i think selena would be perfect for the role of hannah but u know for courtney would either be debby ryan or ariana grande wait no DEFINETLY ariana grande
I don't think that Selena fits the part of hannah, I don't think she's a bad actress at all, but when I look at her, she's too Disney for the role, too innocent, plus I think certain scenes would be akward to watch with her as Hannah (the hot tub) just putting it out there,
This made me feel like crying in the back of my throat... Though i admit, it wasn't how I imagined his voice to sound, it really sort of sums up the tone of the book. It's so hard to capture unless you look at the situation with the utmost seriousness. The whole story's absolutely breathtaking. (For a while, I thought this tape was gonna be empty...)
Omg whats up witj all you saying selena gomez wouldn't fot the role. First of all people should give her a try, maybe she would be good with that role who knows. What if dhe has another personality or characteristic. This probably would be a pg-13 movie so she obviously would have to say those words like "ass" & "hell". So probably she will good role. Its just that evreyone so used to seeing her in disney roles. Well selena probably ones to move on into something more intense. Give her a try! (:
@LyZBEYDY13 we will.. we have no change actually if we want to see the movie :D we are just saying that we think there are many great actors out there who would suit hannah a million times better :D we don't hate on selena.. we just dislike her for this role..
I dont know if its only me but i kidna didnt understand why the book cut off at clay calling for skyes name? Isnt that supposed to be a huge part of the book? I dont know can someone please tell me?
I want Diana Argon from Glee to play it because it sounds like her voice on the tapes and she an amazing actress. Or maybe Nina Dobrev she an amazing actress also. Not saying Selena isn't that she isn't a amazing actress she just doesn't fit the role.
you know i'm not sure who made the fourteenth tape but god was this book true. I cried so much when I read it and finally it makes people, even if its just the ones that read it, see, now I know that even some of the ones who did, in fact, read it, probably won't notice someone whose reaching out because those who need help usually are the ones who stay silient about it but suicide is the end and thats what holds me back.
i think this was someone we didn't get introduced to in the book maybe a friend she did turn to but didn't confide in completely ...or it could be a way to keep people from just listening to these tapes without reading the book ;)
I'd like to see Selena as Hannah. I think, as a Selena fan, it would be cool to see her in something somewhat dark like this. Are they actually going to make the movies with Selena Gomez and Logan Lerman, though? I've been hearing it for months, and neither of the stars has said anything about it, so I'm just wondering.
I think it's Mr. Porter because Hannah said she went to him for help and he said he was sorry he couldn't help. I think Clay is going to be played by Logan Lerman (I think that's how you spell his last name) and for all of you debating on who Hannah is, it's Selena Gomez. If you don't believe me, search "Selena Gomez In Thirteen Reasons Why Movie" by clevverTV.
I think this is suppose to be Tony. If anyone got the shit end of the stick it's him. He barely knew her, but was tasked with making sure the tapes were passed on. He's also the 13th person who heard them. He wasn't included in the list, but the 10 person was also the first, so Tony is number 13.
@colbie04 I agree. these videos were posted to a tie in blog that is heavily implied to be Tony. Also, Clay never had the opportunity to record to the tapes, nor video record them.
I think it's suppose to be Clay. Cause Mr. Porter didn't "know her" the way Clay did, he didn't care for her the way he did. Mr. Porter didn't do this, it was Clay.
Woah! Was this Clay? I'm pretty sure it wasn't Clay his voice is reeeeeeeeeally deeep and he even talks like a teacher, if it was Clay he would of cussed at least once or said something besides 'peers' and Mr. Porter was the last one right?
i kinda think its mr.porter becuse he said he wish he could have done somthing 2 help her and in tape 13 she said the books and stuff didnt work in the tapes 2 mr.porter
Is this Mr. Porter? Cause it can't be Clay (or what I imagined him to sound like) In my head, I heard a voice that was boyish and young.. This also sounds too young for Mr. Porter, I imagined him as 40+ and very warm. This person doesn't sound as warm as I wanted.
