if you want to get credit for your dance moves, then FILE A LAWSUIT. it doesnt matter whether you'll get beaten by the company, just so long as you put forth that you made an EFFORT to get credit for what is yours. by saying "there's no use" "since i'm not a big name" you're basically saying 'my dance moves are free for you to take since i'm not gonna do anything' stop complaining and do something if you're gonna whine about it.
As an aspiring choreographer, I would be so sad if this happened to me. All the hard work was just stolen! I hope this sly SM choreographer feels really bad about this...and poor SHINee are getting the blame now :/
i'm not trying to be rude but fans can be so stupid sometimes. you guys need to gtfo off no one cares about some fakeass kpop group we're here to watch a dope performance
unlike these douchebags, i understand you guys! if my favorite kpop group (shinee) ripped off a dance choreography i came up with without me knowing, i would stop being their fan asap and be pissed as hell, even if it wasn't their fault. (like "wth is that taemin... key... minho... jjong... and onew... doing the dance *i* came up with and didnt tell me?" talk about lack of appreciation!)
okay heres the thing..i do admit that ur dance it awesome but i dont think u shud be so dramatic about this..okay, so even if they did that dance during a performance, it's just for a dance battle. it's not like they claimed ur dance to be theirs...but seriously i love your moves..:)
@manat23ee its just a dance routine, dude. chill. yeah, they didnt say who was it that came up with the moves, but like i said, shinee didnt say anything like 'hey, we invented the dance move ourselves'. look at it this way, it means that the dance is just too awesome that even the choreographers at SMEnt wanted to do it for a show. ps i think you have a problem against kpop or something.
Ummm... gtfo if what your talking about has nothing to do with this performance. Take your garbage arguments somewhere else you're just spamming the page.
the "SHINee stealing your choreography" is a ridiculous claim in seeking attention.that performance was just a single performance.to believe a choreographer searched YouTube to find a dance thts not even the same song is a little preposterous. whats probable is tht one of your own dancers or someone who you've taught that part to was hired by, or even works for SM and used your dance for the very insignificant performance. it wasnt evenfor a single or a music video..really this is pathetic.
@thesongendshere ahahaha, dont be stupid!!. sm's choreographer took pat cruz's choreography. Thats what happened. Don't try to act like thats not what happened. ahaha, What you said is more probable is actually 100 times less likely. It doesn't matter where the performance was or how insignificant it was. They still claimed it as their own when in fact it wasn't. They (sm) stole someone else's hard work. You make shinee's fans look ignorant.
You know kpop fangirls have taken over your posting when there's horrible grammar everywhere.
Anyways ... MAD PROPS for the awesome choreo. Keep 'em coming :) Don't worry, karma will most definitely come back and bite SME in the ass for all they've done so far.
Oh I think SM should be blamed, too, instead of poor SHINee, they would never steal from anyone else.
i would be pissed, too If my choreo was stolen from others and be claimed as theirs...but...oh well D:
Don't blame SHINee, poor SHINee, poor original choreographer. I just love the choreo and learnd it now XD
I think this ones is better.But it's anyway an awesome choreography, even when SHINee danced it!! Good job on this, Pat~ But I'm sorry for Pat and SHINee that it turned out like that >_<
what the fuck! i would be so freaken piss if i was in that guy's situation...man the person in charge of sm's choreography should get the hell out of there and be fired...man sucks for SHINEE they probably didn't even know that their dumbass choreographer stole someone's hard work..retard with no shame when he/she took his work and taught the choreo. to shinee
@johnchoivideos: you're right they should apologize...and the difference between what SME did with Pat and what YG did with Shaun, Lyle and Aimee is YG actually "hired" them and brought them onboard to choreograph. SME just stole Pat's choreo. SHINee is not the one's at fault here but its also their responsibility to check and double-check where their choreography comes from. For Pete's sake...
Disappointed!I think dance choreographies should be protected now. And next time, SME, be classy, okay? Do some research and coordinate the TV stations to put the credits on our TV or computer screens. :|
I agree to shinee's fans here. Even though I am a shinee fan I stand by what's right. Sure Shinee copied their dance BUT it is not them who choreographed the dance that they used for Lady Gaga's song. It was their choreographer. SHINee MIGHT not know that their choreographer just copied the dance steps from this group that's why they still used it in their performance. The one you should talk/blame it all to is their choreographer and not SHINee. :)
Just approach or sue whoever who choreograph the dance for SHINee.
I don't care if I'm just being bias or whatever shit. As a Shawol, I don't appreciate it when my boys are called "talented dancers"-apparently in a sarcastic way.
SHINee is more than just DANCERS.
Thanks god that the performance that cause all these discussion is merely a 1 min special stage.
LOOK. SM. The one who "owns" SHINee is the one in the wrong okay. so kpop fans stop getting butthurt over this. sure it's disappointing to know that one of your idols (and mine too) copied choreography's but someone has to own up. i'm ashamed of those kpop fans who are not sensible enough to know that someone has to take responsibility. and that someone is shinee's choreographer okay.
As much as I find it rude that he's spoken negatively about SHINee through one video, you have to understand the guy. His own choreography was stolen, I do understand his anger. You can't blame Pat Cruz at all.
Also, SME sucks ass. It seems like they've been getting lazy lately... I don't blame SHINee, they were only given the choreography to learn to, they did. It's not SHINee's fault at all.
It's funny how this video got +1000 views after copying thingy XD
To SHINee fans - a lot of you are getting upset at Pat Cruz for saying "talented" in quotation-marks. It's obvious he doesn't care about Kpop and SHINee at all, so he doesn't know anything about it. Truth be told... Many people now will know SHINee through Lady Gada cover, and... you gotta agree on that - they weren't doing well in this performance, hence why those quotation-marks.
But it's sad that he chose to judge the band only after seeing one video, that was shallow.
SHINee is not to blame. how can you be blamed for something you didn't know about? if they knew and it's gonna be announced officially, feel free to correct me.
i really feel bad that they're choreographer copied the dance, but if they band didn't know about, you just cannot blame them.
i just knew there would be comments about SHINee XDXD
I'm am a SHINee fan myself.
the thing is... just because they danced this particular dance doesn't mean they're not talented. for example... stand in front of a mirror, Pat, chose some random choreography and dance right then and there.... does it mean you're not talented just because you danced somebody's else dance? NO.
Instead of - stop this circus, people. Where the hell is SHINee's blame, when they just do what choreographer showed them? - All of you said orginal is better... so try to dance like that and sing, then we'll talk.
shinee has nothing to do with the choreography. they just dance what their choreographer teach them. if there is anyone to be blamed, its the choreographer.
i agree that the original is better but isnt it a bit harsh to call the boys (shinee) faggots?
im not a big fan of them but i dont go around saying bad words or bad things about them..
