Gilmour, Wright & Mason: Pink Floyd - Arnold Layne live FULL VERSION

[phoenicianA]

stop arguing like babies !!! Roger Waters is my best composer and Gilmour is my best guitarist, Rick and Nick too. That's why Pink floyd is the best band ever !!!

[TerdVader]

It's kind of disappointing that before the song starts someone screams for Roger Waters. I'm all for Roger Waters, but if I was there, and these 3 talented guys came out to pay their respects for a friend that passed, I think in this moment, it's not the time for yelling for a reunion. Even the band seems a bit stunned. How do you respond to that!?!? Nice rendition BTW :)

[jeanperiquito]

who is playing on this?

Is that Robyn Hitchcock on second keyboards?

[jaruel37]

I think the 2nd keyboard player may be Jon Carin, it's tough to tell from the quality of the video.

[RayManzarekGod]

@jaruel37 Judging from the hair, dress, and figure, it looks like him, and he is practically ALWAYS the secondary player, either for Waters, or Gilmour, or Floyd.

[Kurbisa]

19. A Great Day For Freedom

20. Coming Back To Life

21. Lost For Words

22. High Hopes

So do your math. And I should point out that Gilmour's work can be found in 26 years (1968 1994), Waters' in 15 years. And now, if you don't want to look at the facts, fuck off.

[TheElusiveBirdMan]

buuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuurrrrrrrr­rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrnn­nnnnnneeeeeeeeed. lol

[dragmio]

When you put it like that, there are more Dave's great songs than Roger's. He obviously went for quality not quantity. But of course, they were at their best when Rick joined them in composing. His harmonic progressions were unbelievable. There aren't many of Rick's songs on PF albums because he was a nice guy. There are many of Roger's because he's an egomaniac. And that's all there's to it.

[Kurbisa]

6. Wish You Were Here (with Waters' help for the verses) 7. Dogs 8. Young Lust (with Waters' additional musical bits) 9. Comfortably Numb 10. Run Like Hell 11. Signs Of Life 12. The Dogs Of War 13. On The Turning Away 14. Yet Another Movie 15. A New Machine (Pts. 1 & 2) 16. Terminal Frost 17. Sorrow 18. Poles Apart

[Kurbisa]

53. Take Your Filthy Hands (...) 54. The Fletcher Memorial Home 55. Southampton Dock 56. The Final Cut 57. Not Now John 58. Two Suns in The Sunset 59. Free Four Gilmour alone wrote the following musics: 1. A Spanish Piece 2. The Narrow Way (Pts. 1, 2 & 3) 3. Fat Old Sun 4. What's Uh The Deal 5. Childhood's End

[Kurbisa]

39. Bring The Boys Back Home 40. The Show Must Go On 41. In The Flesh! 42. Waiting For The Worms 43. Stop! 44. Outside The Wall 45. When The Tigers Broke Free 46. The Happiest Days of our Lives 47. The Post War Dream 48. Your Possible Pasts 49. One of The Few 50. The Hero's Return (Pts. 1 & 2) 51. The Gunner's Dream 52. Paranoid Eyes

[Kurbisa]

24. In The Flesh? 25. The Thin Ice 26. Another Brick In The Wall (Pts. 1, 2 & 3) 27. Mother 28. Goodbye Blue Sky 29. What Shall We Do Now? 30. Empty Spaces 31. One of My Turns 32. Don't Leave Me Now 33. The Last Few Bricks 34. Goodbye Cruel World 35. Hey You 36. Is There Anybody In There? 37. Nobody Home 38. Vera

[tjrrockandrollmaster]

@Kurbisa The Last Few Bricks was Waters/Gilmour. The writing credits on Is There Anybody Out There Sony reissue rectified the misprint on the original issue.

[Kurbisa]

11. Grantchester Meadows 12. Several Species of Small Furry Animals (...) 13. If 14. Saint Tropez 15. Julia Dream 16. Biding My Time 17. Money 18. Brain Damage 19. Eclipse 20. Welcome To The Machine 21. Pigs On The Wing (Pts. 1 & 2) 22. Pigs 23. Sheep

[tjrrockandrollmaster]

@Kurbisa However, David and Rick's arranged Roger's demos to make the songs what they did. It was after Wish You Were Here it became about Roger Waters and cut Rick Wright out then Nick Mason and then have David Gilmour as his session guitarist.

