I approve of some of the changes, it made for a smoother viewing, but Lyra shouldn't get all chatty and annoying with Iorek. In the book, she senses he's a tough character and wants to earn his respect.
@mikky107 Actually no, it's two characters pulled into one, in the book Billy Costa survives with his daemon attached and little Tony Makarios (unfamiliar to Lyra before she finds him in the shed) dies eventually without his Ratter.
For added Lulz, after the "You wish to ride me?" part, skip straight to 3:10 straight after lyara says 'yeah'. and remember, it's faster without armour.
I always thougt Iorek would say no to letting Lyra ride him. You know, proud panserbjorn prince and all that, but I was so suprised that he was humble enough to do that. I wish I could ride him too, Iorek is so cool!! XD
LORD ASRIEL AND MS COULTER DIE TAKING DOWN AN ANGEL INTO AN ABYSS -- LYRA AND WILL VENTURE INTO THE LAND OF THE DEAD AND OPEN A WINDOW FOR ALL THE GHOSTS OF PEOPLE TO ESCAPE USING THE SUBTLE KNIFE -- LEE SCORESBY DIES FIGHTING -- THE MAGISTERIUM GETS OVERTHROWN BY ASRIEL's MULTI-WORLD ARMIES -- ASRIEL USES RON TO OPEN THE PORTAL INTO THE OTHER WORLDS BY CUTTING HIS DAEMONS CONNECTIONS -- DUST IS AFFECTED BY PEOPLES CONSCIOUS THOUGHTS -- looks like I just did a Sirius Black XDXD
@bgibson36 Well, in a movie, it does make more sense. Plus, they have to cut down the movie, else it'd be too long. I know that it's annoying to have important scenes changed or taken out, but....
There has to be footage out there somewhere of Ian McKellen not being able to get through that line without laughing...maybe it's been destroyed, but he couldn't have done that on the first take.
I'm almost positive Ian McKellen is the dude who voiced the polar bear. He was also Gandalf in the Lord of the Ring trilogy and Magneto in the X men trilogy.
WHAT!!! They took Lyra to the Svalbard?!? They were supposed to take her to Bolvangar! I'm cool with alterations to the original story, but that's huge!
OMG OMG...this is an epic fail for the writer...one of my most touching parts was the one with the child and the fish...they just wanted to sell..lyra finds "bill"...wtf?WTF?!!that's so common in these movies...that's crap
ummm she had to get permission to ride the bear from Lord Faa.and wth there are more freakin auroras in thee story ..hah oh weel its a move and they doing a pretty good job..descent like i quess
In The books the Magisterium is supposed to be like the Catholic religion and the battle in the last book is supposed to be like the distruction of God. Even though I don't necessarily believe in God I still think people should be able to believe in whatever they choose.
The thing is, God isn't even in the books at all. The 'Authority' was actually just an angel, the first angel, who pretended that he had created the world. There's no mention of a creator at all.
I'm pretty sure the person doesn't die. I'm sure they end up as one of those souless people. But then again I've not read the books in ages so I could be wrong.
No, i think that if u kill someones daemon, u kill the person too... but u r right, it'd be quite inconvinient... the only advantage i see is that u r never alone....
Unfortunately, the producers HAD to make billy costa change places with tony makaroes who's deamon was named ratter. also, Tony Markaroes died a few hours after Lyra found him, and no such thing happened to Billy in the movie. Also, Wen Billy is talking at 6:10, he doesn't realize that he is holding his own deamon. Also, Lyra never told Roger that she had seen billy in this film. It this movie had been rated PG-13, we would've seen ALL the dying parts, and epic scenes. Too bad
They are not going to make the subtle knife a movie because in the golden compass film, when Lord Asriel showed the sample of pictures he had brought from Svalbard, there was no Mention of Grumman, who as Lord Asriel presented, was dead, but in reality, he's alive and is will's father. The whole point of will's adventure was to find his father. Plus, we only get a glimpse of Lord Boreal in TGC, and he was never shown at Mrs. coulte cocktail party, but is the main antagonist of book 2.