Also Selena Gomez shouldn't be in the movies, imagine all the 7 year olds crying in the hot tub scene. It should be Emma Stone even though she isn't blonde...:3
It is a beautiful story and book. But there is one thing I don't understand. I reconize this part from the book but it isn't on a tape i thought or is that my misunderstanding. Can someone please answer this. And sorry for my bad English
I got the book while on Vacation with my family and I couldn't put it down. This book is about how every little thing makes a difference in one way or another..... I feel like I could change the world now
i think everyone is two quick to judge selena, i wouldnt of classed her two play te role of hanna but... she has the talent ive seen people play characters in movies where they have 2 play completely different personalities i think she would do good tbh x
@daaynaJooycex I have in fact seen people do opposite personalities, and sometimes it works. But sometimes it doesnt work. And this book is just too good to risk the slight chance of it not working. Personally, i feel whoever voiced Hannah in the tapes here would be perfect, if not, I would say Diana Agron
omg i am so tired of people complaining bout selena gomez how shes going to play hannah in the movie and then ruin it. how the hell do you guys know so just shutup and if you got a problem with it DON'T watch the movie!
I personally think it is the author who speaks at the end and they hired Olivia, or whatever her name is, to do the recordings in order to reach more people through youtube. It's a promotional thing.
It's obviously Mr. Porter. I mean, if you read the channel title, it's called hannahsfriend13. number 13 is Mr. Porter. and plus Clay couldn'tve posted these cuz he shipped the tapes to the next person. So that narrows it down to Mr. Porter and Tony, whom didn't want to leak out the tapes. and plus the person talking both sounds and acts really mature, which leads me to believe it is Mr. Porter moreso than Tony.
I'm going to be VERY disappointed if Selena Gomez is Hannah! She's going to make this really good book look like a joke at least put her as a not important character. But she will ruin this movie. And book
wait who is it??? clay????? I thought Clay was bad, I am so cinfused, someone help me understand...... (I wonder who will play him in the movie, Logan Lerman, maybe Zac Efron....hmmmm)
@theloveofwolves i agree with you she should be Courtney if anybody... but not Hannah. I even think Demi Lovato would do better than her because of what she's been through she could relate better than Selena..
I think its Mr. Porter. He just has that whole teacher thing in his voice lol. These tapes were great. The girl on these tapes should of got the part for Hannah, NOT Selena Gomez. Selena is a good actress just I think Hannah is way too mature for her to pull off. But I guess we all have to wait and see.
hahaha i was expecting Hannah thank you and all that, and I was confused for a minute why there was a man speaking O___o. then it hit me. Oh yeah...it's Clay XD
@FromCowboysToCarrots i got, that you thought that only her ass is suitable for hannah, or maybe not :D well i was just curious, maybe you can find anything else, what could fit with hannah.. i mean you were the first one to point out, she has the perfect butt :D i just can't say that in a serious voice.. hahahahahahaaaa
@FromCowboysToCarrots i do not care about the disney thing.. i live in a little country in europe, and am not really familiar with that.. but she is juts plainly annoying.. :D
I think its Mr. Porter he feels the people on the tapes need to know that there is more to their actions than listening to them. Hannah Baker is dead and they can't take that back. I like this new addition
i dont think its the author i think its the guy who is pressing the button to like the tape player, because like clay and mr. porter didnt know anything else that could've like made hannah's life any better, this is just confusing.
People say that suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.....that's not always the case wounds of the heart never heal it always leaves a scar, big or small it all
Matters. Some problems just aren't temporary........
Clay to me has changed now he's more muscular and mysterious an handsome after listening to this. I'm halfway through the book It's Clay talking <3 I know it
I think this was just the guy saying "go and buy the book, support the author, know the real story"...i think thats also why the tapes weren't completely done aswell
THe guy who is saying this his name is troy he is the guy who gave hannah the recoder but he didnt know that hannah was going to tell 13 reason why she killed herself...
@Solcito1235 I agree ive read it twice and dont remember reading it. i literally just finished it for the second time. this recording made the book that much more real
It's CLAY. because in the book he kept talking about how much he wished he could of helped her, if only he asked, and found out what was wrong, and blah blah blah. Clay is the one speaking.
is it clay? I mean the way he talk it's almost as if he has been watching over her, beating himself as if it was his fault she died. Or is it Mr.Porter, who was trying his hardest not to feel guilty and just 'move on' ? just like what he told Hannah. So which one is it? Clay or Mr.Porter?
but it cant be tony because he had the second set of tapes, not the originals that she sent out. i dont know who it is supposed to be, but the creator of these tapes (as good as they are) left out a lot, and i guess added this because this tape is NOT in the book. amazing book btw!
