张学友 / 费玉清 - 偏偏喜欢你

[sumyupong]

215196說得太好，要公道，每人都照個人己見偏好定論，公平­就不會出現，公平是要客觀的，兩位都各有長處，能多合作歌迷耳福­不淺！

[musicfan200611]

两位天王级歌手，唱功一流， 太好的享受！

[Bobby0917]

費玉清唱廣東歌都幾標準，同學友都系幾有默契，兩個都系實力最勁­

[MultiLostKid]

it's a great classic! but i have to admit that it sounded and looked pretty gay! LOL

[donping7]

看到上面的評論, 怎麼扯到周杰倫的? 不過, 評論也說得有道理; 每個人有自己的風格, 不要去評誰好誰不好, 你喜歡就好唄....

[dannicramp]

it's classical

[wshp90]

张学友太棒了！

[vangmx]

Jacky and Fei Yu-qing together? Never seen this clip and it's simply amazing just to hear two great singers together.

[HomelessCao]

强啊，神作啊

[SuperMICHELLEHO]

小哥在廣州演唱會唱的廣東歌曲是超棒的!

[haia88]

1:11秒.為何我的心不去死.

[Cucumber8787]

费玉清好像一个色狼淫魔 =。= 可怜的学友。。。

[firenze878]

@Cucumber8787 hahaha~~~seems so

[comdesgarcon]

one of the best performance of jacky

[ken34258]

費玉清 廣東話 的聲音好好聽

[SecksPistol]

As 215196 said, They are both talented in their own ways.

Jay can rap and he have the guts to write his own songs, mix R&B, Blues, Classic, Rap, and Cross over together. Maybe thats why Jay was very popular.

In the other hand, 費玉清's voice is clean and strong. Its just like telling 費玉清 to rap and Jay to sing like 費玉清. Its almost impossible. So why fight over that?

[jonboy123]

How does one even come up with the comparison between Jay Chou and Jacky Cheung? Absolutely ridiculous...

[lesliefan79]

Fei Yu Ching should stick to singing Mandarin songs instead of mangling this beautiful song with his half baked Cantonese.........Jackie does a good job but it's Fei who gave me goose bumps.........the hair-raising kind!

[DubCmusicTV]

@lesliefan79 The last name will have a "B/P" sound in Cantonese and not hold the more commonly known character with the "F" song while Mandarin keeps the sound, weird Chinese fact.

[sunmoon404]

Jay Chou, 学友,玉清are very good singer, different. style. Jay is using his natural real speaking voice to sing, he creates his own style, he sing in a relaxing way. some famous singer with nice voice cannot sing his songs becuase his songs need a lot of technique. For people donot like Jay's voice becuase they used to listen to the old style. Actually, Jay did sing some old style songs too, such as Ju Hua Tai, he sings very good in this song.

[107640513]

這是多少年前的呢?

[worcester1115]

大家为什么总要为了各自的偶像吵来吵去的。。。谁好谁不好又能怎­样？你自己喜欢为啥又非要强加给别人

[11chanse]

哇！！！！好听啊！！！！

[darren1381]

Danny Chan truly encore.... HK great singers mostly parai early ages... what a great duet...

[aerinya]

還好大家都有自知之明不會把周董和歌神拿來比 會很難看啦..

[magician226]

很少聽學友唱小調，另有一番味道啊~

[zazamica]

學友的偏偏喜歡你 是激情版 過癮

DANNY 的偏偏喜歡你 淡的如生活 卻不可或缺的必須 

[taochunglee]

小哥的廣東歌也唱得不錯欸

[yiaphwee]

学友声音在里面不够出!!声音明显较薄.........没味道­!!

[parkbenchguy]

@yiaphwee 你如果去听张学友唱张惠妹的《听海》你就会觉得他的声音怎么这么­细。歌手也是人，也有擅长不擅长的歌曲，也有对歌曲的不同理解与­诠释。张学友变成了歌神，更重要的是他稳定的实力和敬业精神。

[paullee238]

@yiaphwee

費哥的key較高, 學友個key要提高就佢, 所以得出這效果.

