Added: 3 years ago
From: davidjohncooke1
Views: 47,926
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (64)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i love this song!!!

    

  • Glee did a good job, but theres only one Streisand.

  • guys this is about barbra streisand

    <3

  • SweetPoffin you are so FUNNY ROTFL!!

  • This is a Barbra Streisand video. SHUT THE FUCK UP ABOUT LEA FUCKING MICHELE.

  • i love Barbara and Lea..... I LOVE BRODWAY... BUT I LOVE GLEE TOO!

  • There is.. en will never be ..someone that is better than Barbra.

    Greetings from Holland.

  • neither are "better", omg. you can't even compare them. this is the original, and lea's is an amazing cover. that's it. the rest is personal preference.

  • Lea michele is so much better and I love her <3

  • Lea in my opinion is way BETTER thumbs up if u agree

  • these are 2 recordings pieced together aren't they?

  • @tarisone I think so too

  • .......How can u even compare this to Glee???? This is REAL golden age Broadway/Hollywood. OBVS the voices are gonna sound different....just like any older songs/singers. Lea just sounded more modern..... (EXACTLY why I hate glee...they ruin the original song with their good pop voices).

  • nizz rachel sings this better then ms. streisand by far honestly.

  • OKAY PEOPLE!!! JUST BECAUSE BARBRA STREISAND IS A LEGEND DOESN'T MEAN THAT LEA MICHELLE'S VERSION IS CRAP!!! IN MY OPINION, LEA DID 10X BETTER, AND THAT'S AFTER HEARING THE BARBRA STREISAND VERSION FIRST! SERIOUSLY, JUST CALM DOWN!

  • @OPYDAX How about you take your hand off that caps lock Gleeker

  • i think this one is okay, but you can't really FEEL the energy in the way that you an when lea does it. I just don't like this song!

  • I HATE THIS VERSION!!!!! LEA HAS A SO MUCH MORE ENERGETIC TAKE TO IT. EVENN THE MUSIC IS 10 TIIMES BETTER. SORRY, BUT THAT'S JUST HOW IT IS!!!

  • @OPYDAX  You're wrong. :)

  • i think both versions are good glee and barbra streisand

  • look 0 dislikes thats just to show she is awsome

  • Her voice is so beautiful!! I love it!

  • okay so this might be the original version, but the glee version is SO much better, it's the truth. i'm not saying this one isn't good, glee's version is just better. and yeah barbara might be a "legend", but it just happens that a newer version was performed better.

  • @hannnnnnnna123 Glee, is auto-tuned hannnnnnnna.

  • @ramdomperson5201 ...no it's not..

  • @ramdomperson5201 wanna bet?

  • @ramdomperson5201 Lea Michele has been on Broadway. I'm pretty sure she doesn't need auto-tune

  • lea michelle tortured this song in a live performance...

  • @markfliance802

    I second that. She was awful... The film version of this song had such better orchestration than the original Broadway one, that's for sure - and had more "oompff" - but that horrible girl just tortured this and should not be allowed to sing it. She did an ok job on the recording, but I cannot stand the no vibrato till the last moment style that most pop/musical theatre type singers are doing these days... it's awful!

  • @rlee1976 you guys need to be open to change, and the change that different artists will bring to a piece. That is what makes a piece interesting, right? Not saying the Lea Michelle version was the best, but it definitely wasn't awful. She is good...and it isn't really her fault they do so much autotune crap on the show.

  • Lea sing this song better, is the truth. :S

  • the movie version in funny girl is better i think

  • Shame on all the little ones who think the Glee version is better! I'm a total gleek and yeah, Lea Michelle is lovely, talented, and a solid performer. But Barbra Streisand is a LEGEND, her epic intensity just gives me goosebumps! There's something about Lea's sound that's just too "clean", she doesn't take risks like Barbra does.

    There's simply no comparison! :)

  • Comment removed

  • It makes me laugh to hear that the youngens think that Lea's rendition is better than Barbra's. Given, hers is unique and she is great in her own way! But seriously people, do you know who Barbra is? She is the inspiration for so many people for decades and generations. No Barbra = no Funny Girl broadway and film ! Have some respect.

  • i can sing this so well, it actually makes me happy

    im clearly like a chocolate barbara streisand... jkjk

    but i do have a vid up on my channel and maybe ill put a vid up of me singing this so youtube can see how clearly ahmazing i am! :P jk

  • Lea Michele sounds better sorry Barbara

  • This is a powerful and truly outstanding performance by an extremely talented and gorgeous Barbra Streisand! Barbra gives so much energy and raw talent to this classic. I love you Barbra. You ROCK always & forever in my heart!!

  • I really love this better thantheglee version. Especially on the movie recording.

  • GLEE VERSION JUST SO BETTER *-*

  • @LumaSpigolon

    i dont agree

  • I just love Barbra's voice. She's just got so much sass and flair to the way she sings. It's absolutely spectacular.

  • Thanks for posting this classic!

  • Me encanta como compilaste las fotos!Desde la young "funny girl" Barbra a la madura y deslumbrante Streisand

  • I love this Song

  • love this ssong

  • Don't tell me not to live

    Just sit and putter,

    Life's candy and the sun's

    A ball of butter,

    Don't bring around a cloud

    To rain on my parade.

    Don't tell me not to fly,

    I've simply got to

    If someone takes a spill

    It's me and not you.

  • good job! haha could you please post from which clips you got these, along with the dates? Ü

  • it's better to watch the film Funny Girl with this song. Go look for that scene and it's pretty much the same as the Glee version.

    Glee did a good job with it though.

  • omg!!!! where is this from? y did u cut into the new halfway threw?

  • I heard this on Glee and i simply just HAD to listen to the real version!

  • @noonikins Me too!

  • @noonikins me too! I love this song! (glee version too ;D)

  • actually, there's one key change- at 25 secs in from broadway to hollywood. Still, amazing!

  • you did an awesome job putting this video together! i like the song transition from one to the other. Did you do the song or is it available on CD?  nice video- have seen it at least 13 times.

  • Fabulous-- same song,same artist, same key from age 22 to 66. Unbelievable! Great post. Thanks!

  • @rambrewster Actually, the original key is a half-step higher...but then she stayed consistent again.

  • Great editing. I love all her versions, and its interesting hearing her thru the years. Her last 'Myy' before 'parade' is spine tingling!! I also love her medley version on 'My name is Barbra'. Thanku 4 uploading!

  • Wow! That was great!!! Improving it through the years!

    Thank you!!!!!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more