Added: 2 years ago
From: ColinSchachat
Views: 354,647
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (118)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • this is a joke,the first one is so funny

  • PERFECTION!!!!!!!!!!!

  • GRANDISSIMI...

    BRAVI.

  • The first singer 's Italian was combination of Hebrew. This is the most hilarious singing.

  • וואו איזה יופי

  • can u believe that this ugly helfgot didn't let Cantor Adler perform anywhere, he blocked him out all the way for many years, like he still do to many other great ones this days, what a shame, you belong in hell for taking away from others food on the table....

  • Great voices, but the Italian is a bit awkward.

  • Adler is a man of G-d.

  • ahahah he sings with soul !!! ^ ^

  • CHAZAK !!!! AM ISRAEL CHAI !!!!

  • This is just fabulous! Share with the whole world!

  • Wow! What a delightful surprise to find in an email!

  • So beautiful!

  • Marvelous, Italian opera singer and two Jewish Cantors what more can one asked for.. They all need to go on tour and sing both italian opera and jewish religious songs. That would knock the socks off everyone

  • @jackma152 which one is the italian opera singer?

  • Maravilhoso!

    

  • Bellissimo - magnifico.

  • Jews are the best in everything.

  • Beautiful

  • Magnifique ! Beautiful ! נפלא

  • timing in the end bit was all over the place but helfgoot still got most poweful voice

  • Very nice -- just makes you want to smile. Thanks.

  • awesome, the jews are good at everything!

  • Sign these Gentlemen up with a performance contract PRONTO!

    ENJOY, ENJOY, ENJOY!!!

    Beautifully rich voices singing "O Sole Mio"

    Bravos, Bravos, Bravos!!!

    I have tears in my eyes.

    Superbly performed!!!

  • Wonderful!

  • Gorgeous voices.

  • Qué hermoso, me encantó!!! SHALOM

  • vacaga

  • simply beautiful!

  • These guys are fabulous chazzanim, however we should leave this music to the Paverotti's of the world.

  • Everyone appreciates a classic and this is a favorite of many. These men are using their beautiful God-given voices. They should share it for others to enjoy.

  • What other voices are their but god given voices? did they have a choice to sing with store bought voices? I don't understand? it seems everone is flipped out because a Jewish man is singing in Italian, this is good but amazing no.

  • this is so funny to watch and listen to them. But at the same time they are interesting too considering their age.

  • They really sing their kippurs off.

  • Magnifique..... Mazeltov

  • Rabbis were singing before there was a Rome let alone an Italy so be quiet please. Read the Bible

  • Of course Rabbis and many others have been singing for thousands of years. I'm saying that there's a style of classic Italian singing that is suited to this kind of music, and it's not something that they have demonstrate in this video. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, so do not be rude and tell me to be quiet. This is not a religious issue, it's about vocal style.

  • I tend to agree with the guy who slammed you for giving such an opinion-ATED critique using words like "interpreters of Neopolitan songs". If you indeed have that view then at least offer a few of your more enlightened viewpoint as to spefically how and why you would say such a thing. What do YOU know about it?

    When you make negative unsupported criticism, is it any wonder you engender the enmity of the majority of us who can appreciate the vocal excellence. You come off a fraud, madam.

  • Sir, these gentlemen have lovely voices, and I salute them for their performance. I stand by what I said though. I'm sure even they would agree that their forte is not Italian singing. They have every right to sing the repertoire, and I wish them well.

  • The three of them have nice voices, but let's be real: They do not have the Italian style. Great interpreters of Neopolitan songs they are not!

  • a good part of the Italian population was originally Jewish, so many were forced to convert to Roman Catholic, or be executed...especially in Sicily when it was under the rule of Spain....the Kingdom of the Two Siclies. There has always been a simlarity between Italian and Jews ...expecially in America.  Rome has the oldest Jewish population in Europe !

  • brilliant!!!!! gave me chills

  • Bravo! What incredible voices!

  • Brlliant. Thank you for sharing and demonstrating that music really is the language that knows no boundaries.

  • Why are still there in the world stupid people who things harassment is cool? When are they going to evolve as human beings?

  • very  nice....bravo

  • Bellissimo thank you yeees we can sing too!!! Hava

  • Where is this taking place? What was the original concert? Sounds excellent!

  • Bravo! I love it!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • we Jews can sing!

  • I bet these synagogues are sold out on the High Holy Days!

  • GREAT!!!!!

  • Exceptional Trio

  • Marvllous! Bravo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • GO JUICE!!!