No, I really think that this is suppose to be Tony. Idk, I think Mr. Porter wouldn't be able to record that considering is "major role" at the end of Hannah's tapes.
Tony. I think. Why would Clay tape that, even though he is almost the last in line? It wouldn't make sense, because Justin etc already listened to the tapes. no point in sending them back eh?
This isn't right....The Back of tape 14 is silence then at the end Hannah Says Thank you.I would know i did this book for a book report,read it three times,and did the thank you thing For the last page.
i think the only reason they put this tape on youtube is to get people to read the book. because all the tapes on here are the shortened version. so yea. idk tho.
Um... this is Mr, Porter, obviously. Because he is featured in tape 13(: Just my thoughts...
KellyAnnRodgers 10 minutes ago
i think selena would be perfect for the role of hannah but u know for courtney would either be debby ryan or ariana grande wait no DEFINETLY ariana grande
dreamer77ize 1 day ago
I don't think that Selena fits the part of hannah, I don't think she's a bad actress at all, but when I look at her, she's too Disney for the role, too innocent, plus I think certain scenes would be akward to watch with her as Hannah (the hot tub) just putting it out there,
catherine869 2 days ago
kinda sounds like CHUCK BASS!!!!!!!!!
BitchImStillAverage 2 days ago 2
Is this Mr.Porter or Tony???
damayalapapaya 1 week ago
<3
AliciaOnline100 2 weeks ago in playlist Uploaded videos
This made me feel like crying in the back of my throat... Though i admit, it wasn't how I imagined his voice to sound, it really sort of sums up the tone of the book. It's so hard to capture unless you look at the situation with the utmost seriousness. The whole story's absolutely breathtaking. (For a while, I thought this tape was gonna be empty...)
Loveheart1997 2 weeks ago
Omg whats up witj all you saying selena gomez wouldn't fot the role. First of all people should give her a try, maybe she would be good with that role who knows. What if dhe has another personality or characteristic. This probably would be a pg-13 movie so she obviously would have to say those words like "ass" & "hell". So probably she will good role. Its just that evreyone so used to seeing her in disney roles. Well selena probably ones to move on into something more intense. Give her a try! (:
LyZBEYDY13 2 weeks ago 2
@LyZBEYDY13 we will.. we have no change actually if we want to see the movie :D we are just saying that we think there are many great actors out there who would suit hannah a million times better :D we don't hate on selena.. we just dislike her for this role..
KairiOnMuNimiXP 2 weeks ago
Is this supposed to be Clay, Mr.Porter, Or Tony?
Emmaleissosexxy 3 weeks ago in playlist Hannah's Reasons
I dont know if its only me but i kidna didnt understand why the book cut off at clay calling for skyes name? Isnt that supposed to be a huge part of the book? I dont know can someone please tell me?
Kaleighization 3 weeks ago
I want Diana Argon from Glee to play it because it sounds like her voice on the tapes and she an amazing actress. Or maybe Nina Dobrev she an amazing actress also. Not saying Selena isn't that she isn't a amazing actress she just doesn't fit the role.
lollelegirl 1 month ago
you know i'm not sure who made the fourteenth tape but god was this book true. I cried so much when I read it and finally it makes people, even if its just the ones that read it, see, now I know that even some of the ones who did, in fact, read it, probably won't notice someone whose reaching out because those who need help usually are the ones who stay silient about it but suicide is the end and thats what holds me back.
lolilovely13 1 month ago
I was hoping to hear hannah's thank you line. When I read that I cried so hard :*(
mizzQAF 1 month ago
I think this is Tony...
xxashleyRxx 1 month ago in playlist More videos from Hannahsfriend13
@xxashleyRxx i agree
EliVoshallzzzz 3 weeks ago
I think Nina should play Hannah. She fits the role.
TheKennieBee1 1 month ago 2
Um... I don't think this was in the book. Just saying.
LoserLikeMe5 1 month ago
My only hope is that Selena Gomez doesn't ruin this movie.
missash70 1 month ago in playlist More videos from Hannahsfriend13
Logan Lerman is perfect for Clay
I have mixed feelings about Selena Gomez as Hannah...
