Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (199)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I prefer Alexandra's version. It's more "powerfull" :)

  • your voice chills me to the bone

  • Kippe(n)vel!

  • BON JOVI the best version of Hallelujah

  • ma ke è tedesco??

  • Hallelujah! THE BEST ON INTERNET

  • haha nog steeds geweldig!!

  • gotta love this judge at 05:29 - 05:31!! :D all stiff and serious - losing it - all stiff an serious! XD lol

  • Alexandra is way better !

  • @braxho Alexandra Burke ?....

  • @applezafrina yea her ... 

  • 13 pple are deaf & blind

  • Jeff Buckley is beter, sorry.

  • Oh my god! She is beautiful! This is such an amazing and heartfelt performance.

  • Oh my god! Amazing! That was a beautiful and heartfelt performance. She is absolutely gorgeous as well.

  • een prachtig nummer vooral de tekst, ik krijg er kippevel van

  • Zunken lukenvimash truleai mochra porca.

  • well, the end isnt very good but her high tones are epic!!! i think she did one of the best performances of this song i've ever heard!!!

  • ik heb nog nooit gehuild om een liedje, maar dit is het eerste liedje waar ik om heb gehuild! PRACHTIG (l)

  • Het was opvallend dat je na 3 zinnen al wist dat ze het had gewonnen :P

  • harrkkk harrrkk fraaak krarkkkk if u guys wanna spit just spit for goodness sake..

  • krijg er gewoon weer kippenvel van !, geweldig <3

  • What's the song 1.10-1.39. It's amazing.The title pleaseeeeeeeeee?

  • @hrkln circus - britney spears

  • @CestKawaiiPlien thank's a lot!

  • @CestKawaiiPlien It;s not the circus of Britney Spears...bau thanks.

  • Comment removed

  • @hrkln sorry I didn't listen to it very well lol but it's if u seek amy - britney spears

  • @CestKawaiiPlien Yes it is...thank''s a lot!

  • waarom was gordon eigelijk naar moskou?

  • @tuurlijk143 Toen deed hij met de Toppers mee aan het songfestival

  • Omg, this girl can belt it!

  • I can still cry at this performance, so beautiful and touching. What a talent this lady is. Hope to see her live again in 2010 and have a picture with her, she's amazing!

  • Ik gun het haar echt! Ze verdient het gewoon!

    En ze doet het gewoon geweldig!

  • She does this song better than Alexandra Burke. But it is also good though.

  • Die erik ook...jezus... Hij doet me echt denken aan carlo van de TV kantine.. hahah.. en hoe hij hier helemaaal meegaat met dat liedje.. !!! Gordon?? I dont know

  • Meu Deus ela canta muito bem... Essa ficou linda na sua voz.

  • Nou ja, strijkers, synthesizers natuurlijk, haha! Maar niet minder mooi!

  • Ja, voor dit nummer luister ik het liefst naar Lisa, wat waanzinnig gezongen en mooi arrangement, stemmen en strijkers, heel bombastisch, hou ik wel van!

  • @suikermuiske.  hij was naar het eurovisie songfestival in Moskou. ;)

  • fantastic!

  • Die eric is echt vaag

  • Waarom was Gordon hier eigenlijk niet bij? Weet iemand dat?

  • moskou geloof ik.. ?

  • Eurovisie Songfestival

  • toen zat die in moskou met de toppers voor het songfestival

  • Amazing :O

  • En nou nog leren schrijven.

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Natalia & Gabriel Rios hebben dit nummer uitgebracht, en de opbrengst is voor Haïti.

  • Wonderful song!

  • Nice ! The backing vocals are so good as well !

  • Omg meen je dat nou dat je zegt van wie het orgineel is??

    Juff Buckley zegt jou weinig denk ik dan..

  • Actually, het is geschreven door Leonard Cohen, Jeff Buckley heeft het óok gecoverd.

  • @jazzyfizzle86 ja dat weet ik ook wel :), maar ik ging er vanuit dat als dat diegen Jeff Buckley al niets deed zeggen dat ik Leonard Cohen al helemaal niet hoefde te noemen ;)

  • Er zit juist heel veel mening achter dit nummer, het gaat over liefde...er wordt ook verhalen van de Bijbel als voorbeelden gebruikt.