[Kurbisa]

@tjrrockandrollmaster Thank you for the update. I really am a devoted Floyd fan, and in the Gilmour - Waters feud I am on Waters' side, but I'm not here to underrate anybody's contribution and I do respect Gilmour's work. The main reason this comments pissed me off is the enormous quantity of ignorance coming from "Roger was grumpy" and all this bullshit. Another thing: those demos (The Wall) were arranged by Waters - Gilmour - Ezrin.

[tjrrockandrollmaster]

@Kurbisa I was more a Gilmour and Wright fan. However I saw the feud as double the music. The Wall demos were a Gilmour/Waters/Ezrin. In fact, Nobody Home was the last song written for The Wall. David and Bob didn't like some of the demos Roger wanted so he went back to his hotel in Los Angeles in a rage and wrote Nobody Home (David Gilmour told Redbeard of In the Studio fame that "Nobody Home" was fantastic and I agree).

[Kurbisa]

@tjrrockandrollmaster Yeah, I know the "Nobody Home" story, and I respect your Gilmour - Wright admiration. I repeat that the reason of my comments weren't the "who' s better story", it was having enough of "fans" who'd dismiss Waters.

[Kurbisa]

Dear Brrrr, Waters alone wrote the following MUSICS (talking about MUSICS, not LYRICS!!!) 1. Take Up Thy Sthetoscope And Walk 2. Corporal Clegg 3. Set The Controls (...) 4. Let There Be More Light 5. Cirrus Minor 6. The Nile Song 7. Crying Song 8. Green Is The Colour 9. Cymbaline 10. Embryo

[Kurbisa]

(...) So when "The Wall" was released (which is the second most sold album ever, right after "Thriller", and which is almost entirely written by "the prick") the financial trouble became history, and with the movie they made a big deal of cash too: Wright was officialy fired in 1979, and not in 1982, after the movie. There are too many so called "Pink Floyd hardcore fans" who are very ignorant about their "so beloved" band, and so they underrate the "prick", who made Pink Floyd great.

[Kurbisa]

Dear paramedic, the so called "prick" was the guy who gave the band his megapopularity in the Seventies: and the Seventies obviously were the most successful period of the band: the "prick" wrote the lyrics of their greatest albums, and even the majority of the music: on "Dark Side of the Moon", there are more Wright's writing credits than Gilmour's. About "The Wall", what you' re saying is a bunch of crap: they all were in a financial crisis in 1978 (...)

[jajah62]

Midwestmidnight, i respect your point of view, but, to me, look at Roger's lives without Dave, he misses tooooooo much, Roger even took 2 guitarists to do what Dave did alone....

Look at Dave's lives, Roger does not miss that much, it sounds very good without him...

[Cgrrp]

@jajah62 actually Pink Floyd used a second guitarist on a lot of their tours (usually Snowy White) even before they split. Not taking a side, just pointing that out. So technically Waters isn't using 2 guitarists live to "do what Dave did alone" because he didn't, at least not live.

[perry222777]

@OrganicTrichome - FYI, Snowy played with them on the Animals Tour - just look.

[danimal97520]

@Cgrrp Snowy White went with Waters when he left. Tim Renwick was Floyd's backing guitarist after that point. Played on both the '87/'88 tour and the Division Bell tour. Snowy White hasn't played a tour with Floyd since Waters left. Just to clear that up some...

[tjrrockandrollmaster]

@jajah62 Roger had three guitarists (occasionally Jon Carin played a fourth guitar) to try and recreate what one David Gilmour did by his lonesome.

[zooreeka]

God, My Ears!!!! It's not the same, takes 2 to know....

Wish they'd have left us the memory of this great great song live with Syd and not assasinated it the way they did here!!!! Need some ludes to get over this one!

[ma16360]

This stuff is at the bottom of the PF music. No one knew they are then because that all what they had to show. The real PF is the 1972and beyond.

There where tones of groups that sings stuff like this and all where better than this. Real PF music is different than all.

[adlo56]

waters is and it was the genius of floyd

[rockaires]

Absolutely right, adlo56. The only genius beside Syd Barrett. Peace.

[DPboy20]

Spam!!!

[DPboy20]

Pink Floyd is no more, neither is Roger's voice. Have you listened to the mediocre crap he has released after 'Amused To Death'? Why hasn't he done a new album? His talent is gone.

