This wasn't in the movie because it was cut out for some reason...and if it was I would have to leave 3 times to cry my eyes out (wishing you were here again and all I ask of you made me cry D'=)
Heartbreaking, indeed. I saw this amazing movie for the first time the day before yesterday and I started to cry in the end just becase I felt so sorry for him </3
I love the different lyrics to this melody, though the version of learn to be lonely by Minnie Driver was exceptional, this one is a heart breaker, because it really shows his soft more gentle side, the part of him that just wanted to love and be loved in return.
I'm one of the lucky ones who actually got to see the stage production of Phantom of the Opera, (Twice), and I don't think they could have picked anyone better for the movie version of Erik than Gerard Butler!! This movie is phantastic!!
Phangirlnumber1 yes! E. R. I. K. Do I need to spell it out again? Gaston Leroux just turned over in his grave. Erik. With a k. Erik. You might want to start keeping your hand at the level of your eyes...
No one would listen No one but her Heard as the outcast hears. Shamed into solitude Shunned by the multitude I learned to listen In my dark, my heart heard music I long to teach the world Rise up and reach the world No one would listen I alone could hear the music Then, at last, a voice in the gloom Seemed to cry "I hear you" I hear your fears Your torment and your tears . She saw my lonliness Shared in my emptiness No one would listen No one but her Heard as the outcast hears
No one would listen No one but her Heard as the outcast hears. Shamed into solitude Shunned by the multitude I learned to listen In my dark, my heart heard music I long to teach the world Rise up and reach the world No one would listen I alone could hear the music Then, at last, a voice in the gloom Seemed to cry "I hear you" I hear your fears Your torment and your tears . She saw my lonliness Shared in my emptiness No one would listen No one but her Heard as the outcast hears
@baby55695 It was not in the movie, because it "slowed the action down and didn't add anything to the plot", as I read in a comment on this clip uploaded here by someone else. Too bad, because it is a really beautiful part where you see the soft, emotional side of the Phantom..
I think the original idea was to have it before Christine woke up and did the " remember there was mist" piece. But It didn't really fit, because it was too close after music of the night for another phantom aria. Still a great piece of music and singing though.
Reality passes into myth, myth passes into legend, and in a way, it becomes larger and more real than it ever was before. Speculate as you will on whether the ghost ever lived. Maybe in a way that's enough. So long as there is music, in a way, there will be an Erik.
@iamthegoalie01 usual AGW-denier stalker of me - the scum that monitors this to go tell the scum pedo-satanists what it says, you're the same scumbag that marked all the truth on my channel here about your stalker/pedo-cult of nature-rape etc as spam.
I've had two male past lives out of at least sixteen so it isn't crazy pedo - kill yourself. You're going to hell when you die, and are facing extensive rape & torture for eternity for conspiring to abuse me and mark my comments as spam.
The story of The Opera Ghost is real you know. I know because I was he in a past life. In fact, it was my second-to-last life. Lies claim I was like how is shown in this movie. How is that possible when this guido-looking asshole can't sing or act his way out of a paper bag? I was 6'4' and noseless and Christine was a blonde swede, Webber, you kikey cunt. Kill yourselves fatties.
@MaidenMarve If you would just do as much as skim over Leroux's novel then you would see that everything I've said about myself in that incarnation is true. Further, you obviously can't help the Freudian slip of acknowledging that I was really Phantom by your stating it as fact when asking for proof, pedo. You clearly know nothing about how reincarnation works or you would never have asked such an insane question to start with.
@lilibud12 bro, you were not Erik, I was. besides, do you even sing? or Fence? and you probably wouldnt get it if I said you are Hooke incarnate. STOP TAKIN CREDIT FOR MAH STUFF!!!!!
@happilyinsane8 Pedo - just thought I'd let you know the reason I haven't posted until now is because Google - the scumfucks hijacked my account.
Once, I had to entirely remove another (due to stalker satanist using its 1000s of pervert channels to complain about me rightly calling its conspiracy evil pedo jew fags etc) channel, cause the Google scum mentioned stole that one too & i couldn't get it back cause of jew pube's idiot verification-code-conspiracy that is allowed to exist.
@happilyinsane8 Anyway, Gerard Butler channel- no one claiming to be me in a past life would incarnate and become obsessed with a false version of it in this one. Like I've told your conspiracy once before already, though the physical descriptions etc in Leroux's book were pretty much spot on - most of the story was skewed - and/or fabricated and turned into literary fantasy bs. Are you really so fucking dense as to think that Leroux was ever going to know every word of what was said anyway?