[447685196]

费玉清的确很适合这首歌，张学友是我偶像，功力摆着呢，果断顶

[caiwoshishui]

张学友 穿的 衣服颜色 真让我无语。。。。

[Lynleeyeah]

@caiwoshishui 十年后你现在穿的衣服一样也会让十年后的人觉得无语

[polykoei]

學友版本比原版的好聽!(雙人合唱也很好聽)

[polykoei]

學友版本比原版的好聽!

[JAPANSHOP1]

好經典哦!!

[warilban]

if you guys like this, you should listen to the original by danny

[215196]

我不喜歡周杰倫, 但我非常佩服他, 我會聽他的歌, 因為在之中能學到不少音樂知識

他很敢去作歌, 把R&B, 古典, 藍調 , RAP, cross over混合到現代的POP歌風格

這也是他當紅的其中一個原因吧

費玉清他那又實又厚的中氣震音, 周杰倫是比不上的

同樣你叫費玉清去唱RAP.....我想大家也能想像到會是怎樣­了

所以, 他們2個是不同的歌手吧, 不能作比較的

麻煩各位學懂去欣賞, 不是像隻狗在佔地盤一樣

[bear2836]

@215196

你說得真的很棒！！

蘋果與橘子無法相比

但都是超級美味的水果

[SChoPstiCKSC8]

@215196 I disagree even if jay chou does crossover. he cannot enunciate words in his songs. problem with now aday singers is that. nowadays singers like jay chou cannot not even sing on beat.

[danmingtai]

雖然說我聽不懂廣東話,但是音樂無國界,好聽的歌曲永遠能突破有­形的疆界,深入人們無形的內心.撥動你我的心弦颤動.

[bbislonely]

我聽到"為何我的心不去死"......

[mhlim2000]

@bbislonely

真的耶！ 哈哈

[ken1992215]

費玉清真係好能勁, 把聲好清....頂佢個肺,

當然張學友都好令聲.....太屈機了 潛水怕屈機

[tea550]

這應該是十幾年前 張學友來台宣傳"吻別"專輯上的節目

當時我只是個國中生 當年剛好看到這段節目

沒想到過了十幾年後竟有人把這個片段po上網 真是懷念阿

[spiritfired]

哇！当场就配第二音……赞！！！！

[lkfczzw]

说实话，唱歌粤语比较好听，说起话来还是普通话好。粤语平时说话­有点像鸭子



[britse7en]

@lkfczzw 你妈就像鸭子

[aw112001]

@lkfczzw 習慣問題而已。

不過你這樣說確實是令我有點兒不開心。因為你說的只是你的主觀感­覺, 而不是客觀事實。

我一樣可以說唱歌粵語好, 說起話來還是英文好。普通話太庸俗了有點像沒品味的人。

你會如何想???

[lkfczzw]

@aw112001 哈哈，对不起啊。我就是抒发一下自己的感觉~ 没别的意思~哈哈，别生气啊。粤语也挺好的~~

[paullee238]

@lkfczzw

咁即係咪說普通話就似雞呢?

[zhai1964]

好好聽!



[terry6374]

費玉清唱的第二句"為何我的心不會死"很有特色

[final1988]

费唱广东的比较没有那么好听...张就把这首歌的精髓唱出来了.­..

好像比原版更好听

[paullee238]

@final1988

原版唱者的演唱技巧, 係教唱歌的最佳反面教材.

[jimmyho8]

好好聽........呢d先係唱歌..

[jimmyho8]

好好聽........

[juliayunjie]

OMG，太经典了！当时的学友好年轻哦，小哥还是伸着脖子的造型­。呵呵

[22572008]

@juliayunjie

数灯泡。。。

[ftch86]

hm......希望有机会看到这组合同台表演

[wenjilu]

講國語的人讀廣州話時總是有一個通病就是他們不會"入聲". 例如: "情意已失去一切都失去" 會變成 "情意已沙去也切都沙去" 費玉清這方面做得很好

[sanijkt]

special 一下，哈哈

[iacceptmail]

好听，但仍有瑕疵， 张学友在2:13没把开头的词唱错的话会更好。

[tan1980729]

一曲入魂!

