Amazing!! You guys are astonishing!! It was really gud friends,the latter half of video as amazing..please tell me which softare you used.I aspire being a director..watch my videos too..i've made a similar attempt for 'Given Up' by linkin park..it's called 'suffocating'..do watch it guys.and all the best for future!!
I like that! Tudom, hogy nem ők énekelnek, de valószínűleg mindenki tudja, aki hallgatja ezt a zenét. Csak az volt furcsa, hogy amikor a zene nagyon hatásoson véget ér, akkor a videó még nem. Ebben a videóban ötlet van, gondolat, és erő a megvalósításhoz. (I think, everybody knows it that not they are singing. It was strange only that the video doesn't end yet when the music ends effectively. This video not a bad one, because there is an idea, thoughts, strength to the realisation.) Thank you!
@Tavaszom Thank you very much. It's nice to see that we're getting an international audience as well as an American one. We felt when making this video that the core idea and the emotion had to be really strong or else it wouldn't be worth making. The instruments and the musical 'performance' were simply used to give it the traditional feel of a music video but are in reality the most non-essential parts of the piece. Thank you for picking up on that, and thank you for your kind words.
@Tavaszom Köszönöm szépen. Jó érzés látni, hogy mi kaptunk a nemzetközi közönség, valamint egy amerikai. Úgy éreztük, hogy ha ezt a videót , hogy az alapvető elképzelést és az érzelem kellett ahhoz, hogy igazán erős , különben nem lenne érdemes . Az eszközök és a zenei " teljesítmény " egyszerűen használható , hogy azt a hagyományos érzést egy videóklip , de a valóságban a legtöbb nem alapvető fontosságú része a darab . Köszönjük, hogy átveszi ezt, és köszönöm a kedves szavakat .
I think the concept was awesome. In this day and age when so many of our children are apathetic and damaged; turning to gangs and drugs to ease the way too fast-paced living of the 21st century, it is nice to see some of them take a positive approach and find something that they can believe in. So what if some think it is cheesy. This was a heart felt tribute to the song. This video made me love this song.
Honestly? I think that trying to do more for the video would obliterate the song's simplicity. There's only so much any video can give to a song before it starts to take away. That being said, I think this is the best possible interpretation of the song.
i was kind of diappointed because i expected a cover. i think maybe you guys should do another video with no instruments and just the story concept. that i think would be cool. can't judge you since i've never made a video before.
And first of all I'm not ignorant. I understand the song. This vid just sucks. Cheesy camera angles. The cut scenes of the drummer is what made me laugh the most. I showed this to my friends at school and they thought it was hilarious
Well I'm sorry that you didn't like it, but considering we filmed this in a two day time window, with a cast and crew of three people, a budget of $0, and no time to do reshoots, we're pretty proud of it. There are definitely things that, given the time, we could have done better, but for what it is we're proud of it, and at the very least you got a laugh out of it.
why dont you give them a little credit. sure maybe they dont have nice camera angles and cant perfectly time all the notes for the instruments but i would like to see you do better with no money and not a lot of time.
Once again people, we accept, and appreciate, constructive criticism. However, if we start seeing more comments like this, negative comments with no explanation, they will be deleted.
@WhyIsProductions ok sure, first of all sorry but i don't see the purpose of trying this, if anything do a live cover of the song or something. but a fake cover music vid of an awesome song kinda seems like a big FAIL. also you could've picked a better location than some guys room, and ya some of the instruments didn't line up which was dumb and i also dont see why your writing lyrics down when the lyrics are shown on the screen anyways
Well as for the fake cover and the location, that was all part of our original concept. We wanted this to feel as close to a professional music video as we could get with a budget of $0. In most professionally done music videos the band is playing to a pre-recorded track, sure it may be the real band playing, but you aren't hearing what was recorded on the set. So we did the same thing, the only problem was that we aren't all professional musicians and hiring RED was a bit outside our $0 budget.