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It looks wack with Rihanna's Disturbia. I think SHINee along with Lady Gaga song gave it some style. You should be thankful at least your choreography is getting somewhere and a big audience is watching it other than just on another video on YouTube.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Oh yeah a big audience, because everyone all over the world knows who shinee is, LOL. Please.
/sarcasm.
Kpop is just a sub-par version of the American music industry minus the fame and album sales and of course earnings, that's why pathetic groups like shinee are singing Lady gaga's songs and not the other way around.
@Learner012 U SHOULDNT BE TALKING ABOUT THAT KPOP HAS MERGE INTO MANY DIFFERENT AREAS AND CONCEPT WITH A LITTLE BIT OF WESTERN MIX BUT TOTALLY "NOT" ENTITLE TO SO CALLED AMERICAN MUSIC ....WHAT IS SO GOOD BOUT AMERICAN MUSIC? RAP, CURSING , SEX, DRUGS, WHAT ELSE IS THERE TO SAY ? AT LEAST KPOP ARTISTS ARENT LIKE THAT !!!!! EVEN THE BACKSTREET BOYS COMPLEMENTED DBSK AND BIG BANG ....WHAT DO U KNOW OF KPOP ....JUST STFU!!!!!!!
@KimLinLa you really think backstreet would not be commenting on kpop artist when backstreet is in korea? come on all american artist are always asked the same question about which kpop artist you like. simple google search and bam they got a name of a artist to claim they like when i bet they dont give kpop the time of day.
plus american music is not all about what you claimed it is.
Lol exactly, no one gives a fuck about Kpop unless they are promoting there. You think people like Beyonce, Rihanna, Lady gaga or the backstreet boys really care about some tiny joke of an industry? lol
Kpop is ALL self-created hype. None of their solo acts or groups sell anything worth talking about, America's and Japan's industry are the biggest and most respected, those TWO ALONE.
Just for you to know, SHINee does have a big audience! They have fame and fans in Asia and all the around the world, aswell as other korean boybands. Actually DBSK, a band from Korea has guiness record for having the largest fanbase in the word.
Asia obviously play songs from Asia and America does the same. The fact that they sang that one time Lady GaGa probably wasn't something they decided, as well as the choreo. And that was the first time they covered something from America.
First off LOL @ all the crying fans, Typical pathetic kpop fans.
Second moron DBSK barely sells 1mil. or 2mil. albums - their fanclub WEBSITE has more members than Lady gaga's yet who is selling more and has more fame in EVERY industry? lol stop spewing that shit like it means something because it doesn't. And she just came out a year or two ago, LOL.
Get a life you obsessive little cheap whore, they will NEVER fuck you. close your legs open your mind. SLUT.
@Learner012 lmao you are on a roll with your insults. it is good you are giving these kpop fans the truth. i will admit i like kpop but i surely knows kpop is far from original. i also know that kpop is not well known as people try to make it. most people in most countries of this world dont know kpop exist.
just because you got like 100 people in one country other than korea who knows what kpop is dont mean it is well known.
kpop would never be well known because kpop gets alot of it's
influence from american music. that is a fact and everyone knows that is the truth.
so most peolpe dont want to listen to something they already heard in english and listen to it again in korean.
i will admit my favorite kpop artist is se7en. the reason is as soon as i heard him sing one last cry i knew he is like one of the few with actual talent.
people who enjoy kpop must learn and face the truth that kpop would never never be anything to most people of the world.
@Learner012 I wasn't being rude, so why did you have to start with the cheap insults?
You should be the one getting a life, I see you a little bit to (bad)informed of kpop for just a "hater".
I never said DBSK was better known than Lady Gaga, so idk why are you saying those stuffs. i was just saying that the kpop industry does reach a lot of countries (man i'm from Chile and I know lot of people that love kpop over here) and that there are some important bands over there that have lots of fans
Blah blah blah, every group, singer and model has a fan somewhere in the world honey. LOL
Doesn't mean that industry is REACHING anywhere, it means there are specific people in other countries that take notice in another industry.
REACHING other countries is what Shakira did career wise with her US debut. When DBSK reaches that level of fame (and even that isn't all that much to talk about) then you say they 'reached' anything. They don't even sell more than Utada Hikaru, lol.
Btw the only importance any Kpop group or singers in Korea have is in THEIR country you moron. LOL
Tell me ONE kpop group or solo act that has the star power that Beyonce, Lady gaga or rihanna has when they leave their homeland? They ALL get first class world star treatment no matter what country or continent they're on, that is IMPORTANT. LOL
DBSK wouldn't be noticed here by anything but asian americans and a few token blacks and whites, lol.
I was talking about fame in their homecountry you moron :) At first you said that they had no fame, fanbase nor earnings and I said that they do have them but I didn't said it was all over the globe like American Divas. It's actually pretty obvious that it's easier for the american industry to get into others countries because american people thinks of themselfs as the most important population in the world and everyone seems to play along with it :)
Actually I never said they had NO fans, fame or earnings. I live in Asia and am well aware of DBSG and their fanbase, from their fan base killing innocent girls with their harassment to DBSG taking SME to court hun. You aren't talking to new blood here, LOL.
Again name one Kpop star or group that has the amount of fame Lady gaga has gained within a year and a half, lol.
Name one that can go to any continent, in any country and sell millions of albums. Because Kpop singers and groups barely ever even crack 100k - that's why you count those that DO on ONE hand. LOL
It's not a matter of 'most important' American artist make more money, have international fame, and sell millions. That's a fact not a thought, lol.
And if a south korean band can get thousands of fans in South America despise the distance and all the ethnical differences then it IS called reaching darling. If you are limited enough to think that the only way of reaching another culture is being played 24/7 in the forgein radios then you really have some issues (:
Thousands of fans? lol hun indie bands in America have thousands of fans everywhere.
International pop icons and stars have millions of fans in EACH and EVERY country.
Again name on Asian group or singer who could come to the US and get the same global icon treatment that someone like Beyonce, Rihanna or Lady gaga could get.
Name one Asian group or singer with diamond album status. And name one group or solo singer that consistently cracks the 1MIL. mark.
Honestly I can't say one name because if I did I would be totally lying. But then again, I accepted in my first post that Asian pop stars are huge only in Asia and therefore I didin't compare them with the American ones.
On the other hand you seem to be doing that a lot, probably because you know that this is the only thing you could posibbly be right about (:
No you didn't honey, you read my post clearly regarding American and Korean pop stars. Got offended like a typical little fan girl BITCH and brought up DBSK hoping I wouldn't know who they were and got put in your pathetic little place, lol.
Stop twisting not only my words but your own, you just seem pretty dense. LOL
And lol @ more assumptions. Yeah and I'm sure the only thing you have in your moronic fangirl mind is fucking the newest 'hawt' boy band you cheap whore.