[CelestialEmpire1]

张学友的第一段中的高音比较滑，就是“心一片空虚”的 心 没有直接上去，第二段好了。

[wht527]

看到這個多先前大家的評論，深感為什麼連聽個歌都要分誰比較優越­?香港人，大陸人，台灣人，還不都是人?跟這個歌手唱的好壞有啥­關係?如果總是看到成就卓越的人就想把他歸為自己的族類，這跟韓­國人有啥差別?我真的很看不起那種自以為優越的人，越是常強調這­種事情，其實就是自己越沒自信的表現~~

而且說真的，自己到底是哪裡人這還要看從哪個觀點出發，就像張學­友，他籍貫其實是天津人，費玉清，他雖然是台灣人，但他父母也都­是大陸其他省份的，所以，討論這種東西真得很沒意義，希望從此不­要看到這種沒營養的討論主題!!

[bear2836]

@wht527

說得好!!!

[xieying2588]

@wht527  Support!

[thenightsky7]

這，告訴周杰倫 誰才是真正的歌神

[aerinya]

@thenightsky7 他自己早就知道了所以來個全方面發展  大家不也是稱他為周董嗎?

[kklee314]

@thenightsky7 又一條懵撚，係都要比較。

我是喜歡張學友，也同時喜歡周杰倫。兩者音樂特色及歌唱發揮都不­同，怎能比較呢？

係都要踩兩腳周杰倫先安落，唉，可悲。

[woRstbB]

千里之外踢掉周杰伦吧，他没够班~

[kklee314]

@woRstbB 周杰倫沒夠班誰夠班？

知道周杰倫創作過多少好的音樂嗎？

千里之外是周杰倫作的，沒有周杰倫就沒有千里之外，怎能踢掉？

傻兮兮的，周杰倫倒是可以選另一個人代替費哥合唱。

正懵撚，冇撚病呀你？學識欣賞音樂先黎話人啦咁多野講！

[LouisLeeKH]

@kklee314 你條冚家剷就正懵撚, 識作曲同識唱歌係兩回事, 唱歌周杰倫就一定唔撚夠班!!!!!

[kklee314]

@LouisLeeKH 唉，都唔明有乜好比較。大家歌路都唔同！你聽多D 唔同風格既歌先好講野啦！

我只不過想表達一下「千里之外踢走周杰倫吧」之等言論是何等無知­！倘若閣下係都要死牛一便頸盲目追踩，

邊個係懵撚大家有目共睹。

[ycc213]

感覺小哥唱得有點像陳百強

但他唱得真的很好聽

[dllyr123]

见识了！

[tamkwai77]

費玉清 sang excellent, i can't tell he is not native cantonese speaker from that song...

[dtowai]

真希望他們再有合作機會

[moc143]

嘩...好好聽!

[ZephDweri]

I think or the way I see, there is more famous cantonese people than mandarin people, andylau,brucelee,chow yun fat,jackie cheung,leslie cheung, leon lai, aaron kwok,jackie chan, jet li AND MORE, all of them are cantonese so fuck off you mandarin suckers! haha

[12116657]

@ZephDweri a u dumb? jet li was mandarin. shame on u . kiddo go back sleep .

[historyrockz]

i think both Cantonese and Mandarin are beautiful languages. why can't we jsut learn to accept different languages and dialects. stop being such an ethnocentric !

[jblows1]

this is so wrong...

[tsuntinlone]

唔知點解台灣人講廣州話準過大陸人好多...雖然都係有口音..­.但係大陸北方人講嘅廣州話時常令人完全唔知佢講緊乜...

[jonastkl]

@tsuntinlone

[sweeper1977]

@tsuntinlone

唔知廣州都係大陸啦！LOL

[tsuntinlone]

@sweeper1977 廣州話=粵語/廣東話嘅標準名稱 LOL

[ading526]

no offence, this version sounds better than the original one, FOR ME

[ym0929kim]

It's is because those stupid non-Cantonese speaking people never will be able to speak Cantonese, that is why Mandarin was chosen as national language so you non-Cantonese speaking idiots!

[vivbri]

A bit weird for two gentlemen singing a love song to each other! Both are good singers though.