HabboNoah 1 month ago
i think this was someone we didn't get introduced to in the book maybe a friend she did turn to but didn't confide in completely ...or it could be a way to keep people from just listening to these tapes without reading the book ;)
cluelesslyurs1 1 month ago
I'd like to see Selena as Hannah. I think, as a Selena fan, it would be cool to see her in something somewhat dark like this. Are they actually going to make the movies with Selena Gomez and Logan Lerman, though? I've been hearing it for months, and neither of the stars has said anything about it, so I'm just wondering.
SelenaLerman 1 month ago
I think it's Mr. Porter because Hannah said she went to him for help and he said he was sorry he couldn't help. I think Clay is going to be played by Logan Lerman (I think that's how you spell his last name) and for all of you debating on who Hannah is, it's Selena Gomez. If you don't believe me, search "Selena Gomez In Thirteen Reasons Why Movie" by clevverTV.
RoyalJustin 2 months ago
I think this is suppose to be Tony. If anyone got the shit end of the stick it's him. He barely knew her, but was tasked with making sure the tapes were passed on. He's also the 13th person who heard them. He wasn't included in the list, but the 10 person was also the first, so Tony is number 13.
masamunekakashi 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
I think it's Tony
colbie04 2 months ago
@colbie04 I agree. these videos were posted to a tie in blog that is heavily implied to be Tony. Also, Clay never had the opportunity to record to the tapes, nor video record them.
masamunekakashi 2 months ago in playlist Uploaded videos
I think it's suppose to be Clay. Cause Mr. Porter didn't "know her" the way Clay did, he didn't care for her the way he did. Mr. Porter didn't do this, it was Clay.
Despite having a very deep voice.
randomzchicka 2 months ago in playlist More videos from Hannahsfriend13
Woah! Was this Clay? I'm pretty sure it wasn't Clay his voice is reeeeeeeeeally deeep and he even talks like a teacher, if it was Clay he would of cussed at least once or said something besides 'peers' and Mr. Porter was the last one right?
swagginpurpleninja 2 months ago
who is it im so confused
i kinda think its mr.porter becuse he said he wish he could have done somthing 2 help her and in tape 13 she said the books and stuff didnt work in the tapes 2 mr.porter
pinkluver2612 3 months ago
who is it im so confused
pinkluver2612 3 months ago
Is this Mr. Porter? Cause it can't be Clay (or what I imagined him to sound like) In my head, I heard a voice that was boyish and young.. This also sounds too young for Mr. Porter, I imagined him as 40+ and very warm. This person doesn't sound as warm as I wanted.
Also Selena Gomez shouldn't be in the movies, imagine all the 7 year olds crying in the hot tub scene. It should be Emma Stone even though she isn't blonde...:3
BakeTHATCAAKE 3 months ago
Slightly disappointed this didn't just have a minute of silence and "Thank you"
PhoenixInvertigo 3 months ago 7
@PhoenixInvertigo
me too...that was one of many really strong moments in the book...if not the strongest
9Epidemais4 3 months ago
Is that supposed to be mr.porter??
PoweredByFajitas 3 months ago
@PoweredByFajitas No, I think it was supposed to be Clay... but it sounds so frickin wrong huh?!?!
SugarBabySugar 3 months ago
i don't know why but this last one is the one that made me want to cry
star67dontknow 3 months ago
Thriving Ivroy - Flowers for a Ghost match Clay soo much.
insecuritycase 4 months ago
It is a beautiful story and book. But there is one thing I don't understand. I reconize this part from the book but it isn't on a tape i thought or is that my misunderstanding. Can someone please answer this. And sorry for my bad English
MiraSara3 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I got the book while on Vacation with my family and I couldn't put it down. This book is about how every little thing makes a difference in one way or another..... I feel like I could change the world now
sakurabloom123 4 months ago
Omg..
I thought clay's voice will be like... Logan lermans voice.
i think logan suits clay more then ever. with selena i dunno know, i love her so imma give her a chance.
wish them both luck.
#Lolena For ever<3
MegaMissymee 4 months ago 3
He sounds like Yamato from Naruto Shippuden
MajoraKidPuppet 4 months ago in playlist More videos from Hannahsfriend13
I think Selena would be a good Hannah,she's never been given the chance before so how do you people know shes gonna ruin it?
NOMdinosaurs 4 months ago
OH GOD. This voice is perfect for Tony - but not Clay.
