I prefer the censored video, if not the song. The "scene missing" frames fit in really well with the overall feel of the video/song. And all you're missing is a really androgynous girl.
They must've really cut the hell outta thid video because from what i seen it's not all that controversial. But this is the censored version. I must see the uncensored version before i draw a conclusion.
Peaches' "Fuck the pain away" and Enrique Iglesias' Tonight (I'm fucking you) are allowed on YouTube uncensored but adults aren't allowed to watch or hear Trent singing that he wants to "Fuck you like an animal?" Come on, at least he's not being depressed like Peaches or rapy like Iglesias- he's just expressing himself.
I WANNA FUCK YOU LIKE AN ANIMAL!!!!!! holy shit truer words have never been spoken. I feel like when i fuck a women im just doing it for physical need, and that need brings me closer to "god" even though i know got doesn't fucking exist. FUCK YEA TRENT YOU FUCKING ROCK!!!!!
Btw trent reznor aka nine inch nails is amazing. For making real music. We need more artist like him these days. Not those flaws metal, emo, screamo bands.
Warum ist dieses Video zensiert? In den Nachrichten und manchen Dokumentationen werden viel schlimmere Sachen gezeigt. Kann ich einfach nicht nachvollziehen.
There is no point in debating these idiots who are trying to compare Reznor's genius to that of "splash in the pan" hacks like Bieber and Lady Gaga. Most of them are not even out of their teens and have no idea what it's like to grow up with music that's original & groundbreaking and not cookie cutter like everything that's out now. Just ignore the trolls and banish them to their crap music and let the grown ups listen to the good shit.
NIN is more than music. It is a journey that trent wants you to accompany him on to places your conscience won't allow your physical body to follow....Go. You'll be glad that you did...
@Dhruv1223 ask us germans :( movies and games are censoerd to smithereens and beyond recognition... just go n this site and see what is banned, or censored schnittberichtedotcom
I'm glad that the censored one is still availible. Let's remember that this was what people saw in 94 and what lead to all the buzz. as a student of history, it is important to have access to this version, to read its social impact.
The religious and sexual symbolism in this video makes it the best video I have ever seen. And the song is perfect; it wreaks of sex! The power and energy are astounding. Talk about feeling dirty after listening to it ! Mmmmmmm. Where's a man when you want one.....
@ashamosa I love Trent's music maybe just as much u could do.. but u shouldn't offend other artist just cause' they re' different, excuse my bad english.
these are the classics. you can't even put lady gaga in the same category as NIN. I mean really? lady gaga is fucking crazy; NIN is singing about some deep shit.
WhoEVER brought up Lady ShitFace on a NIN video should be castrated and fucked like an animal up the butt without any lubrication. STFUUUUU and go watch that shit. Let NIN fans enjoy their music without you comparing real talent to that transvestite. It's disgusting.
I don't undestand what the freick all you guys are talking about. I've been DYING to look for the censored version. YOU PEOPLE WASTE UR TIME ON THIS SEGMENT!! As for the song....LOVE IT AND ALWAYS WILL!! ;D
I am sick of seeing Lady Gaga's name on every video I watch. So, what, if I go watch a John Mellencamp or Tool video her name will be on there too? WTF people? At least get the genre right.
GUESS WHAT I FOUND?? THE UNCENSORED VIDEO AND NOT ONLY THE UNCENSORED TRACK. ITS TITLE IS "NIN - CLOSER - The Full Length , Album version Extended video remix". I TRIED POSTING THE LINK HERE BUT COULDN'T.
Why is everyone comparing Trent Reznor to Lady Gaga?! @samuelellmer you are fuckin stupid.Ther music genres are different.Trent is Industrial rock(with some electronica,dark ambient,& little bit of syntpop which in some songs like "Only").Lady Gaga is pop and dance(with some...will thats it).*Continue to my next comment*
@SamDakota86 Trent has been sucessful in NIN,has made musical scores for the video game Quake and also The Social Network,has been in a music video called "I'm Afraid of Americans" with his music influence David Bowie(which Lady Gaga is an influence to & would probably dream of but never will),helped Marilyn Manson become famous,him,his wife,& Atticus Ross are makng music together in a band called... *continue to my next comment*
@SamDakota86 *continued* called How to Destroy Angels,and has helped made the music genre Industrial more than it is.And don't start me with her winnings in that VMA's shit, those awards mean nothing compared to the grammys.having your album selling the most to become #1 on the Billboard dosn't make you good.The speech that she made in that gay rights ally seems to be the only thing good from her I guess.
