@THEraginBADGER Hey you are right ! But what is the only one tempo?? Í have a recording of Billy, where he plays it at 180 bpm. There´sonly one person who knows the answer ;-)
@Andre1515xxx I can barely tap my foot to 250, lol. It sounds better aroun 156-160, I just play it there because I Can. Personally, I like it slower. :)
lol C flat? how unorthodox, youd think theyd just write the signature of B major as an alterntative = S not that B major is not annoying but at least its less annoying that C flat!
Hi.First of all,i have to say that i really really love your playing.You're doing a VERY good job,playing it on 156.Ofc you can try to go for 160,but the song is actually already fast enough and i think it's just right.
Really - well done!
But one thing i wish you woulda done:Wish you didnt turn on this background drums..it really is annoying.I wanna hear you play and not the drums :)
So maybe you can re-record it at some time without background music :D
verry verry nice from a girls point a view who plays this song 24/7 yer way better then me but then again considering my age.. who knows : - ) but very very nice
Very good! Nice to see you playing the left hand that way (during the main melody).. I've played this song for a long time (I have a version of it in my medley video if you're interested in watching) but I've never played the left hand that way.
Your fingers look great. I don't have any comments to help you improve - you did it so well.
Wait, the only thing is that this song can't be played much faster - (the melody doesn't sound too good)
i got to see billy joel perform this live on november 17, and i can tell you, i thought i'd been watching the best piano player on earth. i've changed my mind after watching this one... i didn't notice more than one missed notes...even billy missed about 5 playing live
Now uv started readin dis dunt stop. This is so scary. Send this to 5 ova videos in 143 minutes When ur done press F6 and ur crushes name will appear on the screen in big letters. This is scary cause it actually works. If u break the chain u will have problems with relations p.s for the next..ages
not yet ;) i saw atomterribles version and was unimpressed, as i say 180 is easy and its not the whole song. also the origional is at 144 so that music is at a slower tempo. it is a good piece yea especially when played by billy joel himself...and me, when you get to 200bpm tho it sounds silly [btw can anyone else do that? na didnt think so ;P]. this is one of the best versions on youtube though still because it doesnt sound like a mess
Come to think of it< i don't recall the middle bit, there must be two or more versions of this song, I had the version that was 120, I remember that, But didn't have that middle chromatic bit, it finished differently too... very good dude!!
not bad..but i can play it at 180bpm with ease and trying i can do 200-210bpm. i dont know why but nobody seems to be able to play it as fast as billy joel, who usually did it in the 170-80bpm range when he performed it live yet ive only been playin properly for a few years
Ok...awesome control and all but, remember, fast is not necessairly good. It loses its musicality when it's played so unbelievably fast. Impressive, but not overwhelming.
5 Stars also for this version (tempo 156) which is faster than the original 70s version in some spots. You do the original fine justice and the wisecritic thanks you for your contributions to youtube!
Again I am writting to you, this is just amazing. Thank you for passing me the sheet music. I wanted to know how long did it take you to learn this song. It seems imposible.
Well done, try to get the speed up a bit :). And for those of you who are in love lol get a hold of the music and try it out! its not as difficult as it sounds and its very impressive nonetheless, especially with a drummer and guitarist!
I love Billy Joel and that is like the master himself, some only associate Joel with Uptown Girl and such like but the guy has an amazing back catalogue from the early 70's such as this !!!
And to think he almost topped himself, what a waste that would have been....oh and don't forget Christie Brinkley - lucky sod !!!
Damn the torpedoes - play it as fast as humanly possible 'til there's smoke billowing up from the keys! This song's made for performance, not sentimentality!
its played faster than in the album i think the album speed is better
THEraginBADGER 1 year ago
@THEraginBADGER Hey you are right ! But what is the only one tempo?? Í have a recording of Billy, where he plays it at 180 bpm. There´sonly one person who knows the answer ;-)
Andre1515xxx 1 year ago
That was really well done. Way to follow the metronome cause you know it won't follow you.
BrianAveryPiano 1 year ago
Sounds great, I played at 205 (yes, correctly, other than a second here and there) and my wrist was swolen!
