I thought a good point was made with the incomplete quote. It looked like a classic case of quote mining -- something I find more typical of theist arguments than atheist's -- so I set of to ShwNerd's channel to chastise him if I found it to be true. What I found was:
The Epic Response to aaronk1994 and ukchristian28... done by someone else! (Part 2)
The "intentionally dishonest" argument is quite persuasively shown to have been "doing you a favour." aaronk1994 should be the one to apologize.
Citing a few negative comments doesn't prove a damn thing. I doubt you'll be highlighting MY comments as part of your "defence", since I don't have anything positive to say about you. You are ill-informed, brainwashed, you lack the courage of your own convictions, floating from YEC to OEC, and you have little to no understanding of theistic philosophy just because you can cite a couple of spurious religious "philosophers". You should TRY reading some Dawkins or Darwin; you might learn something.
ShwaNerd has very loyal subscribers. Whenever aaron makes a video about him, he pays the price. That's exactly what happened to David when he mocked ShwaNerd. David took down his negative video about him when he couldn't handle the pressure from ShwaNerd's people.
its a sad day when a kid like you think they're fucking genius just because they read a little black book:
Christianity: the belief of a cosmic Jewish zombie who was his own father can make you live forever if you symbolically eat his flesh and telepathically tell him you accept him as your master, so he can remove an evil force from your soul that is present in humanity because a rib-woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from a magical tree...
Did you see the new vid Shwa's friend BornInAsphodelMeadow came out with in response to UK? Though Shwa was wrong in trying to use the definition from Jasper as a mental disorder instead of just using the normal definition of delusion, the video pretty much sums it up. It's what he thoroughly should've talked about and I think it's pretty much dead on.
a 14 year old how think he has the answer to life.
What an intellectual embarassment. Finish school, kid, then maybe after you have had a proper education in the sciences then you'll be able to understand what the hell you carp on about in your videos.
Considering your accent, you most probably come from somewhere within the bible belt states, ie: indoctrinated and brainwashed into religious belief since that area is thick with IDiots.
Oh and you stutter so much that it detracts from your point. And the fact that you have to read from a script is quite pathetic. Probably another thing your parents did for you.
Clearly you're nothing but a chump who has his mother or father put words in your blank slate of a mind, you're mentally retarded if you think "god" exists. They beat you so many times in bible school that you were forced to "praise" this false being. I feel pity for you, but then I come to my senses and remember that you believe in "god" and laugh at you. Good luck with the faith bit, I hope it serves you well in "heaven", while you're getting butt fucked by "god".
There is no doubt in my mind that one day theism will be classified as a mental illness. I believe genetics play a role in this illness.
ukchristian is irrelevant. He doesn't even have 200 subscribers. His videos are boring to watch also. ShwaNerd has never lost to a theist before. He could pwn ukchristian in a 2 minute video.
Hello Joseph. Have you watched my videos on the subject? Did you listen to the portion of the video Aaron played? Do you know that psychology deals with individuals rather groups or belief systems?
Oh, I thought I would make an exception. It's hard not to comment when you are trying to defend something so downright stupid. I tell you what. If you promise to be a good little boy I'll unblock you so you can comment on the videos themselves. It would be interesting to see you attempt a point by point refutation.
Oh Yes, I had better not mess with him because his silly little fans will mindlessly one star my videos and leave a load of vulgar remarks. Like I care about that.
No uk, I'm not going to be a good little boy. Your videos are so stupid and boring, I'm going to rip you apart point by point, and it won't be pretty.
Well, you're not commenting on any of my videos unless you apologise and promise to behave yourself. I suppose we can talk on here. Or are you going to provide a video response. That would be even better:).
also, any argument for christianity can be applied to any other religion; so are these guys saying that muslims and scientologists and hindus are right too?
You poor ..poor child... please go to your dads sock drawer and find one of his playboys and take a look at what god made for you.. cause your on the road of never getting it...
Hah... now after seeing UK's video with a tad of research, it would seem that Sha really fucked up lol.
I think I can see where he was going, giving him the benefit of the doubt here, but it was badly misplaced.
Not only did he really not do his research, but his original intended idea (which was pretty generalizing on its own) only seemed to apply to the hardcore fundies, which I don't think properly apply to the likes of you guys, especially you Aaron who has even rejected the idea of YEC.