@SamDakota86 You're the fucking idiot. At what point did I mention ANYTHING about awards? This was never about awards you dickshit moron. The very fact that's all you have to back up your argument just go to show how pathetic and meaningless you are to this entire debate. Why don't you just go back to the Hurt video and comment about how it's so much better than Cash's cover yeah?
@SamDakota86 True, but she does attempt to push the limit stylistically must like many Industrial artists did in the nineties. Her videos have been fairly controversial for a pop/dance artist. If I were to compare her to an industrial artist though, it would probably be Marilyn Manson.
@SamDakota86 This was only ever about the two artists being controversial. You're directing this argument towards me about their different genres, and then explaining what they sound like. What.the.fuck.retard? I listen to both artists, you don't need to explain to me how they sound. In fact what argument are you EVEN making??
Read over your comments, and realise how absolutely irrelevant and mediocre they are in comparison to mine.
@SamuelEllmer I was explaining my comments to everyone you fuckass, not just you!Looks like you only read some of my comments,and awards isn't the only thing I said,I also said about Trent's acomplishments and his legacy.And I don't see whats so bad about NIN's cover being better than the original.Go listen to every NIN album.When you hear The Fragile songs do you think of Lady Caca(maybe for me Starfuckers Inc. is the only song for me that represents her and the rest of the pop artists for me.)
@SamDakota86 My worst mistake evidently was saying that I enjoy listening to both NIN and Lady Gaga, because apparently that's call for every NIN fan to jump on the 'THEY HATE DIFFERENT MUSIC THAN ME FUCK THEM' emo non-comformist bandwagon. I also enjoy listening to How to Destroy Angels and The Beatles. Anyone got anything to say about THAT?
@SamuelEllmer And if you want to talk about controversial,look at the music videos on NIN's Broken album,(if you heard of it) like Happiness in Slavery and Gave Up and rest of them their was suppost to be a VHS/DVDS for the MV's,but the videos were so violent that it wasn't even released.Probably so violent that it makes Alejandro and Telophone look like kids movies.tSearch "Lady Gaga Copies / EXPOSED/Grammys 2010" on Youtube. Shows she isn't that much original as some people say.
@SamDakota86 I still don't understand why you had to specifically mention and link me in your post. Calling me stupid for saying I respect both artists?! No, I don't think of Lady Gaga when I listen to ANYTHING of NIN's. Because they're completely fucking different! My VERY FIRST AND ORIGINAL comment on this video was about Gaga and Trent having controversial tendencies and how it's effected their popularity because of what route they took their controversy down.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
It seems the only people that want to reply to any of my comments on this video (which aren't related, but I never intended it to get like this) are strictly all NIN love and no Gaga love. It's fine to have that opinion, but honestly, you don't need to start an argument with someone who's NEUTRAL on both sides. I respect both artists for their MUSIC. So go leave your close-minded ignorant selves elsewhere, and not in my inbox T.T
@SamuelEllmer Hey, I get what you mean. I'm sort of in the middle here (perhaps leaning slightly more towards Gaga) I don't consider either to be high art or godly. This video isn't that remarkable to be honest - I've seen the uncut version too. An Aleksandr Rodchenko lookalike and a few lazy nods to Man Ray does not make something high art. It seems elevated way beyond what it is - a music video. I love Trent but he doesn't even begin to touch the genius of the two artists I've mentioned.
@SamuelEllmer Now with Gaga people underestimate her; they belittle her but I think she's going to have the last laugh. She has only just released one Album and an EP! The Fame was a pretty solid pop record with darker undercurrents.Have you heard the new remix, Scheiße? (yeah, the title made me laugh...)
I also detect a hint of Misogyny here on the comments for this video in regards to Gaga. A woman is a talentless whore for being influenced by other artists... all righty.
If you want the uncensored song (not video,alas)try typng in 'Sherlock'fromthe BBC'modern update;someone (sorry, forget the name) did a great fan vid featuring the hate/hate thing on between Sherlock and Jim(I.E. Sherlock being Holmes;Jimbeing Moriarty,of course) using this song. Youalsomight enjoy checking out 'Sherlovk meets Mean Girls' ... it's too snarky for words!