[TheElusiveBirdMan]

Actually his In The Flesh DVD is fucking awesome.

[DasGoldenBoy]

I liked it more than the Floyd's Pulse. I had a chance to see the Water's show and it fell through and when I saw In The Flesh I was so pissed off.

[DPboy20]

Waters WAS the nerve in Pink Floyd. Now he is only an old grumpy man who is heavily relying on backing tracks and vocal assistance to tour and cash in playing the old songs with no new material. Playing large arenas and small stadiums just like Pink Floyd did without him, which pissed him off, as he claimed Pink Floyd's music was not ment for large outdoor arenas and stadiums, and for the last 3 years he's been doing the same thing himself. RIP Rick! This was Rick and Pink Floyd's last ever gig.

[floydgenesisnut]

This is indeed the last post-Roger Waters era Pink Floyd gig. Although they hadn't recorded since 1994, they did gigs here and there since the end of The Division Bell Tour but this was sadly their swan song with Rick Wright (God bless him and his friends and family). David Gilmour won't play with Roger Waters again. Roger's become a hypocrite now enjoys playing large venues whereas David's changed once he and wife Polly had more kids that the larger than life spectacle was a thing of the past.

[DPboy20]

This was Rick's last Live performance, and the last by Pink Floyd too in a way.

[qwerty09121209]

RIP Rick

[Futurolvidado]

Gracias Rick

Te llevaremos en nuestros corazones y estarás presente en cada nota, cada melodía que nos legaste, en cada sueño hecho música que salió de tu ser, por siempre.

[PFLOYD33]

hope you're playing that gig in the sky now.RIP

[lucianopinguim]

wright fica com deus

[castanoargentina]

Se ha ido el maestro Wright!

[melanie993]

RIP. Rick Wright

[brenhollhunt]

Now it will never happen. RIP Rick Wright :(

[stratJL]

i think a reunion isnt impossible. if someone yelled out ROGER WATERS!!!!! a few years back gilmour woulda been pretty pissed off. now it seems like he got a kick out of it. im sure things have smoothed over alot between david and roger. lets hope for the sake of music that the floyd does actually get back together.

[flymogram]

Anyone know why Roger didn't join them?

[DPboy20]

Roger "had" to pick up his girlfriend at the Airport, or so he said.

[golf520man]

i always wondered that, he always said he wanted more but had no time to spare a couple hours for this

[wap9]

fuck roger waters . that asshole thought he was the band . fuck him hes gone. and good ridance. the division bell proved . rick. nick. and david gilmore were pink floyd. dont get me wrong roger was a huge part of floyd in the 70s . but he lost it in the end. listen too his solo albums . he sucked by the 80s.oh and lets not forget si rip you genius.

[DPboy20]

Well put! As David Gilmour said, there used to be a balance between music and lyrics, but Roger turned away from the Pink Floyd sound, and focused on bombastic concepts and lyrics. When David and Nick w. Rick continued in 1987 there were a balance between words and music again. The band especially focused on the music on 'A Momentary Lapse Of Reason' and especially on 'Division Bell'. Compare them to 'The Final Cut', 'Amused To Death' and 'The Pros & Cons Of Hitch Hiking'.

[MidwestMidnight]

Rogers albums were WAY better than the crap Floyd put out after he left.

[paramedic6801]

ok, that was pretty stupid. since most of the crap he sings is from his floyd days. waters is an arrogent self absorbed prick.although he is a good song writer.

[MidwestMidnight]

No shit. He wrote 90% of the material while he was in the band.

[paramedic6801]

and you think he was the only one who had input on that 90% huh? waters was trying to take the band a direction it did not want or need to go. He wanted to turn everything into some huge theatrical event "the wall" when everyone else just wanted to play music. if you would care to learn some facts you would see that his wall movie not only practically bankrupted the band but also drove the wedge between them he even fired wright over it. yep, he's a prick.

[MidwestMidnight]

I didn't say he wasn't a prick, but he was more of a musician than anyone else in the band. Seriously. Listen to "A Momentary Lapse of Reason" and "The Division Bell" and compare them to "The Pros and Cons of Hitch Hiking" and "Amused To Death". What sounds more like Pink Floyd?!! ROGER'S albums. You can't even argue that.

