Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (300)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Wow, that was amazing. Loved it!!!

  • @Jonnyboy567 Thank you very much, see other APP covers (probably better than this) on my channel urbania70, on singer's channel Aleclovesgenialmusic or on channel eyerobotmusic (where I and Alec join a guitarist).

  • Amazing cover !! 

  • @jag2724 Thank you, long live APP!

  • Great cover! The piano and singing was absolutely beautiful!

  • @TylerDz1701 Thanx. I'm satisfied about the piano and Alec's singing, less about my backing vocals :) Welcome on my channel, there are also many other APP covers on it

  • Very well done!

  • @TheFluktuationAcht Thank you.. at least is better than the remix which L'il Wayne just did of this song saying "bitch and pussy"..

    As you're German you may be interested in the German tribute band.. See the link in my list of favorite channels

  • The was a pretty legit cover guys

    Good job

  • VERY GOOD GUYS VERY NICELY DONE THANK YOU

  • Great cover of a great song!

  • A lovely rendition that drew me in - thank you for posting.

  • @dakotablue52 Thank you 

  • Most amazing cover. Very well done. One of my favorite APP songs.

  • @1auriculatus Thank you very much. If you like Amontillado suggest you check the cartoon videoclip to which we posted as response.

  • @1auriculatus Thank you ! ;-) Feel free to check out also "Shadow Of A Lonely Man" from the same session BUT uploaded on my channel.

  • @ALEClovesGENIALMUSIC Did already check out a lot of your performances weeks ago. Great stuff. Thanks for sharing them with us!

  • Giorgio and Alec - I can't get enough of this song.

  • @shardwick55 Thank you dear Sherry

  • excellent, surprising performance. Thank you . Greetings from Germany whereever you. Sauber gespielt....

  • @maxmul Danke !!

  • my son likes it too

  • @maxmul Danke schoen. Always nice to see APP fandom in young generations. There's an APP tribute band in Germany, checkthe following link (I can't post it directly for antispam system) youtube (dot) com (slash) LNparsonsliveproject

  • @shardwick55 Thanks Sherry ^_^

  • The first time I heard the harmonies in this song on the album I felt like crying it was so beautiful. This cover is as brilliant and faithful to the original . Piano excellent! Vocals are gorgeous. Thanks for posting and performing one of my favorite songs.

  • @kcDakota You're welcome. See other APP covers on my channel.

  • @kcDakota Thanks a lot ! ;-)

  • @urbania70 and Alex

    Superb....

    @urbania70:

    and your I robot interpretation reminds me Keith Jarrett as well...

    very much keen to see and hear more from both of you...

    FANTASTICO....SIETE No. 1

  • Great cover

    Greetings for your new channel

  • @TIMECRISTAL Thanx again. My new channel is actually not mine, it's the channel about APP, although I'm the main admin. youtube(dot)com/APPfanChannel

  • This is wonderful!

    This is one of my favourite songs, and you have made the best of it! Do you have a score for it, or you picked it up by ear?

    Anyhow, wonderful!

  • @NikolaVeber Thank you very much. For this particular song I played by ear, it's a very easy one. See more APP covers on my channel.

  • nice

  • Speachless....I had enough money in my pocket to buy one album -77

    This one or Santana Marathon....bought this.

    To date, i still listen to this Album.

    This is just great!

  • @Beyond13337 Thank you very much. The album is today published in deluxe edition with 8 bonus tracks, including the Orson Welles narrations which had been cuttend from the 76 version because didn't arrive in time, Orson Welles radio spots, two songs more, demos. The Alan Parsons Project, as it was originally called "Tales", was supposed to be the 1st but many other concept albums followed with the same top quality. For more check youtube(dot)com/APPfanChannel

  • @urbania70 Mille grazie for the info. Didnt know about the Orson Welles narrations.

    Going to get the DL edition when i get home from sea(work) :)

    Joined the group aswell, keep up the good work Maestro!

  • @Beyond13337 You're welcome. Actually the Welles narrations were included alrady in the 87 edition. But the deluxe edition contains more Welles material like the awesome radio spot.

  • Fantastic ! :)

  • Standing ovation! Watching tis video, and others you've done just brings a smile to my face. You are both obviously well trained, gifted and serious musicians. I feel the same way, in spirit, even though I am not a musician. So well done! Thank you

  • Thank you. I have a classical base but also learned by myself. Are you a Project appreciator?

