt - Check out jonschmidtdotcom
ZKMX7 4 months ago
Congratulations, Beautiful achievement. Can you steer it with RC rudders? Does it work in any other direction.
Splitsquid 5 months ago
@Splitsquid Thanks for your kind words. Yes, indeed there is a RC version. Please check my channel where you can find my other videos on the same subject.
ZKMX7 5 months ago
Hoax! You used battery power. Shame on you!!
file83 7 months ago
@file83
Please let me know why you think that!
ZKMX7 7 months ago
@ZKMX7 "Think" might be too strong a word here. This person simply can't appreciate what's being demonstrated here and your video lacks the sex and violence needed to keep the attention of the average Youtuber. Your boat is cool, nice work.
EyeSquaredAre 4 months ago
how does it turn itself toward the wind? I dont see a tail thing behind the windmill.
Ashitanoyuki 7 months ago
@Ashitanoyuki
The drag of the rotor itself works the same way as a windvane - it doesn't need anything else to keep it pointing into the wind.
ZKMX7 7 months ago
@ZKMX7 very nice %
ej20daZe 5 months ago
@ZKMX7 AYE, it be true! I have seen a few actual wind generators work like that.
gaypotter 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I watched! I look like a very experimental project boat! I'm only an electric guitar player who sing from my heart. At the moment I look for a bassist, a drummer and other members and a life sharer for the my band. Also all support and help are welcome! I vote up because it look like a very experimental project boat and also piano there sounds in my mind great!
DirtyAssa 7 months ago
thats beautiful! :D
xXDarkMidnightSunXx 11 months ago
Works even better with vertical fan...then you can move in any direction.
Donsfast 1 year ago
but why couldn't you add this to a light car model and drive for free? and a little extra juice from solor panels.
markfriesen1979 1 year ago
@markfriesen1979
You could. There is no reason why you shouldn't.
ZKMX7 1 year ago
Quite interesting! I've enjoyned!
Lucasquinamo 1 year ago
You just gave me an Idea for my project
frilink 1 year ago
have you tried this with a heavier boat?
sheerterror77 1 year ago
@sheerterror77 Certainly have. Check out my other videos or search under "windmill driven boat"
ZKMX7 1 year ago
That's beautiful! I just had that same idea today -- awesome to see that it works!
saab93secv 1 year ago
song name?
Reallaty 2 years ago
"First Run"
By Jon Schmidt
(New age piano player)
ZKMX7 2 years ago
@ZKMX7 i dont think thats the song i searched and it sounds nothing like this
Reallaty 2 years ago
Comment removed
Reallaty 2 years ago
Comment removed
Reallaty 2 years ago
that it amazing i thought of somethinglike this when i was 4
i never thought it be possible
s0undw4v3ultra 2 years ago
Its very nice free energy depend wind!
vroom350 2 years ago
Ok, thank you very much for your answer.
Do you think to show both the windmill and the propeler on a next video ?
Alomphega 2 years ago
Hi Peter,
Good job, so I have a question : is there a propeler under the water ?
GC
Alomphega 2 years ago
Yes, there is a propeller, otherwise it could not go directly against the wind.
ZKMX7 2 years ago