No, they r not going to do the film cause TGC wasn't very well in america. It's true, they should've mentioned Grumman & there isn't the cocktail party in this film, we just know about it cause Mrs. Coulter say to Lyra something about the gest list in part 3.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Well, I live in Asia, so I got no idea whatsoever what the americans think about it. however, TGC received bad rewiews because it didn't contain the last three chapters, and esspecially, rogers death, and the opening to the world of Cittaga'zee (if that's how it's spelled). Now I am writing a book also about a tweleve year old, but with much more action and mystery and less despair than "Philip Pullman's " 'His Dark Materails.' After all. he was forty eight when he wrote that, FYI He's an athist
Well, I live in England but I've read many times that the americans didn't like it... TGC didn't receive bad reviews just because this, it's that the damn church thinks thats against god, so it will not be good to produce it, just because of the church!!! (And is Cittagazze)
you said it yourself. Because his writing mocked the church, it was given bad reviews; most of the population of USA are christians. Why do you think Narnia was so popular despite the fact that it was prohibbited in every public school?
loads of public schools allow religious things, they're just not SUPPOSED to. the small town public school i grew up in regularly included bible stories, references and movies into our curriculum, we even learned about creationism in science
well that's just up to chance. Once my sister was in public school, where they didn't allow you to say, g-d, blessing ect. Anyway, on their graduation, a kid bfrom their class gave a speech, and during it, all of the kids in the class sneezed, and the audience said 'ga bless you'. The principal was speechless. Also, your science creation class is acceptable there, because scientists have their own idea of how the world was created: the big bang, and that wasn't really what happened
true, but public schools like del perado in boca raton florida are free and only go up til like 5th grade. Als, I went there for an interview once (as you can see, I didn't get in), and I heard one of the students call their math teacher 'teacher'. Isn't that weird? They couldn't even have called them 'math teacher'? My enttire life I've been going to a religious private school, that's why I know so much about G-d
excuse me but I had a good expirience learning he true veiw of the world. What are you an atheist? U sound like one. What you said was very insultive. Just know that for the future.
I know that mort of the USA population iis christian, but I have a best friend that really belives that God criated us and HDM is her fave series! Everyone has their own religion & the truth is, u liking or not, that the church doesn't like the other religions & if she could, she'd kill everyone that doesn't believe in their God. Have u already seen Angels & Demons?
cuz the trilogy does have some action; I can't deny that. But still, the waypullman emphisized it in books 2 and 3 is like ... I;m not going to even say it. He for the stupiest reason doesn't want to believe in g--d. I don't care, but that doesn't mean he has to write a trilogy about his hating religion. What's angels and demons?
never heard of it, but my parents saw divinci, and told me that it wasn't appropriate or good, so I never saw it. I ike harry potter better than his drak materials, cuz after finishing the series, I felt that my money paid for the books was spent wisely, and the books were excellent; I wish I could write as well as j.k. rowling. After finishing his dark materials, I felt robbed, cuz the trilogy (other than the golden compass) was terrible with no moral or epic battle, both I was anticipating
So i'm reading everyones commments to see what they think and they all say this movie kind of sucks and im wondering if I should read the books now or if i should just sorta go along with the movies now that the first book is kinda ruined now. Should I read the books? Are they THAT amazing?
I read every day and I've read TONS of books. By the time you have finished the second book, and then the third, I guarantee you will love them. The story is SO much better in the books... This movie doesn't hold a candle to the books.
Book 3 "Amber Spyglass" is probably the best single book I've ever read.
Until this point the movie was pretty good. But here they messed it all up.
And I'm not complaining because the events are in a different order from the book, the problem is purely cinematic: the timing of the film is utterly ruined from this point to the ending.
I sort of liked this movie until they switched tony with billy and now they completely skipped the bolvangar part. Now I'm just feeling really disappointed.
