Strangely, I don't really care if Anette sings this. I like it better with Tarja, and it will never be better, but Anette does ok on this song. Wanna see epic fail? See Marco play Sacrament of Wilderness. That's Sami's best song with Nightwish. Losing Tarja wasn't the only thing that changed their sound. Losing Sami changed them too, it was just not as much.
Grow up people. I'm sick of snotty little brats who think they're superior to the artists themselves. If Annette sang this first, then Tarja came along, you'd be hating on her too. If Tarja hadn't been such a bitch, she wouldn't have been kicked.
If it's the music that makes a band good, then shouldn't the biggest factor be that Tuomas is still WRITING the music? Regardless of the Annette VS Tarja debate, or how crappy you thought DPP was, (which, IMO, though not as strong as many earlier NW discs, still had its own respective moments of brilliance) you mustn't forget that it all comes from the same source. For this reason, like it or not, Nightwish is here to stay. It'd be great if we could avoid flaming each other now. T
Hello, I haven't been here for a week and apparently this is a reply to me. Didn't know because you didn't press reply. Anyways on to the comment, Are you saying NW is popular now because Tuomas has been writing better lyrics? What do you mean from the same source? I never said or forgot that it was Tuomas writing the lyrics. In my other comments I said popularity is irrelevant, therefore music overcomes popularity. I don't understand your point on your comment? Flaming each other?
I had one opinion and people started flaming me. I'll like to say its an debate, but there is no valid answer. I was a fan, but I did not praise them! You want to win this, but you don't have a valid argument. Tuomas made it more appealing. I don't think they're good anymore, IMO. Just because NW is a popular band and Tuomas is the songwriter, doesn't mean the music is in FACT good. Music is subjective. Are you apart of a NW fan group whose slogan is NW is here to stay?
BTW, Tuomas lyrics are not great. When I say Music, I actually mean the music not lyrics. I would never listen to rock. Why listen to rock when you can listen to Metal? \m/ Too bad NW is not anymore.... Bye and that was a nice chat. Oh, and don't worry I know Tuomas composed the music, still not metal though. Its like Anette said ''its not PURE metal''. And NO music is brilliant these days. ♥Priscilla
Why is it that every time I express my opinion on Nightwish, I get the same answer.
''(They're more popular then ever before)'' ''(they're good because they have a best selling album)'' Popularity is irrelevant! I'm sure that Tuomas himself will agree with ''Popularity is irrelevant' Popularity doesn't make it good, MUSIC makes it good! Sure they have gained a lot of Lacuna Coil fans but lost all their old fans. Even if it was Tarja singing this Album, I'll still say DPP is crap.
??? Ankka939, In my last comment, I clearly said that popularity does not matter to me. Popularity is irrelevant. Tuomas probably meant that ''Nightwish won't last forever''. I meant ''won't last like 3 years or so''. That is my opinion. I'm not saying this to be mean or to offend someone. My words are completely genuine. This conversation is over. I hope one day you'll understand that just because something is popular, doesn't mean its good. Thanks for your opinion, -Priscilla♥
Yes it IS Tuomas's band, and nothing last forever. When my band loses sales, It will end, regardless if its MY band. And who are you to say Nightwish is not going anywhere? It is my opinion that it won't last but I did not say it will end this minute. By the way didn't I end this conversation? And When are you ever going to read any of my replys to you? Obviously you don't. -Priscilla
I love metal, but I also love pop. Anette is not a good pop singer, rock singer, whatever you call it. I'm all for the pop singing, but Anette is just not good. Well its the end of Nightwish, Tuomas said he wants Nightwish to be around for another 10 years. But at this pace, not going to happen. Nightwish is over.
Hello Ankka939, Agree to disagree. DPP may be their best selling album, but its not their best sounding album. MUSIC is all that matters, at least to me it does. DPP is definitely not their best album, music wise and singing wise. Live, Anette doesn't sound like she did on the album, thats what the studio is for. Listen, I'm not here to argue, I sure that isn't your intentions as well. But I have yet to hear a good reason of why Nightwish is still good. I wish them luck, but they won't last.
It's A-N-E-T-T-E. For those of you who can't spell. I don't know how you can like Nightwish and see them live, when none of you can spell their lead singer's name right.
hmmmmm... Annette doesnt really have the epic deep voice, but it sounds sweet instead of of xtreme epicness... Kinda weird with Annette, and kinda creepy... nice attempt. ^_^u
annette singing sounds different, thats just it. it sounds good even though it'll never be the same. she can sing metal and whatever, it will just sound weird because you'll always remember how tarja sang it and think that's how it was meant.
This is like the only old Tarja song that I actually think is better suited for Anette. They are both great singers, but most of old nightwish is way out of her vocal range, them changing the key on this however was genius. I always thought this song sounded a bit odd when Tarja sang it, and I think Anette's more rock centric sound is more suitable.
@arzoil96 no tarja is not better than anette with voice ya but as a performer anette is way better than tarja ever was ,well too bad for tarja that she is not with NIGHTWISH anymore cus ha she got fired almost 5 years ago and that's really bad for her .
nightwish never was rock band....they were symphonic metal but now, they......she is good singer, but not for this style of music....she is better for pop...
O.o No no no! O.o I just got back from Tarja's concert which included Wishmaster and OMG no! In Tarja's live it's powerful, strong, flawless! It's not that I hate Annette's voice but definitely no for songs performed by Tarja! I love nightwish but if I have to endure this way the old songs, I prefer going only to Taja's concerts!
