The Einstein quote you opened with is intriguing to me. Space and time are only modes by which we think and not actual conditions in which we live. It's clear from your animations and discussions that all dimensions are either spatial or temporal. This leaves me thinking that ALL dimensions are simply something we think about, not what actually exists.
Am I off base here? I feel you sort of alluded to this in your "jumping jesus" video also.
Just to clarify things for those who don't bother to click the links -- the 5th dimensional camera is a purely FICTIONAL ART PROJECT, and the letter he's reading out was written by an Art School grad and a self-taught web developer.
Even if they were in contact with quantum information scientists, extra dimensions do not appear in ANY quantum physics.
Their project is fun and creative, but has no basis in any sort of actual science or physics. Using this for "proof" of his ideas is just sad.
@kllrbny As I said, Oxford's Dr. Simon Benjamin is associated with the QIP IRC, google that. The Quantum Information Processing Interdisciplinary Research Project is a collaboration between 12 major universities including Oxford, and Industrial Partners such as HP and Toshiba. Is the camera a speculative presentation based upon what might be possible? Of course, I make no other claims. But the underlying theory presented in his video is directly related to my description of the fifth dimension.
@10thdim Whatever description you have is bullshit until you can experimentally prove that your interpretation makes more sense than other explanations. If you say it JUST an interpretation, and cannot be proved. it is not science. By definition, a theory should be able to predict, and be verified. If not, however beautifully your interpretation/theory is, it is just a fantasy. I think it is just sad to mislead future young, potential physicists.
@kllrbny I'm a physics student, This series of videos is not right. You guys can be amazed by the model he made up. But don't fall for it as if it is really what the world is like. If you truly want to learn something about these subjects, learn it from physicists, not someone on youtube. If you (10thdim) want to argue with me, why don't you go publish your idea in nature or something? Please don't go around and fool people.
@jwliang09 Wow, congratulations, you're telling us you know more than the scientists from Oxford who gave this idea of "fifth dimension as probability space" their support. You must be very smart if you know more than these people from Oxford!
@socratesrock I never claimed I know more than they do. Just show me the evidence, scientific experimental proof that is repeatable and predictable. That is science by definition. Until (10thdim) does that, it will not be accepted by mainstream scientists. If he is right, why doesnt he try to publish this crap? Oh wait, it wont be able to go through peer review journals. Okay, publish it in fantasy land, like in creative writing section .
you are saying that there are multiple universes, and each universe have all the dimensions wich conform the reality of that universe, and all those dimensions doesn't let a person to go out of its space, and the time defines all of the universes and dimensions?????
The display of this proposed/fictional 5-D camera reminds me a lot of the large amount of screens behind the Architect in The Matrix Reloaded. On those screens he could monitor each and every possible outcome for Neo's responses to his questions, and each screen had hundreds of smaller screens in its background. Very interesting stuff, thanks again Rob.
As our capabilities to improve our own situation towards a goal of perfection increases, our need for higher intellectual stimulation also increases. Which, to me, seems like we are creating our own problems. Right now this is all very interesting, but I could easliy see our species ultimatley choosing De-Evolution, in an attempt to find a FINAL END, that may not actually exist. This attempt may be what creates our universe in the first place. All is One
For all the tremendous good this could some day bring about...there is also that much potential "bad" out there that could create unforseeable problems.
I am a subscriber to the idea that "good" and "bad" cannot exist without each other, and that as you chase one, the other will interfere with the your ability to have ALL of one without the other in permanance over all dimensions.
Simplicity is equal to Complexity in this way, because the results are likely to be the same "chasing a dream."
Ok, these videos are boring. Why are there no examples of what these dimensions might look like? If it's because we may not be able to perceive them, then ok, but at least try to show it.
When was this video made? It's already been done in a better way by watchin "the matrix 3" where Neo meets the Architect. His choices - 5th dimensional states are all played on mini screens around the room, showing his choices before he's made them.
Is this not the 5th dimension, many states (same frames with differing states) of the 4th dimension at once in one moment in time?
If looking at the clip I mentioned you'll notice that your shown, 3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th dimensional views / states.
Rob, how can you say you don't count time as a dimension when the 4th supposedly is the timeline from our past to present and future? What is the 4th dimension then, if not time? That's what i remember from yourr original videos explaining the dimensions. Thanks.
@An1MuS I say time is a direction, not a dimension. In my original animation I say that from our perspective its better to refer to the 4th as duration, this perspective makes it easier for us to acknowledge that for 3D creatures there are two directions in the 4th dimensions, time and anti-time. But if we were 2D creatures we would say that duration was in the 3rd dimension, and so on. This is in a number of my vlogs including What's Around the Corner:
@An1MuS Interesting that Dr. Timothy Leary considered the fourth (of eight) neurobiological circuits to be the social-sexual circuit which is basically memes and genes.