@NewYorker991 "the illuminati" is merely a dead cult that we & media have raped & revived into a universal marketing tool. theres nothing to be afraid of.
lady gaga es un puta de los gays, no tiene realmente ningun talento musical no deberian admirala, no se compara con el maesto trent reznor es una ofensa que los comparen
Ok....i'm doing everyone a favor.....there IS a UNCENSORED version here on youtube....it's by Nintend00, and it's running time is 7:11...now stop whining and see it.....thx.....
I love the part with the aviator type goggles when the 'wind' is blowing on him.
MegaDroidBoy 1 week ago
@monkeys37 And a crucified monkey o_O
thatoneguy855 3 weeks ago
I prefer the censored video, if not the song. The "scene missing" frames fit in really well with the overall feel of the video/song. And all you're missing is a really androgynous girl.
monkeys37 1 month ago
jared letos best lovesong :D
x3Josiix3 1 month ago 2
Why i must confirm +18 if the video is CENSURED???
SAY NOOOOOOOOO TO CENSURE
N0RlK0 1 month ago
Wow, I know that chorus! Limp Bizkit used it in Hot Dog.
hujjer 1 month ago
Somebody actually flagged the censored version? Special much?
86toMOOSE 1 month ago 2
What other video could say they had strong influences from the great Brothers Quay and Joel Peter Witkin? This is the best video ever!. Period.
DivineManiaStudio 1 month ago
censoring the f-word in this song is so stupid XD
the song rocks all the same <3
sudynlj 1 month ago
screw the boots! i want trent reznor!
Alteredmind100 2 months ago
Comment removed
jesusaz1 2 months ago
Awwwww!!!! I want that boots!!!! :)
maschagohlke 2 months ago
i love this song :)
jnash1318 2 months ago
i like this song
jnash1318 2 months ago
heres the link for the uncensored video:
vodpod.com/watch/1444582-nine-inch-nails-closer-uncensored-1994-on-vimeo
perazasamuel 2 months ago
They must've really cut the hell outta thid video because from what i seen it's not all that controversial. But this is the censored version. I must see the uncensored version before i draw a conclusion.
cocoaqueen16 2 months ago
Peaches' "Fuck the pain away" and Enrique Iglesias' Tonight (I'm fucking you) are allowed on YouTube uncensored but adults aren't allowed to watch or hear Trent singing that he wants to "Fuck you like an animal?" Come on, at least he's not being depressed like Peaches or rapy like Iglesias- he's just expressing himself.
MJRNKR 2 months ago
@MJRNKR baha "rapy like iglesias" lolol it's the truth
ChiyoYSayuri 1 month ago
Wow, that was weird. But not as bad as I expected after confirming I'm 18 or older.
AJandHerCookie 3 months ago 2
ew wtff...
mjfreak1111 3 months ago
if you wanna fuck her like an animal, then fuck AN ANIMAL. idiots
hebrisch 3 months ago
ts.. censored. People who censor plain nudity feel embarrassed by their own naked reflection.
paraprog85 3 months ago 2
i wanna fuck u like an animal... i wanna fell u from the inside =) como me gusta esa rola
xtitaniooox 3 months ago
I WANNA FUCK YOU LIKE AN ANIMAL!!!!!! holy shit truer words have never been spoken. I feel like when i fuck a women im just doing it for physical need, and that need brings me closer to "god" even though i know got doesn't fucking exist. FUCK YEA TRENT YOU FUCKING ROCK!!!!!
airmanfair 3 months ago
I'm gonna have the best nightmares tonight.
Michaelinchen 3 months ago
Oh boy oh boy, the censored version.
Tianoevanova 4 months ago
eww the vid :xx
Lauchilein 4 months ago
Jared Leto's favourite love song :D
94Guilty 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Trent Reznor, you fiiilthy biiitch. <3
NookaNanooka 5 months ago
Comment removed
NookaNanooka 5 months ago
i wanna FUCK you like an animal... duuh, there, I said FUCK!
szonyix 5 months ago
Btw trent reznor aka nine inch nails is amazing. For making real music. We need more artist like him these days. Not those flaws metal, emo, screamo bands.
joey4245 5 months ago
Vevo won't allow trent to upload the uncesored version. So they told youtube to it ban it.
joey4245 5 months ago
@joey4245 Uhm, it's been uploaded for awhile.