TurbofanDude 1 year ago
Hey, I can play at 205. LOL You sound great
TurbofanDude 1 year ago
Hey man, why not play it with 250 bpm. Guess it sounds much greater ;-)))
Andre1515xxx 1 year ago
@Andre1515xxx I can barely tap my foot to 250, lol. It sounds better aroun 156-160, I just play it there because I Can. Personally, I like it slower. :)
TurbofanDude 1 year ago
@TurbofanDude
But it's much more fun to fight with yourself to keep the 250 :)
Schoorsch32 1 year ago
@Schoorsch32 lol, I got 215 once, but it was pretty damn hard
TurbofanDude 1 year ago
wow you're good! :D
eltonj4ever 1 year ago
Nice one ;) Perfect speed ! i like it this way ! =)
mike4853 1 year ago
i think there was a video from you before.
best one =)
Schoorsch32 2 years ago
thanks :-)
Andre1515xxx 2 years ago
This is definitely one of he best, if not the best rendition of this I've seen that isn't Joel himself.
Well done!
ninjaquest 2 years ago 2
Amazing!
yasoxxxx 2 years ago
on the album "streetlife serendade" this song is played in the key C Flat...eww!
Nice playing, I wish I could do that!
huggedtodeath93 2 years ago
C Flat really? damn thats what I thought when I heard the recording. lol thats not fun at ALL!
quadrelatera 2 years ago
lol C flat? how unorthodox, youd think theyd just write the signature of B major as an alterntative = S not that B major is not annoying but at least its less annoying that C flat!
cambridget 2 years ago
The grand was (de) tuned !! He was always playing in C.
Andre1515xxx 2 years ago
how long did it take you to work this out? you are just wow....you make me look like a beginner
NerdBoy001 2 years ago 2
=D good job!
ducky3d 2 years ago
ha is das geil xD
Stormbubi 2 years ago
im still working on this song, words cant describe how awesome that was.
brentsummers1 2 years ago
Best version of Root Beer Rag I've seen. You breezed through the difficult lines! Nice job!
chicagospots 3 years ago
Amazing. Do you have the sheet music for that? I'm blown away.
Formetheus 3 years ago
Clap Clap Clap!
Mark4669 3 years ago
great played :)
Oukbok 3 years ago
Damn that was good!
dahur 3 years ago
dude, that was crazy good, as the poptart stick figure people would say! No, but really though, you played amazing.
pianoperson12345 3 years ago
i started learning this about a year ago then i stopped. you make this look so easy.
amazing
heyiplaypiano 3 years ago
das tönt echt hammer mässig
ich bin auch am lernen ;)
mach weiter so
daemu77 3 years ago
ja ist wirklich sehr virtuos wie komme ich an Noten für Piano.
ducatirafi 3 years ago
You are good man!
JamesLiveProductions 3 years ago
Wow. That was really good. You = GOD :) Now give your hands :D
JordanDupuis101 3 years ago
Hi.First of all,i have to say that i really really love your playing.You're doing a VERY good job,playing it on 156.Ofc you can try to go for 160,but the song is actually already fast enough and i think it's just right.
Really - well done!
But one thing i wish you woulda done:Wish you didnt turn on this background drums..it really is annoying.I wanna hear you play and not the drums :)
So maybe you can re-record it at some time without background music :D
Congratulations!
-Alligator Jack
AlligatorJack01 3 years ago
mega!
Stonejohn28 3 years ago
Sehr Gut!!! Bravo!!!
Mit Freundliche Grüssen : István
stefi144 3 years ago
very nice played!
rootinier 3 years ago 2
MOST EXCELLENT!!!
josephtierney11 3 years ago
Don't bother going for 160... you did an excellent job at 156 and pushing it faster would ruin it!
curtmcd 3 years ago 3
verry verry nice from a girls point a view who plays this song 24/7 yer way better then me but then again considering my age.. who knows : - ) but very very nice
RockleeME 3 years ago
wow!! i think it's a fantastic version of this song, thank you very much!!
murdererer2 4 years ago 3
hello :) could you mail me sheet music of this please? thanks
justysbasketball in yahoo
ssstevenash 4 years ago
I will. It should come soon but the quality might not be great .
lamborghinifreak 3 years ago
billy would be proud. well done
katubus 4 years ago 6
props man major props
ppppppppppaaaaaaaaaa 4 years ago 3
do you know where i could buy this piece in C major for an instant download online????
please respond back
jamesypoo25 4 years ago 2
as opposed to the one in F# major?
gordo39432 4 years ago 4
Excellent job! Bravo!