SuperCanadianMuffin 4 months ago 4
Ah... got chills....
blackjack801 4 months ago
But there wasn't a 14th tape in the book. . . .just saying. :)
purpleicesparkles 5 months ago
@purpleicesparkles Well duh! xD lol It's just Clay's tape that he recorded. :3
chipsahoy303 4 months ago
i think everyone is two quick to judge selena, i wouldnt of classed her two play te role of hanna but... she has the talent ive seen people play characters in movies where they have 2 play completely different personalities i think she would do good tbh x
daaynaJooycex 5 months ago
@daaynaJooycex I have in fact seen people do opposite personalities, and sometimes it works. But sometimes it doesnt work. And this book is just too good to risk the slight chance of it not working. Personally, i feel whoever voiced Hannah in the tapes here would be perfect, if not, I would say Diana Agron
bvbarmysupport 4 months ago
omg i am so tired of people complaining bout selena gomez how shes going to play hannah in the movie and then ruin it. how the hell do you guys know so just shutup and if you got a problem with it DON'T watch the movie!
iheartsoftball13 5 months ago 3
this is so sweet, he is so nice he is trying so hard to make up for what he didnt do to save Hannah Baker
justinblover33 5 months ago 14
@justinblover33 one question remains, Who is HE! people say its Porter or Clay.
YABAtheDRUG357 1 week ago in playlist More videos from Hannahsfriend13
But if mr porter is on the tape who is the person playing the tapes...
ImaginaryWarmth 5 months ago 3
I personally think it is the author who speaks at the end and they hired Olivia, or whatever her name is, to do the recordings in order to reach more people through youtube. It's a promotional thing.
z0mgitzmanderz 5 months ago 2
It's obviously Mr. Porter. I mean, if you read the channel title, it's called hannahsfriend13. number 13 is Mr. Porter. and plus Clay couldn'tve posted these cuz he shipped the tapes to the next person. So that narrows it down to Mr. Porter and Tony, whom didn't want to leak out the tapes. and plus the person talking both sounds and acts really mature, which leads me to believe it is Mr. Porter moreso than Tony.
Doofus41 5 months ago 2
Comment removed
Doofus41 5 months ago
I'm going to be VERY disappointed if Selena Gomez is Hannah! She's going to make this really good book look like a joke at least put her as a not important character. But she will ruin this movie. And book
BigJackandMoFo 6 months ago
wait who is it??? clay????? I thought Clay was bad, I am so cinfused, someone help me understand...... (I wonder who will play him in the movie, Logan Lerman, maybe Zac Efron....hmmmm)
justinblover33 6 months ago
That was super creepy. I'm sorry.
CJSinger13 6 months ago
I wonder if Selena will do the make out scene??? Or will say all the bad words ???
AlexaLucky13 6 months ago
I think Selena Gomez should be Courtney or Jessica
theloveofwolves 6 months ago
@theloveofwolves i agree with you she should be Courtney if anybody... but not Hannah. I even think Demi Lovato would do better than her because of what she's been through she could relate better than Selena..
musicinmysoul3 5 months ago
I think Selena gomez should be Courtney or Jessica? It would expand what she plays before? What about you?
theloveofwolves 6 months ago
Do you think this be Clay or Tony? Think about wouldn't it be more sence to be one of them?
theloveofwolves 6 months ago
So how well is Selena Gomez gonna do the hot tub scene...Or do u think they're just gonna cut it out altogether? Can't wait for the movie!
CynSmiles13 6 months ago
maybe this is the Authors Part.... Yaa...
YABAtheDRUG357 6 months ago
THIS ISN'T IN THE BOOK!!!! INSTEAD SHE SAID THANK YOU!!!!!!
qtysound 7 months ago
this is not in the book
familyclifton 7 months ago 13
I think its Mr. Porter. He just has that whole teacher thing in his voice lol. These tapes were great. The girl on these tapes should of got the part for Hannah, NOT Selena Gomez. Selena is a good actress just I think Hannah is way too mature for her to pull off. But I guess we all have to wait and see.
Mandygirlie13 7 months ago 4
14?okaaaaaay....xDCool tape;)
KatharaxDlovesKibaxD 7 months ago
That's clay I ve read this book and it was clay love da book
sonshine98 8 months ago
Is this Clay?
XCherryPie98X 8 months ago
hahaha i was expecting Hannah thank you and all that, and I was confused for a minute why there was a man speaking O___o. then it hit me. Oh yeah...it's Clay XD
WitheredWings345 8 months ago
its clay talking at the end ithink
SWEETlikeSUMMERlove 9 months ago
that's random ...