@happilyinsane8 Btw, of course I can sing in this incarnation, but I'm nowhere near as good as then, and I don't do it professionally. Where did you hear that you have to do the exact same things you did and as good as you were then to prove you're telling the truth about who you were in a past life, pedo? Where ever you heard it, it's wrong and doesn't make sense anyway.
@happilyinsane8 (cont) If that were the case, you wouldn't really have reincarnated, and you'd be stuck in some false-hologram-time-wrap where you're still living out your past life, only it'd be slightly altered by culture. Plus, if that were true, then how can you possibly expect me to believe you were me in a past life when you can't even type proper?
@lilibud12 fourth, I am not obsessed with my former life, unlike you, who could probably quote my biography at any number of places, and fifth, you would not be so stupid or insecure as you are that you would have to resort to "trollin" 13 year olds who are smarter than you.
@happilyinsane8 Also, even if I had the opportunity to sing profesionally now, I wouldn't, cause of how music has become such a handicapped, mentally ill thing, done specifically to rape people's souls with noise-pollution and nature-spirits/animals etc.
I know what sane music is. It's pro-nature like acupuncture/therapy and mostly soft piano. Piano music should be played during surgeries, but it's not because most surgeons are the scumbag wrong-tech nature-abusers.
@lilibud12 one, you are incredibly stupid with an extremely limited vocabulary and an exceedingly closed mind. two, if you were a serial killer, which is bull because I was he, its slightly hypocritical to call me a pedo. three, you clearly have no interest in the arts at all if you think good music is dead. it is incredibly easy to find. ever heard of placido domingo?
@MaidenMarvel Also, I never, at any point, gave you permission to use my first name. You have to earn that privilege you dumb cunt. If you would stop being such a tarded cunt you would see a major difference in how your life is run. Kill yourself.
@lilibud12 Leroux claims The Phantom was real so I believe him, but according to Leroux's interview with the Persian, Erik did indeed have a nose. Anyway, I love the book but, I like Webber's interpretation of The Phantom better than Leroux's.
love this story so much. i mean regardless of form i'll watch it. but the movie is definitely my favorite. there was some stuff over on snapsnap i stayed up all night watching. like interviews and behind the scenes stuff. it was really cool.
@mschaiga Tell me about it. He did fantastic! Michael Jackson wanted to be the phantom and I think he would have done good but Gerry did really good :) It makes you wanna cry doesnt it? the music is amazing! I dont know why they got rid of this scene. its beautiful!
@MJDancingMachine14 I totally agree with you and yes it does make me wanna cry. I actually nearly cried to the movie lol. It's very amazing. True, they had no right to get rid of it. Thank goodness its on YouTube :)
@ColeyyyRiceee Yopu got that right! It ought to be against the law to be that sexy........and he's the best actor I've ever had the pleasure to watch. He can do any type of roll!
I always sing this song silently to my self when no one listens to me when I try to say something. Even with a clear voice. Besides it is my favorite song!
if i where christine when the phantom gave her the ring i would ask " if i accept your engament do you promise to stop tormenting the ones i know and the people i love and live with me and not leave my side for anyone but me "
I love him! Gerard butler was greatcfor the part idc what others think. He's singing might not of been phenomenal but his acting was perfect. I truly felt his sorrow.
Like a lot of people, I wasn't a huge fan of Gerard Butler's signing in this movie. It was okay, but not as good as I would have liked. BUT, he sounds great in this song! I'm not sure if it's just more in his range or that I've never heard anyone else sing it to compare, but I think he does a beautiful job with this song. ^__^
God, not only does he write music, he's deep, is an ARTIST and just wants to be loved. I feel /so/ bad for him, and I've read the book. But wouldnt everyone go a bit insane from lonliness, hatred, and just plain discrimination for being different? I feel bad for him, and his life. End of Story.
@TheKittylover1 Don't we all I cried when I heard the phantoms child story. But don't worry he comes back to Christine on the musical Love Never Dies. I am DIEING to see it
@TheKittylover1 Me too! I was on his side the whole movie. Gerard is such a GREAT singer (he's singing 4 real). I cried watching the Opera & the movie. Both were good!
@TheKittylover1 He wasn't "different." He was completely disfigured. Treated horribly, but to be loved by an innocent girl without being judged on his looks, he began to depend on her greatly. His absolute obsession with her drove him mad. How it was written intended for the audience to feel for the Phantom. It is also to show us the shallowness we all have on both ends of the spectrum.
@ everyone. ALWs version is pretty loosley based on the Leroux novel. In the Leroux novel and the 1925 silent film the Phantom is creepy, insane and a murderer. When watching the 1925 film you learn to feel little/no compassion for the phantom. In ALWs version, he is a sentimental , loving maniac. In the silent film yes, he loves Christene but he sleeps in friggin coffin. Case Closed.