Now that both of us had made of points clear and you have absolutely nothing else to say than those stupid insults then i shall leave.
This could had been some interesting interchange of opinions if you weren't such a jerk.
And lol @ you calling me a cheap whore and a moronic fangirl with a shallow mind.
I know it's not true so it just passes through me like nothing at all but it actually makes you look like a jerk with no more arguments to compite with (:
No more arguments? babe it takes two to argue, LOL. If you have an arguement that I haven't already taken a shit on then please do present it.
You're the one who started with the personal attacks moron. "probably because you know that this is the only thing you could posibbly be right about (:"
Looks personal to me, don't dish it out if you can't take it bitch. Now state some FACTS or FUCK OFF you idiot. LOL Damn I love being right =D
Whether you hate Shinee or whatever, I'd very much appreciate it if you refrain from insulting k-pop. You think we aren't well aware that the asian music industry is exactly that? The ASIAN music industry? I don't think yur a bitch nor do I think yur completely in the right. But I love k-pop. Deeply, so when you say stuff like that it really fricking hurts. Can we just call a truce?
PAT CRUZ!~ Yur choreo is frickin awesome. Keep yur head up, yur one talented dude =)
Refrain? hun sure thing, as soon as Youtube becomes a private site and screens each comment to make sure no one if getting their little feelings hurt, LOL.
Oh and yes the Korean music industry is just that, doesn't change the fact that the American music industry is ALSO JUST THAT, but American entertainers are clearing leading when it comes to fame, earnings and album sales. Fact over feelings bitch. lol Also there is no "asian music industry" they are all seperate, China, Japan, Korea, ect.
@Learner012 lol how long are you going to fight with these kpop fans? lol let them believe that their little kpop artist is so well known and that kpop is so well known.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Btw why would they be happy about someone taking credit for their work? and making a profit from it by being hired by SME to teach the homos in shinee THEIR choreo.?
That's pathteic, I would be insulted if I saw fags like shinee butcher my own choreo.
Learner012 They didn't credit them self. The choreographer's name hardly even gets mentioned or shown when there's a performance. Thankful they should be that their choreography is witnessed by a massive audience, their shouldn't be complaining since they are totally unknown choreographers. And profit?it was shown ones in an end of the year special that's the only time they have performed the song. It's a one time thing just to show something new and entertain not to promote it as their own.
for one, Shinee are not fags, they might not be your type of artists, but calling them fags is going a bit too far,
also if you knew anything you would know that the show where they did it was just a one-off end of year special programme where they covered a different song. so they werent trying to promote anything (eg album etc)
@Learner012 there is no need for people like you in the world. why dont you keep your hate to yourself, im sure you would never say the things you said if you were in person which is quite pathetic.
No need for people like me? lol what you mean someone who doesn't like a certain music industry and states the fact that Kpop is no where near Japan's or America's status in the overall music industry? LOL
Hun if you can't accept others opinions or views on the same topic I suggest you slit your throat and remove yourself from the gene pool you worthless piece of vile trash.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Seriously, lol. It seems like YGE is CONSTANTLY given warnings and lawsuits from Sony or somewhere else for stealing lyrics or music, and now SME is getting caught up in this shit too.
This group(?) OWNS those little SM faggots shinee. LOL
The SM choreographers are HUGE fans i think. but if they were truly crazy about dance they would have had more RESPECT ! I don't think that they deserve to be considered as choreographers or dance lovers. Ttss i'm mad !
ok,you oughta put a copyright on each of your new dance moves from now on.you know thats the legal way to go n yes its possible. stealing your choreography for a stage performance is not a crime, unless its like an official video or something,we all copy from some where.and k-pop doesnt do anything original.thers no point whining cos i dont think SMs going to hire you, just like YG takes help from Shaun. do your own thing and be happy. now that you are famous!
bahh, SM Ent suckkssss. they think "bad publicity" is "good publicity". they did it know fully well how eagle-eyed netizens from all around the world are (esp. in Korea). D;
this is bull, so everyone here jst says they're awesome dancers jst 'cause they feel sorry for them? i mean have you heard two sides of the arguement? ohks let's say it WAS copied, you srsly can't blame shinee, they probs din' noe. blame the choreographer or sme as they're the ones hu chose it! saying shinee isn't 'talented' is pretty bull too, i mean taemin got into sme for his dancing, i wonder why these ppls haven't become famous for their dancing if they're soo much better than shinee.
SHINee was just dancing like they were told. In their company unless people spontaneously tells them to have a dance battle everything is choreographed by the company. Don't have hard feeling toward them they are just chess pieces on their company's board
That's not fair at all that they took your choreography and didn't credit you for it. It's okay because you guys can dance 100 times better then SHINee ever could.
why didn't you guys give credit to the original choreographer -.- like really if it's not your work give credit and get their (original choreographer) names out there
No matter who actually did copy, it sucks that the original choreographer doesn't get recognized. Dance is the physical expression of music- like in the tumblr, the reasoning and meaning of movements become shattered.
As someone in the community, I understand the pride it feels to be the extension of a song through choreo and the artistic expression behind it. No matter what the skill of someone, someone's piece of work is special and precious to them
I don't think SHINee should be the one to blame. The person who "choreographed" their routine should be blamed for it. It's so sad that this had to happen =/
@STICKITtotheman its funny how you people don't blame the actual "famous singer/ group". becuase they are famous and you love them and actually you have to come blame the person who choreographed the dance. its like saying you worked so hard on something and another person came and took it without your permission and everyone WOWED you for doing a good joy. you are left without any credit. at least state where you got the dance from, so he can get credit and known for cause of his hard work.
huh? i don't get why this was directed at me because i also think that the original choreographer should have been credited. it's wrong for SHINee's choreographer to pass it off as his/her own work. i don't even like SHINee lol
This has been flagged as spam show
DEAR PAT CRUZ,
if you want to get credit for your dance moves, then FILE A LAWSUIT. it doesnt matter whether you'll get beaten by the company, just so long as you put forth that you made an EFFORT to get credit for what is yours. by saying "there's no use" "since i'm not a big name" you're basically saying 'my dance moves are free for you to take since i'm not gonna do anything' stop complaining and do something if you're gonna whine about it.
