Comodo vs. Norton 2011 Editions Test 2 Video 2

[mangkaw321]

comodo, kaspersky and emsisoft... is d best

[actionmanatee]

comodo: 2

norton: 0

free antivirus is better than paid antivirus! Symantec was 100% WRONG!

[banstaman]

I love COMODO.

[15Hayki]

Comodo rocks :)

[700007123]

CIS my ass Norton.

[Voyager699]

Most of Malware comes NOT with Magic to the PC´s , it comes over the Internet . In this Case Norton protect very good. That is the Point you not say in your Video. Your Test is a fail...

[iraklibatumi]

Hi friends, let us write our own Top 5 Antivirus programs...

1. Comodo

2. Norton

3.AVG

4.Viper

5.Avast

[26psyside]

@iraklibatumi

1.Comodo/Norton

2.Avast

3.Kaspersky

4.Avira

5.MSE

[bogdan1504]

I would like to see Comodo in a AV-Comparatives test.

[cocopara]

Lang. Comodo were critizied for handing out SSL ceritifcates to malware programs or wtf etc.

[TheDMaNIZiLLNaSTy]

Hey Languy, when the AV detects a file malicious, is it best to "Clean," Quarantine", or "Delete"? Thanks(COMODO IS)

[1EnterNameHere1]

i dont see why he cant do norton tests with sonar... and what do u mean by D+?

[BC0046400]

Done what you said lang put comodo on my system. I like it a lot better picked some things up that my other one didnt so I am happy with that result so think I will buy the full version.

Thanks again

[adumb1992]

comodo is kinda like sandboxie.. XD

[Bashop77]

I just did a test with Norton internet security 2011 and let it scan a folder with 5922 trojan samples, it only detected 2137 of them ! HitmanPro detected 4546 trojans.

Uninstalled Norton, installed Comodo internet security 2011 and let Comodo scan the folder, Comodo detected 5872 trojans, not bad :).

The trojans can be found on the internet, if you google "6000 trojan sample pass-auToeXeCw0rm.rar", can someone verify these findings ?

[prusaks]

Comodo asks a lot of questions and for a regular user that is a problem.

[bbbbweb]

Can you do something else apart for NIS v CIS 2011 editions now?

[ballader1]

hey tested COMODO v5 today and they definetely have improved, the video will be uploaded in 1 - 2 hours or maybe less ;)

[MultiDeath1000]

tdl3???!?!?! way serious

[1EnterNameHere1]

one reason comodo is good for protecting u is because of there sandbox. everytime languy99 sandboxes something, most likely the app just terminates its self. so languy, could u make those comodo reviews without the sandbox? because i think that if any other anti-virus had a sandbox like comodo, it would be wayy improved.

[languy99]

@1EnterNameHere1 even if I disable the sandbox comodo will still have D+.

[cocopara]

@languy99

The reason it wasnt found is more likely because Comodo signed it, they as said in the earlier post. Please google it :).

[AgulkaWieczorek]

@1EnterNameHere1

yea and he could make those norton reviews without the sonar

[Kinemitor]

@1EnterNameHere1 languy was not sanboxing anythin, it was automatically by the antivirus

lets remart what u just said:"if any other anti-virus had a sandbox like comodo, it would be wayy improved.

so? then they should or it proof more comodo is best

[BC0046400]

Yes phone fixed now bloody apple will try that comodo in the moring thanks again.

[BC0046400]

Opps two comments there cell phone crash

[languy99]

@BC0046400 fixed

[BC0046400]

Will do it first thing in the moring thanks for the help.

Keep up the good work

Cheers

[languy99]

look people I am done tolerating personal attacks. If you attack me personally you will be blocked and all of your posts deleted.

[MrDarthcam]

@languy99 hellz yea man

[cocopara]

@languy99

I love your videos Languy. But I do request a test where you allow global hooks etc because MW2 uses a global hook so most people would accept it.