I'm not sure if I agree on the self destructive part, but indeed it seems to me as if she is angry at herself and doesn't love herself, or at least not in the way she used to.
Quite intresting realy, especially since this scene was suggested by Philip himself...
Jes in the book is better ever... sorry when i made false things but i´m german... in a film they can´t do anything from the book in it... ther film was 10 hours long when they made all things in this film
aww i didnt get to see part 6 :(
lunaycorrecamino 1 year ago
I approve of some of the changes, it made for a smoother viewing, but Lyra shouldn't get all chatty and annoying with Iorek. In the book, she senses he's a tough character and wants to earn his respect.
Eldritchfan 1 year ago
WHAT THE HECK??? Tony Makarios is the kid she found in the shed not billy costa! ratter is tony's daemon!!
Maxbtwshow 1 year ago
I feel sorry for Lyra because both of her parents are selfish pricks
larzkao 1 year ago
cat: something wrong lyra: hush pam Cat: something terrible im afriad Lyra: we Have to master our fear
envyia 1 year ago
Poor Pan.
g3g3ify 1 year ago
its so sad that Billie(or in the book Tony) dies
Roosje360 1 year ago
they found tony not billy and ratter is tony's daemon
94gymnast 1 year ago
"You wish to ride me?" "No I wish to be ridden"
94gymnast 1 year ago
I wouldda said Stay here, PLEASE
OneOfTheAliens 1 year ago
Wasn't it Tony who had his Ratter cut from him?
intheTea04 1 year ago
@intheTea04 Same person, different name
mikky107 1 year ago
@mikky107 Actually no, it's two characters pulled into one, in the book Billy Costa survives with his daemon attached and little Tony Makarios (unfamiliar to Lyra before she finds him in the shed) dies eventually without his Ratter.
Itjed 1 year ago
@Itjed I know :)
I just got past that part in the book, where she takes out a coin and writes "Ratter" on it.
I nearly cried.
mikky107 1 year ago
you...wish...to..ride me? ROFL
newworldboss 1 year ago
So many comments about "You wish to ride me"? Shows where most people have their brain. ;-)
Trondesson 1 year ago 2
The real Svalbard... is... not... forested ! :-P But okay, it's a semi-historic fantasy universe, so I'll let that pass... ;-)
ZemplinTemplar 1 year ago
Why is her daemon asking her what's wrong? Wouldn't he know too?
taintedfeatherx 1 year ago
You wish to ride me?
LOL that cracked me up.
Lewiogo 1 year ago 3
@Lewiogo yes i do XD
The2323full 1 year ago
thiz movie confuses me
jjluvz2blazy 1 year ago
How did she know his demon was missing? She just assumed? Didn't even ask? I so confused.
dPuffijeen1 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
thats not meant to be billy
NinjaGiraffeness 1 year ago
whos will again?
LoveMehBesties 1 year ago
HOOOLY SHIT!
The kid doesnt have a deamon :(
OMFGG, what kinda fucked up person would do that to like an 8 year old?
LoveMehBesties 1 year ago 5
@LoveMehBesties They took his SOUL...talk of dealing with the devil.
dPuffijeen1 1 year ago
Pan is my favorite!
Omnignosis 1 year ago 3
Pan is my favorite character! Mew! Mew!
Omnignosis 1 year ago 2
haha! yea, i thought i was the only one noticing that sentence. Kinda weird, lol but funny though.
chyechye31 1 year ago
I want 2 ride a Polar bear!!
redribbonkaya 1 year ago
For added Lulz, after the "You wish to ride me?" part, skip straight to 3:10 straight after lyara says 'yeah'. and remember, it's faster without armour.
meercat666 1 year ago
Pan is so cute. I want a daemon too lol
tdforjesus 1 year ago 3
poor Billy. It's a horrid thing to cut away a person's Daemon, let alone a CHILD'S.
