Somehow I don´t like when he says "Thank you for giving us a great life", cause it gives the impression that they don´t do it for the audience, but for themselfes (for the money).
@Hewson60 No it doesn't. It's aknowledging the fact the fans have given them a great life, they realize it and they appreciate it. Why else would they ever thank the fans unless to show their appreciation for what the fans have given them. In no way shape or form does him thanking the fans for a given them a great life give the impression they do it for the money. One of the dumbest things live ever read.
that was beautiful........... it is a very personal song .....if you have lost someone close to you ......this magnificent song says it all .........i could see why he could not do this on a stage ....
You've created magic once again... I know you said in your description you weren't happy with having to use shots that were not all in front of a live audience, but I think it actually worked rather well. It creates the illusion of Bono thinking, for a moment while he's onstage, of how lucky he is that his life turned out the way it did.... At least, that's what it felt like to me. :)
Love.
kywomanlml 3 months ago
the best, fact
67carlsberg 4 months ago
this should have been a single makes me so much closer every time x great melody x
sunnysideoflove 6 months ago
Yes, it is a little gem. Thank you for posting this.
slipperyelmful 6 months ago
Comment removed
marccruz004 7 months ago
Well the heart that hurts
Is a heart that beats... ♥
justme788 8 months ago 2
one unofficial amazing video!!
bbyraluca 9 months ago
Hermosa canción...
Ahlam110 10 months ago
Look at u2 one lukes first sung it is Soooo cool try it .
Soo u2are the best
stringsman1 10 months ago
Bono actually said to me once, 'Your's is bigger than mine'. True story.
Mrsilenciobackgammon 11 months ago
really? ummmm I guess good for you sad for bono then
Anamamma1 3 weeks ago
i heart u2
sunnysideoflove 11 months ago
Dowwnload the audio from this video at speedyconversion doht cohm.
TorinLicklider380 1 year ago
Song has some seroius heart in it. Peace
ChocolateTeaPot100 1 year ago
this is the best song of the album but live version is a fake...this song could never be played in a live show
TheUncleJane1 1 year ago
@TheUncleJane1 U2 can Play Everything live.
JustaU2Fan 1 year ago 2
how true this song is listen
scottieflatbox 1 year ago
Beautiful song..thanks heaps for this!
Simmomufc 1 year ago
Comment removed
V0cx 1 year ago
best version!!!!
kijgel 1 year ago
The "Thank you for giving us a great life" is in reference to his father whose picture is shown as he says it.
katecalnan 1 year ago
Somehow I don´t like when he says "Thank you for giving us a great life", cause it gives the impression that they don´t do it for the audience, but for themselfes (for the money).
Hewson60 1 year ago
@Hewson60 uhm... what?
Stereotype23 1 year ago
@Hewson60 No it doesn't. It's aknowledging the fact the fans have given them a great life, they realize it and they appreciate it. Why else would they ever thank the fans unless to show their appreciation for what the fans have given them. In no way shape or form does him thanking the fans for a given them a great life give the impression they do it for the money. One of the dumbest things live ever read.
Hallucination 1 year ago
I'm one of those people who think this is a dull song...
But after a saw your BEAUTIFUL clip for MoS i ended up here and well...
I really loved it, well done :-)
BelgianBono 1 year ago
This is the best song off of 'How to dismantle an atomic bomb'
benbot87 1 year ago
that was beautiful........... it is a very personal song .....if you have lost someone close to you ......this magnificent song says it all .........i could see why he could not do this on a stage ....
jenjune 2 years ago
Thank you
ArnoHul 2 years ago
You've created magic once again... I know you said in your description you weren't happy with having to use shots that were not all in front of a live audience, but I think it actually worked rather well. It creates the illusion of Bono thinking, for a moment while he's onstage, of how lucky he is that his life turned out the way it did.... At least, that's what it felt like to me. :)
rglovesu2 2 years ago
amazing work
AGONZO22 2 years ago
Awesome Thx
benjamincole77 2 years ago
Awesome THx
benjamincole77 2 years ago
Awesome! I hope they'll play it again before long. In the mean time, this is a great substitute - thank you!
u2se 2 years ago