Sotardie 3 months ago
Also...really nice choreography. I hope that one day I can become this awesome! :D
NanaKitten95 3 months ago
As an aspiring choreographer, I would be so sad if this happened to me. All the hard work was just stolen! I hope this sly SM choreographer feels really bad about this...and poor SHINee are getting the blame now :/
NanaKitten95 3 months ago
What part did the boy band steal?
maggyjo 5 months ago
i'm not trying to be rude but fans can be so stupid sometimes. you guys need to gtfo off no one cares about some fakeass kpop group we're here to watch a dope performance
dondaorightnow 5 months ago
unlike these douchebags, i understand you guys! if my favorite kpop group (shinee) ripped off a dance choreography i came up with without me knowing, i would stop being their fan asap and be pissed as hell, even if it wasn't their fault. (like "wth is that taemin... key... minho... jjong... and onew... doing the dance *i* came up with and didnt tell me?" talk about lack of appreciation!)
waddleNguin 7 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
SIMPLY:.:COPY`,,&,..PASTE.,'
ＷＷＷ.ＷＡＴＣＨＦＵＬＬＭＯＶＩＥ.ＴＫ
SIMPLY..'COPY;.,&`.;PASTE..;
nelsonrandynelsonran 8 months ago
Poor Shinee!! Poor Shaun and Pat!!
amayachoify 9 months ago
guys, just ignore it...pretty soon dem koreans are gonna bomb us!
8c0a8t 10 months ago
haha stupid haoles..they think they can rule the world (tsk tsk)
now they're all getting pay back for copying snsd's song heh?
8c0a8t 10 months ago
okay heres the thing..i do admit that ur dance it awesome but i dont think u shud be so dramatic about this..okay, so even if they did that dance during a performance, it's just for a dance battle. it's not like they claimed ur dance to be theirs...but seriously i love your moves..:)
supergirl94ily 11 months ago
@supergirl94ily lol who wouldnt be?
waddleNguin 7 months ago
@supergirl94ily that's like singing a song that's not yours, but not saying who's it by, learn something about stealing stupid.
manat23ee 5 months ago
@manat23ee its just a dance routine, dude. chill. yeah, they didnt say who was it that came up with the moves, but like i said, shinee didnt say anything like 'hey, we invented the dance move ourselves'. look at it this way, it means that the dance is just too awesome that even the choreographers at SMEnt wanted to do it for a show. ps i think you have a problem against kpop or something.
supergirl94ily 5 months ago
dun blame SHINee.. they have nth to do w it.. Mayb the choreographer of this dance works for SM or is hired by them to choreo too?
gohhuimin1993 1 year ago
@gohhuimin1993 they danced to it, they have everything to do with it, it's called stealing dummie
manat23ee 5 months ago
Ummm... gtfo if what your talking about has nothing to do with this performance. Take your garbage arguments somewhere else you're just spamming the page.
Anyway, where was Shaun and Jeka?
Daraisvip 1 year ago
ahh there formations are so clean!
rockdinh 1 year ago
almost too many fuckn ppl to be onstage, they were good but aov was better hands down the judges sucked balls for this one
bboykountz 1 year ago
Than q...........
afsalk001 1 year ago
i like the first song......
whats that song??? if anybody know the song pls reply....
waiting for response...
afsalk001 1 year ago
well, shinee did a good cover of it, right?!
lauraseattlekyu 1 year ago
the "SHINee stealing your choreography" is a ridiculous claim in seeking attention.that performance was just a single performance.to believe a choreographer searched YouTube to find a dance thts not even the same song is a little preposterous. whats probable is tht one of your own dancers or someone who you've taught that part to was hired by, or even works for SM and used your dance for the very insignificant performance. it wasnt evenfor a single or a music video..really this is pathetic.
thesongendshere 1 year ago
@thesongendshere ahahaha, dont be stupid!!. sm's choreographer took pat cruz's choreography. Thats what happened. Don't try to act like thats not what happened. ahaha, What you said is more probable is actually 100 times less likely. It doesn't matter where the performance was or how insignificant it was. They still claimed it as their own when in fact it wasn't. They (sm) stole someone else's hard work. You make shinee's fans look ignorant.
mas0n51 1 year ago 6
You know kpop fangirls have taken over your posting when there's horrible grammar everywhere.
Anyways ... MAD PROPS for the awesome choreo. Keep 'em coming :) Don't worry, karma will most definitely come back and bite SME in the ass for all they've done so far.
flowMANGOES 1 year ago 4
Oh I think SM should be blamed, too, instead of poor SHINee, they would never steal from anyone else.
i would be pissed, too If my choreo was stolen from others and be claimed as theirs...but...oh well D:
Don't blame SHINee, poor SHINee, poor original choreographer. I just love the choreo and learnd it now XD
I think this ones is better.But it's anyway an awesome choreography, even when SHINee danced it!! Good job on this, Pat~ But I'm sorry for Pat and SHINee that it turned out like that >_<
XueTuKyoto 1 year ago
too long
28luv 1 year ago
they copied the part when rihannas- disturbia piece comes on
integlstrike 1 year ago
which part of it?
fikah67604086 1 year ago
ok... i dont even SEE how SHINee could've copied them... like AT ALL!!! i'm just not seeing it...
SparklyChibi 1 year ago
Sad that SHINee's choreographer copied it, but I think it was pretty stupid for him to call out SHINee on something they had no control over. :|
blahness001 1 year ago
what the fuck! i would be so freaken piss if i was in that guy's situation...man the person in charge of sm's choreography should get the hell out of there and be fired...man sucks for SHINEE they probably didn't even know that their dumbass choreographer stole someone's hard work..retard with no shame when he/she took his work and taught the choreo. to shinee
angskeet 1 year ago 5
i dont think its shinees fault....whoever choreographed them the dance should take blame...
freeleighrandom 1 year ago 4
@johnchoivideos: you're right they should apologize...and the difference between what SME did with Pat and what YG did with Shaun, Lyle and Aimee is YG actually "hired" them and brought them onboard to choreograph. SME just stole Pat's choreo. SHINee is not the one's at fault here but its also their responsibility to check and double-check where their choreography comes from. For Pete's sake...
harakeeri 1 year ago
@johnchoivideos
they're not on SM, it's YG...
MixSynchro 1 year ago
@johnchoivideos Right?
lnbtlover6159 1 year ago
Disappointed!I think dance choreographies should be protected now. And next time, SME, be classy, okay? Do some research and coordinate the TV stations to put the credits on our TV or computer screens. :|
msfattylin 1 year ago
as long as i njoy both~
i'm a shinee fan but i think this one's better though
eLeepemADAM 1 year ago
well no shit this ones better. the company can actually dance, unlike shinee
mas0n51 1 year ago
its not Shinee that u should blame its the choreographer
love the dance ^_^
F6mF6mF6m 1 year ago
yah, choreographers stole the dance for SHINee! i hate SM really, hate them to the max. Original choreo is nice.
LuLuBellsama 1 year ago
the steps fit lady gaga's song perfectly though.. haha. love the routine.
yeob0 1 year ago
it isn't the same as SHINee's Just Dance dances until 3:00. But It's OK. Two groups are great
ngocchau13 1 year ago
omg the original choreography is so beautiful..seriously..
kawaiigurl1231 1 year ago
these group is great.
anyway.