[brushington9999]

据说民国时定国语的时候粤语以一票输给北京话，其实历史还是挺偶­然的，虽然不是广东人，但是我支持文化的多样性，因为广东话是最­古老的中国话，秦皇汉武唐宗宋祖都那么说啊～～

[myth206]

@brushington9999 方言也有它自身的魅力不错，不过请不要歪曲。

粤语输了是因为北方方言适用范围最大，而两广做为革命发祥地自然­很多人在政府中。

广东话无非是古汗音留存比较多而已，客家话也不少。秦皇说的可不­是古中原话，他是陕西的；唐宗也不是，本来就是鲜卑血统，何况之­前已有五胡乱华；

[klsuperman]

@myth206

你所說的五胡亂華時期其實正是中原語南遷的高峰期，換句話說現時­的廣東話真正的來源是中原黃河流域。是華夏人真正的本語，而南遷­避禍的過江諸人也分成數支，較偏東南的就是現時的客家和閩南語系­，較偏南和西南的就是現在的廣州話系。而廣州話受北方胡人語系的­「污染」最少，所以才可以稱為中華語系的「活化石」。

[myth206]

@klsuperman 广东话是汉以后中原音和古越族音的混合。

不过就算是原装的，也不是决定共同语的决定因素，而是使用范围和­人口。

[klsuperman]

@myth206

「使用範圍和人口」，全中國最多人口的省份是四川省，那麼全中國­人都應該改說四川話好嗎

[klsuperman]

@myth206

現在的所謂「普通話」來源自東北苦寒之地，此地古時稱為塞外，用­來流放罪犯還可以，你信中國人的語言會源於此種地方嗎？而且這種­語言歷史不過幾百年不到，現在你所說的函蓋範圍大只是因為清朝時­候的滿人用行政手段將自己家鄉的語言強加於漢人，你自己是漢人的­話是不是應該支持語言「撥亂反正」呢

[cscwty]

我是香港人也覺得小哥粵語唱得好，不輸給廣東人

[klsuperman]

母語是國語的人說廣東話通常會犯一個小毛病，就是過份用力去強調­廣東話的音節，以為這樣就會更神似，其實廣東人聽起來反而會有點­怪，費玉清在這方面做得很好，不會過份用力去強調粵語音節，聽起­來自然又舒服，而且發音也相當標準，值得一讚。

[d1216210]

不知道其他人有沒有感覺到,兩人同是巨蟹座,彼此有點惺惺相惜.­

[bean06hk]

嘩 廣東話很準喔！

[iLov3YuRi]

臺語更難聽.

[ym0929kim]

@otterboxiphone

You ignorant! If you don't know other foreign languages, shut your fucking mouth!

[gongshiya]

特別給你唱，，更難聽！！

每种語言都有不同的特色，看你怎麽去聽和看..

[gongshiya]

特別是你唱，更難聽。。

每种語言都有不同的特色，看你怎麽去聽或看和態度....

看你一定是嬉笑去欣賞的，你不佩欣賞音樂。

幫我問候一下你媽媽和幫我問問她，爲什麽生下你這樣一個人？

[otterboxiphone]

Whatever you said cannot change this fact. Cantonese sucks. This languages needs to go extinct.

[021311]

From linguistic aspect Cantonese is better than Mandarin because Cantonese and other Chinese dialects are closer to the original Chinese Language.

[truckee1971]

It's your loss if you don't want to speak or learn Cantonese, it's a mutual feeling, don't think too highly of your Mandarin language, IT SUCKS BIG TIME.

[alexanderleewang]

@otterboxiphone

Stinky language? I didn't mind the fact that you don't care for Cantonese but you're a shame calling Cantonese a stinky language.

[021311]

@otterboxiphone Do you know why they chose Mandarin as official even the founder of New China was Cantonese? Northern people are too damn stupid to learn Cantonese, I was born and raise in HK, but I could still speak Mandarin correctly.

[dragunov23]

@otterboxiphone how sad that languages can be targeted by jackoffs such as yourself...

[percysong]

我们真幸运，生活在张学友与费玉清的年代

[linlinpiggy]

太经典了！！！

[wanchaksum]

第一段學友唱得好好聽

[gotoandlearn]

很美的歌! 感謝提供!

[wanchaksum]

唔知幾時再可以同台合唱呢?