Jesus. You people and this Tarja/Annette Holy war. Annette fucking rules. Get over it. Out with the old, in with the new. I love Tarja. i love Annette. I love Nightwish. It's all the same bad ass shit.
If Annette doesn't want to be compared to Tarja she should stick to the songs made by her. She's decent on her own, but if she tries to sing what Tarja did she is going to fail.
@74orangebeetle don´t forget, that nightwish hasn´t made at last 5 years a good album, so they sing the "old" songs. passion play wasn´t as famous as Ones
@74orangebeetle Go and say that to Tarja, if she realy didnt needed Nightwish for her career, she should stop singing nightwish's songs. Anette is a part of Nightwish and Nightwish gotta play those songs.
whats so bad about it? i'll tell you, its not the almighty tarja turunen thats not singing. she was so flawless anette has no chance at sounding good at this... get a frickin grip people why in the hell would you compare the 2 singers? do what i do, pretend its a new song and dont even let tarja enter your head... you might actually enjoy it then. anettes a fuckin good singer she doesnt need to sound like tarja to be good. its ok, you can say it, we wont tell anyone=)
definitivamente el poder de vocal que tiene Tarja... Annette no lo iguala.. los temas de Nigthwish.. siempre seran famosos por la voz de tarja.. debían haber esocgido una vocalista con mayor ataque vocal.. Annette.. sencillamente.. no jala.. :(
bullshit Tuomas u know it was a mistake to get Tarja out.... u lost the essence of Nightwish... u must get her back.. or at least get a good sopprano singer not a pop singer like Annete please.... ur messing up ur songs
well maybe annete is not that bad but goddamnit after hearing tarja this is abslout bullshit she does NOT have the type of voice needed for this music
She uses auto-tune in the original songs.... you can tell when auto-tone is being used because of the echo delay. I heard one of the songs on boost, fucking my ears bleed.
Nooooo Annnet ha matado otra cancion mas por favor Aneete te pedimos de corazon desde Costa Rica no mates mas canciones... Tarja se estara revolcando al escucharte... por favor no mas.......
She has murdered WISHMASTER I really hate you Aneete, I would like Tarja were there. Tarja has power for singing Annete has... nothing a Silly Voice... TARJA RULES TRJA POWER... FOREVER WISHMASTER BY TARJA....
I thought that this would be worse. This song isn't quite "trashed" as people say, but yes, Tarja had a more powerful voice for this song which made it sound better, but there is nothing that we can do about that now, is there?
you do realize on her solo career Tarja covers like 3 previous NightWish songs so you could extrapolate this to mean she is insulting them as well........
First of all... stop with the bullshit...Your "henglish"? Come on!!! Plain bullshit! You're not Italian. You're not even a real person.
2nd: You, my friend, never went to a Nightwish concert, because, if you did, you would like Anette more then Tarja. People that did, know what I mean. I rest my case!
sorry for my terrible henglish ..i'm italian..and i think Annet sing like a poor woodcock..she has ha pop style..it's not good for a group like Nightwish...
Tarja has a lyric style..she is better for this kind of music.
Watching this I don't know whether I should laugh or throw up. This is not Nightwish, this is horrible...even that little dance she does near the beginning is vomit provoking. Rest in peace Nightwish...I miss you.
Anette is fine singing the songs from dark passion play album but not the old songs....her voice is not strong like Tarja's who sings better this kind of music.
I wish one day Tarja back to Nightwish then Nightwish turn to be the great band that once it was.
I agree with you 100%, I don't know why she keeps insisting on singing old nightwish songs. Her voice cannot handle old nightwish songs, she should stick to new Nightwish.
Listening to live preformances from both Anette and tarja, I personally think that Anette's better. Her voice carries better than Tarja's in a concert situation, but I think I still do like Tarja's singing better than Anette's when it comes to the CDs.
If Annette can't sing wishmaster, ghost love score and the phantom of the ophera then nightwish has lost its soul, she should be able to sing ALL the songs in a beautiful way not killing the songs
Your just used to Tarja singing it. Annette isn't doing bad at all. It's just different. Just imagine someone singing disarm other than Billy Corgan. Or someone singing welcome to the jungle other than Axel. Neither one is going to be as good because it's not the original. Doesn't mean the singer sucks. Secondly, Nightwish didn't even write Phantom of the Opera. Why the hell would you even bring that up? Ah, what's the point, all you guys suck anyway.
To those who think Anette kills Tarja's songs and hates Tuomas for kicking out Tarja and replacing her with Anette, FUCKING DEAL WITH IT! The guys Nightwish made their choice, and all of y'all are going to have to deal with it. Also, if you really think Anette kills Nightwish, then STOP LISTENING!
I'd also like to add that it was the band's decision, not solely Tuomas's. Anette's voice is different than Tarja's so obviously they're going to sound different. Some songs I do agee Tarja pulled off perfectly and Anette dosen't quite measure (ie Phantom of the Opera, which they cited they pobobly won't play again), but I love Anette and I think she brings something new to most of the songs and songs like Wishmaste and Nemo she kinda makes he own and they come out great. Total cutie too
I think Anette does a great job at this song, dispite the HUGE voice range difference. I do love the way she rocks out, btw, and love her outfits. I liked the one she wore on August 27
in Philly. It was a green dress with different colored spirals. She wore a plastic tiara when the did The Islander, it was funny! Anyway, Anette does the old songs well, dispite the voice range difference between her and Tarja.