1andonlySaraEliza 1 year ago 2
@1andonlySaraEliza that's pretty sad. how could somebody inflict that much pain on a kid?
amanda3685 1 year ago
I always thougt Iorek would say no to letting Lyra ride him. You know, proud panserbjorn prince and all that, but I was so suprised that he was humble enough to do that. I wish I could ride him too, Iorek is so cool!! XD
Rita3500 1 year ago
wow lyra tells pan to hush WAYYY too much if i were Pan i would be really pissed off right about now.
meghan0095 1 year ago
i wanna ride him, I WANNA RIDE HIM TOO!!!
RivenMark 1 year ago 5
uh... not how the book went... captured and taken to bears? i dont think so
deaglePwnz 1 year ago
@deaglePwnz no she was taken to the gobblers wasnt she?
kinglibertylolz 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
LORD ASRIEL AND MS COULTER DIE TAKING DOWN AN ANGEL INTO AN ABYSS -- LYRA AND WILL VENTURE INTO THE LAND OF THE DEAD AND OPEN A WINDOW FOR ALL THE GHOSTS OF PEOPLE TO ESCAPE USING THE SUBTLE KNIFE -- LEE SCORESBY DIES FIGHTING -- THE MAGISTERIUM GETS OVERTHROWN BY ASRIEL's MULTI-WORLD ARMIES -- ASRIEL USES RON TO OPEN THE PORTAL INTO THE OTHER WORLDS BY CUTTING HIS DAEMONS CONNECTIONS -- DUST IS AFFECTED BY PEOPLES CONSCIOUS THOUGHTS -- looks like I just did a Sirius Black XDXD
theonenonlysnk 1 year ago
now now, let's not be filthy-minded here, righty-o?
SuperGrommie 1 year ago 2
誰か日本語吹き替えもうpしてくれw
novel193 1 year ago
awesome
flarewolf01 1 year ago
btw lee scoresby is so cool ! i mean he just stood there and Shot some dudes Like that...
mumser12 1 year ago
lol "You... wish to ride... me?" priceless :D
ugaboj 2 years ago 3
lmfao the balloons a smiley face XD
InvaderZimCat 2 years ago
the word is spelled deamon
xlr8man165 2 years ago
the word is spelled daemon
TheMoonPower 2 years ago 2
How come no one has a elephant as a demon... lol
C1u3z 2 years ago 3
@C1u3z I guess It would mean they would have a REALLY big ego. lol
Rita3500 1 year ago
2:35
robSJU2010 2 years ago
i wish to ride him 2
johnsonmaya 2 years ago 2
Farder Coram and lord Faa actually let her 'ride' him in the book, no sneaking
Dazizco 2 years ago 3
Again with the inconsistancy! In the book she was kidnapped and sent to Bolvangar BEFORE she went to Svalbard. Stupid Hollywood.
bgibson36 2 years ago 2
@bgibson36 Well, in a movie, it does make more sense. Plus, they have to cut down the movie, else it'd be too long. I know that it's annoying to have important scenes changed or taken out, but....
sailormoonfan1421 2 years ago
youuuu wish to ride.... MEEEEEEEEE
soooo funny
JadeMichael101 2 years ago 6
WOW
cirepril143 2 years ago
you wish to RIDE me?
saddayinroxbury 2 years ago 6
LOL i love the "you wish to ride me" and he had a wth! face on :)
heatherstar87 2 years ago 7
I just saw this yesterday, I'm on the third book. I re winded the "You wish...To ride me?" part so many times. It's hilarious!