Simba7032 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK FUCK !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Maplebeatz 6 months ago
FUCK
Maplebeatz 6 months ago
Electro Psycho funk rock!!!
RMProdux2008 6 months ago
This explains perfectly why i had cut in the past. *shriekofsoul* help me
westshideasss 6 months ago
Marilyn Manson used many elements from the "Closer" video in his music videos in "The beautiful people" and "Tourniquet"
Suntearock 6 months ago
cool song
i love trent raznor
ffm20zaheri 6 months ago
The "Scene Missing" is kind of a draw back, but it makes it look more old and vintage.
AwesomeRandification 6 months ago
Warum ist dieses Video zensiert? In den Nachrichten und manchen Dokumentationen werden viel schlimmere Sachen gezeigt. Kann ich einfach nicht nachvollziehen.
otissi2000 7 months ago 14
@otissi2000 ja verstehe ich auch nicht wieso das zensiert ist
schade eigentlich der song wurde fast nie auf mtv gespielt damals
ffm20zaheri 6 months ago
@otissi2000 kann es auch nicht nachvollziehen, aber 1994 waren die da sicherlich noch strenger.. obwohl, heute ist es auch nicht viel besser..
eddiesautoparts 6 months ago
i can totally picture George Michael singing this song at 1:00
NEOMASOCHIST 7 months ago
lick the microphone again Trent, that's so hot! xD
seriously one of the best bands EVAR!!
and honestly, Americans are weird: why censor FUCK when he's saying things like "it's your sex I can smell", huh? no sense in that.
NachtmahrDelivery 7 months ago
Seriously, I have to confirm that I'm over 18 to watch a cencored MUSIC VIDEO?! Bring back the original version!
donnarynn 7 months ago
@donnarynn VEVO has the uncensored version on Youtube. Watch it there.
TheSilverSurpher 7 months ago
There is no point in debating these idiots who are trying to compare Reznor's genius to that of "splash in the pan" hacks like Bieber and Lady Gaga. Most of them are not even out of their teens and have no idea what it's like to grow up with music that's original & groundbreaking and not cookie cutter like everything that's out now. Just ignore the trolls and banish them to their crap music and let the grown ups listen to the good shit.
mfleming98 7 months ago 2
love the gloryhole shot
sietepeaches 7 months ago
by far NIN greatest song and video
bennyfree74 7 months ago
by far, nine
bennyfree74 7 months ago
Even censored, this is a masterpiece. We don't see works like these anymore.
GokuMcDuck 7 months ago
NIN is more than music. It is a journey that trent wants you to accompany him on to places your conscience won't allow your physical body to follow....Go. You'll be glad that you did...
nooffbutton9 8 months ago
censoring should be censored.
Dhruv1223 8 months ago 24
@Dhruv1223 ask us germans :( movies and games are censoerd to smithereens and beyond recognition... just go n this site and see what is banned, or censored schnittberichtedotcom
Leaper1280 3 weeks ago
@Leaper1280
That sucks, that happens with indian TV, they censored shrek for crying out loud!!!!
Dhruv1223 3 weeks ago
I want to fuck him like an animal HNNNNG
TheLuckyLadyLuck 8 months ago
THUMBS UP if all you think about is SEXXXX after listening to this!!!!! ME SO HORNY RIGHT NOW..............
El11Lagunero 8 months ago
Feels sad that it´s censored =( But the Song is pretty good xD
oODatHumBuG1987Oo 8 months ago
He's sooo hot when he was ties up, and singing <3333
LittleDollGirl 8 months ago
Fuck yeah that bass is sick.
alienation69 8 months ago
Now this is a bass line
dockaiser 8 months ago
I miss the 90's.