I gotta say she sucked at the chorus, but the verses were alright, definately not a song suited to her, id like to see more wishmaster style songs written to compliment annette becuase she does have a great voice
Please, someone put her out this misery. Or I will cut my ears off, Van Gogh style. And if I see her stupid "dance" anymore, I will gauge my eyes out.
I agree with most of you. Annette can sing, but song's like Wishmaster belong with Tarjas operette. But with annette you start paying attention to the other members of the band... which is what they wanted... still prefer tarja tho <3
Yes,Tarja is great for old Nightwish songs, but sorry.Annette is good for pop songs.She said that her voice is powerful when she is singing high notes.Sorry but I can´t hear these high notes!!! NW are playing Wishmaster in a different key (it is lower than original and she still can´t sing these high notes which should be there.Instead of it she is screaming and destroying her voice. OK, let her sing new NW songs, maybe she is good in it, but stop talking that she can sing well old NW songs!
ok ppl i am starting to get tired of reading the same comments over and over, Annette sucks...bring tarja back. i love tarja as much as the next person but she deseverved getting kicked out. she stopped talking to the whole band for a year...do u really think they would keep her? anyway they are both good they just have different singging styles. annette is better for some songs and tarja is better for others.
give a banana to annettem and maybe she stay on the stage, and sing really cause this is pretty bad. She doesnt know sing the old song of nightwish.. I love u tarja!!
annette is very talented but we are used to listen to tarja siguing lyric....not what annette sings, But i really like her voice, but not as a replacement
Anette is a talent singer like Tarja but you don't like her and that's totally different thing.The band didn't want to take other opera style singer so you better respect their freedom to do what they like.NW can't please everybody and they don't make music only to you!
IMO, NW completely missed the boat for not choosing an operatic singer and I am far from being the only one who thinks the same. I have nothing personnal against Annette, she seems quite a decent person and she has some talent. I am generally disappointed with her voice (too generic) but I don't mind her too much on a song like Amaranth. It suits her voice and style. However, Wishmaster (especially when you compare it to Tarja's beautiful version)shows her limitations as a singer.
Nightwish is not the first and last band with a new lead singer.Life is sometimes shit because you can't get what you want or wish.Tuomas said in one interview:"we took Anette and maby we lost some old fans but we get new ones too".Maby they lost you but this is life!
Hey Tarja lovers!We get your point that you don't like this so WHAT!The band don't care your opinions and they still have lot of old and new fans.Crying Tarja here don't change absolutely NOTHING!You better find something else to listen...like Tarja's solo...BYE,BYE!
I would say terrible is a poor choice of words. Is it different? Yes. And in being different the sound now appeals to a different crowd. Some old fans are part of this crowd still, some are not. It doesn't mean it is terrible. Annette does have talent, just different talent. The more proper thing all of you should be saying is that you do not enjoy it, which is fine. It doesn't mean however there aren't people that do enjoy it. Every coin has two sides.
Nothing against Anette because she sounds FANTASTIC singing the songs that are meant for her to sing, but old Nightwish songs just weren't made for her voice, even with the song sped up it just doesn't sound right, she may have even improved on her singing of old Nightwish songs but it will never be the same.
So, when I first came across this I though to myself 'damn video thief' and then I looked at the user profile and thought 'wait no, it's cool I gave him copies of this after the show.' Audio of this was much better at the show. But it's decent for a digital camera. ^ ^
At the concert I went to last night she did this song AMAZINGLY!! must have had some practice from then and she has a little more operatic sound about her now
That's an elaborate stage for karaoke night.
thebigbadjames 6 months ago
I would kiss her if I could. She is so hot and tough.
arnolsolitude 7 months ago 3
Wow .I actually really like Annette's version of Wishmaster! Wow!
TheSonofInnocence 11 months ago 7
I saw a Video of Tarja with Wishmaster at Wacken 2010.
If you compare these 2, this here is crap!
Annette is a good singer, but the old Tarja songs are made for Tarjas voice and not for Annette!
Braze77 11 months ago
Please come back to Detroit NightWish! i want to see these guys live really badly! NW forever \M/
SOAPYEXECUTION 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
gogo power rangers?
greyoldfellow 1 year ago
Strangely, I don't really care if Anette sings this. I like it better with Tarja, and it will never be better, but Anette does ok on this song. Wanna see epic fail? See Marco play Sacrament of Wilderness. That's Sami's best song with Nightwish. Losing Tarja wasn't the only thing that changed their sound. Losing Sami changed them too, it was just not as much.
TroubleClef2112 1 year ago
Fail. And here I was hoping this wouldn't waste my time. I was wrong. GET OFF THE STAGE! >_<
SeraphimIllusion 1 year ago
ZOMG!!!! I WANT TARJA ANNETTE SUCKZ!!!
Grow up people. I'm sick of snotty little brats who think they're superior to the artists themselves. If Annette sang this first, then Tarja came along, you'd be hating on her too. If Tarja hadn't been such a bitch, she wouldn't have been kicked.