ItsTheJuan 2 years ago 48
There has to be footage out there somewhere of Ian McKellen not being able to get through that line without laughing...maybe it's been destroyed, but he couldn't have done that on the first take.
mapscannotcontainme 1 year ago
@mapscannotcontainme Who ia Ian Mckellen?
redribbonkaya 1 year ago
@redribbonkaya
I'm almost positive Ian McKellen is the dude who voiced the polar bear. He was also Gandalf in the Lord of the Ring trilogy and Magneto in the X men trilogy.
mapscannotcontainme 1 year ago
@ItsTheJuan what a perverted movie
The2323full 1 year ago
thats ian mckellen voicing the bear.
jaback123 2 years ago 9
that girl talks waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyyyyyy to much!
seanmcj 2 years ago
lol "you wish to RIDE me ?"
tranduc2 2 years ago 13
Not only did she want to ride him, but she did it without any 'armour'.
koulac 2 years ago 59
@koulac hahahahaa i get it
boycrazygirl567 1 year ago
they are traveling through to somolia
get to bolvangar
MadameSpazz 2 years ago
w8... isn't going lyra be inside the bolvangar? not svalbard... its so confusing than a game usually
Cutiemeghurl 2 years ago
WHAT!!! They took Lyra to the Svalbard?!? They were supposed to take her to Bolvangar! I'm cool with alterations to the original story, but that's huge!
UniversalHeat 2 years ago 3
OMG OMG...this is an epic fail for the writer...one of my most touching parts was the one with the child and the fish...they just wanted to sell..lyra finds "bill"...wtf?WTF?!!that's so common in these movies...that's crap
OverweightFatGuy 2 years ago 5
I think the reason why this movie didn't go so well at the movies is because it is very hard to understand when you havent read the book...
Think theyve left out quite alot of details and raised the tempo in the storyline
Kinda like the harry potter series.
aformalia 2 years ago 4
7:47 fail
jimmycrackcorn1981 2 years ago
Well? At 6:13, she says Billy but it isn't Billy! It should be Tony Makarios! It's all wrong! And where's the fish?
Menasiletye 2 years ago 4
They've taken a lot of the story out, ):
and switched Tony for Billy. |:
ZacEfronLurver 2 years ago 2
he's holding it! u can c it at 6:07! they so sudnt of swapped billy and tony around!
TheRachel666 2 years ago
NOOO NOT BILLY... It shouduve been tony makarios instead )= I hate the makers of this movie
mumser12 1 year ago 4
I wonder what happens when you shoot the demon
Horrordas 2 years ago
Their human dies.
FinlayO 2 years ago 2
Not in the movie...if the Demon dies, the human goes insane....
Cullengirl449 2 years ago 2
didnt the hunter people take her to Bolvangar first?????????
O_o i'm so confused!
zombieporn99 2 years ago
who voiced Pan???
zombieporn99 2 years ago
freddie highmore
unemployments 2 years ago
she is supposed to go boulvangar before she see's the king
PhycoTwilightFreak 2 years ago
Wheres his fish? Billy...well originally Tony, had a fish that he held dear.. and they left it out! it was supposed to be significant...
saffiragiesha 2 years ago
ummm she had to get permission to ride the bear from Lord Faa.and wth there are more freakin auroras in thee story ..hah oh weel its a move and they doing a pretty good job..descent like i quess
ashshulee11 2 years ago
in the books it wasnt billy who was the ghost.. shortcuts ftw.
Afterzor 2 years ago
billy's not supposed to lose his daemon! and lyra goes to bolvanger before the ice bears... this movie doesn't follow the book at all!
xmissindigox 2 years ago
they didnt take any women on the trip!
lisun58 2 years ago
Wasn't it Tony they found in the shack? Not Billy?
luineff 2 years ago 2
Yep. This is just one of many distorted / false details in the movie.
WalkerKansasRanger 2 years ago
"U wish 2 ride ME?!" LOL!!
bluekittykat77 2 years ago 7
it's so funny because on every single video there always comes a discussion of religious shit or whatever. just comment on the movie, damn it!
Cathydoescovers 2 years ago
In The books the Magisterium is supposed to be like the Catholic religion and the battle in the last book is supposed to be like the distruction of God. Even though I don't necessarily believe in God I still think people should be able to believe in whatever they choose.