"You feel little to no compassion for Erik from the 1925 version" Are you kidding? Not to be prude but the '25 version is, to date the most fateful to Leroux's book, in fact. The 1925 version did actually have the scene where the Phantom was playing his violin to Christine at the cemetery, and the duel with Raoul for Christine, these however, were cut, but survive in the form of still photographs. As for lack of compassion, You can see the torture in the Phantom's eyes and face
@phangirlnumber1 Why? Because he almost died to save Christine? Because he was not abused terribly as a child so the audience naturally feels less sympathy for him?
To put an arguement down. The musical is based on the book, not a retelling. As someone who acts in plays and played Raoul in my high schools version, I have this to say. In musicals expression is the most important thing. ALW took the horrible man of Eric in the book and made him sympathetic so that people will have the debate of Raoul vs Phantom. It is all a part of making people love the characters and making it successful
Check my cover out if you would please guys! Let me know what you think :) hope I did it justice! Sorry its a bit out of sink.. still... I hope its a good listen! :D
Many a time I have deliberated to myself whether Erik was a good or bad guy. The story plot of The Phantom of the Opera is a complex, intricate one. And no, not just this movie I have seen other versions.
@Iced1992 I agree, and that's what makes it so difficult. I meant more of an in general- I can't really explain it. But I adore this movie and story line. 'Tis a good one.
@RedRosesLast4eva hi again, iknow its been three months since our conversation but i have read the first book and it ends with the phantom dying, so i was wondering how can there be a second book!?!? please explain!!
@dineydreamer Um... Yeah.... There are different types of alternate ending. Some are based more off the movie, so they can work around the whole "Phantom dying" bit. Then other are more book-ish. Those type normally go back to before Christine leaves with Raoul, so they can change her reaction. Then, like the one I'm telling you about, Phantom fakes his death.
71 people didnt listen
ShadowWolf850 2 weeks ago in playlist Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera
He's so hot!!! he can enter my dreams any time XD
TransformersFan75 2 weeks ago
hey at 2:12 you can see the mask from masqurade
SuperMjlova 2 weeks ago
This wasn't in the movie because it was cut out for some reason...and if it was I would have to leave 3 times to cry my eyes out (wishing you were here again and all I ask of you made me cry D'=)
klgrif 2 weeks ago
@klgrif It was in the credits
VeilBloodClaws 2 weeks ago
Heartbreaking, indeed. I saw this amazing movie for the first time the day before yesterday and I started to cry in the end just becase I felt so sorry for him </3
TiaShaw 3 weeks ago
wait ! hold my hormones !? i never saw this in the move :D damnnnnn
XxXChikis 3 weeks ago
1.5 Million people are listening nao :D
XxCCtinaxX 3 weeks ago
I don't remember this in the movie :o
bformvalintine 4 weeks ago
I cried like and idiot :') kkkkkk
cassiateitel01 1 month ago 2
I love the different lyrics to this melody, though the version of learn to be lonely by Minnie Driver was exceptional, this one is a heart breaker, because it really shows his soft more gentle side, the part of him that just wanted to love and be loved in return.
gaarasonlydemongirlz 1 month ago
I'm one of the lucky ones who actually got to see the stage production of Phantom of the Opera, (Twice), and I don't think they could have picked anyone better for the movie version of Erik than Gerard Butler!! This movie is phantastic!!
chbell613 1 month ago
I LOVE this song!! I wish it was available somewhere!! (Besides outakes!)
chbell613 1 month ago
JUST KILLING
GORGEOUS
luizikish 1 month ago in playlist Другие видео от пользователя cindyphantom
That broke my heart....I would have listened :') :'(
irishmusicalgurl1216 1 month ago
Why didn't it show the scene on dvd?
890ht 1 month ago
Phangirlnumber1 yes! E. R. I. K. Do I need to spell it out again? Gaston Leroux just turned over in his grave. Erik. With a k. Erik. You might want to start keeping your hand at the level of your eyes...
MikalaS18 1 month ago
Ughh. This man makes my heart smile and frown at the same time.. I just wanna hold him. By farr my favorite song.♥
tiggerrules00 2 months ago
Comment removed
happilyinsane8 2 months ago
A shame that this was cut. It would have added even more humazing tragedy to Eric.
okamido 2 months ago 4
@okamido *twitch* It's spelled with a 'k'. Erik. ERIK.
Seriously, there are phangirls that will massacre you for that.