    Alleen omdat je het niet begrijpt betekent niet dat het nergens over gaat. XD

  • <33

  • hoezo geen gevoel in haar muziek? Super mooi!

  • Zij heeft het verdient! Jij bent de beste Lisa!

  • they should've had a different name than x-factor

  • She sang this as well and good as our Alexander Burke who won our X factor in the UK.....beautiful xxxx

  • Lisa was explaining how you can make your own version of this song and she did. Wonderful to hear you say about Alexander Burke, respect!

  • Comment removed

  • Greetings from Denmark- so beatifull, so feeling

  • amazing!! so amazing!! the best version i have seen yet!! i loved it!! soo moving!!

  • k krijg kippenvel vn haar stem :) echt mooi :)

  • GEWELDIG (l)!

    dIT IS EEN GEWELDIG NUMMER

  • Te gek !

    Zooó mooi :)

    

    I ♥ IT !

  • G-E-W-E-L-D-I-G!

    Zei is echt zo erg verandert sinds de auditie!

  • actually it is....

    far better then leona lewis...

    to bad most english people can't accept thad lisa is better

  • When did Leona sing Hallelujah?? its Alexandra Burke sang in X factor!!!

  • Exactly!! Some people just havent got a clue!

  • LEONA ?? maybe alexandra .. not leona.. LOL

  • 4:32

    eric van tijn wil bijna meezingen :)

    kippenvel iedere keer dat ik haar hoor zingen... ze is echt zó geweldig.

  • Sorry to hear about your loss Sakigirl87. I like Alexandra's better, but Lisa, Jeff, anyone that sings well sings this song beautifully. It is a beautiful song. Each artist is going to have fans and is going to have those who think someone else sings better. That's how artist stay in business. Luckily we are all different (that's why they call us individuals)>

  • this song is very special to me as it was played at my sister's funeral. I cry every time I hear it and this version is my second favorite behind Jeff Buckley's. I just love Lisa! Rest in Peace Darla :)

  • Honey I beg to differ From the Us Alexandra wishes she could sing as good as this girl ! Lisa got voice and soul ! she's amazing ,plus hallelujah is a very beautiful soulful song

  • this is amezing how she sings it whit feel and she is so good you can feel the emotion and the sensation of the evening amezing

  • LOOOOOOL idiot

  • :O I Lovee it!!!!

    Gewoon Kippenvel overal!

  • ZE KAN SUPER ZINGEN

  • een top wijf na 8 weken nog steeds kippevel succes verder

  • nou laten we het erop houden dat iedereen een eigen smaak en mening heeft van die reacties hieronder...

    ik vind het iig terrecht dat ze x factor heeft gewonnen

  • helemaal mee eens!!!!!!!!!!!

  • You're only saying that because you're from The Netherlands.

    Alexandra performs and has spunk on stage, whereas Lisa just hangs about like a lifeless bag of spuds.

    Not to mention Alexandra is a FAR better singer than Lisa... you can't even compare them. Lisa just sounds like any girl who walked in from the street and was actually way off with a lot of the notes... nothing special about her at all.

    Alexandra will go global like Leona...

  • Comment removed

  • Well, having seen both versions, especially with your commet in mind, I guess it must be a matter of taste. Having said that, I much prefer the darker, more soulfull voice of Lisa- to me Alexa's voice sounds just the same like so many other female singers, including the vibrating/piching voices. That always makes my sphincter twitch, and I'm glad Lisa doesn't do that.

  • Lifeless bag of spuds... How could I've forgotten this is a dancing song? :-(

    Have you ever looked at footage from some of the greatest female singers from the 30s to 70s- DARE to say that about them!!! :P

    And Alexa might go global, just like Lisa might. Unfortunately, there's more to it then singing to make it that far.

    Being British probably is a (slight) advantage, but just a little bit. Being American would really help, since it's the biggest market on the planet, but they're chauvinist.

  • There is more to it than singing you're right... personality, looks normally help, production...