  • @urbania70 Oh I love APP! I have been a fan for 25 years! APP music is very inspirational.

  • @goodfella1962 Thanks for the beautiful comment ;-)

  • u guys are brilliant imo

  • Thanx

  • @ylSsrutger Thanks a lot ! :-)

  • what a nice surprise to hear this played by others than APP! thank you!

  • Thanx. Various people in the world play APP appropriately, including tribute bands. See the dedicated link on my channel.

  • Since the death of Eric I haven't really listened to any song of the APP. But I let this song open the portal again:)

  • Yes, I too passed a similar "Silence&I" period.. then the contacts with fans forced me to listen the music and that broke ice.. it's then that I began to realize that he's really immortal in his music. See on my homepage my tribute medley if you didn't

    Giorgio

  • Eric would be proud of you! One more THX one more time to U both! Great Job Guys! Thx for yor Mail....(s)

  • Yes, very sad days for us fans, with Eric's passing away.

  • @Cryptkeeper030 Thanks very much !

  • WHAT AN AWESOME COVER!! You did a very good job!

  • Thanx. If you are an APP fan let me know, I'll send you info about the fan community.

  • @801Milcah Thank you ;-)

  • I must have missed this video :D Cool to see you once again in person Giorgio :) brilliant stuff!!!

  • Thanx Pawel, this video is somehow improvised. My best videos so far, besides the Rick Wright tribute, are I Robot and Voyager / What Goes Up, and both are more near to the Floyd style. Check them.

  • A superlative rendition!  Bravissimo!

  • Thanx!

  • Thanks !

  • Geat stuff guys, keep up this great job! Try to improve the sound quality, it deserves!!

  • Check my latest videos

  • Thank you !

  • Bravo!!! What a great effort. This may inspire me to do some singing with my daughters. Have you ever thought of doing any Steely Dan covers?

  • Thanx. Sorry I'm not familiar with Steely Dan.

  • You two have great musical sense. You don't just reproduce the songs, but take "possession" of them briefly but respectfully to the creators. Great job, as always! :)

  • Thanks again !

  • Felicidades simplemente maravilloso por favor seguir asi con mas canciones de Alan Parsons.Espero ansioso mas videos como este.Desde España SALUDOS.

  • Thank you. You find more APP covers in both mine and Alec's channel.

  • Thanks again ;-)

  • I love this album since the 70´. So I was surprised of your realy great performance. Fantastic play and singing. Go for more!

  • Thank you very much. We recorded various APP covers, both separately and together, check both my channel and that of AlecLovesGenialMusic. And indeed we have new stuff coming.

  • Thanks !!! You're welcome ! As Giorgio already said, we have other APP covers posted on YouTube and more to come ;-)

  • excellent job!

  • Thanks a lot !!

  • Do You have any notes for the piano music, or it is your own work? If you have notes, please write where I can find it. Thanks, Alexander

  • First of all, hi. As indicated in title, the composition is by The Alan Parsons Project and mine is only a cover, adapted for piano/voice. APP sheets are very rare and I played this by ear.

  • Yes, I know, I meant the 'composition' as adaptation for piano. So, all in all, You've got a very good ears! Congratulations. Very nice performance!

  • Are you a fan of Tales?

  • Maybe not a fan, but I really like and admire The Alan Parsons Project's music, especially playing on my own (piano). Now I can perform only Sirius and Eye in the sky.

  • bravissimi!!! e credo italiani, il che è quasi incredibile.

    splendida la sequenza a due voci e l'inciso.

    Un solo suggerimento: la telecamera a favore e non contro luce!!!!!!!!!

  • Grazie mille.

    Per il mio vocal di risposta, speravo di avere più fiato, ma sono più un pianista.

    Controluce: il video è stato improvvisato in 10 minuti. Per fortuna non c'è stato il tipico effetto silouhette del controluce. Piuttosto, contrasta tematicamente con l'atmosfera del brano. Su tutti gli altri miei video al piano troverai ottime condizioni di luce.

  • Grazie davvero ;-)

    Grazie anche per la sottoscrizione !

  • excellent performance. I met Alan p. once in Chicago

  • Thanx!

  • Thank you justme6555 !!