I agree to shinee's fans here. Even though I am a shinee fan I stand by what's right. Sure Shinee copied their dance BUT it is not them who choreographed the dance that they used for Lady Gaga's song. It was their choreographer. SHINee MIGHT not know that their choreographer just copied the dance steps from this group that's why they still used it in their performance. The one you should talk/blame it all to is their choreographer and not SHINee. :)
lovelyrose04 1 year ago 9
Which of shinee Dance was a copied 1?
mangopein 1 year ago
from 2:56
they danced on the tune of disturbia though.
agaconyelo 1 year ago
Shinee is not in blame but the choreographer
mangopein 1 year ago 2
yes it is quite the same as SHINee's Just Dance dances . the choreographer should be ashame ! this is just low !
chocolovemeltz 1 year ago 4
wateVer...both are very GOOD daNCERS...
antonetR 1 year ago
Just approach or sue whoever who choreograph the dance for SHINee.
I don't care if I'm just being bias or whatever shit. As a Shawol, I don't appreciate it when my boys are called "talented dancers"-apparently in a sarcastic way.
SHINee is more than just DANCERS.
Thanks god that the performance that cause all these discussion is merely a 1 min special stage.
MeldNeo 1 year ago 5
yea thanks to another butt hurt fans that can only think their idols as god...shinee is more as a dancers? huh...
puyenk 1 year ago
and about the choreography :D wow. this is just so darnnn good :D wooot. i wish i could dance like that...someday in the near future :D
pinefir 1 year ago
LOOK. SM. The one who "owns" SHINee is the one in the wrong okay. so kpop fans stop getting butthurt over this. sure it's disappointing to know that one of your idols (and mine too) copied choreography's but someone has to own up. i'm ashamed of those kpop fans who are not sensible enough to know that someone has to take responsibility. and that someone is shinee's choreographer okay.
pinefir 1 year ago 4
-__-
trieuhien89 1 year ago
em sorry but can anyone tell me the name of the song after disturbia?i love the whole choreography!thanks fr sharing! :))
jigglypufflala 1 year ago
those who said KPop sucks are fags..
ajpein 1 year ago 12
But, I hope with that, people will realize that Pat Cruz indeed is a great choreographer. He deserves respect.
Again, it's not SHINee's fault.
Damn, 3 comments in a row. YT commenting limit should be out XD
Agrafka 1 year ago 24
As much as I find it rude that he's spoken negatively about SHINee through one video, you have to understand the guy. His own choreography was stolen, I do understand his anger. You can't blame Pat Cruz at all.
Also, SME sucks ass. It seems like they've been getting lazy lately... I don't blame SHINee, they were only given the choreography to learn to, they did. It's not SHINee's fault at all.
It's funny how this video got +1000 views after copying thingy XD
Agrafka 1 year ago 9
SHINee fan here, oh.
To SHINee fans - a lot of you are getting upset at Pat Cruz for saying "talented" in quotation-marks. It's obvious he doesn't care about Kpop and SHINee at all, so he doesn't know anything about it. Truth be told... Many people now will know SHINee through Lady Gada cover, and... you gotta agree on that - they weren't doing well in this performance, hence why those quotation-marks.
But it's sad that he chose to judge the band only after seeing one video, that was shallow.
Agrafka 1 year ago 10
SHINee is not to blame. how can you be blamed for something you didn't know about? if they knew and it's gonna be announced officially, feel free to correct me.
i really feel bad that they're choreographer copied the dance, but if they band didn't know about, you just cannot blame them.
00UserNotFound00 1 year ago 5
i just knew there would be comments about SHINee XDXD
I'm am a SHINee fan myself.
the thing is... just because they danced this particular dance doesn't mean they're not talented. for example... stand in front of a mirror, Pat, chose some random choreography and dance right then and there.... does it mean you're not talented just because you danced somebody's else dance? NO.
00UserNotFound00 1 year ago 6
We are really sorry that happened but please keep in mind that it isn't SHINee's fault.
I'm a big fan of SHINee and that made me feel really bad for them.
lmambal 1 year ago 4
tsk tsk tsk SMH.. this is NOT the first time SM is accused of plagiarism.
materialist126 1 year ago 4
any artist can be accused of plagiarism.
xXSuJuNo1FanXx 1 year ago
@materialist126 When was the other time they were accused of plagiarism???
Coolzadi13 1 year ago
Instead of - stop this circus, people. Where the hell is SHINee's blame, when they just do what choreographer showed them? - All of you said orginal is better... so try to dance like that and sing, then we'll talk.
omo, for me SHINee is better.
SHINee is love.
mikayo6 1 year ago
dang, I wish I could dance like them.
poning110 1 year ago 5
that was like AAMAZING!! i cant believe the dance cheo. peeps stole the dance.-_-
wanabeazn666 1 year ago 4
I'm sorry but shinee didn't steal it, they were teached by their cheo. Give them a break, they just do what theyr told to do..
boebiej 1 year ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Shinee faggots,
shinee homos
Shinee what else do you wanna call them?
do me a favour sweetheart.
STFU and enjoy the fucking video.
if you aint got nothing nice to say. writing it on a youtube comment is it REALLY gonna make a difference to the society?
dont think so darling.
so.
do me a favor shut your fucking gob aite?
noodlezero 1 year ago
@kikibu1421 yea, because everyone has the time to check what people around the world are doing all the time.
suiekou45 1 year ago
shinee has nothing to do with the choreography. they just dance what their choreographer teach them. if there is anyone to be blamed, its the choreographer.
i agree that the original is better but isnt it a bit harsh to call the boys (shinee) faggots?
im not a big fan of them but i dont go around saying bad words or bad things about them..
phrelestavilla 1 year ago 39
Original is wayyyy better.
But do not blame Shinee, blame SM.
& You don't need to call Shinee "faggots", we talk about respect here.
jujuliiiie 1 year ago 44
totally agree with you :)
Rossana20 1 year ago
the original TOTALLY BETTER!
I LOVE THIS DANCE... beautifull koreograph!!!
emaetea 1 year ago
originals definatly better
MicroSunny 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It looks wack with Rihanna's Disturbia. I think SHINee along with Lady Gaga song gave it some style. You should be thankful at least your choreography is getting somewhere and a big audience is watching it other than just on another video on YouTube.
lnbtlover6159 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Oh yeah a big audience, because everyone all over the world knows who shinee is, LOL. Please.
/sarcasm.
Kpop is just a sub-par version of the American music industry minus the fame and album sales and of course earnings, that's why pathetic groups like shinee are singing Lady gaga's songs and not the other way around.