Anyway, this is getting interesting lol. I just dumped my gf and feeling a tad shitty over it but this'll definitely give me some entertainment to distract me with lol. I wonder how Shwa's going to react.
I guess that is a valid point. Some of the claims made kind of stick but I do agree that it's far too broad and generalistic to apply to all theists even the fundies.
He might as well have been saying that all black people listen to rap music, heh.
He cited criteria from Karl Jaspers and Alistair Munro which is used to indentify delusions which are caused by the mental illness Delusional Disorder. So, yes he was arguing that theism is the result of a mind disorder, and yes it is most absurd video he has ever made.
A mental disorder would be something rather serious, organic, disabling... A delusion would just be fooling yourself into believing something for which there is little or no evidence. If I believe that I am Napoleon, that's a mental disorder. If I think I'm a good guitar player, that's a delusion. Aaron, I don't think you have a mental disorder. I do think you believe something to be fact for which there is little evidence. You are entitled to your opinion but that is does not make it fact.
You discrace my name you ignorant CHILD Aaron is the name of smart people not christian fools so change your name or get a brain
machinegunkittypycho 2 years ago
There is no such thing as bigotry towards a world view.
But here is a real one for you: Homo.
agentssith 2 years ago
Your name is stupid.
aaron3299 2 years ago
I thought a good point was made with the incomplete quote. It looked like a classic case of quote mining -- something I find more typical of theist arguments than atheist's -- so I set of to ShwNerd's channel to chastise him if I found it to be true. What I found was:
The Epic Response to aaronk1994 and ukchristian28... done by someone else! (Part 2)
The "intentionally dishonest" argument is quite persuasively shown to have been "doing you a favour." aaronk1994 should be the one to apologize.
Blackmark52 2 years ago
It's not nice to make fun of Canadians aaron.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
It's not nice to make fun of Texans either.
aaronk1994 2 years ago
I don't make fun of Texans.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
For all of you looking for jesus- here I am!
callmeblackjesus 2 years ago
Citing a few negative comments doesn't prove a damn thing. I doubt you'll be highlighting MY comments as part of your "defence", since I don't have anything positive to say about you. You are ill-informed, brainwashed, you lack the courage of your own convictions, floating from YEC to OEC, and you have little to no understanding of theistic philosophy just because you can cite a couple of spurious religious "philosophers". You should TRY reading some Dawkins or Darwin; you might learn something.
ollie501 2 years ago
gay haircut lol.
SporeFanCreator 2 years ago
Woah. Why did this video do
so well in views, relative to your usual viewership numbers?
Dhorpatan 2 years ago
ShwaNerd has very loyal subscribers. Whenever aaron makes a video about him, he pays the price. That's exactly what happened to David when he mocked ShwaNerd. David took down his negative video about him when he couldn't handle the pressure from ShwaNerd's people.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
Wow. 1,575 views in 4 days. This video was either very good or very bad.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
@joebevins1999
Yeah. The numbers are very impressive. He rarely cracks over four figures in his videos.
Dhorpatan 2 years ago
i thought your whole thing was no swearing XD
ZippoReviews 2 years ago
JoshU2uber is a parody. Don't take anything he says seriously.
ukchristian28 2 years ago
jrsbarker, maybe you should first learn how to properly use english words before you start dismissing perfectly good comments.
>Genetic fallacy
wtf is that? did you mean generic?
>truth value of statement
did you mean true value?
srsly, finish school, kid, and maybe you won't be such a brainless fag.
thisisallen 2 years ago
its a sad day when a kid like you think they're fucking genius just because they read a little black book:
Christianity: the belief of a cosmic Jewish zombie who was his own father can make you live forever if you symbolically eat his flesh and telepathically tell him you accept him as your master, so he can remove an evil force from your soul that is present in humanity because a rib-woman was convinced by a talking snake to eat from a magical tree...
yeah makes perfect sense.
thisisallen 2 years ago
It sure does! NOT
snaffus 2 years ago
Did you see the new vid Shwa's friend BornInAsphodelMeadow came out with in response to UK? Though Shwa was wrong in trying to use the definition from Jasper as a mental disorder instead of just using the normal definition of delusion, the video pretty much sums it up. It's what he thoroughly should've talked about and I think it's pretty much dead on.
rba718 2 years ago
are you going to the One Master gathering?
spikesofgrace 2 years ago
what is this i dont even
verrac 2 years ago
Pompous retard
23animosity23 2 years ago
hehhe...
a 14 year old how think he has the answer to life.