  • I was pleasantly surprised. You guys just about captured all of the sounds that are humanly possible to capture with a piano/vocal duo. Remember all of the other instruments and chorals used in the original? You guys either exactly matched or adeptly reproduced about 65% of them and it never sounded too thin at all. Excellent. Alan Parsons, Eric Woolfson, and Andrew Powell (let's not forget), true masters of sound, would be overjoyed.

  • And I'm pleasantly surprised about your comment. Yes, in APP music, arrangements are particularly interconnected with the music, so I always try to reproduce all I can, also in my instrumental APP covers. In "Shadow of a Lonely Man", posted as a response to this (on Alec's channel), while writing down the chords, I realized that, besides Eric's great piano chords, also Powell and Paton nuances have their importance.

  • And this is true also for my instrumental APP covers (check my channel).

    Cool user id, I'm too a Star Wars fan, as you'll see in my I Robot cover video.

  • You're very kind ! Many thanks ! ;-)

  • Awesome! I love it!

  • Thanx!

  • Thanks a lot !

  • That was beautiful!  Thanks!

  • Thank You !!

  • Well done! I am a big fan of Alan Parsons Project, in particular of Tales of Mystery and Imagination.

  • Thanx and welcome in the APP fan community. Tales is the fav album of both Eric and Alan.

  • Thanks. My fav album is The Turn of a Friendly Card.

    Did you already hear the new Eric Woolfson albums?

  • TTOAFC is one of my fav too. German tribute band is planning to play it entirely live.

    Yes I have the new EW albums: "The APP that never was" in physical version, and "Edgar Allan Poe" in download version. "Never was" is very good, my fav being that abandoned Stereotomy track (base played by all APP members), now completed.

    As for "Edgar Allan Poe", the previously unpublished tracks are in rock opera style so question of taste. For me they're a souvenir since I saw the London showcase.

  • Welcome and thanks ;-) ALEC

  • wow that was good. can you send me the chords to this song? I can figure out the right hand lead and arpegio stuff if you can just tell me the chords

  • Thanx! I wrote you a private msg

  • Thanks !

  • that was amazing. i love this song and you guys did it justice

  • Thank you very much. Nice nickname, did you know there's an APP instrumental called "The Ace Of Swords"?

  • Thanks a lot !!

  • Certo che ascoltare sta canzone, sia in versione originale che come cover, mi emoziona veramente. Il testo, assai fedele al racconto di Poe, e' davvero splendido e terrificante allo stesso tempo.. Pagherei oro perche' AP ed EW tornassero insieme. E con loro Powell, Ian, David e Stuart.

  • Grazie Fernando!

  • Grazie mille Fernando !

  • Ok i'm not perfect but i try but you have a nice voice

    the high notes are unreachable for me it's my curse

  • Surely a voice that reaches high notes is preferable but I think that for such theatrical songs interpretation is all. You play the guitar really well on it by the way !

  • Thank you very much for the video response!

  • all I can say is, Wow! I wish I listened before now. I love it!!!!!!

  • Thank you K. ! It's a pleasure to have a kind comment from you here ^_^

  • Thanx. Do you mean, you wished you listened before our version, or the original version? I mean, did you know the original?

  • I mean I wish I had seen your video before now, K

  • ma allora sei tu che suoni??? sei un drago veramente!!!

  • Grazie mille

  • Siete Bravissimi, complimenti ^_^

  • Grazie, conoscevi la versione originale?

  • si si ...^_^

  • Grazie ;-)

  • A virtuoso performance! Thank you for emailing me the link! Beautifully done!

  • Thanks, also in name of Alec. Check my channel for more APP covers.

  • Thanks warrenwr !

  • I agree great Tune To Sing ..I like Singing The Voice,Some Other Time And Games People Play

  • Thanks for the subscriptions searchme45 !

  • What a great cover!! Bravo, my friends, this is one of my favorite songs and you do BEAUTIFUL job!

  • Thank you!

  • Thanks a lot !!

  • no guys it was just an old crazy soothsayer. Do you think your father would really want a world with all robots?

  • Siete veramente bravi!! Sono contento di essere stato invitato al Vs gruppo.

    Grazie Giorgio!

    Ciao

    Fegna

  • Grazie Fegna. A essere esatti questo video è distaccato dal gruppo dei fans. Qui siamo solo io e Alec, il gruppo dei fans invece consiste in centinaia di membri e l'amministratore è Lionel, che l'ha fondato insieme a me e altri membri (non Alec).