AHSgurls 9 months ago
Selena Gomez better NOT be Hannah!!!!!!!
UKABUSE1 9 months ago 4
@UKABUSE1 i mean Selena is gorgeus and i like her but she is just so WRONG for Hannah!!
KairiOnMuNimiXP 9 months ago 81
@KairiOnMuNimiXP YES she is THANK YOU. Nobody ever agrees with me on that and she's a terrible choice.
Fiireflys 5 months ago
@Fiireflys she is too sweet, to too.. WRONG!!! i even don't know who suits for her..
KairiOnMuNimiXP 5 months ago
@KairiOnMuNimiXP But she has a nice ass! It's perfect for hannah. lol. I kidd.
FromCowboysToCarrots 3 weeks ago
@FromCowboysToCarrots haha :D other than a sweet good-lookin ass.. can you find a reason why she would suit for hanna? cause i surely do not :D
KairiOnMuNimiXP 3 weeks ago
@KairiOnMuNimiXP I was being sarcastic for the most part. I think she'd make a terrible hannah, haha!
FromCowboysToCarrots 3 weeks ago
@FromCowboysToCarrots i got, that you thought that only her ass is suitable for hannah, or maybe not :D well i was just curious, maybe you can find anything else, what could fit with hannah.. i mean you were the first one to point out, she has the perfect butt :D i just can't say that in a serious voice.. hahahahahahaaaa
KairiOnMuNimiXP 3 weeks ago
@KairiOnMuNimiXP Yeah, I won't like her as hannah. I'll never get passed her 'Disney' self. haha! :D
FromCowboysToCarrots 3 weeks ago
@FromCowboysToCarrots i do not care about the disney thing.. i live in a little country in europe, and am not really familiar with that.. but she is juts plainly annoying.. :D
KairiOnMuNimiXP 3 weeks ago
@KairiOnMuNimiXP Yeah. If you are familiar with her disney self. You'd know what i mean. haha! :D
FromCowboysToCarrots 3 weeks ago
i think it may have been Clay talking at the end & whoever made this video made it up..
tiffanyannluttrell 10 months ago 4
uh...I thought it was 13 reasons why, not 14 reasons why...
arancienne 10 months ago
WHY'D SHE HAVE TO DIE!?! WHY MUST THE GOOD DIE YOUNG!! D: waahh :(
poocutie4 10 months ago
i think it was tony or clay
NikkiBieber4212 11 months ago
I'm pretty sure it was Clay talking. Just to add something.. it was probably a creative way of telling us that there was more on the tapes xD
khhottie1 1 year ago 20
I think its Mr. Porter he feels the people on the tapes need to know that there is more to their actions than listening to them. Hannah Baker is dead and they can't take that back. I like this new addition
LadyBulldoggs689 1 year ago 3
It's clay, he said this in the end of the book.
PukeZombies 1 year ago
i dont think its the author i think its the guy who is pressing the button to like the tape player, because like clay and mr. porter didnt know anything else that could've like made hannah's life any better, this is just confusing.
shaunaxweissx1 1 year ago
Is it Clay or Tony?
naruko75 1 year ago
oh shit this stuff is fucking tramatizing
fluffy4551 1 year ago
there are only 7 tapes!!!! you should change the titles!!!
imdabest143 1 year ago
@imdabest143 But there are two sides to each tape. and 13 sounds better :)
Crossmyyheart 1 year ago
People say that suicide is a permanent solution to a temporary problem.....that's not always the case wounds of the heart never heal it always leaves a scar, big or small it all
Matters. Some problems just aren't temporary........
skydreamer11 1 year ago 7
I read the book, it didnt mention Clay recording this to the last tape. :O
babuchichong 1 year ago
CLAYY!!!! :D
xxxLIBBLYxxx 1 year ago
Clay to me has changed now he's more muscular and mysterious an handsome after listening to this. I'm halfway through the book It's Clay talking <3 I know it
M3l97 1 year ago
Comment removed
mattmattmattm 1 year ago
i think its brilliant that you had clay add to the last side of the tape
emiliana3296 1 year ago 4
its clay because in the book he says this <3
ingridlovesjustinb 1 year ago
@ingridlovesjustinb its tony
HannahFerrin 1 year ago
@ingridlovesjustinb Wait... Seriously?! I thought it was Mr. Porter O.O I did NOT imagine Clay's voice to sound like this.
ninjaswearingtutus 1 year ago 4
@ninjaswearingtutus yeah i know but the book says it and its clay.
ingridlovesjustinb 1 year ago
I think this was just the guy saying "go and buy the book, support the author, know the real story"...i think thats also why the tapes weren't completely done aswell
oOAstarOo 1 year ago 4
I'm guessing he made his own tapes then said "The choice is yours" to whether they wanted to hear the whole story or not. It's really mysterious.
