chopin op.10-12 Revolutionary 4th month ｼｮパン 革命のエチュード 2

[mikeflanny22]

I think you guys are all just jealous of how amazing he is at just 4 months lol

[lllllllllllllll88]

GREAT! Look at that finger action! I'm also working on this. I hope I can get it as well as you. My chords don't sound like I'm putting the keys down together and I hate it. Yours sounds like one note. How the heck do you do that anyway? Ugh!

[FleshMob]

It doesn't matter how much he played piano, 4 months, 1 year, I mean... This is really good.

If guy loves Chopin he should play Chopin, why would he spend 2-3 years working on some easier stuff that he don't like, just because "you can't play Chopin after 1 year".

Time flies so fast!

I started playing guitar when I was 19, and I didn't want to go through all that, "traditional" sheet, I just wanted to play.

Well done, really! When you start playing something at 19, you MUST be loving it!

[YamashitaShoon]

とても素敵な演奏でした。

この曲だけ弾きたい、というあなたの気持ちに憧れちゃいます。

[cmariamagda]

Wonderful!You are very talented!

[Antonio231095]

I'm italian. Non mi interessa se tu, da quanto ho capito con il traduttore, suoni da poco tempo, anche se non c'era tecnica, trovo che dopo 4 mesi sia già un passo avanti

[mario54671]

Hang on, dude. You can't just start playing Chopin after not even a year of piano. it is IMPOSSIBLE for anybody, even a prodigy to learn Chopin at just 1 year of piano. It's not just the technique, because even his preludes and mazurkas which are VERY easy technically take at least a year of piano to learn. You've gotta work your way to it, and it's long, especially to get to Chopin etudes, but you just cannot jump to such an advanced piece like that, just like a baby can't just start walking.

[mario54671]

And such a teacher who would actually let you learn such a difficult piece after just 4 months of piano shows how ignorant he/she is. First you start with little baby versions of pieces with the chord letters written on there, then you read very easy sheet music, then you go to intermediate, and then you start playing Czerny Etudes, you play those for a while, and then after you complete all the books of the Czerny Etudes, you move on to Chopin Etudes, you don't just go from nothing to Chopin.

[go350z]

AND I don't think that you are eligible for saying that. Who do you think you are! You don't know me, my back story― how I have spent my life, and my feelings and EMOTIONS.

[go350z]

First, you should have read my introduction. "Since I was 19, I had been playing the piano by myself, just as my hobby before taking piano lessons." And you should remember that It takes just ten months enough for a baby to start to walk , let alone a year. Are you so sure that chopin played the Czerny Etude, which I personally think to be rubbish, before he played his Etudes?

[mario54671]

I'm sure he did, since that's piano exercises, you should be playing Etudes, it's a daily thing. And it doesn't matter how long it takes for a baby to walk, the point is, they don't just walk out of nowhere, there's crawling, and then baby steps. You can't just start some random piano piece out of nowhere. Your emotions don't matter, since if you don't have technique, you can't express them on piano, to express your feelings and emotions, you need technique. It comes from technique.

[go350z]

You are like a bird which cannot fly in the sky, because you are chained by the traditional and common assumption. You should have studyed history of Czerny and Chopin. You still don't understand the word "challenge" and "creative". The man like you is just right for playing vido game rather than playing Chopin. NEVER FLY IN THE SKY!

[VanargrandsEnd]

how many months did you say you were playing this at? look mate im sorry ive gotten to this level of chopin playing after 2 years of playing piano with a broken wrist to i might add but there is no way your left arm has the built up durability that is needed for this after 4 months now unless you mean you were playing for a few years on your own then you started getting lesssons which is quiet possible to get o this stage in such a short time you chould clarify this in the info section better

[lllllllllllllll88]

@go350z - Great reply for critics. They make me sick! Like they know everything, and they don't know crap. Most don't even have a video, and can't even read music. Those with NO talent always criticize those who do. I saw that on someone's channel and it's so true. You are very talented, and I hope I can play this half as well as you do.  Once I'm done, I'll post it... maybe...lol

Great playing!

[go350z]

"The modern view that perception is not atomistic but holistic, that it is an active and creative process that involves more than just the information provided by the retina was first emphasized in the early 20th century by the German psychologists Max Wertheimer, Kurt Koffka, and Wolfgang Köhle, who founded the school of Gestalt psychology."

I hope you can understand this.

[COCOONFABULA]

I think it was by the Russians but anyway I agree with, Chopin's have to be played with feelings

[COCOONFABULA]

Doesn't matter ^^ You're polish ?

[COCOONFABULA]

I want to be polish ! XD

[COCOONFABULA]

Well Chopin was french too :)

[ArizonaPolarBear]

sure, sure

this is why he never even visited his father's relatives while being in Paris

[COCOONFABULA]

? ....Were you replying to me ? =S

[ArizonaPolarBear]

pretty much, yep :)

[COCOONFABULA]

Refresh my memory please ^^ What did I say ?

[ArizonaPolarBear]

hehe, there is like 16 posts in here, dont get so lazy, ;-)

but i was just having fun, enjoy the music

[COCOONFABULA]

Oh okay I checked out what I said, so maybe he did he loved his father and I'm sure that he knew where his relatives were I surely visited them, anyway who knows! Anyway Chopin considered himself more as a Polish than a French

[informatykatw]

This stuff is easy to lern without instructor.. In my opinion only hard thing is the speed...

[lst9162]

you learned this without an instructor? wow, that's impressive!!! keep it up :D