DrCornwallis100 1 year ago
@SingerPrissy
If it's the music that makes a band good, then shouldn't the biggest factor be that Tuomas is still WRITING the music? Regardless of the Annette VS Tarja debate, or how crappy you thought DPP was, (which, IMO, though not as strong as many earlier NW discs, still had its own respective moments of brilliance) you mustn't forget that it all comes from the same source. For this reason, like it or not, Nightwish is here to stay. It'd be great if we could avoid flaming each other now. T
HevvyMettlRokkr 1 year ago
Hello, I haven't been here for a week and apparently this is a reply to me. Didn't know because you didn't press reply. Anyways on to the comment, Are you saying NW is popular now because Tuomas has been writing better lyrics? What do you mean from the same source? I never said or forgot that it was Tuomas writing the lyrics. In my other comments I said popularity is irrelevant, therefore music overcomes popularity. I don't understand your point on your comment? Flaming each other?
singerprissy 1 year ago
I had one opinion and people started flaming me. I'll like to say its an debate, but there is no valid answer. I was a fan, but I did not praise them! You want to win this, but you don't have a valid argument. Tuomas made it more appealing. I don't think they're good anymore, IMO. Just because NW is a popular band and Tuomas is the songwriter, doesn't mean the music is in FACT good. Music is subjective. Are you apart of a NW fan group whose slogan is NW is here to stay?
singerprissy 1 year ago
BTW, Tuomas lyrics are not great. When I say Music, I actually mean the music not lyrics. I would never listen to rock. Why listen to rock when you can listen to Metal? \m/ Too bad NW is not anymore.... Bye and that was a nice chat. Oh, and don't worry I know Tuomas composed the music, still not metal though. Its like Anette said ''its not PURE metal''. And NO music is brilliant these days. ♥Priscilla
singerprissy 1 year ago
this is not a symphonic voice....she's perfect for groups like dream theater....but for nightwish it takes other voice
wildchild87 1 year ago
Why is it that every time I express my opinion on Nightwish, I get the same answer.
''(They're more popular then ever before)'' ''(they're good because they have a best selling album)'' Popularity is irrelevant! I'm sure that Tuomas himself will agree with ''Popularity is irrelevant' Popularity doesn't make it good, MUSIC makes it good! Sure they have gained a lot of Lacuna Coil fans but lost all their old fans. Even if it was Tarja singing this Album, I'll still say DPP is crap.
singerprissy 1 year ago
@singerprissy He said that Nigtwish won't last. It will last because it is more popular than ever.
Ankka939 1 year ago
??? Ankka939, In my last comment, I clearly said that popularity does not matter to me. Popularity is irrelevant. Tuomas probably meant that ''Nightwish won't last forever''. I meant ''won't last like 3 years or so''. That is my opinion. I'm not saying this to be mean or to offend someone. My words are completely genuine. This conversation is over. I hope one day you'll understand that just because something is popular, doesn't mean its good. Thanks for your opinion, -Priscilla♥
singerprissy 1 year ago
@singerprissy Nightwish will last long as Tuomas wants. Nightwish is not going anywhere.
Ankka939 1 year ago
Yes it IS Tuomas's band, and nothing last forever. When my band loses sales, It will end, regardless if its MY band. And who are you to say Nightwish is not going anywhere? It is my opinion that it won't last but I did not say it will end this minute. By the way didn't I end this conversation? And When are you ever going to read any of my replys to you? Obviously you don't. -Priscilla
singerprissy 1 year ago
I love metal, but I also love pop. Anette is not a good pop singer, rock singer, whatever you call it. I'm all for the pop singing, but Anette is just not good. Well its the end of Nightwish, Tuomas said he wants Nightwish to be around for another 10 years. But at this pace, not going to happen. Nightwish is over.
singerprissy 1 year ago
@singerprissy You are so wrong. Nightwish is nowdays more popular than ever before.
Ankka939 1 year ago
Hello Ankka939, Agree to disagree. DPP may be their best selling album, but its not their best sounding album. MUSIC is all that matters, at least to me it does. DPP is definitely not their best album, music wise and singing wise. Live, Anette doesn't sound like she did on the album, thats what the studio is for. Listen, I'm not here to argue, I sure that isn't your intentions as well. But I have yet to hear a good reason of why Nightwish is still good. I wish them luck, but they won't last.
singerprissy 1 year ago
It's A-N-E-T-T-E. For those of you who can't spell. I don't know how you can like Nightwish and see them live, when none of you can spell their lead singer's name right.
LovingLife411 1 year ago
she's talking or singing? i dont understand
billying1 1 year ago
hmmmmm... Annette doesnt really have the epic deep voice, but it sounds sweet instead of of xtreme epicness... Kinda weird with Annette, and kinda creepy... nice attempt. ^_^u
Badheadphones101 1 year ago
annette singing sounds different, thats just it. it sounds good even though it'll never be the same. she can sing metal and whatever, it will just sound weird because you'll always remember how tarja sang it and think that's how it was meant.
Arverick88 1 year ago 2
Tarja was better... Anette is good for pop or smth, shes not metal style.
mefistof 1 year ago
This is like the only old Tarja song that I actually think is better suited for Anette. They are both great singers, but most of old nightwish is way out of her vocal range, them changing the key on this however was genius. I always thought this song sounded a bit odd when Tarja sang it, and I think Anette's more rock centric sound is more suitable.
joeyfrymaster 2 years ago
If you don't want to listen to Annette go and listen to Tarja's solo album -.-'' Tarja will not come back it was 5 years ago get over it already <.<
kelticprincess 2 years ago 16
Personally.. I think they shouldn't have gotten a new singer and just had Marco do all the vocals.
He is much better suited to think kind of music than Annette.
And he has a beautiful voice.
She's very talented.. but not for Nightwish.