  • What an amazing surprise. Great voices. The Three Tenors better move over. The piano being out of tune is a marvelous touch of authenticity.

  • Genial la voz de los rabinos

  • Espectacular!!!!!

  • santa exists! and sings divine! yeah!

  • BELLESSIMO!!!!MOLTO BENE

  • BRAVO!!!

    BRAVO!!!!!!!

  • lovely and good to see confirmation that being religious does not preclude appreciation of and participation in secular culture. Please retain this for more people to appreciate.

  • Excellent! Very impressed! Bravo!

  • Marvellous. trema Luciano!

  • i wish i could sing like that

    Excellent

  • Love this. As beautiful as it gets. Please keep it available.

  • Incredibly beautiful! Breathtaking!

    Thank you for posting it.

  • איזה ביצועים נפלא!

  • Bravo !

  • Bravo!!!!! Enjoyed this very much!!!

  • Guuuauu!! el ultimo en cantar tiene una hermosa voz, blian a ra!!!!!!!

  • Oy vey!

    This is just great. Que bella cosa.

  • The first tenor messed up the lyrics...lol...

  • my son is a professional opera singer, these are voices to be apprediated! thank you so much for sharing!

  • j'étais au concert c'était superbe !! une vraie merveille

  • Lovely....I wonder what it's like to be able to sing like that (or even at all; I cannot even carry a melody in a pail, as I believe the saying goes!). But I sure can appreciate it. Really makes your heart soar, doesn't it?

  • Quite often non Jews who are anti Jewish post Bigoted remarks about goys to make us look Bigoted, an old trick by nasty people who are filled with hate. I suggest you also listen to Josef Schmidt the J

  • מכל הבחינות נהדר כל הכבוד לכם... נהדרים תמשיכו .....

  • Close your eyes, you're listing to 3 men of serious "voice". Imagine you are at a concert of the 3 Tenors! Magnificant!

  • Sensacionales,, excelentes, maravillosos,,

  • sono scadenti a dir poco

  • Esto no lo superan ni los tres tenores españoles. Ahi queda éso. MAGNIFICO ¡¡¡

  • Qué sorprésa más agradáble¡¡ qué bien cantan ¡¡ me ha hecho mucha ilusión que me enviéis éste video¡¡ jajaja TODÁ RABA SHALÓM ISRAEL. AM ISRAEL JAI ¡¡

  • 'goyishe' and 'yiddish', Jewish or not, does not matter, great stuff!!!!!!!!!!!!1

  • до чего трогательно!!!

  • this is the opposite of a disgrace- a tribute to a great song- by great musician not just chazzanim. Btw, so much of great "Jewish" melody is adapted from so-called 'goyishe' melody anyway.

    Also, you make a huge mistake and make life small when you divide it between 'goyishe' and 'yiddish'. How silly!! Beautiful muisc (art, literature, theatre etc.) belongs to the realm of G-d. Jewish Talibanism is disgraceful, not singing beautiful melody whose origin is not 'jewish'.

  • why don't you get out of the 18th century that you seem to be stuck in - if a tzadik like Meir Helfgott can sing O Sole Mio, who in the world are you to say he shouldn't because it's goyish. Thank G'd most people today have more brains and are more modern than you. Grow up!

  • הסוף לנשמה אלוהית כל החזנות נשאר לנהנתנות נטו

  • Love it!

  • Shalom ! Please see this ! !! !:

    אנא המתן הזה ! שלום

    יהודית ילדה מתאסלמים

    watch?v=ZZ45jWmyPBo

  • They're excellent.

  • BRAVO!!..HAZAK !!

  • Wow, incredible interpretation!!

  • Absolutely beautiful version of a beautiful song!!!

  • Maghetto , maybe you have missed but thos are jews...not palestinians....

    idiot....

  • fantastic.......

  • פ נ ט ס טי

    ב ר א ב ו בראבו ב ר א בו

    נ ה ד ר

  • Bravo! Bravisimo!

  • Wow! Impressive stuff.

  • Wonderful!

  • Wow... very good performance

  • Marvelous! Toda Raba!

    Shavua tov!

  • very nice

  • Beatiful, Bravo. Viva Italy and Israel!

  • Grazie , Toda Rava, Gracias ve shalom le kulam

  • Beautiful!

  • This is a nice thank you to the Italian people for their friendship to Israel

  • A great new take on an old number.

    Gerald Leissner

  • The guy on the left is good!

Loading...
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more