FATMIME 4 years ago 4
I´m play this song too. but not on a piano, i play it on a Akkordeon( i dont now the english name for "Akkordeon")
You playing very good! Respeckt!
Greetings from Germany/Dortmund
knabber35 4 years ago 2
what ur doing is not playing but raping the piano, OMG
tought
D2checker 4 years ago 3
Very good! Nice to see you playing the left hand that way (during the main melody).. I've played this song for a long time (I have a version of it in my medley video if you're interested in watching) but I've never played the left hand that way.
Your fingers look great. I don't have any comments to help you improve - you did it so well.
Wait, the only thing is that this song can't be played much faster - (the melody doesn't sound too good)
jgelhaar 4 years ago
i am at the first page and you make it really good!
but i can play the refrain in tempo 160 too! thats not difficult but all....
purplepopel 4 years ago
respect !
pstickel1337 4 years ago
your damn good man! i have to play this with the chappel I'm in with my german flute. I don't get the point how I should play the lead in 136...
grisele 4 years ago
i got to see billy joel perform this live on november 17, and i can tell you, i thought i'd been watching the best piano player on earth. i've changed my mind after watching this one... i didn't notice more than one missed notes...even billy missed about 5 playing live
anthonystuart69 4 years ago
You're badass! Do you have to do some kind of warm up before playing that?
akalcov 4 years ago
YAERS :-)
Andre1515xxx 4 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Now uv started readin dis dunt stop. This is so scary. Send this to 5 ova videos in 143 minutes When ur done press F6 and ur crushes name will appear on the screen in big letters. This is scary cause it actually works. If u break the chain u will have problems with relations p.s for the next..ages
Lokikol123123 4 years ago
Great job and entertaining to watch your handywork at the keys!
sbbinahee 4 years ago
Go up one octave there, please
Danetist 4 years ago
OK,...and then?
Andre1515xxx 4 years ago
not yet ;) i saw atomterribles version and was unimpressed, as i say 180 is easy and its not the whole song. also the origional is at 144 so that music is at a slower tempo. it is a good piece yea especially when played by billy joel himself...and me, when you get to 200bpm tho it sounds silly [btw can anyone else do that? na didnt think so ;P]. this is one of the best versions on youtube though still because it doesnt sound like a mess
p14n0m4n 4 years ago
Search for "Root Beer Rag atomterrible".
atomterrible 4 years ago
Fer fucks sake the original tempo was written at 120 man I know, I had the music
dnnykly 4 years ago
Come to think of it< i don't recall the middle bit, there must be two or more versions of this song, I had the version that was 120, I remember that, But didn't have that middle chromatic bit, it finished differently too... very good dude!!
dnnykly 4 years ago
not bad..but i can play it at 180bpm with ease and trying i can do 200-210bpm. i dont know why but nobody seems to be able to play it as fast as billy joel, who usually did it in the 170-80bpm range when he performed it live yet ive only been playin properly for a few years
p14n0m4n 4 years ago
finished gloating, mate? i think its great anyone can play this.. its awesome :D
benja54 4 years ago
Hey, Do you have the sheet music for this, I'm currently unable to find it and I would really like to perfect it too a level in which it is good ^.^.
Ansel989 4 years ago
Sweet! This song was oringinally meant to be played extrememly fast. Billy Joel used to play it as fast as he could in concerts, etc. Good Job!
backspin7 4 years ago
Ok...awesome control and all but, remember, fast is not necessairly good. It loses its musicality when it's played so unbelievably fast. Impressive, but not overwhelming.
deltaechoromeo515 4 years ago
good job!
multiplevitamin063 4 years ago
ich will das lied auch so gut spielen können :D echt bewundernswert!!
hupahupahupahupa 4 years ago
Richtig Geil (gespielt!! das Stück sowieso) =)
knut9a 4 years ago
5 Stars also for this version (tempo 156) which is faster than the original 70s version in some spots. You do the original fine justice and the wisecritic thanks you for your contributions to youtube!
wisecritic 4 years ago
you are my star :-)
BigSchroedi 4 years ago
Danke,....wollte schon immer einmal ein Star sein ;-)Frage: Wie kommt man auf die Bühne? Üben,üben,üben,....
