Menora - Bukit Yong Kelantan

[harrybagan]

lamo doh tok tgk nnoro...jame kecik mulo gak tok sir duk bawah....kalu gi tgk mesti nok naik atas panggung skali

[amrlfz92]

menora is not belong to thailand it's belong to malay kingdom

[jamesngjh]

@amrlfz92 Definitely, it originated from the Malays but many Malays are denying their Hindu/Buddhist preislamic past and some are even trying to suppress their own culture because they deem it 'unislamic'. Without the Hindu/Buddhist part of Malay culture, Malay culture will just be another Arab culture.

[amrlfz92]

@jamesngjh ya rite....such a shame...

[noranectv]

Terima kasih keatas semua maklumat ini, maklumat ini penting bagi mereka yang ingin mengentahui asal usul menora (bagaimana dengan makyong adakah dia berlainan?)

[kembali100]

cth lg satu ayam serama pn ckp dr siam padahal thailand dok sibuk mngimpot ayam serama dr malaysia. ksimpulannya slatan thailand dulu memang byk negri2 melayu lama sjak zaman hindusblum siam wujud n depa mpunyai tamadun n budaya depa sndiri sblum dpinjam bangsa len. siam pn byk mminjam budaya khmer/kemboja n kemboja pn byk pinjam budaya champa. tp sume tu dh x nmpk. dulu negri2 melayu san sbg pusat keilmuan duniawi n akhirat trutamanya bidang agama lani jd tmpt super maksiat.ha3

[kembali100]

ni lg satu cth kebaghalan melayu.ckp menora dr siam. aku puas cri sumber tu btul ke x. x betul pn. org siam pn x tau. aku tgk tv thailand pn depa ckp menora brasal dr slatan thai n dr org melayu sndiri. aku rasa melayu bodoh yg x tau sjarah ni pastu rase rndah diri sbg melayu sanggup claim menora dr siam. hoi bahlol! org melayu dulu sblum islam bragama buddha, hindu n aninisme. empayar melayu spt langkasuka dh wujud lama sblum siam wujud. nk heran apa burma, laos n kemboja pn pki mcmni gak.

[amrlfz92]

@kembali100 betul...aku pernah baca dekat blog siam(english)...depa ada tulis yg menora influence dari malaysia....kuku panjang yg depa pkai time menari pon budaya melayu purba.

org melayu dulu2 pakai headgear atas kepala mcm siam pakai 2..tapi byk budaya melayu dah terhapus bila islam menapak di malaysia

[jynpang]

thank you for posting this. please post more. very sad we are losing these dance forms.

[anaktupai76]

Saya pernah tengok menora yang dimaiinkan oleh 100% orang cina satu masa dulu. Diaorang main masa nak bukak kedai baru. Diaorang ada team sendiri.

[jynpang]

@anaktupai76 that's fascinating. wonder if it still exists.

[lynx218]

Kelantan used to belong to the Empire of Siam prior to its defection to Malaya.. thats why the people there speak a little differently.. kelantanese (bahasa kelatae) is a mixture of malay, hokkien and thai.. so you can see in Menora, Mak Yong, Tarian Ashik.. there are elements of siam and Nusantara (javanese) as we all shared a common ancestry. Kelantanese people are a proud and stubborn people who cannot easily shed their generational heritage despite PAS banning the cultural expressions..

[kembali100]

@lynx218 itu loghat la ngok mmg bbeza. negri melayu len ade loghat masing2. dulu kelantan di bwh jajahan siam. bsyukurlh sbb lani x jd mcm sdara kita kt slatan thai sana yg x dpt lpskn diri. ingat org melayu lama dulu sblum masuk islam pki baju melayu n tanjak ka? tamadun melayu lbih lama dr siam/thailand. empayar srivijaya, champa, khmer/kemboja adlh empayar ttua di asia tggara. empayar srivijaya tu pusat dia je kt sumatera tp dlmnya byk krajaan mleayu tua cthnya dsekitar sgnting kra/tanahseri.

[shamyusoff]

Bukit Yong majoriti penduduknya adalah melayu. dan org melayu hanya bermain muzik sahaja. mungkin saya adalah orang melayu pertama yang menjadi karektor utama dalam persembahan menora sehingga kini. kalau ada, boleh hubungi sy sbb seronok juga boleh bertukar2 pendapat. saya pasti penduduk Bukit Yong masih mengingati sy, anak muda melayu pertama membawa karektor Pak Sitong dalam persembahan menora di kawasan tersebut sekitar tahun 2004

[noranectv]

Tkasih. Minta alamat dan no telefon untuk saya hubungi jika ada pertanyaan.