StrawberryPhanGirl 2 months ago 3
@okamido its Erik.... ERIK....GODDAMMIT ITS Erik!!! E...R...I...K!!!! YOU JUST GOT A DATE WITH THE PUNJAB LASSO!!!!!
phangirlnumber1 1 month ago
A beautiful phantom... :0)
ItalianGirl81 2 months ago 4
Phantom's voice makes me cry...
sayopun 2 months ago in playlist Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera 4
the dislikes must be because this clip wasn't in the movie :-)
Balletdancer4life1 2 months ago in playlist only phantom of the opera songs 4
Me: Have you ever seen Phantom of The Opera?
Kourtney: No, but I know that everyone is obsessed with it and think it's amazing.
Me: AND WITH GOOD REASON!!!
TheInuyanma 2 months ago 18
Lol... This was so written for Lucy... (No one but me and my sis will understand this comment XD)
Ryuzaki1022 3 months ago
this would be amazing in the movie, prolly a deleted scene
ryank7x11 3 months ago
damn you Gerard butler your soooo sexy singing as the phantom!! Such a fantastic singer!
Coconutpotion 3 months ago in playlist Phantom of the Opera playlist 5
continue your arguments elsewhere...your comments r not really about the video. plz b kind enough to either stop commenting or send messages.
bugz2050 3 months ago
@happilyinsane8 Wait... so you and Lilibud12 are arguing over who is the Phantom's reincarnation???
CommanderTurner142 3 months ago
@CommanderTurner142 yep.
happilyinsane8 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Johnl4112 3 months ago
Johnl4112 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the same melody titled 'Learn to be lonely' was in the end credit recorded by Minnie Driver.
Perissis 3 months ago in playlist the phantom of the opera
Comment removed
Perissis 3 months ago in playlist the phantom of the opera
Comment removed
Perissis 3 months ago in playlist the phantom of the opera
Comment removed
Perissis 3 months ago in playlist the phantom of the opera
@baby55695 It was not in the movie, because it "slowed the action down and didn't add anything to the plot", as I read in a comment on this clip uploaded here by someone else. Too bad, because it is a really beautiful part where you see the soft, emotional side of the Phantom..
SiljeM91 3 months ago in playlist the phantom of the opera 3
EC. (^^)/
my25raspberry 3 months ago
If I had one wish, I would make myself Mrs. Phantom. Eff Christine! LOVE ME!!!
KarliMarieRoberts 3 months ago
ahhh.....! this man has such a masculine voice (at least in the movie).
2009Azucar 3 months ago
:(
Elezabith95 3 months ago
OMG ,i will have a heart attace ....where was this ?
Elezabith95 3 months ago
Lilibud12 if u were Erik in a past life then did u really sing this stuff n music jus randomly played out of nowhere
gagetsngizmoz 3 months ago
:')
MultiTalent101 3 months ago in playlist MultiTalent101's favorites
Where would this have been in the movie?
PinkCarnationProDux 3 months ago 32
@PinkCarnationProDux
I think the original idea was to have it before Christine woke up and did the " remember there was mist" piece. But It didn't really fit, because it was too close after music of the night for another phantom aria. Still a great piece of music and singing though.
spock101010 3 months ago
@PinkCarnationProDux It would have made a better credits song. The tune's good, but the lyrics were spooky.
DarkGodCthulhu 3 weeks ago in playlist the phantom of the opera
@PinkCarnationProDux It's in the credits
VeilBloodClaws 2 weeks ago
@PinkCarnationProDux Maybe after All I Ask Of You or before Phantom Of The Opera
cathead772 2 weeks ago
@PinkCarnationProDux must be a deleted sie a hundred times and never
MrJAlex07 5 days ago in playlist the phantom of the opera
Wow simply wow. I had to remind myself I'm a manly man just to hold back the tears on this one. It hit me as an artist and out cast.
ChaosIadore 3 months ago
Many people would consider me a cold, calloused man who masks his emotions. However, I can't help but cry for Erik. I'm crying now.
Alphaomegix 3 months ago
Reality passes into myth, myth passes into legend, and in a way, it becomes larger and more real than it ever was before. Speculate as you will on whether the ghost ever lived. Maybe in a way that's enough. So long as there is music, in a way, there will be an Erik.
rwilli94 3 months ago
Wow, Butler sounds decent here. Now, why couldn't he have sounded like this in the movie.
nick33304 3 months ago
I love how many masks are just lying around his lair.
Kyaco2Paco 3 months ago
Is this actually Gerard Butler's voice? Or is it the voice they used in the movie?
crazysquirrel7 3 months ago
Awwwww : )
Such a sad/sweet song. Whose choice was it to delete this song from the movie? Maybe because they just couldn't find the part to put it in at? O.o
linkfan160 3 months ago
@lilbud12 damn dude you're crazy
iamthegoalie01 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@iamthegoalie01 usual AGW-denier stalker of me - the scum that monitors this to go tell the scum pedo-satanists what it says, you're the same scumbag that marked all the truth on my channel here about your stalker/pedo-cult of nature-rape etc as spam.