What an intellectual embarassment. Finish school, kid, then maybe after you have had a proper education in the sciences then you'll be able to understand what the hell you carp on about in your videos.
Considering your accent, you most probably come from somewhere within the bible belt states, ie: indoctrinated and brainwashed into religious belief since that area is thick with IDiots.
ricedrocket 2 years ago 4
Aww how cute he still got a high sleeper ! <33
merzer131 2 years ago
what do you mean he has "3 options"? he can do what ever he wants, you dont have authority over him.
hcj0nes 2 years ago
what is this i don't even.
jeremyydaniel 2 years ago 7
you silly goose
PorygonBoy 2 years ago 9
I`ts ownage not ponage dumb fuck
iamsockpuppet 2 years ago 3
i was on your channel and you pointed over ---> AND THERE WAS NOTHING BUT DARKNESS! WHAT NOW! XD lalalalalala weeeeeeeeee.
slowframe 2 years ago 2
thats a pretty cool story bro
xAdam182x 2 years ago 2
Oh and you stutter so much that it detracts from your point. And the fact that you have to read from a script is quite pathetic. Probably another thing your parents did for you.
Edotheclown 2 years ago 3
Clearly you're nothing but a chump who has his mother or father put words in your blank slate of a mind, you're mentally retarded if you think "god" exists. They beat you so many times in bible school that you were forced to "praise" this false being. I feel pity for you, but then I come to my senses and remember that you believe in "god" and laugh at you. Good luck with the faith bit, I hope it serves you well in "heaven", while you're getting butt fucked by "god".
Edotheclown 2 years ago 5
well, your gay.
kecjr82 2 years ago 5
homo
AtheistChase 2 years ago 4
Homo
Cobaltdrums 2 years ago 4
homo
bliss101 2 years ago 2
Hilarious.
HumanStrategy 2 years ago
Trolls detected in sector fail.
rba718 2 years ago
I hope you learned a lesson aaron; DON'T MESS WITH SHWANERD. If you do, be prepared to be crushed by his army.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
You're getting ripped apart aaron.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
Yeah, all of these highly intellectual comments calling him names are really ripping him apart. You're so funny kid.
ukchristian28 2 years ago
Thank you.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
LOLOL A WIZARD DID IT
iFelix0221 2 years ago
What's with fucking christians. GOD CREATED ME IN HIS IMAGIE IN 1 DAY. Well he fucked it up maan . Whats with your fucking neck? Andurhead? And u?
buzianyadatutube 2 years ago
DIK'EDDDD
1Nickk1 2 years ago
HAIL SATAN
Dantendo1122 2 years ago
Stop reading and learn your lines, homo kid.
Lemoncode 2 years ago
for a xtian u certainly harbour alot of anger...
biggles259 2 years ago
WOW DOES THIS KID HAVE DOWNS?
BrainDe2d 2 years ago
I feel sorry for your parents and friends...........if you have any.
Seriously, quit being a faggot bible basher.
jaypsns 2 years ago
so much fail
b1bIs1337 2 years ago
There is no doubt in my mind that one day theism will be classified as a mental illness. I believe genetics play a role in this illness.
ukchristian is irrelevant. He doesn't even have 200 subscribers. His videos are boring to watch also. ShwaNerd has never lost to a theist before. He could pwn ukchristian in a 2 minute video.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
Hello Joseph. Have you watched my videos on the subject? Did you listen to the portion of the video Aaron played? Do you know that psychology deals with individuals rather groups or belief systems?
ukchristian28 2 years ago
I thought you weren't speaking to me uk?
Let me give you a piece of advice uk. DON'T MESS WITH SHWANERD. His subscribers are very loyal to him.
Delusions can be classified as a mental illness.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
Oh, I thought I would make an exception. It's hard not to comment when you are trying to defend something so downright stupid. I tell you what. If you promise to be a good little boy I'll unblock you so you can comment on the videos themselves. It would be interesting to see you attempt a point by point refutation.