Cyskull8 2 years ago 2
The thing is, God isn't even in the books at all. The 'Authority' was actually just an angel, the first angel, who pretended that he had created the world. There's no mention of a creator at all.
FinlayO 2 years ago 3
poor billy :(
majasty17 2 years ago
also, how in the world does the books and movies revolve to God? I seriously dont get that, I swear ppl nit pick every thing to make it bad
JeessiieeeLovesYou 2 years ago 3
sorry ,
i can't download this video ,
why ha ?
but I REALLY love THIS VIDEO too !
muslimSAM 2 years ago
SHIT compared to the book
ValleyOfTime 2 years ago 3
I love Lyra's winter outfit!
LemonadeAndLime 2 years ago 2
If you kill a daemon, the person dies. If you kill a human, their daemon dies.
turnipz2 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No if you just kill the daemon the human doesn't for some reason
sevenwolvesrule 2 years ago
you forget any harm done to the deamon is also done to the human
scorpion2105 2 years ago
No I didn't I'm just saying if you kill the daemon the person doesn't die besides there are different ways to kill them
sevenwolvesrule 2 years ago
thats right! but what happen here is that firstly they seperated billy from his deamon! that why billy didnt die!!
bbzelda27 2 years ago
your more of a target if you have a daemon, more vunerable to death.
TheMikster95 2 years ago
I'm pretty sure the person doesn't die. I'm sure they end up as one of those souless people. But then again I've not read the books in ages so I could be wrong.
ThomJBooth 2 years ago
Somehow having a deamon can by inconvenient .... you kill one, you kinda kill the other part ... i think @.@!
musicandstrawberries 2 years ago 7
No, i think that if u kill someones daemon, u kill the person too... but u r right, it'd be quite inconvinient... the only advantage i see is that u r never alone....
Belacquagirl 2 years ago
yeah , that´s true ... both of them die and they can´t even move to far from each other, just like a few yards as it hurts them so much
Lucytheeye 2 years ago
yeah its true if one dies, both die, if ones hurt, both hurt, also you cant be far from each other, because their soles are connected or somthing
JeessiieeeLovesYou 2 years ago
the film is good thx for uploading 5/5
But the books are way more better
playerfelix 2 years ago 5
Unfortunately, the producers HAD to make billy costa change places with tony makaroes who's deamon was named ratter. also, Tony Markaroes died a few hours after Lyra found him, and no such thing happened to Billy in the movie. Also, Wen Billy is talking at 6:10, he doesn't realize that he is holding his own deamon. Also, Lyra never told Roger that she had seen billy in this film. It this movie had been rated PG-13, we would've seen ALL the dying parts, and epic scenes. Too bad
TheMikster95 2 years ago 7
They are not going to make the subtle knife a movie because in the golden compass film, when Lord Asriel showed the sample of pictures he had brought from Svalbard, there was no Mention of Grumman, who as Lord Asriel presented, was dead, but in reality, he's alive and is will's father. The whole point of will's adventure was to find his father. Plus, we only get a glimpse of Lord Boreal in TGC, and he was never shown at Mrs. coulte cocktail party, but is the main antagonist of book 2.
TheMikster95 2 years ago 4
No, they r not going to do the film cause TGC wasn't very well in america. It's true, they should've mentioned Grumman & there isn't the cocktail party in this film, we just know about it cause Mrs. Coulter say to Lyra something about the gest list in part 3.
Belacquagirl 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Well, I live in Asia, so I got no idea whatsoever what the americans think about it. however, TGC received bad rewiews because it didn't contain the last three chapters, and esspecially, rogers death, and the opening to the world of Cittaga'zee (if that's how it's spelled). Now I am writing a book also about a tweleve year old, but with much more action and mystery and less despair than "Philip Pullman's " 'His Dark Materails.' After all. he was forty eight when he wrote that, FYI He's an athist
TheMikster95 2 years ago
Well, I live in England but I've read many times that the americans didn't like it... TGC didn't receive bad reviews just because this, it's that the damn church thinks thats against god, so it will not be good to produce it, just because of the church!!! (And is Cittagazze)
And so what that Pullman is an atheist???