MrRyukage 9 months ago
awesome :>
ez45 9 months ago
couldn t @ninofficial just uploaded it with the nudity pixelated or something?
thedude9099 9 months ago
@thedude9099 the uncensored video used to be on youtube a few years ago. sadly it was removed
MegaStevo1993 8 months ago
@MegaStevo1993 :(
thedude9099 8 months ago
This song is known as the soundtrack from the "Seven"!
natali071 9 months ago
do you see vag and tits in the unsencored version
scythespinner101 9 months ago
I'm glad that the censored one is still availible. Let's remember that this was what people saw in 94 and what lead to all the buzz. as a student of history, it is important to have access to this version, to read its social impact.
featheon 9 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The religious and sexual symbolism in this video makes it the best video I have ever seen. And the song is perfect; it wreaks of sex! The power and energy are astounding. Talk about feeling dirty after listening to it ! Mmmmmmm. Where's a man when you want one.....
GeorgiePPuddinPie 9 months ago
i LOVE this song.... 8D i am addicted to listening to it!
*rapes the replay button*
WHEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!!!!!
ZIMNINFAN1 9 months ago
*uhh* xD
I want to fu** you like an animal *singing*
love this song, a pity its censored, the vid is one of the best i know!
oODatHumBuG1987Oo 9 months ago
the things i'd do 2 trent if he were tied up in my bedroom!!! yummy;-)
belladonna666999 10 months ago
I want to...
almacmunoz 10 months ago
and this came out when....Sonic 3 and knuckles was. mind blowing, and i was growing up at that time too lol
xlted1 10 months ago
This is it. This is the creepiest f*#%ing music video I have ever seen
mythkid1208 10 months ago
@mythkid1208 i heard this song for the first time, and even that was scary. saw the video i was like WTF lol
xlted1 10 months ago
Comparing this to WHO!! WOW...ok..um NO !
MonikaKozmik 10 months ago
@theprinsessa22 definitely a mood setter >;]
overether 10 months ago
How can that song not get you in the mood? ;)
ThePrinsessa22 10 months ago
The good old times!
whitexchina 10 months ago
Lady gaga is just a wannabe freak desesperatly calling for attention. Dont ever compare that with Trenz :/
ashamosa 11 months ago 29
@ashamosa I love Trent's music maybe just as much u could do.. but u shouldn't offend other artist just cause' they re' different, excuse my bad english.
neotetsuo07 7 months ago
good song!!!! my hubby;s shit
blueeyez827 11 months ago
I like the song. Music video is fucked.
CoolGuy62093 11 months ago
in wonder why people dont still wear tight leather pants with those boots XD they look badass on trent
gangstajacy 11 months ago 8
PRETTY SICK! :D LUV IT!
acexjack 11 months ago
i wonder if its coincidence that the mic n this video looks like a b**b? prolly not
prettyprettyrawk 11 months ago
i wonder if its coincidence that the mic n this video looks like a boob? prolly not
prettyprettyrawk 11 months ago
@prettyprettyrawk no, that's why they used it. It's actually a mic for a bass drum.
blahblah110 10 months ago
that monkey seems like he needs help
chapinero017 11 months ago
@chapinero017 look at the uncensored version, the monkey is tied to a cross... That's why.
blahblah110 10 months ago
@blahblah110 this is so censored!, jesus i feel so safe now...
chapinero017 9 months ago 2
I like how NIN blatantly show the edited parts, they should have a very obnoxious noise where the lyrics have been edited though.
mitchalvin 11 months ago
classic song...never gets old for me!
desertgrrrl76 11 months ago 4
THE IS SOOOOOOOOOO A SONG TO HAVE SEX TO
stealth1111 11 months ago 3
I trust in Jesus
and I don't see any blasphemy
(crucified monkey)
barsariel 11 months ago
these are the classics. you can't even put lady gaga in the same category as NIN. I mean really? lady gaga is fucking crazy; NIN is singing about some deep shit.
clarinet166 11 months ago
He must have been really horny...wierd vid, but its cool. i like the song. and wus wit the monkey?? poor thing
Jade93095 11 months ago
hahahaha it wouldnt sound the same if he sang i want to love you like an animal. anyways the poor monkey. =( still great song =P
maidenofrohan 11 months ago
WhoEVER brought up Lady ShitFace on a NIN video should be castrated and fucked like an animal up the butt without any lubrication. STFUUUUU and go watch that shit. Let NIN fans enjoy their music without you comparing real talent to that transvestite. It's disgusting.
brunette6 11 months ago 15
@brunette6 lady gaga is the monkey :D
chapinero017 11 months ago
@brunette6 fuck yeah
Arrrrik 5 months ago
@brunette6 Well put
AwesomeRandification 5 months ago
27 People don't wanne fuck/get fucked like an animal.
DEadlykissED 1 year ago
Sounds like Lady Gaga.