Oh Yes, I had better not mess with him because his silly little fans will mindlessly one star my videos and leave a load of vulgar remarks. Like I care about that.
ukchristian28 2 years ago
No uk, I'm not going to be a good little boy. Your videos are so stupid and boring, I'm going to rip you apart point by point, and it won't be pretty.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
Well, you're not commenting on any of my videos unless you apologise and promise to behave yourself. I suppose we can talk on here. Or are you going to provide a video response. That would be even better:).
ukchristian28 2 years ago
uk, I have nothing to apologize for. If you don't want me to comment on your videos, then that's your choice.
joebevins1999 2 years ago
Ok, down to business then Joe. You are going to provide a point by point response to my two videos are you?
ukchristian28 2 years ago
I lol'd
also, any argument for christianity can be applied to any other religion; so are these guys saying that muslims and scientologists and hindus are right too?
coolsmelly 2 years ago
Are you reading a script? lol
It must have taken a god to make you.
A cruel cruel god.
LoneOreo 2 years ago
Please deepthroat a shotgun and pull the trigger, you'd do the world a favour.
kang174 2 years ago
You poor ..poor child... please go to your dads sock drawer and find one of his playboys and take a look at what god made for you.. cause your on the road of never getting it...
COME ON ... your a kid.. act like it
masterbate
video games
sling/shots
oneyetroll 2 years ago
Blocked.
aaronk1994 2 years ago
Your fucking ridiculous haircut is proof enough that there is no God.
GiordanoBrunoII 2 years ago
Christ fags can't triforce ▲
▲ ▲
Nefyst 2 years ago
You sir, are a faggot.
mikeb420420 2 years ago
HOMO
cjpxx591 2 years ago
Ghey.
Prepare to be lamed religionfag
shadowlink96 2 years ago
Some people just need a good smack across the face =/
SucculentJuniper 2 years ago
Did Shwanerd actually make the argument in that video that theism was a mind disorder?
I only heard delusion, which is much more reasonable than a mind disorder which is obviously nonsense.
rba718 2 years ago
Hah... now after seeing UK's video with a tad of research, it would seem that Sha really fucked up lol.
I think I can see where he was going, giving him the benefit of the doubt here, but it was badly misplaced.
Not only did he really not do his research, but his original intended idea (which was pretty generalizing on its own) only seemed to apply to the hardcore fundies, which I don't think properly apply to the likes of you guys, especially you Aaron who has even rejected the idea of YEC.
rba718 2 years ago
Anyway, this is getting interesting lol. I just dumped my gf and feeling a tad shitty over it but this'll definitely give me some entertainment to distract me with lol. I wonder how Shwa's going to react.
rba718 2 years ago
It wouldn't even apply to fundies, because their beliefs are part of thier religious background.
ukchristian28 2 years ago
I guess that is a valid point. Some of the claims made kind of stick but I do agree that it's far too broad and generalistic to apply to all theists even the fundies.
He might as well have been saying that all black people listen to rap music, heh.
rba718 2 years ago
He cited criteria from Karl Jaspers and Alistair Munro which is used to indentify delusions which are caused by the mental illness Delusional Disorder. So, yes he was arguing that theism is the result of a mind disorder, and yes it is most absurd video he has ever made.
ukchristian28 2 years ago
A mental disorder would be something rather serious, organic, disabling... A delusion would just be fooling yourself into believing something for which there is little or no evidence. If I believe that I am Napoleon, that's a mental disorder. If I think I'm a good guitar player, that's a delusion. Aaron, I don't think you have a mental disorder. I do think you believe something to be fact for which there is little evidence. You are entitled to your opinion but that is does not make it fact.
DancingRabbit52 2 years ago
I agree, a delusion might be appropriate here but a mental disorder is rather insulting if not totally wrong.
I've come to give theists like Aaronk a little more respect than that.
rba718 2 years ago
Hey thanks, I still think a delusion is a rude title, but a mental disorder? LOL!!!!!!!!!!
aaronk1994 2 years ago
lulz, well I'm not going by the definition Shwa used. A bit of my bias opinion's in there too lol.
Btw, did he ever go back to that Stickam? Or do anything further?
rba718 2 years ago
Nope, he just ran away.
aaronk1994 2 years ago
You need a hair cut young man.
longhornman99001 2 years ago
Yes, he could do with a trim:).
ukchristian28 2 years ago
Talk about your temptest in a tea pot.
DancingRabbit52 2 years ago
Shwanerd doesn't do anything in his videos but mock. He adds nothing sensible to the debates. He just adds in his two cent commentary.
TheBelleNextDoor 2 years ago
Thanks Aaron.
ukchristian28 2 years ago 2