The Persistence of Loss

[stiles05s]

Yeah, why did you fuck up the song...?

[Fox5593]

Why'd you fuck up the song?

[funkypost]

That's why we will nver win the "War Against Terror", we are too sensitive to the human cause....and the radical muslim lives only to VAPORIZE us!!

[Hockeyruler]

I don't get why you would title the video a different name from the song if its a music video. It would make sense if its just a video. But a music video for a song? Use the songs name so we know what we're watching. Besides The Persistence of Loss is another song on the exact same album. Don't tell me you just happened to think of that exact name and it "totally fits" your video. Its a ripoff of another song name. Either be original with naming, or be functional. None of this confusing shit.

[imjoeimjoe]

I am assuming the audio being overlapped was a mistake, but an awesome one, for some reason it works and sounds freaking great, shit you should load this up onto NIN.REMIX.com, LOL!

[75reznor]

@twiggy81r you're welcome .

Cant stand this ridiculous bitchslapping about nothing .

[hazillow]

if i wanted to listen to "leaving hope," i would have searched for that, you dumb fuck.

[75reznor]

Can't you people stop whining about the title of the song and start seeing it for what it is ?

A very beautiful and sad piece of music with a [too much ]fitting video.

Excellent piece of work , war is hell .

[twiggy81r]

Thank you, @75reznor

[dilandinho76]

still is the best album nin ever made. to bad ita allmost impossible to purchase anywhere

[Atak0fth3Umpalumpas]

This is Leaving hope, not persistence of loss.

[kick2320]

yeah dude i know what a retard haha

[666Pestilince666]

fuckin awsome, I loved all the blood and gore, I wish I was in Iraq right now serial murdering people for polital gain and bullshit (sarcasm)

[Hackmoune]

Oh man, those pics are so sad i almost cry

[amarchingpig]

Everyone is so stupid they don't understand the principal of the matter.....I guess ignorance is bliss.

[TheJokerIsDead]

it's "leaving hope" on NIN Halo 17

[japannabe]

I don't think this song is the Persistence of Loss.

[japannabe]

Woops, dumbass comment.

[locutus12]

it is but something gone wrong with the audio. its double up, 1 track out of sync with the other. not sure if that was intended but its a mess. The video however is a masterpiece of tragedy.

[locutus12]

ah, no actually i just checked my tack listing, this indeed isn't the persistence of loss, its leaving hope. but again, its a doubled up mess im afraid, its a shame as it would work very well for this video if not for that.

[lovemychaingun]

this reminds me... I need to go fill up on gasoline

[gerbosan]

Appropiate vision and interpratation of the video and music. Excellent work.

[31337larry]

Persistence of Leaving Hope?

Leaving Persistence?

[DillonDBD]

Still Album

[Fpockets]

great work man!!! Sad but beautiful at the same time.

[twiggy81r]

Again.

I KNOW the song is "Leaving Hope". I used the title "The Persistence of Loss" because the images used in the video are about loss, death and war. It made sense to use a title to explain the photos, hence using "The Persistence of Loss".

I could have used "Leaving Hope" as a title, but it wasn't as meaningful as "Persistence" to me.

Deal with it and try to be creative.

[grietuke]

But where i can found The Persistence of Loss?? :( looks like this song r deleted,or something...

[Poopshooot99]

look for NIN complete discography torrents

[grietuke]

i have all discography... but there wasnt the persistence of loss... i dont knwo how to get it.try to ofund in all torrent sites,in free mp3, but looks like this song is deleted from history:)) maybe u have,and can send me?

[DogbitE6661]

@twiggy81r Nice peice of work man, and I agree. The title you gave the VIDEO is a perfect fit and it is really touching, like amazingly deep, so much so im having trouble finding justifiable words. Excellent work.

[79898325]

I know other people below me have said the same thing, but one more reminder - this is Leaving Hope.

[BuddhaPunch09]

and they are all to NIN songs.

[BuddhaPunch09]

Okay im a huge NIN fan but what hell is the deal with all these stupid depessing vids of pictures of ppl dieing and death. Seriously i counted out like 15 of these dumb vids.

[31337larry]

It's what people want to do with their sad songs

leave it to them, don't worry yourself and enjoy the music my friend.

[FatGermanBastard]

LOL...that's exactly what I just thought.

[StephinRazin]

damn facism. If we were a just ppl we would hang bush and his administration officials.