Just kidding! Lighten up peeps.
robcawsey 1 year ago
thanx fot the uncensored version link
youtube sucks x)
Bookkeeper665321 1 year ago
se7en
AsianAvenger1 1 year ago
Cant wait until I'm an old fart sitting around with my grandchildren and introducing this song to them. Ah, Grandpa's oldies.
verbalweaponry0 1 year ago 4
Haha the pig in the back is goin crrraaaaazzaaayyyy!! :) love the song :D
12sweeneytoddlover 1 year ago
i like the video he is hot
4thalove1 1 year ago
I love this song but video is ... specific !?
Isabela19100 1 year ago
The uncensored version, you guys, enjoy! from Pakistan!!
watch?v=cVgBuwM9zcQ&feature=player_embedded
jahaaz1 1 year ago
Is it me or does Trent Reznor look a lot like John Cusack in this video
GIAMBIBROTHERS2 1 year ago 2
@GIAMBIBROTHERS2 or a really hotter version of severus snape.
maidenofrohan 11 months ago
@GIAMBIBROTHERS2 ive thought the same thing those two look a lot alike
James25H 7 months ago
0:21 - 0:39 , gotta be the best lyrics ever written! =P
Miss4Black 1 year ago
I don't undestand what the freick all you guys are talking about. I've been DYING to look for the censored version. YOU PEOPLE WASTE UR TIME ON THIS SEGMENT!! As for the song....LOVE IT AND ALWAYS WILL!! ;D
CrazyMizfan11 1 year ago
WOW!! They dont want them to say 'Fuck'?? Seriously, whats the big fucking deal?? Saying fuck never hurt anyone!! FUCK FUCKITY FUCK FUCK!!!
hdawg74 1 year ago 34
@hdawg74 It''s ridiculous
notmygeneration 1 year ago
THIS TUNE IS FUCKIN TRIBAL ! BLUNT AN TO THE POINT !!!!!
kelirob449 1 year ago
wow this video this song....awesome! ^.^
xXmiss0coco 1 year ago
I know the uncensored is impossible to find cuz of all the pussies who block it
LosAngelesGuy22 1 year ago 2
arre the missing censored scenes have sex stuff or blood and guts?
LPsCrazyFan99 1 year ago
@LPsCrazyFan99 naked chicks, anti religious images, the word fuck
yyyuuuguppy 1 year ago
geiil !!!
Azwo2010 1 year ago
just <3
stuffdesign 1 year ago
<3
stuffdesign 1 year ago
<3
stuffdesign 1 year ago
John McCain 3:31?
TOGA4808 1 year ago
god i love trent reznor.....musical genius.....he can fuck me like an animal any time.....get closer to me!!!
rainmaker419 1 year ago 3
I am sick of seeing Lady Gaga's name on every video I watch. So, what, if I go watch a John Mellencamp or Tool video her name will be on there too? WTF people? At least get the genre right.
pixierose88 1 year ago
GUESS WHAT I FOUND?? THE UNCENSORED VIDEO AND NOT ONLY THE UNCENSORED TRACK. ITS TITLE IS "NIN - CLOSER - The Full Length , Album version Extended video remix". I TRIED POSTING THE LINK HERE BUT COULDN'T.
nourif93 1 year ago
Why is everyone comparing Trent Reznor to Lady Gaga?! @samuelellmer you are fuckin stupid.Ther music genres are different.Trent is Industrial rock(with some electronica,dark ambient,& little bit of syntpop which in some songs like "Only").Lady Gaga is pop and dance(with some...will thats it).*Continue to my next comment*
SamDakota86 1 year ago 48
@SamDakota86 Trent has been sucessful in NIN,has made musical scores for the video game Quake and also The Social Network,has been in a music video called "I'm Afraid of Americans" with his music influence David Bowie(which Lady Gaga is an influence to & would probably dream of but never will),helped Marilyn Manson become famous,him,his wife,& Atticus Ross are makng music together in a band called... *continue to my next comment*
SamDakota86 1 year ago 16
@SamDakota86 *continued* called How to Destroy Angels,and has helped made the music genre Industrial more than it is.And don't start me with her winnings in that VMA's shit, those awards mean nothing compared to the grammys.having your album selling the most to become #1 on the Billboard dosn't make you good.The speech that she made in that gay rights ally seems to be the only thing good from her I guess.