I find it strange that the Copenhagen interpretation is above the Many-Worlds interpretation. I personally think that the Many-Worlds interpretation is much more plausible.
That camera doesn't need several dozen funky looking lenses, it just needs one conventional lens.
Since the camera also exists within the other realities, all the camera has to do is somehow send data to the alternate versions of itself, which ought to give you a lot more options than limiting yourself to trying to detect photons from another reality.
Hell, it doesn't need a lens at all. Plug it into your computer and you have a bridge to the internets of other realities, webcams and all.
Imagine, Hamachi, multidimensional edition. Want to do some LAN gaming, but have neither the space nor the friends to do it? No problem! Just create a virtual LAN with the versions of yourself from nearby universes, who are (probably) just as eager to play whatever games you like anyway. Their favorite game doesn't exist in your universe? No problem! We also include a convenient file transfer utility, which is totally legal since you technically purchased the game (just not in this universe.)
Although I suppose it would only be a short time until publishers start claiming lost revenue from potential customers from other universes.
"There are an infinite number of Earths out there, each with millions of potential customers that will no longer buy our product since they can simply download it from alternate versions of themselves. As such, we feel we have the right to sue Hamachi for all our lost potential revenue, for the grand total of ∞USD."
Oh man, I read the tenth dimension book in Middle School... Didn't realize there was a whole blog of vids dedicated to this. I've got a LOT of catching up to do.
I just want to be sure does the fifth dimension contain directions including one's that we cannot perceive yet does exist? or is it like is it directions or other stuff like probabilities, simply I am asking is higher dimensions, higher versions of spacial directions?
@deanmullen10 When physicists talk about extra dimensions they are saying that they're all spatial, or some prefer to say "space-like". This project says that all of the extra dimensions are spatial, and that includes the fourth. Search for "Time is a Direction" or "Aren't There Really 11 Dimensions" for more about this concept.
the difference between that scene in matrix is that the movie insinuate that scenes already happened in the past, and neo is just a bug that happens once in a while.
if was a fifth dimension cam, all that neos was talking with the architect at the same time.
Wait so David Deutsch stole your idea? LOL Unless I am understanding this incorrectly. Also the 5th dim camera, is basically a quantum computer, but that type of computing has been around for some time now. Using 3 qubits, in a pattern of 8 think.
It struck me this morning that consciousness holds a state of self immortality, assuming the many worlds interpretation is correct.
Seeing as consciousness can never perceive its own lack of existence, it will always follow along a universe in which it has not stopped existing.
I am not sure if this is to be taken as a paradox in the many worlds interpretation or if it is just a property of it. Either way it is quite a mind boggling possibility.
Congrats! Your "Imagining the Tenth Dimension" video came out when i was in HS and it persuaded me to go into Physics. Now I am just a course or two shy of my Bachelor of Science in Physics. It is great to see how far you have come, and maybe one day soon these theories will be proven. Best of luck in the future and im excited to see how much these ideas will grow.
...hmmm this almost makes me feel as if time is a shadow of the dimension above.
sm0ckr 5 months ago
@sm0ckr hmm ment the "looking around the corner" vid that led me here.
sm0ckr 5 months ago
The Einstein quote you opened with is intriguing to me. Space and time are only modes by which we think and not actual conditions in which we live. It's clear from your animations and discussions that all dimensions are either spatial or temporal. This leaves me thinking that ALL dimensions are simply something we think about, not what actually exists.
Am I off base here? I feel you sort of alluded to this in your "jumping jesus" video also.
christiantjr 6 months ago
Just to clarify things for those who don't bother to click the links -- the 5th dimensional camera is a purely FICTIONAL ART PROJECT, and the letter he's reading out was written by an Art School grad and a self-taught web developer.
Even if they were in contact with quantum information scientists, extra dimensions do not appear in ANY quantum physics.
Their project is fun and creative, but has no basis in any sort of actual science or physics. Using this for "proof" of his ideas is just sad.
kllrbny 1 year ago
@kllrbny As I said, Oxford's Dr. Simon Benjamin is associated with the QIP IRC, google that. The Quantum Information Processing Interdisciplinary Research Project is a collaboration between 12 major universities including Oxford, and Industrial Partners such as HP and Toshiba. Is the camera a speculative presentation based upon what might be possible? Of course, I make no other claims. But the underlying theory presented in his video is directly related to my description of the fifth dimension.