DevinDropDead 2 years ago
uuuuuuuaaaaaaa anette
arzoil96 2 years ago
tarja is 100% better.
arzoil96 2 years ago
no she's not better
bignade00 2 years ago
yes she is
arzoil96 2 years ago
@arzoil96 no tarja is not better than anette with voice ya but as a performer anette is way better than tarja ever was ,well too bad for tarja that she is not with NIGHTWISH anymore cus ha she got fired almost 5 years ago and that's really bad for her .
bignade00 2 years ago
no she's not better [2]
LeoShadow2 2 years ago
try to listen this with anette and tarja is better.. anette can t sing dose old song of nightwish like tarja .
arzoil96 2 years ago
i think annette is much better, after all nightwish is a rock group and now they have a rock singer
gatorgirl87651234 2 years ago
Nightwish is Symphonic Power Metal, not rock.
Xxcom9a 2 years ago 3
nightwish never was rock band....they were symphonic metal but now, they......she is good singer, but not for this style of music....she is better for pop...
RedAndWhiteAngels 2 years ago
i think annette's version is more epic
grimraper666 2 years ago
O.o No no no! O.o I just got back from Tarja's concert which included Wishmaster and OMG no! In Tarja's live it's powerful, strong, flawless! It's not that I hate Annette's voice but definitely no for songs performed by Tarja! I love nightwish but if I have to endure this way the old songs, I prefer going only to Taja's concerts!
oaksoul 2 years ago
WTF ._.'
TwilightMidna8D 2 years ago
Jesus. You people and this Tarja/Annette Holy war. Annette fucking rules. Get over it. Out with the old, in with the new. I love Tarja. i love Annette. I love Nightwish. It's all the same bad ass shit.
Neverbeforemetal 2 years ago
I'm probably one of the few who actually likes this version with Annette. There's something new and refreshing about her voice.
Tarja and Annette are both great in their own ways. Everyone who compares them should stop wining and get a fucking life.
agnosticforce 2 years ago
It's a crap without Tarja. Anette does not have such powerful voice...
ravenssx 2 years ago 4
If Annette doesn't want to be compared to Tarja she should stick to the songs made by her. She's decent on her own, but if she tries to sing what Tarja did she is going to fail.
74orangebeetle 2 years ago 9
@74orangebeetle don´t forget, that nightwish hasn´t made at last 5 years a good album, so they sing the "old" songs. passion play wasn´t as famous as Ones
...sry for the bad english
Rockmeetsrock 1 year ago
@74orangebeetle Go and say that to Tarja, if she realy didnt needed Nightwish for her career, she should stop singing nightwish's songs. Anette is a part of Nightwish and Nightwish gotta play those songs.
nwcarmen 1 year ago
whats so bad about it? i'll tell you, its not the almighty tarja turunen thats not singing. she was so flawless anette has no chance at sounding good at this... get a frickin grip people why in the hell would you compare the 2 singers? do what i do, pretend its a new song and dont even let tarja enter your head... you might actually enjoy it then. anettes a fuckin good singer she doesnt need to sound like tarja to be good. its ok, you can say it, we wont tell anyone=)
Discipleofbabylon 2 years ago
omg......she sucks when singing the 2 names after the first chorus......wait, she sucks int he whole song.
SalandFindles 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Annette would be ok for High school Musical, but not for Nightwish!!!! Don't care if Tarja is a diva, please take her back!!!
allthingsalfx 2 years ago
Comment removed
allthingsalfx 2 years ago
definitivamente el poder de vocal que tiene Tarja... Annette no lo iguala.. los temas de Nigthwish.. siempre seran famosos por la voz de tarja.. debían haber esocgido una vocalista con mayor ataque vocal.. Annette.. sencillamente.. no jala.. :(
ronaldhell 2 years ago
I will always compare it to Tarja's voice, and well... it sucks.. I cant help it.
Nightwish is just a totally different band now :(
koenigcitizen 2 years ago 3
Tarja Cabulli on paljon parempi laulaja, tämä ei ole kyseenalaistettu.
Mitä jos he menettivät olennaista, että Nigthwish voimakas sopraano äänen kanssa Guitar riffin.
Nyt on ryhmä kuin kuka tahansa tavallinen laulaja.
katytadeoro 2 years ago
bullshit Tuomas u know it was a mistake to get Tarja out.... u lost the essence of Nightwish... u must get her back.. or at least get a good sopprano singer not a pop singer like Annete please.... ur messing up ur songs
DFnLProductions1 2 years ago
Omg.
I just said : WTF?!
machindu31 2 years ago
SametCedd said the absolutly true
sebomckagen 2 years ago
Sucks.
justanamehere 2 years ago
If you want Mrs Tarja Cabulli back, make your own band and ask her to be your singer... Right now, Nightwish IS actually with Anette as singer.
The songs was written by Tuomas, he does what he wants with HIS songs and with HIS band.
Anette's a very good singer, she sings it very very well. I love it.
SametCedd 2 years ago
well maybe annete is not that bad but goddamnit after hearing tarja this is abslout bullshit she does NOT have the type of voice needed for this music
Annete go sing ur pop music
DFnLProductions1 2 years ago 3
pop???
Tarja!! come back!!
oXClaudiaXo 2 years ago
jajajajajajajjaja jjajajajaj
no la critico..pero a tarja no las superas en soprano nunka !!!!!!!!!
echa pa tu pop xD
Velandia999 2 years ago
WTF?!
Tarja was so much better, and that's just sad!
anette can't sing...
i want tarja back.. !!