Belacquagirl 2 years ago
He's a great writer! And the age doesn't count too, a 7 year old child can have the best idea in the world to a book as well as a 60 year old man!
I'm writing an alternative end to HDM, an end where Mrs. Coulter & Lord Asriel doesnt die.
Belacquagirl 2 years ago 4
you said it yourself. Because his writing mocked the church, it was given bad reviews; most of the population of USA are christians. Why do you think Narnia was so popular despite the fact that it was prohibbited in every public school?
TheMikster95 2 years ago
Why was Narnia prohibited? They are so pro-christian it's unreal.
ThomJBooth 2 years ago
cuz no public school allows it's students to read religious things. Narnia likeso
TheMikster95 2 years ago
loads of public schools allow religious things, they're just not SUPPOSED to. the small town public school i grew up in regularly included bible stories, references and movies into our curriculum, we even learned about creationism in science
silverorangetears 2 years ago
well that's just up to chance. Once my sister was in public school, where they didn't allow you to say, g-d, blessing ect. Anyway, on their graduation, a kid bfrom their class gave a speech, and during it, all of the kids in the class sneezed, and the audience said 'ga bless you'. The principal was speechless. Also, your science creation class is acceptable there, because scientists have their own idea of how the world was created: the big bang, and that wasn't really what happened
TheMikster95 2 years ago
as i said, loads of schools allow it their schools, i didn't say ALL public schools do.. :) things are different everywhere.
silverorangetears 2 years ago
true, but public schools like del perado in boca raton florida are free and only go up til like 5th grade. Als, I went there for an interview once (as you can see, I didn't get in), and I heard one of the students call their math teacher 'teacher'. Isn't that weird? They couldn't even have called them 'math teacher'? My enttire life I've been going to a religious private school, that's why I know so much about G-d
TheMikster95 2 years ago
well i feel very sorry for you that you had to endure such bullshit.
xdavanionx 2 years ago
excuse me but I had a good expirience learning he true veiw of the world. What are you an atheist? U sound like one. What you said was very insultive. Just know that for the future.
TheMikster95 2 years ago
arg... i hate the narnia books. blah, blah, blah, boring snoring... zzzzzzzzzzz.
freehueysrf 2 years ago
I know that mort of the USA population iis christian, but I have a best friend that really belives that God criated us and HDM is her fave series! Everyone has their own religion & the truth is, u liking or not, that the church doesn't like the other religions & if she could, she'd kill everyone that doesn't believe in their God. Have u already seen Angels & Demons?
Belacquagirl 2 years ago
cuz the trilogy does have some action; I can't deny that. But still, the waypullman emphisized it in books 2 and 3 is like ... I;m not going to even say it. He for the stupiest reason doesn't want to believe in g--d. I don't care, but that doesn't mean he has to write a trilogy about his hating religion. What's angels and demons?
TheMikster95 2 years ago
it's a book and the movie of it just came out lately it's the prequel to the Divnci Code
obidylan 2 years ago
never heard of it, but my parents saw divinci, and told me that it wasn't appropriate or good, so I never saw it. I ike harry potter better than his drak materials, cuz after finishing the series, I felt that my money paid for the books was spent wisely, and the books were excellent; I wish I could write as well as j.k. rowling. After finishing his dark materials, I felt robbed, cuz the trilogy (other than the golden compass) was terrible with no moral or epic battle, both I was anticipating
TheMikster95 2 years ago
no . she slapped him because she lte lyra get away
chocolytesprynkles 2 years ago 2
where´s part 6? ó.ò
rubinenauge 2 years ago
the books are good, read them
mscg4453 2 years ago 5
No, the books r marvelous!