SamDakota86 1 year ago 8
@SamDakota86 You're the fucking idiot. At what point did I mention ANYTHING about awards? This was never about awards you dickshit moron. The very fact that's all you have to back up your argument just go to show how pathetic and meaningless you are to this entire debate. Why don't you just go back to the Hurt video and comment about how it's so much better than Cash's cover yeah?
SamuelEllmer 1 year ago
@SamDakota86 True, but she does attempt to push the limit stylistically must like many Industrial artists did in the nineties. Her videos have been fairly controversial for a pop/dance artist. If I were to compare her to an industrial artist though, it would probably be Marilyn Manson.
dreadguy14 1 year ago
@SamDakota86 This was only ever about the two artists being controversial. You're directing this argument towards me about their different genres, and then explaining what they sound like. What.the.fuck.retard? I listen to both artists, you don't need to explain to me how they sound. In fact what argument are you EVEN making??
Read over your comments, and realise how absolutely irrelevant and mediocre they are in comparison to mine.
SamuelEllmer 1 year ago
@SamuelEllmer I was explaining my comments to everyone you fuckass, not just you!Looks like you only read some of my comments,and awards isn't the only thing I said,I also said about Trent's acomplishments and his legacy.And I don't see whats so bad about NIN's cover being better than the original.Go listen to every NIN album.When you hear The Fragile songs do you think of Lady Caca(maybe for me Starfuckers Inc. is the only song for me that represents her and the rest of the pop artists for me.)
SamDakota86 1 year ago 4
@SamDakota86 My worst mistake evidently was saying that I enjoy listening to both NIN and Lady Gaga, because apparently that's call for every NIN fan to jump on the 'THEY HATE DIFFERENT MUSIC THAN ME FUCK THEM' emo non-comformist bandwagon. I also enjoy listening to How to Destroy Angels and The Beatles. Anyone got anything to say about THAT?
SamuelEllmer 1 year ago
@SamuelEllmer And if you want to talk about controversial,look at the music videos on NIN's Broken album,(if you heard of it) like Happiness in Slavery and Gave Up and rest of them their was suppost to be a VHS/DVDS for the MV's,but the videos were so violent that it wasn't even released.Probably so violent that it makes Alejandro and Telophone look like kids movies.tSearch "Lady Gaga Copies / EXPOSED/Grammys 2010" on Youtube. Shows she isn't that much original as some people say.
SamDakota86 1 year ago
@SamDakota86 I still don't understand why you had to specifically mention and link me in your post. Calling me stupid for saying I respect both artists?! No, I don't think of Lady Gaga when I listen to ANYTHING of NIN's. Because they're completely fucking different! My VERY FIRST AND ORIGINAL comment on this video was about Gaga and Trent having controversial tendencies and how it's effected their popularity because of what route they took their controversy down.
SamuelEllmer 1 year ago
@SamDakota86
They both have a penis.. so aparently theyre alike.
JulietteNoel0 11 months ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
It seems the only people that want to reply to any of my comments on this video (which aren't related, but I never intended it to get like this) are strictly all NIN love and no Gaga love. It's fine to have that opinion, but honestly, you don't need to start an argument with someone who's NEUTRAL on both sides. I respect both artists for their MUSIC. So go leave your close-minded ignorant selves elsewhere, and not in my inbox T.T
SamuelEllmer 1 year ago
@SamuelEllmer Hey, I get what you mean. I'm sort of in the middle here (perhaps leaning slightly more towards Gaga) I don't consider either to be high art or godly. This video isn't that remarkable to be honest - I've seen the uncut version too. An Aleksandr Rodchenko lookalike and a few lazy nods to Man Ray does not make something high art. It seems elevated way beyond what it is - a music video. I love Trent but he doesn't even begin to touch the genius of the two artists I've mentioned.
fionamac23 1 year ago
@SamuelEllmer Now with Gaga people underestimate her; they belittle her but I think she's going to have the last laugh. She has only just released one Album and an EP! The Fame was a pretty solid pop record with darker undercurrents.Have you heard the new remix, Scheiße? (yeah, the title made me laugh...)