TheTarjaTurunen 2 years ago
sounds like a shitty cover of a highschool band O_o in other words WTF ?!?!
Ragnarock83 2 years ago 3
OMG that was so .... crappy
Urmothafu 2 years ago
WOW... I shouldn't have looked this up.
It's seriously shit. It sounds nothing like the song. Apparently Annette cannot sing live.
I guess I don't need to bother trying to catch them live now. What a shame.
ineedofauniquename 2 years ago
She uses auto-tune in the original songs.... you can tell when auto-tone is being used because of the echo delay. I heard one of the songs on boost, fucking my ears bleed.
QueenCannibis 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
annette sucks!!!!!!! !
niellman 2 years ago
wtf annette is doing in Nightwish ? i can't understand why did they fucking took her ...
suerath 2 years ago 3
very bad
nightwishutku 2 years ago
Anette you`re verry bad!! Tarja Turunen was,is and will be the best singer of Nightwish for all the time!!
TrueManowarFan 2 years ago 4
i like annete but in this song is really bad......
tarja suits better....
katerina240 2 years ago
She's gotten better at this song after this. Which good :D
AnetteHolopainen 2 years ago
Nooooo Annnet ha matado otra cancion mas por favor Aneete te pedimos de corazon desde Costa Rica no mates mas canciones... Tarja se estara revolcando al escucharte... por favor no mas.......
Kuroicam 2 years ago 3
She has murdered WISHMASTER I really hate you Aneete, I would like Tarja were there. Tarja has power for singing Annete has... nothing a Silly Voice... TARJA RULES TRJA POWER... FOREVER WISHMASTER BY TARJA....
Kuroicam 2 years ago 3
Mmmm.. Not my cup of tea. Tarja's version is a lot better.
KittyLuvAvrilLavigne 2 years ago 3
i think she's quite good at old material, but not at this song.. and not at she's my sin..and i hope she'll never sing kinslayer
but otherwise she quite rox
martinahrovat 2 years ago 2
ugh! pls stop her murdering the song!!
lovestruckvampire 2 years ago 3
I thought that this would be worse. This song isn't quite "trashed" as people say, but yes, Tarja had a more powerful voice for this song which made it sound better, but there is nothing that we can do about that now, is there?
Xxcom9a 2 years ago
WHAT-THE-FUCK.
she just killed what was an amazing song.
DuneBuggy00 2 years ago 4
Her voice is nice, but i think it would better match to another band..
VanilleKeks91 2 years ago 6
she pwns this song, go Annette!
DeathinHand 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
man she sucks at wishmaster
counting1210 3 years ago
oh come on ppl its not all that bad, i was expecting worse. pretty good IMO
mdenuzzo 3 years ago 2
Same.
Xxcom9a 2 years ago
please Nightwish dont sing old Nightwish songs unless you bring back Tarja. It's just an insult for her to be singing these songs
Kahn4 3 years ago
you do realize on her solo career Tarja covers like 3 previous NightWish songs so you could extrapolate this to mean she is insulting them as well........
KevinCarey 3 years ago
es you right....is really bad hear the song of tarja with annette voice...she is really bad!!!
4eSaintSeiya 2 years ago 2
oh my god!! she sings so bad
misato2009 3 years ago
No sir, I don't like it. Her butchering of the Elven...I died a little on the inside.
ashsnoww 3 years ago
First of all... stop with the bullshit...Your "henglish"? Come on!!! Plain bullshit! You're not Italian. You're not even a real person.
2nd: You, my friend, never went to a Nightwish concert, because, if you did, you would like Anette more then Tarja. People that did, know what I mean. I rest my case!
vladboldan 3 years ago
sorry for my terrible henglish ..i'm italian..and i think Annet sing like a poor woodcock..she has ha pop style..it's not good for a group like Nightwish...
Tarja has a lyric style..she is better for this kind of music.
dindondan009 3 years ago
What do you mean "lyric style"?
rainboworanges 3 years ago
lol. she kinda makes it sounds egyptian like and stuff. XD
darkeffect1 3 years ago 4
Anette has the wrong type of voice to sing Wishmaster properly, IMO. She does try well though.
GorgomirABjornson 3 years ago
Annettes a babe
jackattack55555 3 years ago
does she sing the misheard lyrics? :DDD
by the way, she looks better than Tarja i think :D
Piotrmiko 3 years ago 3
Nightwish isnt the same, she isnt a bad singer, just not the right one for Nightwish's style of music.
indiekid2590 3 years ago 2
Watching this I don't know whether I should laugh or throw up. This is not Nightwish, this is horrible...even that little dance she does near the beginning is vomit provoking. Rest in peace Nightwish...I miss you.
skullvomit666 3 years ago
Anette is fine singing the songs from dark passion play album but not the old songs....her voice is not strong like Tarja's who sings better this kind of music.
I wish one day Tarja back to Nightwish then Nightwish turn to be the great band that once it was.
Dri486 3 years ago
I agree with you 100%, I don't know why she keeps insisting on singing old nightwish songs. Her voice cannot handle old nightwish songs, she should stick to new Nightwish.
TumaScorpio 3 years ago
Listening to live preformances from both Anette and tarja, I personally think that Anette's better. Her voice carries better than Tarja's in a concert situation, but I think I still do like Tarja's singing better than Anette's when it comes to the CDs.
CryingCrimsonEyes 3 years ago
I like Anette more than Tarja. Now I started to listen to Nightwish;) She's just different but not worse remember that!