TheShatteredDreamer 1 year ago
who's Tony???
CherryLover2854 1 year ago
@CherryLover2854 Read the book. How about that?
ItsAsianPho 1 year ago
@CherryLover2854 i thought it was troy?
CherryLover2854 1 year ago
they say the guy isnt in the book
but the account says "hannah's friend" maybe it his?
boomingpearl 1 year ago
THe guy who is saying this his name is troy he is the guy who gave hannah the recoder but he didnt know that hannah was going to tell 13 reason why she killed herself...
karis1202 1 year ago
@karis1202 no his name is tony
Taje247 1 year ago
@karis1202 His name is Tony, isn't ti? Not troy?
ItsAsianPho 1 year ago
i kno its clay but whos the like real guy i mean everyong knows who the girl was saying hannahs tapes but who was that dude?
outsiderssoda 1 year ago
ok i've read the whole book.. twice! n i've never hear this. it's just something added right? it's not on the book. anyways, it's pretty cool <3
Solcito1235 1 year ago
@Solcito1235 I agree ive read it twice and dont remember reading it. i literally just finished it for the second time. this recording made the book that much more real
LadyBulldoggs689 1 year ago 5
Comment removed
breezybabiixoxo 1 year ago
I would have never imagined Clay's voice to be so... muscular
MarinaAJames 1 year ago 80
The voice is Clay, because I just got finished reading this book & he said this.
misfitdoll23 1 year ago 4
@misfitdoll23 Really?
AhYingx3 1 year ago
@AhYingx3
Yes.
misfitdoll23 1 year ago
It's CLAY. because in the book he kept talking about how much he wished he could of helped her, if only he asked, and found out what was wrong, and blah blah blah. Clay is the one speaking.
OhGetHighOffSarah 1 year ago 5
It`s Clay .
HinaxSasu101 1 year ago
What is this really? I mean was this tape found in the blog or is this actually something that's telling there's a continuation to 13 reasons why.
MarinaAJames 1 year ago
is it clay? I mean the way he talk it's almost as if he has been watching over her, beating himself as if it was his fault she died. Or is it Mr.Porter, who was trying his hardest not to feel guilty and just 'move on' ? just like what he told Hannah. So which one is it? Clay or Mr.Porter?
MarinaAJames 1 year ago
Marcus?
musiclovergirl2 1 year ago
mister porter?
Zuckerveilchen 1 year ago
If it is supposed to be Clay, his voice is ruined here. The accent is weird or something... I don't know how to explain.
I actually think this is Mr.Porter. His voice sounds a lot older. And it never specifies how old he is.
switchitupashley 1 year ago 2
its either Tony's or Clay's I think its Clay's cuz he liked her. Well in the book he did.
XxAmdisxX 1 year ago
Its probly Tony, I pictures Calys vloice way lower..
Beautiful605 1 year ago
that uscks
luciabeckett4 1 year ago
this is supposed to be a movie? what?! the thirteen reasons why movie ha i laugh in your face
ebesco95 2 years ago
thats clay stupids.
TheXXxEmoPrincessxXx 2 years ago
It has to be clay and heres why...
As post by another he says sorry hannah which is a throwback to the actual book where he says to hannah 2 times that hes sorry
Also before hand he talked to Marcus and got mad at the others because they werent getting the point of the tapes.
Also in the book he fills in some of the gaps that hannah left out of her tapes which is why he said "thers a lot more i could share"
maikai1234 2 years ago 3
Either that's Tony or Clay.. but seeing how he mentions "I'm sorry I didn't do something when it couldve mattered" I'm more inclined to Clay
dragonizk 2 years ago 3
but it cant be tony because he had the second set of tapes, not the originals that she sent out. i dont know who it is supposed to be, but the creator of these tapes (as good as they are) left out a lot, and i guess added this because this tape is NOT in the book. amazing book btw!
naflower05 2 years ago
Yeah but i don't think that with all the copy write laws out there they would be allowed to.