I've had two male past lives out of at least sixteen so it isn't crazy pedo - kill yourself. You're going to hell when you die, and are facing extensive rape & torture for eternity for conspiring to abuse me and mark my comments as spam.
lilibud12 3 months ago
The story of The Opera Ghost is real you know. I know because I was he in a past life. In fact, it was my second-to-last life. Lies claim I was like how is shown in this movie. How is that possible when this guido-looking asshole can't sing or act his way out of a paper bag? I was 6'4' and noseless and Christine was a blonde swede, Webber, you kikey cunt. Kill yourselves fatties.
lilibud12 4 months ago in playlist No one would listen
@lilibud12 And how can you prove this fact "Erik"?
MaidenMarvel 4 months ago
@MaidenMarve If you would just do as much as skim over Leroux's novel then you would see that everything I've said about myself in that incarnation is true. Further, you obviously can't help the Freudian slip of acknowledging that I was really Phantom by your stating it as fact when asking for proof, pedo. You clearly know nothing about how reincarnation works or you would never have asked such an insane question to start with.
lilibud12 4 months ago
@lilibud12 bro, you were not Erik, I was. besides, do you even sing? or Fence? and you probably wouldnt get it if I said you are Hooke incarnate. STOP TAKIN CREDIT FOR MAH STUFF!!!!!
happilyinsane8 3 months ago
@happilyinsane8 Pedo - just thought I'd let you know the reason I haven't posted until now is because Google - the scumfucks hijacked my account.
Once, I had to entirely remove another (due to stalker satanist using its 1000s of pervert channels to complain about me rightly calling its conspiracy evil pedo jew fags etc) channel, cause the Google scum mentioned stole that one too & i couldn't get it back cause of jew pube's idiot verification-code-conspiracy that is allowed to exist.
lilibud12 3 months ago
@happilyinsane8 Anyway, Gerard Butler channel- no one claiming to be me in a past life would incarnate and become obsessed with a false version of it in this one. Like I've told your conspiracy once before already, though the physical descriptions etc in Leroux's book were pretty much spot on - most of the story was skewed - and/or fabricated and turned into literary fantasy bs. Are you really so fucking dense as to think that Leroux was ever going to know every word of what was said anyway?
lilibud12 3 months ago
@happilyinsane8 Btw, of course I can sing in this incarnation, but I'm nowhere near as good as then, and I don't do it professionally. Where did you hear that you have to do the exact same things you did and as good as you were then to prove you're telling the truth about who you were in a past life, pedo? Where ever you heard it, it's wrong and doesn't make sense anyway.
lilibud12 3 months ago
@lilibud12 I pity you.
happilyinsane8 3 months ago
@happilyinsane8 (cont) If that were the case, you wouldn't really have reincarnated, and you'd be stuck in some false-hologram-time-wrap where you're still living out your past life, only it'd be slightly altered by culture. Plus, if that were true, then how can you possibly expect me to believe you were me in a past life when you can't even type proper?
lilibud12 3 months ago
@lilibud12 fourth, I am not obsessed with my former life, unlike you, who could probably quote my biography at any number of places, and fifth, you would not be so stupid or insecure as you are that you would have to resort to "trollin" 13 year olds who are smarter than you.
happilyinsane8 3 months ago
@happilyinsane8 Also, even if I had the opportunity to sing profesionally now, I wouldn't, cause of how music has become such a handicapped, mentally ill thing, done specifically to rape people's souls with noise-pollution and nature-spirits/animals etc.
I know what sane music is. It's pro-nature like acupuncture/therapy and mostly soft piano. Piano music should be played during surgeries, but it's not because most surgeons are the scumbag wrong-tech nature-abusers.
lilibud12 3 months ago
@lilibud12 one, you are incredibly stupid with an extremely limited vocabulary and an exceedingly closed mind. two, if you were a serial killer, which is bull because I was he, its slightly hypocritical to call me a pedo. three, you clearly have no interest in the arts at all if you think good music is dead. it is incredibly easy to find. ever heard of placido domingo?
happilyinsane8 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@MaidenMarvel Also, I never, at any point, gave you permission to use my first name. You have to earn that privilege you dumb cunt. If you would stop being such a tarded cunt you would see a major difference in how your life is run. Kill yourself.
lilibud12 4 months ago
@lilibud12 Not sure if deluded
Or trolling us all
ramah920 4 months ago
@lilibud12 I'm definitively going to use "Kill yourself, fattie" in a conversation very soon.