[BC0046400]

I have just a small qwestion to ask. I can just not pick the best security package. I love your work lang guy have watched most of you reviews. I am 18 years old so have a lot of usage out of my laptop surfing the web dowloading all the time and have had 3 reboots this year over virises any thought on what package I should buy for me and my family?

[languy99]

@BC0046400 Why not try CIS v5 and see how you like it. You have nothing to loose, it is free and fairly easy to use. If you have people who don't know how to use a computer you can lock down CIS with parental controls so they will never see a pop up from it.

[ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed]

So is registry easy a major false positive?

[languy99]

@ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed from what I was told, the program is not malicious but the way the company operates is not within acceptable standards anymore so they have been removed from the trusted list. They are also going over all of the trusted list and double checking everything on it.

[TheMassFail]

Languy, I will give you the reason why people think Comodo is bad.

Install Comodo on an old lady's computer, she will have a meltdown trying to learn what SVCHost, COM, sys32, etc. is. Also, the pop-ups are stupid with the information they provide, it should be simpler, smaller, and lighter instead of shutting down your game when playing so you can click Allow for the game to save. The sandbox protects the computer, but it's a pain to LET the program run without a sandbox after you sandbox it.

[Chiron494]

@TheMassFail You actually get very few of those type of alerts with everyday applications. Most of the common ones are already whitelisted.

Still, it's a problem that's currently being worked on.

[languy99]

sorry people I did not cheat, you guys are just sore that Norton failed and I don't know why. You don't work for them, you don't have anything to gain by trying to bad mouth me. Get over it and move on.

[TheGabennn]

@languy99 yeah we not work for them, we are just using it, but u definetly work for comodo. no matter what u say. its pretty bad that a simple software has such a big sentimental feelings for you. get over it and try to relax, go out and smell the fresh air. no problem if u remove this message, i know you red it.

[LUNCH155]

@TheGabennn You are stupid. Languy does NOT work for comodo, he is just a mod on their forums. Go get outside and get a brain.

[ballader1]

@TheGabennn well, languy doesn't work for COMODO. I'm not a Comodo fanboy and I am NOT trying to prove anything.

[cocopara]

@TheGabennn

Haters gotta hate.

Comodo for experienced users like Languy will provide the best protection because what gets past the defensive barrier will be caught by the firewall 100% and there Languy knows exactly what he should do.

[xxXaiderxx]

There's a reason it's called Norton Internet Security, it protects you from downloading malware to. By executing the malware when it's already on the computer, the chances for norton to detect the malware is reduced, I do keep in mind that it will be the same thing for CIS, but CIS and NIS are different programs and that means that they work differently, I think that if you had downloaded the malware through links in a browser then Norton would have blocked a lot more malware

[TheBuckbull]

finally registry easy and registry were found nice part 2 very disappointing that norton did poorly it does well when you throw 10 links at it but not present malware 

[Orlyowl8]

If you dont know how to work with HIPS comodo fails and lacks in comparison to Norton.

[bbbbweb]

GMER makes my comp auto restart

[serj960]

STILL NORTON REMAINS MY FAVORITE!

[ballader1]

why did you make it in parts? You can make a 30 minute video! You are a youtube partner, aren't you?

[ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed]

@ballader1 maximum is 15 minutes

[ballader1]

@ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed not for YouTube Partners. Check out mrizos, he is a youtube partner and he uploads 30+ minutes because of that. Languy can do it too, because he is a partner, btw planning on testing COMODO v5 today!

[ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed]

@ballader1 I know for avrage users they can upload up to 10 mins but partners up to 15 but I think matt is kind of super partner or something like that

[bbbbweb]

@ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed Average users can upload 15 minutes, partners have unlimited minutes. Mrizos just does it.

[ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed]

@bbbbweb Than y doesn't languy99 upload over 15 minutes?

[ballader1]

@ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed average up to 15 mins. Partners unlimited

[ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed]

@ballader1 Then languy99 must no longer be a partner

[ballader1]

@ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed he is, because he has that banner on his channel, only partners can have that

[ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed]

@ballader1 Then y he can't upload more than 15 minutes?