10thdim 1 year ago 4
@10thdim Whatever description you have is bullshit until you can experimentally prove that your interpretation makes more sense than other explanations. If you say it JUST an interpretation, and cannot be proved. it is not science. By definition, a theory should be able to predict, and be verified. If not, however beautifully your interpretation/theory is, it is just a fantasy. I think it is just sad to mislead future young, potential physicists.
jwliang09 3 months ago
@kllrbny I'm a physics student, This series of videos is not right. You guys can be amazed by the model he made up. But don't fall for it as if it is really what the world is like. If you truly want to learn something about these subjects, learn it from physicists, not someone on youtube. If you (10thdim) want to argue with me, why don't you go publish your idea in nature or something? Please don't go around and fool people.
jwliang09 5 months ago
@jwliang09 Wow, congratulations, you're telling us you know more than the scientists from Oxford who gave this idea of "fifth dimension as probability space" their support. You must be very smart if you know more than these people from Oxford!
socratesrock 5 months ago
@socratesrock I never claimed I know more than they do. Just show me the evidence, scientific experimental proof that is repeatable and predictable. That is science by definition. Until (10thdim) does that, it will not be accepted by mainstream scientists. If he is right, why doesnt he try to publish this crap? Oh wait, it wont be able to go through peer review journals. Okay, publish it in fantasy land, like in creative writing section .
jwliang09 3 months ago
@jwliang09 ...yes of course, YOU know everything. (Ecce Homo!) Except for keeping an open mind it seems.
sm0ckr 5 months ago
the only way any human could perceive another possibility is in slumber. our stance is limited, after all we're only 3-d's.
cookieDaXapper 1 year ago
watch?v=4s-UWBzZiG0
AsPinkAsAPanther 1 year ago
so...
you are saying that there are multiple universes, and each universe have all the dimensions wich conform the reality of that universe, and all those dimensions doesn't let a person to go out of its space, and the time defines all of the universes and dimensions?????
someone clear my question
neggflash 1 year ago
The display of this proposed/fictional 5-D camera reminds me a lot of the large amount of screens behind the Architect in The Matrix Reloaded. On those screens he could monitor each and every possible outcome for Neo's responses to his questions, and each screen had hundreds of smaller screens in its background. Very interesting stuff, thanks again Rob.
Gokiza 1 year ago
man i would like to see this guy rllly rllyl pissed it would be funny
TotalGameMaster 1 year ago
Addition to my previous comment:
As our capabilities to improve our own situation towards a goal of perfection increases, our need for higher intellectual stimulation also increases. Which, to me, seems like we are creating our own problems. Right now this is all very interesting, but I could easliy see our species ultimatley choosing De-Evolution, in an attempt to find a FINAL END, that may not actually exist. This attempt may be what creates our universe in the first place. All is One
nomorejournos 1 year ago
For all the tremendous good this could some day bring about...there is also that much potential "bad" out there that could create unforseeable problems.
I am a subscriber to the idea that "good" and "bad" cannot exist without each other, and that as you chase one, the other will interfere with the your ability to have ALL of one without the other in permanance over all dimensions.
Simplicity is equal to Complexity in this way, because the results are likely to be the same "chasing a dream."
nomorejournos 1 year ago
ow many bumbaclot dimensions exist der. mi 'ed feel swell wid all dis raasclat
from Prof Herbert
Quantum Electrodynamics Dept, Portland University, Jamaica
choongification 1 year ago
Ok, these videos are boring. Why are there no examples of what these dimensions might look like? If it's because we may not be able to perceive them, then ok, but at least try to show it.
JaredRandomness 1 year ago
When was this video made? It's already been done in a better way by watchin "the matrix 3" where Neo meets the Architect. His choices - 5th dimensional states are all played on mini screens around the room, showing his choices before he's made them.
Is this not the 5th dimension, many states (same frames with differing states) of the 4th dimension at once in one moment in time?
If looking at the clip I mentioned you'll notice that your shown, 3rd, 4th, 5th and 6th dimensional views / states.
snazzykazzywazzy 1 year ago
Rob, how can you say you don't count time as a dimension when the 4th supposedly is the timeline from our past to present and future? What is the 4th dimension then, if not time? That's what i remember from yourr original videos explaining the dimensions. Thanks.
An1MuS 1 year ago
@An1MuS I say time is a direction, not a dimension. In my original animation I say that from our perspective its better to refer to the 4th as duration, this perspective makes it easier for us to acknowledge that for 3D creatures there are two directions in the 4th dimensions, time and anti-time. But if we were 2D creatures we would say that duration was in the 3rd dimension, and so on. This is in a number of my vlogs including What's Around the Corner:
watch?v=1K_MgAfeZkk
Thanks!
Rob
10thdim 1 year ago
@An1MuS Interesting that Dr. Timothy Leary considered the fourth (of eight) neurobiological circuits to be the social-sexual circuit which is basically memes and genes.
synchromorph 7 months ago
Is their experiment accepted by the scientific community? I mean, are they sure there are no errors or bad results?
FearThisChannel 1 year ago
I find it strange that the Copenhagen interpretation is above the Many-Worlds interpretation. I personally think that the Many-Worlds interpretation is much more plausible.