I also detect a hint of Misogyny here on the comments for this video in regards to Gaga. A woman is a talentless whore for being influenced by other artists... all righty.
fionamac23 1 year ago
If you want the uncensored song (not video,alas)try typng in 'Sherlock'fromthe BBC'modern update;someone (sorry, forget the name) did a great fan vid featuring the hate/hate thing on between Sherlock and Jim(I.E. Sherlock being Holmes;Jimbeing Moriarty,of course) using this song. Youalsomight enjoy checking out 'Sherlovk meets Mean Girls' ... it's too snarky for words!
katoklzmk 1 year ago
Oh shit Trent fuck me like an animal!!!!!!!!
Afraid0fGhosts 1 year ago
i wanna have sex to this song!
nirvanafan1226 1 year ago 2
I used a search engine, typed in Closer Nine Inch Nails Uncensored video and found it on sevenload's site.
kentuckywyldkat 1 year ago
He's so obviously showing everyone the Illumnati:
1. All Seeing eye clock with pyramid
2. Old Men in suits (Elite Bankers)
3. Ram's Head (Sign of Satan)
4. Reptiles (Reptilian aliens)
5. little girl (Pedophilia)
6. sacrifice of the heart....
pretty simple in my opinion...too many to list..
NewYorker991 1 year ago
@NewYorker991 "the illuminati" is merely a dead cult that we & media have raped & revived into a universal marketing tool. theres nothing to be afraid of.
JKenn 1 year ago
@JKenn I don't agree, but I hope you're right
;)
Shmees 1 year ago
@JKenn
hope you're right too... Great video nonetheless...
NewYorker991 1 year ago
I wanna fuck Trent like an animal;)
1SlaytanicFreak 1 year ago
lady gaga es un puta de los gays, no tiene realmente ningun talento musical no deberian admirala, no se compara con el maesto trent reznor es una ofensa que los comparen
miembrocolectivo01 1 year ago
este video musical es el mejor que he visto mark romanek es un maetro del video y trent de la musica industrial psicotica
vayanse a la mierda gringos pero viva trent
miembrocolectivo01 1 year ago
I wanna fuck you like an animal
one of my favourite songs -wet-
chiaP3 1 year ago
Ok....i'm doing everyone a favor.....there IS a UNCENSORED version here on youtube....it's by Nintend00, and it's running time is 7:11...now stop whining and see it.....thx.....
X1
xlted1 1 year ago
I wanna fuck u 2, Mr. Reznor!!!
TheBren70 1 year ago
Lol nine inch heels more like lol amazing song the instrumental version is great!
TeebaFeelinRandom 1 year ago
ami the only one who notices that the metronome is the sign of the illuminati
okamirao 1 year ago
The Director of this vid sure had been looking at Joel-Peter Witkin's photo's.
Bow1elow 1 year ago
Why the fuck would they make a censored version of Closer???
AnHeroDesu 1 year ago
omfg
soooooooooooooooo yummy
best song in the world of sex and makeout :3 nin, you got yourself a complete win :D
OceanBlueLoveSomeday 1 year ago
@OceanBlueLoveSomeday fuck yeah me and my girlfriend did it to this song
Thegangsterzboyy98 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
is the uncut video on youtube still
thehegarty87 1 year ago
@ninofficial they do allow the uncensored version last time i checked.....take a look around.....
xlted1 1 year ago
Thank god for censorship, a messed up masterpiece.
MeteoraCyst 1 year ago
@MeteoraCyst yes i agree to that......
xlted1 1 year ago
freaking scary.........all i can say about the video....the song is awesome.......scary good, that is.....
xlted1 1 year ago
Would like to see them live,finally- great Band! Fuckin censure!
Curanderasworld 1 year ago
This was the real first saw movie
kvega2016 1 year ago 2
-Scene Missing- lol
I could watch 1:24 all day
MrPhenom444 1 year ago
3:48
sweetagdolls 1 year ago
fuckin' censure
tedogio 1 year ago
By far! One of my top ten favorite songs of all time! And tha means a lot' I also like the extended version too.
Punishr84