[zZlovinZz]

嘩 (0.0) good

[K8879576]

兩個不同時代的歌神合唱!!!!

可惜影片音質問題，要不然更好@@

[anyway606]

哇！amazing ! 学友那时候应该很年轻吧！不错！

[lutony123]

really very great match up!!!!awesome performance overall but......somehow i feel something strange...at the end....a little bit "gay "feeling(very little bit only...)

[BrokenWai]

awesome

[josie288]

Jacky is the best!!!!!

[SinoUme]

This is awesome! Both of them are awesome.

This is my first time hearing 费玉清 singing in cantonese. Very excellent. And, 張學友 is just perfection!

[sourirestee]

好令人懷念的年代,這應該是在龍兄虎弟的節目上吧? 聽到這首歌又讓我想起總是憂鬱卻迷人的原唱者陳百強. Miss you much Danny...

[exoyy]

傳世的經典畫面與聲音!

[exoyy]

太好聽了!!!!

[dontgiveashitt]

一個"嘩" 字, 好好聽

[syu031]

Perfection + perfection!!

[tafetasmania]

amazing

[vc1988229]

還有機會看到這經典的無敵組合嗎?

fantastic!!

亞洲兩大高手~~

[DragMeToHellLuc]

@vc1988229 Danny made it look so easy, he had a great gift. I love and miss you.

[Yangace]

0:36-1:03 was so good

[jacky037]

和音好好啊

[h825benny]

所以費玉清唸錯?

[noingticket]

張學友好型@@

[h825benny]

"會"是唸wi嗎?

[cmajorful]

wui,

[dreamtown88]

費大哥的清晰聲音

加上 學友的沉厚的聲音

超強

[sakurababa]

唱的超棒...不过最后有点点...

[ajoe999]

真好聽他們兩人聲音

不過後面兩人唱到相望..."為何我偏偏喜歡你" ... 是蠻尷尬滴

[AJforeverDG]

唱的太好了~

[NVIH]

哈！費玉清竟能唱廣東歌，咬字還可以哩！

很好笑。好玩！

[edwinicq]

holy cow, Fei's annunciation when singing cantonese is perfect, but still has Mandarin accent when he speaks Cantonese

[lkatherineto]

Was this from 1993?

[brushington9999]

蛮夸张的，一个台湾人跟香港人说，我们唱一首广东歌吧~~

[bird7281]

有什麼好誇張的,就像香港人也可以跟台灣人說,我們來唱首閩南語­歌吧.

[snakelau]

@bird7281 愛拼才會贏 很多香港歌手都會la

[chiaweiwoo1]

马来西亚也有马来人艺人唱甜蜜蜜

[brushington9999]

呵呵，马来人大多会讲粤语+国语+马来语+。。。

[chiaweiwoo1]

哈哈，会唱外语的真的很少，楼上的说的是他们会一些短短的句子，­吃饭，睡觉，还有一些粗口酱咯

[klsuperman]

沒什麼好誇張，小朋友你知道在那個年代在華人社會學粵語是一種時­尚嗎？就正如現在學日文一樣

[myth206]

@klsuperman 您的华人社会还真大，您是否了解您所在地区之外有多少比例华人学­日语？

[klsuperman]

@myth206

比例上一定是中國大陸最少囉！呵呵！

[stevengcake]

amazing performance though not synchronized

[TERUBOTSU]

Yeah, heard Fei sang 上海滩once and totally amazed by it! Almost as good as Francis Yip!

[clarayam]

超正組合！百聽不厭！

[nizhenbang]

Ich bin sprachlos!

Super!!!

[wonglisa]

wow, 费玉清 is good in cantonese too. He is so good.

[Arielwithu]

赞啊

[monsttar]

经典！！

[Kalsue]

yes god vs god lol amazing

[zxxx19]

兩個人都唱得很好 讓我不禁跟著唱 不因該拿他們兩個做比較 各有千秋

[animenagai]

Me too! Two gods of Chinese music sharing the stage harmoniously is a beautiful thing.

[Hardbeez]

God vs God!

[papaya6000]

超級組合，真可謂余音繚繞間，經典永流傳

[kimbapbap]

好棒的組合~~