JoTheAnomaly 4 months ago in playlist love song
@lilibud12 Leroux claims The Phantom was real so I believe him, but according to Leroux's interview with the Persian, Erik did indeed have a nose. Anyway, I love the book but, I like Webber's interpretation of The Phantom better than Leroux's.
Kyaco2Paco 3 months ago
Anyone else noticed that Erik was THE OG even before that was thought about. hes a boss.
happilyinsane8 4 months ago
omg gerard B its amazing he sings like an angel im so inpress i wish he was my new toy
natashahelena1 4 months ago in playlist The Phanton of the Opera 3
was this a deleted scene or something?
preppygurl428 4 months ago
the music is the same as the exit credits that was sung by Minnie Driver, the diva Carlotta, "Learn to be Lonely".
BiggDogg1066 4 months ago
@bostera86 the scene was supposed to go after All I Ask of You or at the end of the movie. I can't remember what Webber said.
ZeAriel 4 months ago
For the Phantom of the Opera movie, I'm definately not a fan of Gerard Butler.
For this song though, I definately am a fan of Gerard Butler.
BeWiL0991 4 months ago
I've seen this movie countless times and every single time I hope she stays with him.
chelmoekilljoy 4 months ago
Raoul sucks! GO WITH THE PHANTOM CHRISTINE!
GLEENCIS 4 months ago 60
@GLEENCIS She actually does.
Beowulf54rs 4 months ago
@Beowulf54rs that just made my day!
GLEENCIS 4 months ago
@GLEENCIS Lol you do know thats not a metaphor she literaly does?
Beowulf54rs 4 months ago
@Beowulf54rs OH YAY
GLEENCIS 4 months ago
@GLEENCIS Yeah there is a sequel sadly however 5 minutes after choosing him
she gets shot =/
Beowulf54rs 4 months ago
70 people ran off with Raoul, and are now living an unhappy life.
AndysGirlHowrse 4 months ago
Comment removed
happilyinsane8 4 months ago
where would this scene go in the movie? anyone knows?
bostera86 4 months ago
@bostera86 It was cut out from the movie, as in they didn't want to include it I think
Clare0092 4 months ago
love this story so much. i mean regardless of form i'll watch it. but the movie is definitely my favorite. there was some stuff over on snapsnap i stayed up all night watching. like interviews and behind the scenes stuff. it was really cool.
Michaelscoolio 4 months ago
Gerard is so breath-taking. It's like I have no air when I see this movie. Wow, fantastic job Mr. Butler
mschaiga 4 months ago
@mschaiga Tell me about it. He did fantastic! Michael Jackson wanted to be the phantom and I think he would have done good but Gerry did really good :) It makes you wanna cry doesnt it? the music is amazing! I dont know why they got rid of this scene. its beautiful!
MJDancingMachine14 4 months ago
@MJDancingMachine14 I totally agree with you and yes it does make me wanna cry. I actually nearly cried to the movie lol. It's very amazing. True, they had no right to get rid of it. Thank goodness its on YouTube :)
mschaiga 2 months ago
this song is the story of my life
happilyinsane8 4 months ago
I didn't see this part in the movie? It would've been good to see!
TracyLynn7799 4 months ago
70 persone hanno ricevuto un lampadario sulla testa..
CryVonDeath 4 months ago 2
Simply put "Love it" Thank you!!!
MsCherub123 4 months ago
he has been the best i'v seen so far playing this role Gerad Butler is truly one great actor and singer
genesisthemonster 4 months ago
HE HAS THE BEST EMOTION FROM ALL THE PHANTOMS. SO STFU AND GTFO. THANK YOU.
icried4kishu 4 months ago 6
I cried when he sang "Mascarade" slowly, and with so much emotion. It's like the basic summary of his life, I think. But yeah... it's so sad.
hijklanaop 4 months ago
Umm, Gerard James Butler is the most hottest and talented guy to walk this Earth...jusss' saying...
thumbs up if you agree!
ColeyyyRiceee 4 months ago 4
@ColeyyyRiceee Yopu got that right! It ought to be against the law to be that sexy........and he's the best actor I've ever had the pleasure to watch. He can do any type of roll!
luvphantom2004 4 months ago
omg this is amazing! i am soooooo angry they would cut this from the movie! why would they dooooo that? wtf?!! hes awesome
mrsangelbabe69 5 months ago 5
I always sing this song silently to my self when no one listens to me when I try to say something. Even with a clear voice. Besides it is my favorite song!
celticspirits5 5 months ago 2
I would listen, TEACH ME!!!