    It's irrelevant where people are from, talent can come from anywhere but British acts accounted for 5 of the 7 world top selling albums in 2008 so I don't think being American would help her. They're not chauvinistic in the US since the majority of great singers of all time were American women... even in the 30s - 70s, which yes I have looked at and they were true performing artists and divas.

  • Oh, and while I'm at it; the versions of Cohen and Buckley are also full of funky dancing moves, aren't they? This is not the song for bullshit like that!

    IMHO, the "show" of Alexandra was too full of crap (the candles made me puke, but hey, that's just MY opinion). And just to be curious, Derekoct83, what is YOUR nationality? I guess it isn't French, or is it? IMHO, what you regard as spunk, is bullshit to me. And Alexandra has won in 08, hasn't she? Haven't heard much from her at all since...

  • She didn't have funky dance moves... if you're refering to the music video that was a montage of all her performances.

    The winner of the Factor releases their debut single then spends a year recording the debut album and performs the first single on the first episode of the ensuing season. Alexandra is currently recording with Diddy, Akon, Pharell Williams, Stargate, Freemasons, RedOne and Soulshock & Karlin. She will support Beyonce on the last leg of her tour. What's Lisa upto?

  • Well, you got me on that one! AFAIK, she's currently just enjoying the fact that she won. Doing lot's of performances in Holland, both very small and some big(ger) ones, including The Toppers (which isnt my cup of tea, to put it mildly, but they are HUGE over here, and one of them was her mentor, so I guess that's all in the contract). I do hope she won't go that way -not meant to disrespect, but she should go on another path-> more jazzy/soulful, not hiphop

  • BTW, do check her other performances on Xfactor: her version of Dirty Man and Sober are at least as good as Hallelujah. I promise to check more from Alexandra. I guess we'll never agree on this one. Probably a matter of taste, combined with a little chauvinism (and having lived there for a year, IMHO one of their lesser virtues is that they really are chauvinist, although one can break through that). Shall we keep on slapping each other or call it a stalemate? I do like the discussion though...

  • Yeah she's ok and everything... just not what I would buy. Doesn't mean no-one else should be a fan :o)

    I thought she did well with the Kelly Clarkson song.

    I like the discussion too... I wasn't slagging off Lisa, just prefer Alexandra because she's more dynamic as a performer and I like contralto singers but they're both new so maybe they'll come through in different ways.

    You might have trouble viewing Alexandra's performances as they were removed for copyright. X Factor website is better.

  • Well, let's put it this way then. I actually dislike these programs very much. In fact, I only heard Lisa, AFTER she had won the show and someone else made me see her. So now have Alexandra, we have Lisa (BTW, and Hind->she didn't win, but was definitely the best of the 1st Idols here, check her out as well! Have to say there isn't too many good stuff available). I would say that's a much better result then expected, especially with the auditions in mind... ;-)

  • I can see the benefit and merit of shows like this when they give someone deserving a chance who may not have had it otherwise.... Like Leona Lewis was working in Pizza Hut. When they become farcical or full of sob stories I lose interest I must say. It's meant to be a talent show.

  • Look what you just said ,, ''Funky Dance Moves''

    Dude look how quiet this song is so you know that it is pretty obvious that she isn't making any ''Funky Dance Moves'' you feel me.

  • Yeah I said Alexandra didn't have any in this song... I said she had better presence. She had funky dance moves in the video because it was a montage of all her performances.

  • this is nothing special...

  • I thought that this song was for Alexandra Burke.

  • Normally is GORDON her coach/mentor

    But he was in Moscow for the eurovision 2009 with The Toppers.

    Lisa je bent echt geweldig:D

    Terechte winaar !

  • nederlands trots

  • mooi mooier mooist!!

  • The reccord company choose this songs for her, I like the song but why haven't they choose an other song... She deserved much better!

  • "much better"? I don't think you exactly got how extremely genius and legendary this song is.

  • I didnt mean that the song is bad, i really adore it. But I think that it would be more fair to give her a song that hasn't been used in an other Xfactor edition. People are going to compare to that. Thats my point. Lisa did a great job and I think there is a great future ahead for her!