B4K4pl 3 years ago
actually she's worse. she's different, and that difference makes nightwish worse than when Tarja was the singer.
of course, that's only my opinion (and most of people's)
Potokuz 3 years ago
i dont think so. i see half and half. ppl love tarja and hate anette and ppl love anette and hate tarja.
then theres the awesome ppl like me that love both.
darkeffect1 3 years ago
I'm one of those people who love both =D
There are Tarja fans, Anette fans, and Nightwish fans. =D
I classify myself as a NW fan.
rainboworanges 3 years ago 2
woot woot! hellz yea! ^_^
Nightwish is the awesomest band ever.
ppl should really build a bridge and get over it...with the whole anette and tarja thing. XD
darkeffect1 3 years ago
I know, huh? It's been a few years already.
rainboworanges 3 years ago
exactly
its not like they all left :P
only tarja
not that it wasn't sad :(<--
but annettes got a better live style in my opinion :)
Lightbringer1234 3 years ago 2
Yeah, Anette is way more enthusiastic and is great with the crowd.
rainboworanges 3 years ago
tarja sing best... anneto nooo ¬¬
but nightwish is the best
LyShahoran 3 years ago
0:30 No Annette... no air guitar...
honestguitarist 3 years ago
Lol...oh thats amusing :)
CryptKeeper2929 3 years ago
This is a shit!
SirMartinez1989 3 years ago 3
ela acabou com wishmaster,anette não presta pra ficar no nightwish, ela é pop, ela tem a voz bonita mais não pra esse tipo de música..
Tarja volta para o NIGHTWISH!!!!
DarkPrincess02 3 years ago 3
If Annette can't sing wishmaster, ghost love score and the phantom of the ophera then nightwish has lost its soul, she should be able to sing ALL the songs in a beautiful way not killing the songs
morrigan77 3 years ago
Your just used to Tarja singing it. Annette isn't doing bad at all. It's just different. Just imagine someone singing disarm other than Billy Corgan. Or someone singing welcome to the jungle other than Axel. Neither one is going to be as good because it's not the original. Doesn't mean the singer sucks. Secondly, Nightwish didn't even write Phantom of the Opera. Why the hell would you even bring that up? Ah, what's the point, all you guys suck anyway.
tommy3354 3 years ago
sounds different... but not bad!!!!
masterofmorphine92 3 years ago
To those who think Anette kills Tarja's songs and hates Tuomas for kicking out Tarja and replacing her with Anette, FUCKING DEAL WITH IT! The guys Nightwish made their choice, and all of y'all are going to have to deal with it. Also, if you really think Anette kills Nightwish, then STOP LISTENING!
yourworstnightmare95 3 years ago 5
I'd also like to add that it was the band's decision, not solely Tuomas's. Anette's voice is different than Tarja's so obviously they're going to sound different. Some songs I do agee Tarja pulled off perfectly and Anette dosen't quite measure (ie Phantom of the Opera, which they cited they pobobly won't play again), but I love Anette and I think she brings something new to most of the songs and songs like Wishmaste and Nemo she kinda makes he own and they come out great. Total cutie too
CryptKeeper2929 3 years ago
I think Anette does a great job at this song, dispite the HUGE voice range difference. I do love the way she rocks out, btw, and love her outfits. I liked the one she wore on August 27
in Philly. It was a green dress with different colored spirals. She wore a plastic tiara when the did The Islander, it was funny! Anyway, Anette does the old songs well, dispite the voice range difference between her and Tarja.
yourworstnightmare95 3 years ago
Oh and that dance annette is doing, while quite funny, she is just rockin out...we all do it...*cough*
Stalwart33 3 years ago 2
I gotta say she sucked at the chorus, but the verses were alright, definately not a song suited to her, id like to see more wishmaster style songs written to compliment annette becuase she does have a great voice
Stalwart33 3 years ago
AHHHHHHHHHHHHH!
She's destroing Wishmaster, stop her please!
God, I've never liked her, I think she's too much pop, but I believe she could work with new NW songs, but don't let her sing the old ones...
She's killing my myth...
Oh,well,sorry for the many many grammar mistakes...
SmashDownHLS 3 years ago 3
Please, someone put her out this misery. Or I will cut my ears off, Van Gogh style. And if I see her stupid "dance" anymore, I will gauge my eyes out.
davidku18 3 years ago 2
yesss that `dance`.... I cant take it!!!!
Archvillee 3 years ago
sorry annette you have a good voice for your songs but you killed tarjas song
xoxoCINxoxo 3 years ago
I agree with most of you. Annette can sing, but song's like Wishmaster belong with Tarjas operette. But with annette you start paying attention to the other members of the band... which is what they wanted... still prefer tarja tho <3
lauragrigis 3 years ago
Annette can really substitute the lead singer of a band... like Paramore or something like that, but NEVER Nightwish.
What the hell is this dance that she does in front of the microphone??
Tuomas, I hate you for what you've done with Tarja, YOU DESTROYED NIGHTWISH.
taistelijan 3 years ago 2
Honestly.. I was expecting her to sing it even worse.. but it's not that bad.. taking in consideration that it's live too...