Hugemickeyfan 5 months ago
I want to be Mrs Phantom. *sigh*
MrsJosephMerrick 5 months ago 34
@MrsJosephMerrick No, you've got a husband. Should leave him to me as I long to have a lover!!!!!
boywithalobster 5 months ago
@MrPatrickProductions me2
demi4821 5 months ago
so sad he didn't tried heroin with her!
Loepetterson82b 5 months ago
@Loepetterson82b Dun do that!
boywithalobster 5 months ago
if a man EVER sang like gerard in this...LOVE AT FIRST NOTE. I would do anything~<3
invisdablegrl 5 months ago 3
if i where christine when the phantom gave her the ring i would ask " if i accept your engament do you promise to stop tormenting the ones i know and the people i love and live with me and not leave my side for anyone but me "
MegaFruitloops123 5 months ago
I love him! Gerard butler was greatcfor the part idc what others think. He's singing might not of been phenomenal but his acting was perfect. I truly felt his sorrow.
ImpossiblexXxLove 5 months ago
Like a lot of people, I wasn't a huge fan of Gerard Butler's signing in this movie. It was okay, but not as good as I would have liked. BUT, he sounds great in this song! I'm not sure if it's just more in his range or that I've never heard anyone else sing it to compare, but I think he does a beautiful job with this song. ^__^
matrixinterface 5 months ago 3
wow..i like this scene i wish this was in the movie and i could watch this scene all over again! :D
jadenramsey 5 months ago
wow! where did u find this?? this isnt in the movie is it!
sophie76623 5 months ago
somone kill raoul !
beijaninha 5 months ago
quase chorando seriamente aqui *-*
beijaninha 5 months ago
ok what happen to the phantom in the ending
DarkSkysify 5 months ago
So? I like coffins. But he was a bit eviler in the book.
AliceAddams13 5 months ago
this was a deleted scene !!
hathor261 5 months ago
@AmeleaAF Thanks for your answer! Are there any other deleted song in the movie?
Keex07 5 months ago
God, not only does he write music, he's deep, is an ARTIST and just wants to be loved. I feel /so/ bad for him, and I've read the book. But wouldnt everyone go a bit insane from lonliness, hatred, and just plain discrimination for being different? I feel bad for him, and his life. End of Story.
TheKittylover1 5 months ago 129
@TheKittylover1 Don't we all I cried when I heard the phantoms child story. But don't worry he comes back to Christine on the musical Love Never Dies. I am DIEING to see it
JAMbannana 4 months ago
@TheKittylover1 Me too! I was on his side the whole movie. Gerard is such a GREAT singer (he's singing 4 real). I cried watching the Opera & the movie. Both were good!
TracyLynn7799 4 months ago 3
@TheKittylover1 He wasn't "different." He was completely disfigured. Treated horribly, but to be loved by an innocent girl without being judged on his looks, he began to depend on her greatly. His absolute obsession with her drove him mad. How it was written intended for the audience to feel for the Phantom. It is also to show us the shallowness we all have on both ends of the spectrum.
shooglechic 4 months ago 3
i feel so bad for him</3
DEATHifly 5 months ago in playlist the phantom of the opera
@ everyone. ALWs version is pretty loosley based on the Leroux novel. In the Leroux novel and the 1925 silent film the Phantom is creepy, insane and a murderer. When watching the 1925 film you learn to feel little/no compassion for the phantom. In ALWs version, he is a sentimental , loving maniac. In the silent film yes, he loves Christene but he sleeps in friggin coffin. Case Closed.
broadwaynerd99 5 months ago
"You feel little to no compassion for Erik from the 1925 version" Are you kidding? Not to be prude but the '25 version is, to date the most fateful to Leroux's book, in fact. The 1925 version did actually have the scene where the Phantom was playing his violin to Christine at the cemetery, and the duel with Raoul for Christine, these however, were cut, but survive in the form of still photographs. As for lack of compassion, You can see the torture in the Phantom's eyes and face
thEannoyingE 1 week ago
@broadwaynerd99 very clearly, so as for the lack of that, I don't know what you are talking about.
thEannoyingE 1 week ago
@broadwaynerd99 And the "sleeping in a friggin coffin" Was actually part of the book. dumbass.
thEannoyingE 1 week ago
Where is this song in the movie?
Keex07 5 months ago
im listening eric
wolfluver20 5 months ago
Can't believe this song wasn't in the movie, it's so beautifull, and shows a whole different face of the phantom.
NRfun 5 months ago
Too bad that Christine chose Raoul. Personally, I much more prefer the phantom. But it is a matter of taste
I'm felt sorry Eric, I almost felt his pain when she left him ...