As for the location, we chose to have it all set inside a bedroom because we wanted a place that could feel comfortable and isolated at the same time. We wanted it to feel like this guy was trapped in this room, but also that he was choosing to be there. We were going for a theme of duality, and I thought we pulled it off pretty well, but perhaps there was more we could have done. As for the lyrics, I agree, that was a weak scene and we probably could have done better there.
Also, when we typed up the captions for the lyrics, we didn't know that it would play with them on by default. That bothers us immensely and we wish we could have them default to 'off.'
Thank you for taking the time to tell us what you thought.
This is probably the dumbest thing i've seen. First of all, I bet your cheap ass squire p bass sounds super great when you tune that e string down to a b. Second, the drummer looks like he's been playing for 2 weeks. The guitar player is the only one who doesn't look like an idiot. Try again kids. This sucks so bad, I thought it was a joke.
I'm so happy that you completely missed the point of the video. We weren't performing this live so we weren't necessarily concerned about being 100% with the instruments. We all had different musical abilities, varying from Josh, who is in an amazing up-and-coming rock band to David, who has next to no musical ability.
Again, though, the playing wasn't the point. It was a means to an end. The point was the story of the video, something that was obviously completely lost to you.
We don't mind constructive criticism, in fact we encourage it. If you respectfully tell us what you didn't like we'll assess it and use it to inform our decisions in the future, but if you come in here with a completely ignorant comment, and an obvious intent of flame baiting, we won't respond to that.
The reason I allowed your post to show up is so I could make a point. We're not trying to censor our critics, but if anyone posts a comment that is rude, insulting, or vulgar, we will delete it.
The video tells a story that relates to the theme of the song. The song talks about how often times we are our own worst enemies, and that there is a 'fight inside' all of us between our different feelings.
In this video the main character is struggling with guilt, friends he has lost or betrayed, and whether he should forgive himself and move on or succumb to his guilt. We portrayed this by having him literally trapped inside that room, fighting with himself to escape, and eventually losing.
Thanks, that was my (David's) fault in editing. Kaei and Josh both did fantastic playing, so any errors with their instruments were the fault of the editor.
omfg. awsome,5 stars man.cool screenshots. you guys are like the future version of RED. YOU GUYS SHOULD TOTALLY DO YOUR VERSION OF HIDE AND ALREADY OVER, OR SOME OTHER SONGS. EXCELENT JOB DUDES.
Main Character/Bassist/Singer - David Daut is hot...
Kittenkat105 1 month ago
lol i liked it :D ^_^
VAMPIREGIRL0121 6 months ago
dude, that's pretty sweet........
Covers4Christ 10 months ago
What is the point of this!?
TheSassyfoxx 1 year ago
I thought the video was great, I take it you guys don't actually play those instruments?
AudioDemonStudios 1 year ago
it is AWESOME!!
SonOFJesus22 1 year ago
ok so it sucked ......u had to rock out more and start headbutting but anyway good job
blazed39 1 year ago
weird /
AsiLaYDyiNg4794 1 year ago
hey guys it derek dalton that cool i like. call me some time ok
snowpaintballer 1 year ago
Amazing!! You guys are astonishing!! It was really gud friends,the latter half of video as amazing..please tell me which softare you used.I aspire being a director..watch my videos too..i've made a similar attempt for 'Given Up' by linkin park..it's called 'suffocating'..do watch it guys.and all the best for future!!
abhithemsay 1 year ago
I like that! Tudom, hogy nem ők énekelnek, de valószínűleg mindenki tudja, aki hallgatja ezt a zenét. Csak az volt furcsa, hogy amikor a zene nagyon hatásoson véget ér, akkor a videó még nem. Ebben a videóban ötlet van, gondolat, és erő a megvalósításhoz. (I think, everybody knows it that not they are singing. It was strange only that the video doesn't end yet when the music ends effectively. This video not a bad one, because there is an idea, thoughts, strength to the realisation.) Thank you!