[zubinmohamad]

I belived Manora came from the Langkasuka Kingdom, situated in the South of Thailand and North of Malaysia. So Manora is not Thai per se, it belongs to the shared, older kingdom before 1909 Bangkok Treaty. Check out Zubin Mohamad also

[EmpayarMelaka92]

@zubinmohamad I believe so.Some of my khmer friend also say that manora were originated in malay peninsula/Langkasuka kingdom.And influence the tai people.

[kembali100]

@EmpayarMelaka92 setuju dgn ko

[kembali100]

@zubinmohamad setuju dgn ko.

[zubinmohamad]

Nice. Is there a Thai community in Bukit Yong? I know they are not Malay, may be some musicians and also some Mak Yong combination

[noranectv]

Bukit Yong penduduknya ramai Melayu ada beberapa kerap penduduk berugama budha berketurunan Siam jadi sejarahnya tidaklah saya ketahui, cuma bila ada acara tamat latihan majlis diadakan disitu. thanks

[sayyid14]

@noranectv Kon di kepala pakai itu memamg budaya melayu seblum islam.sebelum Thai@Siam dtang dari Nanchoa Yunnan China ketika kerajaan Thai jatuh oleh serang orang Mongol mereka Lari di Cambodia,meyedut budaya Khmer(cambodia)&Melayu.Kon menara di kpla tu asalnya dari pengaruh Hindu.selepas islam dtg & jga Siam makin kuat & banyak menawan tanah2 melayu dari Champun,Ratchaburi,sampai santun,narathiwat so mereka "mencuri budaya itu" bila islam datang banyak pengaruh hindu dibuang salah satu Makyong

[sayyid14]

@noranectv macam budaya melayu lain mcm Headgear menera kon,sembah(tangan cmpun ala mcm orang jawa,siam,kmbja wat tu),dah tak pratikan oleh melayu semenajung,brunei,sulu,Riau.ki­ta mesti segarkan semula..aku tgk kat MENTOR baru2 ni dah mulakan budaya salam sembah tu bagus la..sebenarnya Khmer dan Melayu yg menerab budaya tuh sebelum VIET , Thai, Burmese menjajah mon-Khmer & Melayu.muka Khmer dan melayu tak jauh beza coklet2 @ kulit sawo matang lah dari Thai dan Viet sepet & kuning.itulah buktinya

[sayyid14]

@noranectv Satu lagi penah tgk tak Raja Bersiong Versi Tengku Abdul Rahma Menteri KIta pertama itu Menujukankan Sebelum Islam orang2 Melayu berbudaya INDOCHINA memakai sama seperti orang2 KHMER selepas itu Siam.Siam adalah Bangsa terbaru yg menerima budaya INDOCHINA(mon-khmer dan Malayanic)..kajilah Thai takde hak nak Claim dia punya..so ini Boleh dikatakan milik melayu juga dikongsi Khmer,Cham,Malays & 2nd Coming Lao,Thai,Shah & Burmese.Itu Pakar Sejarah dunia kata bukan saya.jaga budaya kita!

[akpattujuh]

soh tok cha dio join sekali...baru best daa..buat go dok nuggu kat situnyoo...nate sie make bewok perghut hija...hahah

[solarnoise]

haha damn it i miss seeing this back home, those rhythmic drums ans gongs have always been straight up fireeee... some better presentation that would be more appealling is good though

[iamyie]

menora.. originally from thai. but kelantanese have influence from thai.. a bit similar with mak yong and its played in kelantan too...

[shannonO125]

Are you sure this is a Malay dance? Looks like Thai to me. Head dress, clothes, and hand guestures.

[Charaht]

Thank you for posting. This is the best Manora video I have seen, I missed it a lot. I wish I can visit my elderly uncle in Kalantan soon .......

[ikokmulah]

mano ni kat tokong tok ca ko?

[pokaik]

menora bukit yong tanbun ko gapo.... tahun bila

[BigBro1043]

this potrays the greatness of the malay culture

[noranectv]

thanks, I try my best

[haryatt]

tolong download banyak jenis menora lagih nah

[noranectv]

thanks I try my best

[keELaBLiZzy]

please upload more on this menora dance!!!

[noranectv]

thanks, I try my best