Magicvoodo7991 6 months ago
Christine&Raoul:thats all i ask of -
me:YOU!!!
Raoul: what did i -
Me:you made MY Erik cry!
Raoul:who's-
-this scene censored for epic ball kicking & sudden 200 foot drop from roof
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
@phangirlnumber1 hahah XD
NRfun 5 months ago
Comment removed
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
Comment removed
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
Dear Vicomte, Erik may be deformed,but you're just plain ugly!
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
0:00 im listening! xoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxoxo
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
70 people still won't listen!
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
noooooossa sera que ele numca ele vai ser feliz tnho uma dó dele
christine além de ele ser 100% mais lindo e tem uma vóz mais suave e bonita
sarahstefany2011 6 months ago
poor phantom... I'm listening. why would christine ever choose Raoul.
phantomLOVESamy 6 months ago
(0)0)
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
Erik,im listening!
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago 2
Dear Raoul, you suck. -OG
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago 87
@phangirlnumber1 Why? Because he almost died to save Christine? Because he was not abused terribly as a child so the audience naturally feels less sympathy for him?
Gordonverno 4 months ago
@Gordonverno Correct.
Beowulf54rs 4 months ago
@phangirlnumber1 As a kid- I listened to the soundtrack & loved many songs.. love songs; years later I was distraught to find Raul sang them
'
MegaNFer81 4 months ago
@phangirlnumber1 Who's raoul?
gamma830 4 months ago
@gamma830 the other man :/ who deeply sucks. He stole Christine from the Phantom
blackassassin2k7 4 months ago in playlist blackassassin2k7's Favourited Videos
This has been flagged as spam show
im listening!!! Erik! im listening!
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
Comment removed
phangirlnumber1 6 months ago
Lol i would definitaly lose my mind if I lived in a (techniquely) a basement
the rest of my life when all I could do is sing to myself were in this movie
I consider in Erik's case to be a fancier way of talking to yourself and draw.
Beowulf54rs 6 months ago
To put an arguement down. The musical is based on the book, not a retelling. As someone who acts in plays and played Raoul in my high schools version, I have this to say. In musicals expression is the most important thing. ALW took the horrible man of Eric in the book and made him sympathetic so that people will have the debate of Raoul vs Phantom. It is all a part of making people love the characters and making it successful
mjjrussell 6 months ago
They really should have put this in the movie...
CiCi52197 6 months ago
Oh mah gawd, I need to go freaking cry now! I don't care if he's a psycho!!!!
TheArmyTrombone 6 months ago
Gerald Butler can sing
Zipito06 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check my cover out if you would please guys! Let me know what you think :) hope I did it justice! Sorry its a bit out of sink.. still... I hope its a good listen! :D
please subscribe if you like my videos :)
JoshWylie1 6 months ago
I wish this would have been in the movie... :(
peggysuegirl 6 months ago
Many a time I have deliberated to myself whether Erik was a good or bad guy. The story plot of The Phantom of the Opera is a complex, intricate one. And no, not just this movie I have seen other versions.
killcomputer 6 months ago
@killcomputer The answer is outside your false dichotomy. It's never as simple as good or evil.
Iced1992 6 months ago
@Iced1992 I agree, and that's what makes it so difficult. I meant more of an in general- I can't really explain it. But I adore this movie and story line. 'Tis a good one.
killcomputer 6 months ago
@RedRosesLast4eva hi again, iknow its been three months since our conversation but i have read the first book and it ends with the phantom dying, so i was wondering how can there be a second book!?!? please explain!!
dineydreamer 6 months ago
@dineydreamer The Return of the Phantom isn't written by Leroux. Its just published fanfiction.
WaxedLegs 6 months ago
@WaxedLegs oh ok that makes sense thank you! :D
dineydreamer 6 months ago
@dineydreamer Well, each "second book" is a bit different. In the one I read, Phantom faked that death to get people to stop looking for him.
RedRosesLast4eva 6 months ago
@RedRosesLast4eva oh i see, so there are different "book 2"???
dineydreamer 6 months ago
@dineydreamer Um... Yeah.... There are different types of alternate ending. Some are based more off the movie, so they can work around the whole "Phantom dying" bit. Then other are more book-ish. Those type normally go back to before Christine leaves with Raoul, so they can change her reaction. Then, like the one I'm telling you about, Phantom fakes his death.
RedRosesLast4eva 6 months ago
@RedRosesLast4eva oh ok, thank you for explaining it! :D
dineydreamer 6 months ago
@dineydreamer No prob :)
RedRosesLast4eva 6 months ago