  • Grazie Fernando !

    Confermo che le cover o di Giorgio o mie o con entrambi non sono dirette conseguenze dell'esistenza del gruppo creato su YouTube. Il gruppo non 'produce' video, anche se dà ad essi un po' di visibilità in più tra i fan ;-)

  • que temazoo!! what a beautifull song, how can the world not realize what TAAP is? I can't figure...

    Boys you made a great interpretation, i will join the fun group now

  • Thank you very much

  • Simply amazing guys, Regards Billy ;)

  • Thanx Billy, you find other APP covers in mine and Alec's channel (link in description).

  • Thanks a lot Billy !

  • Wow!

  • Thanx! Check a similar collaboration in the video response.

  • Thank You!

  • Hey Folks - That was great - I know the Original since 1984 - when I was nine years old - I've never heard a better Cover than yours - get on like this! I am amazed! If Alan Parson ever needs two great Musicians - I'll be voting for you! Great Performance! THX a Lot!

  • Thank you very much! Sub and visit my channel for more.

  • Thank you Cryptkeeper030 !! If Alan could listen to you, ha ha :-))) Thanks again ! You can find other APP tributes on my channel also. You're welcome !

  • Completely awesome! Lovely vocals ... and of course, the playing? Classic AND classy!

  • Thanx again Carol. Credits here go also to Alec. Visit his channel! The Logical Song, I'm not in love, Nothing Left to Lose are all covers by him which i can suggest particularly.

    And, we did a collaboration similar to this one, itìs posted as video response.

  • Thanks Carol ^_^ You're very welcome !

  • Yeah!! few people like good tunes like the tune that you play, now the music is rare to hear a good tune just popular music the music before was a lot better than the music of today to me garbage don't get me wrong but that's my point of vew, just perfect guys to me! later!

  • Thanx again. Yes, most music of 70s/80s, in particular the most experimental as this one, was special. Starting from 90s the creativity went down, with of course many exceptions.

    People which like APP are not so few. The CDs have just been relaunched in expanded editions, and there's a big fans community on the internet. Also here on YouTube, I'll send you the invite to the fans group.

  • Wow!!! what a performance great both voices are great and the piano man wow!so good! super!! mega!! extra!! great, take care buds!

  • Thank you very much.. an APP fan I suppose, isn't it?

  • Thanks a lot joserfaf !

  • This has always been my favorite Poe story & favorite "Tales" track. I've always loved how the music gets so beautiful as Fortunato begs for his life & Montressor taunts him.

    Very nice live-acoustic version!

    *****

    ~R

  • Thank you very much. If you didn't, check the Amontillado video by AceGallagher to which we video-responded here (click the link under the video): cartoon completely made by herself, 100k visits.

  • Thank You !!

  • This is beautiful! So nice to hear today:) All my stars! 5*****

  • Thanx a lot, Cameragirl!

  • Thanks a lot Jane ^_^

  • Excellent cover!

  • Thanx friend, welcome on my channel!

  • Damn you guys are awesome!! I wanna go over there and play the percussion parts with you!

  • You're welcome! Also check "Shadow of a Lonely Man" in the video responses and my APP/Ladyhawke medley. Thank you also for putting as favourite this and Pipeline.

  • ^_^ Thanks !!

  • Fantastic!!! Thanks for uploading and sharing all these awesome songs!!! all your videos are great!! 5*!

  • Thanx a lot for your comment, Lorena! Long live 70s and 80s!

  • Thanks also by me ^_^

  • Congratulations Mr. Urbania and ALEClovesGENIALMUSIC, fantastic!!

  • Thanx rpm3345, that's a cool userid! Are you an Alan Parsons Project fan?

  • Thanks rpm3345 ^_^

  • Yes I am, and thanks for upload your videos.

  • You're welcome and there's more to come. I send you invite in the APP fans group.

  • 'Part of you dies each brick I lay'... bravi!

  • Grazie ! Benvenuta ^_^

  • Sì, meno male che Alec lì ha cantato proprio come John Miles, così ha coperto bene il mio pietoso backing vocal haha.. sono più dotato sulla tastiera che alla voce.. Grazie Claire! Visita l'altra cover che abbiamo registrato in quella sessione, Shadow of a Lonely Man, cliccando la video risposta sotto questo video!