Learner012 1 year ago
@Learner012 U SHOULDNT BE TALKING ABOUT THAT KPOP HAS MERGE INTO MANY DIFFERENT AREAS AND CONCEPT WITH A LITTLE BIT OF WESTERN MIX BUT TOTALLY "NOT" ENTITLE TO SO CALLED AMERICAN MUSIC ....WHAT IS SO GOOD BOUT AMERICAN MUSIC? RAP, CURSING , SEX, DRUGS, WHAT ELSE IS THERE TO SAY ? AT LEAST KPOP ARTISTS ARENT LIKE THAT !!!!! EVEN THE BACKSTREET BOYS COMPLEMENTED DBSK AND BIG BANG ....WHAT DO U KNOW OF KPOP ....JUST STFU!!!!!!!
KimLinLa 1 year ago
@KimLinLa you really think backstreet would not be commenting on kpop artist when backstreet is in korea? come on all american artist are always asked the same question about which kpop artist you like. simple google search and bam they got a name of a artist to claim they like when i bet they dont give kpop the time of day.
plus american music is not all about what you claimed it is.
digiworld1989 1 year ago 4
Lol exactly, no one gives a fuck about Kpop unless they are promoting there. You think people like Beyonce, Rihanna, Lady gaga or the backstreet boys really care about some tiny joke of an industry? lol
Kpop is ALL self-created hype. None of their solo acts or groups sell anything worth talking about, America's and Japan's industry are the biggest and most respected, those TWO ALONE.
Kpop is down there with china lol.
Learner012 1 year ago
@KimLinLa ps kpop was just like american music before the censoring in kpop came along.
digiworld1989 1 year ago 2
Learner012
Just for you to know, SHINee does have a big audience! They have fame and fans in Asia and all the around the world, aswell as other korean boybands. Actually DBSK, a band from Korea has guiness record for having the largest fanbase in the word.
Asia obviously play songs from Asia and America does the same. The fact that they sang that one time Lady GaGa probably wasn't something they decided, as well as the choreo. And that was the first time they covered something from America.
xtimeximperfectx 1 year ago
First off LOL @ all the crying fans, Typical pathetic kpop fans.
Second moron DBSK barely sells 1mil. or 2mil. albums - their fanclub WEBSITE has more members than Lady gaga's yet who is selling more and has more fame in EVERY industry? lol stop spewing that shit like it means something because it doesn't. And she just came out a year or two ago, LOL.
Get a life you obsessive little cheap whore, they will NEVER fuck you. close your legs open your mind. SLUT.
Learner012 1 year ago
@Learner012 lmao you are on a roll with your insults. it is good you are giving these kpop fans the truth. i will admit i like kpop but i surely knows kpop is far from original. i also know that kpop is not well known as people try to make it. most people in most countries of this world dont know kpop exist.
just because you got like 100 people in one country other than korea who knows what kpop is dont mean it is well known.
kpop would never be well known because kpop gets alot of it's
digiworld1989 1 year ago
influence from american music. that is a fact and everyone knows that is the truth.
so most peolpe dont want to listen to something they already heard in english and listen to it again in korean.
i will admit my favorite kpop artist is se7en. the reason is as soon as i heard him sing one last cry i knew he is like one of the few with actual talent.
people who enjoy kpop must learn and face the truth that kpop would never never be anything to most people of the world.
digiworld1989 1 year ago 3
so pat not exactly knowing who shinee are makes sense. with that said i am only being truthful.
digiworld1989 1 year ago
@Learner012 I wasn't being rude, so why did you have to start with the cheap insults?
You should be the one getting a life, I see you a little bit to (bad)informed of kpop for just a "hater".
I never said DBSK was better known than Lady Gaga, so idk why are you saying those stuffs. i was just saying that the kpop industry does reach a lot of countries (man i'm from Chile and I know lot of people that love kpop over here) and that there are some important bands over there that have lots of fans
xtimeximperfectx 1 year ago
Blah blah blah, every group, singer and model has a fan somewhere in the world honey. LOL
Doesn't mean that industry is REACHING anywhere, it means there are specific people in other countries that take notice in another industry.
REACHING other countries is what Shakira did career wise with her US debut. When DBSK reaches that level of fame (and even that isn't all that much to talk about) then you say they 'reached' anything. They don't even sell more than Utada Hikaru, lol.
Learner012 1 year ago
Btw the only importance any Kpop group or singers in Korea have is in THEIR country you moron. LOL
Tell me ONE kpop group or solo act that has the star power that Beyonce, Lady gaga or rihanna has when they leave their homeland? They ALL get first class world star treatment no matter what country or continent they're on, that is IMPORTANT. LOL
DBSK wouldn't be noticed here by anything but asian americans and a few token blacks and whites, lol.
Learner012 1 year ago
I was talking about fame in their homecountry you moron :) At first you said that they had no fame, fanbase nor earnings and I said that they do have them but I didn't said it was all over the globe like American Divas. It's actually pretty obvious that it's easier for the american industry to get into others countries because american people thinks of themselfs as the most important population in the world and everyone seems to play along with it :)
xtimeximperfectx 1 year ago
Actually I never said they had NO fans, fame or earnings. I live in Asia and am well aware of DBSG and their fanbase, from their fan base killing innocent girls with their harassment to DBSG taking SME to court hun. You aren't talking to new blood here, LOL.
Learner012 1 year ago
Again name one Kpop star or group that has the amount of fame Lady gaga has gained within a year and a half, lol.
Name one that can go to any continent, in any country and sell millions of albums. Because Kpop singers and groups barely ever even crack 100k - that's why you count those that DO on ONE hand. LOL
It's not a matter of 'most important' American artist make more money, have international fame, and sell millions. That's a fact not a thought, lol.
Learner012 1 year ago
And if a south korean band can get thousands of fans in South America despise the distance and all the ethnical differences then it IS called reaching darling. If you are limited enough to think that the only way of reaching another culture is being played 24/7 in the forgein radios then you really have some issues (:
xtimeximperfectx 1 year ago
Thousands of fans? lol hun indie bands in America have thousands of fans everywhere.
International pop icons and stars have millions of fans in EACH and EVERY country.
Again name on Asian group or singer who could come to the US and get the same global icon treatment that someone like Beyonce, Rihanna or Lady gaga could get.
Name one Asian group or singer with diamond album status. And name one group or solo singer that consistently cracks the 1MIL. mark.
Go one hun, facts speak. =)
Learner012 1 year ago
Honestly I can't say one name because if I did I would be totally lying. But then again, I accepted in my first post that Asian pop stars are huge only in Asia and therefore I didin't compare them with the American ones.
On the other hand you seem to be doing that a lot, probably because you know that this is the only thing you could posibbly be right about (:
xtimeximperfectx 1 year ago
No you didn't honey, you read my post clearly regarding American and Korean pop stars. Got offended like a typical little fan girl BITCH and brought up DBSK hoping I wouldn't know who they were and got put in your pathetic little place, lol.