Belacquagirl 2 years ago 7
why did mrs. coulter slap her self? did she do smething stupid? probably let lyra get away. oh i think that's why.
chocolytesprynkles 2 years ago 2
So i'm reading everyones commments to see what they think and they all say this movie kind of sucks and im wondering if I should read the books now or if i should just sorta go along with the movies now that the first book is kinda ruined now. Should I read the books? Are they THAT amazing?
SailorSun89 2 years ago
I've only read the first book and it's not that great. But it's a little different than the movie.
3speranza5 2 years ago
I read every day and I've read TONS of books. By the time you have finished the second book, and then the third, I guarantee you will love them. The story is SO much better in the books... This movie doesn't hold a candle to the books.
Book 3 "Amber Spyglass" is probably the best single book I've ever read.
Rallans1 2 years ago 5
Until this point the movie was pretty good. But here they messed it all up.
And I'm not complaining because the events are in a different order from the book, the problem is purely cinematic: the timing of the film is utterly ruined from this point to the ending.
Grissha 2 years ago
she basically slapped herself...ahahah
Dancingintherain15 2 years ago
The movie is not like the book´s - but it´s still a damm good movie!!
Metkongs 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
i hate the golden monkey he is so stupid. also i wanna get laid tonight!!
hallaislandgirl 2 years ago
You wish to ride me? LOL
Dimebag1337 2 years ago 6
ROFL XD "you wish to ride me" ahahahahh
killerberdo 2 years ago 7
i can't bare any more. i give up. film is a douche
teamcrumb 2 years ago 2
I sort of liked this movie until they switched tony with billy and now they completely skipped the bolvangar part. Now I'm just feeling really disappointed.
Tvfreak46 2 years ago 3
In the book it's not Billy who lost his daemon but a kid named tony, and Billy's daemon is not named Ratta. That's a huge mistake...
mariechantal15 2 years ago 4
You have that right. It's not Billy who lost his daemon!
Sweetcars12 2 years ago 2
It's Ratter, by the way ...
sweetheartartist 2 years ago
i think he's saying Ratter but his act-cent (sorry cant spell that word, lol) sounds like Ratta :P lol
sprite3517 2 years ago
hermitgamer // its for you play wow and then u get other mounts haahah
nisse341 2 years ago
WRONG!! da movie is all wrong
NimxNam 2 years ago
kind of...
lovemusic1007 2 years ago
is it just me or does pan sound a lil bit like piglet from winnie the pooh?
Sapphire1297 2 years ago 2
you wish to ride me?"
Yeha"
i thought that was funny
kittencuddle771 2 years ago 2
seriously though, how can it get more badass than a bear mount? O_O
hermitgamer 2 years ago
she slapped her monkey!! Why is she hitting herself?? lol
VistaMay12 2 years ago 6
she seems kinda crazy right?! O_O
MissNoOne555 2 years ago
Is it not obvious she is angry at herself for ignoring Lyra as her daughter all these years?
melvinhendrikse 2 years ago
That makes sense.
sweetheartartist 2 years ago
Perhaps showing that she's self destructive and obviously doesn't love herself as much as she should
Agaettis 2 years ago
I'm not sure if I agree on the self destructive part, but indeed it seems to me as if she is angry at herself and doesn't love herself, or at least not in the way she used to.
Quite intresting realy, especially since this scene was suggested by Philip himself...
melvinhendrikse 2 years ago
XD slaping a monky XXD
lockdownhamster 2 years ago 2
when come the second movie!!?
SpriterSully 2 years ago
sorry for you ther will be bo secend movie... they sed they wond conten-U the siris
lockdownhamster 2 years ago
Why not? At the end of this movie, they sort of made it a cliff-hanger. They can't just leave it dangling like that, otherwise fans will be upset.
Plus, it makes sense to add a sequel to the movie.
sweetheartartist 2 years ago
Jes in the book is better ever... sorry when i made false things but i´m german... in a film they can´t do anything from the book in it... ther film was 10 hours long when they made all things in this film
Dabldido 2 years ago