Andre1515xxx 4 years ago
Still awesome.
Rackergen 4 years ago
amazing. Wish I could play it that well.
Oppdal77 4 years ago
took awhile to get my mouth to close... nicely done!
louswire 4 years ago
well fuking dun. 130 is my limit with this piece and even at tht i usually make a few mistakes. well dun again
chimperooney 4 years ago
That was amazing dude, and yeah the sheet music would be great for this.
Apachelar 4 years ago
This is brilliant!
interigator 5 years ago
Again I am writting to you, this is just amazing. Thank you for passing me the sheet music. I wanted to know how long did it take you to learn this song. It seems imposible.
Educs 5 years ago
wowowowowowowowowowowowowowowowow! (my fingers moved almost as fast as yours typing that! ;0)
LiverpoolPoet 5 years ago
I'd love the sheet music too, if you have the time that is?
I keep watching you work, it's incredible!
LiverpoolPoet 5 years ago
You can get it out of the complete billy joel collection books. I bought both volumes at the music store. they're great books.
deathon2legs55 5 years ago
Well done, try to get the speed up a bit :). And for those of you who are in love lol get a hold of the music and try it out! its not as difficult as it sounds and its very impressive nonetheless, especially with a drummer and guitarist!
daniscool99 5 years ago
I love Billy Joel and that is like the master himself, some only associate Joel with Uptown Girl and such like but the guy has an amazing back catalogue from the early 70's such as this !!!
And to think he almost topped himself, what a waste that would have been....oh and don't forget Christie Brinkley - lucky sod !!!
wataf211110 5 years ago
Hey I did this song too.. and a couple of others so please check me out... I'm new but I promise my songs are worth wild
Ansel989 5 years ago
Holy cow! How long have you been playing?
Would you mind sending me the sheet music as well? I'd love to give this song a try!
sdfdsgerggr 5 years ago
BEAST!!!! cant wait for 160
homestar216 5 years ago
What key is this in?
Ansel989 5 years ago
Hi Andre1515xxx can you send me the sheets too? You play this very good!!
shini007 5 years ago
Billy Joel himself would be proud. Absolutely Flawless. When are you going to go for 160?
muiscgangsta92 5 years ago
yes....yes you are a god. I bow down to you... I'm not worthy! I'm not worthy!!!
rinzable 5 years ago
wow that defines "flawless"
bsilverop 5 years ago
Damn the torpedoes - play it as fast as humanly possible 'til there's smoke billowing up from the keys! This song's made for performance, not sentimentality!
nlllvqker 5 years ago
Exelent please can you tell me where can I find the sheet music?
Educs 5 years ago
Hi Educs, I can send you the sheets via email.Greetings Andree
Andre1515xxx 5 years ago
thank you andree. could you send me please your sheets of the root beer rag. thank you very much.
ps. brilliant playing
donpiano1 5 years ago
ok, sry, now i know the original, its quite faster XD
issiro410 5 years ago
Awesome tempo and absolute clean!
But please, please, do me a favour, don't try to make it yet faster, you will destroy the song. ;-) (ich spreche aus erfahrung)
sers
issiro410 5 years ago
Viele Grüsse an Vera von Diego & Alain.She will know,who we are
mcaly 5 years ago
ok killerman, that's fast. But it took 42 years to come to this point...
dg6da 5 years ago
Thanks brother :-)
Andre1515xxx 5 years ago
WORKING ON IT?!
What's to work on?! :p
HexenX 5 years ago
....make it better and faster :-)
Andre1515xxx 5 years ago
I play that song myself, but must say, u just MASTERED it.
Mullenfreek 5 years ago
Thanx,Im working on it :-)
Andre1515xxx 5 years ago