FearThisChannel 1 year ago
This is excellent! Loved it! Learning a bit more every day.
crescentrose 1 year ago
That camera doesn't need several dozen funky looking lenses, it just needs one conventional lens.
Since the camera also exists within the other realities, all the camera has to do is somehow send data to the alternate versions of itself, which ought to give you a lot more options than limiting yourself to trying to detect photons from another reality.
Hell, it doesn't need a lens at all. Plug it into your computer and you have a bridge to the internets of other realities, webcams and all.
smariot 1 year ago
Imagine, Hamachi, multidimensional edition. Want to do some LAN gaming, but have neither the space nor the friends to do it? No problem! Just create a virtual LAN with the versions of yourself from nearby universes, who are (probably) just as eager to play whatever games you like anyway. Their favorite game doesn't exist in your universe? No problem! We also include a convenient file transfer utility, which is totally legal since you technically purchased the game (just not in this universe.)
smariot 1 year ago
Although I suppose it would only be a short time until publishers start claiming lost revenue from potential customers from other universes.
"There are an infinite number of Earths out there, each with millions of potential customers that will no longer buy our product since they can simply download it from alternate versions of themselves. As such, we feel we have the right to sue Hamachi for all our lost potential revenue, for the grand total of ∞USD."
smariot 1 year ago
Oh man, I read the tenth dimension book in Middle School... Didn't realize there was a whole blog of vids dedicated to this. I've got a LOT of catching up to do.
accordingleaf 1 year ago
I just want to be sure does the fifth dimension contain directions including one's that we cannot perceive yet does exist? or is it like is it directions or other stuff like probabilities, simply I am asking is higher dimensions, higher versions of spacial directions?
deanmullen10 1 year ago
@deanmullen10 When physicists talk about extra dimensions they are saying that they're all spatial, or some prefer to say "space-like". This project says that all of the extra dimensions are spatial, and that includes the fourth. Search for "Time is a Direction" or "Aren't There Really 11 Dimensions" for more about this concept.
Thanks!
Rob
10thdim 1 year ago
gnarly cool! interesting stuff!
PhilosopherFresh 1 year ago
Very interesting concept. Reminds me of the scene with The Architect from the last Maxtrix movie.
So are physicists in general thinking that the additional dimensions are not spacial but probability based?
wado1942 1 year ago
@wado1942
the difference between that scene in matrix is that the movie insinuate that scenes already happened in the past, and neo is just a bug that happens once in a while.
if was a fifth dimension cam, all that neos was talking with the architect at the same time.
shit!... in certain way that makes sense too! O_o
ManelRuivo 1 year ago
Brilliant
Kazzbaah 1 year ago
awesome the 5th dim camera's very interestn i wanna learn more
joneschri6 1 year ago
lol you know at the END where all WRONG !!!
nice video
grtzz
poerik 1 year ago
It's great to see you back, Rob.
burchified 1 year ago
Wait so David Deutsch stole your idea? LOL Unless I am understanding this incorrectly. Also the 5th dim camera, is basically a quantum computer, but that type of computing has been around for some time now. Using 3 qubits, in a pattern of 8 think.
marcuelcajon 1 year ago
So this 5th dimensional camera is basicaly nothing?
kaczan3 1 year ago
It struck me this morning that consciousness holds a state of self immortality, assuming the many worlds interpretation is correct.
Seeing as consciousness can never perceive its own lack of existence, it will always follow along a universe in which it has not stopped existing.
I am not sure if this is to be taken as a paradox in the many worlds interpretation or if it is just a property of it. Either way it is quite a mind boggling possibility.
Rob has this thought ever occurred to you?
AntiThe1stGuy 1 year ago
@AntiThe1stGuy On Wikipedia, look at the article Quantum_suicide_and_immortality
smariot 1 year ago
@smariot Thanks. That is exactly what my thoughts were, I didn't realize that it was a well established concept already.
AntiThe1stGuy 1 year ago
allways sheding knolage on my man
helpearthbounding 1 year ago
Cool Thing!
BeAnAgeLabs 1 year ago
Congrats! Your "Imagining the Tenth Dimension" video came out when i was in HS and it persuaded me to go into Physics. Now I am just a course or two shy of my Bachelor of Science in Physics. It is great to see how far you have come, and maybe one day soon these theories will be proven. Best of luck in the future and im excited to see how much these ideas will grow.
cougar1515 1 year ago 2
Looks very cool!
TheToxicVoid 1 year ago
Congratulations! Looking forward to seeing "Entangled Neurons"; sound interesting. :)
yousefamar 1 year ago
@yousefamar Thanks! I've provided the link to the text version of Entangled Neurons in the description box below the video here.
10thdim 1 year ago