[ballader1]

@ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed he can, but he probably doesn't want to

[ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed]

@ballader1 No I asked him and he said he can't

[ballader1]

@ahmeeeeeeeeeeeed when?, sometime ago YT disabled the ability for partners to upload large videos, but it got reenabled on 25th of August, Languy99 should check his large video's size and if it's big then he should use the Java uploader

[MegaCamu]

Norton screwed up! AGAIN!!

[ballader1]

why did you changed settings in COMODO? (Enabled Cloud Scanning) (Not a Symantec fanboy, but still i think that testing in stock configuration is the best.)

[KodamaNoKoe]

@ballader1 Cloud Scanner is enabled by default for background scan, but not for manual full scan (because it slows it down), but I don't think it made a difference though.

[ballader1]

@KodamaNoKoe actually it did, because the cloud scan scans files with the latest version of their database in realtime, so I am pretty sure it improved the results ;)

[KodamaNoKoe]

@ballader1 @11:05, you can see the scanner detected 7 viruses in the zip (the same it removed before the test) and one more with the heuristic (maybe created with another virus). The heuristic isn't based on signature.

[ballader1]

@KodamaNoKoe i wasn't talking about the heuristic one -.-

[KodamaNoKoe]

@ballader1 Well, what were you talking about? The other ones were found with the antivirus before the test, there were the same in the zip file.

[ballader1]

@KodamaNoKoe 9 were found in the full scan, 1 was the heuristic, so we have 8, COMODO in the start detected 7, so thanks to the cloud scan 1 more thing was detected

[KodamaNoKoe]

@ballader1 15 - 7 (files left in the folder) = 8.

[ballader1]

@KodamaNoKoe that's even worse! if it was that, because it means that these weren't detected before, but using the cloud thingy it got them

[KodamaNoKoe]

@ballader1 huh... you don't understand...

CIS removed 8 files @5:30 (extracted in the directory), and it detected 8 files @11:05 (inside the zip). It's the same files.

[ballader1]

@KodamaNoKoe oh, you were right, just checked it, I thought that it had removed 7 files at 5:30

[PCWORLDPHOTODESIGNER]

@languy99 Thanks for this review, this is much realistic situation than first review! Looks like this is one more prove that Comodo is the best product on market! And Norton IS 2011 fails again! But this Firewall and D+ popups are very annoying. They should work on this, and they will have much better product! J am having one more question. Do they have plans to create Anti-virus for MAC users? Thanks!

[languy99]

@PCWORLDPHOTODESIGNER I don't know as of right now.

[antivirushelp]

you didn't activate NIS

[Eragon86micky]

great Comodo

[SchaduwBlink]

NIS really failed this test. The one thing that I noticed about CIS is that you really need to know what you are doing when you respond to a popup. I don't know if people would know that some of those actions and may think that flash needs to hook in like that. We know that was a fake flash installer, but would someone else? So, if you really know what you are doing, CIS can protect you. NIS just failed. Interesting results. Thank you for taking the time to do this.

[KodamaNoKoe]

@SchaduwBlink That's why you should click "Sandbox" if you don't know what's happening or you're not sure (that's what languy99 did in the video). But you should ask yourself some questions if you see a popup from Defense+, because it doesn't happen very often (due to the vendor trust list).

The most common popups you may see are the auto sandbox (but you don't have to do anything in this case) and the firewall popup if an app try to access internet.

[languy99]

@KodamaNoKoe exactly and with comodo at least you get the chance to block the malware, with NIS you never get that chance.

[AaronKatrini41]

Just a quick question: Where did you get those malwares , MDL?

Thanks for the review !

[languy99]

@AaronKatrini41 nope, I get them from many different sources.

[AaronKatrini41]

@languy99 Yeah you did good because people pretend that Comodo always detects whats on mdl as malware. Comodo FTW!

[TheShadowkiddx]

Nice Review, very shocking results, i expected both products, to end up with s perfect score. i just don't understand why Norton failed. Anyways nice test, and COMODO did a fantastic job.