Tavaszom 1 year ago 2
@Tavaszom Thank you very much. It's nice to see that we're getting an international audience as well as an American one. We felt when making this video that the core idea and the emotion had to be really strong or else it wouldn't be worth making. The instruments and the musical 'performance' were simply used to give it the traditional feel of a music video but are in reality the most non-essential parts of the piece. Thank you for picking up on that, and thank you for your kind words.
WhyIsProductions 1 year ago
@Tavaszom Köszönöm szépen. Jó érzés látni, hogy mi kaptunk a nemzetközi közönség, valamint egy amerikai. Úgy éreztük, hogy ha ezt a videót , hogy az alapvető elképzelést és az érzelem kellett ahhoz, hogy igazán erős , különben nem lenne érdemes . Az eszközök és a zenei " teljesítmény " egyszerűen használható , hogy azt a hagyományos érzést egy videóklip , de a valóságban a legtöbb nem alapvető fontosságú része a darab . Köszönjük, hogy átveszi ezt, és köszönöm a kedves szavakat .
WhyIsProductions 1 year ago
Hey, it's better than Guitar Hero!
ASeventhSign 1 year ago
so fake. 1:23 hitting thw tom when there's supposed to be a cymbal crash
xLukexDukex 1 year ago
nice vid guys, keep up the great work,try to make some other vids,and fuck what the haters say,there hater thats their job.
MrAlejandre1995 1 year ago
I think the concept was awesome. In this day and age when so many of our children are apathetic and damaged; turning to gangs and drugs to ease the way too fast-paced living of the 21st century, it is nice to see some of them take a positive approach and find something that they can believe in. So what if some think it is cheesy. This was a heart felt tribute to the song. This video made me love this song.
shadowneme 1 year ago
nice vid.you guys should try to make some more.
MrAlejandre1995 1 year ago
Honestly? I think that trying to do more for the video would obliterate the song's simplicity. There's only so much any video can give to a song before it starts to take away. That being said, I think this is the best possible interpretation of the song.
viewerguy27 1 year ago
nice video guys!
jangofet222 1 year ago
omg... you serious?
JoCoDev 1 year ago
Its not as bad as the idiots say. Everyone has to hate even though they could do no better. Ignore them.
LYFProductoins 1 year ago
i was kind of diappointed because i expected a cover. i think maybe you guys should do another video with no instruments and just the story concept. that i think would be cool. can't judge you since i've never made a video before.
karmanameless 1 year ago
And first of all I'm not ignorant. I understand the song. This vid just sucks. Cheesy camera angles. The cut scenes of the drummer is what made me laugh the most. I showed this to my friends at school and they thought it was hilarious
Chopdawg09 2 years ago
Well I'm sorry that you didn't like it, but considering we filmed this in a two day time window, with a cast and crew of three people, a budget of $0, and no time to do reshoots, we're pretty proud of it. There are definitely things that, given the time, we could have done better, but for what it is we're proud of it, and at the very least you got a laugh out of it.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
@WhyIsProductions .....well i have to say...it did sucked.....but putting all that effort in it.....was hard....so excellent job!!!!!
sgtlino1 1 year ago
@Chopdawg09
why dont you give them a little credit. sure maybe they dont have nice camera angles and cant perfectly time all the notes for the instruments but i would like to see you do better with no money and not a lot of time.
jangofet222 1 year ago
sorry guys but this really sucks
dono7bob 2 years ago
Ok do you mind telling us what sucks about it?