[Brrrrr43]

Not gonna argue, It's a matter of taste. You listen to Waters, I'll listen to Gilmour. Thankyou...Peace

[767fife]

though the wall movie is a pretty great mindfuck

[Brrrrr43]

lyrics, yes, the music was Wright and Gilmour, he hardly wrote any of the music to go with his political lyrics.

[MidwestMidnight]

Please!!! Everything Floyd put out from "Animals" on were practically Waters solo albums.

[767fife]

i didnt realize a momentary lapse of reason even had waters on it

[djtrixen]

MidwestMidnight:

Dude, this is a classic track originally sung by Syd Barrett, for crying out loud. After all, that's why they were playing it. It was their first single and has nothing to do with post-Waters Floyd (even though they happened to be the ones playing it). Duh.

By the way, AMLOR & TDB are friggin awesome. Stick a sock in it.

[ePhilosopher]

arno;d the pig

[dullsville]

This is more important than the Live 8 reunion.Yay for Rick!

[charlesportilho]

Esse cara deve ser doido. Nada nos ultimos 26 anos foi mais importante q o Live 8 na vida do pink floyd.

[ltcurry]

Wrights voice sounded incredibly strong that night.

[gaderius]

"whish roger where there ..."

[alex69gilmour]

yeaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa­a atte alex floyd

[fedefrusciante]

increible!

[Obelisk2290]

For all intents and purposes this is a PF reunion

[etherealreaper]

I would like to agree, but without Barrett or Waters I just can't quite call it that..sorry if I'm picky..I just miss the beginnings. But the intent is sincere and the fact remains, they are all a piece of what was Pink Floyd.

[Obelisk2290]

well i meant as far as gilmour took rick on tour when nick is there its pink floyd 1987-present. Thats what i meant though i have to admit that I thought syd's contribution was not that much as far as the whole body of wory until 1994. Just my .02 cents. He was a shooting star

[dycedrummer]

floyd r great,rogers great,daves great.i hate all this dave-waters whos best,whos the better leader etc,just enjoy the f**king music.its all good!

[JDAR001]

speak the word man!!!!

[RanEdogawa]

I disagree with you NigelEno... Pink floyd can exist without him.... They didn't need rog' after 81 and Pulse , that they have play without him , is an awesome show and DVD =O I think it's david who's more important than roger ;o) but as I said , it's not the same without syd...

[piterfloyd]

Roger its the brain , Gilmour the eyes and hands , Nick and Rick , legs and boddy , and Syd the master !

[DEEMUSICBUG]

♥Roger♥

[NigelENO]

Without Waters, Pink Floyd don't exist... Waters is foundamental also with Barret... Waters is the nerv of Pink Floyd

[RanEdogawa]

hairyfella (6 days ago)

Pink FLoyd still exists. its just without roger waters

Yes , but however there was a ...stupid ? ^^ guy who didn't seem to know this and shouted " Roger Waters ! " lmao.... In frensh , we call this "un boulet" XD

^^'

But the video's great of course , but it's not the same without the first leader of pink floyd : Syd Barrett ( rip ) I mean the soul of that song is missing...

[hairyfella]

Pink FLoyd still exists. its just without roger waters

[xClaireBurgessx]

Well I think it's a great video! x

[marumicchy]

the noisy volume is BULLSHIT

[dullsville]

Cool! I am wondering if somebody has clips of Kevin Ayers and Robyn Hitchcock from the show?

[Dizzaddy]

all you bitches don't know shit about Floyd. Bitches.

[MoreGilmour]

Bet I know more than you.

[oceifador]

Andy Bell, Oasis bassist, not the Erasure guy, played with them.

[bassandsox]

This isn't too special. They played together on David Gilmour's tour.

So...Roger? Why couldn't you play with them?

The funny thing is, David wasn't even around when they MADE this song. heh

[AlmightyStove]

Yeah, but he certainly played this song a lot after he replaced Syd I bet.

[91535110]

Wish i was there !

[DanRules89]

wish you were here

[91535110]

Gay?

[DanRules89]

its a song dumbass, some fan u r

[91535110]

It was a joke...

[CarmeliteMusic]

Could you believe it when they walked on? My life was completed!

[andrewjburgess]

I was in total disbelief! I had said to my brother that Waters would probably be there because he was playing London the following two nights, but he was convinced that the others would make an appearence too. I wasn't so sure and so was in shock when they did! What an amazing moment that was...