Stop twisting not only my words but your own, you just seem pretty dense. LOL
And lol @ more assumptions. Yeah and I'm sure the only thing you have in your moronic fangirl mind is fucking the newest 'hawt' boy band you cheap whore.
Learner012 1 year ago
Now that both of us had made of points clear and you have absolutely nothing else to say than those stupid insults then i shall leave.
This could had been some interesting interchange of opinions if you weren't such a jerk.
And lol @ you calling me a cheap whore and a moronic fangirl with a shallow mind.
I know it's not true so it just passes through me like nothing at all but it actually makes you look like a jerk with no more arguments to compite with (:
xtimeximperfectx 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
No more arguments? babe it takes two to argue, LOL. If you have an arguement that I haven't already taken a shit on then please do present it.
You're the one who started with the personal attacks moron. "probably because you know that this is the only thing you could posibbly be right about (:"
Looks personal to me, don't dish it out if you can't take it bitch. Now state some FACTS or FUCK OFF you idiot. LOL Damn I love being right =D
Learner012 1 year ago
Whether you hate Shinee or whatever, I'd very much appreciate it if you refrain from insulting k-pop. You think we aren't well aware that the asian music industry is exactly that? The ASIAN music industry? I don't think yur a bitch nor do I think yur completely in the right. But I love k-pop. Deeply, so when you say stuff like that it really fricking hurts. Can we just call a truce?
PAT CRUZ!~ Yur choreo is frickin awesome. Keep yur head up, yur one talented dude =)
Erry949 1 year ago
Refrain? hun sure thing, as soon as Youtube becomes a private site and screens each comment to make sure no one if getting their little feelings hurt, LOL.
Oh and yes the Korean music industry is just that, doesn't change the fact that the American music industry is ALSO JUST THAT, but American entertainers are clearing leading when it comes to fame, earnings and album sales. Fact over feelings bitch. lol Also there is no "asian music industry" they are all seperate, China, Japan, Korea, ect.
Learner012 1 year ago
Wow. You are just not worth talking to...
Erry949 1 year ago
@Learner012 lol how long are you going to fight with these kpop fans? lol let them believe that their little kpop artist is so well known and that kpop is so well known.
digiworld1989 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Btw why would they be happy about someone taking credit for their work? and making a profit from it by being hired by SME to teach the homos in shinee THEIR choreo.?
That's pathteic, I would be insulted if I saw fags like shinee butcher my own choreo.
Learner012 1 year ago
Learner012 They didn't credit them self. The choreographer's name hardly even gets mentioned or shown when there's a performance. Thankful they should be that their choreography is witnessed by a massive audience, their shouldn't be complaining since they are totally unknown choreographers. And profit?it was shown ones in an end of the year special that's the only time they have performed the song. It's a one time thing just to show something new and entertain not to promote it as their own.
lnbtlover6159 1 year ago
for one, Shinee are not fags, they might not be your type of artists, but calling them fags is going a bit too far,
also if you knew anything you would know that the show where they did it was just a one-off end of year special programme where they covered a different song. so they werent trying to promote anything (eg album etc)
please. get OVER yourself.
xXSuJuNo1FanXx 1 year ago
My type of 'artist'? lol shinee don't write, produce or compose. they aren't artist period.
And I'll call WHOEVER the fuck I want fags. Go back to your little prissy boyband and talentless girl group videos you dumb bitch.
Learner012 1 year ago
@Learner012 there is no need for people like you in the world. why dont you keep your hate to yourself, im sure you would never say the things you said if you were in person which is quite pathetic.
maplewood145 1 year ago
No need for people like me? lol what you mean someone who doesn't like a certain music industry and states the fact that Kpop is no where near Japan's or America's status in the overall music industry? LOL
Hun if you can't accept others opinions or views on the same topic I suggest you slit your throat and remove yourself from the gene pool you worthless piece of vile trash.
Learner012 1 year ago
yes !! you guys are really good !!
coolgirl6644 1 year ago
Actually , i am really disappointed about the korean music.
There are always news about the plagiarizing different kinds of western music . g-dragon , 2ne1 , sometimems plagiarzise underground music , cn-blue
and that time the dance.
I love shinee , but i get sick of this plagiarizing culture .
coolgirl6644 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Seriously, lol. It seems like YGE is CONSTANTLY given warnings and lawsuits from Sony or somewhere else for stealing lyrics or music, and now SME is getting caught up in this shit too.
This group(?) OWNS those little SM faggots shinee. LOL
Learner012 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
@Learner012 *coughicoughagreecoughwithcoughyoucough*
doubleheadeddude 1 year ago
GD did not plagiarize.
He is going to cooperate with Flo Rida in Heartbreaker-remix version.
It will be occured in DVD Solo Concert "Shine A Light" of him in March.
The jealous public opinion will be stamped out.
leslie18888 1 year ago
WOW. i'm in awe. im speechless. O.o
awesome choreography!!
sixteenthstar718 1 year ago
actually in the front, too many people that i can't focus where i should look at.
and it's kinda messy.
But the "disturbia" was AWESOME.
love the steps.
about the cheoreography thing with SM & SHINee, i have no comment
SHINee, all the BEST!
Joan8336 1 year ago 3
again SM? first Suju to Lyle's then now Shinee to Pat Cruz's?
am actually sick of all this copying, stealing, plagiarizing things in korea. seems like nothing comes out original anymore -.-
and blame the choreors! not SHINee or SM.
angelpara7 1 year ago 6
i like the camera bit of the dance lol
uknowfanx 1 year ago
The SM choreographers are HUGE fans i think. but if they were truly crazy about dance they would have had more RESPECT ! I don't think that they deserve to be considered as choreographers or dance lovers. Ttss i'm mad !
seyna322 1 year ago 4
OMG!!!
they are the same...
im sorry if they copied your choreography..i mean why wouldnt they its AWESOME!!!..
but its not SHINee fault...
BTW...love your moves..they're AWESOME!!!!!...
myfishy09 1 year ago 3
damn whats wrong with sm these day
actually wats wrong with korean entertainment these days
just sucks how shinees getting blamed
the choreographers probably said it was theirs and taught them
shinee probably didnt know anything
same thing happened with cn blue's song
geenakimx3 1 year ago 3
woww... you guys are amazing!!!
you guys danced so powerful. i love it!
dhii1235 1 year ago
why ? SM why ? - -;
GDROCKZvip 1 year ago
lol its neither sm or shinee's fault. its the choreographer's fault.
but i think that he should be happy someone famous like shinee used his work, although the company didnt even ask permission.
since i am a fan, if i was the choreographer, i would be in heaven.
NatsumiNL 1 year ago
I cant find the similar thing from the 2 choreography...!