PurpleWitchAla 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
annette sucks
Tisz92 3 years ago
it seems a calf singing...but godluck 4 her and the pop band!
kakazinha85 3 years ago
Yes,Tarja is great for old Nightwish songs, but sorry.Annette is good for pop songs.She said that her voice is powerful when she is singing high notes.Sorry but I can´t hear these high notes!!! NW are playing Wishmaster in a different key (it is lower than original and she still can´t sing these high notes which should be there.Instead of it she is screaming and destroying her voice. OK, let her sing new NW songs, maybe she is good in it, but stop talking that she can sing well old NW songs!
misomed 3 years ago 3
ok ppl i am starting to get tired of reading the same comments over and over, Annette sucks...bring tarja back. i love tarja as much as the next person but she deseverved getting kicked out. she stopped talking to the whole band for a year...do u really think they would keep her? anyway they are both good they just have different singging styles. annette is better for some songs and tarja is better for others.
olaallppl123 3 years ago 3
give a banana to annettem and maybe she stay on the stage, and sing really cause this is pretty bad. She doesnt know sing the old song of nightwish.. I love u tarja!!
MANTIAnox 3 years ago
annette is very talented but we are used to listen to tarja siguing lyric....not what annette sings, But i really like her voice, but not as a replacement
csabbia 3 years ago
Jesus, it doesn't get better with time... Annette just doesn't have the talent required to compare favourably with Tarja on this song...
Enough of the Oheeee, Eheeee, Aheeee!!!
Ozbeach 3 years ago
Anette is a talent singer like Tarja but you don't like her and that's totally different thing.The band didn't want to take other opera style singer so you better respect their freedom to do what they like.NW can't please everybody and they don't make music only to you!
RockSidi 3 years ago 5
IMO, NW completely missed the boat for not choosing an operatic singer and I am far from being the only one who thinks the same. I have nothing personnal against Annette, she seems quite a decent person and she has some talent. I am generally disappointed with her voice (too generic) but I don't mind her too much on a song like Amaranth. It suits her voice and style. However, Wishmaster (especially when you compare it to Tarja's beautiful version)shows her limitations as a singer.
Ozbeach 3 years ago
Nightwish is not the first and last band with a new lead singer.Life is sometimes shit because you can't get what you want or wish.Tuomas said in one interview:"we took Anette and maby we lost some old fans but we get new ones too".Maby they lost you but this is life!
RockSidi 3 years ago 6
Hey Tarja lovers!We get your point that you don't like this so WHAT!The band don't care your opinions and they still have lot of old and new fans.Crying Tarja here don't change absolutely NOTHING!You better find something else to listen...like Tarja's solo...BYE,BYE!
RockSidi 3 years ago 2
it doesn't mean that this doesn't sound horrible
mishakaz 3 years ago
I would say terrible is a poor choice of words. Is it different? Yes. And in being different the sound now appeals to a different crowd. Some old fans are part of this crowd still, some are not. It doesn't mean it is terrible. Annette does have talent, just different talent. The more proper thing all of you should be saying is that you do not enjoy it, which is fine. It doesn't mean however there aren't people that do enjoy it. Every coin has two sides.
xanith02100 3 years ago
Horrible!!
Hasta mi perro lo haría mejor.
Nightwish ya murió sin Tarja.
Saludos!
0cureberry0 3 years ago
Annette sucks :D
Mnemosyne6134 3 years ago
Nothing against Anette because she sounds FANTASTIC singing the songs that are meant for her to sing, but old Nightwish songs just weren't made for her voice, even with the song sped up it just doesn't sound right, she may have even improved on her singing of old Nightwish songs but it will never be the same.
Halloweenkitten 3 years ago
she isn't bad, but.... Tarja is better than anette
por ultimo que no cante los temas que tarja canto
por que le alen pesimos! so horrible! i can't belive that ¬¬ i hate she
es como que intentaron reemplazar a tarja, pero a anette no le funciona
B10ndM4CH1n3 3 years ago 3
una porqueria
I prefer Tarja
horribleeeeeeeeeeee
rominonna 3 years ago 3
horrible, horrible!!!!
metallara91 3 years ago 2
are u from y! answers? xD
Anyway I gotta agree with you... this sucks very bad
------------
I've never liked Anette, and I'm not able to make me like her... And probably never will!
Sfacteria 3 years ago
yeah, i'm from y! answers! XD XD
metallara91 3 years ago
Oh come on, of course she didn't hit the high notes! It's not in her vocal range so just don't complain. I love this version sung by Anette.
Alexandritee 3 years ago 4
So, when I first came across this I though to myself 'damn video thief' and then I looked at the user profile and thought 'wait no, it's cool I gave him copies of this after the show.' Audio of this was much better at the show. But it's decent for a digital camera. ^ ^
siren1187 3 years ago
noob
Porchetta70 3 years ago
oh god, she can't even hit the high notes! That made this song for me.
don't get me wrong, she does it her way nice, but it's just not that same :(
Tarja forever!
jimmyoperaguy 3 years ago
ew yeah this sounds bad!!
At the concert I went to last night she did this song AMAZINGLY!! must have had some practice from then and she has a little more operatic sound about her now
LLAMAbrittxX 3 years ago
theres songs that tarja sing better and another ones that annette sings better but the both are really great
sebas741 3 years ago
I still prefer Tarja.
Wich song Annette is Better?
TKS
Boris210 3 years ago 2
I just heard Annette in the Sacrament of wildernness in tavastia 2007 and i think is better
daviberto 3 years ago
Excellent ! Les jeux de lumières sont fabuleux ! :D
ghostkill77 3 years ago
awesome song, and verry well recorded. the quality of the video is really nice. thx for posting ^^
xXSlave2MusicXx 3 years ago 2