[hatfisc]

Morons. Obama has injected more power into the government in six months than W did in his whole 8 years. If you are a politcal degenerate, keep your attempt at your parents ideological rants to a nil. Fuckwads like you and your ilk have us still looking backward when our problems are ahead of us.

[WhiteSSP]

You realize this is exactly what a facist society would have done, right?

[iscleyva]

THIS IS LEAVING HOPE, change the name

[dtc5793]

this is leaving hope, not persistence of loss

[doomday323]

wow surprise surprise, an anti war piece and here you are fighting again,

And everyone wonders why there is so much hate and war and violence when assholes like this are fighting over something as stupid as a fucking video, listen to the music, watch the video, it makes sense in the end

NIN FTW

[jjbmcalitt]

dumb ass!

[amarchingpig]

How about you shut the fuck up, society lacks common sense, like you have just displayed, just another stain on an already ruined world. Not only is it entitled wrong, it is doble looped and sounds like complete shit. I have the utter right to express how I feel about moronic bastards like you and twiggy, the freedom of the internet is a beautiful thing, so if I want to point out someones short comings in an explicit way, I FUCKING WILL YOU RAT ASS PIECE OF SHIT. I will equalize you

[Excovon]

I do agree with your right to give your own opinion, especially since that's what the comments are. The song is titled wrong, the quality's somewhat poor, I understand. But you still don't have to be so rude and demanding about it. Personally, I don't care for this video either, but it was a good effort.

Be a little nicer about your opinions next time, for the sake of people who don't care to read about you swearing your ass off.

[amarchingpig]

Thank you for wasting my time, the one thing that no one can ever get back. Why don't you come up with an original title at least? Instead of ganking the title to another song. Why can't anyone ever use common sense?

[twiggy81r]

FYI:

You wasted your own time by posting a response to this video.

[amarchingpig]

Nope, if I felt it would have been a waste of time I wouldn't have. Idiots like yourself need to be adressed and treated as such, I didn't waste my time equalizing you. Bitch

[westforestdesigns]

To me people are not created evil but the devil attacks people there whole life until their situations lead them to choose the wrong path and the rest are to weak to stand up for what is right. What have we become, where is the love for your brothers and sister, we have all become numb and we do not stand together to fight for what is right. We all bleed red and we all feel the pain of loss. We kill those who kill to teach it is wrong to kill

[ganesha4444]

the devil you believe in is in reality the true nature of mankind. Sorry brother, but we are all your "devil."

[dtc5793]

LEAVING HOPE, MATE!!!!

[TSchnell82]

wierd echo. bit too depressing aswell.

[leegsy]

This song is actually called Leaving Hope.

[twiggy81r]

You're a genius.

It was done intentionally. The title of the video is "The Persistence of Loss" and I used the song "Leaving Hope" for the music for the video.

[leegsy]

I don't think so. I think you got your titles mixed up. It's not a big deal. You are forgiven.

[twiggy81r]

Again.

There are two references to this video. The title is a NIN song and the music is a NIN song. I chose, from a creative point of view, to call the video "The Persistence of Loss" and to use the music from "Leaving Hope".

[KN1V35X]

Dude you mixed up the titles.

[dlwhinery]

This song is "Leaving Hope". Not "The Persistence of Loss" dude....you must've made a mistake. no big deal.

[ZombieSlaver]

Haha, wow, all these stupid fuckers keep pointing out that this is Leaving Hope, like you didn't already know that. It makes me laugh.

[hbeezey]

um

did you put the song in twice or something? because its echoing -_-

[aonewomancrowd]

My heart shudders.

[idiotbrothers]

I wish I could say the same..But I gave my heart away a long time ago, and it got torn to pieces.

[byrontzapu]

Doesn't matter how is it called : leaving hope or other.I can say only OH MY GOD...The world we live in it...OH MY GOD...I have tears in my eyes....Oh my god.................

[libbern]

I really liked it. Not only does it have NIN in it, but it shows a picture of the true world that many people tends to not know about. Not wierd that someone blow themselves up when a country invade your country and ruins your life. Good thing that you also showed some american soldiers/soldier suffering... Again, good music shoice. Peace

[libbern]

Dont misunderstand suffering as in "suffering because he deserved it". Americans is also suffering a lot under the idiotic rule of Bush and co, not as much as the Arabs though.

[Aranman16]

So tragic...I had to cry a bit at 4:00.

Makes me ashamed to say I live in America.

[nothingnow948]

this is called Leaving Hope not Persistance of Loss btw if you didnt know.