Porkhu 1 year ago
ok,you oughta put a copyright on each of your new dance moves from now on.you know thats the legal way to go n yes its possible. stealing your choreography for a stage performance is not a crime, unless its like an official video or something,we all copy from some where.and k-pop doesnt do anything original.thers no point whining cos i dont think SMs going to hire you, just like YG takes help from Shaun. do your own thing and be happy. now that you are famous!
tsheringeden 1 year ago
omg this is great!
cintaakukepada 1 year ago
really really good.
gaaaaa i hate this.. SM come on~!! we all know you can do better than that..
the dance goes so good both in disturbia & just dance though..
very nice video~!!
sjyoo14 1 year ago
this is a awesome choreography
hate SM Entertainment not SHINee
i strongly believe they are innocent
cello741 1 year ago 7
oooh wait i thought the name pat cruz sounded familiar but now i see hes with the company!!! riight
i ve seen a few perfs of them :D they are SICK
ive seen that bodyrock perf of 2008 and 9 i think
itwas amazing
ThugLady 1 year ago
bahh, SM Ent suckkssss. they think "bad publicity" is "good publicity". they did it know fully well how eagle-eyed netizens from all around the world are (esp. in Korea). D;
it's not SHINee fault though, it's SM Ent's.
swtgal125 1 year ago 11
You guys dance amazingly good!
destiny428 1 year ago 2
stop talking about shinee, people. just enjoy the awesomeness of this vid :D
kwonleadah1 1 year ago 3
cool, you guys danced it better. but then again you created it.
kapuso7ako 1 year ago
I hope they dont intend to blame shinee because its not their fault. its the people at sm's fault.
aikofury 1 year ago
this is bull, so everyone here jst says they're awesome dancers jst 'cause they feel sorry for them? i mean have you heard two sides of the arguement? ohks let's say it WAS copied, you srsly can't blame shinee, they probs din' noe. blame the choreographer or sme as they're the ones hu chose it! saying shinee isn't 'talented' is pretty bull too, i mean taemin got into sme for his dancing, i wonder why these ppls haven't become famous for their dancing if they're soo much better than shinee.
IchigOxYH 1 year ago
SHINee was just dancing like they were told. In their company unless people spontaneously tells them to have a dance battle everything is choreographed by the company. Don't have hard feeling toward them they are just chess pieces on their company's board
SunniMinimi 1 year ago 2
This video got a LOT more views thanks to SHINEE.
kahlen 1 year ago 3
ahh SHINee's dance and ur dance defs look the same!
they should have given u credit :S
but it's not SHINee's fault, cus they didn't know about this.
they don't decide on the dances..their company does.
so their company should defs take the blame.
sorry that they took ur dance without giving u credit :(
ur a talented choreographer :)
wendychenchen 1 year ago 4
a huge fan of shinee, but I'm sorry to hear their choreographer is bullshit
you're a lot better at dancing than they are!
korean artists steal music from other major artists all the damn time; dance is more occasional, but it still happens
I'm really sorry :/
This is the one thing that really bothers me about k-pop; no originality.
blackdragonwingz 1 year ago
That's not fair at all that they took your choreography and didn't credit you for it. It's okay because you guys can dance 100 times better then SHINee ever could.
shecantgetenough 1 year ago
why didn't you guys give credit to the original choreographer -.- like really if it's not your work give credit and get their (original choreographer) names out there
0ralia0re0 1 year ago
No matter who actually did copy, it sucks that the original choreographer doesn't get recognized. Dance is the physical expression of music- like in the tumblr, the reasoning and meaning of movements become shattered.
As someone in the community, I understand the pride it feels to be the extension of a song through choreo and the artistic expression behind it. No matter what the skill of someone, someone's piece of work is special and precious to them
No wonder Choreo Cookies takes theirs down
KarateSHOES00 1 year ago 6
good stuff. gosh choreographers need to be more creative!
HUNNILICIOUS 1 year ago
thanks pat for choreographing this! :)
shinee brought an awesome performance with your choreography
HUNNILICIOUS 1 year ago 2
I don't think SHINee should be the one to blame. The person who "choreographed" their routine should be blamed for it. It's so sad that this had to happen =/
STICKITtotheman 1 year ago 6
@STICKITtotheman its funny how you people don't blame the actual "famous singer/ group". becuase they are famous and you love them and actually you have to come blame the person who choreographed the dance. its like saying you worked so hard on something and another person came and took it without your permission and everyone WOWED you for doing a good joy. you are left without any credit. at least state where you got the dance from, so he can get credit and known for cause of his hard work.
itswinniechu 1 year ago
huh? i don't get why this was directed at me because i also think that the original choreographer should have been credited. it's wrong for SHINee's choreographer to pass it off as his/her own work. i don't even like SHINee lol
STICKITtotheman 1 year ago 7
thats sucks that they stole the choreo..but they are really good dancers too :)
steffi6661 1 year ago
sorry about SHINee stealing the choreo :[
love this though :D
WILLisCURSED 1 year ago 4
wats the last song?
steeeephie 1 year ago
Whats the song at ? 1:58
blaze2001 1 year ago
hey its subi!
mrkrisme 1 year ago
what is the last song called?
Leopardxpink 2 years ago
thats mike fal in the first song not shaun.
kabaJabba21 2 years ago
@kabaJabba21 Shaun choreographed it though..
MYRNNN 1 year ago
@MYRNNN No.... Pat Cruz did......
getinspiredd 1 year ago
@ getinspiredd Nope, just look it up on youtube, shaun evaristo 11/6/08..
MYRNNN 1 year ago
maaaan that t.i set got me aaammpppeed shux shauns swag is awesome for that song dang
fr33shm3n 2 years ago
Someone can give me the name ot the second song ? please.
Thanks a lot ;)
bountila 2 years ago
The Dynamo Of Volition - Jason Mraz
EdtheLed 2 years ago
Comment removed
bountila 2 years ago
WOW!
that was practicly flawless.
from the handwork, to the feet, to the levels, to the sync, to the thightness!
I am truly impressed (and that takes a lot - so that says something).
Truly outstanding.
probz!
ugieman 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i didnt like how they used mgmt's electric remix and did hip hop style choreo to it. i think it could've used some poppin and some more iso's
webutekniq 2 years ago
good job guys.! i was hella feelin it.
drenfromdaygo 2 years ago
that was AMAZING.. i loved it.
allstarcheer024 2 years ago
My God u all r so AWESOME! (real words) :) ;) so wonderful!
jchina3 2 years ago
THE COMPANY made me love tat song disturbia fuhsho!!! sicc'ness YO!
lilpnoiste08 2 years ago
dude dey r ill fosho...if u dnt wanna get down after watchin dem perform sumthin rong wit d rythm section of yo brain...
jedi916 2 years ago
bakk. ez naon jó!
Lilla0096 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
subi you mutha fucka!
joelborres 2 years ago
disturbia piece was siiiiick =)
sthanibat 2 years ago