Rusty3721 2 years ago
good point, but they could have had more. and i really dont know who the guy is supposed to be, cause this wasnt in the books... =/
naflower05 2 years ago 3
I think this is Tony. But I still think that they should have put the 'Thank You' part from hannah in.
ShouldHaveNeverMetU 2 years ago 3
No, I really think that this is suppose to be Tony. Idk, I think Mr. Porter wouldn't be able to record that considering is "major role" at the end of Hannah's tapes.
Yukana101 2 years ago
This is Mr. Porter...... in tape 13 she TALKS about mr porter but this is his voice though I don't think this was part of the book :|
MrsSkellingtonLover 2 years ago
@MrsSkellingtonLover it wasnt...lol i agree with u
AKHDAROXXURSOX 2 years ago
Tony. I think. Why would Clay tape that, even though he is almost the last in line? It wouldn't make sense, because Justin etc already listened to the tapes. no point in sending them back eh?
JitskeNL 2 years ago
Maybe clay... who's Tony again?
spillontopage13 2 years ago
I thought this was mr. porter at first...
lorlproductions 2 years ago
This isn't right....The Back of tape 14 is silence then at the end Hannah Says Thank you.I would know i did this book for a book report,read it three times,and did the thank you thing For the last page.
LawlietJourney 2 years ago
This was tony. I'm sure.
Please... pleasee.. post the rest. PLEASE, PLEASE, PLEASE?
BlueEyedJonasFan 2 years ago 2
if i do recall.. its 13 reasons why. not 13 reasons why and then some random guy repeating "the choice is yours" for dramatic effect?!
westsideshorty24 2 years ago 60
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!
roxorgirl13 2 years ago
@westsideshorty24 if u read the book you would know that when Clay got this, this side was blank but he recorded this one this side for hannah
Theaddictiveshowdied 1 year ago
@westsideshorty24 maybe its supposed to be clay adding to the tapes? idk but nuthin like that was ever in the books.
lilmissscreamo1 1 year ago
@westsideshorty24 LOL Ikr
arancienne 10 months ago
@westsideshorty24 I remember that there was 13 reasons and then a 14th tape which was also Hannah...but I don't remember what she said Dx
pattykins100 6 months ago
@pattykins100 she just said, "thank you"
jml0425 6 months ago
ithink this is clayy..or it could possibly be tony !
2kool4u96 2 years ago
its the last one its boy talking
bflvr199 2 years ago
Is this really you? Or is this fake.. -_-
morgaaan96 2 years ago
We all know Hannah on these tapes is played by Olivia Thirlby - does anyone know whose voice this is?
Untitledshadows 2 years ago 3
i think the only reason they put this tape on youtube is to get people to read the book. because all the tapes on here are the shortened version. so yea. idk tho.
xACDCxRocks 2 years ago
I don't remember this being in the book?
Paperboyluver101 2 years ago
i read the boook but i dont remeber this part,,....
the book was amazingly goood
babystephanie13 2 years ago
these tapes are the shortened version, i think that people would feel for the story more if they were whole.
there should be an audiobook with all of the tapes.
frshlove 2 years ago
I like tape 14 in the book better...
corribobo 2 years ago
wait a minute this was not in the book? was it?
spy5five 2 years ago
No it wasn't.
oOSkiTTIeSOo 2 years ago
ok good because i was about to re read it
spy5five 2 years ago
wait wait hold on a minute here... i havent read the book and i am fascinated about these tapes. I just want to know how Hannah committed suicide?
faevolturi 2 years ago
She swallowed a bunch of pills
SakuHira 2 years ago
How? Pills.
saryvalenzuela 2 years ago
I think it's the person that posted these videos recorded this tape and added it as he sent it on.
peacelovebethx 2 years ago
why is there a guy talking? the last side of the tape is hannah saying thank you
dancergir131 2 years ago 49
ikr
saryvalenzuela 2 years ago
@dancergir13 I know aye ! ! !
GeorgiaLevi611 1 year ago
@dancergir131 It's Clay Jensen. Emphazising one of the main points of the book, everything you do has consequences and not just for you.
DisneyChannel021 8 months ago 4
just finished the book!!!
SO GOOODDD; one of the best books ever!
but i dont remember this being in the book.... was it?
osnapitzjeff 2 years ago 4