Once again people, we accept, and appreciate, constructive criticism. However, if we start seeing more comments like this, negative comments with no explanation, they will be deleted.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
@WhyIsProductions ok sure, first of all sorry but i don't see the purpose of trying this, if anything do a live cover of the song or something. but a fake cover music vid of an awesome song kinda seems like a big FAIL. also you could've picked a better location than some guys room, and ya some of the instruments didn't line up which was dumb and i also dont see why your writing lyrics down when the lyrics are shown on the screen anyways
dono7bob 2 years ago
Well as for the fake cover and the location, that was all part of our original concept. We wanted this to feel as close to a professional music video as we could get with a budget of $0. In most professionally done music videos the band is playing to a pre-recorded track, sure it may be the real band playing, but you aren't hearing what was recorded on the set. So we did the same thing, the only problem was that we aren't all professional musicians and hiring RED was a bit outside our $0 budget.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
As for the location, we chose to have it all set inside a bedroom because we wanted a place that could feel comfortable and isolated at the same time. We wanted it to feel like this guy was trapped in this room, but also that he was choosing to be there. We were going for a theme of duality, and I thought we pulled it off pretty well, but perhaps there was more we could have done. As for the lyrics, I agree, that was a weak scene and we probably could have done better there.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
Also, when we typed up the captions for the lyrics, we didn't know that it would play with them on by default. That bothers us immensely and we wish we could have them default to 'off.'
Thank you for taking the time to tell us what you thought.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
although this is a home made vid, it still great^^it really have a great effect on the theme of the song
xander975 2 years ago
i love RED! Awesome vid. I saw this from Hancock. GREAT JOB!
Miranda514 2 years ago
This is probably the dumbest thing i've seen. First of all, I bet your cheap ass squire p bass sounds super great when you tune that e string down to a b. Second, the drummer looks like he's been playing for 2 weeks. The guitar player is the only one who doesn't look like an idiot. Try again kids. This sucks so bad, I thought it was a joke.
Chopdawg09 2 years ago
I'm so happy that you completely missed the point of the video. We weren't performing this live so we weren't necessarily concerned about being 100% with the instruments. We all had different musical abilities, varying from Josh, who is in an amazing up-and-coming rock band to David, who has next to no musical ability.
Again, though, the playing wasn't the point. It was a means to an end. The point was the story of the video, something that was obviously completely lost to you.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
We don't mind constructive criticism, in fact we encourage it. If you respectfully tell us what you didn't like we'll assess it and use it to inform our decisions in the future, but if you come in here with a completely ignorant comment, and an obvious intent of flame baiting, we won't respond to that.
The reason I allowed your post to show up is so I could make a point. We're not trying to censor our critics, but if anyone posts a comment that is rude, insulting, or vulgar, we will delete it.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
dont really c the point of the vid sorry...
FallenReaper6 2 years ago
The video tells a story that relates to the theme of the song. The song talks about how often times we are our own worst enemies, and that there is a 'fight inside' all of us between our different feelings.
In this video the main character is struggling with guilt, friends he has lost or betrayed, and whether he should forgive himself and move on or succumb to his guilt. We portrayed this by having him literally trapped inside that room, fighting with himself to escape, and eventually losing.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
We thought the song would fill in whatever story the visuals alone didn't, but perhaps we should have made it a bit more clear.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
this is beast!
runr576 2 years ago
Awesome job thank you
three3days4grace5 2 years ago
nice work
noah1970 2 years ago
On 2:57 of the song the snare is off time with the song, but kool video 9/10.
stre3t90 2 years ago
Thanks, that was my (David's) fault in editing. Kaei and Josh both did fantastic playing, so any errors with their instruments were the fault of the editor.
WhyIsProductions 2 years ago
Yay! Red!!! :D My favorite song is Never Be The Same. You should try that one, too!
suzical04 2 years ago
nvr be the same is like fight inside just more achoustic and slow
Sh4d0wPhenix 2 years ago
Good video coprighted or not its too cool and u didnt even have to leave your house!
cameronisadaredevil 2 years ago
omfg. awsome,5 stars man.cool screenshots. you guys are like the future version of RED. YOU GUYS SHOULD TOTALLY DO YOUR VERSION OF HIDE AND ALREADY OVER, OR SOME OTHER SONGS. EXCELENT JOB DUDES.
lilmaine 2 years ago
Hahah
cameronisadaredevil 2 years ago
YEAH! I LOVE YA DAVID! Nice job. (Hello my awesome drums)
BabuskinMuahaha 2 years ago
Good job. 5/5
allTimeSubscriber 2 years ago