  • the presenter sounds like she has got flem lol

  • what do you mean flem?

  • for queeneelizabeth111

    Eric:

    it was a good experiece, this song is perfect for her. With this song she is gonna win.

    Female:

    Lisa i could cry, because you sang this song so beautiful and because this is the last night from Xfactor

    Older female:

    Lisa i heard that you were gonna sing this song and the only thing i could think about is : omg i hope this is going to be good.

    well lisa you did great.

    (sorry for the wrong spelling)

  • kippenvel..

  • someone translate what the judges are saying? much appreciated

  • she is good,

  • this is good!

  • Go lisa, je kan echt goed zingen(K)

  • FAKING GOED

  • mooi

  • Comment removed

  • supeeer mooi! SHE CAN SING!:D

  • i think you're comment os boring ,...like you can do better,,..... right!!

  • And you should learn English spelling before rambling on on here.

  • KIppen kippenvel ben haar grooste fan Als concert komt GA ik er na toe FTW:D

  • Geen woorden voor gewoon geweldig krijg er elke x als ik er weer naar luister kippevel van

  • lisa best ever

  • luister es naar alexandra burke veeeeel mooier

  • Altijd weer dat vergelijken, doodmoe wordt ik ervan, en van jou dus nog veel moeier,ga iemand andersv vervelen!

  • search for Molly Sanden-Halleluja, she's amazing too.

  • OMG! How can people say that she is bad?? They really are soooo amazingly stupid.. OPEN YOUR EARS!! She is the best singer I ever heard or saw winning a talent show on TV.. Even Kelly Clarkson said she was scared to sing again when she heard Lisa.. She is just, SIMPLY THE BEST!!!

  • well said

  • kate voegele is a cunt

  • Ze zingt het echt mooi !

    Ik krijg er echt kippevel van.. ;$

  • Joey Star

  • Mooi,

    ik vind de originele versie toch nog veel beter

  • echt super goed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    ik heb het gezien op tv!

    je moet er echt bijna van huilen!!!=D

    echt goed. gewoon goed

  • goede beeld kwaliteit

    mooi

  • Great song, but like the 500th cover of the original! The piano is a mix of Jeff Buckley and Rufus Wainwright (/whatever you write that name)

  • echt heel goed.

    kippevel gewoon.

  • dit is nou gewoon het bewijs dat al die verprutste telent showen toch iets kunnen opleveren.

    dit is echt geweldig!!

  • GEWELDIG DIT !!!

  • So much talent!

    I never liked this song but she got me interested in leonard cohen again.

    Do listen to Jennifer Warnes interpretations of his songs!

  • she soo good

    she deserve to win !!!!

    i love her

  • Why can't she?

  • I dont know why she just cant, well she has a good voice just not as good as some other famous singers. and when you compare her singing it to say Jeff buckley you can tell the difference

  • She's an amateur compared to all those. You won't find other famous singers in a competition because they've received HUMONGOUS amount of training. Lisa's awesome, and with training she'll get huger.

  • Mooi=D

  • niet perfect gezongen (zoals bv alexandra), maar echt wel heeel goed

  • sorry but she copied alexandra burke's version and didnt do it as welll... shes good but didnt win over me

  • Alexandra.. lol.. crying biatch. Lisa has strength and she shows it. Nothing fake about her.

  • alex isnt fake... perhaps a little over exaggerated and too bubbly at times but i dont think she's fake.. i do like leona lewis better. im not saying lisa is terrible she sings very well actually. she just didnt put any effort into making the song her own.

  • why wassnt Gordon on the live show?

  • he was and still is in moscow for the eurovision 2009.

  • that really sucks he should have been there to witness her victory. Eurovision sucks all the x factor contestants are better than those silicon infused wannabes without talent Dima bilan makes me ashamed to be russian.

  • he was in moscow

  • i dont think shes bad.

  • naa she can't sing :L!!!! haha!!

    alex burke ftw!!

  • Wow this is awesome. I was looking for a good version of Hallelujah and I found it. This gave me goosebumps!! Holland has talent. lol

  • Ze had beter niet zo'n strakke jurk aan kunnen trekken.